Professional Documents
Culture Documents
192
WOLFFETAL
Table 1
Relationship between knowledge of mental illness and mental handicap and the belief that the mentally ill may be
less intelligent v. Fear and Exclusion (factor 1), Social Control (factor 2) and Goodwill (factor 2)
Social Control
Mean
(s-d.)
Mean
(s.dJ
Goodwill
Mean
(s-d)
0.86
0.08
-0.18
-0.50
< 0.001
(0.96)
(0.66)
(0.71)
(0.61)
-0.05
006
-0.12
0.11
;! NS
(054)
(0.81)
(0.79)
(0.80)
0.11
-0.49
< 0.001
(0.91)
(0.59)
-0.07
0.25
i <0.05
(0.86)
(0.68)
0.73
-0.20
<0.001
(1.09)
(0.74)
-0.08
0.03
NS
(1.02)
(0.77)
193
Table 2
Ability to name at least two mental illnesses v. sociodemographic group, knowing somebody with mental illness and
having suffered from mental illness
Group
Able to name Group
Able to name
rf.P
two mental
two mental
illnesses
illnesses
Non-Caucasians (n=12)
27% 38% 41% Caucasians (n=201) Sodal
71% 72% 71% x^ai.seiid.t^.tO.ool
Sodal dassB-V(/=72)
32% f 52%
class I and II (n=138) A'
65% 70% 64% ]C^23Wd.i:P=<0.00\
O'tevel/betow (n=78)
( 54% 33%
level/above (n=135) Aged
67% 88%
X^I&Bftlcl.t^.cO.OOI
Aged over 50 (n=34)
56%
under 50 (n=T79) Less than
^=12.98;
3reater than 5 years in
5 years in street No children
1d.t;P=<0.001
street Children in
in the household (n=135)
t^m,'\iii;P=<0.<n
household (ff=78) Don't
Know somebody (ff=170)
^ZOOild.tiNS
know anybody (<7=43)
Suffered mental illness
X2=17.03;1d.t;^=<
Table 3
Ability to distinguish between mental illness and mental handicap and give an example of mental handicap v.
sociodemographic group, knowing somebody with mental illness and having suffered from mental illness
Sioup
Able to
Group
Able to
f.P
distinguish
distinguish
'ton-Caucasians (f>=52)
social dass ffl-V (n=72) 0
level/below (n=78)
\gedover50(/7=34) 3reater
than 5 years in street
(n=114) children in
household (/i=78) )on't know
anybody (f=43) tat suffered
12% 8% 9%
6% 19%
19% 14%
24%
^e^id.ti/'^o^
f^WS-.Mt-.f^^.Wn
X2=1R20;1d.t;/^<
0.001 ^=7.66; 1d.t;/'=<
0.01 J^ZWdi.HS
^.Wiil-.HS
^=331;1d.t;NS
/=0.35;1d.t;NS
194
WOLFF ET AL
Table 4
Belief that the mentally ill may be less intelligent v. sociodemographic group, knowing somebody with mental illness
and having suffered from mental illness
Group
% believe the Group
% believe the ^.P
mentally ill
mentally ill
less
less intelligent
intelligent
Non-Caucasians (n=52)
39% 32%
Caucasians (n=162)
12% 11%
X^IReftld.t;^ 0.001
Social class 111-V (n=72)
33% 50%
Sodalclasslandll(/)=139) A
10% 12%
^14.37,-ld.t;^^
0' level/below (n=78) Aged 24% 20%
level/above (n=136) Aged
12% 18%
0.001 ;
over 50 (n=34) Greater
23% 18%
under 50 (n=1SO) Less than 17% 17%
C2=18.80;1d.t;/=<
than 5 yeais in street (f?
5 years in street (n=101) No
0.001 ^ZJWiit.f^^.Wn ]
=T13) Children in
children in household (n=137)
^SWiii:P=<0.06
household (n=77) Don't
Know somebody (ff=171)
X^OI^Id.t.-NS
know anybody (n=43) Not
Suffered mental illness (n=24)
X^O.^Id.t.NS ^O.OZsuffered mental illness
ld.tiNS
195
WOLFF ET AL
196
Limitations
Our population is not representative of the general
population, therefore any inferences drawn about
the population as a whole should be tentative.
The results may be biased by a social desirability
response set and people's stated attitudes may not
be correlated with actual behaviour.
The study has not elucidated the main determinants
of attitudes as total predictive power was small and
associations do not prove causality.
197
198
WOLFF ET AL
where did you get most of the information about the policy? Is them occasionally? Would you have casual conversations with
anything like this happening in your area? If yes, where did neighbours who had suffered from mental illness? If
you hear about this? If yes, where did you get most of this somebody who had been a former psychiatric patient came to
information about it? Did they know about the hostel? If yes, live next door to you, would you visit them? (Responses: very
was it because of our survey? (g) Attitude to community care likely, likely, uncertain, unlikely, very unlikely.)
policy: What is your opinion of the policy to close psychiatric
hospitals? What do you think of the idea of long stay
psychiatric patients being discharged from hospital into small
References
units in the community? What effect do you think this will
have on local residents? Overall, do you think that psychiatric
BELSON, W. A. (1957) The Hurt Mind. Audience Research
care in the community has a good or a bad effect on local Report, . BBC.
residents?
O/BHUORA, D. & SCOTT, 1. (1989) The report of a working
(h) Opinion about the need for education: Do you think that party of \ the fourth Collegiate Trainees' Committee.
local residents would offer help for the mental health facilities Psychiatric Bulletin.
in their neighbourhood? What help could local residents give?
13, 330-333.
Would you offer your help? Do you think it is important for I^BROCKINGTON, I. F., HALL, P. H., LEVINOS, J., et al (1993) The
community's tolerance of the mentally ill. British Journal of
local residents to be given information about new mental
Psychiatry. 162, 93-99.
health facilities in their area? What kind of information in your
opinion might someone need if patients were going. What do CHEYNE, G. (1773) The English Malady. London: G. Strahan.
COHEN, J. (1988) Statistical Power Analysis/or the
you think is the best method of providing this information?
Behavioural
Sciences, (2nd edn). New York: Academic Preqs."
Appendix 2. The self-report inventory of fear of and
^PUMMING, E. & CUMMING, 1. (1957) Closed RanksAn
behavioural intentions toward the mentally ill
Experiment in Mental Health Education. Cambridge, MASS:
Respondents were asked to complete a 5 point response scale Harvard University Press.
for each question. Responses were coded on a scale of 1 to 5. "^.DOHRENWEND, B. P. & CHINO-SONG, E. (1967) Social status
Fear: "I am afraid of people with mental illness" (Responses:
and attitudes towards psychological disorders: the problem
strongly agree, agree, neutral, disagree and strongly disagree).
of tolerance of deviance. American Sociological Review,
Behavioural intentions: Would you object to having mentally
32, 417-433. DYER, C. (1993) Children's nurse convicted
ill people living in your neighbourhood? Would you avoid
of murder. British
conversations with neighbours who had suffered from mental
Medical Journal, 306, 1431-1432. GATHERER, A. & REID, 1.1.
illness? Would you be willing to work with somebody with a
A. (1963) Public Attitudes and Menial
mental illness? Would you invite somebody into your home if
Health Education. Northamptonshire Mental Health
you knew they suffered from mental illness? Would you be Project. VMACLEAN, U. (1969) Community attitudes to mental
worried about visiting somebody with a mental illness? If illness in Edinburgh. British Journal of Preventive and Social
somebody had been a former psychiatric patient, would you Medicine, 23, 45-52.
have them as a friend? If somebody who had been a former
MAUGHAM, S. (1938) The Summing Up. London: Pan, 1976.
psychiatric patient came to live next door to you, would you
p. 40. MORI (MARKET OPINION & RESEARCH
greet
INTERNATIONAL ) (1990) Mental Health - Public and Business
Attitudes. London. Research project for the Mental Health
Appeal. NORUSIS, M. J. (1988) SPSS/PC-^- V2.0 Base
Manual. Chicago:
SPSS Inc.
RICHARDS, K. (1982) A mind disordered: the public view.
Nursing , Mirror, Oct 13.5S-56. V TAYLOR , M. S. &DEAR, M.
J. (1981) Scaling community attitudes
toward the mentally ill. Schizophrenia Bulletin, 7, 225-240.
WILLCOCKS, A. (1968) Cited by: Anon. (1968) Public attitudes
to mental health education. Editorial. British Medical Journal,
5584, 69-70.
Geoffrey Wolff, MRCPsych, Institute of Psychiatry; Soumitra Pathare, MRCPsych, Tom Craig, PRCPsych,
Academic Department of Psychiatry, St Thomas's Hospital, UMDS; Julian Leff, FRCPsych, MRC Social,
Genetic and Developmental Psychiatry Research Centre (Social Psychiatry Section), Institute of Psychiatry
Correspondence: Dr Geoffrey Wolff, MRC Social, Genetic and Developmental Psychiatry Research Centre (Social Psychiatry
Section), Institute of Psychiatry, DeCrespigny Park, Denmark Hill, London SE5 8AF. E-mail:
gsw@scpu.mrc.ac.uk
(First received 4 April 1995, final revision 4 July 1995. accepted 18 October 1995)