32 views

Uploaded by George Hrabovsky

Solving the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff equations.

- Covariant and locally Lorentz-invariant varying speed of light theories Jo ̃ao Magueijo
- art-3A10.1007-2Fs10773-009-0181-0
- Joel Smoller and Blake Temple- Theory of a Cosmic Shock-Wave
- Essay on bing bang
- History of Einstein Equations
- Resumão de Geometria
- 20 Jan 2010
- CTS 001
- C.M. Will- The Confrontation Between General Relativity and Experiment
- Notable Ex
- The Einstein field equation in terms of the Schrödinger equation
- Th Povert o Scientis
- 0711.2416v1[1]
- R. Geroch. General relativity lecture notes. 1972.pdf
- b5 General Relativity and Cosmology
- Lorentz
- Listening - Black Holes - 20 Facts
- Microsoft Word - Document1asdgfvx
- 9 5 Dilation
- On the Possibility of Catastrophic Black Hole at the LHC (WWW.OLOSCIENCE.COM)

You are on page 1of 6

George E. Hrabovsky

MAST

James Firmiss

MAST

Abstract

In this paper the authors interpret the equations from the famous paper by Oppenheimer and Volkoff [1] in

Mathematica. We then plot the solutions for various conditions.

Introduction

The birth of the study of compact objects traces back to the landmark paper written by J. R. Oppenheimer and G. M. Volkoff [1], and will be called

OV throughout this paper. OV was a great departure from the previous work of Arthur Eddingtonbased on conveniently assumed distributions

of stellar energy sources to invent different stellar modelsand Lev Landauwhose work was based on equilibrium conditions from Newtonian

gravitation. OV is based on the general relativistic calculations of the metrics (and thus the Ricci tensor) and the stress-energy tensor from Richard C.

Tolman [2]. It is thus fully in line with general relativity, though the assumption of no cosmological constantconsistant with Einsteins views at the

timemay require some rethinking in light of recent results regarding so-called dark energy.

The Model

OV is very clever and mathematical, sometimes the physics is submerged and difficult to locate. We begin and assign the value for the

parameter K = 41 .

K=

1

4

= K(sinh t - t)

(1)

and for pressure,

=

eqn12 = p[r]

1

2

1

3

K sinh t - 8 sinh

K Sinh[t[r]] - 8 Sinh

1

3

1

2

t+3t

(2)

t[r] + 3 t[r] ;

u

r

= r 2 (sinh t - t).

and,

(3)

OV.nb

t

r

eqn19 = D[t[r], r] 1

3

r3

=-

sinh t - 2 sinh 12 t

r (r - 2 u) cosh t - 4 cosh 1 t + 3

2

2

Sinh[t[r]] + 8 Sinh

1

2

We avoid a singularity by assuming a minimum radius of 0.001 absolute units. We then assign the following initial conditions:

ic[tt_] := {t[0.001] tt, u[0.001] 0, [0.001] == 0.1752, p[0.001] == 1.458}

The Solution

We now use NDSolve to get the solution for the equations and initial conditions.

soln[tt_] := NDSolve[{eqn11, eqn12, eqn18, eqn19, ic[tt]}, {u[r], t[r], [r], p[r]},

{r, 0.001, 50}]

We will assume an internal temperature of 1 in absolute units. This gives us the initial conditions:

ic[1]

{t[0.001] 1, u[0.001] 0, [0.001] 0.1752, p[0.001] 1.458}

{t[0.001] 1, u[0.001] 0, [0.001] 0.1752, p[0.001] 1.458}

It also gives the solution (in InterpolatingFunctions):

s1 = soln[1]

{{u[r] InterpolatingFunction[{{0.001, 0.211127}}, <>][r],

t[r] InterpolatingFunction[{{0.001, 0.211127}}, <>][r],

[r] InterpolatingFunction[{{0.001, 0.211127}}, <>][r],

p[r] InterpolatingFunction[{{0.001, 0.211127}}, <>][r]}}

{{u[r] InterpolatingFunction[{{0.001, 0.211127}}, <>][r],

t[r] InterpolatingFunction[{{0.001, 0.211127}}, <>][r],

[r] InterpolatingFunction[{{0.001, 0.211127}}, <>][r],

p[r] InterpolatingFunction[{{0.001, 0.211127}}, <>][r]}}

Here we see the temperature profile with radius.

(4)

OV.nb

FrameLabel {"r [Arbitrary Units]", "t(r) [Arbitrary Units]"},

PlotLabel

"Temperature as a Function of Radius from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations"]

Temperature as a Function of Radius from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations

1.0

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.0

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

r [Arbitrary Units]

Plot[[r] /. s1, {r, 0.001, .2}, Frame True,

FrameLabel {"r [Arbitrary Units]", "(r) [Arbitrary Units]"},

PlotLabel

"Density as a Function of Radius from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations"]

Density as a Function of Radius from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations

0.014

0.012

0.010

0.008

0.006

0.004

0.002

0.000

0.00

0.05

0.10

r [Arbitrary Units]

0.15

0.20

OV.nb

FrameLabel {"r [Arbitrary Units]", "p(r) [Arbitrary Units]"},

PlotLabel

"Pressure as a Function of Radius from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations"]

Pressure as a Function of Radius from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations

0.05

0.04

0.03

0.02

0.01

0.00

0.00

0.05

0.10

0.15

0.20

r [Arbitrary Units]

FrameLabel {"p(r) [Arbitrary Units]", "(r) [Arbitrary Units]"},

PlotLabel "Pressure vs. Density from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations",

AspectRatio 2 / 3]

Pressure vs. Density from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations

0.014

0.012

0.010

(r) [Arbitrary Units ]

0.008

0.006

0.004

0.002

0.000

0.00

0.01

0.02

0.03

p(r) [Arbitrary Units]

0.04

0.05

OV.nb

FrameLabel {"p(r) [Arbitrary Units]", "t(r) [Arbitrary Units]"},

PlotLabel "Pressure vs. Temperature from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations",

AspectRatio 2 / 3]

Pressure vs. Temperature from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations

1.0

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.0

0.00

0.01

0.02

0.03

p(r) [Arbitrary Units]

0.04

0.05

OV.nb

FrameLabel {"(r) [Arbitrary Units]", "t(r) [Arbitrary Units]"},

PlotLabel "Density vs. Temperature from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations",

AspectRatio 2 / 3]

Density vs. Temperature from the Oppenheimer-Volkhoff Equations

1.0

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.0

0.000

0.002

0.004

0.006

0.008

0.010

0.012

0.014

Conclusions

Not surprisingly, these equations yield a model of neutron star structure for suitable choices of initial conditions.

Future Work

We will attack the problem in five ways:

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

Create new models based on different initial temeprature values in absolute units. This can be done even by people who do not understand the

equations or physics involved. This is a good learning opportunity for students or technicians.

Create new models based on different initial conditions. This requires some knowledge of neutron star physics to choose reasonable initial

conditions.

Create new equations based on a non-zero cosmological constant. This requires some mathematical sophistication to rederive the O-V

equations.

Create new equations for non-spherically symmetric cases. This requires rederiving the Einstein field equations.

Create new equations of state based on more accurate neutron star physics. This requires knowledge of nuclear physics and quantum field

theory/elementary particle physics.

Bibliography

A. [1] J. R. Oppeneheimer, G. M. Volkoff, (1939), On Massive Neutron Cores, Phys. Rev. 55, pp. 374-381.

B. [2] Richard C. Tolman, (1934), Relativity Thermodynamics and Cosmology, Oxford Univeristy Press, reprinted in 1949.

- Covariant and locally Lorentz-invariant varying speed of light theories Jo ̃ao MagueijoUploaded byFrancisco Zúñiga Frias
- art-3A10.1007-2Fs10773-009-0181-0Uploaded bykahfi20085877
- Joel Smoller and Blake Temple- Theory of a Cosmic Shock-WaveUploaded byLukoe
- Essay on bing bangUploaded byjithukk
- History of Einstein EquationsUploaded byGuillermo Eaton
- Resumão de GeometriaUploaded bySergio Fiuza Fiuza
- 20 Jan 2010Uploaded byDhivya Rini
- CTS 001Uploaded byChetan Jain
- C.M. Will- The Confrontation Between General Relativity and ExperimentUploaded byPortsnuyh
- Notable ExUploaded bycollin_lim_2
- The Einstein field equation in terms of the Schrödinger equationUploaded byVasil Penchev
- Th Povert o ScientisUploaded bydocwavy
- 0711.2416v1[1]Uploaded byBayer Mitrovic
- R. Geroch. General relativity lecture notes. 1972.pdfUploaded byUhum
- b5 General Relativity and CosmologyUploaded byAndrew Orr
- LorentzUploaded byMelody Shields
- Listening - Black Holes - 20 FactsUploaded byFernanda Sales
- Microsoft Word - Document1asdgfvxUploaded byVishakha Kendre
- 9 5 DilationUploaded byKenny Toth
- On the Possibility of Catastrophic Black Hole at the LHC (WWW.OLOSCIENCE.COM)Uploaded byFausto Intilla
- 80 Mark SssssUploaded byArchana Agarwal
- ReadingUploaded byJean Pierre Giraldo
- Constraint Relation Sheet -1 (26.08.2011)Uploaded byJaya Gudral
- motionmountain-volume6Uploaded byreportmyexaminer
- Einstein on the Ether 1924 PbUploaded byValter Alnis Bezerra
- Dissertation Draft 2Uploaded bySantosh Kumar
- Chapter 3 - Forward KinematicsUploaded byTalha Ardıç
- 0007287Uploaded byMurali Krishnan Nair
- Magnetospheric Eternally Collapsing Object (Jeffy Hodgson)Uploaded byDr Abhas Mitra
- measuring the speed of lightUploaded byapi-267083617

- Chapter 3 More NumbersUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- Chapter 1 NumbersUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- Chapter 1 NumbersUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- Article #1 The Amateur TheoristUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- Chapter 2 LogicUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- Session 1 Introduction to Theoretical PhysicsUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- Chapter 3 More NumbersUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- Chapter 1 NumbersUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- Article #1 The Amateur TheoristUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- Chapter 2 LogicUploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky
- guide1Uploaded byGeorge Hrabovsky

- Poverty ResearchUploaded byKeval King
- User Mode LinuxUploaded byLuis
- Pentland Studio and power station objecction Sample Letter to MSPUploaded byDamhead Community
- what is piUploaded byapi-325181218
- Propulsive Performance Analysis of a Stepped Hull by Model Test Results and Sea Trial DataUploaded byMichael McDonald
- resume dejan zivkovic 09Uploaded byzivanovic
- criminologyUploaded bySamina Haider
- Yet Another Agile MethodologyUploaded byRavi Warrier
- science grade 3 lessonUploaded byapi-298999910
- Raymond Williams’ Conclusion.pptxUploaded byAbdelhak Saddik
- Business Management Ethics & EntrepreneurshipUploaded byAsmita Sharma
- NOAA ICING.pdfUploaded byricardotorres
- Evaluation of Aluminum Alloy Brake Drum for Automobile ApplicationUploaded byIJSTR Research Publication
- Fundamentals Of Management 8th Edition - Chapter 3 Test BankUploaded byjhawk757
- 30423983 Leon Trotsky LeninUploaded bymax_vico2281
- CurriculumVitae-MdGolamSarowar. (1)Uploaded bySarowar sojol
- vocab 1-28Uploaded byPeterChao123
- Readme-ClockDomainCrossing.docxUploaded byM V N V Prasad
- experiment for rube goldbergUploaded byapi-366504107
- ExampleUserAcceptanceTest PlanUploaded bykris_acc85
- Prince BookUploaded byApiph Putra
- Cad StandardsUploaded byPaulo Veríssimo
- Participant FormUploaded byKim Mason-Milward
- Differences between Casework and Group Work.docUploaded byeldhoev4804
- B118-73 Little 1970-1 ArticleUploaded bystevenamedina
- JanUploaded byJan Lucas
- PSA ShortcutUploaded byBich Lien Pham
- FMB920 User Manual v0.08Uploaded bymarcelocastilloe
- Emerging Trends UNIDO 2013Uploaded byaadhan
- VLE Methanol- waterUploaded byIvan Suarez