Professional Documents
Culture Documents
insightsonindia.com
http://www.insightsonindia.com/2013/11/29/india-and-nuclear-issues-connecting-the-dots/
Paper 3
Government Budgeting: On Nuclear sectors
Infrastructure: Energy
Science and Technology Developments: Stages of Nuclear program in India
Achievements of Indians in Nuclear energy field
Indigenization of Nuclear technology and developments there in
Sustainable development issue: Nuclear Fusion provide sustainable development: India is working with
ITER as full member
Environmental Impact Assessment related to nuclear power plants
Disaster and Disaster management: Especially in the backdrop of Fukushima Nuclear disaster but we will
also look into other disaster like Chernboyl, Three Mile Island etc for lesson.
Security issues: Threats to Nuclear Power Plants through terrorism, Cyber terrorism, Air attacks etc
Now I have connected all possible angles with respect to our syllabus
I will just put some important issues because covering all things is possible but to write them is hectic. So I am
just mentioning the most important ones. Already I have drafted how all papers are related to each other. Please
try to connect like this. Its work of few hours but it is for ever.
Paper 1: Do you think its related to paper 1, which seems so conventional.
Yeah it is, how?
Trace the world history: World War 2: Nuclear attack on Japan by USA
Two bombs, A Little Boy atomic bomb was dropped on the city of Hiroshima on August 6, 1945, followed by a Fat
Man bomb on the city of Nagasaki on August 9.
Before that the development of nuclear bomb:
MANHATTAN PROJECT:
In 1939, World War II started America and Germany was in a race to build the first atomic bomb. Already, the
theoretical framework of the Nuclear Bomb had been provided by Alfred Einstein. The United States & UK
launched a massive research and product program called the Manhattan Project. The first self sustaining nuclear
reaction was shown by Fermi, and at the same time scientists led by Robert Oppenheimer built and tested the
first nuclear bomb at Los Alamos, New Mexico, USA.
ATOMS FOR PEACE:
In the late 1950s, there was the invention of the hydrogen bomb by Edward Teller from the principle of nuclear
fusion. Some more developments such as nuclear power generation for nuclear submarine and the nuclearpower aircraft carrier took place. In 1953, US President D. Eisenhower addressed the United Nations in his
Atoms for Peace speech. In this speech, he called for international co-operation in the development of nuclear
technology for peaceful purposes. At the same time, other countries such as Soviet Union, the UK, the USA,
France and Canada already started their civil nuclear program.
Now from here on, paper 2 and 3 will be merged while discussion.
Indias nuclear program: Three stages:
Indian Stand:
The international laws were made when developed countries already had such technological advancement
and at that time the proliferation of nuclear trade was not like in contemporary times. No law is Gods law
and old laws should be inclusive as per current scenario. Such laws are required taking into consideration
the escalating trade among nations and domestic laws of developing nations should also be looked with
equity at par with developed nations and international conventions.
For larger public good and inclusive development, it is required to have liability on both, operator and
supplier.
Section 17(a) and (c) adheres to international commitments and section 17(b) is the need of current
scenario.
Civil Nuclear Authorities advocates no dilution in this section and Supreme Court also advised to make it
inclusive.
But the question is how?
What is the way ahead?
This tussle is adversely affecting Indias dire need of nuclear energy and nuclear commerce. India should
restructure its policy to include maximum scope to provide thrust to nuclear negotiations. Some of these hurdles
can be avoided by providing for contractual provisions by which the Indian operator provides timely feedback to
the supplier in relation to the functioning of a component that doesnt suffer from Patent or Latent defect.
Indigenization of technologies with ample support from funding may prove to be beneficial for India in longer run.
Then, India has huge resource of Thorium, which is to be used in Indias third generation nuclear reactor to be
completed by BARC. India needs to expedite its process of completion so as retain self sufficiency and less
scope for dependency on international market.
Moreover Indias Fast Breeder Reactors are purely indigenous. FBR uses plutonium-239 as fuel and convert it
into U-238 to be processed further. These reactors act as a connecting link in the nuclear reactor program of
India. They consume the fuel produced in the first stage and produce fuel for themselves and then are capable of
converting Th-232 into U-233 to be used as fuel for third stage.
This capability could prove an asset for Indias third generation nuclear program and would make it more self
reliant in time to come.
Another staunch area is Nuclear Fusion based Reactors:
India is already a member in ITER program of EU. From India, Institute of Plasma Research, Ahmadabad and
SAHA Institute of Nuclear Physics represent ITER. India should work actively for fusion based nuclear reactor as
it would be the energy of future.
ITER is very important for this year mains as it was in news few months back. Two things need to be
remembered.
First ITER and its principle and second, LASER based fusion. Please google it.
Some questions:
1. What are the institutional set ups of Indian nuclear program? How far you agree with restructuring of the
same?
2. Critically examine the nuclear program of India.
3. After Fukushima disaster, there were numerous uproar against the nuclear reactor set up at Kudankulam.
What are the safeguard mechanisms incorporated to make nuclear reactors free of any disaster? Discuss
in the backdrop of SC verdict.
4. The path of sustainable development focuses on nuclear fusion. Critically comment
5. Trace the development in the field of Nuclear Energy based on Fusion. What role Indian institutions play in
this?
6. Compare and contrast the nuclear tests of India.
7. Indias nuclear policy points towards time and tested diplomacy. Do you agree? Give your views
8. Indias nuclear energy development is governed by resource constraints. Comment.
9. Fast Breeder Reactors are acting as connecting links for Indias nuclear program. Elaborate
10. The tests of 74 and 98 led to different developments. Comment
INSIGHTS 2015. All Rights Reserved.