Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Content
Appendix
| 1
EXAMPLE
New high-growth
ventures
New
New product
Palm
Smart
Sony Playstation
Rollerblades
New industry
Direct satellite TV
Netscape
Mobile telephony
New business
system
Dell
Fotolabo
Charles Schwab
FedEx
Product/
service
Existing
Existing
New
Business system
| 2
Standard use
Complications for
New Venture projects
Start-up companies:
Application for venture
capital
Search for management
team members
Communication with
partners, suppliers,
Established, developed
businesses for investment
decisions
In-house budget
allocations
External financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
High insecurity
concerning technology,
timing, and cash need
Difficult data situation
due to newness of
innovative products
Necessity of external
know-how transfer
Lack of skills/motivation/
time
Start-up
business
plans to be
tailored to
new venture
needs
| 3
Generic requirements
Explanation
Constantly adapting
Impressing by clarity
Convincing by facts
Understandable even
for non-experts
Consistent and
concise
Optically compelling
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 4
Milestones
Level of maturity
of business idea
Completion of
financing
Step 3
VC-tailored
business plan
Step 2
Rough business
plan
Marketing and
Step 1
Idea description
Product/service
Market and
sales
Business system
Opportunities and
risks
External
evaluation (due
diligence)
Deal structuring
Management
team
Implementation
plan
Financing
New decision
on further proceeding
when next milestone is
reached
competition
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 5
Content
Appendix
| 6
Executive
summary
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Product/
service
Marketing
and
sales
Financing
Management
team
Business
system
Opportunities
and
risks
| 7
Executive
summary
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
Product/
service
Marketing
and
sales
Financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Management
team
Business
system
Opportunities
and
risks
| 8
STEP1
Idea description
Most important
questions an
investor asks!
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 9
STEP2
| 10
Executive summary
CASE EXAMPLE
Potential foam plus applicator to replace expensive and space consuming earth
Product/service
Market and
competition
Marketing and
sales
tons/day
Major competitor: 3M/Sanifoam (application takes longer and is more
complicated)
Business system
Opportunities and
risks
| 11
EXERCISE
Answered questions
Missing element
Evaluation of
Rusmar summary
See appendix
for proposed
solutions
| 12
EXERCISE
Answered questions
Missing element
Evaluation of
Rusmar summary
| 13
Executive
summary
Product/
service
Management
team
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
Marketing
and
sales
Business
system
Financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Opportunities
and
risks
| 14
STEP1
Idea description
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 15
STEP2
| 16
EXEMPLARY
Better
| 17
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 18
CASE EXAMPLE
Not fulfilled
Fulfilled
Exercise 2:
Training participants
describe
needs of Rusmar's
customers1
| 19
Executive
summary
Product/
service
Management
team
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
Marketing
and
sales
Business
system
Financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Opportunities
and
risks
| 20
What experience or abilities are lacking? How will the gaps be closed?
By whom?
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 21
52
38
31
25
15
12
17
1 Reasons for rejecting business plans by firms experienced in biotechnology venture capital
2 Multiple responses given
SOURCE: Coopers and Lybrand, McKinsey
| 22
EXEMPLARY
Percent2
Venture
begins
Technology &
mkt.
validation
Proof of
economic
viability
Explosive
revenue
growth
Sustained
earnings
growth
CEO
Technology
Marketing
Sales
Finance
1 Reasons for rejecting business plans by firms experienced in biotechnology venture capital
2 Multiple responses given
SOURCE: Coopers and Lybrand, McKinsey&Company
| 23
Unemployed
Start-ups
or recent graduate
4
6
Not from
business
13
42
Running other 14
businesses
21
Small established
companies
Example include
Intel
Microsoft
Lotus
Sun Microsystems
Mattel
CompuServe
Advanced Micro Devices
Raytheon
Fairchild Semiconductor
TRW
CondeNast
News Corp
| 24
Traditional corporate
experience does not fit
new venture needs
but corporate
experience is valuable
when it includes
Skills aligned to
Business building
roles, e.g.,
Led expansion into
new geographic
markets
Built new product
line or division
Provided
marketing
leadership to
develop a new
brand
Relevant industry
sector experience
| 25
EXAMPLE
High skill level
Medium skill level
Skill gaps
Team members
J. Chaplin
S. Fischer
M. Smith
Technology
Finance
Project management
Hard
factors
Contacts
Marketing/sales
Production
Human resources
Social competence
Soft
factors
Initiative
Obvious
skill gaps
to be filled
with
additional
team
members
Communication
Sales/negotiation skills
| 26
Executive
summary
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
Product/
service
Marketing
and
sales
Financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Management
team
Business
system
Opportunities
and
risks
| 27
STEP1
Idea description
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 28
STEP2
What market volume (value and amount) do you estimate for your
individual market segments over the next five years?
| 29
Market characteristics
EXAMPLE
ROUGH
ESTIMATES
Market competitiveness
Number of B2B marketplaces
Market growth
percent
100
Total revenues
of B2B marketplaces
estimated to grow at over
100% per year revenue
potential ~ USD 50 bn
in 2014
~1,000-2,000
Most vertical
specialty
market-places
expected to
consolidate
Attractive
50
Unattractive
0
1
10
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
~100-200
100
1000
Potential market size
USD millions
2010
2020
| 30
CASE EXAMPLE
| 31
CASE EXAMPLE
Potential
market volume
for Rusmar
foam?2
1 Assumption
2 See appendix for proposed solution
SOURCE: Inc.-Magazine
| 32
STEP2
What are the barriers to market entry and how can they be overcome?
What market share does your competition have in the various market
segments?
| 33
Competitive advantage
Revolutionary improvement
In performance
Unique
competitive
advantage
19
Creation of unusually
Emotional bond with
customer
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
27
| 34
Degree of fulfillment
Customer requirements
dumping time)
Simple application
Cost advantage per application
Equal performance as layer of earth
regarding
Odor absorption
Erosion from weather
Protection from pests
Constant availability of foam
Applicator licence available quickly,
at low cost, and without concern
(without reassessment of the dump
by regulators)
Rapid and high-quality maintenance
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Rusmar
3M/Sanifoam Reason
Rusmar 30 min./3M 60 min.
3M two components
Rusmar 6 cents per sq. ft.,
3M 13 cents
Rusmar
leading
| 35
Executive
summary
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
Product/
service
Marketing
and
sales
Financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Management
team
Business
system
Opportunities
and
risks
| 36
STEP1
Idea description
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Marketing and
sales only
briefly
touched in
idea
description;
more details
in rough
business plan
(stage 2)
| 37
STEP1
Time
Cost
Quality
Reference
price
(currently
available
product)
Advantage point
of new
of view)
produc
(customer
point of
view)
Incentive
for buying
new
product
Selling
price of
new
product
| 38
EXAMPLE
Facts
Exercise 4:
What is the appropriate price
for the Ciena product?1
| 39
STEP2
In which partial market segments will you make your market entry? How
do you plan to turn this "toehold" into a high-volume business?
What sales volumes are you targeting (detailed data by market segment)?
| 40
Select
segmentation
criteria
Determine
segment
volume
++ Very high
+ High
o Medium
Critical
Analyse
customer value
per segment
Segment 1
++
Segment 2
++
Segment 3
++
Select clearly
separate and
segments with a
strong
proposition
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Arrive at market
segments
plausibly and
validate it
Understand
customer value
per segment
Determine
target segment
and evolution
strategy
Identify
competition per
segment
Consider direct
competitors and
substitutions
for market
launch
Anticipate
evolution path
| 41
Consumer goods
markets
Industrial goods
markets
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 42
Executive
summary
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
Product/
service
Marketing
and
sales
Financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Management
team
Business
system
Opportunities
and
risks
| 43
STEP2
What does the business system for your product/service look like?
How high is your need for technical input (raw materials, materials to
create your service)?
Which partners will you work with? What are the advantages of
working together for you and your partners?
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 44
EXEMPLARY
Covered by City Scape
Generic
value chain
Research &
Development
DevelopCase
ment of
example City Internet
Scape
technology
Production
City
Scape
system
design
Acquisition
General
information
Businesses
Marketing &
Sales
Internet
production
Distribution
Marketing
Consumers
Businesses
Business
sales
Service
Updates,
services
Licensing
| 45
EXEMPLARY
Highest scalability
Revenue sources
Description
Revenue potential
Contract
development
Others
service provision or
consulting
Customer training
Support/Maintenance
IP sale/license fees
Product
Line 1
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Product
Line 2
Product
Line 3
| 46
Executive
summary
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
Product/
service
Marketing
and
sales
Financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Management
team
Business
system
Opportunities
and
risks
| 47
STEP3
What are the most important milestones for the development of your
business, and when must they be reached?
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 48
Implementation plan
Main activities
EXEMPLARY
12/17
Activity 1
Activity 2
Responsible
KSF 1
KSF 2
KSF 3
Activity 3
Key success
factors
USD xx
Milestones
Investment need
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Milestone 1
USD xxx
USD xxx
USD xxx
| 49
BACK-UP
2012
1
10
11
12
Development
Software development
CityScape server setup/operation
Demo software development
Test/debugging Nuremberg
Catalog development
Development of transaction module
Marketing
Build up customer relationships
Develop marketing campaign
Launch marketing campaign
Start in Nuremberg
Start in Munich
Start in Wrzburg
Start in Regensburg
Management
Founding of CityScape
Formation of team
Setup of operations
Recruiting of software specialists
Start of alliances with internet providers
First financing round
Second financing round
Third financing round
Milestones
First
Start of
CityScape CityScape
prototype Nuremberg
SOURCE: "Planen, Grnden, Wachsen"
Four
cities
Ten
30
cities cities
60
cities
| 50
Executive
summary
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
Product/
service
Marketing
and
sales
Financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Management
team
Business
system
Opportunities
and
risks
| 51
STEP3
How high is your need for financing based on your liquidity planning?
How much cash is needed in the worst case scenario?
How will your cash flow develop? When will you expect to break even
(= sum of all revenues greater than the sum of all expenses)?
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Financial plan
outlines
Cash flow statement
Income statement
Balance sheet
| 52
Am I profitable?
Invoice
Invoice
Invoice
Income statement
Deposits
...
...
...
Proceeds
...
...
...
Payments
...
...
...
Liquid funds
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Balance sheet
Expenses
...
...
...
Profit/loss
Assets
...
...
...
Equity + liabilities
...
...
...
| 53
Cash flow
statement
Deposits
Payments
Income
statement
Deposits and payments
refer to the amount of
liquid cash and are not
entered into the books
until actual payment
takes place
Liquid funds
Proceeds generated
and expenses
(consumption of
resources) are entered
into the books for the
period under review
irrespective of concrete
payments
Income
Expenses
Profit/loss
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 54
EXAMPLE BIOCHALLENGE
DM thousands
Assets
Equity + liabilities
Fixed assets
Intangible assets
Real estate and buildings
Technical equipment, plant,
and machinery
Other equipment and fixed assets
Equity
Nominal capital
Additional paid-in capital
Net earnings/losses brought forward
Net income
20
0
1,936
0
Current assets
Raw materials and supplies
Semi-finished and finished goods
Accounts receivable
Other receivables
Liquid funds
0
20
400
0
5,945
Total assets
8,321
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
8,560
0
-7,229
2,470
Liabilities
Provisions
Long-term bank loans
Short-term bank loans
Accounts payable
Other liabilities
0
4,500
0
20
0
8,321
| 55
Food
Research and
development
Consulting
Leasing
Electronics
Automobiles &
machinery
Chemicals
Publishing/
printing
Textiles
Revenues
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
100.0
Sales
96.2
98.9
92.1
88.5
93.7
91.5
88.6
94.0
94.4
1.7
0.5
3.6
7.0
3.5
3.5
7.3
1.8
1.9
Extraordinary
income
2.1
0.6
4.3
4.5
2.8
4.9
4.2
4.3
3.7
98.5
96.9
92.6
100.8
97.2
94.4
93.3
97.6
100.3
61.7
0.7
43.9
41.3
40.7
32.1
43.3
30.6
38.3
16.2
23.8
27.4
16.7
31.5
27.7
7.7
6.6
2.9
4.1
4.6
3.2
4.8
4.1
2.4
3.1
1.6
1.1
0.6
0.3
1.0
0.4
Expenses
Cost of
materials
Personnel
expenses
14.3
Wages and
salaries
2.8
Social security
Rent
0.5
Interest
1.1
0.5
1.4
39.5
1.4
1.3
1.7
2.0
2.3
Depreciation of
fixed assets
3.6
4.9
4.6
6.7
3.3
2.8
4.4
5.4
3.9
Other
depreciation
0.2
0.0
0.6
0.1
0.7
0.9
3.3
2.3
0.9
14.4
50.1
38.2
33.8
19.0
16.5
23.3
18.5
17.6
1.5
3.1
7.4
2.8
4.6
6.7
2.4
-0.3
Other operating
expenses
Profit
-0.8
| 56
Valuation methods
Year
Free
cash
flows
5
Continuing
valu1e
11,000
Profit for relevant
period (year 5)
380
-1,960
-660
-150
Discount 65%
rate
55%
Discount 0.606
factor
0.416 0.328
Today's
value
-1,188 -275
Entity
2,500
value
Debt
880
45%
-49
+
35%
25%
25%
0.301
0.328
0.328
115
289
3,608
905 x 43
(multiple)
Different
methods
possible
EUR 38,900
Discount factor (IRR
= 65% for 5 years)
x 0.082
Total 2,500
value
Total 3,190
value
1 Assumption: FCF in year 5 is 1,100, growth rate 6%, discount rate 16%
SOURCE: Planen, grnden, wachsen (McKinsey&Company)
| 57
Financing stages
Seed
Start-up
Expansion
Personal savings
Loan by family
Government subsidies
Bank loans
Leasing
Venture capital
Stock market
| 58
Business plan
Preselection
| 59
Executive
summary
Market
and competition
Implementation
plan
Product/
service
Marketing
and
sales
Financing
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
Management
team
Business
system
Opportunities
and
risks
| 60
STEP2
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 61
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 62
Sensitivity analysis
EXEMPLARY
DM
Determinants of different
scenarios have to be well
understood
Best-case
scenario
Base-case
scenario
Worst-case
scenario
Payback period
Financing need
Year
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 63
Content
Appendix 1
Additional questions for
complete business plan (step 3)
| 64
STEP3
Most important
questions an
investor asks!1
| 65
STEP3
| 66
STEP3
| 67
STEP3
How, and at what cost, can you adjust your capacity in the
short term?
| 68
STEP3
What will your planning look like for the next five financial years
under both a best and worst case scenario?
What effect will this have on your need for capital and
your return?
| 69
Content
Appendix 2
Proposed Rusmar case example solutions
| 70
Evaluation of
Rusmar summary
Answered
questions
Missing
element
forecast?
()
needed?
SOURCE: McKinsey&Company
| 71
()
needs?
()
Answered
questions
Missing
element
Evaluation of
Rusmar summary
()
()
| 72
CASE EXAMPLE
Not fulfilled
Fulfilled
Space savings of
some
30%, lifetime
improvement of ~10%
Odor absorption
Erosion from weather
Protection from pests
Degree fulfilled by
Rusmar, Inc.
More garbage:
approx.
USD 5,800 per day/
USD 1.5 million per
year
Lower costs:
approx.
USD 1,100 per day,
USD 0.3 million per
year
| 73
Average daily
capacity per dump
~ 5,000 tons*
500 dumps
CASE EXAMPLE
Covered area
per day
Covered area
per year2
Potential
market size3
~ 500,000m m2
(Maximum)
~ 130m m2
(Maximum)
USD
70 m/year
~ 300,000m2
(Minimum)
~ 78m m2
(Minimum)
USD
42 m/year
Average area
in use
~ 1,000m2/day1
Average distance
between cover
layers
~ 5 m*
1 Assumptions
2 About 260 working days
3 Assessed price of 54 US cent/m 2
SOURCE: Inc. Magazine
300 dumps
| 74
Assumption
Average cable length of 50
km with costs of DM 50 100 per meter
Non-financial incentives
No digging of new cables
Faster installation of new
technology
For
comparison:
Total cost for
Ciena are
< DM 10,000
2.5
2.5
Selling price of
new product
| 75