You are on page 1of 4

Tabulation Statement in connection with the for the supply of the Air Conditioners

under UGC.
Table: 1.
Details from the Schedule of Materials which appear in the tenders submitted by the firms, i.e. M/S Green Channel Solutions, 1/969 G,
First Floor, Zaina



Sl.
No
Item
Brand and
Model
Numbe
rs
Rate Total Brand and Model
Number
Rate Total Brand and
Model
Number
Rate Total
1. AC
1.5
Sharp AH-X 18
PET W(18000
BTU) Invertor
Technology,
R410, GAS
COANDA Air
Flow, Instant
Law Voltage 2
step, Super Jet
, Laundry
Function
19 46090 875710 Carrier, 1.5TR ,
Hi-Wall Split Unit
( Model Supria
with 4 meters
Copper Piping,
Wiring and
Insulation
Not
specified
43000
Not
Specified
Carrier, 1.5TR ,
Hi-Wall Split
Unit ( Model
Supria with 4
meters Copper
Piping, Wiring
and Insulation
Not Specified
44900
Not
Specified
2, AC
1.1
Sharp AH-X 13
PET W(13000
BTU) ) Invertor
6 35690 214140 Not mentioned
Not
mentioned
Not
mentioned
Not
mentioned
Not mentioned Not
mentioned
Not
mentioned
Not
mentioned
Technology,
R410, GAS
COANDA Air
Flow, Instant
Law Voltage 2
step, Super
Jet,
Laundry
Function
3, Sta
bili
zer

Crompton
Greaves Super
Booster
Stabilizer
25 4500 112500 Stabilizer 4kva
Not
specified
2300




Not
specified
Stabilizer 4kva
Not
specified
2400





Not
specified





4 Sta
nd
Heavy Duty
Stand

25 650 11250 Out Door Unit
Stand
Not
specified
750
Not
specified
Out Door Unit
Stand
Not
specified
790
Not
specified
5 Inst
alla
tio
n
Cha
rge
Installation by
Company
Trained
Engineers with
Vacuum
Process
25 1300 32500 Instillation Charge
Not
specified
1500
Not
specified
Instillation
Charge
Not
specified
1575
Not
specified
6 Wir
ing
Wo
rk
32 AMPS
power plug,
MCB, DB,
Wires, Pipe,
Other
Accessories
For
25
units
- 54000 Refrigerant
Copper Piping
with Wiring and
Insulation
- 750
Not
specified
Refrigerant
Copper Piping
with Wiring
and Insulation
800




Total Rs


-


---


13,00,100


Total


--


48300

Not
specified


Total


--------


50465

Not
specified

Table 2:
Details from the Schedule of Materials appear as Option 1 in the tender submitted by the firm; M/S Green Channel Solutions, 1/969 G, First
Floor, Zaina Buildings, West Hill, Kozhikode- 673005,



Remarks
1, Tender submitted by M/S Green Channel Solutions, 1/969 G, First Floor, Zaina Buildings, West Hill, Kozhikode, 673005, compared to those submitted
by others firms appears as more detailed, specific and complete. It seems from their tender that they undertook a detailed site-inspection. The AC machine
quoted in their tender is stated as using INVERERTER TECHNOLOGY which is already proved across the globe as energy efficient and environment-friendly.
M/S Green Channel Solutions, 1/969 G, First Floor, Zaina Buildings, West Hill, Kozhikode, 673005.
Item Brand and Model Numbers Rate (RS) Total (RS)
AC 1.8 Sharp AH-XP 21 RET W (21000 BTU) Invertor Technology, R410, GAS
COANDA Air Flow, Instant Law Voltage 2 step, Powerful Jet, Eco Mode, Quiet
Function, Torque Control Technology
19 56200 1067800
Stabilizer

Crompton Greaves Super Booster Stabilizer 19 4500 85500
Stand Heavy Duty Stand

19 450 8550
Installation
Charge
Installation by Company Trained Engineers with Vacuum Process 19 1300 24700
Wiring Work 32 AMPS power plug, MCB, DB, Wires, Pipe, Other Accessories For 19 units - 43000
Total Rs 1229550.
Compared to Traditional 5 Star Air Conditioners (regulating temperature by using a compressor that is periodically either working at maximum capacity or
switched off entirely), INVERTOR TECHNOLOGY Air Conditioners are capable of saving 40% of energy consumption.
2. Schedule of Materials in the Tenders submitted both by M/S Sun Business Corporation, Kottaram Building East Nadakkavu, Nadakkavu- 673011
and M/S Kerala State Industrial Enterprises Limited, Kerala Soaps Complex, 29/75 A, Gandhi Road, Vellayil, Nadakkavu-673011 are seems to be
interestingly similar in handwriting and both of them express a near-complete unawareness of the specific requirements at C.K.G.M Govt
College.
3. A/ C machines from M/S Green Channel Solutions, 1/969 G, First Floor, Zaina Buildings, West Hill, Kozhikode, 673005 are stated as having one year
warranty for entire unit and five year warranty for Compressor. Other tenders did not mention such post-purchase service. Moreover, the service for the
supplies from the M/S Green Channel Solutions, 1/969 G, First Floor, Zaina Buildings, West Hill, Kozhikode, 673005 is stated as available from Calicut. Other
two tenders are silent on the service part.
4. Option 1, given in the table number 2 appears as more economical and useful for the C.K.G. M Govt College. AC Machines, though of 1.8TR are more
energy efficient and cost effective than the 1.5TR machines. Numbers required in the former is only 19 against 25 in case the letter.