You are on page 1of 92

EXHIBIT 1

DECLARATION OF MARC WOLINSKY IN SUPPORT OF HP’S MEMORANDUM
IN SUPPORT OF PRELIMINARY APPROVAL OF THE SETTLEMENT AND
IN OPPOSITION TO THE MOTIONS TO INTERVENE AND SEVER
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page1 of 92





Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page2 of 92









































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page3 of 92























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page4 of 92







































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page5 of 92












































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page6 of 92












































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page7 of 92





















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page8 of 92







































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page9 of 92


























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page10 of 92






















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page11 of 92







































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page12 of 92





























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page13 of 92



















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page14 of 92






































REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page15 of 92















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page16 of 92



























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page17 of 92





























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page18 of 92









































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page19 of 92




































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page20 of 92













































































REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page21 of 92




REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page22 of 92



























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page23 of 92



















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page24 of 92





































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page25 of 92







































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page26 of 92








REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page27 of 92

























REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page28 of 92

































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page29 of 92






































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page30 of 92














































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page31 of 92







































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page32 of 92
























































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page33 of 92






















































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page34 of 92

















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page35 of 92











































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page36 of 92




























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page37 of 92


































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page38 of 92


























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page39 of 92





























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page40 of 92




































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page41 of 92
















REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page42 of 92
























































REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page43 of 92





























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page44 of 92




















































REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page45 of 92

































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page46 of 92
































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page47 of 92
















































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page48 of 92




























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page49 of 92
















































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page50 of 92






























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page51 of 92






























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page52 of 92











































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page53 of 92






































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page54 of 92































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page55 of 92






























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page56 of 92































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page57 of 92





















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page58 of 92
































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page59 of 92



























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page60 of 92













































REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page61 of 92



REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page62 of 92




REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page63 of 92


REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page64 of 92















REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page65 of 92




































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page66 of 92



REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page67 of 92


REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page68 of 92















REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page69 of 92




























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page70 of 92














































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page71 of 92
























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page72 of 92






























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page73 of 92






















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page74 of 92





















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page75 of 92





























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page76 of 92



























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page77 of 92





























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page78 of 92


























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page79 of 92








































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page80 of 92





























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page81 of 92




















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page82 of 92






























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page83 of 92



































































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page84 of 92








































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page85 of 92
























































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page86 of 92












































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page87 of 92






















































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page88 of 92











































Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page89 of 92




























REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page90 of 92

















































REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
REDACTED FOR PRIVILEGE
Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page91 of 92














Case3:12-cv-06003-CRB Document211-1 Filed09/04/14 Page92 of 92