Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THEORIES ON PROPERTY!
A. In General!
4!
B. First Possession!
4!
C. Labor!
4!
D. Utilitarian!
4!
E. Democracy!
4!
F. Personhood!
4!
4!
B. Legal Positivism!
4!
4!
4!
E. Bundle of Rights!
4!
4!
4!
2. Rights as Property!
4!
a) Real Rights!
4!
b) Personal Rights!
4!
c) Distinctions!
4!
4!
a) Common/Res Nullious!
4!
b) Public Dominion!
4!
c) Private Property!
4!
4.
5.
4!
a)
4!
b)
4!
4!
B. Ownership!
1. In General !
5!
5!
a) Definition!
5!
b) Incidents of Ownership!
5!
c) Limitation!
Page 1 of 15
5!
5!
5!
a) Rule on Accession !
6!
6!
3. Right to Use!
6!
6!
6!
4. Right to Transfer!
6!
6!
b) Kinds of Transfers!
6!
5. Right to Exclude!
6!
a) The owner or lawful possessor of a thing has the right to exclude any
person from the enjoyment and disposal of the thing. (Art. 429)! 6!
b)
c) Self-Help!
C. Co-Ownership!
6!
6!
6!
6!
3. On Right to Use!
6!
4. On Right to Exclude!
6!
5. On Right to Transfer!
7!
6. On Right to Vindicate!
7!
7. On Right to Partition!
7!
8. Obligations of Co-Owners!
7!
9. Renunciation of Shares!
7!
7!
D. Possession!
1.
In General!
7!
7!
2. Acquisition of Possession!
8!
3. Loss of Possession!
8!
4. Effects of Possession!
8!
9!
9!
9!
2. Trespass!
9!
a) Cause of Action !
Page 2 of 15
9!
b) In Real Property!
10!
c) In Personal Property!
11!
11!
11!
b) Nature!
11!
11!
11!
12!
12!
12!
12!
12!
12!
12!
1. Taxation!
12!
2. Eminent Domain!
12!
12!
12!
5. Environmental Regulations!
13!
13!
13!
1. Occupation!
13!
2. Accession!
14!
3. Intellectual Creation!
15!
15!
15!
1. Donation!
15!
2. Succession!
15!
3. Sales!
15!
4. Exchange !
15
Page 3 of 15
I.
THEORIES ON PROPERTY!
A.
B.
C.
D.
E.
F.
In General!
First Possession!
Labor!
Utilitarian!
Democracy!
Personhood!
Natural Law!
Legal Positivism!
Property as the Law of Things!
Right to Exclude as the Source of Property!
Bundle of Rights!
4.
5.
Page 4 of 15
B. Ownership!
1. In General !
a) Definition!
(1) In its strict sense!
(a) Property signifies that dominion or indefinite right of user, control and
disposition which one may lawfully exercise over particular things or objects
(63 Am Jur 2d). !
(b) Property is composed of certain constituent elements, namely, the
unrestricted right of use, enjoyment and disposal of the particular subject of
property. !
(2) Meaning of Title !
(a) Refers to that which is the subject of ownership, and is that which is the
foundation of ownership. !
(b) It is the evidence of a persons right or of the extent of his interest; the
means whereby the owner is enable to maintain or assert his possession
and enjoyment. !
(c) Colour of title is that which gives a semblance or appearance of title, but is
not the title in fact. It is anything which shows the extent of the occupants
claim!
b) Incidents of Ownership!
(1) Possession and Control !
(a) Ownership of property implies the right of possession and control; !
(2) Right to its Product or Increase !
(a) It carries with it the right to its product !
(b) It carries with it the right to its increase!
(3) Right to Transfer !
(a) It includes the right of alienation or disposition in any lawful manner which
the owner deems fit !
(b) Must comply with the mode appropriate appropriate to the kind of property in
order to be effectual. !
(4) Right to Vindicate!
(a) Includes the right to protect and defend such possession against the
intrusion or trespass of others which may include self-help; and!
(b) Right to judicial relief!
c) Limitation!
(1) An owner may put his property to any use not unlawful, however absolute and
unqualified may be his title, an owner holds the property under the implied
liablitiy that his use of it shall not be injurious to the equal enjoyment of others
having an equal right to the enjoyment of their property of others nor injurious to
the rights of the community. a claim of restrictions and limitation in the use of
such property must be clearly and indubitable established!
(2) Governmental control and regulate properties to secure the general safety, the
public welfare and the peace, good order and morals of the community. This
does not confer power to control rights which are purely and exclusively private,
but it does authorize the establishment of laws requiring each citizen so to
conduct himself and use his own property as not uncecessarily to injure another.
The state may provide regulations as to the acquisition, enjoyment and
disposition of property and may even take private property for a public purpose,
subject to the right of the individual to just compensation. !
(3) Property is subject to certain burdens which it must bear in common with other
property of a like kind.!
d) Under the Civil Code Art. 427!
(1) Over Things!
(2) Over Rights!
2. Presumptions!
Page 5 of 15
a) Rule on Accession !
(1) All works, sowing and planting are presumed made by the owners at this
expense (Art. 446)!
b) The law favours actual possessors !
(1) Ownership is presumed in favour of actual possessors. (Art. 433)!
3. Right to Use!
a) Art. 428 of the Civil Code!
(1) The owner has the right to enjoy subject to limitations established by law
(Separate Discussion on Limitations of Property Ownership)!
(2) Injurious Use - Art. 430. The owner of the thing cannot make use it in such a
manner as to injure the rights of a third person!
b) 1987 Constitution, Article XII, National Economy and Patrimony!
(1) Use of Property!
(a) The use of property bears a social function, and all economic agents shall
contribute to the common good. Individuals and private groups, including
corporations, cooperatives and similar collected organisations, shall have
the right to own, establish and operate economic enterprises, !
(b) The us of property is subject to the duty of the state to promote distributive
justice and it intervene when the common good so demands. !
4. Right to Transfer!
a) Art. 428 of the Civil Code!
(1) The owner has the right to dispose property subject to limitations established by
law!
b) Kinds of Transfers!
(1) Assignment of ownership!
(2) Assignment of use only !
5. Right to Exclude!
a) The owner or lawful possessor of a thing has the right to exclude any person
from the enjoyment and disposal of the thing. (Art. 429)!
(1) Enclosure and Fences (Art. 430) but subject to servitudes!
(2) Self Help (Art. 429) !
b) Resort to judicial process if possession is loss (Art. 433)!
c) Self-Help!
Enclosures and Fences Art. 430!
Exceptions in the Civil Code - Lawful Interference in cases of acts of necessities
Art. 432 / damages!
Servitudes!
C. Co-Ownership!
1. Definition: The ownership of an undivided thing or rights belongs to different
person (Art. 484)!
2. General Rule!
a) Presumption is equal shares (Art. 485)!
b) Full ownership of his share (Art. 493)!
c) On Share - the share of the co-owners in the benefits as well as in the charges are
proportional to their interest and any stipulation altering this proportion is void . (Art.
485) !
3. On Right to Use!
a) Any co-owner ay use the thing in accordance with its purpose (Art. 486)!
b) Cannot use it in such a way as to injure the interest of the co-owners or prevents
them from using it according to their rights!
c) Co-owner may not alter the thing in common even though it will benefit all coowners; judicial relief if the withholding of consent is prejudicial (Art. 491) or if the
resolution of the majority is prejudicial (Art. 492) !
4. On Right to Exclude!
Page 6 of 15
D. Possession!
1.
In General!
a) Definition !
(1) Possession is the holding of a thing or the enjoyment of a right (Art. 523). !
(2) Only things and rights which are susceptible of being appropriated may be the
object of possession (Art. 430)!
b) How is Possession Exercise!
(1) Possession can be exercise in ones own name or in that of another (Art. 524)!
(a) Possession of a thing as an owner!
Page 7 of 15
Page 8 of 15
2. Trespass!
a) Cause of Action !
(1) The owner has the right of action against the holder and possessor of the thing
in order to recover it. (Art. 428, Par. 2)!
(2) Presumption of ownership is given to actual possessor (Art. 433)!
Page 9 of 15
(3) In an action to recover, plaintiff must rely on the strength of his title and not on
the weakness of the defendants claim (Art. 434)!
b) In Real Property!
(1) Self Help!
(2) Criminal Actions !
(a) Usurpation of Real Rights under Article 312 of the RPC!
i) By means of violence against or intimidation of persons takes
possession of any real property !
ii) Usurp any real rights in property belonging to another!
(b) Other Form of Swindling under Article 316 of the RPC!
i) Any person who pretending to be the owner of any real property shall
convey, sell, encumber of mortgage the same!
ii) Any Person who knowing that the property is encumbered shall dispose
the same although such encumbrance is not recorded!
iii) Any person who sell, mortgage or encumber real property use as surety
in a bond !
(3) Recovery of Possession!
(a) Forceable Entry and Unlawful Detainer!
i) An action instituted by a person deprived of the possession of any land
or building by force, intimidation, threat, strategy, or stealth (Forceable
Entry) or a landlord, vendor, vendee or other person against whom the
possession of any land or building is unlawfully withheld after the
expiration of any contract, express or implied (Unlawful Detainer).!
ii) Action is instituted with the Municipal/City Trial Court!
iii) Action must be instituted within one year !
(1) from time of unlawful deprivation !
(2) demand to vacate !
iv) Relief is restitution of possession with damages and costs!
v) Procedure is covered by Rule 70 of the Rules of Court on Forceable
Entry and Unlawful Detainer!
(1) Summary Procedure!
(2) Immediate Execution on Judgement !
(3) A possessor deprived of his possession may within ten days from
filing of the complaint present a motion to secure from the court a writ
of preliminary injection to restore him in his possession. Court must
decide the motion whiting thirty (30) days. (Art. 539) !
(b) Accin Publiciana!
i) If cause of dispossession is not FEUD or upon expiraation of one year to
commence an action for FEUD !
ii) If the action is due to tolerance!
(c) In Lease - the lessor is not obliged to answer for a mere act of trespass
which a person may cause on the use of the thing leased; but the lessee
shall have a direct action against the intruder (Art. 1664); act of trespass
when the third person claims no right whatever!
(d) Mere acts of trespass does not suspend payment in sale (Art. 1590)!
(4) Recovery of Ownership and Possession!
(a) Accion Reivindicatoria !
i) The action is for recovery of ownership and not just possession!
ii) The defendant claims ownership over the land such as when there is
adverse possession!
(5) Writ of Possession!
(a) Issued at the instance of the applicant in the following instances!
i) Land Registration Proceedings!
ii) Extra-judicial Foreclosure of Mortgage as against the mortgagor!
iii) Judicial Foreclosure as against the mortgagor!
iv) Execution Sale!
Page 10 of 15
c) In Personal Property!
(1) Self Help!
(2) Replevin!
(a) Rule 60 of the Rules of Court!
i) Recovery of possess of personal property!
3. Nuisance and Interference to Property Rights!
a) Definition - (Art. 694) An act, omission, establishment, business, condition of
property or anything which injures, annoys, offends, shocks, defies decency,
morality, obstructs or interferes with free passage or hinders or impairs the use of
property !
b) Public and Private Nuisance (Art. 695)!
(1) Public Nuisance or Common Nuisance affects a community or neighbourhood or
any considerable number of persons although the extent of annoyance or range
or damage is unequal!
(2) Private nuisance affects only specific individuals and not the whole community;
violates only private rights!
c) Nature!
(1) Per Se - nuisance at all times and under any circumstances, regardless of
location or surroundings!
(2) Per Incidens - nuisance by reason of the circumstance and surroundings !
d) Easement against nuisance !
(1) Every building or piece of land is subject to easement which prohibits the
proprietor or possessor from committing nuisance through noise, jarring,
offensive odor, smoke, heat, dust, water glare and other causes (Art. 682)!
(2) Police Power - Subject to zoning, health, police and other laws and emulations,
factories and shops may be maintained provided the least possible annoyance
is cause to the neighbourhood (Art. 683)!
e) Condemnation of Property by reason of health, safety or security (Art. 436)!
(1) The owner of a property is not entitled to compensation when it is condemned
by the State by reason of health, safety or security !
(2) Unless such action is unjustified!
f) Remedies!
(1) Prosecution under the Penal Code!
(a) Limited to public nuisance!
(2) Civil Action!
(a) If public nuisance - action shall be commence by the city (Art. 701)!
(b) Exception - it may be filed by a private person if it is specially injurious to him !
(3) Abatement without judicial proceedings!
(a) Public Nuisance by Officers of the Law(Art. 700-703)!
i) Exercise of police power by the State - the State may authorise its
officers to abate public nuisance without resort to legal proceedings and
without notice or hearing;!
ii) Limitation - it must be reasonable and effectively exercise; not unduly
oppressive to individuals; the injury must be done to the property is
necessary to accomplish the abatement (Art. 707 provides that person
performing extra-judicial abatement may be liable for damages if he
causes unnecessary injury or the the alleged nuisance is declared by the
court as not a real nuisance.!
iii) Owner of the property not entitled to compensation!
(b) Public Nuisance by Private Persons (Art. 704)!
i) Private persons may abate a public nuisance that are injurious to him by
removing or if necessary destroying the thing; in extreme necessity;
timeliness!
ii) Must not breech the peace!
iii) Demand must be made to abate and owner refused!
Page 11 of 15
iv) Must be made with the approval of the district health officer and with
assistance of the local police!
v) The value of the property must not exceed three thousand pesos!
(c) Private Nuisance by Private Persons (Art. 706)!
i) Procedure is similar to abatement of public nuisance by private person!
4. Torts and Damages!
5. Quieting of Title (Chapter 3)!
a) An action brought to remove a cloud on title to real property by reason of any
instrument, record, claim, encumbrance or proceedings which is apparently valid or
effective but is in truth and in fact invalid, ineffective or unenforceable, and may be
prejudicial to said title. (Art. 476)!
b) Legal or equitable title to or interest to real property!
c) Return of all the benefits acquired by the plaintiff to the defendant (Art. 479)!
B. Easements!
C. Private Ownership vs. The State!
1. Taxation!
2. Eminent Domain!
a) Art. 435. No person shall be deprive of his property except by competent authority
and for pubic use an always upon payment of just compensation.!
3. Police Power in General!
4. Land Use Regulations/Zoning!
a) In General !
(1) Interference with the Traditional Property Rights Regime !
(2) Freedom to use land except only in nuisance and easement!
(3) Constitutionality!
b) Zoning!
(1) Non-Conforming Uses!
(2) Amortisation!
(3) Zoning Amendments!
(4) Variance!
(5) Special Exceptions!
c) Future of Land Use Regulations!
d) Laws on Land Use in the Philippines!
(1) Batas Pambansa Blg. 220 - Authorises the ministry of human settlements to
establish and promulgate different levels of standards and technical
requirements for economic and socialized housing projects in urban and rural
areas from those provided under Presidential Decrees No. 957, 1216, 1067 and
1185.!
(2) Presidential Decree No. 957 - regulates the sale of subdivision lots and
condominiums.!
(3) Presidential Decree No. 1216 - defining "open space" in residential subdivisions
and amended section 31 of Presidential Decree No. 957 requiring subdivision
owners to provide roads, alleys, sidewalks and reserve open space for parks or
recreational use)!
(4) Republic Act No. 7160 - mandated the LGU to prepare and implement a
comprehensive land use plan (CLUP) and shall approve subdivision plans.!
Page 12 of 15
(5) Executive Order No. 71 - implemented the provision of RA No. 7160 on the
LGUs mandate to approve subdivision plans, to cities and municipalities
pursuant to R.A. No. 7160 (LGC).!
(6) Executive Order No. 72 - implemented the provision of the LGC for the
preparation and implementation of the comprehensive Land Use Plans.
HLURBs role on standards. !
(7) Republic Act No. 7279 - Urban Development and Housing Act provided a
comprehesive and continuing urban development and housing program,
establish the mechanism for its implementation.!
(8) Proposed Land Use Act - 20 years of deliberation in Congress!
e) Cases:!
5. Environmental Regulations!
a) In general !
(1) Many environmental law affects how property can be use. !
(2) Environmental laws developed only in the 1960s and created a comprehensive
legislation that sometimes intersects with laws governing property.!
b) Property and Ecology !
(1) Land is not a passive entity waining to be transformed by its land owner. Land is
already at work, performing important services in its unaltered state. Some
ecological functions have been recognized and protected by law. Viewing land
through the lens of natures economy reduces the significance of property lines.
(Joseph L. Sax, Property Rights and the Economy of Nature, 45 Stan. L.
Review. 1433, (1993)!
c) Theories!
(1) Utilitarian theory - land is solely the owners property to develop as the owner
please!
(2) Green theory - ecological ethic emphasises the moral duty of humanity to act as
a steward of natural life (J. Peter Bryne, Green Property, 7 Const. Comment.
239, 243 (1990)!
(3) Public Trust Doctrine - lands are deemed to be owned in trust by the sovereign
for the benefit of the public!
(4) Bundle of rights - title does not include the right to violate the public trust. !
d) Cases:!
Page 13 of 15
Page 14 of 15
Donation!
Succession!
Sales!
Exchange
Page 15 of 15