An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can
enrich or limit their experience of belonging. Discuss this view with
detailed reference
Interaction between individuals provides a foundation of belonging. Particular connections and relations are distinctive according to whether the multifaceted concept of belonging is enriching or limiting. Raimond Gaitas, Romulus My Father is a memoir that portrays these positive and negative experiences by exploring the synergy that is belonging. Gaita demonstrates the enriching and yet limiting effect of an unfamiliar landscape on a protagonist Romulus, whose cultural foundation causes a bias and a subsequent struggle to belong. However this physical struggle to belong is built upon a juxtaposing and yet enriching memory of what Romulus desires. A strong cultural heritage with dominating values and ethics, leads to the formation of lifelong and enriching bonds. This occurs whilst barriers to belonging form from the elements which provide Romulus with a sense of security. Similarly, Herzls, Der Judenstaat pamphlet illustrates how a cultural schism either limits an individuals sense of identity. Individuals strive to escape persecution or strengthen their cultural foundation as they endeavour to reach a common goal of reaffirming their beliefs whilst escaping discriminating communities. However enriching this may be, by forming a Jewish state, Jews are purposefully alienating themselves from the wider world and limiting their own cultural diversity. Both texts explore how although an experience may be elevating, its degree of enrichment may not outweigh the limitations that consequently occur.
Security is often provided to an individual encountering alien environments or situations through a congregation based on backgrounds, ideals or ethnicity to form a smaller community within a greater society. In Romulus My Father by Raimond Gaita, protagonist Romulus is presented with an unfamiliar and daunting environment where he sought out security and a sense of belonging, As soon as my father arrived at the camp, he asked the man who greeted new arrivals whether there were other Romanians. Hindsight conveys a notion of a lifelong bond formation between Romulus and minor protagonist Hora. This bond depicts the enrichment formed between like-minded and culturally alike characters that provide a strong sense of belonging. However this same bond is formed on a bases of insecurity and failure to assimilate which illustrates a limitation to both characters cultural enrichment and therefore their belonging to a wider, more diverse community. This friendship is built upon both cultural similarities and ideological ties which demonstrate the multifaceted nature of belonging via highlighting the importance of social bonds that allow individuality and identity, known as character, which is an imperative trait to both Hora and Romulus. This individuality is based upon idiosyncratic differences. However, due to similarities in values and morals both characters are portrayed as being highly influential on Raimond especially and respected by a wider community. This demonstrates how an individuals interaction with others can enrich their sense of belonging. Romulus is deeply affected by the pedigrees of culture which shape his experience of belonging and influence the way in which he relates to the Australian landscape. Cultural dislocation proves to be a limitation to Romulus sense of acceptance as he feels restricted by a chasm of cultural dissimilarity. Use of tactile imagery shows Romulus strong connection with his homeland and his desire for the soft and European foliage portrays. He continues with this mentality by surrounding himself with Balts, (immigrants) and an artificial European aesthetic, the pepper tree. Romulus discontent with the Australian landscape is emphasised through parallelism with his wifes adverse attitude to the topography, desolate symbols of deprivation and barrenness.. Gaita uses a dysphemistic and hyperbolic description of Christines cultural dissimilarity, the vast landscape with only crude wire fences. The dislodgment of both Romulus and Christine reiterate their negative view on the Australian landscape with a parallel provided with their aversion to an unfamiliar culture that they knowingly avoid, inevitably limiting their experience of belonging. This desolate attitude towards an Australian setting is shared between adult characters depicted in the memoir, however these ideals are juxtaposed with Raimonds epiphany and connection to the land that provides a culturally and enriching connection between identity and setting for protagonist Raimond. This connection demonstrates how and individuals interaction with the world around them can enrich their experience of belonging whereas Romulus and Christines connection illustrated their environments possible limiting traits.
Der Judenstaat Paragraph Synthesis Paragraph Conclusion
An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging. Discuss this view with detailed reference
Intro:
Our sense of belonging is individual and unique to each of us. It is shaped by our individual perspectives, experiences and often reflects how we see ourselves. An individuals interaction with other people and the world around them does pose the potential to either enrich or limit their experience of belonging. Our perception and attitude influence the ways in which we can belong to or with certain groups, people or landscapes. Our perception is shaped by our past experiences and influences, thus each persons sense of belonging are unique. It is through this that the way individuals interact with each other and the world around them is influenced, which in turn can either enriches or hinders ones sense of belonging. This notion is evident in the memoir Romulus, My Father by Raimond Gaita and the petition by Vincent Lingiari, Gurindji Petition to Lord Casey, Governor General. The two texts address this notion through exploring the different aspects that give way to an enrichment or hindrance of ones sense of belonging.
This essay was a band 6 - some teachers gave it full marks and a few gave it close to full marks... whatever this essay may be, I hope it helps :) Enjoy, Tash An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging. Discuss this view with detailed reference Considered a fundamental aspect of being human, belonging is an ambiguous concept which can offer individuals a sense of identity, security and connectedness. Experiences of belonging are closely related to a persons interaction with others, as positive experiences can enrich their sense of belonging, and negative experiences can limit their sense of belonging. An individuals limited experience of belonging through their inability to positively interact with others can often incite them to reject the majority through acts of defiance, self-alienation and rebellion. This notion is extensively explored within Peter Skrzyneckis poem, St. Patricks College, from the anthology Immigrant Chronicle, and Stanley Kubricks 1971 film A Clockwork Orange as both texts illustrate the protagonists limited experience of belonging through their interaction with others leading to their acts of defiance. Conversely, Peter Skrzyneckis poem,10 Mary Street- also from the anthology Immigrant Chronicle-explores the notion that it is through the positive interaction with others that an enriched sense of belonging can be established.
OR
An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can limit their experience of belonging solely due to their culture. This is portrayed in both Peter Skryzneckis poetry and in the short film directed by Michael Weisler, Missing Her. The poem Migrant Hostel identifies that a culture will seek out people of the same culture in order to create a sense of belonging. The poem Postcard identifies that belonging to a place is achieved through experience. The short film Missing Her shows how ones culture can alienate.
Structure An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging. There are TWO key parts to this essay question that you will need to address in your response. a. An individuals interaction with others and the world around them You need to spend some time asking yourself these questions: Who or what does the speaker/individual interact with in this poem? Why does this interaction occur? b. can enrich or limit their experience of belonging You need to spend some time asking yourself these questions: What is the individuals experience of belonging that is communicated in my poem? Does this interaction enrich the individuals experience of belonging? Why/How? Does this interaction limit the individuals experience of belonging? Why/How? As you can see, writing an essay requires A LOT of thinking BEFORE you start writing. Once you have written your answers to the above questions, then you can formulate your TWO hypotheses, you can go and see if the evidence from the poems actually to supports your hypotheses by filling in an evidence chart. Remember that ultimately you will ONLY be writing on ONE of these hypotheses the one that YOU determine has the most evidence to SUPPORT it. Your essay structure will be similar to this: P1: Introduction outline hypothesis, say something briefly about each poem what its about and/or how it links to your hypothesis P2: First poem and hypothesis two pieces of evidence to support first half of statement (who or what the individual interacts with) then a linking phrase mid- paragraph similar to it is this interaction that leads to as you them move on to your two pieces of evidence that supports the second half of your hypothesis (whether this interaction enriches or limits the individuals experience of belonging). P3: Second poem and hypothesis (but remember your linking phrase to show there is a logical relationship between your previous paragraph and this one) two pieces of evidence to support first half of statement (who or what the individual interacts with) then a linking phrase mid-paragraph similar to it is this interaction that leads to as you them move on to your two pieces of evidence that supports the second half of your hypothesis (whether this interaction enriches or limits the individuals experience of belonging). P4: Conclusion find a memorable quote from someone memorable (former prime minister, Shakespeare etc) that links to your hypothesis about belonging. Restate your hypothesis and your texts discussed in essay. I hope that helps! I dont want to be TOO prescriptive with structure please feel free to play around with it! BUT please make sure that you have a strong argument that responds DIRECTLY to the essay question and that allows you to provide RELEVANT and meaningful EVIDENCE to support it. Note: in English EVIDENCE = quotes as well as analysis and evaluation of the effectiveness of techniques to achieve the composers desired purpose.
An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging. This statement can be readily depicted through various texts which include Raimond Gaitas memoir, Romulus My Father and Universal Studios 2004 film, Hating Alison Ashley. Both of these texts involve various techniques that assist in portraying the concept of belonging to both an environment and to relationships. Belonging is a concept that is more complex than it first appears. It may be experienced on many levels between belonging and not belonging, be it to a family, a friendship, a place or a surrounding environment. It is a perception that is shaped within personal, cultural, historical and social contexts. Belonging is to fit in or to be accepted in a particular place or environment, to feel comfortable and connected to other individuals. Alternatively it may be isolation or alienation from others, to feel estranged or at odds with the environment. Raimond Gaitas memoir, Romulus My Father demonstrates how an individuals interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging to an environment. Gaita uses first person throughout the book, not only to express his experiences but to articulate both his mother and fathers experiences of belonging to their surroundings also. Romulus is a migrant to Australia who always considered himself Romanian. Gaita often expresses Romulus as being at odds with the environment, never reconciling to the Australian landscape, whose foliage and vegetation seemed symbols of deprivation and bareness. This statement is symbolic of how he feels towards Australia and demonstrates how Romulus chose to only see the negative aspects of his surrounds and focused more on his desire to be back in Europe amongst soft and gentle foliage. These two simple descriptions of different landscapes are instantly juxtaposed and express Romuluss feelings of loneliness in...
Interaction is the very inception of belonging. Whilst the concept is multifaceted and complex, there are distinctive interactions that either enrich or limit an individuals experience of belonging. This is highlighted through examination of Gaitas RMF and other texts, which each explore the synergy that is belonging. The pedigrees of culture forge the basis of an individuals experience of belonging. impact on the way in which individuals relate to a particular geographic environment. Collectively, culture and environment can be an enriching force of connection; despite this, cultural dislocation can also limit ones sense of belonging. Gaita feels limited by a chasm of cultural dissimilarity. His use of tactile imagery creates a strong connection between Romulus and his homeland as he yearns for soft and European foliage. This idea is reinforced as he attempts to manufacture an artificial European aesthetic in Frogmore by surrounding himself with the pepper tree and other Baltic immigrants. Romulus rejection of Australian Flora and Fauna is furthered through parallelism with his wifes adverse attitude to the topography. Gaitas hyperbolic and dysphemistic description: the vast landscape with only crude wire fences effectively illustrates Christines state of cultural dissimilarity. The displacement experienced by Romulus and his wife is reiterated as their distaste for the Australian bush is paralleled with their aversion to a culture that is too unfamiliar to embrace; inevitably limiting their experience of belonging. Romulus limited relationship with Australian environment and culture is juxtaposed with Raimonds enriching connection and avid experience of belonging. Gaita conveys this through a potent use of pathetic fallacy as Raimond finds solace in the sparse scrub and open bushland whereas his father perceives the bush in a manner that implies its deficiency: desolate symbols of deprivation and barrenness. This blatant conflict of
Interaction is the very inception of belonging. Whilst the concept is multifaceted and complex, there are distinctive interactions that either enrich or limit an individuals experience of belonging. This is highlighted through examination of Gaitas RMF and other texts, which each explore the synergy that is belonging. The pedigrees of culture forge the basis of an individuals experience of belonging. impact on the way in which individuals relate to a particular geographic environment. Collectively, culture and environment can be an enriching force of connection; despite this, cultural dislocation can also limit ones sense of belonging. Gaita feels limited by a chasm of cultural dissimilarity. His use of tactile imagery creates a strong connection between Romulus and his homeland as he yearns for soft and European foliage. This idea is reinforced as he attempts to manufacture an artificial European aesthetic in Frogmore by surrounding himself with the pepper tree and other Baltic immigrants. Romulus rejection of Australian Flora and Fauna is furthered through parallelism with his wifes adverse attitude to the topography. Gaitas hyperbolic and dysphemistic description: the vast landscape with only crude wire fences effectively illustrates Christines state of cultural dissimilarity. The displacement experienced by Romulus and his wife is reiterated as their distaste for the Australian bush is paralleled with their aversion to a culture that is too unfamiliar to embrace; inevitably limiting their experience of belonging. Romulus limited relationship with Australian environment and culture is juxtaposed with Raimonds enriching connection and avid experience of belonging. Gaita conveys this through a potent use of pathetic fallacy as Raimond finds solace in the sparse scrub and open bushland whereas his father perceives the bush in a manner that implies its deficiency: desolate symbols of deprivation and barrenness. This blatant conflict of
Romulus My Father/ Watchmen- Belonging By spectre2230, october 2011 | 4 Pages (920 Words) | 500 Views | 4 .5 1
2
3
4
5
(1) | Report | This is a Premium essay for upgraded members Upgrade to access full essay TAKE OUR RELATIONSHIP PUBLIC... Send
Tweet
An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging. Belonging is a complex and ever changing perception of ones self that is tested, altered and ultimately reflected upon as the epitome of upheld beliefs and expected moral actions determined by the influence of our surroundings which is determined by our place within the societal cohort. Belonging as stated is an inward reflection of your upheld moral code formulated by the company you keep and the choices you make which determine at heart the nature of your belonging. Within biographically written Romulus My Father by Raimond Gaitia and Watchmen a nostalgic noire-esk representation of the conflict between the USA and Soviet Russia in 1985 directed by Zack Snyder the notion of belonging extends beyond the simple ties of friendship and belonging through instinctive impulse but a developed, undervalued and heightened sense of an interpreted belonging towards individuals and their beliefs but within their environments. Belonging to an environment presents itself in the sharing of common interests, this societal belonging allows for the individual to belong within a society, although at times the sense of conforming can restrict the expressions of individuals who are opposed to set beliefs and can lead to instances of not belonging. Within the setting of Romulus My Father the notion of holistic belonging is adapted to an immigrant family whose belonging is evident in the beliefs central to their existence which uphold inherent practices of its family members, Romulus, Christine, Raimond and their emotional interpretation of their surroundings and towards each other. Romulus who is the title character expresses his belonging as a belonging to place. Romulus demonstrates connection to people through his belonging to his home land of Romania, Always considered himself a Romanian use of definite diction stressing always suggesting the relationship.
Romulus My Father By elyse94, october 2012 | 5 Pages (1181 Words) | 107 Views | 4 .5 1
2
3
4
5
(1) | Report | This is a Premium essay for upgraded members Upgrade to access full essay CLICK THREE TIMES FOR GOOD LUCK Send
Tweet
1. An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging. The ways in which we belong, and not belong have a clear connection with the ways we interact with others and the world around us. It is through relationships and a sense of belonging with other people, peoples inner sense of belonging and connections to environments and places that enrich or limit ones sense of belonging. People are enriched as a result of strong relationships that provide security and develop a sense of belonging. Similarly, connections to places and environments can enhance a sense of belonging. A lack of these interactions can make it difficult for a person to build connections. These ideas are explored in Raimond Gaitas book, Romulus, My Father which strongly focuses on how relationships with people, the environment, society and ourselves defines the degree to which a sense of belonging is established and maintained. Similarly in the cinematic adaption of Truman Capotes novel, Breakfast at Tiffanys, the audience views different dimensions of belonging and reflects on how interactions with others and the world aroundHolly Golightly influence the her sense of belonging.
Relationships and they way they enrich our lives, sense of identity and how they form the way in which one belongs is a significant theme throughout Romulus It is accepted that relationships can enrich our lives and strengthen a sense of identity. The extent to which an individual feels a sense of belonging is often linked to the nature of the relationships they have built. In RMF two significant relationships explored are those between Raimond and his father Romulus and Raimond and Hora... The strength of these two relationships enriches Raimonds sense of belonging, regardless of the other dimensions of his childhood that would normally limit a childs sense of belonging. He showed me the connection between individuality and..
Romulus My Father By rainbows4eva, july. 2013 | 4 Pages (768 Words) | 24 Views | 4 .5 1
2
3
4
5
(1) | Report | This is a Premium essay for upgraded members Upgrade to access full essay TAKE OUR RELATIONSHIP PUBLIC... Send
Tweet
ROMULUS MY FATHER, THE ISLAND
Belonging is about finding a sense of place in the world which can be due to a strong sense of connection with others. For those who dont belong and cannot find their place they are faced with problems of alienation and loneliness from others or feel estranged or in conflict with the environment. These different aspects are reflected in the texts Romulus my Father, Raimond Gaita and The Island, Armin Greder. These texts portray the concept of belonging and not belonging, whether it is to family, a relationship, place or environment.
Romulus my Father conveys how an individuals relationships are central to our sense of belonging and help us find natural connection whether it with environment or people. Raimond Gaita uses first person throughout the book to express his experiences as well as his mother and fathers experiences of belonging to surroundings. Romulus is a migrant to Australia who always considered himself Romanian. Although Romulus Gaita does not feel at home in Australia he belongs due to the connection he has with those around him. The use of high modality verb choice suggests pleasant nostalgia about events. Most evident in Romuluss recollections of his father, I loved him too deeplyno quarrel could estrange us, which displays the sense of belonging he feels with his father. This relationship is evident after Christina dies, we came together as son and husband with the woman whose remains lay beneath us. Raimonds aspect of belonging is familial. Juxtaposed against Raimonds belonging is Christines inability to belong. Christina is ostracized by the Australian community, due to her promiscuous, unfaithful ways and inability to properly care for her son, Raimond. Christina is described as a troubled girl, who longed for company. This conveys her misfit personality, blinding her from connecting with the environment she is shown, wishing for bigger and better things she neglects those around her...
Home
Miscellaneous An Individuals Interaction with the World Around Them Can Enrich or Limit Their Sense of Belonging By infern0rage1, march 2011 | 4 Pages (996 Words) | 3 Views | 4 .5 1
2
3
4
5
(1) | Report | This is a Premium essay for upgraded members Upgrade to access full essay CLICK THREE TIMES FOR GOOD LUCK Send
Tweet
An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can limit or enrich their experience of belonging. Belonging is central to how we define ourselves: our belonging to or connection emerges from interaction with people and places. Belonging is a distinct identity characterised by affiliation, acceptance and association. Belonging is shaped by personal, cultural, historical and social contexts. By increasing their understanding of themselves and the world around them they can limit or enrich their experience of belonging. These judgements are epitomised in Peter Skrzyneckis Immigrant Chronicles, a collection of poems that consists of 10 Mary Street and Migrant Hostel, which detail the migrant experience and the barriers which limited their experience of belonging. Contrasting perceptions of belonging are presented in the well profound novel Looking for Alibrandi by Melina Marchetta which highlights the limitations in belonging due to racial difficulties encountered within society. Skrzyneckis poem 10 Mary Street tells the story of the house that Peter and his mother Kornelia and his father Feliks moved into in 1951, after arriving in Australia from Germany. It also features an in-depth description of his childhood in relation to living at 10 Mary street. Also included in this poem is the description of the connection that Peter has with his parents. A reoccurring theme of time is present throughout the poem 10 Mary Street. This is shown with the constant repetition of the line for nineteen years. The use of this repetition allow us to engage as to how long Peter had stayed at the house as well as to reinforce the long period of time in which he had enriched his experience of belonging to the house as well as his parents. The garden is also an important aspect of their lives, where the poets parents watered plants grew potatoes like adopted children, stressing their strong connection to the home. To Peter, who was a child himself, the...
(1) | Report | This is a Premium essay for upgraded members Upgrade to access full essay CLICK THREE TIMES FOR GOOD LUCK Send
Tweet
An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging
Belonging is a concept universal to humans and is essential aspect of peoples lives. An individuals experience of belong could be both enriched and limited from their interaction with the world around them. The memoir Romulus, My Father, written by Raimond Gaita and the graphic novel by Shaun Tan, The Arrival both incorporate prominent aspects of the concept of belonging. Through their representation of various elements in the text, ideas about family unity and the sense of connectedness with the environment both show how the experience of belonging is enriched, yet limited to a certain extent.
Through the interaction between Raimond and his father, Romulus, a sense of family relationship is established in Gaitas memoir. The moral and ethical values of Romulus along with the innocuous nature of Raimond enforce the importance of a strong family unit. I know what an honest man is; I know what friendship is I know because I remember these things in the person of my father. This repetition of the word I in the statement reinforces the strong connection, both morally and spiritually between father and son. It accentuates the enriched sense of belonging experienced by Raimond through his interaction with his father. However, limitations in their sense of belonging are also portrayed by Gaita in his text. My fathers vulnerability changed my attitude to Frogmore. In his sighs I heard our isolation and for the first time I felt estranged from the area. Here, the fractured bond between Raimond and Romulus is show. Frogmore has somewhat become a symbol of their family unity and with his father now falling into insanity, Raimond begins to feel isolated from the area. This elucidates how a weak family unity detracts his belonging to the surrounding, highlighting the limitations of belonging in a foreign environment without the essential..
Romulus, Between Shades of Gray and the Kite Runner Essay By TheIngenue, march 2012 | 5 Pages (1179 Words) | 3 Views | 4 .5 1
2
3
4
5
(1) | Report | This is a Premium essay for upgraded members Upgrade to access full essay TAKE OUR RELATIONSHIP PUBLIC... Send
Tweet
An individuals interaction with others and the world around them can enrich or limit their experience of belonging
The base for an individuals experience of belonging begins with the tempestuous walk we undertake throughout our life. Through our cold days of solitude we long to reach the sunlight which will thaw the chill of isolation. Most achieve this goal easily, creating a network of relationships and solidifying their place in the world. However, for others, this journey endeavoured only ends in tragedy and regret. Through the novels of Romulus, My Father, Between Shades of Gray and The Kite Runner, we see the ramifications of the pursuit of acceptance, safety and the right to be content.
Through Romulus My Father, the withdrawal of Christina highlights the negative effects of her inability to belong. She becomes deeply depressed, and her isolation and inability to function in her new home diminishes her self-acceptance. Although she attempts to connect with Raimond and Romulus, her efforts fail. She cannot belong even to her own family. Through symbolism of the meat in the lines below, Raimond Gaita shows the great depth of Christinas longing for connection with her family, and the impact of the consequences of her actions upon her son. Perhaps she and my father had discussed the chances of reconciliation, for the time she was here she tried harder than ever to care for me and the house. She made curtains for the windows, cleaned and occasionally cooked. On my eleventh birthday we lit the stove and she cooked ... She burnt the meat, but so rare was the experience of her preparing any kind of meal that I have since had a fondness for burnt meat.
With the character of Romulus, the pursuit of belonging is not undertaken. He simply has no desire to belong; however, his actions and karakter make him able to solidify his place in the world. He interacts with those around him without a need for acceptance, and thus achieves a goal that he...
(1) | Report | This is a Premium essay for upgraded members Upgrade to access full essay CLICK THREE TIMES FOR GOOD LUCK Send
Tweet
An individuals identify defines their ability to belong, thus ones interactions which develop a personal identity are integral in belonging. This concern is highlighted through Raimond Gaitas memoir Romulus My Father which explores the implications of personal interactions on self-identity and hence implications on sense of belonging. Similarly, Franz Kafkas novel Metamorphosis explores a mans altered identity as a result of personal interactions and the subsequent result on the mans sense of belonging.
The environment is fundamental in the development to which an individual forges a personal identity, and thus is essential in enhancing or restricting ones belonging. In Romulus, Romuluss lack of identity hinders his belonging, as he is unable to forge his identity in Australia. Romulus, having always considered himself Romanian, struggles to identity himself with Australian landscape. He longed for the generous and soft European foliage, but the eucalypts of Baringhupseemed symbols of deprivation and bareness The use of symbolism highlights Romuluss lack of identity in Australia, to which is attributed to the landscape. The deprivation and bareness of the land reflects Romuluss inability to connect, and thus his lack of identity in Australia. The juxtaposition of the Australian landscape to the European landscape further emphasise Romulus lack of identity as he connects only to the beautiful trees of Europe and fails to embrace the Australian landscape. The environment is crucial in development of ones personal identity and hence crucial in belonging, thus Romuluss inability to connect, and consequently his lack of identity limits his experience of belonging.
Similarly, the interaction with environment in shaping a sense of identity is further explored in Romulus. Throughout the memoir Romulus fails to understand the environment, and as a result doesnt develop an identity. He set fire to the stook in order to kill the snake....