You are on page 1of 10

Electric Bicycle Using Batteries and Supercapacitors

D. M. Sousa, P. J. Costa Branco, J. A. Dente

DEEC AC-Energia /CAUTL, Instituto Superior Tcnico, TU Lisbon

DEEC AC-Energia, Instituto Superior Tcnico, TU Lisbon
Av. Rovisco Pais, 1 1049-001 Lisboa
Lisboa, Portugal

Tel.: +351 21 841 74 29, +351 21 841 74 32, +351 21 841 74 35.
Fax: +351 21 841 71 67.

Electric vehicle, Energy storage, Supercapacitor, Power converters for EV, Electrical drive.

In this paper, a traction system useful for an autonomous Electric Vehicle of individual use is described.
The developed system is constituted in a first approach by two different power sources: one is constituted
by batteries or by fuel cells, and the other by supercapacitors. This paper describes a technical solution
joining and accomplishing the usage of two energy storage systems in the same traction system. In the
developed system, the supercapacitors run as element that store energy temporarily and that can be used to
retrieve energy.
Starting from the functional characteristics of typical electrical vehicles and characterization of a typical
routing profile, the energy consumption is obtained.
In order to characterize and design the system, this is described in detail, namely the supercapacitors
models, the battery, the power converters and the implemented strategy of control.
According to the obtained results, a control strategy that allows an effective management of the stored
energy in the system regarding the vehicles optimal functioning and increasing its autonomy is also
presented and discussed.
Based on experimental and simulation results, the advantages and disadvantages of the proposed solution
are presented.

In the modern societies, the increasing needs of mobility means sometimes increasing the number of
vehicles circulating. Ambient concerns, as for instance local pollutant emissions for the atmosphere,
influence also, in nowadays, the technical decisions related with all kind of vehicles. In this context, new
alternatives to the existing internal combustion engines are mandatory. So, vehicles with electric
propulsion seem to be an interesting alternative [1, 2, 3].
Starting from this context, this research describes a solution that was developed and studied to be applied
in electric vehicles of individual use as bicycles. The solution proposes the combination of two sources of
energy, batteries and supercapacitors, and two DC-DC converters. On board, batteries and supercapacitors
store the energy. Anyway, the proposed topology considers that fuel cells should be used in two ways:
replacing the set of batteries or to charge the batteries and the supercapacitors.

As it is well known, in the typical electric traction systems the batteries drive the high currents and in the
worst situation drive the current peaks demanded by the load. As it is well known, this type of operation
decreases strongly the autonomy of the vehicles for individual use. The continuous and random operation
of electrical vehicles requires and claims for systems improving the autonomy and the performance of the
available ones. In this situation, a solution to improve the battery behaviour and its time life is to replace
temporarily the battery by another power source or, as in the developed solution, to supply the system
using other power source when undesired and transient situations occur [4]. In this case, the load is
supplied by the complementary energy source avoiding, at least, deep discharges of the battery. The
adopted solution uses supercapacitors, which drive the peaks of power required by the load.

Requirements of the system

The first step in order to project the system is to establish the objectives of the work according to the
energy consumption and the performance of the vehicle for individual use. To estimate the power required
by this type of vehicles, we have considered that the forces applied to the vehicle are, as represented in
figure 1, the following:
Fa = M a


F g = M g sin


F air =

M C D A f v (t ) 2


F r = M g C R cos

Where: Fa is the resulting force; Fg is the gravitational force; Fair is the air friction force; and Fr is the
wheels friction force; parameter is the air density (1.29 kg/m3); Af is the frontal area of the vehicle; CD is
the air friction coefficient (tipically 0.9 for a scooter and 0.8 for a bicycle); and CR is the wheels friction
coefficient (usually between 0.008 and 0.014).

F air =

M C D A f v (t )2

F r = M g C R cos
F g = M g sin

Fig. 1: Forces applied to the vehicle

Considering that the vehicle runs with a speed v, the power required by the system is:
PVE = P a + P g + P air + P r
PVE = M a (t ) v(t ) + M g v(t ) sin + M C D A f v(t )3 + M g C R v(t ) cos


Assuming that the vehicle speed is equal to the angular speed of wheels with radius R, torque of the
traction system can be estimated as:
T VE = T a + T g + T air + T r
T VE = M a(t ) R + M g R sin + M C D A f v(t )2 R3 + M g R C R v(t ) cos


Anyway, to analyze and compare the performance of different vehicles for individual use, operating
conditions in terms of speed and autonomy should be used. So, based on the Portuguese standards (NP EN
1986-1), a typical urban cycle (Figure 2), repeated 10 times, with the total duration of 1180 s should be
fulfilled by the traction system in terms of torque and speed and by the power sources on board in terms of
energy stored.

Fig. 2: Profile of the used urban cycle

To fulfill the cycle above and taking into account the physical dimensions of a bicycle or a scooter, the
nominal power required by this type of system stays in the range of 2 kW to 2.5 kW. So, based on the
premises and conditions above, a traction system is proposed aiming the autonomy, efficiency and
performance of this type of vehicles.

Global system
The main elements constituting the global system are two power converters, two energy storage systems
(in the basic implementation, batteries and supercapacitors) and the traction motor [5].
With the proposed solution, the most important objective is to increase the capacity of storing energy and
vehicle autonomy, avoiding deep discharges of the batteries.

In order to achieve this goal, the global topology represented in figure 3 was investigated.









Fig. 3: Global system

The power converters

The proposed topology uses two power converters. Their main functions are:

The power converter DC-DC 1 (operating as buck or book converter (figure 4), in agreement
with the level of charge of the supercapacitors) transfers energy from the supercapacitors to the
The DC-DC 2 converter adjusts the supply voltage of the traction motor (in this case, a DC
motor) to control its speed.








Fig. 4: Converter topology of the used DC-DC power converters

The traction motor

The implemented traction system is based on a DC motor, which dynamic behaviour can be represented


U f = r f i f + L f

d ia

+ k
U a = r a i a + La

J dt = k ia T Load


To project and analyse the system, knowledge of motor parameters is mandatory. In particular, the
electrical time constant and the starting current allowed by the system, which according to experimental
tests are, respectively:

a =

L a 30 ms

i start

20 A



The supercapacitors model

The nominal voltage of each supercapacitor available is lower than the rated voltage of typical electric
traction systems (12 V or 24 V, for instance) [6]. Therefore, in order to fulfill the rated voltage of these
systems, it is mandatory to connect supercapacitors in series and in parallel modes. Anyway, to investigate
the dynamic behaviour and the performance of the global system it is important to know the
supercapacitor model, which electric equivalent model is represented in figure 5.

Fig. 5: Equivalent model of a supercapacitor

The supercapacitor model is constituted by an inductance L, a resistance Ri and an impedance Zp
connected in serie. The impedance Zp can be calculated using the expression:
Z p ( j ) =

coth( j )



To the available supercapacitors (2.5 V; 200F 30% (at 20C)), the parameters of the model were
obtained by electrochemical impedance spectroscopy, which simulated and experimental spectra are
shown in figure 6 [7, 8].

- Imag(Z) [mOhm]















Re(Z) [mOhm]

Fig. 6: Spectra of a supercapacitor impedance

Experimental and Simulation Results

In a first approach to the problem, the supercapacitors were connected in parallel with the battery, as
represented in figure 7 [9, 10]. To study and analyse the performance of such system, both experimental
and simulation results were obtained. The implemented model (simulated using the @Matlab/Simulink)
includes dynamic models to the used battery and supercapacitors [11, 12, 13].




Fig. 7: Circuit connecting in parallel the supercapacitors and battery

The electrical equations representing the circuit are in a first approach the following:

i a = i SC + ib

v = v SC i R SC = vb ib Rb

i SC = C v SC


A prototype of this circuit was implemented in the laboratory, with a set of batteries (12V, 7Ah each one),
a DC motor and a five supercapacitors in series (Ctotal = 200/5 = 40 F). To a random load diagram, the
experimental and simulation results obtained are shown in figures 8 and 9. From these results, it is
important to point out that current peaks are driven by the supercapacitors, thus avoiding deep discharges
of the batteries. Furthermore, when the motor is braking the supercapacitors are charged.

urren t [A]
(A )










im e (s)[s]




C urrent ( A )

Fig. 8: Experimental results

T im e (s)



Fig. 9: Simulation results

A reasonable agreement between the experimental results and the simulation ones is observed, leading that
the assumption that the developed models constitute a good approach and the circuit behaves as foreseen
Anyway, the above operating principle is only valid if an effective control of the energy transit between
the supercapacitors and the battery is reached.

The control strategy

The first approach to the problem of energy management is based on the calculation of an average value
of the current iDC demanded by traction system. The average current should be supplied by the main power
supply, which can be the set of batteries or a fuel cell [3, 14, 15]. The difference between the

instantaneous value of the load current ia and the average value of iDC will be the current supplied by the
supercapacitors, iSC.
When the current iSC is positive and the total voltage of the supercapacitors is higher than the energy
availability, the break level V, a duty-cycle is applied to the semiconductor S1 (figure 4) running the DCDC 1 converter as a boost converter. On other hand, if the supercapacitors does not have energy available,
that is, the set of supercacitors is discharged or their voltage is under the break level, converter DC-DC 1
is switched off and the main power supply supplies the traction system. For negative values of iSC and if
the supercapacitors do not have the maximum load V, converter DC-DC 1 runs as buck converter. When
the supercapacitors voltage reaches the value V , converter DC-DC 1 remains in its stand-by mode.
Anyway, if a fuel cell is used as the main power supply, condition iDC <0 cannot occur. If for instance, iDC
is negative and the supercapacitors are fully load, to guarantee the protection of the fuell cell, converter
DC-DC 2 is switched off, that is, the power supply and load are disconnected.
The flow chart representing the algorithm of control is represented in figure 10.

Fig. 10: Flow chart of the algorithm of control

In this paper an electronic converter using two power sources connected through two DC-DC converters is
described having potential application in electric bicycles or in other vehicles for individual use without
internal combustion engines.
The proposed system uses in its basic topology a set of batteries and a bank of supercapacitors to supply
the traction system but is also designed to replace the batteries by fuel cells. The conception of the
proposed system is also the first step to investigate the solutions and systems that allow to charge
electrical vehicles in remote places or when the infinite power nets are not available. In this case, fuel cells
can be used to store energy and to restore the energy of these types of autonomous vehicles.
With the proposed solution, it is expected to increase the autonomy of electrical vehicles as electric
bicycles or scooters and to avoid high current peak and fast discharges of the batteries. Therefore, a
control algorithm managing the energy stored on board and the running of the proposed system is
From the experimental and simulation results obtained it is important to point out that the proposed system
has an appropriate performance in hard situations like high loads avoiding deep discharges of the batteries.
Furthermore, it is also possible to adequate the algorithm of to the profile of the course and maximize the
energy recovering. It is also important to refer that the running of the DC-DC converter either as buck or
boost converters does not introduce perturbations in the system dynamics, in particular the vehicle speed
remains constant.
This work reflects also the real perspective of integration of multi energy storage systems in a unique
traction system. The proposed solution reveals advantages from the point of the viewpoint of the traction
system concerning overload situations and avoiding an unnecessary over dimensioning of all system.
In the further work, the implemented power circuit (figure 3) will be analysed taking into account the
amount of energy stored for unit of weight in the storage systems available and useful to these type of
small vehicles.

[1] Chan. H and Sutano D., A New Battery Model for use with Energy Storage Systems and Electric Vehicles Power
Systems, IEEE Power Engineering Society Winter Meeting, 2000.
[2] Szumanowski Antoni, Pirkowski Piotr, Chang Yuhua: Batteries and Ultracapacitors Set in Hybrid Propulsion
Systems, Powereng - International Cnference on Power Engineering, Energy and Electrical Drives, paper no. 220,
[3] Lin Bruce, Conceptual design and modelling of a fuel cell scooter for urban Asia chapter 2 Electric Vehicles,
Princeton University, 1999
[4] Mohan Ned et al, Power Electronics Converters, Applications and Design, Third edition, John Wiley & Sons Inc,
[5] Sousa D.M., Costa Branco P. J., Dente J.A.: Electric Bicycle Supplied by an Electronic Converter Using Distinct
Forms of Energy Storage, Powereng - International Cnference on Power Engineering, Energy and Electrical Drives,
paper no. 223, 2007.
[6] Bullard G. et al, Operating principle of the ultracapacitor, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, Vol. 25, No. 1, Jan.

[7] Buller S. et al, Modeling the Dynamic Behaviour of Supercapacitors Using Impedance Spectroscopy, IEEE
Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. 38, No. 6, pp. 1622-1626, December 2002
[8] Naminsnyk A. and Zhu J., A survey of electrochemical supercapacitor technology, Faculty of Engineering,
University of Technology, Sidney
[9] Pay S. and Baghzouz Y., Effectiveness of Battery - Supercapacitor Combination in Electric Vehicles, IEEE
PowerTech Conference, June 23-26, 2003, Bologna, Italy.
[10] Miller John and Smith Richard, Ultracapacitor assisted electric drives for transportation, Maxwell Technologies.
[11] Salameh Ziyad M., Casacca Margaret A. and Lynch William A., A Mathematical Model for Lead-Acid
Batteries, IEEE Trans. On Energy Conversion. Vol. 7, No. 1, March 1992
[12] Gao L., Dougal R., Liu S., Active Power Sharing in Hybrid Battery/Capacitor Power Sources, IEEE Eighteenth
Annual Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition - APEC '03, 2003
[13] Linzen Dirk et al, Analysis and evaluation of charge balancing circuits on performance, reliability and lifetime
of supercapacitors systems, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. 41, No. 5, pp. 1135-1141,
September/October 2005
[14] Gassmann Fritz et al, Supercapacitors boost the fuel cell car, Europhysics News Vol. 34, No. 5, 2003
[15] Larminie James and Dicks Andrew, Fuel Cell Systems Explained, Second Edition, 2003 John Wiley & Sons,