There is increasing fungal resistance to Nystatin; experts now recommend other treatments. Mother and infant must be treated, even if only one is symptomatic. There is little evidence-based information on management of this common problem.
Original Description:
Original Title
Treatment of Mucocutaneous Candidal Infection in the Breastfeeding Mother and Child
There is increasing fungal resistance to Nystatin; experts now recommend other treatments. Mother and infant must be treated, even if only one is symptomatic. There is little evidence-based information on management of this common problem.
There is increasing fungal resistance to Nystatin; experts now recommend other treatments. Mother and infant must be treated, even if only one is symptomatic. There is little evidence-based information on management of this common problem.
Child Katie Reynolds, MD, Betsy Ayers, IBCLC, and John Werdel, MD Abstract Candidal infections of the breastfeeding mother and infant are commonly encountered in clinical practice, but can be increasingly difficult to treat successfully. Mothers may complain of severe pain, but sometimes physical examination of the breasts is entirely normal. Diagnosis should be based on assessment of risk factors, history, and examination of the mother and infant. Both mother and infant must be treated, even if only one is symptomatic. There is increasing fungal resistance to Nystatin; most experts now recommend other topical preparations as first-line maternal treatment (including miconazole, clotrimazole, mupirocin, and Gentian Violet). Options for treatment of the infant are more limited, including topical nystatin or Gentian Violet, and systemic fluconazole. Lack of response within three to four days of treatment should prompt reassessment and consideration of alternate topical therapy of systemic treatment. Treatment should be continued at least one week after resolution of symptoms, and environmental control of yeast overgrowth is essential. Background The importance of breastfeeding for mothers' and infants' long-term health is recognized by the American Academy of Family Practice 3 , the American Academy of Pediatrics 4 , and the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology 5 . These organizations, along with the World Health Organization6, recommend six months of exclusive breastfeeding, and at least one to two years of breastfeeding combined with other foods. In an effort to promote these goals, physicians must become knowledgeable about management of breastfeeding concerns and their treatment. Nipple pain (often a result of Candidal infection 1 ) has been shown to be one of the major causes of premature weaning 2 . Although research into treatment options is expanding, at present we have little evidence-based information, and none of the above-referenced organizations provide consensus recommendations on management of this common problem. The following information and recommendations are based on a review of the current literature, incorporating expert opinion where controlled trials are not available. It is critical to treat both mother and infant, even if one is asymptomatic; coordination between care providers will be necessary if more than one physician is involved with the dyad. Diagnosis Symptoms of Candidal involvement of the nipple can be quite variable, and the differential diagnosis is extensive. Mothers often complain of pain that is severe, generally sudden in onset (often after weeks or months of successful nursing), burning or shooting, and occurs during and between feedings. 7 The mother's nipple may appear entirely normal despite ongoing infection; conversely, the infected infant does not always have clinically evident thrush. Presentation of symptomatic nipple involvement may include puffiness, scaling, flaking, weeping, dark pink or shiny red or purple coloration, erythema, striae radiating from the nipple, satellite lesions, or vesicular rash. 2 Symptoms in the infant can include feeding difficulty 2 (either refusing to nurse or pulling off the breast repeatedly while still appearing hungry), fussiness and possibly increased gassiness 7 , and may be associated with a Candidal diaper rash. On examination, the involved infant generally has white patchy plaques on the oral mucosa, and background erythema, but again there may be no significant findings. Assessment of maternal risk factors for candidal infection may be useful in making the diagnosis when clinical presentation is atypical. These risk factors include history of antibiotics during labor 8 , vaginal yeast infection, history of gestational diabetes or ongoing maternal hyperglycemia, antibiotic or corticosteroid use (in mother or infant), nipple trauma (as from incorrect latch), and pacifier use. 9
Treatment of the Mother Topical Therapy A recent survey of physician members of the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine demonstrated that most lactation experts begin treatment with a topical antifungal. 2 For this purpose, ointments are preferred, as they provide a better moisture barrier and are less likely to sting. 10 These ointments are applied sparingly to the nipple and areola after each feeding, or at least 3-4 times daily. Traditionally, nystatin has been used as first-line treatment for this purpose; however, recent studies show that there is increasing resistance of C. albicans, up to 40-45% of strains tested.11 As a result, some experts recommend that this no longer be used as initial therapy. 10,13
Other topical antifungals include miconazole (Monistat, Micatin); this preparation has the advantage of very poor bioavailability in the infant 10 , and therefore need not be wiped off prior to the next feeding. Clotrimazole (Lotrimin, Mycelex) may also be effective, but may be a topical irritant and thus worsen maternal pain and inflammation. There is also systemic absorption of clotrimazole by the infant, and this can result in elevated liver enzymes, and wiping off the product prior to nursing is recommended. 10 Mupirocin ointment has recently been shown to be efficacious, as it has both antifungal and antibacterial activity. 8 There is no significant absorption from topical use 10 , and it is ideal for nipples with severe cracking or trauma which may also have bacterial superinfection. With topical antifungal preparations, improvement is typically seen in 24 to 48 hours, and symptom exacerbation in the first day of treatment is not uncommon. If a patient is not improving after three to four days of treatment, a different topical preparation can be tried. Most sources recommend treating for one to several weeks after symptom resolution. 2
Gentian violet is a traditional antifungal and antibacterial agent that remains efficacious. It is available without a prescription in a 1% solution, and should be diluted to 0.25-0.5%. It is used once daily for no longer than 3 to 4 days, and can damage mucus membranes if overused (uncommon). 10 Patients often experience relief within hours of the first treatment and require only a single treatment, with complete resolution of pain by day three. The solution is swabbed onto mother's nipple and areola and onto the child's oral mucosa; alternatively, the child may simply be allowed to breastfeed after topical application to the nipple and areola. Caution is required in the use of this product, as it temporarily stains skin (duration approximately 2 days) and permanently stains all other surfaces with which it comes into contact. Many lactation experts also recommend bathing the nipples with vinegar solution, to help reduce fungal overgrowth. One tablespoon of white vinegar is added to 1 cup water, and applied directly. The solution must be made fresh daily to avoid contamination. 12
Treatment of the Mother Systemic Therapy Failure of topical therapy generally indicates the need for systemic treatment; this is commonly due to deeper ductal candidiasis. Fluconazole (Diflucan) is generally administered at 200-400 mg PO on the first day of treatment, followed by 100-200 mg PO qd. At this dose, infants receive less than 6% of the usual pediatric dose.10 Two to four weeks of therapy is recommended, 7,8,10
with some practitioners extending treatment to six weeks. The clinical cure rate for fluconazole is 86%, compared with 46% for nystatin; however, cost is substantially higher (see Appendix A). If pain continues despite systemic treatment, the practitioner should consider altering management. Although Candida albicans remains the most common species to cause human infection, less common strains including C. krusei, C. glabrata, and C. dubliniensis are often resistant to fluconazole, and require treatment with ketoconazole.8 Alternatively, pain may be persistent due to non-fungal etiology, including vasospasm, bacterial superinfection, contact dermatitis, or rarely Paget's disease of the nipple. If patients report white discoloration of the nipple associated with the pain (suggestive of vasospasm), they should be instructed to keep the nipples warm and cover after feeds; magnesium and calcium supplements may also be helpful, and occasionally oral nifedipine. 8 If there is suspicion of bacterial superinfection, treat with topical (mupirocin) or oral agents. Visible breaks in the skin may reasonably be assumed to be secondary to bacterial involvement. 13 Severely inflamed nipples may have a component of contact dermatitis, and may benefit from moderate strength corticosteroids in addition to antibiotics. 10,13
Treatment of the Mother Pain Management Pain from nipple candidiasis is often severe (8-10 on the pain scale), so prompt treatment is critical for the successful continuation of breastfeeding. 2 Shorter, more frequent nursings may be more comfortable. Cool packs prior to feedings are recommended, and nipples should be air- dried after each nursing (unless the patient also experiences nipple vasospasm). If pain is too severe for direct nursing, milk can be expressed and fed via bottle or cup to the infant. Breast shells between feedings may be helpful when nipples are extremely sensitive to touch (caution: NOT nipple shields). 9 Ibuprofen can be recommended for analgesia; narcotics are rarely indicated. Treatment of the Child First-line treatment of the child by most lactation experts still consists of nystatin solution, 2
despite the above-referenced increasing resistance. Parents should use a cotton swab to rub into all surfaces of the child's mouth, gums, cheeks, under the tongue, and the roof of the mouth. The manufacturer recommends four times daily, but some physicians will treat more often (half dose, eight times daily), due to yeast's ability to grow rapidly. Gentian violet may also be used as described above; again, overuse can potentially result in damage to mucus membranes. Other topical antifungal preparations are not available in pediatric form. Fluconazole may be used for treatment failures, and is increasingly used as first-line treatment. The usual dose is 6 mg/kg PO on first day, followed by 3 mg/kg/day for 2 to 4 weeks, or at least one week after resolution of symptoms. Although not yet approved by the FDA for use in pediatric patients, a recent survey indicated that 90% of practitioners use it. 10
Treatment of the Environment Many treatment failures and recurrences are due to incomplete eradication of yeast from the environment, or from treatment of only one member of the mother-child pair. Patients should be educated that pumped milk can contain yeast, even if frozen, and may recontaminate the infant's mouth if used at a later time. It should be labeled "yeast" and used immediately, or saved for emergency use only. Good handwashing is important, and all equipment (pacifiers, bottles, rubber nipples, breast shells, and pump kit parts) should be boiled daily and washed after each use with hot soapy water. Nursing pads may form a reservoir for yeast growth, and should either be avoided during treatment or washed in 10% bleach solution. All clothing, towels, and diapers should be washed in the hottest possible water and dried in sunlight if possible. Mothers should use a clean towel after each shower or bath. Complementary therapies are gaining popularity in this as in most other ailments. Acidophilus supplements, either via yogurt with active cultures or in capsules (40 million to one billion units tid) may reduce yeast colonization, and should be used daily for two weeks after symptoms are gone. Other preparations that may discourage yeast growth include grapefruit seed extract (250 mg tid), garlic (3 triple-strength deodorized tablets tid), zinc (45 mg qd), and B complex vitamins (one qd). 14
Summary Candidal infection of the maternal nipple and infant's oral mucosa can seriously impair the chances of successful long-term breastfeeding. Symptoms are often severe, but clinically apparent signs of maternal involvement may be subtle, and diagnosis requires a high index of suspicion. The most important principal of treatment is recognition that both mother and infant require treatment, even if only one has clinically apparent involvement. Although Nystatin has been the mainstay of therapy, there is now significant resistance and higher chance of treatment failure with this regimen. Treatment for mother and infant may incorporate topical or systemic antifungal therapy, and often needs to be continued for up to four weeks, particularly when there is deeper ductal involvement. Failure of topical therapy generally indicates the need for a different topical preparation or a change to systemic therapy; failure of systemic therapy should prompt consideration of resistant Candida species or alternative diagnoses. Finally, eradication of fungal organisms from the environment is essential to successful therapy. References 1. Amir LH, Donath S. Re: breastfeeding, pain and infection. Letter to the editor. Gynecol Obstet Invest 1999;48:145. 2. Brent NB. Thrush in the breastfeeding dyad: results of a survey on diagnosis and treatment. Clin Pediatr 2001;40:503-6. 3. American Academy of Family Physicians. Policies on Health Issues: Breastfeeding. URL:http://aafp.org/policy/x1641.xml 4. American Academy of Pediatrics. Work Group on Breastfeeding. Breastfeeding and the use of human milk. Pediatrics 1997;100(6):1035-8. 5. ACOG Educational Bulletin #258. Breastfeeding: maternal and infant aspects. July 2000. American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists 2002 Compendium of Selected Publications. 6. Wright AL. The rise of breastfeeding in the United States. Pediatr Clin North Am 2001;48(1):1-12. 7. Tait P. Nipple pain in breastfeeding women: causes, treatment, and prevention strategies. J Midwifery Womens Health 2000;45(3):212-5. 8. Amir LH. Candida: what's new? ABM News and Views 2001;8(4):32. 9. Morton L. Lactation fact sheet series. Topic: Yeast. Idaho WIC Program 2002. 10. Hale TW. Medications and Mother's Milk, 10th ed. Amarillo: Pharmasoft Publishing, 2002:133-6, 284-7, 324, 536. 11. Flynn PM, Cunningham CK, Kerkering T, San Jorge AR, Peters VB, Pitel PA, Harris J, Gilbert G, Castagnaro L, Robinson P. Oropharyngeal candidiasis in immunocompromised children: a randomized, multicenter study of orally administered fluconazole suspension versus nystatin. The MultiCenter Fluconazole Study Group. J Pediatr 1995 Aug;127(2):322-8. 12. Ayers, Betsy, IBCLC. Personal communication. January 30, 2003. 13. Huggins KE, Billon SF. Twenty cases of persistent sore nipples: collaboration between lactation consultant and dermatologist. J Hum Lact 1993;9(3):155-60. 14. Mohrbacher N, Stock J. The Breastfeeding Answer Book. La Leche League International. Revised edition 2003:483.