Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VETERINARY PRACTICE
Part 1
Philip A.M. Rogers MRCVS
e-mail : progers@grange.teagasc.ie
Updated 1991, 1993, 1995
Postgraduate Course in Veterinary AP, Dublin, 1996
ABSTRACT
Acupuncture (AP) is a reflex phenomenon with diagnostic and therapeutic value. AP points
(APs) and Channels (AP meridians) have many applications in routine veterinary practice.
AP has diagnostic and therapeutic value.
Irritated organs/functions cause reflex changes in sensitivity (usually hypersensitivity to
pressure, heat and electrical current) at specific zones (the AP points (APs)) on the body's
surface (diagnostic effect). Adequate stimuli (needling, injection etc) applied to the APs can
influence the pathophysiology of the affected organs/functions (therapeutic effect).
Most of you are Vets whose main source of income comes from private practice. If you hope
to integrate AP into your day-to-day practice, you must keep certain considerations in mind:
1. You must study AP in reasonable detail. A few weekend seminars may be enough to get
you started but are only the beginning of mastery of AP.
2. The AP technique which you use routinely should require a maximum of 10-20
minutes/session, otherwise the number of cases which you can treat/week will fall. Unless
your fee for treatment includes a cost for the time involved, your income will fall in
proportion to the fall in cases/week. Point injection is the fastest method and gives good
results.
3. Having studied AP, you should present it in a scientific way to your clients and your
colleagues. This is essential if you wish to preserve your reputation as a vet and a scientist.
This paper discusses AP point injection; methods of adapting ultrasonic, faradic, laser and
other physical therapies along AP principles; some of the best indications for AP therapy in
large and small animals and possible uses of AP analgesia in surgery. It also discusses options
for AP training; continuing study and development of intuitive powers in relation to an
Holistic "total view" of health and disease and some of the methods of fostering public
awareness of AP.
ACUPUNCTURE (AP): REFLEX AND ENERGETIC CONCEPTS
AP has diagnostic and therapeutic value. It has many applications in routine veterinary
practice (1,2,11,12,13,14).
First thing on arrival, before other preparations, AP needles or hypodermic needles 5 cm long
and 19 to 23 gauge are placed to a depth of about 3 cm in GV02,03,04 and to a depth of 4-5
cm in the BL points, bilaterally. The farmer or an assistant is shown how to twirl and
manipulate the needles and is instructed to continue twirling them in sequence for 10-15
seconds each. Two needles can be twirled together. Alternatively, an electro-AP stimulator is
attached to the needles and the frequency is set for about 5 Hz. The output voltage is increased
until the needles are pulsating in rhythm with the outputs.
The vet then proceeds to reposition the uterus and to ensure that it is fully back. A uterine
pessary may be inserted. The vaginal lips are sutured as usual and a special harness to apply
perivulval pressure is applied for a few days. Normally the whole procedure takes only 15-20
minutes and there is seldom any straining or re-expulsion of the uterus by the cow. Spinal
anaesthesia is seldom necessary. The late Erwin Westermayer (Germany) made a superb
video-film showing this method in eight random cases.
3. Cows: hormonal infertility/functional pituitary, ovarian, uterine pathology: Infertility
in cows is often associated with anoestrus, persistent corpus luteum, pyometra and cystic
ovary. Main points are traditional points YungQi (near BL26, bilateral), 9-10 cm from the
midline between the transverse processes of 5th & 6th lumbar vertebrae. Any AhShi points in
the lumbosacral area (in the area BL23-34 and BL52-53) are added. AP can be by point
injection, manual needling + electro-stimulation for 10-15 minutes, repeated every few days
until the cow comes into oestrus.
Alternatively, point injection with 5-10 ml solution of 0.25-0.50% procaine, vitamin B12,
homeopathic agents etc can be used. Anoestrus usually responds to 1-2 treatments, cows
coming into oestrus within 3 weeks. Cystic ovaries may need up to 4 sessions, with the
formation of a corpus luteum by the 10th day and the appearance of oestrus by 3-5 weeks
after the last treatment.
Some vets apply moxa to the needle handles (when the needles are inserted) and allow the
moxa to burn itself out. Kothbauer also uses paracervical injection, via a very long needle.
4. Small animals: conjunctivitis, rhinitis: Main APs for these disorders are: Conjunctivitis:
LI04: BL01; GB01 / + / GB20: ST01,02; LV03; TH23. Rhinitis: LI04,20; Z 03,14; GB20;
GV23,25. The animals may be needled with fine human AP needles, 10 mm long and 30-32
gauge. The needles are inserted to a depth of 2-3 mm on the face points; 12-25 mm on GB20
and 12 mm on LI04. In acute cases, quick needling (a few seconds/point) is sufficient. Repeat
daily for 2-3 days. In chronic cases, sessions should last 10-20 minutes, repeated once every
3-7 days for 4-6 sessions.
Alternatively, APs may be injected with 0.1 to 0.5 ml of solution using a dental syringe and a
very fine needle. In severe conjunctivitis, if the animal is quiet, pricking the everted eyelid in
3-6 places is recommended in large animals, or injection of 0.1 ml 0.25-0.50% local
anaesthetic into a few subconjunctival areas. One may also try laser or ultrasound using the
same APs, but avoid irradiating the eye.
In chronic cases of conjunctivitis, warn the owner not to allow the dog to poke its head out of
the car window while the car is moving.
If the problem is in the flexor tendons, search these areas and the area behind the scapula
(BL13,14,15 = LU, PC, HT Shu points) and the lumbosacral area (BL22,25,27 = TH, LI, SI
Shu points) also. Note carefully and treat all sensitive areas.
In therapy, choose main points from: AhShi points plus main points for the affected regions
(9,12,14,18). Treat acute cases every 3-7 days for up to 8 sessions. Expect results by the third
session in acute cases and by the 4th-5th session in chronic cases.
In tendinitis, local APs along the affected tendons are added. In bursitis, local points and
TianYing points (penetration of the bursa or cyst) are added. (I have had poor or no results
with AP in tendinitis until I used a 30 mW pulsed infrared Laser, applied to many points over
the medial, posterior and lateral edge of the tendon, with other APs). Laser gives better results
than AP in tendinitis but the longterm benefit in seriously trained/torn tendons is
questionable, unless the owner/trainer lays the horse off work for 10 months.
10. All species: anaesthetic emergencies (apnoea, respiratory arrest, cardiac arrest). The
main point is GV26, in the midline at the lower extremity of the nostrils. Occasionally, KI01
is added in small animals.
Immediately the emergency is noted, insert a needle, 19-30 gauge (depending on species),
into GV26, directing the needle towards the nasal septum. Stimulate the point by strong
twirling, rotation and pecking of the needle. (Some colleagues who were disappointed with
AP at GV26 in emergencies did not stimulate the needle adequately. Strong stimulation is
needed). In apnoea and respiratory arrest, expect a response in 10-60 seconds. Remove the
needles when breathing recommences. If there is no response in 60 seconds try artificial
respiration for a few minutes and needle again. The response in apnoea and respiratory arrest
is almost 100% if the heart continues to beat.
In cardiac arrest however, the response may be as low as 40% and stimulation of the point
must continue for up to 10 minutes. The method is very good in neonatal asphyxia, coma,
shock, traumatic shock and haemorrhagic shock. Remember GV26 + KI01 in shock,
collapse, coma, emergencies. Remember PC06 for cardiac cases, thorax, lung disorders,
nausea.
11. All species, nephritis, cystitis: Nephritis: BL22,23,58; GV03,04; SP06,09; ST25;
GB25; KI03 / + / BL24,25,27,28,31,32; ST28; TH09; SP14; LV08; KI07; CV06. Cystitis:
BL28,38,58; CV03,04; KI02,03; ST28 / + / BL23,25,26,31,32,33,54; GB26,29; SP06,09;
CV02; ST27. Main points for treatment are drawn from these lists, depending on the
symptoms and diagnosis. Also check for AhShi points in the lumbosacral and low abdominal
area and include these points.
Treat acute cases daily for 4-6 sessions, expecting a response by third session. Treat chronic
cases once/week. (Chronic nephritis, with marked fibrosis may have a low success-rate). If
vomiting or other signs are major signs, include points according to the symptoms (9). Point
injection, needling + moxa; electro-AP; electro-stimulation or ultrasound techniques may be
used.
AP ANALGESIA FOR SURGERY
b. enhancing the defence systems of the body to cope with the various challenges that the
organism meets.
a. Orthodox medicine has a very limited view of the causes of disease. Therefore, its
diagnoses are equally limited.
The concepts of holistic medicine have been discussed more fully elsewhere (5,6,7,8). The
holistic approach tries to assess how the external or internal environment may be changed
to help the health of the patient. Harmful electromagnetic fields may be neutralised or
eliminated; scars "obstructing the Channels" can be mobilised etc; diet can be altered or
supplemented; management errors in animal handling can be corrected etc.
b. By its nature AP is holistic, especially if practised in the more classical method, using the
laws of Choosing Points or the laws of Energetic AP (Pulse Diagnosis, Five-Phase Theory,
the Eight Principles etc (5,6,7,8).
AP works not only on the affected region, organ or symptom, but on the defence system of
the whole organism. It can not be compared validly with suppressive or symptomatic therapy
(aspirin/ analgesics/tranquillizer), nor with the diabetes-insulin dependence approach. In mild
diabetes, AP (at the correct points) helps to counteract any infection or mild inflammatory
changes in the pancreas, assists pancreatic function and helps the body to produce its own
insulin. The outcome of a successful course of AP in this case would be a patient who is kept
reasonably healthy by its own defence response. The patient is not dependent on exogenous
drugs or further AP ad infinitum to keep it healthy.
In our therapy, we must be ready to use whichever system or combination of systems which
we feel are necessary. In many instances, we will use the well-tried and usually successful
orthodox methods first. Only if they fail would the unorthodox methods be considered. In
other cases, where we know from past experiences that orthodox methods give unsatisfactory
results, we should be ready to try the unorthodox. AP is indicated in many of these cases.
One may decide to combine AP with medical therapy, say in acute infections. For example, in
acute pneumonia with fever, diluted antibiotic solutions may be injected at APs for the lung
(BL13; PC06; CV17; NX04; LU01 or 05 or 06) and at AP points for fever (GV14) and
immune response (LI04 or 11; ST36), so that the total dose of antibiotic is correct but many
active APs are also treated.
In the beginning, it is safer to use this combination method until one is reasonably advanced
in one's AP study. (From a research viewpoint, the combination method is not so satisfactory
as is makes it difficult to assess the value of AP in relation to the orthodox therapy). Later one
can use AP alone in suitable cases.
Drugs which may antagonise or reduce the effects of AP include: large doses of narcotics,
methadone, analgesics, corticosteroids, opiate antagonists (naloxone, naltrexone etc), alcohol,
tranquillizers or sedatives.
These drugs may antagonise or reduce the neural effects of AP at the level of the specific and
non-specific receptors in the brain, spinal cord and other target areas. Where possible, a
period of 24-28 hours abstinence from these drugs is advisable before AP treatment. Patients
on corticosteroid therapy should be weaned off steroids for some weeks before AP. Care
should be taken not to terminate steroid therapy too abruptly.
In certain circumstances, it may be necessary to administer sedatives or tranquillizers to
facilitate AP, for example in difficult patients (such as cats, vicious dogs or horses). The
alpha-2 agonist (opiate substitute) detomidine or medetomidine (Pharmos, Finland) is said to
enhance AP effects in horses and dogs. Administration of D-phenyl alanine (DPA) for some
days before AP analgesia in humans is said to enhance the depth of analgesia and to turn
"non-responders" into "responders".
Similarly, in AP analgesia, intravenous sedatives (diazepam etc) can be very useful
supplementary drugs. Also, small doses of general anaesthetic can be used with AP
analgesia (doses which would not adequate for good anaesthesia if AP was not given also).
In the treatment of withdrawal from cigarette smoking, a Dublin physician (Tom Elliott)
combined a mild dose of tranquillizer (Ativan, 1 mg/day) with press needles in the Earpoints
LU and ShenMen. His results were >80% successful at 4-5 weeks after commencement) as
compared with 45-65% success by other acupuncturists using the same points but no
tranquilliser.
In the treatment of human narcotic addiction, electro-stimulation of Earpoint "Lung" or the
mastoid processes has been very successful in detoxification without withdrawal symptoms,
but detoxification requires 4-8 days before urine tests are "negative" for the drug. A new
development (pioneered by H.L. Wen, Hong Kong) is to combine AP stimulation with
repeated i/v injection of naloxone. This reduces the detoxification period to about 10 hours.
(Naloxone displaces the drug very rapidly from the opiate receptors and AP prevents the
withdrawal symptoms by stimulating the release of endorphin, which had been inhibited by
the exogenous drug).
DEVELOPMENT OF INTUITIVE DIAGNOSIS AND HEALING
As I wrote the first version of this paper (1980), I was on holidays with my family in Fethard,
a fishing village on the South East coast of Ireland. A 7-year-old boy was drowned in a large
river a few miles away. The river is tidal and the drowning occurred while the tide was rising.
Dozens of fishermen with nets, grappling hooks, fishing lines etc dragged the river for 5 days.
They had the assistance of a diver also. The body was not recovered. A friend of the boy's
father knew of my unorthodox interests. He asked if I could suggest a diviner who might
locate the body. Next day, I brought the boy's father and his friend to Sgt. Neil Boyle, an
instructor in the Garda Training School, Templemore. This man is one of the most famous
diviners in Ireland. He does most of his divining in his own house by divining over a map!
Within minutes of our arrival, and working over an accurate navigation chart of the river, the
diviner got a reaction some 75 metres west of a fixed marker-buoy in the river. He said that
the body would be found there. The boy's father then exclaimed that the boy's teacher had
dreamed that the body was near there but the search party had not acted on this dream!
The search was switched to that area at 1900h on Friday night but was disrupted 3 times by
ships passing up the river. At about 2300h, one of the fishermen hooked a submerged object
but lost it. Early next morning, the body was seen floating on the surface of the river within
10 metres of the mark as indicated on the map by a man about 120 km distant from the spot!
The search was over. Was the diviner's mark a coincidence? Definitely not! This man has
located dozens of missing persons, alive or dead, using this technique. He usually knows
immediately if the missing person is dead. He has located them in lakes, rivers, the sea and on
land.
Development of intuitive diagnosis and healing was discussed in more detail elsewhere (7).
Those of you who already have some ability in this area (or who may be interested) will find
it very helpful to join groups or societies of professional colleagues (medical and vet) who
discuss these topics. Discussions with colleagues who know this reality can accelerate your
own growth in the area. AP is only one system! There are many others and combinations are
possible.
One such group is the Scientific and Medical Network, c/o: David Lorimer, Lesser
Halings, Tilehouse Lane, Denham, Uxbridge, Msex UB9 5DG, UK. (Fax: +44-1985835818; Email: Scientific and Medical Network @smnet.demon.co.uk, or,
100114.1637@compuserve.com)
If one wishes to grow in skill as a healer, one must continue to study many different methods.
Study must be a routine part of one's profession, despite the great difficulties that this poses to
private practitioners (and their partners and families!). What to study? There is so much in
orthodox literature that one could study specialist journals in one small area and never get
to the end! I would urge you, however, to read some unorthodox concepts, such as those on
osteopathy/chiropractic, homeopathy, food allergy, psychic phenomena, radiaesthesia. Even if
you can not yet accept their scientific validity, you will find them highly entertaining! Some
of you will know by "gut reaction" that their main claims are valid and you may be stimulated
to continue this aspect of your study in greater depth.
Special Interest Groups (SIGs) on Email and WWW: Those who want to explore the more
esoteric aspects of the psyche in healing can subscribe to SIGs on Email Lists (such as
CAM&VM, Holistic, INDHN etc; details on request), or visit specialist Home Pages on the
Internet (WWW), such as AltMed, AltVetMed, Dowsing Pages etc.
If one can improve one's intuitive or divining ability, it can be of great value in reaching a
detailed and accurate diagnosis as to the causes and nature of the problem. This gift alone
would be of great value. However, if one can also develop ones psychic (transmitting) healing
power, the healer and the patient are doubly blessed. There are a few who have these gifts. If
they are latent in you, please do not waste them. If (like me) you have mediocre talent in the
intuitive/psychic field, don't worry! The more rational pragmatic methods may be slower in
day-to-day use but they also give good results.
FOSTERING PUBLIC AWARENESS OF AP
TV and press coverage in recent years have informed most people that AP therapy and
analgesia for human surgery have definite roles in medical science. However, few people
know that AP is equally applicable in vet science. Research in humans and animals has shown
that AP is a powerful physiotherapy which involves reflex effects, humoral and
neuroendocrine effects (1,2,5,11).
While vets are learning the system and trying to integrate it into their approach to animal
diseases, they may not wish to enter into much discussion on the topic. Later, as they grow in
experience, they should gradually let their clients know that AP is just one more modality in
the fight against pain and illness. The mystique and magical image of AP, so often
exaggerated in the public press, should be dispelled. In its place, the concept of reflex
therapy (activation of the normal defence and healing systems of the body by the stimulation
of reflex points) should be fostered. If used properly, AP is the most powerful form of
physiotherapy. In incompetent hands, AP may give poor results and in the wrong hands, may
spread viral diseases (AIDS, hepatitis etc in humans; swine fever etc in animals).
Practitioners new to AP should replace the temptation to be over-enthusiastic with a more
pragmatic approach ("let us try it in this case"). Over-enthusiasm can lead to great
disappointment when failures occur.
AP, like every other attempt to fight disease, has its failures (2,15). It also can be a costly
system in terms of professional time. With orthodox vet medicine, many cases can be treated
by one or two visits, leaving appropriate medicines to the owner to administer when the vet
has diagnosed the case. This is not applicable with AP therapy, unless the owner has a TENS
instrument or Laser and is instructed in their use, or unless he/she is shown which points to
massage between sessions. In chronic cases, AP therapy often requires repeated therapy
sessions and these cost money. The owner should be warned of this, as some people expect
miraculous cures after one or two sessions!
In many western countries, physicians and vets, especially those in the academic life, have a
strong scepticism towards AP. Some are definitely prejudiced against AP. This is largely due
to lack of knowledge on the types of conditions which respond to AP and to the mechanisms
involved. We should discuss these topics with our colleagues when suitable opportunities
arise and we should be prepared to assist them in their search for factual data and research
information, should they require this.
It is very helpful to the practitioner and to those colleagues who may require clinical
information to keep accurate records of all cases treated by AP. These records should
contain details of the clinical examination, the diagnosis, the AP method and the APs used,
any other medication used, the dates of treatment and the outcome of the case. If 20-40 vets in
each country kept notes of their cases, very valuable information could be made available to
their AP society as well as to their State Vet Schools after 1-2 years. I strongly urge you to
organise such a study as a group.
CONCLUSIONS
Integration of AP into your practice will take time and patience. You will need to study AP
well and to foster public awareness of its value and mechanisms. Explanation of AP
mechanisms in terms of reflex action via the neuroendocrine system is more acceptable to
academic colleagues than those based on theories of intangible, undefined Life Forces (Qi).
In your early attempts at AP, it is advisable to choose just a few conditions which interest
you. Learn the approach to these in depth before you attempt to treat new conditions.
If you do not wish your clients and colleagues to know that you are attempting AP methods,
you can adapt ultrasound, electrostimulation and laser therapy with little difficulty. You can
also use point injection with good success. As you grow in experience, it will be better for you
(and for the acceptance of AP as a valid system) if you let your clients and colleagues know
that you are using the Chinese system.
Integration of AP analgesia as a routine preparation for surgery is not likely to become
popular in the West. However, it may be considered in high-risk patients, shock victims and
Caesarian section. The analgesia and obstetric effects of lumbosacral points in bovine
dystocia and bovine prolapsed uterus require no electro-stimulation and could become
routine.
A Chinese parable says: "What can a frog in a well know of the outside world?". There is a
mighty universe around us! Can we see it all? Can we feel it, taste it , touch it and smell it all?
Can we "weigh" (measure) the Energy of Life? I don't believe it! I believe that there are other
ways of knowing reality. To grow in knowledge and skill requires study and practice. I urge
you to study unorthodox as well as orthodox concepts. In particular, I urge you to read on
psychic methods of diagnosis and healing and to experiment with these systems together with
your orthodox methods and other therapeutic systems.
Therefore, I urge you to continue your studies, especially in areas of unorthodox concepts.
Study and experiment with the area of psychic phenomena such as dowsing or divining in
relation to healing. These methods are as applicable to animals as they are to humans. Some
of you may possess ability in these areas. I believe that the best therapy will consist of a
sound mechanical approach plus the extra benefits of the psychic approach.
REFERENCES
Further details of AP are in other lectures by the author. These and other manuscripts are
based on material presented in 1980 to the teaching seminar at the Veterinary College in
Helsinki, organised by Jukka Kuussaari. Most have been updated since 1990.
AP is a highly integrated system whose concepts and philosophies are strange to Westerners
at first. Thus, Western students of AP should read and re-read these concepts until they
become familiar with them.
The lectures, listed below, cover many traditional (classical) and modern (scientific) aspects
of AP and related topics. This set of lectures will help students of AP to get the "feel" for
subject. They complement lectures given at IVAS, BVAS and other organised training courses
on AP.
Vet or Medical colleagues are most welcome to use this material for study or teaching
purposes but the author reserves copyright and does not wish others to use this material for
commercial publications. All the papers starred (*) are in one publication (Acupuncture in
Animals, Proc 167, 548 pp) available from The Postgraduate Committee in Veterinary
Science, University of Sydney, 280 Pitt St., Sydney South, NSW, Australia 2000. Those not
starred are available from the author:
1*. A brief History of AP and the Status of veterinary AP outside mainland China
2*. Effects of AP on the Defence Systems and conditions responsive to AP (1980) and AP for
immune-mediated disorders (1991).