[N.B. The figures in the margin indicate full marks. Questions must be answered in English. Examiner will take account of the quality of language and of the way in which the answers are presented. Different parts, if any, of the same question must be answered in one place in order of sequence.]
Marks
1. Rahim Afroz Ltd. (RA) manufactures domestic solar panels and has a financial year end of 31 December. Its directors are now considering expanding RAs scale of operations via an initiative called Project North.
If Project North is proceed, then RA would have to invest in new capital equipment which would cost Tk.3 million and be purchased on 31 December 2011. Because of the fast rate of technological change in the solar panel industry, PAs directors estimate the Project North would enjoy a three-year period of competitive advantage (2012-2014).
RA has paid for market research which produced the following estimates for Project North.
(1) Year to 31 December 2012 (all figures expressed in December 2011 prices) Total sales Tk.2,200,000 Total variable costs Tk.1,200,000 Total fixed costs (including interest paid of Tk.17,000) Tk.427,000 (2) Increasing sales volume in 2013 and 2014 10% pa (3) Inflation rates: Sales prices 5% pa All costs 8% pa (4) Working capital (to be in place at the start of each trading year) 10% of total annual sales (5) Trade-in value of capital equipment (in December 2014 prices) Tk.600,000
Capital allowances
RAs machinery and equipment attracts capital allowances, but is and will be excluded from the general pool. The equipment attracts 20% (reducing balance) capital allowances in the year of expenditure and in every subsequent year of ownership by the company, except the final year. In the final year, the difference between the machinerys written down value for tax purposes and its disposal proceeds will be either:
(i) treated by the company as an additional tax relief, if the disposal proceeds are less than the tax written down value, or (ii) be treated as a balancing charge to the company, if the disposal proceeds are more than the tax written down value.
Other information
RA uses a post-tax money weighted average cost of capital of 14%. RAs directors would like to assume that the corporation tax rate will be 28% for the foreseeable future and tax will be payable in the same year as the cash flows to which it relates. Unless otherwise stated all cash flows occur at the end of the relevant trading year.
Requirements
(a) Calculate the net present value of the Project North initiative at 31 December 2011 and advise RAs directors whether they should proceed with it. 13 (b) Calculate the sensitivity of the decision in part (a) to changes in the estimated volume of sales. Ignore the impact of working capital in this calculation. 5 (c) Advise RAs directors whether Project North initiative should proceed if the trade-in value of the capital equipment at 31 December 2014 were to be Tk.100,000 (in December 2014 prices). 5 (d) Explain briefly your treatment of RAs interest payment of Tk.17,000 in part (a). 2 (e) Explain Shareholder Value Analysis and identify the extent to which its principles are employed in making the decision in part (a). 5 [Please turn over] 2
2. DDS is a Bangladeshi company which manufactures and sells large-scale components for the oil and gas industries. As the majority of its customers are international, the DDS board is considering whether the company should be hedging its exposure to foreign exchange risk. One of its key customers is NSDF, a Norwegian oil exploration company.
DDS and NSDF have recently agreed a contract (DDS/12/57) for the supply of a large consignment of components. DDS will start manufacturing these at the end of December 2011 and the work will be completed in the summer of 2012. DDS will receive the agreed contract price, 16.75 million Norwegian Kroner (NK), on 31 December 2012.
Information regarding Bangladesh and Norwegian currencies is given in the table below:
Table
(1) Recent research paid for by DDS produced the following forecast spot rates for NK/Tk. at 31 December 2012: Probability 9.200 9.230 10% 9.300 9.330 10% 9.400 9.430 40% 9.500 9.530 40% (2) Spot rate (NK/Tk.) 9.300 9.325 (3) Forward rate at 31 December 2012 offered by DDS bank: 0.10 0.13 NK discount (4) Current interest rates Borrowing Depositing NK 6.60% pa 5.70% pa Taka (Tk.) 5.49% pa 4.30% pa (5) DDS bank has quoted the following twelve month currency over-the-counter options each with a premium of Tk.25,000; A put option on 16.75 million NK at an exercise price (NK/Tk.) of 9.300 A call option on 16.75 million NK at an exercise price (NK/Tk.) of 9.250
Looking ahead, the DDS board has also identified a surplus of funds denominated in Taka. It is planning to invest this in June 2012 in an interest-bearing BD deposit account for a period of six months. It would like to investigate how it might hedge against adverse interest rate movements.
Requirements
(a) Assuming the current date is 31 December 2011, calculate the sterling amount receivable by DDS on 31 December 2012 if it uses: 12 (i) the expected spot rate in 12 months time (ii) a forward contract (iii) a money market hedge (iv) an option. (b) Making reference to your calculations in part (a) discuss the issues that should be taken into account by the DDS board when it considers whether it should hedge the NSDF receipt. 8 (c) Advise the DDS board as to the effectiveness of employing the following methods of hedging the companys exposure to interest rate risk on the proposed investment of the surplus funds in June 2012: 8 (i) a Forward Rate Agreement (FRA) (ii) an interest rate future (iii) an interest rate option (iv) an interest rate swap.
3. HH Ltd. is a small private company that runs a residential activity centre from a stately home, Sundabban Hall, and its 125-acre estate in Khulna. The companys client base comprises principally of local government bodies who send groups of disadvantaged children for residential stays at the estate and private firms who send employees on people development programmes centred on all aspects of leadership, team-building and management development.
[Please turn over] 3
Since HH was established almost 15 years ago, all of its shares have been owned by members of the Khan family. In addition, the residential courses on offer and the range of activities included in them have been restricted by the level of accommodation available in Sundarban Hall itself and by the fact that HH has never used long-term external finance to invest in developing the available facilities.
However, following the recent appointment of Aniq Khan as chief executive in succession to his father, Sabur Khan, who has retired, the family is now keen to expand both the accommodation on the estate and the range of activities on offer to clients. A recently commissioned report by a firm of management consultants has estimated that HHs proposed expansion plans will cost Tk.2.8 million.
The most recent management accounts for HH can be summarized as follows:
Income Statement for the year ended 31 May 2011 Tk.000 Revenue 11,024 Profit from operations 1,281 Tax (359) Profit after tax 922 Dividends (433) Retained profit for the year 489
Balance sheet as at 31 May 2011 Tk.000
Non-current assets 4,228 Current assets 616 Current liabilities (594) 4,250
Share capital (ordinary Tk.1 shares) 2,000 Retained profits 2,250 4,250
Returns on invested funds and the proportion of profits retained are consistent with previous years. Within its current assets HH has only a small cash balance and within its current liabilities it has no borrowings.
Upon his retirement, the former chief executive, Sabur Khan, sold his shares to other members of the family. At the time, the consideration paid for these shares was based on an estimated valuation provided by HHs auditors of Tk.4 per share.
There has been much debate among the directors regarding the source of finance for the firms proposed expansion, with some directors wishing to continue with the policy of no long-term debt and others believing that debt finance should be the preferred option.
Requirements
(a) Calculate HHs cost of capital, stating and justifying the assumptions and methodology you employ. 8 (b) Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of a right issue to fund the proposed expansion, and, as an alternative to a right issue, whether a listing on the Dhaka Stock Exchange Ltd. (DSE) would be appropriate, given HHs particular circumstances. 8 (c) If debt finance were to be used: (i) explain the benefits that might accrue to HH if the proposed expansion was financed by convertible loans rather than an ordinary bank loan; and (ii) explain the implicit assumptions underlying the use of HHs resultant weighted average cost of capital as a discount factor in appraising the proposed expansion. 8 (d) Without using calculations, identify the methods that the companys auditors might have used to value HHs shares. 6
[Please turn over] 4
4. You have been approached for financial advice by the management of a client, Z Ltd. a manufacturing company. Z Ltd. was established in 1957 and formed the platform for growth. The following information relates to the proposed financing scheme for a management buy-out of Z Ltd.
% Tk.000 Share capital held by Management 40 100 Institutions 60 150 250 10% redeemable cumulative preference share (redeemable in ten years time and all sold to institutions) 1,200 1,450 Clearing bank Loans 700 Overdraft facilities (currently 12% per annum) 700 2,850
Loans are repayable over the next five years in equal annual instalments. They are secured on various specific assets, including properties. Interest is 12% per annum.
Z Ltd. is at present part of a much larger organization, which considers this segment to be no longer compatible with its main line of business. This is despite the fact that Z Ltd. has been experiencing growth in revenue in excess of 10% per annum.
The assets to be acquired have a book value of Tk.2,250,000, but the agreed price was Tk.2,500,000.
Requirements
(a) What is the difference between (i) a management by-in and a management buy-out? (ii) a self-off and a spin-off? 4 (b) Write a report to the buy-out team of Z Ltd. appraising the financing scheme. Your report should include inter alia, the cash flow implications of the proposed scheme. 8