Supreme Court of Georgia

Jane Hansen, Public Information Officer
244 Washington Street, Suite 572
Atlanta, Georgia !4
4!4"#5$"%&5
hansen'(gasu)reme*us


CASES DUE FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
Summaries of Facts and Issues
!ease note" These summaries are prepared by the Office of Public Information to help news
reporters determine if they want to cover the arguments and to inform the public of upcoming
cases. The summaries are not part of the case record and are not considered by the Court at any
point during its deliberations. For additional information, we encourage you to review the case
file available in the Supreme Court Cler!s Office "#$#%&'&%(#)$*, or to contact the attorneys
involved in the case. +ost cases are decided within si, months of oral argument.
Monda#$ %u!# &$ '()*
)("(( A+M+ Session
ROUSE ,+ T-E STATE .S)*A))/01
A man con+icte, of mur,er in Muscogee Count# is a))ealing his con+iction an, life
)rison sentence, arguing he ,eser+es a ne- trial because the 'u,ge ma,e an im)ro)er statement
,uring 'ur. selection about -here the crime -as committe,*
FACTS" On Se)t* , 2!!#, Scottie Gillen, a ".ear"ol, ,i+orce, father of four, -as
foun, gas)ing for breath along /aiser 0ri+e in 1olumbus, GA* He ,ie, before the ambulance
arri+e,* Accor,ing to state )rosecutors, about a -ee2 earlier, Gillen ha, been te3ting an, tal2ing
to t-o sisters, 4iss. an, 4elissa 1ona-a., -ho li+e, together along -ith their bo.frien,s,
5rian 0e-berr. an, 1harles 4ellinger* 6he night before Gillen -as 2ille,, the sisters sho-e,
their bo.frien,s te3t messages Gillen ha, sent 4iss. in -hich he offere, to ha+e se3 -ith either
of the sisters* 4ellinger an, 0e-berr. reacte, angril. an, -ante, to lure Gillen to the house to
beat him* 6he sisters instea, hatche, a )lan to rob Gillen because he usuall. carrie, a lot of
mone.* 6he ne3t ,a., 4elissa calle, Gillen an, )romise, se3ual fa+ors if he7, get her some
cigarettes* 0e-berr. calle, his ol,er brother, Ste+en A* 8ouse -ho -as in his earl. 2!s, an,
as2e, his hel) in beating an, robbing Gillen* 0e-berr. later sai, his brother agree,* After 4iss.
an, 4elissa ,eci,e, the. ,i, not -ant the robber. to ha))en in their front .ar,, the. as2e,
Gillen to meet them ,o-n the street at an a)artment com)le3* He arri+e,, an, 4elissa -ent -ith
$
him in his truc2 to a nearb. store for cigarettes* 8ouse mean-hile calle, 4elissa an, tol, her
that -hen the. returne,, she shoul, ha+e Gillen )ar2 ne3t to the -oo,s* As 4elissa -al2e, a-a.
from Gillen7s truc2, 8ouse, 4ellinger an, 0e-berr. -al2e, out of the -oo,s an, u) to the
truc2* Accor,ing to 4ellinger an, 0e-berr., 8ouse struc2 u) a con+ersation -ith Gillen about
go"carts an, truc2s that laste, about 2! minutes* 6he. testifie, 8ouse then struc2 Gillen an,
2noc2e, him off the truc27s tailgate onto the groun,* 8ouse got on Gillen7s bac2 an, )ut him in a
cho2ehol,, re)eate,l. telling Gillen to 9go to slee)*: 4ean-hile, 0e-berr. 2ic2e, Gillen in the
stomach -hile 4ellinger )unche, him in the face* ;+entuall. 8ouse release, Gillen an, rolle,
him face ,o-n in the grass, -hile 4ellinger too2 Gillen7s -allet* After fin,ing no mone., the
three -ent home* All three men -ere arreste, later that ,a.*
Accor,ing to the forensic )athologist -ho con,ucte, the auto)s., Gillen suffere,
numerous in'uries to his hea, an, nec2 area* 6he )athologist testifie, that the in'uries to Gillen7s
nec2 alone -oul, ha+e been fatal* 6he cornu, or cartilage at the ti) of his A,am7s a))le, ha, been
bro2en, an, the stra) muscles running u) the nec2 -ere bruise, an, blee,ing < a common
strangulation in'ur. an, consistent -ith a))lication of a cho2ehol,*
After their arrest, 8ouse ga+e a signe, statement in -hich he ,enie, 2no-ing -ho Gillen
-as, ,i, not a,mit to )lacing him in a cho2ehol,, but ,i, a,mit to stri2ing Gillen in the face an,
2noc2ing him to the groun,* He sai, he 2ic2e, him in the face t-o or three times, an, one of
those times ma. ha+e hit him in the throat* He sai, he onl. hit Gillen because Gillen 9sna))e,:
an, 'um)e, off the tailgate of his truc2 to attac2 him*
A 4uscogee 1ount. gran, 'ur. in,icte, 8ouse 'ointl. -ith the t-o Har,a-a. sisters,
4ellinger an, 0e-berr., charging them -ith malice mur,er, felon. mur,er an, robber.* 8ouse7s
brother an, other three co",efen,ants acce)te, )lea ,eals in e3change for testif.ing against
8ouse* 4ellinger an, 0e-berr. acce)te, charges of +oluntar. manslaughter an, robber. -ith
4ellinger agreeing to a !".ear sentence to ser+e 25 .ears in )rison an, 0e-berr. agreeing to
ser+e 2! .ears in )rison* 4elissa 1ona-a., -ho -as about 2! at the time of the mur,er, )lea,e,
guilt. to robber. an, remains in )rison, an, her ol,er sister, 4iss., is out on )arole after ser+ing
time for cons)irac.* At 8ouse7s trial, his attorne. argue, that 8ouse, 4ellinger an, 0e-berr.
-ere e=uall. res)onsible for Gillen7s ,eath, an, li2e them, the 'ur. shoul, return a +er,ict of
guilt. on +oluntar. manslaughter an, robber. charges but not on the mur,er counts* >ollo-ing a
trial in August 2!!7, ho-e+er, the 'ur. con+icte, 8ouse of felon. mur,er an, robber. an, he
-as sentence, to life in )rison* He no- a))eals to the state Su)reme 1ourt*
ARGUMENTS" 8ouse7s attorne.s ma2e onl. one argument? 6he trial 'u,ge ma,e a
re+ersible error b. commenting to )ros)ecti+e 'urors ,uring the 'ur. selection )rocess 9that .ou
-ill be hearing about a case, -hich is a mur,er case that ha))ene, in 4uscogee 1ount.*: 96he
trial court7s statement that the case @ha))ene, in 4uscogee 1ount.7 -as a comment on +enue in
+iolation of Official 1o,e of Georgia A $7"&"5,: 8ouse7s attorne. argues in briefs* 9Benue is a
'uris,ictional fact, )lace, at issue b. the ,efen,ant7s )lea of not guilt., -hich the State must
)ro+e be.on, a reasonable ,oubt*: CBenue is -here the crime too2 )lace an, ,etermines -hich
count. court has 'uris,iction o+er the case*D 9Accor,ing to A $7"&"5, a court7s comment on a fact
to be )ro+e, b. the State @shall be hel, b. the Su)reme 1ourt or 1ourt of A))eals to be error an,
the ,ecision in the case re+erse,, an, a ne- trial grante,E*7 5ecause the 'ur. began this trial
ha+ing been tol, b. the court that +enue -as in 4uscogee 1ount., 8ouse must be grante, a ne-
trial*: In 2!!7 in Patel v. State, the state Su)reme 1ourt foun, a 'u,ge7s statement that 9+enue is
2
)ro)er in >a.ette 1ount. or -e -oul,n7t be here right no-: a +iolation of A $7"&"5 an, re+erse,
the lo-er court7s ruling* 6he high court rule, in Patel that the 'u,ge7s offen,ing comment -as
not 9the t.)e of )al)able @sli) of the tongue7 the a))ellate courts ha+e e3cuse, from the strict
man,ate of A $7"&"5*: 9>or a @sli) of the tongue7 to be palpable, it must be @easil. )erce)tible7 as
a sli),: the attorne.s argue* 9Fothing in the conte3t of the trial court7s statement that the case
@ha))ene, in 4uscogee 1ount.7 -oul, gi+e an. in,ication to the 'ur. that the trial court meant
an.thing other than the )lain language of its statement*: >urthermore, the State cannot argue that
the 'u,ge7s later instruction to the 'ur. to ignore his statement cures the error* 96his 1ourt hel, in
Patel that @instructions gi+en to the 'ur. b. the trial court cannot cure a +iolation of A $7"&"5,:
the attorne. argues*
6he 0istrict Attorne. argues on behalf of the State that the trial court7s statement ,uring
+oir ,ire 9-as a )al)able sli) of the tongue an, it coul, not ha+e misle, or confuse, the 'ur. an,
-as not a 'u,icial e3)ression of o)inion on +enue*: Official 1o,e of Georgia A $7"&"5 ma2es it a
re+ersible error for a 'u,ge to e3)ress his o)inion as to -hat has been )ro+e, or not, but a 9mere
+erbal inaccurac. in a charge, -hich results from a )al)able @sli) of the tongue,7 an, clearl.
coul, not ha+e misle, or confuse, the 'ur., is not re+ersible error,: the State argues* 9Where a
charge as a -hole substantiall. )resents issues in such a -a. as is not li2el. to confuse the 'ur.
e+en though a )ortion of the charge ma. not be as clear an, )recise as coul, be ,esire,, a
re+ie-ing court -ill not ,isturb a +er,ict am)l. authoriGe, b. the e+i,ence*: Hnli2e the case in
Patel, the 'u,ge7s comment in this case occurre, as )art of 'ur. selection, )rior to argument or
-itness testimon.* 96he court necessaril. nee,e, to orient the )anel to the time an, )lace the
crime -as allege, to ha+e occurre, to facilitate =uestions about )rior 2no-le,ge of the crime
an, )ossible relationshi)s to the )arties in the case,: the State argues* 95ecause the sli) of the
tongue occurre, ,uring the +oir ,ire charge an, -oul, not ha+e misle, or confuse, the 'ur., it
,oes not re=uire a ne- trial in A))ellant7s case un,er A $7"&"5*:
Attorne#s for Appe!!ant .Rouse1" 4ichael 6arleton, James 5onner, Jr*
Attorne#s for Appe!!ee .State1" Julia Slater, 0istrict Attorne., 8obert 5ic2erstaff, Sr* Asst*
0*A*, Samuel Olens, Attorne. General, 5eth 5urton, 0e)* A*G*, Paula Smith, Sr* Asst* A*G*,
1hristian >uller, Asst* A*G*

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful