Professional Documents
Culture Documents
5.1 SUMMARY
The research topic reflects a concern over the presence of M&A activities in the
growth and development of the media industry in Malaysia. The viability of M&A
activities in the local media industry as a business strategic tool has become clouded
by objections voiced out by sectors of the Malaysian public concerned about media
democracy.
the growth of the Malaysian media industry. The research observed the phenomenon
viability of M&A activities is sought through the examination of the corporate growth
Berhad.
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
The need to develop and grow, and stay competitive and sustainable in business is
management models namely, life cycle model and the competitive forces model as the
mechanisms to seek justifications for certain growth behaviour in the media industry
in Malaysia. Both the PLC and FFA are the business management models claimed
purposeful in determining the position of a company along the industry life cycle and
M&A may be a relevant and wise option along the path of a product’s life cycle. At
the growth level, companies with strong capital may aggressively pursue their
model implicates the deployment of M&A on the decline stage where adaptation and
companies may merge with new but larger influence companies. At this point,
knowledge of the life cycle concept assists managers to understand acquisition costs
versus operating expenses costs, and find a correct balance the two factors (Susman,
1989).
With the proposition that a trend in the modern day development and growth of the
media industry is facilitated by M&A exercises, the research sought to find answers to
74
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
Investigations conducted provided the following answers to the following questions.
Based on the premise that M&A is a corporate external expansion tool, MPB has
purchase agreement (SPA) and share sales agreement (SSA). In doing so, MPB
has not exercised company merger as at the time of research but instead was found
instance, the subsidiaries operating the television stations TV3, ntv7, 8TV, and
From the perspective of the industry life cycle, the assumption that the time span
of each stage of growth is not definite, MPB has expanded its business size fast in
developing its competitiveness by physical size, assets, capital size, workforce and
75
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
expertise, and market reach through the accumulation of subsidiaries leading to
FFA model is the ‘threat of new entrants’ which recognises that high entry
barriers deter new comers into the industry thus safeguarding the prosperity of
existing industry players. MPB has the size of operations competitive enough to
discourage new entrants as well as substitutes into the industry. In so doing, MPB
has developed itself into a mega media conglomerate ever powerful as ‘supplier’
and ‘buyer’.
c) What drives the case company to adopt M&A activities in its growth strategy?
The desire to expand businesses is the most common motive for a merger
(Gaughan, 2000) and proponents of M&A contend that M&A appeals to business
entities for the purpose of synergistic gains, market positioning, and financial
issues such capital access, cost savings and tax relief. Its acquisition exercises
television channels in 2003 that tallied with the increase in MPB’s net revenue
from RM279 million (2003) to RM328 million (2004) is illustrative of what drives
MPB into exercising M&A activities in its expansion strategy. Further evidence is
observed when MPB proceeded to acquire two radio stations and two external
outdoor advertising firms in 2005 which corresponds to the 22% increase in the
76
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
d) What implication(s) do M&A activities have on media ownership in Malaysia?
vying for the same market exist. Horizontal acquisition as exercised by MPB in its
acquisition of ntv7, 8TV, and TV9 to add to its group of TV stations is an act of
where monopoly would be the end product and consumers’ bargaining power is
weakened.
terms of physical size, market size, capital size, and revenue size.
agglomeration that limits media ownership. With licenses controlled by the authority,
new entrants to the industry which is particularly obvious in the broadcast media.
3. Agglomerating media platforms under one corporation does not lend to the concept
of free market competition. With the expansion mode employed by MPB, the motion
along the continuum of oligopoly has reached the point of duopoly where private
77
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
players in the Malaysian media industry that own broadcast media as well as print
segmentation scheme for its television and radio networks (Refer Table 4.5).
differentiated but how best is the dissemination of information on issues that call for
differentiated opinions.
5.2 DISCUSSION
With the exception of STMB (TV3), NSTP, Grand Brilliance and TRC, the rest of its
subsidiary companies are takeovers by sales and purchase transactions of shares and
assets. STMB and NSTP were both its progenitors, while Grand Brilliance and Tiga
Events Sendirian Berhad were the result of MPB internal restructuring. The
acquisition activities took place within the time span of only three years between 2003
MPB exercises corporate acquisitions rather than total merger. The acquired entities
became new additions to its existing media platforms whereby the incoming resources
consolidated with the existing ones under a group management. At the immediate
78
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
effect, ntv7, 8TV, and TV9 were all acquired and placed as subsidiary entities to
MPB. Once acquisitions were completed, internal restructuring ensued and all the
acquired entities were consolidated with TV3 which now acts as the anchor company,
all under the governance of a Group Executive. Similarly, the outdoor advertising
companies, UPD and TRC, were acquired as subsidiary mergers before consolidating
them with the existing BTO, making it the anchor company headed by a Group
Executive. The two radio channels acquired went through the same process.
MPB would make visible the prevalence of a trend in the growth of the local media
is yet to be judged.
5.3 CONCLUSION
competitive analysis forces had been purposeful in establishing justifications for the
presence of M&A activities in corporate growth as in the case of MPB. At the same
time, the industry life cycle model and its variations have helped in visualizing the
Porter’s FAA has provided the basis for MPB’s corporate actions with regards to its
business strategies. By the FAA theory, MPB is truly on track along the road to
79
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
capital, assets, expertise, and market. It is a local media giant which can afford to
The Malaysian media industry has grown from sporadic small scale operations during
organisations. Long gone are the family owned and run media operations. In place are
corporations whose owners are identified by their percentage of share interests. In the
post war era, especially prior to independence, the growth of commercialised media
intensified but then, it was only the print media category which include newspapers,
tabloids, books and periodicals. Modern day facilities are drivers of M&A that is
enjoy better exposure to the media but may get more of the same in terms of
The research came to a conclusion that M&A activities lend to the business growth of
MPB in particular, and the media industry in Malaysia in general. The factual data
and information on the corporate actions of MPB with regards to its corporate growth
shows that merger per se have not taken place at MPB as of the time of research. The
corporation thus far have been exercising acquisitions and consolidations only,
leaving the acquired companies to operate independently while MPB holds majority
interests in all of its subsidiaries. The trend of utilising pure ‘merger’ as a tool for
growth was not found at MPB but there were strong indications of a trend in
developing a “media supermarket” with all media platforms available under the single
80
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
This research is an initial move towards understanding the extent M&A activities are
instrumental in the growth trend of the local media industry. The current research
could only afford a literature search on a single case. A complete understanding of the
situation requires an extensive research which is beyond the capacity of this research.
The indirect concern of this research is over the contributions of M&A on free market
products by marketing its television and radio programmes according to market niche.
However, in view of the limited capacity of this research, further investigations are
to probe into other instances of convergences in the Malaysian media industry for an
empirically oriented research. Taking a similar look at other such cases would further
bring to light the growth trends in the modern day media industry in Malaysia.
5.4 RECCOMENDATIONS
The research was a novice study on an issue much talked about but least
researched in the Malaysian context. The exploration ventured has left room for
further research that would draw the true picture of the hearts and minds of the people
Aware of limitations earlier anticipated, the current research may suffice as a path
finder expecting future efforts to pick up where the current research left off. As such,
a continued research in this area is very much recommended for reasons as follows:
81
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
1) In its limited capacity, the current research had managed a single-subject case
study, far from the ideals of the case study methodology. Developing from the case
technique of information gathering that may include interviews and surveys would
have enriched the findings and provided a better description of the phenomenon.
3) The models employed were, to the best knowledge of the researcher, long-standing
highly acclaimed business management tools. The models employed in the research
were not taken as true performance measurement tools but they had been purposeful
as the basis to describe and justify the corporate actions of the subject of research with
regards to the phenomenon. Options are open for future researches to employ other
4) The research sought to address the phenomenon of merger in the growth trend of
the Malaysian media industry from the perspectives of economic demands with slight
82
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
REFERENCES
Audretsch, D. B. & Feldman, M. P. (1996). Innovative clusters and the industry life
cycle. Review of Industrial Organisation, 11; 253-273. Netherlands: Kluwer
Academic Publishers.
Bernama (2006, December 1). NSTP-Utusan Melayu merger for financial reasons,
says Abdullah. Posted to http://www.biznewsdb.com/ Retrieved 19 March
2007.
Business Insight ( n.d. ). Porter’s Five Forces Analysis Model.. Retrieved 25 June
2007 from http://www.businessinsight.com
83
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
Carlton, J. R. & Lineberry C. S. (2004). Mergers, acquisitions, and organizational
culture. In Carlton & Lineberry (Eds.) Achieving Post-merger Success; 7-16.
California: Pfeiffer.
Dimmick, J. & Coitt, P. (1982). Levels of analysis in mass media decision making: A
taxonomy, research strategy, and illustrative data analysis. Communication
Research, 9(1), January 1982; 3-32. New York: SAGE Publications Inc.
Fauzias Mat Nor (2003). Malaysian corporate mergers and acquisitions. Malaysian
Mergers & Acquisitions: Theory and Slected Cases. Malaysia: Prentice Hall,
Pearson Malaysia Sdn.Bhd.
Gomez, E.T. & Jomo K.S. (2001). Malaysia’s political economy: Politics, patronage,
and profits, (2nd Ed.). UK: Cambridge University Press.
84
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
Huitt, W. G. (2004). Motivation to learn: An overview. Educational Psychology
Interactive. Valdosta, GA: Valdosta State University. Retrieved 4 July 2007
from http://chiron.valdosta.edu/ whuitt/col/motivation/motivate.html
Komninos, I. (2002). Product life cycle management. Urban and Regional Innovation
Research Unit. Thessaloniki: Aristotle University. Retrieved 16 April 2004
from http://www.urenio.org/tools/en/Product_Life_Cycle_Management.pdf
Lang, L.R. (2000). South China Morning Post vs. TVE. Cases of Mergers and
Acquisitions in Hong Kong; 47-70. Singapore: Prentice Hall-Pearson
Education Asia Pte. Ltd.
Levitt, T. (1965). Exploit the product life cycle. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved
16 April 2007 from http://www.hbsp.harvard.edu/hbsp/hbr/articles/jsp?
ml_action=get-rticle&articleID65608&ml_page=1&ml_subscriber=true
McCombs E. M. & Shaw. D. (1972). The agenda-setting function of the mass media.
Public Opinion Quarterly, 36; 176-187. Retrieved 4 July 2007 from
http://www.soc.unitn.it/sus/membri_del_dipartimento/pagine_personali/delgro
sso/personali/articoli%5Cagendasetiingtotal.htm
85
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
McNamara, C. (1997). Basic overview of organisational life cycles. Authenticity of
Consulting, LLC. Retrieved on 24 November 2007 from
http://www.managementhelp.org/org_theory/org_cycle.htm
Media Prima (Malaysia) Berhad [MPB]. (2007). Annual Report 2006. Retrieved 28
March 2007 from http://www.mediaprima.com.my
MPB. (2007). About Us. Media Prima Berhad. Retrieved 28 March 2007 from
http://www.mediaprima.com.my
New Sabah Times, (2006). Corporate profile. New Sabah Times: About us. Retrieved
22 April 2007 from http://www.newsabahtimes.com.my/nstweb/profile
New Straits Times Press [NSTP] (2007). Corporate history. NSTP: About us.
Retrieved 12 March 2007 from http://www.nstp.com.my/Corporate/nstp/
aboutus/ aboutHistory.htm
86
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
Radio Station World (2007). Malaysia Radio Frequencies. Global Radio Directory.
Retrieved 22 April 2007 from http://www.radiostationworld.com/locations/
malaysia/Radio.asp
Rocky’s Bru. (2006, December 13). MP’s, Senator “No” to NSTP-Utusan Melayu
Merger. Message posted to http://www.rocky’bru.blogspot.com/2006/.
Retrieved 19 March 2007.
Tamil Nesan (1994). Tamil Nesan 70th Anniversary Special Edition 1994. Malaysia:
Tamil Nesan Sendirian Berhad.
Veale, J. (1998). Business Life Cycle, The. Professionalising The Corporate &
Family Organisation (PTCFO) Inc. Retrieved April 2007 from
http://www.ptcfo. com/businesslifecycle.html.
87
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.
White, G. (2002). Journalists and community stakeholders: Allies in the fight against
media consolidation. Center for Communications and Community. Retrieved
July 2007 from http://www.sscnet.ucla.edu/ issr/ccc/content/ archive/article-
journ-fcc.htm
.
Wikipedia Foundation Inc. (2007). Newspapers in Malaysia. Wikipedia Encyclopedia.
Retrieved 22 April 2007 from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_news
papers_in_Malaysia
Wong & Partners (2004). Malaysia Guide to Merger and Acquisitions 2004-2005.
Retrieved 4 July 2007 from http://www.bakernet.com/NR/rdonlyres/_/39066/
Malaysia 200506.pdf
88
Please purchase 'e-PDF Converter and Creator' on http://www.e-pdfconverter.com to remove this message.