You are on page 1of 2

sequences and series - Is the sum of sin(n)/n convergent or divergent?

- Mathematics - Stack Exchange


http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/36732/is-the-sum-of-sinn-n-convergent-or-divergent[2012-04-01 1:44:58]
log in chat meta about faq
QUESTIONS TAGS USERS BADGES UNANSWERED ASK QUESTION
1 Answer
active oldest vot es
11
3
Possible Duplicate:
Proving that the sequence is boundedly convergent on
So, in my calculus class (one I'm teaching, not taking), the sum has come up a few
times. Unfortunately, as someone not exactly an expert in the convergence of sums, it seems to
resist the few techniques I know. Certain none of the usual first year calculus tricks (integral test,
alternating series test, ratio test, etc.) work, and the only more tricky technique, partial
summation, I can think of doesn't seem to work either (one would need that is
bounded, which I believe is false).
It seems like it should converge, since it switches sign quite often, but on the other hand, the
harmonic series can mess with your intuition, so I don't have much trust in that. So, I ask to you:
Does this series converge?
(sequences-and-series)
link improve this question
edited Oct 10 '11 at 11:52 asked May 3 '11 at 17:35
6 Andrey Rekalo's answer here seems to answer your question. t.b. May 3 '11 at 17:38
According to Wolphram Alpha it converges to wolframalpha.com/input/?
i=Sum+1+to+infinity+sin%28n%29%2Fn Amrico Tavares May 3 '11 at 17:42
1 @Amrico: in the thread I linked to there is a derivation of that limit. t.b. May 3 '11 at 17:44
@Theo: I started writing my comment before yours was visible. Now it is irrelevant. Amrico Tavares May
3 '11 at 17:50
Given the way the question is titled, I would answer "yes" Ross Millikan Oct 10 '11 at 13:00
feedback
closed as exact duplicate by t.b., Zev Chonoles , Aryabhata, Ben Webster, Isaac
May 4 '11 at 23:15
This question covers exactly the same ground as earlier questions on this topic; its answers may be
merged with another identical question. See the FAQ for guidance on how to improve it.
Is the sum of sin(n)/n convergent or divergent? [closed]
t.b.
33.9k 3 76 134
Ben Webster
306 1 7
Welcome!
This is a collaboratively edited
question and answer site for
people studying math at
any level and
professionals in related
fields. It's 100% free, no
registration required.
Got a question about the site
itself? meta is the place to talk
about things like what
questions are appropriate,
what tags we should use, etc.
about faq meta
tagged
(sequences-and-series) 1511
asked 11 months ago
viewed 551 times
active 5 months ago
Linked
Proving that the sequence
is boundedly
convergent on
Related
Sum of the alternating harmonic
series
Convergence of
Is divergent?
(x) = F
n

k=1
n
sinkx
k
R


n=1
sin(n)
n
sin(n)
N
n=1
( 1)
1
2
(x) = F
n

k=1
n
sinkx
k
R
sin( )/n
n=1

n
k

n=2

(1)
n
n
2
(ln(n))
n
search
sequences and series - Is the sum of sin(n)/n convergent or divergent? - Mathematics - Stack Exchange
http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/36732/is-the-sum-of-sinn-n-convergent-or-divergent[2012-04-01 1:44:58]
about | faq | blog | chat | data | podcast | shop | legal | advertising info | mobile | c ont ac t us | f eedbac k
stackoverflow.com api/apps careers serverfault.com superuser.com meta area 51 webapps gaming ubuntu
webmasters cooking game development math photography stats tex english theoretical cs programmers unix
apple wordpress physics home improvement gis electronics android security bicycles dba drupal
sharepoint scifi & fantasy user experience skeptics
rev
2012.4.1.2043
site design / logo 2012 stack exchange inc; user contributions licensed under cc-wiki with attribution required
13
The sum of
which is clearly bounded and hence by generalized alternating series test (also known as
Dirichlet's test) the sum converges.
EDIT
Hence,
link improve this answer
edited Oct 10 '11 at 7:42 answered May 3 '11 at 17:40
What does the Generalized Alternating Series Test say? Jonathan Gleason May 3 '11 at 17:42
1 @GleasSpty: The generalized alternating test is also known as Dirichlet's test. Wiki explains this in some
detail en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirichlet_test Sivaram Ambikasaran May 3 '11 at 17:46
How does one prove that formula for the sum? I'm guessing that writing and
then following your nose gives the result, but I haven't tried it. Michael Lugo May 3 '11 at 17:53
2 @Michael: An elegant way in my opinion would be to multiply the sum by and then write it as a
telescopic difference of cosines canceling out the terms to get the answer in the final form.
Sivaram Ambikasaran May 3 '11 at 17:54
@ShreevatsaR: doesn't need to have a limit. All we need is to be bounded. (In fact consider the
alternating series . The sequence of partial sums of the numerator is which
doesn't have a limit but it is bounded and hence the series converges.) Sivaram Ambikasaran May 3 '11 at
18:16
feedback
Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged
(sequences-and-series) or ask your own question.
process91
1,296 11
Sivaram Ambikasaran
19.7k 1 20 71
Proving that the sequence
is boundedly
convergent on
Is convergent?
Convergence of
when converges
what is the speed of a divergent
series?
Convergent or divergent series
Closed form for
Example of Convergent Series
Convergence of the series
Is there any possibility to do divergent
summation with ?
Convergent Sequence Terminology
An example of a divergent double
sum
Closed form for ?
Closed Form For
Closed Form For
Determine if sum of series is rational
or not
Convergence of
Sum of two conditionally convergent
series
Convergent sum with primes
Changing divergent series to
convergent by re-ordering
denominators
Is the sequence
convergent?
Find a sum of appropriate values of
and to determine the value of
a series
Is the infinite sum of convergent?
Why?
sin(n) =
n=1
N sin(N) cot( )cos(N) +cot( )
1
2
1
2
2
= sin(n) S
N

n=1
N
2sin( ) = (cos(n ) cos(n+ )) =cos( ) cos(N + )
1
2
S
N

n=1
N
1
2
1
2
1
2
1
2
= S
N
cos( ) cos(N + )
1
2
1
2
2sin( )
1
2
sin(n) =( )/(2i) e
i n
e
i n
sin( )
1
2
S
N
S
N
1 +
1
2
1
3
1
4
1,0,1,0,
(x) = F
n

k=1
n
sinkx
k
R
sin

n
(1 )
n=1

sinan
an

n=1

a
n

1
n
n
(1
n=1

)
n+1
(n) sin
2
n
exp( )

k=1
k

n
k=1
sin
(kn)
2k+1
sin
(knh)
2k+1

n
k=1
sin
l
(kn)
2k+1
sin
n
k=1
1
k
sin(g(n))
f(n)
= (arctan u
n

n
p=0
x
2
p
)
2
cos sin
2
n