Why do they murdered Sabeen?

Sabeen Mahmud

A human rights defender was murdered allegedly by the agents of military establishment for holding discussion on
Balochistan

( April 28, 2015, Hong Kong SAR, Sri Lanka Guardian) Who
killed Sabeen Mahmud? The Asian Human Rights Commission, a rights group based
in Hong Kong SAR, come up with facts and claimed the Pakistan military must take
responsibility for this brutality. In their Urgent Appeal programme, the AHRC says,
Sabeen Mahmud, 40, was a prominent Pakistani social and human rights activist and
was also the director of T2F [The Second Floor] that has been a mainstay of Karachis
activists since it opened in 2007.

After her murder, a press release condemning the killing was issued by the Inter
Services Public Relations (ISPR), headed by A Major General of Pakistan Army. This
is the first time in the history of Pakistan that military has come out with a statement on
the murder of a social activist. The act has been perceived by the groups of civil
society as the self-confessional statement from military establishment to stop people
from pointing fingers at the security establishment, the appealed observed.
Full text of the appeal reads as follows;
The Asian Human Rights Commission (AHRC) condemns the brutal murder of a
peace activist and human rights defender by the so called unknown persons after
arranging an open discussion on the gross violation of human rights in Balochistan.
Ms. Sabeen Mahmud, who was receiving life threats from the persons belonging to
spy agencies of the security establishment to cancel the talk that had prominent
Baloch activists Mama Qadeer, Ms. Farzana Majeed and Mir Mohammad Ali Talpur as
panelists. The mysterious calls threatened her with dire consequences if she went
ahead with the talk. Some unknown persons riding on a motorbike wearing helmets
shot several bullets at her while she was going back to her home with her mother after
the talk. The gunshots killed her while also causing serious injuries to her mother.
It is to be mentioned here that the chief of notorious intelligence agency, Inter Service
Intelligence (ISI), has forcefully stopped a talk on Balochistan, organised by the
Lahore University of Science Management (LUMS) on April 9 by writing a threatening
letter to the Vice Chancellor of LUMS organised a talk on, Local as well as
international media have hinted at possibility of the militarys intelligence agencies
particularly ISI in Sabeen Mahmuds murder.

CASE NARRATIVE:
The city of light witnessed another dark moment when freedom of speech activist and
owner of The Second Floor T2F, a famous hangout place for poets and intellectuals
in Karachi Pakistan, was shot dead by unknown assailants on April 25 when she and
her mother were returning from a talk held on issue of Baluchistan. Sabeen Mahmud
received five bullet wounds and died on her way to the hospital while her mother is still
in critical condition. Sabeen was very vocal about the issue of Baluchistan and had
held the talk titled Un silencing Baluchistan Take 2. The talk featuring Mama Qadeer
and Farzana Baloch of Voice of Baloch Missing Person (VBMP) was to be held
originally in Lahore University of Management Sciences (LUMS) a fortnight ago but
was cancelled at the last minute due to pressure from the Director General of countrys
notorious intelligence agency, the ISI. Sabeen took a brave step and hosted the talk at
T2F despite receiving threats.

Sabeen Mahmud, 40, was a prominent Pakistani social and human rights activist and
was also the director of T2F [The Second Floor] that has been a mainstay of Karachis
activists since it opened in 2007. Sabeen held the cancelled talk at T2F nn defiance to
the military and intelligence agency. According to media reports, she had contacted a
friend to ask for advice about whether she should go ahead with the event. She was
having doubts as the person who had initially agreed to moderate the discussion had
backed out.
After her murder, a press release condemning the killing was issued by the Inter
Services Public Relations (ISPR), headed by A Major General of Pakistan Army. This
is the first time in the history of Pakistan that military has come out with a statement on
the murder of a social activist. The act has been perceived by the groups of civil
society as the self-confessional statement from military establishment to stop people
from pointing fingers at the security establishment. The chief of the ISPR, Major Asim
Bajwa in his tweet said We condemn the tragic & unfortunate killing of Ms
Sabeen Mahmud. Our heart goes out to bereaved family at this sad moment- as if
fearing a backlash from the aggrieved civil society. Major Asim promised through his
tweet that Int (intelligence) agencies been tasked 2 render all possible assistance 2
investigating agencies 4 apprehension of perpetrators &bring them to justice.

Object 1

According to Mr. Asif Farukhi, a dear friend of Sabeeen and a famous columnist,
Sabeen received a bullet attached letter threatening her with dire consequences if she
hosted the talk on Baluchistan at T2F a week before it was scheduled. . Sabeen
updated her status on social media before the talk began and wrote,
We need to stand together and face what may come out our way. My logic tells me
that the establishment will not come in guns blazing, at worst they will demand that we
cancel and they will harass us later by asking for paper work and bank statement etc.
However everyone who chooses to attend should understand the climate and make
their own decision regarding safety.

A famous economist and writer, Dr. Ely Ercelan, warned the people that dont talk of
Balochistan if you want to stay alive
The Sindh Chief Minister upset by the high profile murder, knowing very well that who
are behind the murder, has promptly ordered an investigation of the incident by the
Additional Inspector General of Police and to submit report. Knowing very well that
ordinary police officer does not go after the powerful agency so he will come out with
the conclusion that some un-known persons have killed Sabeen and will vow to
apprehend the culprit and soon the matter will become history.
The federal government must appoint judges from Sindh high court to hold inquiry in to
the murder of human rights defender and bring the culprits before the court of law
whatever is their position. It is high time that the civilian government look into the
affairs of the notorious intelligence agencies who are running their own parallel system
against the rule of law.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION:
Freedom of expression as guaranteed under the Constitution has been time and again
suppressed in the name of national security, glory of Islam, etc. by the military as well
as the civil government. Speaking against the military, the ISI in particular, has always
been considered a taboo and no media house dares to cross the line.
Previously the ISI was allegedly involved in the attack on Mr. Hamid Mir who sustained
serious injuries. Mr. Hamid Mir, one of Geo TVs most famed anchor-persons has
directly accused the ISI chief for the attack and conspiracy to assassinate him and of
silencing any critique of the ISI or its agents.
A report by the Human Rights Watch states that the ISI has a long and welldocumented history of abductions, torture, and extrajudicial killings of the critics of the
military and others. Those abducted are routinely beaten and threatened and their
relatives are told not to complain as their release is imminent, and then when released
they are threatened with further abuse if the ordeal is made public. Pakistani and
international human rights organizations, including the Human Rights Watch, have
extensively documented the ISIs intimidation, torture, enforced disappearances, and
killings, including those of many journalists. There were many complaints against the
attacks from ISI officers and their involvement in killings of the journalists. There are
examples of journalists like Hyatullah, Musa Khel and many from Balochistan who
were killed after getting abducted by the powerful intelligence agencies of the army. A
prominent journalist, Umer Cheema, was also abducted by the intelligence
establishment and was severely tortured and sodomised by army officials. But, as is
typical where the military are concerned, no perpetrator has ever been prosecuted nor
has any enquiry been concluded.

Mr. Umer Cheema, a senior journalist at The News International, a daily newspaper
based in Islamabad, was kidnapped, tortured and humiliated for six hours on 4
September, 2010. He was picked up in cloak-and-dagger style in the early hours by
men in commando uniforms and driven to a safe house. Here unknown persons took
over; he was beaten black and blue, humiliated beyond comprehension, he was made
to strip off his clothes, hung upside down and remained in the illegal custody for hours.
Finally, he was thrown out on the roadside at Talagang, 120 kilometers from Islamabad
with a shaved head and a threatening message for Ansar Abbasi, the head of the
newspapers investigative section. The recent attack on the Express Television anchor,
columnist and consulting editor for the Friday Times, Raza Rumi indicates the serious
threats faced by Pakistani journalists in their line of duty. The threats have also forced
Ayesha Siddiqa a prominent military analyst into self-exile.
Most of the journalists killed belong to the tribal belt or Baluchistan. The military
ensures to make an example out of those who dare speak against the institutionalised
terrorism in the name of national security.
On 13 March 2013, human rights defender Ms Perveen Rehman was shot and killed
by Un-Known armed motorcyclists, close to her offices. Perveen Rehman was a
social and economic rights defender, working with communities in the slums of
Karachi. She was director of the Orangi Pilot Project, one of Pakistans most
successful non-for-profit social programmes, which helps local communities escape
from poverty. Perveen Rehman had recently been documenting the situation in
villages close to Karachi, which are affected by land grabbers and religious
extremists.Perveen Rehman had previously reported being subjected to death threats.
On one occasion, an armed man reportedly stormed her offices and ordered staff to
leave.
SUGGESTED ACTION:
Please write letters to the authorities listed below urging them to immediately appoint a
judicial inquiry committee consisting of judges from High Court to probe the murder of
a human right defender and peace activist, Ms. Sabeen Mahmud and provide security
to her mother who is in hospital as the alleged killers from notorious intelligence
agency will not allow her to be an eye witness in the case. Please also urge them to
provide security and safety to the other peace activists and human rights defenders.
The government of Pakistan must be asked as a member of the United Nations, to
follow the obligations to ensure the equal enjoyment by all people within its territory of
the personal and advocacy rights protected by the Universal Declaration of Human
Rights (UDHR) and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).
Discharge of these obligations entails the right to Freedom of Expression and safety
and security of the journalists, which the Human Rights Committee has determined
applies to both criminal and civil proceedings.
The AHRC is writing a separate letter to the UN Special Rapporteurs on Freedom of
Expression and Opinion, and on the Situation of Human Rights Defenders, calling for

their intervention into this matter.