4 views

Uploaded by 6doit

- Econometrics Project
- dougherty study guide.pdf
- Bank_Governance_Effectiveness_Anwar_Deepty_BD
- DATA final ARIMA.xlsx
- Growth and Poverty Reduction in Nigeria
- Trade Liberalisation 16-05-08
- 20110715123735-INFRASTRUCTURAL-MANAGEMENT-2011-2012
- Dependent Variable
- free to threes
- Modeling and forecasting realized volatility getting the most out.pdf
- ch04[1]managerialeconomic
- Assignment 1Q
- A Holistic Approach for Determining the Characteristic Flow on Kangsabati Catchment
- Practical Examples using Eviews.pptx
- Annotated SPSS Output
- Prem Kanth
- Analyze Experiment
- EViewsGuide.pdf
- SAS MP
- 10.1.1.462.5462

You are on page 1of 7

Eunice Han

ehan@fas.harvard.edu

September 30th, 2010

Yi 0 1 X 1i 2 X 2i u i

To allow the effect of X1i on Yi to depend on X2i, we can include the interaction term

X1i* X2i as a regressor.

Yi 0 1 X 1i 2 X 2i 3 ( X 1i * X 2i ) u i

Q1. Show that

Y

X 2i

depends on X1

=

Y

2 3 X 1i

X 2i

Q2. Plot the regression line of Y and X2, when X1 = a and X1 = b, where a<b. Assume that

all the coefficients are positive.

When X1 = a, the regression line is

When X1 = b, the regression line is

Yi 0 1 a ( 2 a 3 ) X 2i

Yi 0 1b ( 2 b 3 ) X 2i

Q3. Let's assume that Y is wage variable and X1i is a binary variable which is 1 if

observation is black and 0 otherwise. X2i is tenure. We want to test whether the effect of

1

tenure on wage of black people is different from that of non-black people. How do we

test whether the intercept is the same for two groups? How do we test whether the slope

is the same for the two groups?

Wage i 0 b la ck Bl ack i ten u re Tenure i b la ck _ T en u re ( Bl ack i * Tenure i ) ui

To test the slope we should test if

black

ten u b la ck

=0 significant, so there is difference

Research Question: Does increase in fuel price raise the unit cost?

Data Description: Christensen and Greene (1976):

We have production data on 158 electricity generating plants in 1970. The data includes

the prices of inputs (labor, capital, and fuel) used to produce electricity and quantity of

electricity produced and total costs of electricity.

Variable

log_cost: log of total cost

log_unitcost: log of unit cost (unit cost= total cost/output)

log_output: log of total output of electricity, GWH

log_wage: log of wage rate

log_capital: log of capital price index

log_fuel: log of fuel price

Descriptive Statistics

Interpret the slope coefficient in the following regressions.

Q1. Unit cost=2.152 + 0.132 *(Fuel Price)

R2 = 0.06, N=158

$1 increase in fuel price is expected to increase the unit cost of electricity by $0.132.

Q2. Unit cost=-7.081 + 3.916*Log(Fuel Price)

R2 = 0:06;N=158

1% increase in fuel price is expected to increase the unit cost of electricity by $0.039.

Q3. Log(Unit cost)=0.926 + 0.026*(Fuel Price)

R2 = 0:24;N=158

$1 increase in fuel price is expected to increase the unit cost of electricity by 2.6%.

Q4. Log(Unit cost)=-0.902 + 0.771*Log(Fuel Price)

R2 = 0:25;N=158

1% increase in fuel price is expected to increase the unit cost of electricity by 0.77%.

* Scatterplot of unitcost vs. fuelprice

Q. Using the two scatterplots would you suggest using (1) unitcost and fuelprice or (2)

log_unitcost and log_fuel for modeling linear regression?

The relationship between unitcost-fuelprice looks nonlinear and the fitted regression line

doesnt seem to represent their relationship well. Taking logs of both variables make the

relation look much more like a scatter with a linear relation.

The first 4 specifications have different functional forms of the control variable Output.

The specification 5 has an interaction term between output and fuel price.

Q2.Using regression (2), estimate the effect on log(unit cost) of changing from

log(output)=1.5 to log(output)=2, holding constant the values of the other regressors in

regression (2).

log(unit cost)=[-0.597*2+0.03*22]-[-0.597*1.5+0.03*1.52]= -0.246.

Q3. Assume that you want to test linear vs. quadratic specification in log(output). How

would you perform the test? What is the result of the test?

We will use model (2) to test the null hypothesis:

H0 :

and H1 :

l ogout put 2 0

l ogout put 2 0

To perform the test, just look at the coefficient of (log_output2) in specification (2). If the

value is significantly different from 0(|t-statistic|>1.96), we can reject the null hypothesis.

Since it is significant at 5%, we reject the null of linear model in favor of quadratic model

specification.

Q4. For now, we consider the specification (2). Could you interpret the coefficients on

log_output and on log_output2? Could you describe the characteristics of the dependence

of log(unit cost) on log(output)?

We CANNOT interpret the coefficients on log_output and log_output2 separately

because it is not possible to change log_output keeping log_output2 constant. We can,

however, say something about the relationship between log(unit cost) and log(output) by

looking at the coefficients on log_output and log_output2. Since the coefficient on

log_output is negative (-0.597) and on log_output2 is positive (0.030), we know that if

we plot log_output on the x-axis and log(unit cost) on the y-axis, we would get a parabola

like this:

Q5. Test the hypothesis that the dependence of log(unit cost) on log(output) is quadratic

vs. cubic model.

We will use regression (3) to test the following hypothesis:

H0 :

and H1 :

l ogout put 3 0

l og out put 3 0

To perform this test, just look at the coefficient of log_output3 in regression (3). Since the

coefficient is not significantly different from 0 at 5% significance level, we cannot reject

the null of quadratic model in favor of the cubic model.

Q6. Test the hypothesis that the dependence of log(unit cost) on log(output) is linear vs.

cubic.

We will use regression(3) to test the null hypothesis:

H0 :

l ogout put2 l ogout put3 0

H1 : at least one of them is not zero

To test null hypothesis, we use the F-test since we are testing more than one hypothesis

simultaneously. The reported F-statistic is 70.2 and the p-value is less than 0.001. So we

reject the null of linear model.

Q7. Considering all the previous question, what specification among (1)-(3) would you

choose and why?

I would choose specification (2). We reject the linear model in (2), so (1) is inferior to

(2). We reject cubic model in (3) in favor of quadratic, so (3) is inferior to (2). (2) wins.

Q8. Compare specification (2) and (4). Do you think there is OVB in the coefficient of

log(fuel price) in specification (4)?

Yes. The coefficient of log(fuel price) in (4) suffers from OVB. To see this we should

check whether omitted variables (log_wage and log_capital) satisfies following two

conditions:

(1) log(wage) and log(capital price) are determinants of log(unitcost)

(2) log(fuel) are correlated with these omitted variables log(wage) and log(capital price)

We already know from regression (2), that log(wage) and log(capital price) are important

determinants of log(unit cost). Log(capital price) is significant at 1%, log(wage) is

significant at 10%. To check the second condition, we can find the correlation between

the variables, or we can run the following regression.

Since both log(wage) and log(capital) are important factors explaining log(fuel price)

looking at F-test and R-squared, we conclude that both conditions are satisfied.

Q9. What specification among (1)-(4) is the best in your opinion?

We know that (2) is better than (1) and (3). So we only need to compare specification (2)

and (4). Even though R-squared and Adjusted R-squared is almost same, its better to

include log(wage) and log(capital price) as control variables since they are correlated

with log(fuel price). Therefore, model (2) wins!

Q10. Do the firm with higher output and the firm with lower output have the same

increase in unit cost from a unit increase of fuel price, holding wage and capital price

constant?

No. In (5), interaction term between output and fuel price is positive and statistically

significant. So the regression line for the firm with higher output have different intercepts

and slopes (steeper slope) from those with lower output.

- Econometrics ProjectUploaded byCarlos Ferreira
- dougherty study guide.pdfUploaded bykthesmart4
- Bank_Governance_Effectiveness_Anwar_Deepty_BDUploaded byMehedi Hasan
- DATA final ARIMA.xlsxUploaded byMelissa Palma Portugal
- Growth and Poverty Reduction in NigeriaUploaded byFeji Odibo
- Trade Liberalisation 16-05-08Uploaded byKaif Gee
- 20110715123735-INFRASTRUCTURAL-MANAGEMENT-2011-2012Uploaded byPuneet Sood
- Dependent VariableUploaded byRadith Shakinda
- free to threesUploaded byapi-408200501
- Modeling and forecasting realized volatility getting the most out.pdfUploaded byTricia Thaíse
- ch04[1]managerialeconomicUploaded byArif Darmawan
- Assignment 1QUploaded byRemo isaac
- A Holistic Approach for Determining the Characteristic Flow on Kangsabati CatchmentUploaded byInternational Journal of computational Engineering research (IJCER)
- Practical Examples using Eviews.pptxUploaded byNadeem Mumtaz Ghumro
- Annotated SPSS OutputUploaded bydkduong
- Prem KanthUploaded byazzam_ali
- Analyze ExperimentUploaded byJuan Gonzalez
- EViewsGuide.pdfUploaded byRashidAli
- SAS MPUploaded byMuhammad Rizki Mujiono
- 10.1.1.462.5462Uploaded byWaqas Ayub
- karmadadoushlinearregressionprojectUploaded byapi-358666256
- Chapter 9Uploaded byjaved765
- 1-s2.0-S2211812814005185-mainUploaded bySai Srinivas
- 38-73-1-SMUploaded byMinhaz Kamal
- Precipitation Data AnalysisUploaded byKent Xyrell Mendoza
- Impacts of the Trilemma Policies on Inflation, Growth and Volatility in GreeceUploaded byAkash Bhatia
- 2004_05_dummyUploaded bykishlay88
- eijcse3065Uploaded byBatepola Arach
- Behavioral Statistics in ActionUploaded byARPITA DUTTA
- General EducationUploaded byLauren

- Statistical Physics of Spin Glasses and Information Processing an Introduction - Nishimori H.Uploaded bynadx123
- talk_cma.pdfUploaded by6doit
- thesis.pdfUploaded by6doit
- feierUploaded by6doit
- Tuck Scool of Business Case TipsUploaded byRajat Mishra
- 1403.5179.pdfUploaded by6doit
- 1610.08104.pdfUploaded by6doit
- file.pdfUploaded by6doit
- papkre09Uploaded by6doit
- 0505032Uploaded by6doit
- wu1Uploaded by6doit
- 0812.3378.pdfUploaded by6doit
- Liu_columbia_0054D_10924.pdfUploaded by6doit
- syllabusUploaded by6doit
- BEP_finalUploaded by6doit
- IBIG 02 01 Walk Through Resume GuideUploaded bySuhas
- 48-162-1-PB.pdfUploaded by6doit
- API 111 Solutions 7.docUploaded by6doit
- Solutions to practice questions.pdfUploaded by6doit
- Midterm Answers Fall 2013.pdfUploaded by6doit
- FileUploaded by6doit
- 289922981-problem-set-7-solution-pdf.pdfUploaded by6doit
- final2012.pdfUploaded by6doit
- Fin2013.pdfUploaded by6doit
- Midterm12ans.pdfUploaded by6doit
- Fin2012.pdfUploaded by6doit
- Midterm13.pdfUploaded by6doit
- Midterm12014.pdfUploaded by6doit
- final2011answers.pdfUploaded by6doit
- midtermtwo15.pdfUploaded by6doit

- The Role Law Plays in Modern SocietyUploaded bySana
- Bridge Engineering Handbook, FundamentalsUploaded byMuhammad Zeeshan
- 2011.11.08 - Diaphragm Considerations for Structural EngineersUploaded byUALU333
- BCM 503BUILDING SERVICES ENGINEERING IUploaded byMohd Azmil Mohd Rohani
- Competency Demonstration Report,ReviewMyCDRUploaded byMark Peter
- Poster PrzntationUploaded bySakshiKoul
- IJE-324Uploaded byPayalSi
- Biometric ArchitectureUploaded byMahaManthra
- Meteor Burst Communications- article on commercial history, developments, key international projects- Don Sytsma interviewUploaded bySkybridge Spectrum Foundation
- Shipping ExecutionUploaded byMohamed Salah El Din
- Well Test Desing and AnalysisUploaded byMuhammad Ali Buriro
- AS179-92 LF - RF SwitchUploaded bysam
- String Theory Only Game in Town TestsUploaded bySilvino González Morales
- Complete Denver Zoning CodeUploaded byPatrick Gubitose
- A_242Uploaded byAnuranjan
- Mwd Sonny ClassUploaded byZULFAKHRIBINZAKARIA
- Question Bank Brand ManagementUploaded byAshutosh Sharma
- Internal Combustion EnginesUploaded bySajith Nawarathne
- Improve Energy Efficiency of Electrical System by Energy Audit (Data Logging)Uploaded byIAEME Publication
- Equilibrium PPTUploaded byYusrianah
- auiref5_88Uploaded bydavidsim1990
- Mix DesignUploaded byPankaj Munjal
- Developing Critical and Creative Thinking Through ChessUploaded byChess in Schools and Academic Excellence
- RESERVOIR CHARACTERIZATION AND STRUCTURAL INTERPRETATION OF SEISMIC PROFILE A CASE STUDY OF Z FIELD NIGER DELTA NIGERIA (1).pdfUploaded bySanjeev Singh Negi
- Direct Incorporation CCM MyCoid (1).pdfUploaded bySanjevee Nathan
- PMO Charter Template with ExampleUploaded byMegan Wale
- Catalogo Aisladores MacleanUploaded byDawn Hernandez
- Methodology and the New School of Sanskrit Poetics Tubb and BronnerUploaded bySuhas Mahesh
- Aurora Regenerative Turbine 150 Series BrochureUploaded bythehammer2
- Bhushan Traioning Report 786Uploaded byDeepak Giri