Preliminaries for Structural Sizing

© All Rights Reserved

18 views

Preliminaries for Structural Sizing

© All Rights Reserved

- 2a_cufsm Tutorial 1
- Sway Mode - EC3
- lec2
- Plate Girder Part 1
- Optimum Design of Stiffened Plates for Different Loads and Shapes of Ribs
- 4 Buckle Triggers
- IPC2012-90642
- Longitudinal
- CE2252 Strenth of Materials Question Bank-xams9
- 1-s2.0-S0141029614002703-main
- etabs modelare ferm metalica
- Sd Article 12
- Buckling Study 1 1
- Bert
- Buckling
- CSD365 Lecture 10 DCT Combined Actions Member Restraints
- Vessel Design
- Composite Course Part 3
- Topic Bending
- Section 2 Capacity

You are on page 1of 8

Before we can start designing the fuselage, it is beneficial to know how it is likely to fail.

The likely mode of failure is buckling as can be seen in the figures below and on the

following page.

Shown in the figures below is an

idealization of the frame and skinstringer combination. The frames act

as springs to resist the displacement of

the skin-stringer combination.

In the case were the frames or ribs are

themselves not stiff enough, the

structure buckles in a global sense

much like a long rod. If the frames or

ribs are stiff enough, a node is

enforced and a local type of buckling

Gerard, p30

occurs. Theoretically, the minimum

weight is achieved when both modes

are likely to occur simultaneously. In

practice, structures are designed so

that the local buckling occurs first. The general type of failure is considered to be

unacceptable for aerospace structures.

Gerard, p 32

Gerard, p 27

Gerard, p 40

Our job as structural designers is to prevent the skin-stringer combination from buckling

and to make the frames stiff enough to prevent the global type of failure. It should be

noted that there is nothing to gain by making the structure any more stiff than it needs to

be.

Frames

The primary purpose of frames is to provide end restraints for the skin panels and to resist

out of plane deflections when the skins try to buckle. The primary factor in buckling

and resisting deflections in general is the stiffness, EI. The goal of frame or rib design is

to select a stiffness, that is a material and cross sectional area, and spacing to make the

local buckling of the skins as likely as the global buckling of the entire structure (large

spacing and low stiffness).

Shanley has shown that a proper model for this type of behavior is

(Insert Figure here)

When the panel buckles, it does so as if were hinged at the buckling point. The required

spring constant to prevent buckling is

k required c1

P

L

An applied bending moment causes the highest stresses at the top and bottom of the

structure and zero stress at the neutral axis. Therefore only a small portion of the

structure supports the bending load. So if we assume that the load is applied over the top

and bottom fraction of the structure, the fraction represented by c2, we can find an

equivalent load by using the definition of torque or moment.

Pequivalent c 2

M

D

Now that we know what spring stiffness is required, we can compare it to the spring

stiffness of a circular frame under diametrically applied loads.

k actual c3

EI

D3

c1

P

EI

c3 3

L

D

c2

c1 M

D c EI

3

L

D3

EI C f

MD 2

L

If experiments can be conducted with frames of known stiffness, a value of C f can be

calculated when the other parameters are selected in a way that causes local and global

buckling to occur simultaneously. According to Shanley, this value is

C f 6.25 10 5

5

Gerard in doing a similar calculation showed C f 6.84 10 . The higher the value of

this parameter, the more likely local buckling is to occur.

Recall which cross sectional area is used in the definition of the moment of inertia I of

the frame. Because I contains geometric information, we can use it to determine an area.

This area swept around the circumference gives a volume.

If it is assumed that the frame cross section is rectangular (remember in conceptual

design we arent too concerned with the actual shape), then

I

1

bh 3

12

Area bh

By definition,

2

I

A

where is the radius of gyration. If a typical value is known, then it is easy to find the

frame area.

However, Shanley has shown that another parameter better captures the efficiency of the

frame in bending.

k4

I

A2

k4

1 h

12 b

The height-to-width ratio can be thought of as an aspect ratio. For one of Shanleys

examples, the value of k was about 5. This gives

h 60

b

For a frame designed under optimal conditions, i.e. no cutouts, no point loads, this sounds

about right.

Panels

Panels usually refer to a composite structure consisting of both skins and stiffeners

(stringers). Sketches of panels were shown in the first couple of pages of this section.

When it comes to sizing the skin and stringers, Bruhn in Analysis and Design of Missile

Structures and Shanley both state or imply that it is difficult to treat the problem as two

smaller problems: one for the skin and one for the stringers. Instead, their combination is

studied.

Panels can be constructed from many types of materials and stringer cross sections. The

choice of material is primarily based on cost or material properties depending on the

types of loads the structure will see. The choice of stringer cross section is more of an

art, but some statements can be made. There are several primary families of cross

sections: Z, Hat, J, and Y.

Hat stringers are easy to construct, but when attached to the skin, they create a

closed pocket of air that can hide corrosion. This can be overcome by using the

hat stringers as fuel vents in wing structures.

Z stringers are also easily constructed, but have an offset shear center. When

deflected, they also twist.

J stringers can be hard to form, but are useful for joining 2 panels together.

Y stringers were studied long ago by NACA. Although hard to form, NACA

found that the Y stringer was the best of all of the stiffeners.

As I was implying, some stringers are better than others. This quality can be described

by a panel efficiency factor that only depends on the type of stiffener used and not size.

From experimental data in Gerard, the following efficiencies were obtained.

1.02

0.985

1.15

Type

Z

Hat

Y

The panel efficiency factor is used in many calculations such as finding the required

effective skin thickness.

Another approach to the panel problem is given in Shanley. If various stringers, panel

lengths, and materials are tested to failure, a plot of allowable stress vs. load per unit

width per panel length is obtained and can be seen below. This q, also called the

loading parameter, is simply the load divided by the dimension over which it is

applied.

t

P

P

L

q = P / width

As can be seen, the shorter the panel length the higher the allowable stress. The reason

why the panel does not develop its full compressive yield stress before failure is that

it buckles. This explains why shorter panels (closely spaced stiffeners) can develop

higher stresses. The 75S-T material develops much higher stresses and therefore

lower weight, but that has to be weighed against other factors such as cost and

fatigue properties. The dashed line represents the upper limit for 24S-T material.

An interesting twist that will be useful for sizing is by rearranging the data in the plot

from Shanley. If the calculated value for allowable stress f is divided by the

corresponding value of

obtained.

f q

t q

L

L

q

L

L

This result is obtained from the definition of stress and the fact that the cross sectional

area is for the stress is A t w , where w is the panel width.

When plotted for the 24S-T material this gives

0.02

0.015

t

L

0.01

0.005

0

0

10

0

20

0

30

0

40

0

50

q0

L

60

0

70

0

80

0

90

0

References

1. Gerard, George. Minimum Weight Analysis of Compression Structures. 1956.

Chapters 2, 3, and 7.

2. Gordon, J.E. Structures, or Why Things Dont Fall Down. 1978. Chapters 13 and

14.

3. Shanley, F.R. Weight-Strength Analysis of Aircraft Structures. 1960. Chapters 2, 3,

4, and 15.

4. Bruhn, Elmer. Analysis and Design of Missile Structures.

- 2a_cufsm Tutorial 1Uploaded byPravin Awalkonde
- Sway Mode - EC3Uploaded bytiagofreire
- lec2Uploaded byDebadatta Ratha
- Plate Girder Part 1Uploaded byMuharamon Sania Putra
- Optimum Design of Stiffened Plates for Different Loads and Shapes of RibsUploaded byluke636250
- 4 Buckle TriggersUploaded byNguyen Hoai Phuong
- IPC2012-90642Uploaded byMarcelo Varejão Casarin
- LongitudinalUploaded byArul JO
- 1-s2.0-S0141029614002703-mainUploaded byIliuta Florea
- CE2252 Strenth of Materials Question Bank-xams9Uploaded byHariharan Elangandhi
- etabs modelare ferm metalicaUploaded byMariana Suciu
- Sd Article 12Uploaded byrs0004
- Buckling Study 1 1Uploaded byNameis Ghoffar
- BertUploaded byNguyen Ngoc Tuan
- BucklingUploaded byAnonymous wWOWz9UnW
- CSD365 Lecture 10 DCT Combined Actions Member RestraintsUploaded bygabuchia
- Vessel DesignUploaded byNazrinaazAhmad
- Composite Course Part 3Uploaded byVarun Shastry
- Topic BendingUploaded byUmmer Bava
- Section 2 CapacityUploaded byAchala Fernando
- Practical Compactness and Bracing Provisions for the Design of Single Angle BeamsUploaded bybruno_alq
- DynamicBuckling of Thin Isotropic Plates Subjected to in-plane ImpactUploaded byTashi Malhotra
- Concrete Filled Steel TubesUploaded byJovanne Langga
- 01_3_104Uploaded bycmkoh
- question Bank.pdfUploaded bysandip kumar
- msen1993-1-1-2010preUploaded byXhoneyra Ira
- 1.3 (4)Uploaded bySue Ila
- Exp 10 WAGNER BEAM.docxUploaded byRaj Kumar
- Analysis and Experimental VerificationUploaded byAndonny Daq Delgado
- STEEL AND TIMBER REPORT COMPILED (AAA).pdfUploaded byLee Chen Choon

- Aircraft Structures 1Uploaded byvodmox
- Chapter 5 Loading BobUploaded byYadana1
- Strength of material.pdfUploaded byYadana1
- Basic ChemistryUploaded byYadana1
- Aircraft Structures IIUploaded byvodmox
- 1424596234.6202chapter-1Uploaded byAnoop Prajapati
- Wave and SoundUploaded byYadana1
- Impact Load -Strain EnergyUploaded byYadana1
- ColumnsUploaded byYadana1
- GPS_2005Uploaded byYadana1
- Dynamics (Linear Kinematic)Uploaded byYadana1
- Dynamics (Linear Impulse and Momentum)Uploaded byYadana
- Dynamics (Work and Energy) TutorialUploaded byYadana1
- Kinematics of Rigid Body- Absolute MotionUploaded byYadana1
- Aerospace Legislation 1Uploaded byYadana1
- Calculus - A Basic RulesUploaded byYadana1
- Forces.pdfUploaded byYadana1
- PhysicsUploaded byYadana1
- What Makes Good SupervisorUploaded byIndra Bayu
- Frequency Response and Control StabilityUploaded byYadana1
- MixturesUploaded byYadana1
- Atomic TheoryUploaded byYadana1
- Major Repair of Composite MaterialsUploaded byYadana1
- AC Electrical System1Uploaded byYadana1
- EQM Rectangular Cordinetes Prb SolutionUploaded byYadana1
- 5-1 Landing GearUploaded byYadana1
- 12 Auto Pilot IntroUploaded byYadana1
- 27 AnswersUploaded byYadana1

- Mitsubishi Manuals 217Uploaded byPham Long
- NAME Study Guide 12 31 09Uploaded bymaria_bustelo_2
- synthesisofsillyputtylikepolymerUploaded byapi-263251621
- CHEM 17 - Freezing point of naphthalene and boiling point elevation of water.Uploaded byGerry Mark Gubantes
- Устройство, Работа, Проверка, Настройка. g3520c 2002 a.Uploaded byAleksey
- Operation Manual KH-777 (09-10-2013)-R1.pdfUploaded byHeriansyah
- HiMatrix F35Uploaded byMuhammad Raditya
- A Simple Method for Power Loss Estimation in Pwm Inverter-fed MotorsUploaded byjalilemadi
- A Microprocessor Based Protection System for Generator-transformer UnitsUploaded byBalaga Harish
- Maths Comprehensive Worksheet December 2017 Class 6 PaperUploaded bySyed Asim Raza
- Speech Recognition.pdfUploaded bysharukhsshaikh
- V002T05A010-HT2013-17527(2)Uploaded bysagarsrinivas
- Problem Set Fd 2dheatUploaded bypazrie
- Downforce Without Wings ProtecUploaded byDavid Dominguez
- 14 Three Moment EquationUploaded byTayyab Zafar
- Thermal ConvectionUploaded byhASEEBABDUL889209
- CATIA - Generative Assembly Structural Analysis 2 (GAS)Uploaded byliapomi
- Experiment1.docxUploaded byRamaDinakaran
- General Guidelines for a Microbiological Laboratory of Optimal CapacityUploaded bybilalmas
- 1NT - Fixed Temperature ThermostatsUploaded byjpntjpnt
- BODY MECHANICS.pdfUploaded byAny Andriani
- ENVAC Roosevelt Island AVAC PresentationUploaded byrooseveltislander
- Ways to Memorize Formulas For JEE Main Preparation _ CrackiitjeeUploaded byNcnagesh Prasad
- Balanced Forces PptUploaded bygaluhfahmi
- gunas 2Uploaded byPoonam
- 06mbr1Uploaded byكرم عمرو
- PBR Packer Setting Steps (1)Uploaded bys v poyil
- Mach2-6-11Uploaded bycarllongway7369
- 1-s2.0-S187770581500332X-mainUploaded byAravind
- LM2940-CUploaded byMiguel Mejia

## Much more than documents.

Discover everything Scribd has to offer, including books and audiobooks from major publishers.

Cancel anytime.