Donofrio - NJ Apellate Court (Oct. 30, 2008)

uoc.

• UlntHt.
.,.... ..u.s,
B&Oft...,. 01' nA'" 01'
""" ftAn 01' _ JUllU.

C1U1tQYr Al'ruCJ.TIOII
nLDh lO!J7/01
StInUOll CO<IaT 0' ....
..,'aLU.n OlVlS'OII
OOCUT 100 .....
llO'I"OlI 100. J.M_OISJ_OITl
UPOll.& 'MT, ,
"""""'IB\' CJ.JU:1ItWI
UoL'!"I1OO
.', c. ...-muo. PJIO a:
,.... ,.'11"
Bt, AT'T'OJllI8' ....... ,ot
aESPOIIOP'1' SKUI'M' 0Ir

nIS ....?nIIl ....VIIG 8UlI OClLf PHUlO,..:> TO TO If 'B OIl
n18 JOTI DIl' 01' 0C'l'08U;. lOOB. anD, 0UI1ltaD AI I"OU.C*S'


TIIJ: SICU'!'AII' 0' ITAU TO
OETtlIl,llIIlf: ILfOIaILU'"
Of' CloJroTDATZlI I'\IllStwrT 'l'O
L..l.....i....A U'I1-11
...-'
GIWfRlI DEniO ot1rIR
tIC I \ ( I ,
....... u."" pro ••• C. _frio•• _ ........, l.n.
pre....... All _ .."" ...HuttOft u.st, !s ....:>ce. i ...,.ioco
_ n.
UOY of ,nr<l<1ub....In hen..,", of SUU,
.ina 'Idl. fee"""'y') noordino the bOoll,"" to
.....,-.I _1<101 10 U. ro.... GOo""...} Il-.:doc to boo Mold
". ,. _: •• UU. AppoUSnt ...u ........:
U"" SoOCnury .... hUlll >O!>.ot _ ".,.,_ 10 loOt
-.., _ L..L..I....t.o. ."u-n '" .....
..rlfle..i .. of ue _UHe.U..... for ofUco of \.be ..joe
put, ..udlclat.. f .... 'It tile WaN •. J_
In ("lICCah") ond 111 Ob_ C"or.--), 111
order lor UM' " ..... or u ......Ol\dldo and U.l.
010... of ....,.on to 0W'O'" "" NoH..... 10 .u... '
lIpOoeIUcaU,. "ppooUou pol... t ... foU_lot .........n..A<!
pO....ion .., u.. ....."..,
'"'" s.e.-.u..,. of ...... "'" hU. Ua.o.
olther-ata dayo "foro o"r abe'lon "" ..
ony ...... IOt.. ooai.....e<I 10 uy dl .
,..ltlO1' or ....HUe... of
_noHor. or ..... """ "tl"" .,..Ufl.....
filed ..!to II.. uo to O'OtM f..... abUI
..-. .tId 0"",,"" zu. _ ond ..-.1 of
effloo. ...<1 10........ .... ,to club of !:be
_reI """"ti•• of <be ....... o:.. .... of
'I! 'Wb geMl...... fllF yDqt "" Ulln
.l.hlp "K' C1l5mn "' he tzy 'n sgl'tJ ... tg
nltl II 'w=h "KT'on. nh ... 10
04d101oo UH' _. or ... cuclideO" tor
ud. 1/1...·rr.. "t olMl unl .."
........ 1taD,J'...c!It..·._"1:lcl_l"
..,. oad> 00.... U1". .. or peUU.. til "Itt
11.1.00••ull coe.."" <l>e _ 1_
ot .11 _r " .4.1d tbe o!U tor
t""1' are opocu lr -s"o.• te<I. lOci
_. 01 the pe.... l •• by which Or
1'011011'.1 .ppeU.01oo u....o< ""leb .re
... l1' -.looU<l. .. ... I.o"
cUr.n11' by ltI>oot oU.ti""d...
p011Hc.l _nu1 lIell 1>0 oortlU" ••
,I.-n... • ..
.tAll be _. eon.1U.... """ !o",..,_. _
, e...." ..l fOr U. 1lCC.1.a .ocI Obeao ".,...i,no _ro no01U.... "t
pood.""1' "r uu .ppllceU..... end _ro o"PPl1'" ..lu
cop..I •• of _co tIlnN'" ..,... OUlee ot tbe ...u.......,.
_r.l......... ,,_oJ._ ....U.,.... .... _ .... l.Jo.... or _ ...
•• _c, l.Jo u.io _".r.
'.",,'18M
v.c.nc10. or. flll.d nb.lOqU.ndy ••
to 1....
_..,..
oonU"d. tb.O tbo pbr... "by 1....nUd.do in lL,L..S....6...
19,13_22 rdon to th. Fruid.nU.I c.ndid.t.. tlto....1>...nd
nnt to tMir .1.cOon or olto VOt.... .M oh.o tlt40 Ito,U'O
thUoby rlOqUiro. ,Ito s.cr...ry to verity tn.
qu.UUenionl of lIeC.in end 0b0l00 to ......... Pr..ident.
In particulor. .WOn.", roil.. qu..ti",," .bout wh.tn.r
uod.r Artic1. n. S.cUon 1 ot tho Dnited S...... Con.tltuUon.
on<! Ob r ••och ". n.turol llo"" Clthu. or • Citi.."
of ,n. ""ite<! S , .t tho ti_ of on••dopeion nf [tn.
r.dord) conleituUon." not.. tn.t IICC.in .... •
• Ibeit to porentl ..tIC ...n b<><.b united S..... dohon•• on •
fe<l.rU IIiU..ry be.o 'n thO ro"...... C.nU '''n. in 1936,
tlrritory ..ni"n not • p....t ef tho unhod 'tlt....non tn.
coutitution nUt oCopted. AppellO"t furtnor not..
.llovotioni .•t Ob.... "",010 toehor .... not .n
......rio.n 01Ohen, .... b<>rn in Itony. or in Inder..I'o, nthor t.II."
tn. ltoto or Ro..oH••M tn", Ob..... h.. I>Ot ."..onted
nl. orl,in.1 b'rtn ".rtiU".to to hi. c'th.n.h'p.
Ait""".n .P!I4'llant _. not .clopt th... .ccu..tion. of
C1lqu.1l.f1Htion. n. contlnc. thot Oh.y >:*'.uiu ie.depend.".
in d ...l.on »y t"" ..".--tory, not..ith.t.ndin. tb.t IlcCd" onO
01> hove ""0" l1<&1."oeod .t tho "o.pectlv. "oei"""l conv.ntion.
of b<>th ..jor peliti""l porti•• 0:><1 or. "" tho ••norol .I.ctlon
!>ollote of tho other fOrty_nine .to,...
Uvin. ...",i_ 'weU."t·. olei... .nd tho ""itte"
_dUo" nf tn. Attorn.y Genoul ..........tilried thn
eplHln.nt hoo fol.le<l to dfloOn.tuu • lHolihcod of .""co.. on
thO .."lto o' hi. cl.1JoI. i""l"C.lc.• hio 1ntocpr.Utio" of tho
s.c....ry •• r"""ti.... 1 ,,-.- L..L.LA... 1',13·21, .nd tn"o hi.
r....... for UU.ord'nory 'njunctive .. en t.II. .vo e' 0
not'on.l Oll'Ction ..,.t be ..oj..,tl<l. CU"," Y 1>0919;'. '0 IL..oL.
126, 13: (1912). IIo""",,U•••""n..... hOe u.... uon.bly delOyod in
tho p.....". HtJ.V'Uoc "" OCt,,",," :7. 20OS • .mitn ori.o•
... t o' thO Secnto""1 .",ioo'l In cortifyi". .l••tor. 'er 1Ie'Clic
."d 010_ on 'opt_r 22, 200•. lis U,lJ_l0
tuqulri". cbjoet1on. to '.rtiUc.t.. 01 ,,"";notien for
",..id.ntin Olectou to be fUod ..lthln four O.y. "I the HHn.
d..dlin.) • .lu.....&1G. KcMenr'. Y Conln•• 1U 'OS.
(App. Di •. 2007). Ito 01.0 note th.t th.u 1. no
_.U.ti"" of 1_.:11.,••n<! 'r...poroblo h...., ice..... h .. ""1
th.U.nv. to 'hi .ll'Cti"" r ..ulto Oln ....it tho "OIIpletto"
'.",,'18M
v.c.nc10. or. flll.d nb.lOqU.ndy ••
to 1....
_..,..
oonU"d. tb.O tbo pbr... "by 1....nUd.do in lL,L..S....6...
19,13_22 rdon to th. Fruid.nU.I c.ndid.t.. tlto....1>...nd
nnt to tMir .1.cOon or olto VOt.... .M oh.o tlt40 Ito,U'O
thUoby rlOqUiro. ,Ito s.cr...ry to verity tn.
qu.UUenionl of lIeC.in end 0b0l00 to ......... Pr..ident.
In particulor. .WOn.", roil.. qu..ti",," .bout wh.tn.r
uod.r Artic1. n. S.cUon 1 ot tho Dnited S...... Con.tltuUon.
on<! Ob r ••och ". n.turol llo"" Clthu. or • Citi.."
of ,n. ""ite<! S , .t tho ti_ of on••dopeion nf [tn.
r.dord) conleituUon." not.. tn.t IICC.in .... •
• Ibeit to porentl ..tIC ...n b<><.b united S..... dohon•• on •
fe<l.rU IIiU..ry be.o 'n thO ro"...... C.nU '''n. in 1936,
tlrritory ..ni"n not • p....t ef tho unhod 'tlt....non tn.
coutitution nUt oCopted. AppellO"t furtnor not..
.llovotioni .•t Ob.... "",010 toehor .... not .n
......rio.n 01Ohen, .... b<>rn in Itony. or in Inder..I'o, nthor t.II."
tn. ltoto or Ro..oH••M tn", Ob..... h.. I>Ot ."..onted
nl. orl,in.1 b'rtn ".rtiU".to to hi. c'th.n.h'p.
Ait""".n .P!I4'llant _. not .clopt th... .ccu..tion. of
C1lqu.1l.f1Htion. n. contlnc. thot Oh.y >:*'.uiu ie.depend.".
in d ...l.on »y t"" ..".--tory, not..ith.t.ndin. tb.t IlcCd" onO
01> hove ""0" l1<&1."oeod .t tho "o.pectlv. "oei"""l conv.ntion.
of b<>th ..jor peliti""l porti•• 0:><1 or. "" tho ••norol .I.ctlon
!>ollote of tho other fOrty_nine .to,...
Uvin. ...",i_ 'weU."t·. olei... .nd tho ""itte"
_dUo" nf tn. Attorn.y Genoul ..........tilried thn
eplHln.nt hoo fol.le<l to dfloOn.tuu • lHolihcod of .""co.. on
thO .."lto o' hi. cl.1JoI. i""l"C.lc.• hio 1ntocpr.Utio" of tho
s.c....ry •• r"""ti.... 1 ,,-.- L..L.LA... 1',13·21, .nd tn"o hi.
r....... for UU.ord'nory 'njunctive .. en t.II. .vo e' 0
not'on.l Oll'Ction ..,.t be ..oj..,tl<l. CU"," Y 1>0919;'. '0 IL..oL.
126, 13: (1912). IIo""",,U•••""n..... hOe u.... uon.bly delOyod in
tho p.....". HtJ.V'Uoc "" OCt,,",," :7. 20OS • .mitn ori.o•
... t o' thO Secnto""1 .",ioo'l In cortifyi". .l••tor. 'er 1Ie'Clic
."d 010_ on 'opt_r 22, 200•. lis U,lJ_l0
tuqulri". cbjoet1on. to '.rtiUc.t.. 01 ,,"";notien for
",..id.ntin Olectou to be fUod ..lthln four O.y. "I the HHn.
d..dlin.) • .lu.....&1G. KcMenr'. Y Conln•• 1U 'OS.
(App. Di •. 2007). Ito 01.0 note th.t th.u 1. no
_.U.ti"" of 1_.:11.,••n<! 'r...poroblo h...., ice..... h .. ""1
th.U.nv. to 'hi .ll'Cti"" r ..ulto Oln ....it tho "OIIpletto"
_ w.
tbe "lid elKton ..111 ll<>t ............... t U. Cl..,toul
C",11_ ... OllC_r n. ... ..,t. n. I I,
.uL..A1.IlI J ll...L..l:....l I 7 ("'!'Il4o .1IKOon 01 ...... l ...n. oDd .lce
u ..ldut of uch UAn ,hall _t aft<! ,he 'booi ....<>t•• Oft the
Urn lIOII<loy -'"r 'M •..,011<1 ........._, In !>IoC_r ".••
foll .....l'" t.lItth: ._1"........ Ot .""b pt.e. la • ..,10 fun .....
le,I"I.'=- of • ....,10 'un "Jr.oll (IUte'."I.
puloUc \.:>....... I" all _rly ••ocU'" aIld UN Dal.,...
of ..,itl... ,I"" UM U. ,,1..::u- CaM ,boo
p"'atu, of &\111-...... of NllO" -...I Uot nt.l..l"" of _<'<IWI
ab........ lMUotl "l-rU<lTl. ...i,h .,d"'"
_11.00". cblM t .... r.lhf.
'1""11, .... tOX.. 11> pOO.ollIl UU••1a11ar Htlllnl"" in the
1,,<1<0...1 """'-ro.. oIl.aU...,a, UM ...._d... for
"IH.,. 01 -=,,11:1 ..... _ 1'>0." -., "'"..,.;<I.. :kL.
t....L.. Is-v" _. _ .t.......SlI.ii 1d • Cirtl ""ti 01-
nil. 100' ... U91t11 (1.0..... OCt. "Ii: ZUlli .." r ..
lKlO&I.I. III L.....IlillIl.. 1. U (II ••••• .Q...L. .IIIU.o.
Ill, 110<10 •• I .. "".... by ..""u. AprIl 10, HI'1
'."daria, til••• IO/:Col" to " " ..ennl born (Ula",,· uo.".. ArU"le
It. keU"" I or t.tIoo \l1IHe<I ... eon.dtud.... ..,
loner aU., b1 ..r.....o. _1.
_U..,.. ·• ....J.OOI lor l.... .... .,,..1 u.. _ ••luy·,
dl"'lood 1nect.ioIl ie ,,"flied ..... hie .pplicnlO11 i..

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful