Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR

Algorithmic Decision Theory

Best choice recommendation, ranking and sorting for a decision
problem
Ignacio Ponce-Alcaide
University of Luxembourg
June 24, 2013
Ignacio Ponce-Alcaide Algorithmic Decision Theory
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Introduction
1
Problem characteristics (problem-11.xml)
2
Best choice recommendation process (Decision Deck
Application)
3
Best choice recommendation process (Python scripts)
4
Sorting of the decision actions
1 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Introduction
1
Problem characteristics (problem-11.xml)
2
Best choice recommendation process (Decision Deck
Application)
3
Best choice recommendation process (Python scripts)
4
Sorting of the decision actions
1 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Introduction
1
Problem characteristics (problem-11.xml)
2
Best choice recommendation process (Decision Deck
Application)
3
Best choice recommendation process (Python scripts)
4
Sorting of the decision actions
1 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Introduction
1
Problem characteristics (problem-11.xml)
2
Best choice recommendation process (Decision Deck
Application)
3
Best choice recommendation process (Python scripts)
4
Sorting of the decision actions
1 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Decision alternatives
2 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Performance criterion
3 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Performance criterion (II)
4 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Rubis Performance Table
5 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Valued adjacency table
The RUBIS analysis retrieves the following adjacency table...
6 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Rubis best choice recommendation
... and draws these conclusions:
7 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Vetoes
8 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Best choice recommendation
The scripts support the same conclusion:
9 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Potential worst choices
10 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Decision action sorting
A sorting of the choices can be done based on the digraph:
11 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Towards a single BCR
But one of the elements of the potential best choice group is
ranked lower!
12 / 13
Introduction Problem description Decision Deck Application Local Python scripts Towards a single BCR
Towards a single BCR (II)
With the head to head comparison between the two remaining
alternatives a conclusion can be drawn
13 / 13