4 views

Uploaded by Luminita Mocanu

© All Rights Reserved

- yahoo answers
- Nov 2005 3H
- Edexcel GCE core 4 mathematics C4 6666 advanced subsidiary jun 2006 mark scheme
- Lambert Problem
- M2A1 Angle of Maximum Range
- 12.3
- Add Maths 2001
- Mathcad - extra8
- 1380_4H_que_20090601
- Pmr Paper 1 set 2
- Midterm Practice Prob 1
- The Messenger of Mathematics v17 1000034177
- jee extra problems.pdf
- TRIGONOMETRIC Ratio & Identities Theory_H
- C2 Trigonometry - Questions
- inverse_trig_functions2(2).ppt
- 4.6InverseTrigFunctions.ppt
- trigonometric ratios
- Solutions A
- Edexcel C3 PaperA

You are on page 1of 5

other chords AB and CD are drawn; AD cuts PQ at X and BC cuts PQ

at Y. Prove that M is also the midpoint of XY.

William Wallace's proof is based on the following diagram:

Let's drop perpendiculars x1 and x2 from X and y1 and y2 from Y on AB and CD.

Let's also introduce a = MP = MQ and x = XM and y = YM. Observe several

pairs of similar triangles, which implies the following proportions:

Triangles

Mx

Mx

Ax

Dx

and My

and My

and Cy

and By

Proportion

x/y = x /y

x/y = x /y

x /y = AX/CY

x /y = XD/YB

1

from which

x/y = x1/y2 x2/y1 = x1/y1 x2/y2 = AXXD/ CYYB = PXXQ/ PYYQ.

So that

x/y = (a - x)(a + x)/ (a - y)(a + y) = (a - x)/(a - y) = a/a = 1.

And finally x = y.

Let O be the center of the given circle. Since OM XY, in order to show

thatXM = MY, we have to prove that XOM = YOM.

Drop perpendiculars OK and ON from O onto AD and BC, respectively.

Obviously, K is the midpoint of AD and N is the midpoint of BC. Further,

DAB = DCB and ADC = ABC,

as angles subtending equal arcs. Triangles ADM and CBM are therefore similar,

and AD/AM = BC/CM, or AK/AM = CN/CM. In other words, in triangles AKM

and CNM two pairs of sides are proportional. Also, the angles between the

corresponding sides are equal. We infer that the triangles AKM and CNM are

similar. Hence, AKM = CNM.

Now, have a look at the quadrilaterals OKXM and ONYM. Both have a pair of opposite straight angles, which implies that

both are inscribable in a circle. In OKXM, AKM = XOM. In ONYM, CNM = YOM. From which we get what we've been

looking for: XOM = YOM.

For convenience, denote the angles as on the diagram on the right. Let x =

XMand a = PM. As in Proof 1,

AXXD

= PXXQ

= a - x.

DX;

= xsin()/sin(180 - ( + + ))

= xsin()/sin( + + ).

And in AXM

AX = xsin()/sin(),

which leads to

AXDX = xsin()sin()/sin()sin( + + ) = a - x.

From here we may find x:

x = asin()sin( + + ))/(sin()sin() + sin()sin( + + )).

The latter expression is symmetric in and . Therefore, if we repeat the derivation for the segment y = MY, we'll get exactly

same result. Hence, x = y.

According to Leon Bankoff (Mathematics Magazine, Volume 60, No. 4, October 1987, pp. 195-210) the appellationThe

Butterfly made its first appearance in the Solutions section of the American Mathematical Monthly in the February 1944

issue. Since the diagram of the theorem (with two wings on each side) established by Qiu Fawen and his students gives a

more realistic depiction of a butterfly, I suggest to call the statement A Better Butterfly Theoremwhich might be interpreted as

both A "Better Butterfly" Theorem and A Better "Butterfly Theorem", the former being my preference.

Let there be two concentric circles with the common center O. A line crosses the two circles at points P, Q and P', Q', M

being the common midpoint of PQ and P'Q'. Through M, draw two lines AA'B'B and CC'D'D and connect AD', A'D, BC', and

B'C. (This is the Butterfly.) Let X, Y, Z, W be the points of intersection of PP'Q'Q with AD', B'C, A'D, and BC', respectively.

Then

(1)

(Since X coincides with Z and Y with W when the two circles coalesce into one, The Butterfly Theorem is an immediate

consequence of A Better Butterfly Theorem.)

The proof depends on the following

Lemma

Let in RST, RU be a cevian through vertex R. Introduce angles = SRU and = URT. Then

(2)

The proof follows from the fact that Area( RST) = Area( RSU) + Area( RUT) by a consistent application of the sine

formula for the area of a triangle. (For example, Area( RST) = RSRTsin( + )/2.)

We apply Lemma to triangles AMD', A'MD, B'MC, and BMC':

(3)

sin( + )/MZ = sin()/MD + sin()/MA',

sin( + )/MY = sin()/MC + sin()/MB',

sin( + )/MW = sin()/MC' + sin()/MB.

(4)

sin()/MC + sin()/MB' + sin()/MC' + sin()/MB,

(5)

sin()(1/MC - 1/MD) + sin()(1/MC' - 1/MD').

Now, drop perpendiculars OM1 and OM2 from O onto AA'B'B and CC'D'D. M1 is the midpoint of both AB and A'B', whereas

M2 is the midpoint of CD and C'D'. Obviously,

(6)

MD - MC = MD' - MC' = 2OM = 2OMsin().

1

(7)

However, as is well known, MAMB = MCMD and MA'MB' = MC'MD'. Therefore, (7) is true, as is (5), which in turn, implies

(1).

- yahoo answersUploaded byl2kassassisn
- Nov 2005 3HUploaded bypappadut
- Edexcel GCE core 4 mathematics C4 6666 advanced subsidiary jun 2006 mark schemeUploaded byrainman875
- Lambert ProblemUploaded byStephen Lutz
- M2A1 Angle of Maximum RangeUploaded byBrian Lilly
- 12.3Uploaded byR Gomez GC
- Add Maths 2001Uploaded byapi-26423290
- Mathcad - extra8Uploaded byDesejo Sozinando
- 1380_4H_que_20090601Uploaded byaset999
- Pmr Paper 1 set 2Uploaded bycgnash
- Midterm Practice Prob 1Uploaded byKevin Navidad
- The Messenger of Mathematics v17 1000034177Uploaded byLeandro Az
- jee extra problems.pdfUploaded bysuar90
- TRIGONOMETRIC Ratio & Identities Theory_HUploaded bythinkiit
- C2 Trigonometry - QuestionsUploaded byahamed
- inverse_trig_functions2(2).pptUploaded byZazliana Izatti
- 4.6InverseTrigFunctions.pptUploaded byBryce
- trigonometric ratiosUploaded byapi-237271221
- Solutions AUploaded bykhey
- Edexcel C3 PaperAUploaded bywinston
- Maths Workbook.docUploaded bydnes9999
- Plane TrigoUploaded byedniel maratas
- Fss Prelims Am p2 2009Uploaded bymath3matics3
- midterm 12-13Uploaded byapi-253679034
- 88218419-Section12-8notes.docUploaded bykprk414
- qedissuev3Uploaded byapi-272546296
- LokusUploaded byrosliza
- eulerUploaded bydavid.contatos4308
- Form 5 Formulae and NoteUploaded byCerlovela
- 4037_w12_ms_22.pdfUploaded byAsha D'sa

- Approximately Half of Adult AmericansUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- rbt_grammar_ws02_4bUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- 6texts 2018 Barnovschi g CnnbUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- BrandingUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- LikesUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- The power of a postUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- BrandingUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- analiza strony_U+ü-ENGUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- Traseu 2 Plecare Din GalatiUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- writing fluency in 5 steps.docxUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- Assignment 1, Selecting Key Vocabulary-1Uploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- AfishUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- Barem de CorectareUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- 8Uploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- Clasa a 8a CNNB 8aprilie !Uploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- Testare Initiala 7 2017-2018.DocUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- writing fluency in 5 steps.docxUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- European CouncilUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- Materials SpeakingUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- qpage64Uploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- 2014_engleza_judeteana_sibiu_clasele_xixii_sectiunea_b_subiectebarem(1).pdfUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- 2014 Martie OJE Subiect Clasa X-AUploaded byAnthony Adams
- 2009 Engleză Etapa Locala Subiecte Clasa a XI-A 1Uploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- awake.docxUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- Subiecte Olimpiada.docUploaded byLuminita Mocanu
- Olimpiada de Limba Engleză 11 Section bUploaded byLuminita Mocanu

- Framing, Strategizing and PlanningUploaded bySahar Al-Jobury
- Kano Model (1)Uploaded byShri Harsh
- Experimental Investigation of MIG Welding for ST-37 Using Design of ExperimentUploaded byIJSRP ORG
- 19Uploaded byfrancisccano714991
- Trauma DuodenalUploaded byDesy Erina
- Vmware Interview QuestionsUploaded byshyam_pet057765
- The Orca Keto Did Attack and Kill Alexis MartinezUploaded byJeffrey Ventre MD DC
- myp 1 math criterion onlineUploaded byapi-242287187
- 2012 Mapping Elearning StudyUploaded byUmmu Muqri
- Identify and Classify Vibration Fault Based on Artificial Intelligence Techniques - ProquestUploaded bySanda Pyae Sone
- merakiUploaded byluiza iliescu
- The Concept of Transport Capacity in GeomorphologyUploaded bymarcopumas
- Brosur symex XP-100.pdfUploaded byHari Putra Petir
- navaratri 2010Uploaded bySachin Singh
- FolioUploaded byMark Anthony Baes Enoy
- Bhutan Road Trip ItineraryUploaded byAyush53
- Mcq Anesthesiology Group 5Uploaded byLaw You
- FSUploaded byRaw Gear
- 01.EGovFrame Training Book II EnUploaded byJosé León Arellano Corral
- MAHR 06_MillimessUploaded byIsmael 8877
- Educate and EmpowerUploaded byKiMo Ali
- Glasgow: The Real Mean City by Malcolm Archibald ExtractUploaded byBlack & White Publishing
- Barbara Egedi, Coptic Noun Phrases, diss. Univ. Budapest 2012Uploaded byfcrevatin
- Revised Whitemanual 2013Uploaded byneelesh2k5
- Book of Abstracts BvUploaded byGiorgiana Gianina Danea
- Position Profile - McKnight Foundation - Director of LearningUploaded byLars Leafblad
- second sem evalUploaded byapi-283861986
- Manual Cos2010Uploaded byRyan Rawlings
- Ge 440106Uploaded byFelipe Pereira
- Capnotrainer Optimal BreathingUploaded byMichael Grant White