Professional Documents
Culture Documents
b#OOEPEHRHIOE
VEFMHXU^E
?\FEHR$)HIHMGMIPFUI
;]:[`dSbf[W_dWcg[^`d_`ZSUWSUWaU[q_VWaWcd`_Sd( ;]bfWV[`
SIS]`^q_W]Wdaoc[efVWdST[`V[dUWc_[^[W_e`WdemV[dafWde`S[^aSce[c
]S^[d^STW_V[U[q_ Sdfd Z[\`d Z`j( If aS]STcSVWU]ScS4 }I[ S]Yf_` VW
g`d`ec`de[W_W XS]eSVW dST[VfcoS& VW^m_VW]SS :[`d& W] UfS] VSSe`V`d
STf_VS_eW^W_eW& j _`kSZ[WcW5 j ]W dWcm VSVS~ #IS_e[SY` +4/$( 9fS_V`
W] bfW ]]WgScWda`_dST[][VSV VWdWW dST[VfcoS ^md bfW c[bfWkS& a`VWc`
XS^S& _` bfWVScm UZSdbfWSV`( ;] eS] SacW_VWcm VW] YcS_ CSWdec` _`
d`]`]`bfWVWTWZSUWc& d[_`eS^T[n_W]^`V`VWZSUWc]`aScScWU[T[c]S
Sac`TSU[q_V[g[_S!;PMEDR@QW PDWDQ#a( ,+$(
;]eW^`cVW] IWp`cWdW]ac[_U[a[`VW]SdST[VfcoS&jW]Z`^TcWbfW
SUUWVWSdWc^`VW]SV`ja]Sd^SV`S]SdW^W\S_kSV[g[_S&WdW]W\W^a]Sc
^md_`T]WVW]S`TcSVW :[`d(((
;]U`_`U[^[W_e`WiaWc[^W_eS]VW]S gWcVSVWcSa[WVSV&W_]SU`_dS'
YcSU[q_j W] dWcg[U[` V[Sc[`d S :[`d& SdWYfcS ]SUf]efcS^md W]WgSVSVW
]S^W_eW& W] S]^SjW] UfWca`((( BScWUWaU[q_VW]a`VWcV[g[_`Z`_cScm
_fWdec`d d[_UWc`d WdXfWck`d W_ TfdUS VW dST[VfcoSaScSW] fd` U`_U[W_'
kfV` VW _fWdecSd XSUf]eSVWd ^md W]WgSVSdaScSZ`_cSVW :[`d jTW_V['
U[q_ VW _fWdec`d dW^W\S_eWd( 9`^` WdeSd XSUf]eSVWd d`_ VWc[gSVSd VW
:[`d j _` Sfe`UcWSVSd& VWTWcoS_ dWc SacWU[SVSd U`^` eS]W_e`d VW :[`d
aScSdWcW^a]WSV`dW_dfdWcg[U[`(
BSd XSUf]eSVWd ^W_eS]Wd bfW W] U[W]` _`d VS VWTW_ dWc ecSeSVSd
U`^` ]`da`VWcWd^mdW]WgSV`daScSY`TWc_ScW]cW[_`VW]UfWca`( B`d
SaWe[e`dj]SdaSd[`_Wd_SefcS]WdVWTW_dWcafWde`dTS\`W] U`_ec`]VW ]S
U`_U[W_U[Sj]`dSXWUe`dWda[c[efS]Wd(((
BS cW][Y[q_ VW @WdfUc[de` _f_US VWYcSVS S bf[W_ ]S cWU[TW& _f_US
]` ZSUW cfV` ` e`caW& VWdU`cend ` acWdf^[V`& SaSd[`_SV` ` Vfc` VW
U`cSkq_( 7] U`_ecSc[`& cWX[_S W] Yfde`& dS_e[X[US W] \f[U[`& afc[X[US j
W__`T]WUW ]`daW_dS^[W_e`d ]]Wgm_V`]`dW_USfe[g[VSVS@WdfUc[de`!2L
JSF@PDQBDJDQRH@JDQ#a( +.+$(
2RPMQKR$*HIHMGMIPFUI, 3OSUMQGMSMRHIOEVEFMHXU^E
:[`d ]W V[` S IS]`^q_ ]S dST[VfcoS bfW n] VWdWSTS ^md bfW ]Sd
c[bfWkSd& ]`d Z`_`cWd ` ]S ]ScYS g[VS( BW U`_UWV[q ]` bfW ZSToS aWV['
V`4 f_S ^W_eW VWda[WceS& f_ U`cSkq_ YcS_VW j f_ Wdaoc[ef e[Wc_`( }N
,('/,-+-(-'/(*%-%&%.)'%;;; 382:35080109420 276
8XQIV$+HIHMGMIPFUI, 8EYIUHEHIUEIHXGEGMaQ
IS]`^q_ dW [_eWcWdq WdaWU[S]^W_eW W_ ]SZ[de`c[S_SefcS]&aWc` dfd
[_gWde[YSU[`_Wd _` dW ][^[eSc`_Sf_ d`]` cS^` VW] dSTWc( CWV[S_eWf_
WdefV[` V[][YW_eW VW e`VSd ]Sd U`dSd UcWSVSd& S_[^SVSd W [_S_[^SVSd&
`Tefg`f_U`_UWae` U]Sc` VW] 9cWSV`c( ;_ ]Sd XfWckSd VW ]S_SefcS]WkS&
W_W]^f_V`^[_WcS]jS_[^S]&jW_e`V`mcT`]&ScTfde`jX]`c&gWoSf_S
cWgW]SU[q_ VW ]S dST[VfcoSVW :[`d& Sbf[W_ U`_`UoSj S^STS USVSgWk
^mdS^WV[VSbfWdWWdX`ckSTSa`cSacW_VWc(
BSdST[VfcoSbfW:[`d [_da[cSTSSIS]`^q_dWWiacWdSTSW_US_e`d
VWS]STS_kSjW_^fUZ`dac`gWcT[`d( }Nac`afd`ecWd ^[]aScmT`]Sd5 j
dfd gWcd`d XfWc`_ ^[] j U[_U`( JS^T[n_ V[dWceq VW ]`d mcT`]Wd& VWdVW
W] UWVc` VW] BoTS_` ZSdeS W] Z[d`a` bfW _SUW W_ ]S aScWV( 7d[^[d^`
V[dWceq VW ]`d S_[^S]Wd& VW ]Sd SgWd& VW ]`d cWae[]Wd& jVW ]`d aWUWd~ #+
HWjWd.4-,& --$(
;_ ]`dac`gWcT[`d VW IS]`^q_ dW WiacWdS_ac[_U[a[`d VW f_Sg[VS
dS_eS W [_eW_e`d W]WgSV`d5 ac[_U[a[`d _SU[V`d VW] U[W]` bfW ]]WgS_ S ]S
a[WVSV5 ac[_U[a[`d bfW VWTW_ cWY[cUSVSSUe` VW ]Sg[VS( <fW ]S S^a][S
V[Xfd[q_ VW Wde`d ac[_U[a[`d j W] cWU`_`U[^[W_e` VW :[`d U`^` 7bfW]
Sbf[W_aWceW_WUWe`VSS]STS_kSjZ`_`c& ]`bfWZ[k`VW]`dU`^[W_k`d
VW] cW[_SV` VW IS]`^q_ f_S na`US VW W]WgSU[q_ ^`cS] eS_e` U`^` VW
ac`daWc[VSV^SeWc[S](
;dUc[T[q n]4 }8[W_SgW_efcSV` W] Z`^TcW bfW ZS]]S ]S dST[VfcoS&
j bfW `Te[W_W ]S [_eW][YW_U[S4 a`cbfW df ^WcUSVWcoS Wd ^W\`c bfW ]S
^WcUSVWcoS VW ]Sa]SeS& j dfd Xcfe`d ^md bfW W] `c` X[_`( Cmd acWU[`dS
Wd bfW ]Sda[WVcSdacWU[`dSd5 je`V` ]` bfWafWVWd VWdWSc& _` dWafWVW
U`^aScScSW]]S(BScYfcSVWVoSdWdemW_df^S_`VWcWUZS5W_df[kbf[Wc'
VSc[bfWkSd j Z`_cS( Ifd US^[_`d d`_ US^[_`d VW]W[e`d`d& j e`VSd dfd
gWcWVSdaSk( ;]]SWdmcT`]VWg[VSS]`dbfWVWW]]SdWSdW_4 jT[W_SgW_'
efcSV`dd`_]`dbfW]S^S_e[W_W_~#Fc`gWcT[`d -4+-'+2$(
}IST[VfcoS S_eW e`V`4 SVbf[WcW dST[VfcoS4 j S_eW e`VS ef a`dWd[q_
SVbf[WcW[_eW][YW_U[S~#Fc`gWcT[`d.41$( };]ac[_U[a[`VW ]SdST[VfcoSWd
W]eW^`cVW@WZ`gm~#IS]^` +++4+*$( };]eW^`cVW@WZ`gmWdST`ccWUWc
W]^S]5 ]Sd`TWcT[Sj]SScc`YS_U[S&jW]^S]US^[_`j]ST`USaWcgWcdS&
ST`ccWkU`~#Fc`gWcT[`d24+-$Y;PMEDR@QW PDWDQ#aa( ,-&,.$(
9EUWIV%"HIHMGMIPFUI,3MOOEPEHRHIOEVEFMHXU^E
{Gfn eW^Sd VW ^WV[eSU[q_ acWdW_eS_ ]Sd ISYcSVSd ;dUc[efcSd S ]S
^W_eW z:q_VWafWVW_ZS]]ScdWeW^SdVWU`_eW^a]SU[q_^mdW]WgSV`d6
z:q_VWZSjeW^SdeS_ [_eW_dS^W_eW [_eWcWdS_eWd6 z;_bfn dW_e[V` d`_
e`VSd ]Sd [_gWde[YSU[`_Wd VW ]S U[W_U[S Zf^S_S U`^aScST]Wd W_ dfT]['
^[VSVj^[deWc[`U`_ ]SU[W_U[SVW ]S8[T][S6 z:q_VWZSjS]Y` bfWSdo
^fWgS]SXfWckSVW] [_eW]WUe`Sf_aW_dS^[W_e`ac`Xf_V`jdWc[`6
I[aWc^[e[^`dbfW]S8[T][S_`dZST]W&_`dW_dWpScm]`bfW_[_Yf_S
`ecSU`dSafWVWW_dWpS^`d( FWc` {Sj dWWdaSU[S]S^W_eWW_UfS]bf[Wc
`ecSU`dS& WiUWae`]SFS]STcSVW:[`d( BS][eWcSefcSd[_gS]`c&]SdZ[de`'
c[Sd X[Ue[U[Sd d`_ g`cSk^W_eW VWg`cSVSd& ^[W_ecSd ]S 8[T][S& U`_ e`V`d
dfd eWd`c`d VW gWcVSV dSYcSVS& aWc^S_WUW VWdUf[VSVS d`TcW _fWdecSd
^WdSd( I[dWZ[U[WcSVW]SFS]STcSISYcSVS]ScWY]SVW]Sg[VS&cWX[_Scm&
W]WgScm j dS_e[X[UScm( ;d ]S g`k VW :[`d S] Z`^TcW( zBW acWdeScW^`d
SeW_U[q_6
}BS Wia`d[U[q_ VWefd aS]STcSd S]f^TcS5 ZSUW W_eW_VWcS ]`d d[^'
a]Wd~( B`d m_YW]Wd Wdem_ \f_e` S] bfW WdUfVc[pS ]Sd ;dUc[efcSd aScS
[^acWd[`_Sc W []f^[_Sc ]S ^W_eW( ;] ^S_VSe` VW 9c[de` V[c[Y[V` S ]`d
V[dUoaf]`d ZSUW^[]`UZ`U[W_e`d Sp`d4 };dUfVc[pSV ]Sd ;dUc[efcSd5 a`c'
bfW Sg`d`ec`d `d aScWUW bfW W_ W]]Sd eW_n[d ]Sg[VS WeWc_Sj W]]Sd d`_
]SdbfWVS_eWde[^`_[`VW^o~& e[W_WZ`jaScS_`d`ec`d[YfS]XfWckSbfW
;] IS]gSV`cVW]^f_V``XcWUWW]V`_VW]Sg[VSWeWc_SS]`dVWdUS'
cc[SV`d( 9`_f_SU`^aSd[q_Sf_^Sj`cbfW]SVWf_aSVcWeWccW_S]bfW
aWcV`_SSdfZ[\`VWdUScc[SV`&SccWaW_e[V`j dfXc[W_eW( @WdrdTfdUSf_S
cWdafWdeSSdfd `XcWU[^[W_e`dVWS^`cjaWcVq_( 9]S^SS]`d WccS_eWd4
}L`]gW`d S ^o& j j` ^W g`]gWcn S g`d`ec`d~ #CS]SbfoSd -41$( I[ W]
aWUSV`c _` WdUfUZS ]S g`k VW ^[dWc[U`cV[S bfW ]` ]]S^S U`_ e[Wc_` j
U`^aSd[g` S^`c& df S]^S bfWVScm W_ ]Sd e[_[WT]Sd( I[ VWdSac`gWUZS
]S`a`cef_[VSVbfWdW ]WacWdW_eSjaWcd[deWW_ df^S]SU`_VfUeS&W_W]
^`^W_e` ^W_`d WdaWcSV`& ]S [cS VW :[`d USWcm d`TcW n]( };] Z`^TcW
bfW cWacW_V[V` W_VfcWUW ]S UWcg[k& VW cWaW_eW dWcm bfWTcS_eSV`& j _`
ZSTcm aScS n] ^WV[U[_S~ #Fc`gWcT[`d ,34+$((( };] eW^`c VW @WZ`gm Wd
W] ac[_U[a[` VW ]S dST[VfcoS~ #Fc`gWcT[`d 34+*$ ;d W] Xf_VS^W_e` VW ]S
U`ccWUeS WVfUSU[q_( B`d bfW& eW_[W_V` f_S `a`cef_[VSV XSg`cST]W& _`
ZSjS_SacW_V[V`WdeSac[^WcS]WUU[q_&_`d`]`Wdem_VWdUS][X[USV`daScS
W]dWcg[U[`W_]SUSfdSVW]IWp`c&d[_`bfWd`_f_U]Sc`aWc\f[U[`aScS]S
U`^f_[VSVW_]SbfWg[gW_(
IS]`^q_ WiZ`ceS S ]`d\qgW_Wd4 }EjW& Z[\` ^o`& ]S [_decfUU[q_ VW
ef aSVcW& j _` VWdacWU[Wd ]S V[cWUU[q_ VW ef ^SVcW5 a`cbfW SV`c_` VW
YcSU[S dWcmSefUSTWkS&j U`]]ScWd SefUfW]]`((( BS dST[VfcoSU]S^SW_
]SdUS]]Wd4((( L`]gW`dS^[cWacW_d[q_5ZWSbfoj`VWccS^Scn^[Wdaoc[ef
d`TcWg`d`ec`d&j`dZScndSTWc^[daS]STcSd~#Fc`gWcT[`d +42&35,*',-$
Y>DQRHKMLHMQN@P@J@HFJDQH@#e(.&aa( ,*/&,*0$(
#"
:[`d SdWYfcScm_ W] ni[e`( C[W_ecSd ]S S_e[YfS U`_XWVWcSU[q_ VW] ^S]
Wdem`cYS_[kSVSU`_ecSW]]`d& n] ]Wd ^S_VSbfW dWS_ gS][W_eWd j XfWceWd
jbfW ]fUZW_gS]Wc`dS^W_eWa`cbfWe[W_W_f_U[W]`bfWYS_Sc&je[W_W_
W_dfdX[]SdS7]Yf[W_bfWWd^mdbfWf_m_YW]& W]a`VWc`d`=W_WcS] VW
]`dW\ncU[e`dbfWU`_VfUW ]`dW\ncU[e`dVW]U[W]`( ;_`USd[q_VW ]Se`^S
VW @Wc[Uq& _[_Yf_` VW ]`d W\ncU[e`d VW ?dcSW] afV` S]STScdW VW ZSTWc
fdSV` df XfWckSX[_[eSaScSVWcc[TSc]`d ^fc`d VW ]SU[fVSV& d[_`bfWW]
Fco_U[aW VW] W\ncU[e` VW @WZ`gma]S_Wq WdSTSeS]]S U`_ ]S^Sj`c dW_U['
]]Wk&aScSbfWW]IWp`cd`]`cWU[T[WcS]SY]`c[SjW]Z`^TcW_`dWWiS]eScS
S do ^[d^`( :[`d _`d ZS ac`^We[V` e`V` a`VWc5 a`cbfW ]S ac`^WdS Wd
aScSg`d`ec`djgfWdec`dZ[\`d&jaScSe`V`d]`dbfWWdem_^fjV[deS_eWd&
eS_e`dU`^`W] IWp`c]]S^W(
:WTWZSTWcf_SXWjf_SU`_X[S_kSU`_e[_fSdW_W]9Sa[em_VW_fWd'
ecS dS]gSU[q_( :WTW^`d `TWVWUWc dfd qcVW_Wd( BSd aScWVWd VW @Wc[Uq
USjWc`_U`^`cWdf]eSV`VW`TWVWUWcqcVW_Wd!0MLEJHBRMW T@JMP#a( ++2$(
:[`d `TcScm ^ScSg[]]Sd a`c SbfW]]`d bfW U`_XoW_ W_ n]( I[ ]`d
bfW ac`XWdS_ dWc df afWT]` _` e[W_W_ ^md XfWckS Wd a`cbfW U`_XoS_
VW^Sd[SV`W_dfac`a[SdST[VfcoSj_`aWc^[eW_bfWW] IWp`ccWgW]W df
a`VWcW_ df TW_WX[U[`( l] SjfVScm S dfd XoW]Wd Z[\`d W_ e`VSd ]Sd `US'
d[`_Wd d[VWa`d[eS_e`VSdfU`_X[S_kSW_n]j]W`TWVW_d[_UfWde[`_Sc]`
!>DQRHKMLHMQN@P@J@HFJDQH@#e(.&a( +0-$(
##