You are on page 1of 49

3

((

Ccritical

public

discourse)

Ctheo

of

the

state)

C c.

Q)

(
)

"

(1 989. 1.

22)

lic

awareness)

...................................................11

(state) ...............19

..........................................32

P
.............................................43

....................................60

......................................73
...................................................78

1980 i

1987

.......

11

??

:\'

1>

1950 60

......

12

13

H "

H "

()

()

Csociology

action)

"

14

of social

15

2>

(sti tutiona l

aaratuses)

4>

Crelative

autonomy)

1980

3>

"

Cstate)

()

""

16

17

"

(peripheral caitalist develo'lent)


--

ical ublic discourse) -

(ractical-n0 rmative olitical philoso.hy)

(stte)

1960

" .

18

19

"

< 5>;

"

10>

" 6>;

"
7>; (

)(
f

()

(
) 8>;

"

(civil
"

society)

( ular-democratic

struggle)

< 9

>;

......

state) (socie)

(M_

Weber)

1960

(R. Miliband) (N. Poulantzas)

1 1>

'

(c. Q)

(state) (calist

20

12>

21

()
7

)/

()

()

)()

iJj(jJJ

22

23

~.:--

()/

()

()

24

"

()

25

rfjf!

(decommod;cation)

()

......

(liberal

()(

capitalist

""

()

......)

state) i

27

26

:
""

()

.( bureaucracy)

posiv

ration q_ l

structure) (

()

chnobureaucratic lanning)

14>

(J.

Habermas)

13>

28

(1)

29

""

(2)

Alice

H.

Amsde

15>

--f

"

(3)

30

31

" < 1

......

GNP

" O~

Ctechno

cratic

consciousness)

John Friedmann

17>

32

33

("

")

18>

"

(non~ve

()

problems)

"

()

(ultimate

real)

"

< 17>

(domain

of

meaninglessness)

(meaning)

"(

(fact)

"

( value)

( instrumentalism)

( ragmatism)

34

35

()

"

< 19>

):

(critical

moral judgment)

"

< 2 1>

""

;;

(ublic sphere)

......"

< 20>

36

37


l
""

H """

H ("

Objectivity"

in Social Science and Social Pol


1904 )

"

" < 22>

(value relevance)

{ideal type)

38

(objective ossibili)

23>

( valuative

discou (citical

dis

course)

(J.

Haben)

(cognitive

interest)

7
(technical

cogzitive

interest)

( ractical

cognitive

te st)

39

'il!iI!

(systematically

disto ed

co ucation)

( critical

24>

social

science)

ideology)

(emac to

interest).

(cn"tique of

cognitive

(autonomy)

25>

- (

roach)

l di

""

40

41

historical-structural

'f!!iIJ

1.it--iiA

W
>

"

""

26>

Cauthoritaan regime)
:

~---'>-

42

43

"

"

( rq_-makg) ;

'1"

"

< 29>

< 27>

"

1950

; 1950 ;

"

< 28>

H "

"

H "

(develo'l entalist

"

Cardoso)

(E. Faletto)

state) (F.

44

H.

45

'1 1949

60

"

30>

("

" ~"")
("""")

""

1950

1949

(1 948) 33%'

1949 1948

(1 953) 52% ' 1959

"

58% ' 36%

"

20%' 15% ; 1952

47%

0.5 29% 0.5~1

46

47

'Ir

"

1950

) 3

34>

1950

1950

3D

1950

32>

(1 953~60)

; 1950

48

49

25

1itiaEM
az--'s-bit

()

j!!Jyjsil-

iT:

1950

( 1950

36

(eriheral

>

capitalist

develo.

ment)

..

:(

:(

1953 7

t 35>)

'

50

51

--

""

"

37>

""
0

"" H

"

"

"

40>

(periPheral capital accumulation)

..

4 1>

" < 38>

()

'

1953

43>

' H

" < 39> 0

52

53

(informal sector)

(ifras-

truclure) 44>

"

"

:1j1!ji--te
(Samir

Amin)

45>

(sectoral

disarticulation)

1421"

"

54

55

L]I

48>

46 >

J Li

49>

60

(devel

o ment

of

underdevelo ment)

0"

< 47>

()

()

50> 0

(urb

""

iformal sector)

60

56

57

"-"

5 1>

"

60

) .(

A lice

H. Amsden

58

59


(1 945)

73 1987 424 253


3 912
1987
' 800

29 334
45 9% ' 34 466 54.1%

5011

35

52>

803 19 994
56% ' 160

60

5 207 : 836
1 489 6 696

28 000
14 475 52%' 085
2 744 ; 3 390

61

585 3 329 53>

: (3)

5 731 54> '

.409

"

(49~51 )"

2034 )

() 6696

5 615

(
295 )

)
55>

1988

9 6 ~160

"

"

: (1 50

: (2)

;;

62

63

...... 56>

"

57>

;;

(Karl Polanyi)

<: The

Great

(1 944) .

Tranrmation "J

"

"

<

; (fictitious

commod-

59>

iti)

""

"

58>

64

..

" < 60> ""

65

_./

""

142

"

6 1>

"

"

"

"

1984

47.5 / 21 .4

66

67

/ 28.5 /

38.4 /

110 /

(collective consu tio

Cun roductive) Cunpro.;t-

""

le)

()

68

ea9GPgaz--T-4

69

"

plan-

ning)

" < 62>

()

"-

()

C M. Castells)
"

meaning) "

"

70

"")

of

socie);

"()

Cunified culture) " < 63>

Cse~ roduction

Curban

Csystem

"

"

71

-h !

()

()

'li:

72

73

:
-

1950

hv"um a

()

A
i
ib
"

)'

(.)60

)-

74

75

()

1.

:: bnEEAAY EE

(public awareness)

(ublic roblem-consciousness) "


64>

2.

76

77

Z
C

'1986 1 210
1987 1 835 p.
22
2. . <>

.1988.

11'

3. "

" Alain

Tour-

Eye--An

analy-

aine' The Voice and the

sis of social movements (tr. by Alan Duff,

:
LU

3

FJ

1983 1987

1 516
1987
676 . <
>

1988.
)

78

fTV

1.

Cambridge University Press , 1981) , part


1

4A Martin

cal

Carnoy , The State and Politi-

Theo (Princeton

1984) ,

University Press ,

pp.130~5.

5. <>

:> ' 282 (1987.

6. 25) , pp.

'

28~31.

6. . <>

1988. 2.

10~11)

7. <
(

79

. . . .

1988. 2.

10~11)

Marxist Analysis of the State" , Sociol-

8.

ogy , Vo l. N o. 4 (N ovember , 1984) , pp.

9. <> ' <.:> '

269 (1 986.

12. 10) , pp.

36~40

<

0
0986

:>

( 1987)
(

'1988.

: <

> ' <. 305


10)

11'

(1988.

6.

<

> ' <. 305 (1 988.

6.

10)

noy : B.

J essop ,

The

Car-

C<<italist

C<< ital

ed. by J. Holl-

1978)

12. 11

Offe, Structural Problems of the

Capitalist State" , in Klaus von Beyme ed.

German

Political

Studies.

Vo l.

Publications , 1974) , pp. 31 ~57;

1 (Sage

The

Cap-

italist State and the Problem of Policy


Formation" , in Leon N. Lindberg et a l.
ed

Stress and Contradiction in Modern

Caitalism

11. M.

125~44;

(D.

C.

Heath ,

Contradictions

State (MIT Press , 1984)

01

1973) ,

the

pp.

Welfare

State (New York University Press , 1982);

D. Held and J. Krieger, Theories of the

01 the State (St. Martin's Press ,

State: Some Competing Claims" , in D.

Held et a l. eds. , The State in Capitalist

Euro e

(London , 1984) , pp. 1 ~20; C. Pier-

son , New Theories of State and Civil


Society

State and

oway and S. Picciotto (Edward Arnold ,

C.

10. <>

563~71;

Recent

Developments
80

in

Post

J ames

O'Connor The

Fiscal Crisis
1973)

13. (

Toward a

Ratio

Society, Legitimation

81

'-

Crisis;

fare

Contradictions

of the

Wel-

State)

] ohn Keane , Public Life and Late

Ca. ital

Press , 1987) , pp.

165~18 1. .t p.

174 ; Thomas B. Gold , State and


Socie

the

Taiwan

Miracle

CM.

E.

ism CCambridge University Press , 1984) ,

Sharpe , 1986) , p.

> '

totally

administered

124. <

<:>

society?"

14. 13

1975) , pp. 31 ~

U
FdMR

?]. Keane Contradictions

Weifare

of the

State

15. Alice H. Amsden, The State and Ta-

iwan's Economic Development" , in Peter

B. Evans et a l.
Back In
pp.

eds

Br~gi~g

the

St.te

CCambridge University , 1985) ,

78~106.

17.].

Friedmann, The

Epistemology

of

Social Practice; A critique of objective

16. Hagen Koo , The Interplay

of State ,

Social Class , and W orld System in East


Asian Development: the cases of South

knowledge" ,
pp.

Theo1

and

Secie' 6

C1978).

75~92

18. Manuel

Castells and Emilio de Ipola ,

Korea and Taiwan" , in Frederic C. Deyo

Epistemological Practice and the Social

ed. , The Political Economy of the New

Sciences" ,

Asian Industrialism

CMay 1976) , pp. 111 ~44

82

CCornell

University

Economy

83

and

Socie

5:

19.

Eugene t1 eehan What

" ( realistic-em. irica l)

Should Political

Scientists Be Doing ?", in George ]. Gra-

(bureaucratic

ham ]r., and George W. Carey eds. , The

1972) Fred R. Dallmayr , Polis and

20. <{>

1987 )

) ]ohn

178

Keane , Public Life and Late

'p.

rent

Perspectives

Social

24. ]. Habermas

Knowlge

? Cur

Theo "

and Human Interests (tr.

by ] eremy ]. Shapiro , Beacon Press ,

Vol-

ume 2 (]AI Press , 1981) , pp. 31~37 '

1971)

p.34 Fred

lmayr

pp.

R. Dal-

180~2

22. M. Weber , The Methodology of the

Soc f

Sciences (tr. and ed. by Edward A. Shils

Toward a Rational Society (Beacon Press ,

and Henry A. Finch. The Free Press ,

1970) Legitimation

1949) , p.

1975) ]ohn

56

R.

23.

Crisis (Beacon Press ,


Keane ;

Dallmayr !;

ester ed. , Critical

Theo and

Fred

]ohn For-

Public Life

(MIT Press , 1985)

25. 70 "

]ohn Keane

Ca_ lis

2 1. C. Offe, The Social Sciences: Contract


Research or Social Movement

rationality)

"

Post-Behavioral Era (New York: McKay ,

Praxis (MIT Press , 1984) , p.

85

84

-r

: Duncan MacR

Jr., The Social

30.
<:)

1975)

Function of Social Science (Yale Univer-

3 1. Hagen Koo'

sity , 1976): Frank Fischer , Politics,

32. Samuel

Val-

ues, and Public Policy: The Problem of


Methodology (Westview Press ,

1980)

ment of

p. 167

P. S. Ho , Economic Develo.

Taiwm

1860~1970

versity Press , 1978) , pp.

(Yale Uni-

116~120

26. Alice H. Amsden , Hagen Koo , Thomas

33. Mark Selden

B. Gold () ; Frederic C. Deyo ed. ,

The Political Economy of the New Asia

>

Industrialism ; <
> '

1987) ;

<:-
( '1988)

<:

( '1987) ; <

>

'

<:

(1988)
9~31

p.

29.

(1988)

<:

pp. 11 ~51; <

'1945~1973>

'

( 1984

1984.

12)

34. 1950
1953

27.
28.

pp.

'

p.

28

p. 9

86

( <:

87

:> 'p. 67)


"

33

Selden ; <
>

' <

23 2 pp. 26~40 ; <


>

' <

20 2 pp. ~65 ;
:>

1972)

"

<:>

1981 ' 1973)

35. <:>

1978) , p.

30

36. 1950

"

1957

"

( <

1989.

l' )

Alice H.

Amsden 15

()

( Amsd

pp. 90~94)
Amsden

88

(
-

()

<

89

. . ~ ~ .

pp.

161~163;

318~330

GMP

"

({.>

, pp.

280~81 ' 1987)

44.

45.

37. <"
> '

(1988) , pp.

263~337 p.

288

p. 11

pp.

176~209

<.
( '1976)

, pp. 1 ~90

46.

38. 16 p.

39. 34

: (.

40. "

((

(.

> ,

pp.

128~ 129

136~ 142

4 1. pp. 35~6:

47. S. Amin, Accumulation on a World Scale

(tr. by B.

Pearce 'I onthly

1974) voL 1 , pp.

pp.75~80

42. p 78
43. "

1987)

90

Review Press ,

18~ 19

48. A. Portes and J. Walton , Labo

Class

and the International System (Academic


91

84~7;

Press , 1981) , pp.

A. Portes, The

Informal Sector: Definition , Controversy ,

and Relation to
1 (1 983) , pp.

Development Rev

7:

151~174

49.

50.

1980

. <
>(

1988. 2) ,pp. 4~5

. <:>

1984) , pp. 23~26 :

>

<:> ' 24

8 (1987) pp. 22~25


() .

5 l.

92

"

p. 156)
52.

53. 77
50 'pp. 15~20

54
55.

77 50 'pp. 15~54 : 77 51

pp.

24~42 : 77 52

pp.

12~23

56. . <:

93

(1987)' pp.

36~7

57. <"
}

1975)
58. K.

pp. 11 ~23

Polan

p. 11
62. <>

The

Great

(Beacon Press, 1957) , p.

Transformation

76

'

7~23.

1985) pp.

p.19

63. M. Castells, The

Ci and

the Grassroots

i O'Connor

(University of Califomia Press, 1983) , pp.

301~5.

64. C.

Of The

Social Sciences: Contract

Research or Social Movements

rent

59. Ibid. , p. 178

in

Soc 1

Theo "

Cur

vo l. 2 ,

p.37

60.

Pers ective

p.

16

6 1. 1962
......

()

" <

(1962)' pp. 1 ~2

94

'

95