Daily Herald the Brown
vol. cxliv, no. 84 | Wednesday, October 14, 2009 | Serving the community daily since 1891
U. spent
thousands
on lobbying
By Sydney Ember
Senior Staf f Writer
The University spent nearly $160,000
on various lobbying activities, in-
cluding direct contact with govern-
ment officials to influence national,
state and local legislation, in the 12
months ending in June 2008, ac-
cording to its most recent publicly
available tax filings.
The total includes $65,755 spent
on total compensation for Brown of-
ficials who work to influence efforts
at the federal and state levels and
nearly $93,698 to organizations that
specialize in lobbying the federal
government on behalf of research
universities.
The tax filings for 2008 show a
large jump in spending on lobbying.
In the previous fiscal year, spanning
parts of 2006 and 2007, the Univer-
sity coughed up only $52,329 for
lobbying activities. But the Univer-
sity may be cutting back on the fees
doled out to lobbyists and related
organizations, said Marisa Quinn,
vice president for public affairs and
University relations.
“Every year, we review the value
for the University of belonging to
these organizations,” Quinn said,
adding that since 2008 the Univer-
sity has reduced some of its contri-
butions to lobbying organizations
and is planning to reduce more.
For example, Quinn said, the
continued on page 4
Art group exploding traditional art forms
By Talia Kagan
Staf f Writer
A solitary, sneakered flautist plays
slow and mournful tones on the
side of an informal stage. Nearby,
nine barefoot students contort their
bodies and weave through each
other.
Though their movements are
improvised, at times the students
are eerily in sync. Two floodlights
provide a warm glow in the nearly
empty black-box theater in Produc-
tion Workshop’s Upspace.
Twenty-three hours later, nine
students writhe and bend on the
same stage. But this isn’t a repeat
performance — it is the same show,
finally coming to an end.
These performances were part
of a continuous 24-hour show pro-
duced by the Brown University
Movement Experiments. Founded
last year, the experimental student
inside
News.....1-4
Sports.......5
Editorial...6
Opinion....7
Today........8
www.browndailyherald.com
E y es on the s k ies
A new exhibit, “Beyond the Moon: 400 Years of Astronomical Ob-
servation,” opened recently at the John Hay Library.
Researchers get big award to investigate OCD treatment
By Jamie Brew
Contributing Writer
Brown professors are among a team
of researchers that recently received
a $10.5 million grant from the Na-
tional Institute of Mental Health to
study a new treatment for Obsessive
Compulsive Disorder. Brown faculty
will lead two of the study’s six sub-
projects.
OCD, an anxiety disorder, affects
more than 2 percent of the world’s
population and can be debilitating.
Treatment regularly includes medi-
performance group coordinates
events involving music, visual art
and dance — sometimes all three
simultaneously. Last week, BUME
combined the three in a series of
events — a collaborative trash sculp-
ture, a “playground happening” and
a day-long show — attracting ques-
tions, wonder and, sometimes, no
notice at all.
FEATURE
BUME (its members pronounce
the name “boom”) started off the
week’s events last Tuesday by
producing a collaborative trash
sculpture on the Main Green, said
Sam Tarakajian ’10, the event’s co-
ordinator.
BUME members began by build-
ing a wooden scaffold in the morn-
ing, he said. They asked bewildered
onlookers to trade their trash for
cookies and added the collected
News, 2
Spaced out
The Hay launches an
exhibit celebrating 400
years of astronomy
195 Angell Street, Providence, Rhode Island
Max Monn / Herald
SEE STORY, PAGE 2
cation and cognitive therapy.
But deep brain stimulation may
soon be more common in treating the
disorder. The therapy, which is the
focus of the study, involves surgically
inserting an electrode in the patient’s
brain. The electrode connects to a
pacemaker-like device in the chest
that sends the brain electrical im-
pulses.
DBS therapy has proven effective
as a treatment for other conditions,
such as Parkinson’s disease.
Associate Professor of Psychiatry
and Human Behavior Ben Green-
items onto the wooden skeleton
throughout the day.
Cables, Ratty containers and a
high-voltage switch were among
the items that people traded in,
Tarakajian said, adding that he kept
the switch. Some donors simply
emptied pockets full of loose candy
wrappers and papers, and others
went to their rooms or offices to
bring back garbage, he said — a
box of micropipettes, for instance.
The initial construction and
eventual dismantling of the sculp-
ture took just under 12 hours, ac-
cording to Tarakajian.
The sculpture, he said, was com-
monly mistaken for some sort of
protest.
“I just like sculpture,” he said.
A creative connection
The next night, a more ambi-
tious creative undertaking began at
9 p.m. — and ended on Thursday,
BDS workers authorize strike
By Alexandra Ulmer
Senior Staff Writer
In a nearly unanimous vote Tuesday
night, Brown Dining Services em-
ployees authorized their bargaining
committee to call a strike if today’s
negotiations on a new contract do not
yield a satisfactory agreement.
Officials on both sides will meet
at 11 a.m. today to attempt to reach a
consensus on the contentious issues of
health care payments, retirement ben-
efits for new hires and wage changes
ahead of the looming expiration of
the workers’ contract at midnight to-
night. The contract was extended by
48 hours, and a federal mediator was
summoned to today’s bargaining ses-
sion, after negotiations failed to secure
an agreement on Monday.
More than 120 of the approxi-
mately 200 employees congregated
for a membership meeting Tuesday
and expressed disapproval of the Uni-
versity’s most recent proposal, said
berg of the Alpert Medical School
is leading a project to investigate the
efficacy of DBS as OCD treatment.
Greenberg recruited Professor of
Medical Science Barry Connors
— who is heading his own sub-proj-
ect to study the cellular effects of
DBS — to the project.
If Greenberg’s team finds that
DBS consistently helps treat the
disorder, doctors will have a strong
case for expanding its use, which
Greenberg said is currently restrict-
ed to only the most extreme cases
of OCD.
BUME members worked on a “trash sculpture” last week.
after 24 hours of performances.
The concept for the event, titled
“and” by its coordinator Alina Kung
’12, was inspired by a 24-hour piano
performance by experimental mu-
sician John Cage. Kung wanted
to plan a similar performance for
Sports, 5
Spiked!
The volleyball Bears suffer
two decisive losses over the
weekend
Roxana Rivera, the chief negotiator for
the Service Employees International
Union, Local 615, which represents
the workers.
“It was loud and clear that workers
don’t believe that what the Univer-
sity is putting forward is just,” Rivera
said.
The University is confident that the
two sides will reach a consensus today,
Vice President for Public Affairs and
University Relations Marisa Quinn
wrote in an e-mail to The Herald Tues-
day afternoon.
“If for some reason we are unable
to accomplish this,” she added, “we
can agree to a further extension, or
the University can present its final
offer to the union membership for a
vote to ratify or reject the same.”
It is too early to predict whether
another contract extension could be
in the cards, or when a potential strike
might begin, Rivera said. “We have
to see tomorrow to see how we’ll go
forth in the next couple of days.”
Greenberg’s project is one of sev-
eral in the larger study.
Suzanne Haber, a pharmacology
and physiology professor at the Uni-
versity of Rochester, is the principal
investigator of the study. There are
several sub-projects based at various
institutions, she said, including the
two at Brown.
“The components of the group
address the same question but from
different angles,” Haber said.
The study grew out of an existing
continued on page 2
Kim Perley / Herald
BUME, she said, and for practical-
ity, divided the event into hour-long
time slots.
The hour-long acts included
cooking, break-dancing, even im-
continued on page 4
Opinions, 7
Up in Smoke
Sean Quigley ’10 laments
a ban on sweet and spicy
cigarettes
herald@browndailyherald.com
Page 2 THE BROWN DAILY HERALD Wednesday, October 14, 2009

C ampus N EWS “You take out a little piece of brain, and it’s gone.”
— Professor of Neuroscience Barry Connors, on experimental lesion surgery

Essay contest honors Great Emancipator New research director

By Casey Bleho
Contributing Writer
Brown is co-sponsoring an essay
competition for local middle school-
ers to write about Abraham Lincoln
this year, part of its ongoing celebra-
tion of the 200th anniversary of the
16th president’s birth.
The Hildene-Brown Lincoln Es-
say competition — open to all eighth-
grade students in Providence — aims
to promote critical learning skills in
reading, writing and research.
Hildene, which is the house of
Robert Todd Lincoln — the presi-
dent’s oldest son — and is currently
run by the non-profit Lincoln his-
torical organization Friends of the
Hildene, also hopes to promote civ-
ics among younger students, said
Seth Bongartz, Hildene’s executive
director.
“This is our way of at least back-
filling a piece of what we wish was
there,” Bongartz said. “If you’re
learning about Lincoln, you’re learn-
ing about civics.”
Each competitor must read an
1862 letter written by abolitionist
Horace Greeley to Lincoln, press-
ing Lincoln to abolish slavery, and
the president’s response to Greeley.
Contestants will write a 500-word as-
sessment of Lincoln’s response.
“Lincoln has to toe a line that is
very difficult to walk,” said Holly
Snyder, scholarly resources librar-
ian at the John Hay Library, and
the letter “has become such a focal
point concerning Lincoln’s views
of slavery.”
“The hope is that understanding
the letters will help kids understand
the underpinnings of the political
and sociological process that Lin-
coln went through building up to
the emancipation of the slaves,”
Bongartz said.
The top three winners of the
competition will be awarded $1,000,
$750 and $500 respectively, and will
be invited to attend a luncheon in
Providence in January.
“The competition looks to rein-
force University commitment to do
outreach with Providence,” Snyder
said. Together, Hildene and Brown
will “push to digitize collections to
make them more available to the
general public,” she said.
By opening up the University’s
expansive Lincoln collection to local
students, Brown and Hildene hope
to promote research skills and initi-
ate “one step of many state-wide to
promote education about Lincoln,”
Snyder said.
Next year, Brown and Hildene
hope to open the essay competition
to all Rhode Island students, she
added.
hopes to push U.’s tech
By Thomas Jarus
Contributing Writer
The University has hired Katherine
Gordon to oversee the development
and marketing of products based on
faculty research.
Gordon, a former director of busi-
ness development at Harvard, is the
managing director of the Technol-
ogy Ventures Office, a subsection
of the Office of the Vice President
for Research that facilitates contact
between Brown faculty and industry
partners. Courtesy of John Abromowski
At Harvard, Gordon worked in a Katherine Gordon.
similar position, supervising the de-
velopment and commercialization of and works with the faculty of state
new technologies, attaining product colleges and universities, research-
licenses and establishing start-up ers and entrepreneurs who seek to
companies. Before her five years at start businesses in Rhode Island.
Harvard, Gordon was a consultant “On a micro scale, what we’re
for early-stage biomedical compa- trying to do is reinvigorate things,

Brain electrode may help treat OCD
continued from page 1
OCD research program that includ-
ed Greenberg, Haber and Associate
Professor of Psychiatry and Human
Behavior Steven Rasmussen, all of
whom focus their research on OCD.
Now, with the help of the NIMH
grant, the program has expanded
to include researchers who are only
beginning to apply their expertise to
the disorder.
One such newcomer is Connors,
who chairs the Department of Neu-
roscience. While Greenberg tests
humans to find out if DBS works,
Connors will test animals to learn
how DBS functions on brain cells.
Very little research exists on the
effects high-frequency currents —
like those involved in DBS — have
on brain cells, Connors said. His re-
search aims to determine whether
DBS merely disrupts activity in an
area of the brain or whether it actu-
ally enhances brain function.
To examine the currents’ effects
on the brain, Connors’ team will study
the areas of mouse brains that cor-
respond to OCD-related areas in the
human brain, such as the basal gan-
glia. This collection of nuclei contain
the neural pathways responsible for
balancing risk and reward ­— mak-
ing them a key area in OCD and the
target of DBS therapy.
One advantage of DBS is its re-
versability. It alters brain function
without killing cells, making it dif-
ferent from traditional, lesion-based
surgery, which always causes perma-
nent changes.
Lesion surgery is “a one-way
street,” Connors said. “You take out a
little piece of brain, and it’s gone.”
Though DBS is in its early stages
and presents a hopeful avenue for the
future of OCD treatment, Haber said
this research already has tangible
benefits.
“The science is benefitting from
the patients, and the patients are
benefitting from the science,” Haber
said. “It’s really a two-way street.”
nies and launched her own company,
Apollo BioPharmaceutics.
“Dr. Gordon brings experience
both from having started her own
company, from her experience in
the technology transfer office at
Harvard, and her own background
in the life sciences,” Vice President
for Research Clyde Briant wrote in
an e-mail to The Herald.
Bringing Gordon to Brown rep-
resents a continuation of recent
attempts by the University to in-
crease the resources available to
faculty researchers as they enter the
market.
To improve the prospects for new
products, Gordon and her office will
work with the Rhode Island Center
for Innovation and Entrepreneur-
ship, which opened this past spring
get to know the faculty, the research
directions, make sure that people
know we’re here,” Gordon said.
As the year progresses, Gordon
said she hopes to obtain patents,
strike deals and start businesses.
“We hope to see Brown commer-
cialize the appropriate intellectual
property that is created at Brown,
to license that technology and to
have that intellectual property lead
to start-up companies where appro-
priate,” Briant wrote.
Gordon described her first month
as “great.”
“I found everybody to be really
receptive,” she said. People have
been “interested in gathering infor-
mation on our new directions” and
“meeting and talking about our new
ideas,” she added.

sudoku
Astronomy exhibit now open at Hay
By Claire Peracchio
Contributing Writer
With Fall Weekend behind them,
Brown students can now turn to the
exploration of a decidedly less contro-
versial new world: outer space.
“Beyond the Moon: 400 Years of
Astronomical Observation,” a new
exhibit at the John Hay Library, offers
a panoramic view of four centuries of
astronomical inquiry at Brown and
in the wider scientific community.
The display, which includes a gallery
room and an array of glass cases in
the library’s lobby, is the result of a
joint effort by the University’s librar-
ies, the Ladd Observatory and the
preparation for the event, astronomer
Benjamin West and Joseph Brown,
a natural philosophy professor and
one of the founding Brown broth-
ers, collaborated to construct the first
University observation center on a
street that was later aptly renamed
Transit Street.
Holly Snyder, a librarian at the Hay
and one of the organizers of “Beyond
the Moon,” said the interface between
history and contemporary research
played a central role in the planning
of the exhibit.
“We were trying to figure out what
we could do to celebrate this momen-
tous year,” she said. “We decided that
the exhibit should be a conjunction
exhibit, and a film on solar eclipse
studies conducted by Charles Smiley,
the former head of the Department
of Astronomy, which merged with
the Department of Physics after his
retirement in 1970.
The exhibit features other texts
from the Lownes Science Collection,
historical records from the Ladd Ob-
servatory and a variety of astronomi-
cal instruments from the 18th century
to today.
West’s telescope and journal of
observations, which launched the
University’s endeavors in astronomy,
are also on display.
Barbara Findley, a recent visitor to
the exhibit, found out about it through

Daily Herald
Department of Physics. between what has been done histori- her membership in the Brown Com-
the Brown
Running through the month of Oc- cally and what is happening now.” munity for Learning in Retirement.
tober, “Beyond the Moon” celebrates In keeping with this vision, the “It’s a fascinating subject that I
Editorial Phone: 401.351.3372 | Business Phone: 401.351.3260 the timely intersection of a number of display juxtaposes objects and me- otherwise wouldn’t have seen,” she
Stephen DeLucia, President Jonathan Spector, Treasurer historical milestones. This year is the dia related to giants such as Galileo, said. “It’s amazing how much our
Michael Bechek, Vice President Alexander Hughes, Secretary International Year of Astronomy and Brahe and Johannes Kepler with the view of the universe has changed as
The Brown Daily Herald (USPS 067.740) is an independent newspaper serv- the 400-year anniversary of seminal scholarship of distinguished Brown scientists continuously add to previ-
ing the Brown University community daily since 1891. It is published Monday works by astronomer Galileo Galilei professors. One highlight is the ous research.”
through Friday during the academic year, excluding vacations, once during and Tycho Brahe. It is also 240 years Lownes Collection’s first-edition copy But student interest in the exhibit
Commencement, once during Orientation and once in July by The Brown Daily
Herald, Inc. Single copy free for each members of the community.
after the University began telescopi- of Galileo’s 1609 book, “The Starry has been underwhelming, said Andy
POSTMASTER please send corrections to P.O. Box 2538, Providence, RI cally exploring the universe. Messenger,” which contains the notes Moul, a member of the Hay’s reader
02906. Periodicals postage paid at Providence, R.I. Offices are located at 195 The 1769 Transit of Venus — a of the astronomer himself. services staff.
Angell St., Providence, R.I. E-mail herald@browndailyherald.com. phenomenon in which Venus pass- Also on display are digital pho- “I would call this under-utilized,”
World Wide Web: http://www.browndailyherald.com.
Subscription prices: $319 one year daily, $139 one semester daily.
es between the Sun and the Earth tographs of outer space taken by he said. “Unless someone really
Copyright 2009 by The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. All rights reserved. — marked the auspicious start of Associate Professor of Physics Ian makes an effort, they won’t come
astronomical study at Brown. In Dell’antonio, a co-organizer of the into the Hay.”
Wednesday, October 14, 2009
C ampus N EWS
higher ed
news round-up
by ellen cushing and sarah husk
senior staff writers
UCLA student charged with attempted
murder after chem lab slashing
A student at the University of California, Los Angeles
was critically injured last Thursday after a fellow student
stabbed her five times and slashed her neck in an organic
chemistry lab between classes.
Twenty-year old Damon Thompson, a senior at UCLA,
was arrested shortly after the incident and charged yes-
terday with premeditated attempted murder, according to
the Los Angeles Times.
Members of the UCLA community had reported to the
university’s administration that Thompson was exhibiting
erratic behavior in the months leading up to the incident,
but at press time, the Los Angeles Police Department had
not found an obvious motive for the slashing, and the two
students did not appear to know each other, according to
the Times.
The victim — whom officials have not publicly identi-
fied for privacy reasons — is recovering, her family told
the Times.
Colleges still reporting widespread
flu-like illness
As the annual flu season begins, colleges and universities
nationwide are continuing to see thousands of students
whose symptoms are consistent with swine flu, according
to data from the American College Health Association.
In the week ending Oct. 2, there were 6,326 new cas-
es of flu-like illness at the 273 colleges surveyed by the
ACHA, resulting in nine hospitalizations.
Only 8 percent of the schools surveyed had seen no
new cases of swine flu during the week.
The Mid-Atlantic region reported the most new cases.
Rhode Island schools surveyed reported 111 new cases,
for an “attack rate” of 37.4 new cases per ten thousand
students. (Brown is not participating in the survey.)
The ACHA, which releases new data weekly, has been
tracking the incidence of influenza-like illness at the 273
colleges and universities in the sample, which collectively
serve 3.3 million students — roughly 20 percent of the
U.S. college population.
Schwarzenegger nixes pay caps for
public university executives
Legislation to impose restrictions on executive com-
pensation in California’s public higher education sys-
tem was vetoed Sunday by California Governor Arnold
Schwarzenegger.
The proposed bill would have given the state the op-
tion to bar University of California regents and California
State University trustees from increasing the salaries of
high-level administrators within their systems and doling
out bonuses during budget crunches, Insider Higher Ed
reported Monday.
In his veto message, Schwarzenegger objected to the
bill’s sanction of broad state intervention within the UC
and CSU systems.
It is “unnecessary” for the state to “micromanage”
the regents and the trustees, Inside Higher Ed quoted
Schwarzenegger as saying, and such a “blanket prohibi-
tion” would hinder the ability of California’s public insti-
tutions to provide a high quality of education.
The governor’s veto incited vocal dissent from many of
California’s state legislators, in particular the bill’s spon-
sor, State Senator Leland Yee.
Yee criticized the governor for protecting the interests
of executive officers, particularly amid system-wide bud-
get cuts and tuition hikes, calling the veto a “slap in the
face” to students and low wage workers in both systems,
according to Inside Higher Ed.
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
“How do we talk about racism … when we’re told it doesn’t exist?”
Alum kicks off Multiracial Identity Week
By Kate Monks
Contributing Writer
Student speakers joined Ralina
Landwehr Joseph ’96, a professor
at the University of Washington,
in MacMillan Hall Tuesday night
to discusswhat it means to have a
multiracial background, marking
the opening convocation of a stu-
dent-organized Multiracial Identity
Week.
The week of events, which seeks
to explore different types of racial
identities, was organized by two stu-
dents, Christopher Belcher ’11 and
Alexis Moreis ’11. Belcher, who has
been working on the event since his
freshman year, said Brown benefits
from having a unique program to
promote discussion on the topic.
“It’s the only one of its kind in the
entire U.S. college circuit,” he said.
He added that Brown was seven
percent multiracial and growing,
and that multiracial identity is thus
“a topic that’s increasingly impor-
tant.”
In addition to Joseph, two student
speakers, Alexander Brownridge ’12
and Natasha Go ’10, discussed their
personal experiences as multiracial
individuals. Brownridge said that,
when he was three years old, he
asked his mother, “Mommy, why am
I not white like you?” Until he was
a teenager, Brownridge identified
as black, he said. But he became
confused about his true identity after
realizing he could not define himself
with just one clear-cut word.
Coming to Brown made him
even more attuned to the multira-
cial world, he said, adding, “Brown
has given me the opportunity to re-
ally immerse myself in my different
cultures and background.”
“I’ve been multiracial all my life,”
Go said. But, like Brownridge, she
— Ralina Landwehr Joseph ’96
said she had not always been so cer-
tain of her multiracial identity. When
she completed her first census, Go
said she identified only as Asian.
But now the census no longer limits
racial identity to one choice, and Go
can give a more accurate depiction
of herself, she said.
As a student, Joseph, the keynote
speaker, was a co-programmer of the
first Multiracial Heritage Week.
When she first started at Brown,
Joseph said that she, like Go, was
not sure she had “ever uttered the
word ‘multiracial’ before.”
“I could not imagine that it would
enter my daily, hourly vocabulary
during my time at Brown,” she said.
“I breathed, ate and slept mixed-race
for those four years.”
Before coming to Brown, Jo-
seph said she was always plagued
by the question, “What are you?”
The “protective cocoon” she found
at the Third World Center helped
her identify herself as multiracial,
she said.
At Brown, Joseph also became
involved in the Brown Organization
of Multiracial and Biracial Students,
which was founded in 1990 by Mi-
chael Hurt ’94 and Sachi Cunning-
ham ’94. Joseph said she was first
drawn to the group because she was
excited to be “doing something new
and different in the very old world
of race.”
In the course of her lecture, Jo-
seph focused on the various words
assigned to people of mixed races,
though she acknowledged that
many are tinged with a discrimina-
tory past. “Mulatto,” a term used
to describe people who are partly
black, derives its name from the
word “mule.” Joseph said it is often
considered “derisive, troublesome,
antiquated.” Joseph uses the terms
“mixed-race” or “multiracial.”
Page 3
Quinn Savit / Herald
Though the age of de jure dis-
crimination in the U.S. is long past,
and the countr y has elected its
first black president, Joseph urged
people not to view the world as a
post-racial society.
“How do we talk about race, how
do we talk about racism in a world
where we’re told that it doesn’t ex-
ist?” she asked.
People like Obama are held up as
paradigms of excellence, she said,
proof that society is past racial dis-
tinctions. But as much as people
may think the time of racial equality
is upon us, statistics say otherwise,
she said.
“What about high school gradua-
tion rates? What about incarceration
rates?” she asked.
Though she said she recognized
that multiracial history in America
is far from “simply celebratory,” she
said she hoped students would take
advantage of the opportunities at
Brown and that her lecture would
spark discussion about mixed-race
issues.
She closed by encouraging
the audience members to exam-
ine the many facets of their own
identities.
Page 4
C ampus N EWS
24-hour art headlines eclectic week for BUME
continued from page 1
provised jazz. Sock and Buskin, a
student theater group, even held
their board meeting in the space.
About a quarter of the perform-
ers were BUME members, while
the others were simply students
who heard about the show through
word of mouth and the Internet.
One act featured RISD students that
Kung approached on the street be-
cause they were carrying guitars,
she said.
At each hour’s end, performers
sculpted a lump of clay and recorded
one-minute reactions to represent
their on-stage experience.
The clay and the audio record-
ings were meant to provide continu-
ity and communication between the
different acts, said BUME founder
Annie Rose London ’11.
London chose to divide her time
slot equally between cooking and
sculpture, two activities that she
said “affected (her) humors dif-
ferently.” She shared her sauteed
zucchini, beans and eggs with the
only two people then in attendance,
she said.
Audience size at the performanc-
es varied. Sometimes, performers
found themselves alone in the room,
while other events, like spoken
word, drew larger audiences.
In his recorded reflection, one
performer said that he slept dur-
ing the show, but joked that no one
could know because he had been
the only one there.
When BUME member Josh Ko-
pin ’11 began his hour, no one was
in the audience until some of his
friends showed up partway through,
he said.
His performance involved im-
provising “electro-acoustic” music,
recording himself while he read
“esoteric” philosophy and ripping
and scattering construction paper,
he said.
The size of the audience affected
performances, Kopin said, but a
small, or even non-existent, audi-
ence didn’t hurt the artists’ proj-
ects. “I was alone in the room, but
I was definitely still performing,”
he said.
Kung, who spent a total of 19
non-consecutive hours at the space,
recalled that she had been the sole
audience member at Paulina Pagan
’11’s “beautiful” 5 a.m. dance per-
formance. “I felt so selfish having
her all to myself,” she said.
But Stephen Higa GS, a self-de-
scribed “BUME accomplice,” placed
little importance on the number of
people he performed for, calling the
event an example of “performance
for performance’s sake rather than
anybody else’s.”
Playground jamming
On Monday, a small group of
BUME members wrapped up their
week of events by bringing their
whimsical exuberance to India Point
Park Playground.
In contrast to the strict sched-
ule of “and,” there was no official
beginning to the event. The four
students who had been chatting
in a clump minutes earlier slowly
drifted apart.
One student began tapping out
a rhythm on a plastic trash bin. An-
other experimented with the squeak
of the swing set. A third student,
perched atop a slide, read slowly
from a small, leather-bound book.
One by one, they each casually
moved on to something new. A few
left, and others arrived. One girl, sit-
ting in a sandbox, began to paint.
The event was conceived as a
curious, individual exploration of
space and other individuals, said
Rosalie Elkinton ’11.5, the event’s
THE BROWN DAILY HERALD
“I was alone in the room, but I was definitely still performing.”
— Brown University Movement Experiments member Josh Kopin ’11
coordinator. She chose the play-
ground because its structures are
perfect for “exploring gravity” and
“the limitations of dance,” she
said.
BUME has had “jams” in the
past, including one that took place
across the street from the Sciences
Library last spring, Kopin said.
“We just played and danced for at
least two hours,” drawing a curious
crowd, he said.
Just artsy enough
Though BUME is often highly
experimental, Kopin and London
stressed that the group works to
make its type of art accessible.
“We’re open to doing really
esoteric crazy stuff, but we always
try to temper it with accessibility,”
Kopin said.
In experimental ar t, people
worry, “Am I artsy enough to un-
derstand?” London said. But BUME
is meant to provide a comfortable
community of performers, she em-
phasized.
London said she wants to see
more BUME events. “We want to be
doing stuff all the time,” she said.
For one day last week, BUME
did fill a stage non-stop.
By the 23rd hour of “and,” several
half-eaten snacks littered the room
— evidence of the performance’s
marathon nature. At 8:59 p.m., sev-
eral students gathered around a cell
phone’s clock display, waiting for
the 24-hour mark to arrive.
“This is the longest minute of
my life,” Kung said.
The seconds ticked by. When
the clock struck 9 p.m., Kung went
back to cleaning the room.
It was time to take down the
clock that had stood propped on a
music stand throughout the entire
24 hours, a quiet reminder of the
project’s ambitious scope.
Wednesday, October 14, 2009
Amid budget cuts, U.
spends less on lobbyists
continued from page 1
University does not intend to pay
$26,600 in membership dues this
year to the National Association of
College and University Business
Officers, an advocacy organiza-
tion.
The lobbying cutbacks have
come amid a larger effort to re-
duce budget shortfalls — the Uni-
versity is seeking to trim more
than $30 million this fall from next
year’s budget.
On the University’s most recent
Form 990, a publicly available tax
document that the Internal Rev-
enue Service requires nonprofit
organizations to submit, officials
reported that Brown “engages con-
sultants to promote its mission
by working with state and federal
government entities to advocate
for legislation and policy initia-
tives that support higher educa-
tion and the University’s research
agenda.”
The form also specifies that
“certain members of the Univer-
sity’s staff or management devoted
a small portion of their time on
similar activities,” explaining why
the University reports a portion of
these officials’ salaries as lobbying
expenditures.
Tim Leshan, the University’s di-
rector of government relations and
community affairs, said “almost all
research universities hire some-
one to do government relations
and to lobby on their behalf.”
“I’m hard-pressed to name a
research university that doesn’t
hire a lobbyist,” he said.
In addition to individuals on
Brown’s payroll, the University
also paid a general counsel $6,700
in consulting fees in 2008 as part of
its lobbying effort, Quinn said.
The University allocates a sig-
nificant portion of these lobbying
fees to various organizations that
do lobbying work at the federal
level who attempt to affect poli-
cies and legislation relevant to
higher education, according to
Leshan. For fiscal year 2008, these
included national organizations
such as NACUBO, the Association
of American Universities, the Na-
tional Association of Independent
Colleges and Universities and The
Science Coalition, he said, adding
that much of the recorded expen-
ditures went towards membership
dues to these organizations.
Leshan said the University
belongs to these organizations
because the organizations them-
selves employ lobbyists who can
serve the interests of universities
more efficiently than individuals
working on Capitol Hill.
“They worked across the whole
Congress,” he said of lobbyists’ ef-
forts paid for in 2008. “They’re in
the halls of Congress every day.”
Some of these organizations
— including the AAU — played
a significant role in lobbying for
stimulus funding, ensuring there
would be provisions that would
support university-based science
research, Leshan said.
Other organizations were in-
volved with tax policy, research
funding and financial aid issues,
he said, including the reauthori-
zation of the Higher Education
Act, which President George W.
Bush signed into law in August
2008. That legislation is respon-
sible for authorizing the primary
federal student aid programs to
provide assistance to many college
students.
Leshan said he is personally
involved in direct lobbying at the
federal level as the University’s
primary government liaison, add-
ing that a portion of the reported
fees include funds allocated to his
personal salary and benefits.
In addition to the payments the
University reported for fiscal year
2008, the University recently hired
a Washington-based political con-
sulting firm, Lewis-Burke Associ-
ates, to inform the University of
available research opportunities.
“Lewis-Burke was hired primar-
ily when stimulus funding became
available because we wanted to
have a better connection with
agencies that provided funding,”
Leshan said. “They are not really
lobbying as much as facilitating
our relationship with the funding
agencies.”
But he said it was important to
understand that the University was
not hiring its own individual lobby-
ists to promote Brown’s agenda.
The organizations that Brown pays
to represent it in government, he
said, should be considered a nec-
essary and valuable asset.
“They are lobbying on our be-
half,” he said. “That is the primary
reason for their existence.”
SportsWednesday
The Brown Daily Herald
Volleyball falls to Penn and Princeton
By Elisabeth Avallone
Sports Staff Writer
The women’s volleyball team, suffer-
ing from a tough start to their Ivy
League season, fell to Ivy co-leader
Penn (3-0, 11-4) on Friday night and
Princeton (1-2, 3-11) the following
afternoon. The Quakers were quick
to sweep Brown, 3-0, despite Brown’s
best efforts to hold onto the score.
Saturday afternoon the Bears were
again unable to keep up, as they fell
in four sets to the Tigers, 3-1. The
losses dropped Brown to 4-10 overall
and 0-3 in the Ivy League.
Despite Brown’s early lead in the
first set, 5-1, Penn wasted no time
after a short timeout to tie the game
at five and capture the win at 25-17.
Brown put up a fight again in the sec-
ond set but fell late in the set, 25-20.
The Quakers dominated the third
set for a decisive 25-9 victory.
Although all efforts fell shy of
leading the Bears to victory, the
game was not without notable per-
formances. As Head Coach Diane
Short pointed out, Brianna William-
son ’11 had a strong match, lead-
ing the Bears with nine kills and 10
digs. Carly Cotton ’13 held down
the defense with 16 digs. Christina
Berry ’13 also added to the Brown
cause with seven kills and six digs.
Spencer McAndrews ’12 notched a
team-high 18 assists.
“With such a large and young
team, I am really confident in our
ability to make big improvements
with ever y match,” said Kim
Bundick ’10.
The Bears were shortly back in
action against Princeton, as both
teams vied for their first Ivy League
win. The Tigers took what seemed
to be an overwhelming 24-14 lead
in the first set, but were caught
off guard as Alexandra Ilstad’s ’13
serving pushed the Bears back into
the game, down 24-22. Princeton,
however, got its much needed final
point for a 1-0 lead. The second set
seemed very evenly matched, as the
teams fought point for point until
the very end. Tied at 23, Princeton
gained the final two points for the
win.
Following two very tight sets, the
Bears finally had some luck with a
third-set victory. Brown stormed out
to a 13-9 lead, holding Princeton to a
.085 hitting percentage, their lowest
of the day. The Tigers, despite fight-
ing back for a tight finish, came up
short as Brown walked away with a
25-22 victory. The Bears were less
successful in the fourth, as Princ-
eton took a 25-23 win for their first
Ivy League victory this year.
“We played very well at times
and not great at others, but I think
that we’re definitely improving,” said
Short. “We are ranked 20th of 331
in the country in aces and digs, so
we just have to have the rest of our
game catch up.”
As praised by Short, co-captain
Danielle Vaughan ’11 played a great
match, recording a game-high seven
blocks and eight kills for a .400 hit-
ting percentage. Williamson again
held strong with 11 kills and 11
digs, as did Megan Toman ’11, who
notched an additional 11 kills and
seven digs. On defense, Berry held
down the fort with 12 digs.
“Although we may be off to a
rocky start, we are definitely tak-
ing steps in the right direction,” said
co-captain Moira Gallagher ’10, who
tallied six kills and four digs. “We’re
ironing out the problems, and I feel
like we’ll soon be able to get it right
and get some wins. It’s discourag-
ing to start off Ivies like this, but I
don’t see us giving up any time soon.
We’re fighters.”
The Bears face a long road trip
next weekend as they take on Co-
lumbia on Friday followed by a drive
to Cornell for Saturday’s match.
Get The Herald straight to your newsfeed!
facebook.com/browndailyherald
Wednesday, October 14, 2009 | Page 5
s p o rt s i n b r i e f
In roaring wind, Tigers silence w. soccer
The women’s soccer team suffered a tough 1-0 defeat
Saturday afternoon, falling to Ivy League rival Princeton on
an overtime goal.
Tigers midfielder Lauren Whatley scored the decisive goal
just two minutes into overtime play. She ran onto a pass
from teammate Sara Chehrehsa on the left side and blasted
a shot past a diving Brenna Hogue ’10. The Tiger bench
exploded in celebration, leaving the Bears to wonder what
could have been.
On a windy day at Stevenson Field, Bruno once again
struggled on the offensive side. While the Bears have gone
2-2 in their last four matches, they have only netted three
goals in those games.
Despite outshooting the Tigers 11-9 overall, the Bears
only challenged Princeton goalie Alyssa Pont with three
shots on goal. Their best chance came in the 72nd minute,
as midfielder Sylvia Stone ’11 forced Pont to make a leaping
stop on a ball headed for the top corner.
With the loss, the Bears (3-6-0 overall, 1-2-0 Ivy League)
fell to a tie for fifth in the league standings, joining Penn
and Princeton near the bottom of the conference table.
They travel to the neighboring University of Rhode Island
for an afternoon match Wednesday and will continue their
road trip with three additional away games at Harvard, Holy
Cross and Cornell in the next two weeks.
— Tony Bakshi
Editorial & Letters
The Brown Daily Herald

Page 6 | Wednesday, October 14, 2009

l e t t e r to t h e e d i to r

Criticism of Fall Weekend

stokes racial antagonism
To the Editor:
I was struck by the social and
academic irresponsibility displayed
by your published selections of Keith
Dellagrotta’s ’10 speech at Monday’s
rally against “Fall Weekend” (“Rally
against ‘Fall Weekend’ takes on U.’s
name change”).
I am aware that his intention was
to belittle rather than engage the
community he belongs to — how
else to explain his choice to describe
our faculty as “naive, arrogant (and)
haughty?” However, this accounts
neither for the extraordinary lack of
research behind his statements nor
their terrifyingly racist undertones.
In stating that Brown faculty “sid(ed)
with American Indians, less than 1
percent of Brown’s student body,”
Dellagrotta casts this decision as one
made against 99 percent of Brown,
and in doing so pits community
members against one another in an
unapologetically racialized way.
The fact that such a distasteful
position is built upon a clearly un-
researched understanding of pre-
American history only adds to the
embarrassing quality of Dellagrotta’s
words. I hope that the conservative
community at Brown can forgive Del-
lagrotta for further caricaturing their
campus presence through his unseri-
ous and antagonistically trite analysis
of our history and community.
Geoffrey Mino ’12
Oct. 13
A le x yuly

Don’t just read. e d i to r i a l

Book smarts
Get angry! Cooler weather and midterms signal that charity. They should also consider returning
the fall semester is now well under way. As stu- that money directly to their students. The Uni-
dents’ memories of a hectic shopping period versity’s 2009-10 cost of attendance projections
and expensive textbook purchases start to fade, expect each student to spend $633 per semester
letters@browndailyherald.com we would like to remind faculty members of an on books — that’s $1,266 for the school year, a
important matter of principle: No Brown profes- significant financial burden.
sor should profit from the book royalties they The high cost of college textbooks is a prob-
earn by assigning their own book to a class of lem that has received attention on the national
Brown students. level. In 2005, the Government Accountabil-
The possibility that professors might be ity Office reported that the price of textbooks
t h e b r o w n d a i ly h e r a l d
able to profit based on the books they assign tripled between 1986 and 2004. And in 2008
Editor-in-Chief Managing Editors Deputy Managing Editors Senior Editors
makes for a textbook (sorr y) case of a conflict congress passed legislation that requires text-
Steve DeLucia Michael Bechek Nandini Jayakrishna Rachel Arndt
Chaz Firestone Franklin Kanin Isabel Gottlieb of interest. Most book contracts stipulate that book publishers to disclose more information
Michael Skocpol Scott Lowenstein the author receive a percentage of the profits about pricing and to sell supplemental materials
editorial Business from sales. Even if a professor genuinely judges like CDs separately from textbooks. But these
Ben Hyman Arts & Culture Editor General Managers Office Manager
Rosalind Schonwald Arts & Culture Editor Alexander Hughes Shawn Reilly his or her own book to be the best in the field new requirements do not take effect until next
Sophia Li Features Editor Jonathan Spector or the most relevant to the topic of the class, year.
George Miller Metro Editor
Joanna Wohlmuth Metro Editor
students could reasonably question the ob- While the sort of rebate we’re calling for is
Directors
Seth Motel News Editor Ellen DaSilva Sales jectivity of that judgment. For larger classes by no means a panacea, it would help reduce
Jenna Stark News Editor Claire Kiely Sales and more expensive books, the opportunity some students’ book costs. And if a book truly
Andrew Braca Sports Editor Katie Koh Finance
Han Cui Asst. Sports Editor Jilyn Chao Asst. Finance for a windfall profit increases, fueling students’ is an essential text in its field, then sales at other
Alex Mazerov Asst. Sports Editor Christiana Stephenson Alumni Relations skepticism about the real reasons behind the schools should be sufficient to earn the author
Katie Wood Asst. Sports Editor
course’s reading list. significant returns. A fraction of book royalties
Graphics & Photos Managers Some professors have sought to alleviate seems like a small price to pay for the Univer-
Chris Jesu Lee Graphics Editor Kelly Wess Local Sales
Stephen Lichenstein Graphics Editor Kathy Bui National Sales
this concern by promising students they will sity’s improved transparency and integrity.
Eunice Hong Photo Editor Alex Carrere University Sales donate royalties earned from their classes to Students already pay tens of thousands of
Kim Perley Photo Editor Matt Burrows Credit and Collections charity. Professor James Morone has histori- dollars for access to Brown’s faculty and course
Jesse Morgan Sports Photo Editor
cally given away the royalties he earns from offerings. The mere idea that a professor might
production Opinions
Ayelet Brinn Copy Desk Chief Alyssa Ratledge Opinions Editor students purchasing his book for “POLS0220: assign a book to make a little extra money on the
Rachel Isaacs Copy Desk Chief Sarah Rosenthal Opinions Editor City Politics.” Since “City Politics” usually en- side strikes us as crass. We call on all professors
Marlee Bruning Design Editor
Jessica Calihan Design Editor Editorial Page Board
rolls several hundred students whenever it has who assign their own books to avoid the appear-
Anna Migliaccio Asst. Design Editor James Shapiro Editorial Page Editor been taught, we applaud Morone for valuing the ance of impropriety and do what’s right.
Julien Ouellet Asst. Design Editor Matt Aks Board member
integrity of the course over what would probably
Neal Poole Web Editor Nick Bakshi Board member
Post- magazine Zack Beauchamp Board member be a tidy profit. Editorials are written by The Herald’s
Arthur Matuszewski Debbie Lehmann Board member Of course, professors shouldn’t have to do- editorial page board. Send comments to
Editor-in-Chief
Kelly McKowen William Martin Board member
Editor-in-Chief nate the proceeds from self-assigned books to editorials@browndailyherald.com.
Zahra Merchand, Anna Migliaccio, Julien Ouellet, Leor Shtull-Leber, Designers
Madeleine Rosenberg, Ariel Pick, Lindor Qunaj, Copy Editors
Sydney Ember, Anne Simons, Night Editors
Senior Staff Writers Dan Alexander, Mitra Anoushiravani, Ellen Cushing, Sydney Ember,
Lauren Fedor, Nicole Friedman, Brigitta Greene, Sarah Husk, Brian Mastroianni, Hannah
Moser, Ben Schreckinger, Anne Simons, Anne Speyer, Sara Sunshine, Alex Ulmer, Suzannah
C O R R E C T I O N S P olicy
Weiss, Kyla Wilkes
The Brown Daily Herald is committed to providing the Brown University community with the most accurate information possible. Correc-
Staff Writers Shara Azad, Emma Berry, Alicia Chen, Zunaira Choudhary, Alicia Dang,
Juliana Friend, Anish Gonchigar, Sarah Julian, Christian Martell, Heeyoung Min, Jyotsna tions may be submitted up to seven calendar days after publication.
Mullur, Lauren Pischel, Kevin Pratt, Leslie Primack, Luisa Robledo, Dana Teppert, Gaurie C ommentary P O L I C Y
Tilak, Caitlin Trujillo, Monique Vernon, The editorial is the majority opinion of the editorial page board of The Brown Daily Herald. The editorial viewpoint does not necessarily
Senior Business Associates Max Barrows, Jackie Goldman, Margaret Watson, Ben Xiong reflect the views of The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. Columns, letters and comics reflect the opinions of their authors only.
Business Associates Stassia Chyzhykova, Marco deLeon, Katherine Galvin, Bonnie Kim, L etters to the E ditor P olicy
Cathy Li, Allen McGonagill, Liana Nisimova, Thanases Plestis, Corey Schwartz, William Send letters to letters@browndailyherald.com. Include a telephone number with all letters. The Herald reserves the right to edit all letters for
Schweitzer, Kenneth So, Evan Sumortin, Haydar Taygun, Webber Xu, Lyndse Yess
length and clarity and cannot assure the publication of any letter. Please limit letters to 250 words. Under special circumstances writers may
Design Staff Gili Kliger, Jessica Kirschner, Leor Shtull-Leber, John Walsh, Kate Wilson
Photo Staff Qidong Chen, Janine Cheng, Alex DePaoli, Frederic Lu, Quinn Savit request anonymity, but no letter will be printed if the author’s identity is unknown to the editors. Announcements of events will not be printed.
Copy Editors Sara Chimene-Weiss, Miranda Forman, Casey Gaham, Anna Jouravleva, advertising P olicy
Geoffrey Kyi, Frederic Lu, Jordan Mainzer, Madeleine Rosenberg The Brown Daily Herald, Inc. reserves the right to accept or decline any advertisement at its discretion.
Opinions
The Brown Daily Herald
A bad year for the Millennial Generation
DAN DAVIDSON
Opinions Columnist
Upon winning the Nobel Peace Prize, Presi-
dent Obama declared, “We cannot accept
the growing threat posed by climate change,
which could forever damage the world that
we pass on to our children.”
The president understands the importance
of his leadership in addressing problems that,
if left unsolved, will harm our generation. Yet
the first months of his term paint a troubling
image for the future of young people — the
“children” that politicians often implore Ameri-
cans to think about.
Even if you have followed the health care
debate closely, you probably have not heard
a lot about what the ramifications of reform
would be for young people. This is surpris-
ing, considering that as of 2007, 29 percent
of people 19 to 29 years old were uninsured.
One would think that in a debate over health
insurance, we would get more attention.
In the past few months, however, Repub-
licans successfully framed the discourse on
health care around issues that affect seniors.
By warning about “death panels” and railing
against proposed Medicare reforms, the GOP
has fomented opposition to health care partly
by appealing to senior citizens.
Consider Michael Steele, chairman of the
Republican National Committee. Late this
summer he took to the airwaves and op-ed
SEAN QUIGLEY
Opinions Columnist
Indonesian spices and tobacco make for an
excellent smoking experience. Indeed, even
those who look askance at regular cigarettes
typically enjoy the unique aroma created by
the product that incorporates those two ele-
ments: the clove cigarette. Crunchy types es-
pecially are known to travel about with a cloud
of South-Pacific spice over their heads.
However, as of Sept. 22, at least in the U.S.,
cloves have been banned at the behest of
busybody progressives and legislators who,
without a source of honest work, perpetually
seek to manufacture problems — which they
then omnisciently solve by coercive fiat.
The most avaricious of those busybodies,
our venerable president, leapt at the opportu-
nity to dismantle more of his people’s liberties
when he signed the legislation that serves as
the legal foundation for this ban, the Family
Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act.
And in so doing this past June, he caused a
dramatic shift in U.S. policy by empowering
the secular priests — excuse me, federal FDA
regulators — to seek the very ban which came
into effect on Sept. 22.
In their press release, the swine at the FDA
wrote, “The U.S. Food and Drug Administra-
tion announced today a ban on cigarettes with
flavors characterizing fruit, candy, or clove.
The ban, authorized by the new Family Smok-
ing Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, is
part of a national effort by the FDA to reduce
smoking in America.”
In a stinging bit of irony, menthol cigarettes
pages promoting a “Seniors’ Health Care Bill
of Rights” and vowing to fight any proposed
cuts in Medicare. This is the same person who,
when asked if he would consider cutting Social
Security or Medicare during a run for Senate
in 2006, told Tim Russert that “everything has
to be on the table.”
Abandoning principle matters little, how-
ever, since political ends are what Republicans
seek. The GOP strategy is aimed at winning
back seats in Congress in the 2010 midterms,
and Republicans know that seniors matter
We lack the electoral clout to refocus the debate
in Washington on issues that affect our future.
far more than we do in determining election
results.
According to the Census Bureau, 48.5 per-
cent of Americans 18 to 24 years old voted in
last year’s presidential election. Americans
65 and older turned out at a rate of over 70
percent.
The disparity in turnout between young and
old is even more pronounced during midterm
elections. In 2002 and 2006, roughly 63 percent
of citizens 65 or older voted. Under 50 percent
of 18 to 24 year olds were even registered to
vote in those elections, and in 2006 a meager
22.1 percent actually cast a ballot.
These statistics, and the fact that the 65 and
R.I.P. Cloves
remain untouched (for the time being). Word
has it that the Congressional Black Caucus
was largely responsible for this inconsistent
exemption.
Besides allowing for the banning of a whole
class of cigarettes, the legislation dramatically
shifted the FDA’s regulatory purview by allow-
ing it to police tobacco for the first time. Since
FDA stands for Food and Drug Administration,
it is curious why this obese bureaucratic blob
would now regulate a plant that has nothing to
do with the agency’s original mission.
Clove cigarettes are only the most recent victim
of an autocratic tendency in modern, “social-
contract” governments to compel others to cease
behaviors that some find annoying.
Maybe the progressives can explain that
anomaly to me. Conservatives, with their
longstanding claim that bureaucracies only
seek to expand in order to feel legitimate and
important, must be wrong. Right?
But until that time, I shall simply note that
cloves are only the most recent victim of an au-
tocratic tendency in modern, “social-contract”
governments to compel others to cease behav-
iors that some find annoying. Common is the
claim that a schoolmarm concern for smokers’
health is the real reason behind the ban; but
those who recognize Puritanism across the
ages are not convinced.
In the past — and presently, for the rem-
Wednesday, October 14, 2009 | Page 7
over age group has almost ten million more
people than the 18 to 24 year old bracket,
make figuring out who to appeal to in 2010
a simple task. We lack the electoral clout to
refocus the debate in Washington on issues
that affect our future.
Many Democrats — including Obama —
are complicit in allowing the concerns of older
Americans to dominate current debate at our
expense. They are trying to prevent short-
term electoral losses, even if the price could
be high down the road.
Last week, Obama reiterated his campaign
pledge to end the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t
Tell” policy. He provided no timetable for this
goal, however, allowing Congress to defer ac-
tion. I doubt legislators gearing up for battles
next year are eager to wade into this contro-
versial issue.
Never mind that the president might send
more troops to Afghanistan, and the military
could probably use some of the 13,000 per-
sonnel discharged under “Don’t Ask, Don’t
Tell” since its implementation. (LGBT issues
generate less support with older Americans
than with young adults, and seniors are more
likely to vote next year. The safe bet is to wait
nant faithful — churches and ministers,
families and spouses, friends and neighbors
would address these matters if they actually
were worrisome. Now we have a government
agency, with a team of Jacobin-esque experts
and horny bureaucrats, all subsisting on the
public dollar, to replace the traditional institu-
tions of marriage, family and church.
But I suppose that is what Marxists, and
their progressive cousins, want.
Yes, I am making the claim that the decline
in the traditional European family is causally
linked to the federal ban on clove cigarettes.
Now, I cannot explain why some people sim-
ply hate liberty, and thus think they have the
authority to coerce people to stop smoking
clove cigarettes.
Yet I am very confident that, were “archaic”
religious rearing and conservative familial
attitudes more prevalent, those who hate
liberty would have less success in foisting
their pet peeves into public law. They would
instead raise their families according to such
preferences.
Which brings me to two fundamental
points: those who love liberty should love
the traditional family; and those who do not
on ending “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell.”
Meanwhile, Senate Majority Leader Harry
Reid seems unconcerned about putting off
climate change legislation until next year. A
climate change bill barely passed in the House
of Representatives this summer; it’s hard to
believe the Senate will get anything done on
this divisive issue during an election year.
Even Obama, not up for reelection until
2012, appears unwilling to put himself on the
line for what he knows is a critical cause. Many
diplomats are concerned that if the United
States fails to act domestically, this year’s U.N.
Conference on Climate Change will not pro-
duce a meaningful international agreement
essential to stemming global warming.
It will be our generation that suffers for
failing to act on climate change, not leaders in
Washington or older Americans. It is sad that
our elected officials are unwilling to take politi-
cal risks when confronted with an issue that
requires powerful leadership to be solved.
Politicians are in the business of getting
reelected, however, something that young
people must recognize before assigning them
all the blame. As long as we continue to exert
little political power, voting in low numbers
and lacking organization, politicians will gladly
avoid the tough choices critical for our future
in favor of the easy ones that assure them
reelection.
Dan Davidson ’11 is a political science
and music concentrator from
Atlanta, Georgia. He can be reached at
daniel_davidson@brown.edu
admire the conspirators that thieve after the
liberty to smoke should not admire the cur-
rent president. I would wager that this column
alone will not convince cultural levelers to
concede my first point, but they should at
least concede the second.
Our president is the enemy of liberty, quite
honestly, in most things. Yet he is especially
the enemy of tobacco connoisseurs, and even
those whose drags fall well below the thresh-
old needed to be called a dreaded “smoker.” I
suppose that, as with the philosopher in Plato’s
Allegory of the Cave, that enlightened former
smoker has returned to bring illumination, in
the form of prohibition.
Whatever. Most fellow undergraduates
were cheering when he made the donkey
move of going all-in with outdated Keynesian
theory this past February, so I really cannot
expect that they will be moved by an appeal to
their aromatic pleasures. As long as he means
well, what could really go wrong?
Two last ironies, if I may. The ban has
caused a slight rift in relations with Indonesia,
the major producer of clove cigarettes. It looks
like the president is not always the solver of
all international disputes.
Also, lest we forget, American Indians gave
us the horrible leaf. In an age when Colum-
bus Day is deemed unacceptable as a holiday
because of the explorer’s actions in the New
World, one would think that the preservation
of Indian culture would be a priority.
Oh, well. Federal experts know best.
Sean Quigley ’10 smoked his first
tobacco with his high school chaplain.
He can be reached at
sean.b.quigley@gmail.com.
 Today 3
to day to m o r r o w
Chem lab stabbing at UCLA
The Brown Daily Herald

No lions, but Tigers shut out Bears

5 51/ 33
Wednesday, October 14, 2009
51/ 35
Page 8

t h e n e w s i n i m ag e s

1 2 1
c a l e n da r comics
Today, October 14 tomorrow, october 15 Cabernet Voltaire | Abe Pressman

11 am — Seasonal Flu Clinics, Jo’s 2:30 PM — A Reading by Novelist

6:30 pm — “The Environmental Crisis
in Haiti: A Growing Threat,” Joukowsky
Forum
Daniel Alarcón, McCormack Family
Theater
4 pm — “The Constitution(s) of In-
digenous Identity in Latin America,”
Wilson 102

menu
Sharpe Refectory Verney-Woolley Dining Hall

Lunch — Buffalo Chicken Wings with Lunch — Chicken Fajitas, Vegan Black Dot Comic | Eshan Mitra and Brendan Hainline
Bleu Cheese Dressing, Falafel in Pita, Bean Tacos, Mexican Succotash
Vegetarian Reuben Sandwich
Dinner — Cilantro Chicken, Mexican
Dinner — Garden Style Baked Scrod, Cornbread Casserole, Herb Rice
Couscous Croquettes with Cider Pepper
Sauce, Vegan Rice Pilaf
RELEASE DATE– Wednesday, October 14, 2009

Los Angeles Times

c r o sDaily
s w oCrossword
rd Puzzle
Edited by Rich Norris and Joyce Nichols Lewis
ACROSS 65 Clownish 34 Above, in poems 47 Like eggs in an
1 Made a 66 Shore birds 36 Slow-moving, as Easter hunt
disapproving a river 48 Skinflints
sound DOWN
6 Witticism 1 Samples a bit of
37 Penetrable 50 Big name in Hippomaniac | Mat Becker
quality of skin perfumery
10 Highlander 2 Ball 38 Makes a cliché 51 Dramatist
14 Cop __: bargain 3 Loud auto honker
of, say Chekhov
in court of yore
39 Exposed 52 Tearful
15 Healing plant 4 “__ mouse!”
16 Oregon Treaty 5 Weekly septet 40 Typist’s stat. 55 Letter after theta
president 6 Argonauts’ leader 44 Crystalline 56 Drift, as an aroma
17 Trembling 7 Large antelope mineral 57 Shipwreck site
18 Having all one’s 8 Tune 46 More petite 58 Air mover
marbles 9 Dainty laugh ANSWER TO PREVIOUS PUZZLE:
19 Word processing 10 Sudden gushing
reversal 11 Conspires (with)
20 Big Southwestern 12 Octogenarians,
trombones? e.g.
23 Ending for “ranch” 13 Boxing ref’s
24 Neither Rep. nor decision
Dem. 21 Whopper
25 Thing creators
27 Madame, in 22 Lord’s Prayer
Madrid words following STW | Jingtao Huang
30 Wide shoe size “Thy will be
31 Geese flight done”
pattern 26 Thus far
32 Actress Greer 28 Eye unsubtly
who received five 29 Drizzly day
consecutive chapeau
Oscar 30 Some pass
nominations catchers
35 At the ready 33 Women xwordeditor@aol.com 10/14/09
37 Refined
trombones?
40 Made on a loom
41 Imitation
42 Med or law
lead-in
43 Command ctrs.
45 Musical beat
49 Wells’s “The
Island of Dr. __”
51 Fill with wonder Classic Deep-Fried Kittens | Cara FitzGibbon
53 Jr.’s son
54 Continuously-
playing
trombones?
58 Clenched
weapon
59 Mechanical
memorization
60 Remark to the
audience
61 To __: perfectly
62 Sporty sunroof
63 Baseball card
brand
64 Wall St.’s “Big
Board” By Charles Barasch
(c)2009 Tribune Media Services, Inc.
10/14/09