Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER 3
Introduction to Structural Dynamics
Learning Objectives
Application of lumped mass idealization.
Identification of simple and multi-degree of freedom
systems of vibration.
Comparison of free and forced vibrations, resonance and
damping effects.
Approximation of fundamental frequencies and mode
shape of simple structures for seismic design.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
Introduction
Dynamic analysis is similar to static analysis except that there is the extra
dimension of time to take into account. Dynamic analysis also involves the
solution of equilibrium equations but with variation in time. The equations
have additional terms proportional to velocity and acceleration.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
Source of Excitation
The most common types of dynamic loading on structures are: wind,
earthquakes, human forces, moving vehicles, industrial machinery, blasting and
pile driving. It is standard practice to use equivalent static horizontal forces
when designing buildings for wind and earthquake resistance. This is the
simplest way of obtaining the dimensions of the structural members. Dynamic
calculations may follow to check and perhaps modify the design.
Human forces, in the form of crowd loading, are almost always treated as static
distributed loads. But observations at a pop concert or football ground can
demonstrate the highly dynamic nature of the loading. Moving vehicles can be
designed for by adding an allowance for impact to their static weight. This has
proved satisfactory for the design of highway and railway bridges. But the
procedures may not be justified for load moving at very high speeds.
Effects of structural vibrations
Vibration of structures is undesirable for the following reasons:
i) Structural damage,
ii) Cracking and other damage to non-structural elements
iii) Effect on equipment
iv) Human discomfort
v) Fatigue fracture.
With modern forms of construction, it is feasible to design buildings to resist the
forces arising from major earthquakes. The essential requirement is to prevent
total collapse and consequent loss of life. For economic reasons, however, it is
the usual practice to accept some level of damage which may be repaired. For
an important structure such as a nuclear plant, there are considerations other
than structural effects damage to nuclear equipment can cause dangerous
consequences, not to mention major financial losses due to down-time. Some
industrial plants with delicate manufacturing processes, e.g. microchip
production, also require special vibration control.
Vibrations in a building may also cause significant human discomfort. The
human body is quite sensitive to vibration and amplitudes as low as 0.05 m
may be detected by the fingertips. In an industrial plant, it may be necessary to
check whether the vibrations caused by industrial machinery exceed human
tolerance limits. Design of tall buildings for wind effects may also have to
consider whether the wind-excited vibrations disturb the occupants to an
unacceptable degree.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
The most basic vibration system consists of a single lumped mass and a spring.
This is said to have one degree of freedom. That is to say, there is only one
possible direction of movement of the lumped mass.
It may seem that such as a crude approximation could produce little in the way
of practical information. In fact, they can be very useful for two reasons.
Firstly, skilled engineers can make good predictions of the behavior of real
structures by intelligent choice of the parameters of simple systems. Secondly,
the complicated motions of a real structure can often be resolved into simpler
motions of a number of mass spring systems and dealt with by superposition.
A sound understanding of the vibration of single degree of freedom (SDOF)
systems is also essential groundwork for understanding the dynamic behavior of
more complicated systems.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
3.3
Damping ratio
The effect of energy dissipating forces that resists the vibratory motion of a
structure is called damping. Damping forces include internal friction and other
effects, which are complex in nature and difficult to determine exactly.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
3.4
The properties of a single degree of freedom system that directly affects its
dynamic response are its mass m, stiffness k and damping ratio .
Free Vibration (No damping)
The free vibration response of a SDOF system is shown below. Free vibration
takes place when a structure vibrates on its own after being imparted an initial
displacement and velocity at time zero.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
10
The mass returns to its equilibrium position c, continues moving to the left,
reaching its minimum displacement -u0 at d, and then the displacement
decreases again, returning to the equilibrium position at e.
The time required for the undamped system to complete one cycle of free
vibration is called the natural period of vibration T (seconds) of the structure.
It is related to the natural circular frequency of vibration (in units of radians
per seconds) and the natural cyclic frequency of vibration f (cycles/sec or Hertz
or Hz) as follows:
Natural Period of vibration
Natural Cyclic Frequency
(sec)
T 2
(cps or Hz)
The natural circular frequency is a function of the mass and stiffness of the
structure:
k
Natural Circular Frequency
(rad/sec)
m
Thus the free vibration properties , T and f depend only on the mass and
stiffness of the structure.
For two structures with the same mass, the one with greater stiffness will have a
higher vibration frequency and a shorter vibration period. Similarly, for two
structures with the same stiffness, the one with greater mass will have a lower
vibration frequency.
Damped Vibration
For a damped system under free vibration, the vibration amplitude decreases
with every cycle of vibration.
The period of vibration TD, circular frequency D and cyclic frequency fD of the
damped structure are interrelated in the same way as for the undamped structure:
2
Damped Period of vibration
TD
(sec)
fD
1 D
TD 2
(cps or Hz)
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
11
D 1 2
T
TD
1 2
(rad/sec)
(rad/sec)
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
12
A periodic loading repeats the same variation over a large number of cycles.
The simplest periodic loading has a sinusoidal or simple harmonic variation.
An example of periodic type loading is the effect of rotating machinery.
Periodic loading can be more complex, e.g. the forces generated by a ship
propeller. However, any periodic loading can be resolved into a series of
simple harmonic components by means of Fourier Analysis.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
13
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
14
u max
u static
= maximum displacement under vibration
= displacement produced by a static force P
= frequency of the applied force
= natural frequency of the structure
= damping ratio of the structure
umax
ustatic
p
Note that the Dynamic Magnification Factor depends only on the frequency
ratio and the damping factor.
It can be observed that as the frequency ratio approaches 1.0, the dynamic
magnification factor becomes very large especially when damping is low (which
is true for most structures). When the applied force frequency and the natural
frequency of the structure almost coincide, the structure is said to resonate and it
will undergo maximum dynamic displacement. When an undamped structure
resonates, the displacement tends to infinity. It is therefore important to ensure,
as far as possible, that the applied force frequency does not approach the natural
frequency of the structure.
For buildings of low to medium height, the structural frequency is generally
different enough from that of wind loading such that the dynamic magnification
factor is practically 1.0. In the design of such structures, wind load can be
treated as equivalent static loading.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
15
Example 1
The structural frame shown in Figure 10 is rigid jointed and fixed to its supports.
The mass of the structure of 5000 kg is concentrated on the beam which is
assumed to be rigid. The columns are assumed weightless and each has
flexural stiffness (EI) of 4.5 x 106 Nm2 in the plane of the structure. If the
structure is assumed to have a viscous damping ratio of 4%, calculate the
damped and undamped natural frequencies.
Figure 10
Solution
The mass of the equivalent one degree of freedom system is
m = 5000 kg
Note that when the frame is displaced, each column is deflected as shown in
Figure 10 (b) with zero rotations at top and bottom. The forces corresponding to
a unit lateral displacement can be calculated from elementary bending theory and
are as shown. Hence the effective spring stiffness of the structure is twice the
lateral stiffness of each column and is therefore
12 EI
k=2x
= 2 x 12 x 4.5 x 106 / 33 = 4.0 x 106 N/m
3
h
Hence, the undamped natural frequency is
1
1
f
T 2 2
= 4.502 Hz
1
k
m 2
4 x106
5000
fD f 1 2 = 4.502 x
= 4.498 Hz
1 0.042
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
16
Example 2
For portal frame ABCD shown in Figure 11, it may be assumed that the
horizontal member is infinitely stiff and that the vertical members have
negligible mass compared with that of the horizontal member. If there is no
damping, determine the natural frequency f and the natural period T.
Figure 11
Solution
The stiffnesses of the members AB and CD are:
12 EI
12 E (3I )
EI
kAB =
N/mm
kCD =
= 4.5 3 N/mm
3
3
L
( 2 L)
L
Hence
EI
EI
k = kAB + kCD = 16.5 3 N/mm = 16500 3 N/m
L
L
k
(where k is in newtons per metre and m in kilograms)
m
16500 EI
EI
radians per second
128
ML3
ML3
2 ML3
T=
=
seconds
128 EI
128 EI
1
f
cycles per second
2 ML3
T 2
2
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
17
m1
M=
m2
.
.
mN
k2
(k1 k 2 )
k
( k 2 k3 ) k3
2
k3
.
K=
.
.
kN
kN
kN
Several properties of the above matrices are useful to bear in mind. First, both
M and K are symmetric matrices. Second, M is a diagonal matrix for a
lumped mass system. Third, the diagonal elements of the K matrix are always
positive.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
18
For a N-DOF system, the mass and stiffness matrices are of order N. Solution
of the eigen problem leads to the N natural frequencies and eigen vectors: n, Xn
(n=1 to N).
It is usual to represent the smallest frequency by 1. This frequency is called
the fundamental frequency of the system and corresponds to the first mode of
vibration. The remaining frequencies correspond to the second and higher
modes of vibration. The eigen vectors Xn are often re-expressed in
dimensionless form by dividing all the components by one reference component
(usually the largest), a procedure called normalization. The resulting vector is
called the n-th mode shape n:
1n
2n
.
1
n = =
X max
.
.
Nn
X 1n
X
2n
.
.
.
X Nn
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
19
Many methods have been developed for numerical solution of the eigen problem
and are available in many textbooks. Usually just the first few vibration modes,
and sometimes just the fundamental mode is sufficient for most dynamic
analysis.
Idealization of multi-storey buildings for horizontal dynamic loading
For the analysis of the response of a multi-storey building to horizontal dynamic
loading (e.g. wind or earthquake), a useful idealization is the shear building or
shear frame model:
i) The mass of the structure is assumed to be lumped at the floor levels.
ii) The floors (i.e. horizontal members) are assumed to be rigid.
iii)Axial deformations in the columns are ignored.
iv) The lateral stiffness of the building is due entirely to the stiffness of the
columns in bending.
In a shear building, rotation of joints is assumed not to occur and the floors can
only move horizontally. Accordingly an N-storey frame will have N degrees of
freedom.
m1 0
M = mass matrix = 0 m2
0
0
0
0
m3
k2
0
(k1 k 2 )
k2
( k 2 k3 ) k3
K = stiffness matrix =
0
k3
k3
The lateral storey stiffness kj of the j-th storey is the storey shear force required
to cause a unit horizontal displacement for that storey. The values of the lateral
storey stiffnesses k1, k2, kN can be calculated from the bending stiffness of the
columns. The contribution of each column to the lateral storey stiffness is
12 EI
given by 3 .
L
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
20
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
21
m1
Mass Matrix M =
m2
.
mj
.
.
m N
k2
(k1 k 2 )
k
( k 2 k3 )
k3
2
k3
( k3 k 4 ) k 4
Stiffness Matrix K =
.
.
kN
kN
kN
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
22
Example 3
Find the natural frequencies and mode shapes of the three-storey building shown
in Figure 15. Assume that the building is undamped.
Figure 15
Solution
The building can be idealized as a three-degree of freedom lumped mass system
with the mass matrix given by
4 0 0
M = 105 0 4 0 kg
0 0 4
The stiffness matrix can be obtained by assuming unit displacements at each storey
and then calculating the forces in the structure. Hence
K = 120 x 10
6 2 0
2 3 1 N/m
0 1 1
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
23
K M = 120 x 10
2
0
( 6 )
2
(3 )
1
0
1
(1 )
where =
300
2110
1
and = 2 =
3
3 = 7.034
11.62
27.50 rad/s
45.94
The mode shapes can now be calculated. Assuming a normalized shape for each
mode, i.e. 3n = 1, gives
1n
n = 2 n
1
Thus
K 2 M X 0
120 x 106
becomes
2
0
( 6 )
2
(3 )
1
0
1
(1 )
1n 0
2 n = 0
1 0
0.198
1 = 0.55 ;
1
0.874
2 = 1.52 ;
1
11.67
3 = 6.03
1
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
24
Example 4
An idealized 2-storey shear building is shown below, with mass lumped at the
floor levels and individual storey stiffnesses. Determine the vibration mode
shapes and the natural circular frequencies of the building.
4000 kg/m
G
3000 kg/m
D
For all columns
EI = 7.68*108 N/m2
3000 kg/m
H
3m
F
4m
7m
7m
Solution
The stiffness matrix can be obtained by assuming unit displacements at each storey
and then calculating the forces in the structure.
3 * EI
=0.04688 EI
43
12 * EI
kCF =12EI/L3 =
=0.1875 EI
43
12 * EI
kEG = kFH = 12EI/L3 =
=0.4444 EI
33
= (0.04688*2 + 0.1875) EI
= 0.2813 EI
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
25
1.1701 0.8888
K = EI
0.8888 0.8888
1.1701 0.8888
= 7.68 x 108
0.8888 0.8888
1.3165 1
= 6.826 x 108
N/m
1
1
Mass Matrix:
4.2 0
4 1.5 0
M = 104
kg
=
2.8*10
*
0 1
0 2.8
K 2 M 0
1.3165 1.5 1
K 2 M = 6.826*108
1
1
2.8 *10 4 2
where =
6.826 *108
1 54.09
= 207.0 rad/s
For 1 = 0.1200
1 1 0
1.3165 1.5 * 0.12
6.826*108
1
1 0.12 X 21 0
1 1
X 1.1365
21
0.8799
Hence 11
1 1
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
26
For 2 = 1.7576
1 1 0
1.3165 1.5 *1.7576
6.826*108
1
1 1.7576 X 22 0
1 1
X 1.3199
22
0.7576
Hence 12
1 1
Revision
Read reference 1 on P.39 65, P.401 - 443.
Read reference 2 on P.3 33, P.201 226.
Main Reference
1. Dynamics of Structures, Theory and Applications to Earthquake Engineering,
3rd Edition, Anil K. Chopra, Prentice Hall.
2. Structural Dynamics, Theory and Computation, 3rd Edition, Mario Paz,
Chapman & Hall.
3. Dynamics of Structures, 2nd Edition, Ray W. Clough & Joseph Penzien,
McGraw Hill.
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
27
TUTORIAL 3
Q1. An idealized 3-storey shear building is shown below, with mass lumped at the floor levels and
individual storey stiffnesses.
Determine the vibration mode shapes and the natural circular frequencies of the building.
Ans:
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
28
TUTORIAL 3
Q2.
Compute the natural angular frequency of vibration in sidesway for the frame shown below and
calculate the natural period of vibration. Idealize the frame as one degree of freedom system.
Neglect axial and shear deformations and the weight of the columns.
(Ans:
= 7.103 rad/sec,
T = 0.885 sec)
If the system has a damping coefficient = 0.1, what are the damped natural circular frequency d
and the natural period of damped vibration Td ?
(Ans:
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
29
TUTORIAL 3
Q.3 A two-storey undamped building frame is shown in the following figure. By using the lumped mass
idealization and neglecting the axial and shear deformation and self-weight of columns, calculate:
(a) Mass (M) and stiffness (K) matrix of the system;
(b) Natural cyclic frequencies (f) of the building; and
(c) Corresponding mode shapes of vibration.
G
2000 kg/m
H
A
4m
2000 kg/m E
A
2000 kg/m
F
5m
C
6m
Q.4
3m
8m
The structural frame of an idealised two-storey shear building is shown as follows. The lumped
masses at floor levels and the relative values of flexural rigidities of the individual columns are
given as shown. Determine:
(a) The mass matrix M of the building.
(b) The stiffness matrix K of the building.
(c) The natural periods and natural cyclic frequencies of the building.
(d) The corresponding mode shapes of vibration normalized with respect to the components of the
second storey.
3 * 105 kg
E
F
EI
2EI
3m
EI
H
D
5
4 * 10 kg
EI
2EI
A
3.5m
EI = 2 * 109 Nm2
for all columns
B
Chapter 3
HD in Civil Engineering
30