You are on page 1of 10

International Journal of BioTechnology

and Research (IJBTR)

ISSN(P): 2249-6858; ISSN(E): 2249-796X
Vol. 4, Issue 5, Oct 2014,1-10
TJPRC Pvt. Ltd.



Laboratory of Biology and Organism of Physiology, Team of Soils Biology, Faculty of Biological Sciences, University
of Sciences and Technology, Houari Boumediene, (USTHB), Algiers, Algeria

Departement of Plant Production, National School of Agronomy, (ENSA), Algiers, Algeria

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of 50 and 100 mM NaCl concentrations on growth, nodulation,
nitrogen fixation and accumulation of proline of four faba bean (Vicia faba L. minor) cultivars growing symbiotically with
Rhizobium leguminosarum bv viciae. The response to salt stress depended on the cultivar and the level salt. Thus, 100mM
NaCl caused a great reduction in growth parameters such as leaf area and dry weight of shoot and root, but the height of
plant was less affected. Number, dry weight of nodules per plant and nitrogen fixation were reduced with increasing
salinity for all cultivars. However, proline content was increased in leaves of all cultivars tested. Sidi Aich and Espresso
were less affected by salt than the sensitive cultivars Castel and Maya. Our results suggests that the NaCl tolerance of the
Sidi Aich and Espresso cultivars is supported by better growth, the less N2 fixation inhibition and a higher osmotic

KEYWORDS: Salt Stress, Cultivars, Dry Weight, Nodules, Nitrogen Fixation, Proline Content
Salinity is considered as a significant factor affecting crop production in arid and semi-arid region of the world
(Munns, 2002).
In Algeria, more than 20% of irrigated lands are affected by salinity (Rouabhia and Djabri, 2010). This problem
was observed in several regions of the country as in Oran, in certain irrigated perimeters where the salinity reaches
considerable proportions (Hamdy, 1999).
An excess of salts in the soil causes many adverse effects on plant growth, which are due to a low osmotic
potential of soil solution (osmotic stress), specific ions effects (salt stress), and nutritional imbalances, or a combination of
these factors (Ashraf, 1994).
Legumes are classified as salt sensitive crop species (Maas and Hoffmann, 1977) and their productivity limitation
is associated with, lower growth of the host plant, poor symbiotic development of root- nodule bacteria
(Georgiev and Atkins, 1993) and, consequently, a reduction in the nitrogen-fixation capacity (Soussi et al., 1998; El Nady
and Bellal, 2005; Kenenil et al., 2010). Unsuccessful symbiosis under salt-stress may be due to failure in the infection
process because of the effect of salinity on the establishment of rhizobia (Fahmi et al., 2011).

Chaker-Haddadj Assia, Nabi Fahima, Ait Kaci-Sadji Hamida & Ounane Sidi Mohamed

Salt stress affects nitrogen fixation in legumes by inhibiting the photosynthate supply to the nodule
(Garg and Singla, 2004), reducing supply of respiratory substrates to the bacteroides (Delgado et al., 1994) and by
alterations in oxygen-diffusion barrier (Serraj et al., 1994).
Survival and growth in saline environment were the result of adaptative processes, such as ion transport and
compartmentation, osmotic solute synthesis and accumulation, which lead to osmotic adjustment (Munns and Termaat
1986). The compounds that accumulate most commonly were proline, trehalose or trigonelline, and glycine betaine, these
compounds have been reported to play a role in the response to salt stress of different legumes (Trinchant et al., 2004;
Lpez et al., 2008). The principal agronomic advantage of faba bean is its ability to fix nitrogen by symbiosis with
Rhizobium bacteria, and thereby substantially contribute to the supply of protein for human food and animal feed and
greatly reduce dependence on energy-consuming mineral N fertilizers (Kpke and Nemecek, 2010).
The inclusion in Algeria, of faba bean in the cropping systems is still rather low despite their beneficial function.
In order to re-launch this culture, it was essential to identify salt tolerant cultivars to improve agricultural production in
soils subject to salinity.
The objectives of this study were to compare the responses of cultivars the faba bean (Vicia faba L. minor) to salt
stress and to assess their symbiotic performance; this was done by evaluating the plant growth, nodulation, nitrogen
fixation, and accumulation of proline.


Biological Materials and Growth Conditions
The cultivars, Espresso, Maya and Castel, were obtained from GAE SEEDS (France). The local cultivar of Sidi
Aich was obtained from Institute of Crop Development in El Khroub, Algeria.
The experiment was conducted in a greenhouse at Technical Institute of Vegetable Crops of Staoueli, Algiers,
(315 E, 3645 N) under semi-controlled conditions: 28 5C / 10 2C day/night temperature, day length ranging from
10-12 h, relative humidity 70 10%.
Seeds were allowed to germinate on filter paper moistened with distilled water for 3 days in darkness.
After emergence, seedlings were transplanted into pots filled with 11 kg

of cultivated soil

with the following

characteristics: clay 2.03%; silt 17.51%; sand 78.45%, organic matter 0.68%; total nitrogen 0.03%; phosphorus (ppm)
2.79; pH 7.56.
Five pots were used for each cultivars and saline treatment, with one plant per pot. Three concentrations of salt
(0 (no added salt), 50 and 100 mM) in the form of NaCl were added to irrigation water when the first trifoliate leaf
appeared (21 days after planting). The treatments were maintained for 8 weeks, coinciding with the onset of flowering.
At the end of treatment, the plants were sampled to determine height of plant. Leaf area was measured using an
Area meter (Thomson model Air Pax Methatronics).
The harvested plants were separated into shoots, roots and nodules. The dry weight of all plant tissues was
estimated after oven drying at 70 C for 48 h.

Impact Factor (JCC): 2.8872

Index Copernicus Value (ICV): 3.0

Effects of Salt Stress on Growth, Nodulation and Nitrogen Fixation of Faba Bean (Vicia faba L. Minor) Cultivated in Algeria

Proline Determination
The proline content in leaves was determined using the method of Bates et al. (1973). The concentration of
proline was calculated from a standard curve of L-proline.
Nitrogen-Fixation Assay
Nitrogenase (EC was determined by the acetylene-reduction-activity (ARA) on the entire root systems
of plant, following the method of Hardy et al. (1968). Gas samples were analysed for ethylene produced in the reaction
using a Perkin Elmer 8600 gas chromatograph equipped with a flame ionization detector and a 3,2 mm x 2 m (long),
Porapak-R-type column (80 mesh) according to Ligero et al. (1986).
Statistical Analysis
The experiment layout was split plot. The parameters studied values were means of five replicates.
Data were analysed using analysis of variance method (ANOVA) and means were separated by least significant
difference (LSD) using SPSS statistical software (version 10). The correlations coefficients among the parameters studied
were also calculated.

Growth Parameters
For the four faba bean cultivars, NaCl caused a high significant (p < 0, 0001) reduction for all growth parameters
(Table 1). However the responses varied with cultivars and with the salt dosage applied.
The percentage reduction relative to the control in height of plant was greater at 100 mM NaCl for Maya and
Espresso where it reached around 49 %, followed by Castel and Sidi Aich with 34 % and 36 %, respectively. The leaf area
was more sensitive to salinity than height of plant. Cultivars Maya and Espresso showed the largest decrease (74%) in leaf
area than other cultivars, especially in the presence of 100 mM NaCl.
Under non-saline conditions, the four cultivars have showed a wide range of dry biomass production.
The cultivars Maya and Castel reached the highest shoot (SDW) and root dry weights (RDW), whereas Sidi Aich and
Espresso reached the lowest.
The salt treatment with 50 mM NaCl induced a reduction in SDW and RDW about 34% and 43%, respectively, in
Sidi Aich cultivar, however in Maya SDW decreased 75% and RDW by 61%. This decrease was even more pronounced
with 100 mM NaCl, the smallest reduction was observed in Espresso and Sidi Aich (about 58%) and the greatest was in
Castel and Maya (about 84%).
Results of root/shoot dry weight ratio (RSR) are reported in Table 1. For Sidi Aich cultivar, the ratio was constant
whereas in Espresso, Maya and Castel, the ratio increased with NaCl,. However, no significant differences were observed
between 50 and 100 mM treatments.
Nodulation and Nitrogen Fixation
Symbioses established between Rhizobium leguminosarum bv. viciae and Vicia faba showed significant variation
between the four cultivars.

Chaker-Haddadj Assia, Nabi Fahima, Ait Kaci-Sadji Hamida & Ounane Sidi Mohamed

The number of nodules per plant in the absence of salt stress varied between different cultivars (Figure 1a), from
107 nodules in Sidi Aich to 257 nodules per plant in Maya. Salt treatment caused a high significant (p < 0. 0001) reduction
of the total number of nodules per plant.
At 50mM NaCl, reduction in nodules number ranged from 36-52 % for the cultivars Sidi Aich, Espresso and
Maya, whilst Castel cultivar had 63 %. In Maya, this parameter was most affected by salinity compared with others
cultivars, especially at 100 mM NaCl, in which nodulation was reduced by 75%.
In non- stressed conditions, values of nodule dry weight per plant between cultivars varied in a range of 0.87-1.45

g plant (Figure 1b). The cultivar Sidi Aich reached the highest dry weight; this was compensated by producing larger
nodules; whereas Maya reached the lowest.
The salt treatment with 50 mM NaCl declined nodule dry weight about 50% in Maya and Sidi Aich, whereas in
Castel and Espresso the reduction of this parameter was more than 65%. In addition, in these cultivars, nodule dry weight
inhibition was 83-89% with the 100 mM NaCl.
Regarding acetylene reduction activity (ARA), nodules formed by Sidi Aich registered the highest value, and
nodules of Castel the lowest value, 39.50 and 24.50 mol C2H4 h-1 plant-1, respectively (Figure 1c). In general, the lowest
salt concentration had a negligible effect on ARA. Sidi Aich appeared to be the less affected cultivar and has showed a
reduction of ARA only about 10%; in Espresso and Maya ARA declined about 30%; whereas in Castel the reduction
attained 49%. However, highest salt treatment drastically affected ARA, reduction was much higher (84-94%) and all
cultivars were salt susceptible.
Proline Determination
In non- stressed conditions, all the cultivars showed similar proline content in leaves (on average 0.22 mg .g leaf
fresh weight-1) but under salt stress conditions a high significant (p < 0.0001) increase of proline content was observed
(Figure 2). However, no significant differences were observed between 0 and 50 mM treatments in Castel, Maya and
With 100 mM NaCl, the highest proline content were observed in Sidi Aich and Espresso cultivars (1.28 and
1.13 mg .g leaf fresh weight-1 respectively) whilst Castel and Maya accumulated 0.74 and 0.61 mg .g leaf fresh weight-1

In the present study, we have evaluated the responses to salt within four cultivars of faba bean in symbiosis with
Rhizobium leguminosarum bv viciae. The responses were dependent on the cultivar and the level of applied salt.
Our results, showed a reduction of all parameters of growth of four cultivars under saline conditions (Table 1).
Indeed, with 100 mM of NaCl, (after 8 weeks), plant dry weight has decreased by about 56-58 % in Sidi Aich and
Espresso respectively, and by about 84 % in Maya and Castel. Similar results were reported in other faba bean cultivars.
Cordovilla et al. (1999) found that plant dry weight in Vicia faba L. cv. Alborea has showed reductions of 65% at 100 mM
NaCl (after 6 weeks). Also, the biomass of shoots in Vicia faba L. cv. Scirocco was reduced to 67% compared to control
plants after 9 day application of 100 mM NaCl (Pitann et al. 2011).

Impact Factor (JCC): 2.8872

Index Copernicus Value (ICV): 3.0

Effects of Salt Stress on Growth, Nodulation and Nitrogen Fixation of Faba Bean (Vicia faba L. Minor) Cultivated in Algeria

According to Aslam et al. (1993) both fresh and dry weight could be used as the criterion for assessing relative
salt tolerance. The comparison of these percent inhibitions, suggested that Sidi Aich and Espresso cultivars are less
sensitive to saline conditions than Maya and Castel.
Ullah et al. (1993) reported that, the reduction in dry matter production of faba bean may be caused by ion
toxicities, reduction water absorption, impaired biochemical and physiological processes associated with increasing salt
For all cultivars, salinity affected leaf area more than plant height (Table 1). Tammam (2003) proposed that the
death of old leaves dues to ion-toxicity might prevent the supply of nutrients and hormones to young leaves. Under saline
conditions, the increase in root-shoot ratio (RSR), (Table 1) were even more significant in Castel, Espresso and Maya
cultivars, that indicated that shoot growth was more inhibited by NaCl than root growth. In this regard, Tejera et al. (2006)
has suggested that increases of RSR with salinity could be associated with lower shoot growth and therefore root growth
might occur at the expense of the shoot growth.
In all the cultivars, the number of nodules and their dry weight were reduced by salt concentrations. These results
are in accordance with experiments of Cordovilla et al. (1999) in faba bean, with Saadallah et al. (2001) in common bean
and with Ben Salah et al. (2011) in Medicago ciliaris. Our results showed that, the greatest reduction was observed in
Castel and Maya (Figure 1a, b).The reduction of nodule dry weight was significantly larger than the number of nodule.
Similar results were reported by Bouhmouch et al. (2005) where the decrease in nodule number caused by 25mM NaCl on
two common bean cultivars, was about 50% and about 94% in nodule weight. The reduction of nodules number
suggested, that the salt inhibited the initiation and the development of a second generation of nodules, since the salt stress
was applied after nodulation (Saadallah et al. 2001; Ben Salah et al. 2011).
Salinity also decreased, symbiotic nitrogen fixation; and the most affected salt concentration was 100mM NaCl
(Figure 1c). Similar findings have been reported in Vicia faba (Delgado et al.1994; Cordovilla et al. 1999), Cicer arietinum
(Garg and Singla, 2004; Tejera et al. 2006) and Phaseolus vulgaris (Khadri et al., 2007). The nodules of Sidi Aich and
Espresso were more effective in comparison to other cultivars.
The decrease in nitrogen fixation may be due to the inhibition of the carbon flow from the plant to the bacteroids
(Garg and Singla 2004; Lpez et al. 2008) and a reduction in cytosolic protein production, specifically leghemoglobin by
nodules (Delgado et al. 1994). Serraj et al. (1994) attributed the decrease in nitrogen fixation by salt stress, to limitation of
oxygen diffusion in nodules or to the toxic effects of Na or Cl accumulation. The correlations among dry weight of the
whole plant, dry weight of nodules and nitrogen fixation per plant were positive and significant in all cultivars (Table 2).
These correlations indicated a close relationship between plant growth and symbiotic nitrogen fixation of nodules.
The proline levels of salt stressed plants were significantly higher with 100 mM NaCl compared to the control
(Figure 2). Sidi Aich and Espresso were less sensitive to salt accumulated much more proline (5-6 folds over non saline
conditions) than Maya and Castel most sensitive (only 2 of 3 fold higher proline than control plants). The increased
accumulation of proline was reported in many species exposed to salinity (Dimartino et al. 2003),and this accumulation has
been proposed to be part of the process of osmotic adjustment that contributes to the cellular adaptation of many plant
species to drought, salinity, and other stresses (Munns and Termaat, 1986). In cowpea (Vigna unguiculata), a salt tolerant
cultivar Pitiuba has a higher osmotic adjustment as compared with a salt sensitive cultivar Perola (Freitas et al. 2001).

Chaker-Haddadj Assia, Nabi Fahima, Ait Kaci-Sadji Hamida & Ounane Sidi Mohamed

In contrast, Katerji et al. (2002) could not find relationship of osmotic adjustment with salt tolerance of broad bean
(Vicia faba L.). Thus, controversies exist to whether accumulation of proline was essential for improving salinity tolerance
or, whether it was just a symptom of salt tolerance.

This study showed variability among faba bean cultivars in the response to salt stress. The responses were
dependent on the cultivar and the level of applied salt.
The cultivars Maya and Castel were most salt-sensitive cultivars whereas Sidi Aich and Espresso were relatively
tolerant. These cultivars showed at high salt concentration better growth, less N2 fixation inhibition and a higher osmotic
adjustment; as such they could be the choice for field applications.


Ashraf, M. (1994). Breeding for salinity tolerance in plants. Crit Rev Plant Sci, 13, 17-42


Aslam, M., & Qureshi, R. H., & Ahmed, N. (1993). A rapid screening technique for salt tolerance in
rice (Oryza sativa L.). Plant Soil, 150, 99-107


Bates, L.S., & Waldren, R.P., & Teare, I.D. (1973). Rapid determination of free proline for water- stress
studies. Plant Physiol, 39, 205-207


Ben Salah, I., & Slatni, T., & Gruber, M., & Messadi, D., & Gandour, M., & Benzarti-Haouala, M., & Zribi, K.,
& Ben Hamed, K., & Perez-Alfocea, F., & Abdely, C. (2011). Relationship between symbiotic nitrogen fixation,
sucrose synthesis and anti-oxidant activities in source leaves of two Medicago ciliaris lines cultivated under salt
stress. Env Exp Bot, 70, 166-173


Bouhmouch, I., & Mouhsine, B.S., & Brhada, F., & Aurag, J. (2005). Influence of host cultivars and Rhizobium
species on the growth and symbiotic performance of Phaseolus vulgaris under salt stress. J Plant Physiol, 162,
1103- 1113


Cordovilla, M., & Ligero, D.P., & Lluch, C. (1999). Effect of salinity on growth, nodulation and nitrogen
assimilation in nodules of faba bean (Vicia faba L.). Appl Soil Ecol, 11, 1-7


Delgado, M.J., & Ligero, F., & Lluch, C. (1994). Effect of salt stress on growth and nitrogen fixation by pea,
faba-bean, common bean and soybeans plants. Soil Biol Biochem, 26, 371-376


Di martino, C., & Delfine, S., & Pizzuto, R., & Loretto, F., & Fuggi, A. (2003). Free amino acids and glycine
betaine in leaf osmoregulation of spinach responding to increasing salt stress. New Phytol, 158, 455-463


El- Nady, M.F., & Bellal, E.B. (2005). Responses of faba bean (Vicia faba L.) plants to root nodule bacteria
under salinity conditions. J Agric Res, 49, 245-253

10. Fahmi, A.I., & Agate, H.H., & Eissa, R.A., & Hassan, M.M. (2011). Effect of salt stress on some nitrogen fixation
parameters in Faba Bean. Pakistan J Biol Sci, 14, 385-391

Impact Factor (JCC): 2.8872

Index Copernicus Value (ICV): 3.0

Effects of Salt Stress on Growth, Nodulation and Nitrogen Fixation of Faba Bean (Vicia faba L. Minor) Cultivated in Algeria

11. Freitas, J.B.S., & Chagas, R.M., & Almida, M.R., & Cavalcanti, F.R., & Silveira, J. A. G. (2001). Expression of
physiological traits related to salt tolerance in two contrasting cow pea cultivars. Documentos Embrapa Meio
Norte, 56, 115-118
12. Garg, N., & Singla, R. (2004). Growth, photosynthesis, nodule nitrogen and carbon fixation in the chickpea
cultivars under salt stress. Braz J Plant Physiol, 16, 137-146
13. Georgiev, G.I., & Atkins, C.A.(1993). Effects of salinity on N2 fixation, nitrogen metabolism and Export and
diffuse conductance of cowpea root nodules. Symbiosis, 15, 239-255
14. Hamdy, A. (1999). Saline irrigation assessment for a sustainable use saline irrigation. Halophyte production and
utilization. Projects n 18 CT 96-0055, 152-162
15. Hardy, W.F.R., & Holsten, R., & Jackson, E., & Burns, E. (1968). The acetylene ethylene assay for nitrogen
fixation: lab and and field assay for nitrogen evaluation. Plant Physiol, 43, 1185-1207
16. Katerji, N., & Mastrorilli, M., & Hamdy, A., & Hoorn, J.W. (2002). Water status and osmotic adjustment of
broad- bean (Vicia faba L.) in response to soil salinity. Acta Hortic, 573, 305-310
17. Kenenil, A., & Assefa, F., & Prabu, P.C. (2010). Characterization of acid and salt tolerant rhizobial strains
isolated from faba bean fields of Wollo, Northern Ethiopia. J Agric Sci Technol, 12, 365-376
18. Khadri, M., & Tejera, N.A., & Lluch, C. (2007). Sodium chloride-ABA interaction in two common bean
(Phaseolus vulgaris) cultivars differing in salinity tolerance. Envi Exp Bot, 60, 211-218
19. Kpke, U., & Nemeck, T. (2010). Ecological services of faba bean. Field Crop Res, 115, 217-233
20. Ligero, F., & Lluch, C., & Olivares, J. (1986). Evolution of ethylene from roots of Medicago sativa plants
inoculated with Rhizobium meliloti. J Plant Physiol, 125, 361-365
21. Lpez, M., & Herrera-Cervera, J.A., & Iribarne, C., & Tejera, N.A., & Lluch, C. (2008). Growth and nitrogen
fixation in Lotus Japonicus and Medicago truncatula under salt stress: nodule carbon metabolism. J Plant Physiol,
165, 641-650
22. Maas, E.V., & Hoffman, G.J. (1977). Crop salt tolerance: Current assessment. J Irrig Drain Div Am Soc Civil
Eng, 103,115-134
23. Munns, R., & Termaat, C. A. (1986). Whole-plant response to salinity. Aust J Plant Physiol, 13, 143-160
24. Munns, R. (2002) Comparative physiology of salt and water stress. Plant Cell Environ, 239-250
25. Pitann, B., & Kranz, T., & Zorb, C., & Walter, A., & Schurr, U., & Muhling, K.H. (2011). Apoplastic pH and
growth in expanding leaves of Vicia faba under salinity. Env Exp Bot, 74, 31-36
26. Rouabhia,

A.E.K., & Djabri, L. (2010). Lirrigation et le risque de pollution saline. Exemple des eaux

souterraines de laquifre miocne de la plaine dEl Ma Labiod. Larhyss journal, 8, 55-67

27. Saadalah, K., & Drevon, J.J.,& Haji, M., & Abdelly, C. (2001). Genotypic variability for tolerance to salinity of
N2- fixing common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris). Agronomie, 21, 675- 682

Chaker-Haddadj Assia, Nabi Fahima, Ait Kaci-Sadji Hamida & Ounane Sidi Mohamed

28. Serraj, R., & Roy, G., & Drevon, J.J. (1994). Salt stress induces a decrease in the oxygen uptake of soybean
nodules and in their permeability to oxygen diffusion. Physiol Plantarum,91, 161-168
29. Soussi, M., & Ocana, A., & Lluch, C. (1998). Effects of salt stress on growth, photosynthesis and nitrogen
fixation in chick-pea ( Cicer arietinum L.). J Exp Bot, 49, 1329-1337
30. Ullah, S.M., & Soja, G., & Gerzabek, M.H. (1993). Ion uptake, osmoregulation and plant- water relations in faba
beans (Vicia faba L.) under salt stress. J Land Man, Food Env, 44, 291-301
31. Tammam, A.A. (2002). Response of Vicia faba plants to the interactive effect of sodium chloride salinity and
salicyclic acid treatment. Acta Agron Hung, 51, 239-249
32. Tejera, N.A., & Soussi, M., & Lluch C. (2006) .Physiological and nutritional indicators of tolerance to salinity in
chickpea plants growing under symbiotic conditions. Env Exp Bot, 58, 17-24
33. Trinchant, J.C., & Boscari, A., & Spennato, G., & Van de Sype G., & Le Rudulier, D. (2004). Proline betaine
accumulation and metabolism in Alfalfa plants under sodium chloride stress. Exploring its compartmentalization
in nodules. Plant Physiol, 135, 1583-1594

Table 1 Effect of NaCl treatments on plant height (cm) , leaf area (cm2) ,shoot dry weight (SDW), root dry weight
(RDW), plant dry weight (PDW) in g plant-1 and root-shoot ratio (RSR) of four faba bean cultivars treated with 0, 50 and
100 mM NaCl.
Table 2 R values showing correlations between dry weight of the whole plant (PDW), nodule dry weight (NDW)
and acetylene reduction activity (ARA) in faba bean cultivars treated with 0, 50 and 100 mM NaCl.
Figure 1 Effect of NaCl treatments on nodule number (a), nodule dry weight (b) and on acetylene reduction
activity (ARA) (c) of four faba bean cultivars treated with 0, 50 and 100 mM NaCl. Mean values of 5 replicates are
followed by S.E.
Figure 2 Effect of NaCl treatments on the proline content (mg .g leaf fresh weight-1) of four faba bean cultivars
treated with 0, 50 and 100 mM NaCl. Mean values of 5 replicates are followed by S.E.
Table 1



Sidi Aich


Plant Height

44.6 2.08

Impact Factor (JCC): 2.8872

Leaf Area










Index Copernicus Value (ICV): 3.0

Effects of Salt Stress on Growth, Nodulation and Nitrogen Fixation of Faba Bean (Vicia faba L. Minor) Cultivated in Algeria

Means with the same letter in the vertical columns do not differ significantly (P0.05).Means are followed by
Table 2
R Values
*P< 0.05, ** P<0.01.







Figure 1



Proline mg g -1 FW



M aya

Sidi Aich

Figure 2