Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Case report
Abstract Hereditary equine regional dermal asthenia belongs to a group of inherited, congenital connective
tissue dysplasias usually described as hyperelastosis cutis, cutaneous asthenia, dermatosparaxis, or EhlersDanloslike syndrome. This report presents the clinical and histological features of three related Quarter horses affected
with regional dermal asthenia. These horses had bilateral asymmetric lesions of the trunk and lumbar regions,
where the skin was hyperextensible. Handling of the skin elicited a painful response and superficial trauma led
to skin wounds. The skin was thinner than normal in the affected areas, with thickened borders and harder fibrotic
masses (pseudotumours). The histopathological findings included thinner and smaller collagen fibrils, and a loose
arrangement of collagen fibres in the middle, adventitial and deep dermis. Massons trichrome and Calleja stains
did not reveal any abnormality of collagen and elastic fibres. Electron microscopy showed no abnormalities. As
in human patients, pseudotumour histopathological findings included fibroplasia and neovascularization. The
pedigree chart of these animals supports an autosomal recessive type of inheritance, which has been suggested
by other studies. This is the first report of this disease in Brazil. Its clinical and histological features resemble those
described in horses affected with this condition in the United States.
IN TRO D U CT ION
Cutaneous asthenia is a group of inherited, congenital
dysplasias of the connective tissue. These dysplasias
are characterized by loose, hyperextensible, abnormally fragile skin, which is easily torn by minor
trauma.1 Cutaneous asthenia has been described in a
number of different species, including cattle, horses,
sheep, dogs, pigs and cats.14 In human patients, this
condition is known as EhlersDanlos syndrome
(EDS). This is the most prevalent heritable disorder of
connective tissue, and it includes several subclassifications.5 In veterinary medicine, the characterization of
this disease is difficult; therefore, this connective tissue
dysplasia has been referred to as cutaneous asthenia,
dermatosparaxis, EhlersDanlos-like syndrome or,
most commonly, hyperelastosis cutis.
In equine clinical practice this skin abnormality is
infrequently diagnosed. There are a few case reports
characterizing its clinical features and histological
findings. The first report described two Quarter horses
with multiple, fragile, hyperextensible skin areas in
Correspondence: A. S. Borges, Universidade Estadual Paulista,
Faculdade de Medicina Veterinria e Zootecnia, Unesp, Botucatu,
SP, Brazil, 18618000. E-mail: asb62@cornell.edu
2005 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology
126
AS Borges et al.
C ASE REPO RT S
Three Quarter horses were referred to the Faculdade
de Medicina Veterinria e Zootecnia, Unesp, Botucatu, Brazil for evaluation of skin lesions. The horses
belonged to the same farm located in Sao Paulo,
Brazil, and were otherwise healthy. Figure 1 is a pedigree
chart showing these patients.
Horse 1, a 4-year-old, chestnut mare, was presented
with a history of recurrent skin wounds in the saddle
area for the past 2 years. Two skin lacerations had
developed on the dorsum after riding, and had been
replaced by an extensive thickened scar. Physical examination revealed several depressed plaques in the thoracic region and lumbar areas. The skin in the affected
areas appeared fragile and thinner than normal; it was
loosely attached to the subcutaneous tissue and easily
raised when pinched together (slack skin). A pachymeter or cutimeter (pair of jaws with a scale in tenths
of a mm, connected to a spring; Hauptner, n. 33865,
Metzingen, Germany) was used to measure skin thickness. The measurements revealed a threefold difference
between the affected and nonaffected skin in the
contralateral side. Some skin plaques showed raised,
thicker edges and the skin was painful when manipulated. During exercise, depressed plaques did not sweat
like the rest of the body. Occasionally, the edges
contained hard, tumour-like masses. Throughout the
2 years, minor skin trauma had induced wounds with
hypertrophic scars and pronounced folding. At first,
the ulcerative wounds were in the saddle area. The
slack skin was evident in the thoracic region, hip joint
and dorsal portion of caudal-lumbar areas. Skin areas
that were thin and hyperextensive were surrounded by
clinically normal skin. Lesions were bilateral without
evident symmetry.
Histopathological findings
Skin biopsies were taken from the lateral neck, dorsal
and abdominal area of each horse. Visibly normal skin
of the affected horses was also sampled. Similar skin
biopsies were obtained from the same areas of a control horse of the same age and breed. Biopsies were
attached to cardboard, fixed in 10% neutral buffered
formalin, routinely processed, embedded in paraffin
wax, and stained with haematoxylin and eosin (H&E),
Massons trichrome and Calleja stain for elastin fibres.
The most remarkable histopathological findings
were the thin and small collagen fibrils, which created
a loose arrangement of collagen fibres within the deep
dermis (Figs 4 and 5). Occasionally, the collagen fibre
arrangement was loose and the fibres were thin in the
superficial and periadnexal dermis (Figs 6 and 7).
In some areas, focal haemorrhage, increased vascularization and a few haemosiderin-laden macrophages
were noted. In some sections the deep dermis of the visibly normal skin showed reduced denseness when compared to normal control horses. The collagen fibres of
all affected horses, including visibly unaffected skin,
were paler on the H&E stain than the collagen from
control normal horses. Subcutaneous fat was not
present in any biopsy samples. The Calleja special stain
did not reveal any abnormality of elastic fibres. Some
collagen bundles of the middle and deep dermis stained
red with Massons trichrome, as did some skin sections
of the normal control horses. Neither the epidermis
nor the adnexal epithelium showed any histopathological change. The pseudotumour histopathological
findings included fibroplasia and neovascularization,
127
Figure 2. Affected animal with fragile skin that was easily raised
when pinched (slack skin). In the affected areas, the skin was loosely
attached to the subcutaneous tissue. These areas were surrounded by
clinically normal skin and by scar tissue.
Figures 4 5. Normal (4) and affected skin (5). Note the paler,
thinner and loose arrangement of the collagen fibres in the affected
skin compared to the same area of a normal horse. H&E.
Bar = 50 m.
D ISCU SSION
The clinical description of affected horses presented in
this study is similar to the condition that has been
described in 50 affected animals in different areas of
the United States. 11 In the patients described here,
the skin of affected areas was easily stretched when
pinched and shaped into a fold that gradually flattened
Figures 6 7. Normal (6) and affected skin (7). The peri adnexal
dermis of the affected skin shows thinner and paler collagen fibres.
Note the increased intercollagen clear spaces. Normal skin biopsies
were taken from the same areas of a normal horse of same age and
breed. H&E. Bar = 50 m.
2005 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology, Veterinary Dermatology, 16, 125130
128
AS Borges et al.
R E FE R E N C E S
1. Scott DW. Congenital and hereditary diseases. In:
Scott DW ed. Large Animal Dermatology. Philadelphia:
W.B. Saunders, 1988: 33457.
2. Patterson DF, Minor RR. Hereditary fragility and
hyperextensibility of the skin of cats. A defect in collagen
fibrillogenesis. Laboratory Investigation 1977; 37: 1709.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
129
Rsum Lasthnie dermique rgionale hrditaire appartient un groupe de dysplasies du tissu conjonctif,
gntiques, congnitales, gnralement dcrits sous les termes dhyperelastosis cutis, dasthnie cutane, de dermatosparaxie, ou de syndrome dEhlers-Danlos. Cet article rapporte les donnes cliniques et histopathologiques
de trois Quarter Horse affects par cette maladie. Les chevaux prsentaient des lsions bilatrales asymtriques,
localises sur le tronc et la rgion lombaire, o la peau taut hyperextensible. La manipulation de la peau provoquait une raction douloureuse et les traumatismes superficiels des plaies. Dans les zones atteintes, la peau tait
plus fine que la normale, avec des bords paissis et des masses fibreuses dures (pseudotumeurs). Lexamen histopathologique a montr des fibrilles de collagne petites et fines, et des fibres de collagne anormales dans les
dermes moyens, annexiels et profond. La coloration de Masson et celle de Calleja na pas montr danomalie des
fibres de collagne et dlastine. La microscopie lectronique na pas montr danomalie. Comme chez lhomme,
lexamen histopathologique des pseudotumeurs a montr une fibroplasie et une novascularisation. Lanalyse du
pedigree de ces animaux est en faveur dun mode de transmission autosomique rcessif, comme dj suggr par
dautres tudes. Il sagit de la premire description de cette maladie au Brsil. Les donnes cliniques et histopathologiques ressemblent celles dcrites chez les chevaux prsentant cette affection aux Etats-Unis.
Resumen La astenia drmica regional hereditaria pertenece a un grupo de displasias congnitas, hereditarias,
de tejido conjuntivo, normalmente descritas como hiperelastosis cutis, astenia cutnea, dermatosparaxis, o
sndrome pseudo-Ehlers-Danlos. Este artculo presenta las caractersticas clnicas e histolgicas de tres Quarter
Horses relacionados, afectados por una astenia drmica regional. Estos caballos tenan unas lesiones simtricas
bilaterales en el tronco y regiones lumbares, dnde la piel era hiperextensible. La manipulacin de la piel generaba
una respuesta de dolor y el traumatismo superficial causaba heridas cutneas. En las reas afectadas, la piel era
2005 European Society of Veterinary Dermatology, Veterinary Dermatology, 16, 125130
130
AS Borges et al.
ms delgada de lo normal, con mrgenes engrosados y masas fibrticas ms duras (pseudotumores). Los hallazgos histopatolgicos incluan fibras de colgeno ms delgadas y pequeas, y una disposicin laxa de las fibras
de colgeno en la dermis media, profunda y adventicia. Las tinciones tricrmica de Masson y de Calleja no revelaron ninguna anormalidad de las fibras de colgeno y fibras elsticas. La microscopa electrnica no mostr
anormalidades. Como en los pacientes humanos, los hallazgos histopatolgicos del pseudotumor incluan fibroplasia y neovascularizacin. El pedigr de estos animales apoya una forma de herencia autosmica recesiva, que
ha sido sugerida en otros estudios. ste es el primer estudio de esta enfermedad en Brasil. Sus caractersticas clnicas e histolgicas se parecen a las descritas en caballos afectados por esta enfermedad en los Estados Unidos.
Zusammenfassung Die heriditre equine regionale dermale Asthenie gehrt zu einer Gruppe von vererblichen, congenitalen Bindewebsdysplasien, die normalerweise als Cutis hyperelastica, cutane Asthenie, Dermatosparaxis oder Ehlers-Danlos-Syndrom bezeichnet werden. Dieser Bericht prsentiert die klinischen und
histologischen Eigenschaften von 3 miteinander verwandten Quarter Horses, die mit regionaler dermaler
Asthenie befallen waren. Diese Pferde hatten bilateral asymmetrische Lsionen im Bereich des Rumpfes und der
Lumbarregionen, in denen die Haut hyperextensibel war. Die Berhrung der Haut lste eine schmerzhafte Reaktion aus und oberflchliches Trauma fhrte zu Hautwunden. In befallenen Bereichen war die Haut dnner als
normal, mit verdickten Rndern und verhrteten fibrotischen Massen (Pseudotumoren). Die histopathologischen Befunde umfassten dnnere und kleinere Kollagenfasern und eine lockere Anordnung der Kollagenfasern in der mittleren, adventitialen und tiefen Dermis. Masson-Trichrome- oder Calleja-Frbung zeigten keine
Anormalitt der kollagenen oder elastischen Fasern. Elektronenmikroskopie zeigte keine Anormalitt. Wie auch
bei humanen Patienten waren Fibroplasie und Neovaskularisierung histopathologische Befunde in den Pseudotumoren. Die Ahnentafel dieser Tiere gibt Hinweise auf einen autosomal rezessiven Erbgang, was in anderen Studien schon vermutet wurde. Dieses ist der erste Bericht ber diese Krankheit in Brasilien. Ihre klinischen und
histologischen Eigenschaften hneln denen, die bei Pferden mit dieser Erkrankung in den Vereinigten Staaten
beschrieben wurden.