You are on page 1of 33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

ThisisGoogle'scacheofhttps://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimfor
whichreliefcanbegranted/.ItisasnapshotofthepageasitappearedonApr24,201502:49:08GMT.The
currentpagecouldhavechangedinthemeantime.Learnmore
Tip:Toquicklyfindyoursearchtermonthispage,pressCtrl+ForF(Mac)andusethefindbar.

Textonlyversion

Adask'slaw
TheProfitofInjustice
Home
About
Best
Books
Contact
Demographics
Notice
Radio
Videos
RSS
PreparetoCelebrate!Theresa(Bank)HolidayinyourFuture
WhatIfUSCollapses?SovietCollapseLessonsEveryAmericanNeedsToKnow

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcan
beGranted
21Oct
Foryears,Ivewatchedproseplaintiffafterproseplaintiffhavetheircomplaintsdismissedby
federalcourtsbasedonadefendantspretrial,MotiontoDismissunderFederalRuleofCivilProcedure
12(b)(6)forfailuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbegranted.Althoughthefederalcourts
repeatedlygrantof12(b)(6)MotionstoDismiss,themeaningofthephrasefailuretostateaclaimfor
whichreliefcanbegrantedhasremainedalmostasobscureasthatofamagicalincantation(abra
cadabra!).Everyonehasheardthewordsbutnooneseemstounderstandwhattheyreallymean.
Overtheyears,Ivespeculatedonseveralpossibleexplanationsforwhatfailuretostateaclaim
forwhichreliefcanbegrantedmighttrulymean.Whatfollowsareseveralcaseexcerptsplusmoreof
mybracketedspeculation.Thisspeculationissomewhatstreamofconsciousnessbutnevertheless
expressesmytheorydejureastowhatthatmysteriousphrasemightreallymean.Icantsaythis
currentspeculationistrue,butitsprobablymybesttodate.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbeg

1/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

Thegeneralruleinappraisingthesufficiencyofacomplaintforfailuretostateaclaimisthata
complaintshouldnotbedismissed***unlessitappearsbeyonddoubtthattheplaintiffcanprove
nosetoffactsinsupportofhisclaimwhichwouldentitlehimtorelief.CONLEYVS.GIBSON
(1957),355U.S.41,45,46,78S.Ct.99,102,2LEd2d80SEYMOURVS.UNIONNEWS
COMPANY,7Cir.,1954,217F.2d168andseerule54c,demandforjudgment,FEDERALRULESOF
CIVILPROCEDURE,28USCA:***everyfinaljudgmentshallgranttherelieftowhichthepartyin
whosefavoritisrenderedisentitled,evenifthepartyhasnotdemandedsuchreliefinhispleadings.
U.S.V.WHITECOUNTYBRIDGECOMMISSION(1960),2FrServ2d107,275F2d529,535
[Theplaintiffmustexpresslyshowhistitletowhateverreliefisrequested.I.e.,the
plaintiffmustshowthatitspossibleforhimtoproveasetoffactsincourt(andprobablytoa
jury)thatproveshehastitletothereliefrequested.
Thereliefmightbeatlaw,butisprobablyequitable.Ifso,theplaintiffmustshowthathe
couldpossiblyproveasetoffactsthatprovedhehadEQUITABLETITLEtotherelief(benefit)
requested.This,inturn,impliesthattheplaintiffmustallege1)factssufficienttoprovethe
existenceofafiduciaryrelationshipbetweenhimselfandthedefendantswhereinheisthe
beneficiaryandthedefendantsarefiduciariesand2)abreachbythedefendantsoftheirfiduciary
obligationsrelativetotheplaintiff.
Theproblemfortheplaintiffisallegingthatgovernmentemployeesowedhimafiduciary
obligation.UndertheConstitutionanddejuregovernment,thegovernmentofficerhasafiduciary
obligationtoeachofthePeople.However,undertheemployeremployeedoctrine,anemployeehas
afiduciaryobligationtotheemployerbutnotthecustomer.Thus,asgovcoemployees(and
onlydefactoofficers),thegovernmentofficialwouldhavenofiduciaryobligationtothe
injuredplaintiffandcouldnotbechargedwithabreachofsuchnonexistentfiduciaryobligation.
Thisimpliesthattheproperdefendantwouldbetheemployerratherthananyofthe
employees.Theemployerwouldpresumablyhavefiduciaryobligations(orperhapsevenan
obligationsatlaw)tothecustomer.
Ofcourse,iftheplaintifftriedtosueagovernmentemployerasdefendantforbreach,that
employerwouldclaimsovereignimmunity.Toprevail,theplaintiffwouldhavetodisprove
thatthegovernmentalemployerwastrulyasovereignentitybyprovingthegovernmental
employerswas1)anindependentcorporationwithitsownEIN2)anindependentadministrative
agencythatworkedforgovernmentbutwasnotpartofgovernment3)conductingitsaffairsin
legaltendersoitcouldnotbeaStateoftheUnion4)actingwithinTheStateratherthanin
thisstate....
Ideallytheplaintiffwouldchargeboth1)thegovernmentalemployerand2)the
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbeg

2/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

governmentalemployees(officials)inmultiplecausesofactionstructuredasdoubleedged
strategieswhereinbothsetsofdefendantscanonlyavoidliabilitybyimplicatingtheother.
I.e.,suethegovernmentalemployerforbreachbasedontheallegationthattheagency
employerhadafiduciaryobligationtothecustomer(plaintiff).Buteventhismightbeastretch
ifthegovernmentemployerwasanindependentadministrativeagencythatwashired(employed)
bywhateverpassesforgovernment.Iftheindependentadministrativeagencyisnotpartof
government,butmerelyanemployee,thentheagencyowesitsfiduciarydutytoitsemployer
thegovernmentratherthantothecustomer.Evenso,acauseofactionagainsttheindependent
agencyemployermustbedevisedforthepurposeofinvitingthatemployertoclaim
sovereignty.
Then,oncetheemployerclaimssovereignimmunity,itemployeeswouldbedeemedtobe
officerswithfiduciaryobligationstothePeopleratherthanemployeeswithfiduciaryobligations
onlytotheemployer.
Also,theemployeescanbechargedwithbreachoffiduciaryobligationsbasedontheir
OATHSOFOFFICE.
Butitsimportanttorecognizethechainofemploymentlinksthatcause1)theofficials
tohavefiduciaryobligationstotheiremployer(ratherthanthecustomerplaintiff),and2)that
employer(ifanindependentadministrativeagency)tohavefiduciaryobligationsonlytowhatever
governmentalentityhiredit(ratherthantothecustomerplaintiff).Theremightevenbeathird
employmentlinkiftheentitythathiredtheindependentadministrativeagencywasitselfan
employeeofTheStateorofthisstate.
However,themoneyissueshouldbeusefultoprovethatthevariesemployerscannot
claimsovereignimmunity.Insofarasanyoftheemployees,officialsandemployersaretransacting
inlegaltender,theycantbeorrepresentaStateoftheUnionandthereforecantclaimsovereign
immunityprovidedthattheplaintiffcustomershowthatallactivitiestookplacewithinThe
State.Iftheplaintiffadmithewasvoluntarilyactinginthisstate,hesprobablywaivedany
complaintbasedonfiduciaryobligationsoftheemployeesand/oremployers.
Thisisacomplexandsubtleprocessthatmightbeimplementedsomewhatasfollows:
First,allegethatyouareaman.
Second,allegethatallacts(andespeciallyinjuries)tookplaceonthesoilwithintheactual
boundariesofTheState.
Third,chargetheperpetrators(employees)asofficersundertheConstitutionforbreach
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbeg

3/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

oftheirfiduciaryobligationstothePeople.Iftheyclaimsovereignimmunity,defeatthatclaim
withthemoneyissue(orothers)anddemandadefaultjudgment.
Fourth,chargetheperpetrators(employees)asemployeeswhoneverthelesshave
fiduciaryobligationstothePeoplebasedontheirOathsofOffice.
Fifth,chargetheperpetrators(employees)withfraudformasqueradingasiftheywere
officersofTheStateandthereforeonlyapretenseofauthoritywhentheykneworshouldve
knownthattheyhadnoauthority(thisdependsontheplaintiffhavingchallengedtheirauthority
fromthebeginningandprecludingthedefactoofficerdoctrineimmunity.
Sixth,chargetheemployerforbreachoffiduciaryobligationstotheplaintiffunderthe
Constitution.
Seventh,chargetheemployerforbreachoffiduciaryobligationsundertheEMPLOYERS
CHARTER!DEMANDTHEYPRODUCEthecorporatecharter!Iftheyhavenocorporate
charter,theymustbeeither1)governmentor2)fraudulent.Iftheyaregovernment,theyhave
fiduciaryobligationstothePeople.Iftheyarefraudulent,theyaresubjecttocriminalprosecution,
RICO,etc.
Eighth,goaftertheattorneysallegedlyrepresentingtheindependentagency(employer)
underaRule12(?)challengewhich(accordingtoFox)requiresthemtohavethelawwiththem
whentheyappearatcourt.Thelawisthecorporatecharter.Iftheydontproducethecorporate
charter,theneithertheagencyisnotindependentanddoeshavefiduciaryobligationsunderthe
Constitution,ortheagencyand/orattorneyisengagedfraudulentmisrepresentation.
Etc.
(Gottocreateadoubleedgedstrategywiththeobjectiveofmakingthemadmit,heads,
theyhaveafiduciaryobligationasofficerstotheplaintiffor,tails,theemployerhasafiduciary
obligationtotheplaintiff.)
Tobeatthe12(b)(6)motion,plaintiffmustshowfactsthatwouldprovehistitletothe
(equitable?)reliefagainstthedefendantfiduciaries.
Butthereisoneotherpoint:Ifthe12(b)(6)isallaboutequitablerelief,whathappensifthe
plaintiffnotonlymakesaclaimunderequity,butalsoallegesalegalorperfecttitleATLAW?
Maybetheycandismissyourequitableclaimnomatterwhatyousay.Butifyoucancreateaclaim
ATCOMMONLAWorperhapsINADMIRALTY,can12(b)(6)evenbeconsidered?
Thatsaverygoodpoint.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbeg

4/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

Createclaimsbothinequity(inthisstate?)andATLAW(withinTheState?)
Thepreviouscourtsdecisionallegesthattheplaintiffcanprovesnosetoffactssufficient
toentitlehim.Thephrasenosetoffactsimpliesthattheremaybeseveralalternativesetsof
factswhichmightbeallegedandpossiblyprovedbytheplaintiff.(Thisiswherethedouble
edgedstrategyapplies.)Plaintiffshouldallegeseveralsetsoffacts(causes?Claims?)under
whichhemightbeentitledtorelief.Thesesetsoffactsshouldbecarefullydevisedsothe
defendantscannotdenyonesetwithoutconfessinganother.]
Acomplaintmaynotbedismissedonmotionifitstatessomesortofclaim,baselessthoughit
mayeventuallyprovetobe,andinartisticallyasthecomplaintmaybedrawn.Therefore,underourrules,
theplaintiffsallegationsthatheissuingincriminallibelshouldnotbeliterallyconstrued.[3]The
complaintishardtounderstandbutthis,withnothingmore,shouldnotbringaboutadismissalofthe
complaint,particularlyisthistruewhereadefendantisnotrepresentedbycounsel,andinviewof
rule8{f}oftherulesofcivilprocedure,28U.S.C.,whichrequiresthatallpleadingsshallbeconstrued
astodosubstantialjusticeBURTVS.CITYOFNEWYORK,2Cir.,(1946)156F.2d791.
Accordingly,thecomplaintwillnotbedismissedforinsufficiency.[4,5]SincetheFederalCourtsare
courtsoflimitedjurisdiction,aplaintiffmustalwaysshowinhiscomplaintthegroundsupon
whichthatjurisdictiondepends.STEINVS.BROTHERHOODOFPAINTERS,DECORATORS,
ANDPAPERHANGERSOFAMERICA,DCCDJ(1950),11F.R.D.153.
[First,thecourtdeclaresthatnotruecomplaintcanbedismissedIFthatcomplaintis
supportedbyavalidCLAIM(toequitableorlegalright?).Thisimpliesthatwemustlearnallof
theelementsrequiredtocreateavalidclaimandproofofTITLEandensurethateachofthose
elementsispresentineachoftheplaintiffsclaims.
Second,theplaintiffspetitionand/orclaimshouldbeexpresslywrittenforthepurposeof
seekingSUBSTANTIALJUSTICE(whateverthatis)ascomparedtowhateveralternativeforms
ofjusticemightexist.IsuspectthatsubstantialjusticemaybeATLAWwhilethealternatives
maybeinequitybutthisrequiresresearch.
Third,plaintiffscomplaint(notclaim)mustshowgroundsforthefederalcourts
jurisdiction.Thisrequirement(referencedinA.D.1950)mightormightnothavebeenimposed
relativetoArticleIIIcourts.(Needsresearch)Asaprecaution,perhapseveryCLAIMshouldalso
includeproofofthefederalcourtsJURISDICTION.Ifthejurisdictionisintheclaim,thenthe
jurisdictionissurelyinthecomplaint...??]
Acomplaintwillnotbedismissedforfailuretostateaclaim,eventhoughinartisticallydrawn
andlackinginallegationsofessentialfacts,itcannotbesaidthatundernocircumstanceswilltheparty
beabletorecover.JOHNEDWARDCROCKARDVS.PUBLISHERS,SATURDAYEVENING
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbeg

5/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

POSTMAGAZINEOFPHILADELPHIA,PA(1956)FrServ29,19F.R.D.511,DCEDPa19(1958)
[First,thereferencetoessentialfactsisambiguousinthatitmightrefertofacts
essentialtotheclaimoritmightrefertofactsessentialtothecomplaint.Thatstwo
differentsetsoffacts.Closereadingsuggeststhatthisreferencetofactsconcernsthose
essentialtotheclaimratherthanthecomplaint.
Clearly,12(b)(6)isallaboutthevalidityoftheclaimratherthanthecomplaint.
Therefore,ifalackofallegationsofessentialfactsinaclaimisinsufficienttocausea
12(b)(6)dismissalaplaintiffscomplaint,thentheissueoffactsessentialtothevalidityofthe
claimisnotcentralto12(b)(6).Thattellsmethataclaimsufficienttoensureacomplaintwillbe
heardmustbebasedontherelevantLAWratherthantheFACTS.
AvalidclaimmustincludereferencetothevalidLAWwhichentitlestheplaintifftoseek
relief.IsthatLAWtheUSC,commonlaw,StateorfederalORGANIClaw,orprivatelaw
undersomeprivatefiduciaryrelationshipbetweenplaintiffanddefendant?
Thevalidclaimmustbebasedonandexpresslyreference(andperhapsevenprove)some
LAWwhichcanbeprovenbyoneormoresetsoffacts.Thissuggeststhatavalidclaimshould
includecertifiedcopiesoftherelevantlawunderwhichtheclaimismade.
More,Iambeginningtosuspectthatthevalidclaimmustbesenttothedefendant
BEFOREalawsuitisfiled.I.e.,firstyoupresentavalidCLAIMtothedefendants(probablyby
meansofcertifiedorregisteredmailforevidence).Yes,yesYES!Illbetthatsit!Illbetwehave
toimplementastandard(administrative?)debtcollectionprocessperhapswiththreeormore
noticesofclaimsenttothedefendants.Illbetthemysteriousclaimthattheplaintiffhas
failedtostateunder12(b)(6)issomesortofcollectionprocessordemandletter(s)thatmustbe
sentbeforethelawsuit.
Theclaimisprobablynotthetextthatsincludedwithinthecomplaint.Theclaimis
probablyaseriesofnoticesand/ordemandssenttothedefendantswhichinformthedefendantsof
thelawandfactualbasisoftheclaim.Theclaimisnotthetext,itstheEXHIBITSoftheseveral
Noticesand/orDemandsthatconstitutecollectivelyavalidclaim.
Theprosesjustsuepeoplewithoutevermakingaproperclaimpriortothelawsuit.Ill
betthatswhytheprosesuitsareroutinelydismissedon12(b)(6).Itsnotaboutthequalityofthe
claimwithinthebodyofthecomplaint.Itsaboutthetotalityoftheclaimprocess
implementedbeforethesuitisfiled.
First,theplaintiffmustpresenthisclaimstothedefendants.Then,afterthetotalclaim
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbeg

6/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

processhasbeenimplementedbytheplaintiffandrejectedbythedefendants,THENtheplaintiff
willhavestatedaclaimforwhichreliefcanbegranted.
Thedeceptionisinthetermaclaimasinfailuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe
granted.Ireadtheindefiniteadjectiveatoimplytheexistenceofasingleclaim.Likewise,I
readthewordclaimtobesingular.Ihavepresumedthissingularclaimmustbetheclaim
assertedinthetextofthecomplaint.Maybethatpresumptionisfalse.Maybeaclaimisnota
singularclaim,butratherthesingularresultofhavingproperlytakenalloftheseveralsteps
requiredtomakeacompleteadministrativeclaims.
Thewhole12(b)(6)processmightsimplybeavariationonfailuretoexhaustyour
administrativeremedies.IllbetIdonthaveavalidclaimtotaketocourtuntilIvefirstgiven
thedefendantsseveralnoticesofclaimthatconformtotheDebtCollectionProcesslaws.
IgivethemNoticeofmyclaimandtherebycreatetheiropportunityfordiscovery(inquiry).
Theygettoaskquestions.IftheydoanythingotherthanASKQUESTIONS,theyarepresumedto
haveadequateNoticeandthenIcantakethemtothehearing.Icanttakethedefendantsto
court(thehearing)untilIvefirststated(givennoticeof)theclaimtothedefendants.
The12(b)(6)motionfordismissalmaybeafunctionoftherulesofproceduraldueprocess
theminimumdueprocessaffordedtoall:1)Noticeand2)Opportunitytobeheard(courtroom
hearing).IllbetthatstatingaclaimissynonymouswithgivingthemsufficientNOTICE.Icant
takethemtocourtuntiltheyvehadadequateNotice.Failuretostateaclaimmeansfailureto
giveadequateNoticepriortothehearing.
Imabout90%certainthatafailuretostateaclaimisultimatelyaboutfailureto
provideadequatenotice(andopportunitytoinquire)ofaclaimtothedefendantsPRIORto
takingthemtocourt.
Ifso,then12(b)(6)failuretostateaclaim(atthefederallevelandsomeequivalentat
yourstatelevel)wouldbethewaytoattackanyINSUFFICIENTNOTICEincludingthosesent
bythegovco.I.e.,ifgovcosentmeanoticeandIrespondedwithproperquestions,andthey
refusedtoanswer,Idhavegroundstomakea12(b)(6)motionforfailuretostateaclaim.
Interesting.Youstarttryingtounderstand12(b)(6)motionsandwindupunderstanding
(maybe)howtoattackgovcoNotices.WithoutsufficientNotice(ofclaim)wecanttakethemto
courtandtheycanttakeustocourt.
IftheessenceofavalidclaimistheLAWratherthantheFACTS,thenthatswhatmustbe
inquiredaboutinresponsetonotice.Thisisconsistentwithcourtdeterminationsthatanadequate
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbeg

7/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

noticeneednotprovideafulllitanyofFACTS.Instead,thesufficientnoticemustonlygive
sufficientinformationtoputtherecipientoninquiry.Ihavepresumed(untilnow)thatthe
properinquirywouldbetodiscoveralloftherelevantormaterialFACTS.Imbeginningto
suspectthatprimaryinquiryisnotaboutFACTS,butabouttheLAWunderlyingtheCLAIM.
Thisconclusionmaybemistakenbut,fornowandforme,itmakesalmostperfectsense.
ThefirstopportunityprovidedbytheNoticeistherecipientsopportunitytoinquireinto
andthendenytheLAWonwhichtheENTITLEMENTtomaketheCLAIMisbased.Inessence
theprimaryquestioninresponsetoaNoticeofClaimisUnderwhatLAWdoyoumakethis
claim?Thesecondquestionwouldprobablybe,Underwhatauthoritydoyoudeemmetobe
subjecttosaidLAW?Third,UnderwhatFACTSdoyoudeemmetosubjecttosaidLAW?
Fourth,InwhatPLACE(TheStateorthisstate)doyoudeemmesubjecttothisLAW?Fifth,If
theallegedLAWisprivateinnature,whatfactsexisttoshowthatIconsentedtobeboundbythis
law?Isthisprivatelawbasedoncontractortrust?Ifso,whereismysignaturevoluntarily
agreeingtobeboundbysuchprivatelaw?Ifthereisnosignature,whatareallthespecific
instancesofmypersonalconductwhichyoubelievegivesrisetoyourTITLEunderPRIVATE
LAWtomakeclaimagainstme?IsthisclaimagainstmealivingmanmadeinGodsimage
andendowedbyhisCreatorwithcertainunalienableRightsandproperlynamedAlfredAdask?
IsthisclaimmadeagainstanentitynamedALFREDADASKwhichmightbeafictionalentity,
personorcapacityotherthanthelivingmannamedAlfredAdask?ArethenamesAlfred
AdaskandALFREDADASKsynonymous?DothenamesAlfredAdaskandALFRED
ADASKbothsignifyamanmadeinGodsimageandendowedbyhisCreatorwithcertain
unalienableRights?IfyourclaimisbasedonPUBLIClaw,doyourepresentthegovernment
TheStateofTexasamemberStateoftheperpetualUnionstyledTheUnitedStatesof
America?IfyourclaimisbasedonPUBLIClaw,areyouanofficerunderTheConstitutionof
TheStateofTexasTheStateofTexasbeingamemberStateoftheperpetualUnionstyled
TheUnitedStatesofAmerica?IfyourclaimisbasedontitleunderPUBLIClawofTheState,
whyisntyourclaimdenominatedinlawfulmoney(goldandsilvercoinasrequiredbyArticle1
Section10Clause1ofTheConstitutionoftheUnitedStatesadoptedonoraboutA.D.1789?
Whatisyourauthoritytomakeaclaimintermsoflegaltenderonthesoilwithintheboundaries
ifTheStateofTexasamemberStateoftheperpetualUnionstyledTheUnitedStatesof
America?
Areyoucognizantofthefactthattheminimumdueprocessavailabletoalldefendantsis
proceduraldueprocess?Areyoucognizantofthefactthatproceduraldueprocessconsists
of1)Noticeand2)Opportunitytobeheard?AreyoucognizantofthefactthatNoticecreatesa
rightandsometimesdutyofinquiryfortheNoticerecipientand/oragentorfiduciaryactingon
behalfoftheNoticerecipient?AreyouawarethattheNoticerecipientsrighttomakeinquiry
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbeg

8/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

entitlestheNoticerecipienttoclaimanswersfromtheNoticeauthor?Areyoucognizantofthe
factthatnoNoticeiscompletesolongasreasonableandrelevantinquirybytheNoticerecipient
remainunanswered?AreyoucognizantofthefactthatwithoutsufficientNotice,plaintiffcannot
lawfullyproceedtoahearing?Areyoucognizantofthefactthatarefusaltofullyanswer
questionsposedbyaNoticerecipientisgroundstohaveacasedismissedforfailuretostateaclaim
forwhichreliefcanbegranted?ADDAUTHORITIES.
Etc.,etc.
FRCP8f:CONSTRUCTIONOFpleadings.Allpleadingsshallbesoconstruedastodo
substantialjustice.DIOGUARDIVS.DURNING,2CIR.,(1944)139F2d774
[Again,theconceptofsubstantialjusticeiscrucial.Whatexactlydoesitmeanorimply?]
Counterclaimswillnotbedismissedforfailuretostateaclaim,eventhoughinartistically
drawnandlackinginallegationsofessentialfacts,itcannotbesaidthatundernocircumstanceswill
thepartybeabletorecover.LYNNVSVALENTINEVS.LEVY,23Fr46,19FDR,DSCDNY(1956)
[Thisimpliesthatwhileanoriginalplaintiffssuitcanbedismissedforfailuretostatea
claim,thatoptiondoesnotexistforacounterclaim.Iftheforegoinganalysisandconclusionsare
roughlycorrect,thenthereisnorequirementtoprovideNOTICEofClaimtothePlaintiffas
prerequisitefortheCOUNTERClaim.Avalidlawsuitfiledbyaplaintiffcreatesopportunityfor
inquiryforboththeplaintiffandthedefendant.Therefore,thereisnoreasonforthedefendantto
createfurtherrightofinquirybyfilinghisNOTICEofClaimas1)thefirststepinproceduraldue
processand2)conditionprerequisiteforproceedingtothehearing.]
JUDICIARYACTOF1789,suitcannotbedismissedbecauseoferrorsinservice

Sharethis:
ClicktoshareonTwitter
Clicktoemailthistoafriend
ShareonFacebook
ClicktoshareonLinkedIn
ClicktoshareonPocket
ClicktoshareonReddit
Clicktoprint
ClicktoshareonGoogle+
ClicktoshareonTumblr
ClicktoshareonPinterest

Related
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbeg

9/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

38Comments
PostedbyAdaskonOctober21,2008inDueProcess,Notice

PreparetoCelebrate!Theresa(Bank)HolidayinyourFuture
WhatIfUSCollapses?SovietCollapseLessonsEveryAmericanNeedsToKnow

38responsestoFRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcan
beGranted

1.
MaxxNY
November17,2008at3:03AM
YupIwasarrestedabout11monthsagofornothavingalicense,Iknewthedaywouldcomeat
somepoint...soiwasalwaysmentallypreparingandscriptinginmyheadforjustthisday.So
whenIdidIboughtDrGravesjurisdictionary.comknowingtheywouldfoistalawyeronme,and
theydid.Therewereabout10hearingsandthenthetrialiftheydidntdismiss
MeJudgewhereistheplaintiff?andsomeguytomyleftintheugliestbrownsuitwithasmug
smirkonhisface,pointedtohimself...
Imotionthecourttoputhimunderoathifheisgoingtotestifyagainstme,iveneverseenthis
manbeforeinmylife...
Whatsyourname?
Silence...
judgewhatshisname?
Silence...
IturnedtotheapparentADAandsaidYouneedtobringmyaccuserbeforemeandthefactsin
evidence...thentheshystermotionedtohavemearrested,inwhichthejudgedeniedhim.
YouseeIfiledtonsofpaperwork,motionsandobjectionsandhopedthatIhadtobethebiggest
painintheass,astheyinvitedmetocourtviahandcuff.THEYprobablyfeltthatIwasntdoing
thepaperworkrightbutmypoetryspoketheTruth.
NowIknewtheywerentlisteningsoIusedpsychologicalwarfare,becauseIwasntgoingaway
andIdontrun,fromanybody...mymotto,
WheninHelldoasthesatanistdo...Istartedshowingupincourtwithupsidedown
pentagramsandanattitudeproblemarmedwiththeTruthandevidenceyoudoNOTneedadrivers
licensea1909letterfromtheNYstateattorneygeneralsofficestatingIdidnotneedalicenseto
operateamotorvehicleinmyprivatecapacity...thejudgesandtheDAsoath,theircontract,
remembernowImLucifer.Funnyhowthingsarewordedbecauseintheiroathissaysto
faithfullydischargetheirdutiesDischargemeanstothrowout,dismissfromobligation,thisis
wheredictionariesareveryhandy,andIcalledthemonthattoo...theircontracttothepublicis
VOID.Sotomakeaverylonginterestingstoryshort,thetrialcame,thelawyerwhoseassIripped
inthecourtroomandletterheviolatedourconfidentialitybytalkingtotheDAWITHOUTMY
PERMISSIONandmymotherandthreatenedmewitharrest,maliciousprosecutionviamy
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

10/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

motherifIdidntshowuptoacourtdatethatIpersonallyadjournedbecauseofothercommitment.
ThejudgetoldthelawyertogetridofthisguyItoldthelawyerthrowitallout,nofines
,surchargessocalledpointsNOTHING...andtheyfinallydid.Imleavingoutdetails.ButIgot
whatIwanted,prettymuchwithabitcapitulation.NowthereasonIsaythisisbecausethereare
manythingsonecandowithouttakingtherevolutiontothenextlevelaccordingtowhatcertain
shortwaveradiohostsstate...andthatisdonotquit,sticktoyourgunsandfightwinorlose.
Alsobringwitnesses.Theycouldntwaittogetmeoutofthatcourtroom,asIwouldstandwhen
theycalledmynameandstate,Fortherecord,Imhereunderthreatduressandcoercionand
whatIwasteachingthepeopleinthecourtroomisyoucanbeverbalandtakeastandandstartto
wakepeopleup...breakthehypnosisofthehocuspocusoftheseboguscourtsifyouarm
yourselfwithknowledgeofyourRights,manifestyourdestinyandmovecosmicwill.ThenI
wouldjustgohomeprayandrepentformysymbolicattemptstoourGoodLord,Jesusformy
poeticlicense:)alongwithagooddoseoftheateranddrama.
WinorloseIwasbeingextremelydisruptivetotheirpsyche.
judgeisthisacourtofrecord?ascourtsofnonrecordhaveNOpowertofineandimprison.
Thereismoreilltellinnextpost...
Reply

Bill
May30,2011at10:33PM
IwouldlovetohavethecopyoftheAGsopinionthatadriverslicenseisnotnecessaryin
NY.
Wouldyoubesokindastoemailittomepleaseorgivemeapropercitationtofindit
somewhere.
Thanks
Bill
Reply

Adask
May31,2011at9:40AM
Thatarticlewaswritten3yearsago.IdontrecallhavinganAGsopinionfromNY.
ButifIdidhavesuchopinion,Ihavesincemovedmydomicileontwooccasions.I
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

11/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

doubtthatIcouldfindthatopinionifyouputaguntomyhead.

Christopher
September30,2012at12:42PM
wouldyoupleaseemailmeacopyofAGsopinionthatdriverslicenseisnot
necessaryinNYplease?oritspropercitationsoIcanfindit?

ida
February16,2012at2:56AM
Thumbsup!Imratherintriguedbyyourcommentaboutacourtofrecordnothavingthe
powertofineorimprison.Doyouhavedocumentationonthat?Iminasimilarlegaltussel
withajudgewhorefusestorecognizeanylawheseemstothinkheisthelaw.Imeveron
thelookoutforammotocrumblehisthrone.Pleaserespondifyoucan.Isurecouldusethe
info.Thankyou.
Reply

EarlatOregon
March25,2014at5:10PM
Ifhesaysheisthelaw,
thenIthinkitisaCourtofEquity.

Christopher
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

12/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

September30,2012at12:35PM
okyouareclearlyright!whatelseandotherdirection?
Reply

2.
MaxxNY
November17,2008at10:01AM
soIhopenottooffend,yetIhopetooffendthosewhoneedtobeoffended...butweareina
spiritualpsychologicalwarEvilshallslaythewickedandthosewhohatetherighteous,willbe
desolatePsalms34:21ThisisRockandRolltomyears.
Reply

3.
AndrewMay
November19,2008at6:45AM
Niceartical,ihavefiledanappealtosecuritiesclassactionproseandhaveadocket#,Imhaving
adifficulttimefindinganappelatebriefwhereoneisactuallyfightingthecompromisedsettlement
madeandorderedwithfinialjudgement.Thecaseinvolvesabiotechcompanymakingnumerous
falseandmisleadingstatementssoimfightingleadcounselandthedefendantstogether.Doyou
haveanybriefslikethisinyourfilethatyoucouldemailmetostudy?Mostbriefsinvolepatents
andthisisnotworkingforme.thanks,andy
Reply

4.
adask
November19,2008at7:20AM
HiAndy,
Yourrequestseemsfairlyexotic.Ihavenothingalongthelinesyouverequested.
Thanksforreadingmyarticle.
Goodluck
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

13/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

Al
Reply

5.
GregoryHeins
November14,2009at5:30PM
Thanks,bookmarkedthisblog.
Reply

6. Pingback:BestAdask'slaw

7.
Jason
August15,2011at3:05AM
Ineedtocontactyou
IamabouttofileasuitagainsttheUSPTOandfoundyourarticleveryinteresting.
Reply

8.
ROBERTMORGAN(@ROBMOR12)
September23,2011at5:42PM
IjustgotwipeoutbytheFederalcourtforacaseagainstahousingauthorityandhudwishihad
sawthisbeforeifilethesuit.Thecourthadproofofmebeenviolatedandtheydismisspursuantto
12(b)(6).nowiknowwhattodonowthatwhybankssendyouthatfirstnoticewhentheygoingto
forecloseonyouthat,stheirClaimsowhentheygotocourtitiseasyforthem.
IfyoudonothavemoneyforattorneyyoudonotgetyourRights,tomeitkinderlikeslaveryitput
youinadifferentclassyougotmoneynoproblem.nomoneynorightsiallwaythoughthatif
someonedidyouwrongshowthecourtproofandthecourtwouldcorrectthisboyiwaswrong
ThisIsworstthantheUSSRovertheirtheydonotbeataroundthebushastheoldsaygoes.
Reply
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

14/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

Adask
September24,2011at5:29AM
Itsnotnecessarilytruethat,havingreadthearticleonFailuretoStateaClaimthatyou
absolutelyknowwhattodonow.WhatyouknowisaTHEORYthatsbeenpresentedon
thisblog.Thattheoryremainstobeproven.More,evenifthetheoryistrue,asinalllegal
conflicts,anythingcanhappen.Youcanbeabsolutelyrightineverythingyoudoandstill
lose.Youcanbeabsolutelywrong,andstillwin.Litigationisalwaysastreetfight.Anyone
canloseatanytime.Anyonecanwin.Youcanneverrelyonanystrategyortheoryto
absolutelyprevailincourt.
Reply

CarolKnapp
November4,2011at10:17PM
HeresMYtheory:
Thejudgeswantfulldiscretiontodeterminewhetheracaseisworthwhileenoughto
wastetheCourtsprecioustimegivingtheplaintifftheirdayincourt.Theproblem
is,toomuchdiscretionencouragesthejudgetoallowhis/herownemotionsto
influencewhathe/shedeemsworthwhile.
FRCP12(b)(6)isintentionallyvague,openendedandimpossibletounderstandso
thatthejudgecanuseitaccordingtohis/herwhimandthesheeple(thecommoners)
aretoostupidtoseethroughtheirtricks.

LaTonyaJackson
August27,2013at11:57AM
tisktiskyousaythisasthoughitisasitasandshouldbe,thelawshouldwinnohocus
pocus.Streetfightsshouldbeleftonthestreet,lawneedstobeexercisedandweneed
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

15/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

toforcetheexercisetohappen.Andofcourseyouhavetotallyselfabsorbedjudges
whomakeupunlawfulgameplansasheseesfit,butshouldwealwaysgowiththe
flow?

JamesBedard
October17,2012at10:41PM
Robertsaiditall.Nomoney,nojustice.Thesejudgestwisteverythingyousay.Ivenever
seenanythinglikeit.Whatcantheaveragepersontellingthetruthdo?
Reply

9.
AmosHason
December23,2011at7:15PM
ISEETHATTHEAUTHORSINHEREKNOWSWHATTHEYARETALKINGABOUT!!!
andthereforeIamaskingforhelp.
Ispent17monthsinjailforcriminalthreatsMADEFROMPUBLICPHONESwhichInever
made.
Iimpeachedthewitnessesstupidlyinthecourseoftrial(Idecidedtobecomepropersincemy
publicpretendercouldntstopaskingmewhydidyoudoit?andpushedmetopleabargain)
Igothungjuriesafterthejudgesallmostinstructingthejuriestocomebackandconvictme
(throughmorejudicialmisconductsuchasrefusingtoheara1538.5motiontosuppressandreturn
ofproperty,asuntimelyfiled.thoughthiskindofmotioncanbefiledinthecourseoftrialitself.
andthecommissioneronjudicialperformence(yeahright)foundmycomplaintinsufficiantto
investigate)
thenextstagewastoforcemeintoapleabargainwhichIvehementlydenied!
andinpursuanttothisrefusalthejaildecidedtoputmeinpsychiatricevaluationclaimingthat
Itoldthejailpsychiatrist(whichIhavenevertalkedtobefore)thatIwanttohurtothersand
stopmyvisitsinproperlibrary,duetomytransfertopsychiatricevaluation.
Icalleda13daysofhungerstrikeandmagicallythecourtdismissmycase!
inthesedaysIamtryingtosuetheLAPDandtheLASDandabouttowritemysecondamended
complaintasthemagicallinesof:failiuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbegrantedis
staringinthecourtordertoreamendthecomplaint.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

16/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

itiscleartomethatthiscomplaintistobedissmissed.
Iwasbeatteninjailtwicebysheriffdeputies.Ihaveherniaasresultandmyentireleftsideis
numbtwoyearsaftermyrelease.andIlostallmypropertyandmoneytoasituationwhereIam
homeless
ifanyoneofLosAngelesareacanhelpmeingettinglegalhelpIwouldapreciateitverymuchand
willingtohireoncontingencybasissinceIhavenothingleftafterthisarrestandIamnotableto
workinthesameworkIdidbeforewithmynewphysicalcondition.
ifyouareabletohelppleasecontactmeonabashelor@yahoo.com
thankyou.
Reply

10.
akismet13df16f51b0d7e6b0bfbd685b4815da4
January7,2012at5:49PM
Ibegtodisagree,Thelackofcopyofwrittencontractorsignificantpaperstoprovesetoffacts,
adequatenoticesbeforethecomplaintdoesntprovetheclaim.
Reply

roee
January7,2012at7:17PM
whatareyoutalkingaboutman?
Reply

davidhemsath@gmail.com
June21,2012at1:13AM
Youranswerishedoesntknowwhatheistalkingabout.
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

17/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

11.
roee
June21,2012at6:15PM
yeap,unfortunatelynoonecanpreventbaboonsassuchfromjumpingforavisitinthesesights.
Reply

12.
Zeke
July12,2012at12:14PM
InUNITEDSTATESexrel.BROOKFIELDCONSTRUCTIONCO.,Inc.,andBaylor
ConstructionCorporation,thecourtsaid,Theofficermaybesuedonlyifheactsinexcessofhis
statutoryauthorityorinviolationoftheConstitutionforthenheceasestorepresentthe
Government.
Reply

13.
STACEYSIMEONHALL
February23,2013at10:48PM
WhatshallldoStaceySimeonHallvsAnnMcCarthy,case#2:2012cv12064,federalcourt
Detroit,JudgeZatkoff.
Reply

Adask
February24,2013at1:59AM
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

18/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

Ihavenoidea.Icanttellfromjustthestyleofacase,andImansweringcommentsonmy
blogat11PM(mytime)onSaturdaynight.ThatshouldtellyouthatImalreadyworking
morehoursthanIcanstand.Ofcourse,ImnotalicensedattorneyandIcantgivelegal
advice.ButevenifIcould,Idonthaveanycookiecuttersolutions.Idhavetoreadmost,
maybeallofyourcasefilebeforeIcouldevendreamofofferinganopiniononwhatyou
shouldorshouldntdo.Illbetreadingtheentirecasefilewouldbeachoreand,likeIsaid,
Imalreadyoverworked.Goodlucktoyou.
Reply

JamesBedard
February24,2013at1:50PM
IhavealreadyfiledmycasewiththeU.S.SupremeCourtanditwasputonthe
docketonFeb11,2013.SoIhopetogettheanswerstoallthosequestions.

Amos
February27,2013at1:32PM
GOODLUCK!
Reply

JamesBedard
February27,2013at7:51PM
Letmeknow,Iwouldbegladtohelpyou.Imighthavetotalktoyouaboutyourcase.
IhaveansweredallthoseissuesinmywrittotheU.S.SupremeCourt.Thatiswhere
youwillprobablyendupandfilingthereisvery,verydifferent.

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

19/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

14.
Twill
September9,2013at2:41PM
Aclaimonwhichreliefcanbegrantedjustmeansthatyouhaveallegedalltheelementsofthe
particularclaim,againstaproperparty,andyouareaproperpartyyourselfforthatkindofclaim.
Ifitsaviolationoflawtotakecandyfromachild,andthechildisentitledbystatutetodoublethe
candyinrecompense,plusanyincidentalexpenses,thencomparethesetwo:
BillywasmeantomeandImacitizenofTexasbutnottheUSandhetookmylollipopandhes
abuttheadandgiveme12centsbecausetheguyontheInternetsaysBillyowesdouble.
Iamachild.Iboughtalollipopfor5cents.Billystolemylollipop.Ihadtherighttoenjoymy
lollipop.Billyhadnorighttotakethelollipop.Ihavebeenharmedintheamountof5centsforthe
lollipop,plus1centIhadtopaymybrothertogetareplacementlollipopbecauseIwas
babysitting.IamentitledbytheTexasChildCandyActtodoublemycostofcandyplus
consequentialdamages.PleaseorderBillytogivemetwolollipopsplus1cent,or11cents.
Reply

Adask
September9,2013at8:04PM
WereyouamemberoftheChordettesbackinthe1950s?
Reply

15.
MagnusRegnant
September20,2013at2:18PM
Hasanyonebeenprovidedacopyofthethis:1909letterfromtheNYstateattorneygeneralsoffice
statingIdidnotneedalicensetooperateamotorvehicleinmyprivatecapacityandifso,could
thisbeeMailtome?
Reply
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

20/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

16.
DouglasKimzey
December13,2013at8:48PM
13Dec2013SanFrancisco/Seattle
Kimzeyv.YelpInc.
Case#2:1301734RAJ
DateofresponseduebyYelpInc.13Dec.2013
Kimzey(ProSe)
RequestforlegalrepresentationbyAdask
Reply

Adask
December14,2013at4:10AM
Imnotalicensedattorneyandprobablycantrepresentanyoneinanycurrentcourt.
However,after12yearsofeditingandpublishingamagazine,Iamahalfwaydecenteditor
andIoccasionallyprovideeditingservicesforotherpeopleslegaldocuments.Ifyouwere
interestedineditingservices,youcouldreachmebyemailatalfredadask@yahoo.com.
Reply

17.
AnotherProSeLitigant
February25,2014at8:21PM
Failuretostateaclaimisacommontacticemployedfortheothersidetodismissyourclaim(s)on
summaryjudgment.Youcanavoiditbyknowingwhatyoucanandcannotrecoverdamagesfor,
understandingproperpleading,learningrelevantcaselaw,andbyarguinginlegalfiction.
Reliefcanmeanmonetarydamagesorinjunctiverelief.Youcanclaimanythinginalawsuitbut
theremustbeacommonlaworstatuteunderwhichyoucanbegrantedsometypeofcivilremedy.
Ifthereisntthenyourclaimwillbedismissed.Knowyourlocalcourtrulesandnotjustthefederal
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

21/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

ones.Ajudgealsohasdiscretionaryreviewattheinitialhearingtoallowyourcasetoproceed
basedontheinitialmerits.
Beawareofandanticipatealltacticsallowablebylawtodismissonsummaryandbepreparedto
fendthemoffwithSupremeCourtdecisionsmadeinyourstateregardingsimilarclaims.Never
relytooheavilyonstatutes.Justbecauseitsonthebooksdoesntmeanitsstillenforced.
Reply

18.
VincentCataldi
March25,2014at2:20PM
RebloggedthisonVincentJCataldi.
Reply

19.
Mel
June16,2014at11:26AM
Youvedefinitelygivenmeastrategyandabestpracticeplan.IamfilingafederalLawsuit
againstAmericanGirlDollsandMattelToysforcopyrightinfringement.Ivesentthemlettersand
acease&desistImgoingtomakesureIstatethelaw,approachthisfromseverallegal
aspects,andtryasbestIcantocovermybasesanddottheisandcrossthetsthisisan
incredibleamountofworktodotoprovesomeonehasstolensomethingfromyouandtomeit
becomesatheftwhentheydenyinfringement.Theyhave25sameandsimilarnamesasinmy
bookandwellover100plots,scenes,dialogue,etc.Andwespeakingofchildrensbooksthatare
about70pagesinchildsizedfontIhaveaCecileHonore,theyhaveCecileReyIhavea
searchforahiddennecklaceinNewOrleansinthe1800stheyhaveasearchforalostnecklacein
NewOrleansinthe1800s.SomuchmoretoitThanksforyoursite/blogthisfailuretomake
aclaimthingisreallytough.
Reply

Adask
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

22/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

June16,2014at11:53AM
HiMelva,
Iskimmedoverthefirsteightpagesofthetextyousentmebyemail.Icanseethattheres
anenormousfinancialpotentialinyourallegationsmillionsofdollars.Thatfinancial
potentialjustifiestheworkyouveputintoyourcomplaintandwillalsojustifyanextensive,
aggressiveandexpensivedefensefromyouropponents.
Youllbefightingthebigbattalionsinalawsuitthatmayrequireyearsoflitigationbefore
itisconcluded.
Asyoumustsurelyrealize,youllneedsubstantiallegalandemotionalresourcestowage
thisbattle.
AsIsaid,Ihaventreadyouentiredocument,soperhapsyouvealreadythoughtofthe
followingideaandincorporateditintoyourcomplaint:Haveyoulookedforevidenceof
otherinstancesofsimilarclaimsofcopyrightviolationsfiledbyotherauthors?Itappearsto
methatiftheresalegitimatecopyrightviolationofyourbook(s),thatviolationwas
concealedwithafairlystandardsetoftrickswherebynamesarechanged,plotsandother
detailsarealsosubtlychangedsoastocreatesomeplausibledeniabilitytoanypotential
chargesofcopyrightviolation.
Plagiarism(especiallyforsignificantpay)mustbeaskillsetthatislearnedandwhichrelies
onafairlyfixedformula.Iftheauthor(notjustMattel)oftheoffendingworkhas
plagiarizedoneofyourbooksusingthesetricks,heorshehasprobablyalsoplagiarized
severalotherbooksusingavirtuallyidenticalseriesoftricks.Ifyoucould:1)identifythe
actualauthor(notjustapseudonym)ofthebookthatplagiarizedyourwork(orperhaps
hisagent)2)thoroughlyinvestigateanyandallotherbookswrittenbythisauthorevenif
publishedunderotherpseudonymsand,3)ifyoucouldfindevenoneotherbookthat
appearedtohavebeenplagiarizedbythesameauthor,youdhaveevidenceofapattern
ofcopyrightviolations.
Arguingthatoneofyourbookshasbeenplagiarizedwillbehardtoprove.Butifyoureable
tofindevidencethatyourbooksandotherauthorsbookshavebeenplagiarizedbythesame
authorinapatternofsimilarconduct,yourallegationswouldbefarmorepowerful,likely
tosucceedandperhapsevencauseyourdefendantstoofferanacceptableoutofcourt
settlement.
Ifyouvealreadythoughtofthispossiblestrategy,Iapologizeforwastingyourtime.Ifyou
haventyetthoughtofit,itssomethingyoumaywanttoconsider.Thisstrategywould
dependonpreciselyidentifyingtheactualauthor(oragent)whoplagiarizedyourbookand
thenconductingaverythoroughinvestigationofthatparticularauthortoseeifhedalso
plagiarizedotherbooks.
Asyoumayknowfromreadingpartsofmyblog,ImnotalicensedattorneyandIdont
providelegaladvice.ButIamastudentofthelegalsystemandIoffertheoriesthatmayor
maynothavesomepracticalapplication.
IsuggestthatyoutotakeeverythingIvewrittenwithsalt.Ioffertheoriesforpeoples
consideration.Idontadvanceanytheoryasabsolutelytrueforpeoplesautomaticbelief.I
presentmytheoriesonlyasplausibleandpossiblytrueandleaveituptomyreaderstomake
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

23/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

theirowndecisionstoattempttoapplyorrejectthosetheories.
Goodluckwithyourlawsuitand,perhapsmoreimportantly,withyourpreliminary
investigation.
Al
Reply

LeaveaReply
Enteryourcommenthere...

Fillinyourdetailsbeloworclickanicontologin:

Gravatar
Email(required)(Addressnevermadepublic)
Name(required)
Website
WordPress.com
Logo
YouarecommentingusingyourWordPress.comaccount.(LogOut/Change)
Twitter
picture
YouarecommentingusingyourTwitteraccount.(LogOut/Change)
Facebook
photo
YouarecommentingusingyourFacebookaccount.(LogOut/Change)
Google+
photo
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

24/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

YouarecommentingusingyourGoogle+account.(LogOut/Change)
Cancel
Connectingto%s
Notifymeofnewcommentsviaemail.
Notifymeofnewpostsviaemail.
PostComment

Search
Search
FollowBlogviaEmail
Enteryouremailaddresstofollowthisblogandreceivenotificationsofnewpostsbyemail.
Enteryouremailaddress
Follow

Categories
"ManorOtherAnimals"
"TheState"vs."thisstate"
"thisstate"vsTheState
10thAmendment
14thAmendment
1stAmendment
2012Election
2014Election
2016Election
2ndAmendment
3rdParty
501(c)3Churches
60Minutes
911
9thAmendment
Abortion
ActionofAccount
AdministrativeLaw
Admiralty
AffirmativeDefense
Agenda21
AmericanIndependenceHour
AntiShysterNewsMagazines
ApathyIndifference
Argument
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

25/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

ArticlesofConfederation
Attorney
Banking
Bankruptcy
Belief
Bible
BillofRights
Bitcoin
Blacks
Borders&Boundaries
Cancer
Certification
Christendom
Christianity
Citizenship
CivilDisobedience
Cognovit
collective
collectivism
Collectivist
Commerce
CommonLaw
CommunismSocialismCollectivism
confidence
Consent
Conspiracytheories
Constitution
Contracts
Corporations
Courtwatchers
Courts
Creationism
Credit
CurrencyWars
Cyberwarfare
DeathbyGovernment
Debt
Debtcollection
Debtors'Prison
DeclarationofIndependence
DeficitSpending
Definitions
Democide
Democracy
DennisCraig
Depression
Derivatives
Despotism
Digitalcurrency
Disease
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

26/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

Dissidents
DoublePersonallity
Drones
Drugs
DueProcess
Ebola
Ecology
Economiccollapse
Economy
Education
Emergency
EndTimes
Energy
EnvironmentalProtectionAgency
Ethics
EuropeanUnion
Evidence
Evolution
ExchangeStabilizationFund
Extraterritorialjurisdiction
FalseFlag
Fascism
FederalReserve
FiatCurrency
Fictions
Fiduciaryrelationship
Firearms
FlightMH17
Food
Foreclosure
Forefeiture
Fractionalreservebanking
Fraud
FreeMarketManipulation
Frivolous
Fukushima
Fun
Gardening
Gender
Genocide
GeoPolitics
GlobalFreeTrade
GMO
Godgiven
Gold&SilverCoin
Good&Evil
Governmentabsurdity
GovernmentasCorporateConglomerate
GovernmentasGangsters
GovernmentBankruptcy
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

27/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

Greece
HealthCare
HilaryForPresident
HipShots
HomelandSecurity
Homosexuality
Humor
Hunger
Hyperinflation
Identification
IllegalAliens
InPersonamJurisdiction
Incomeinequality
IncomeTax
Independence
Indictment
Inflation/Deflation
InterestRates
InternationalLaw
Internet
Investment
Iran
IRS
Israel
Jurisdiction
Land
LawvsEquity
Legal&EquitableTitles
Legalfictions
Lies
Limitedgovernment
Links
ManipulatedMarkets
MaritimeAdmiralty
MarkoftheBeast
MarketPanics
MartialLaw
Military
Money
MoneySupply
MoralHazard
Morality
Music
Muslims
Names
NationavsEconomy
NationalPolitics
NaturalLaw
Nature
Neoconservatives
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

28/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

NewWorldOrderOneWoldGovernment
NorthAmericanUnion
Notice
NuclearPower
Nutrition
Oath
Obama
Oil
OrganicLaw
Patriot
Pensions
People
Person
Petrodollars
plane
Pledges
Plutocrats
PoliceAbuse
PoliceState
Political
PoliticalAction
PoliticalCampaignContributions
PoliticalChoice
PoliticalFreeSpeech
Population
Poverty
Prepper
Presumptions
Privacy
PrivateLaw
Promises
Propaganda
psychologicalwarfare
Publicrage
Publicschools
Questions
Race
Radio
RealPartyInInterest
relationship
RepublicanFormofGovernment
Resistance
RICO
Rights
Robots
Russia
Savings
Science
Secrecy
Securities&ExchangeCommission
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

29/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

Sheriff
ShortSelling
Signature
Slavery&bondage
SocialSecurity
Sovereignty
SpecialInterestLegislation
Speculation
Spies
SpiritualWar
spiritualwarfare
States'Rights
Stats
stocks
Strawman
Strawman&LegalEntities
Subsidies
SummaryJudgment
Summons
Surety
Surveillance
Tariffs
Technology
Territory
Terrorism
TheOrganicLawofTheUnitedStatesofAmerica
TheUnitedStatesofAmerica
Title
TrafficLaw
Transcripts
Treason
Trusts
Tyranny
U.S.vsTheU.S.A.
UCC
UFOs
Ukraine
UnalienableRights
Uncategorized
UnitedStates
Uppercasename
USDollar
USvsUSA
USPS
Values
Venue
Video
War
WealthInequality
Welfare
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

30/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

WhatCan'tbePaid
WorldReserveCurrency
ZipCode
Archives
April2015
March2015
February2015
January2015
December2014
November2014
October2014
September2014
August2014
July2014
June2014
May2014
April2014
March2014
February2014
January2014
December2013
November2013
October2013
September2013
August2013
July2013
June2013
May2013
April2013
March2013
February2013
January2013
December2012
November2012
October2012
September2012
August2012
July2012
June2012
May2012
April2012
March2012
February2012
January2012
December2011
November2011
October2011
September2011
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

31/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

August2011
July2011
June2011
May2011
April2011
March2011
February2011
January2011
December2010
November2010
October2010
September2010
August2010
July2010
June2010
May2010
April2010
March2010
February2010
January2010
December2009
November2009
October2009
September2009
August2009
July2009
June2009
May2009
April2009
March2009
February2009
January2009
December2008
November2008
October2008
September2008
August2008
July2008
June2008
May2008
Pages
About
Best
Books
Contact
Demographics
Notice
Radio
http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

32/33

4/27/2015

FRCP12(b)(6)FailuretoStateaClaimforwhichReliefcanbeGranted|Adask'slaw

Videos

CreateafreewebsiteorblogatWordPress.com.TheChocoTheme.
Entries(RSS)andComments(RSS)
Follow

FollowAdask'slaw
GeteverynewpostdeliveredtoyourInbox.
Join1,085otherfollowers
Enteryouremailaddress
Signmeup

BuildawebsitewithWordPress.com

http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:https://adask.wordpress.com/2008/10/21/frcp12b6failuretostateaclaimforwhichreliefcanbe

33/33