You are on page 1of 15

HOW TO MODEL EARTHQUAKE ACCORDING TO EC8 IN

AUTODESK ROBOT STRUCTURAL ANALISYS 2011


In order to present the steps to define earthquake loads in Robot we have
prepared the 4 story building that is represented bellow. The structure was the following
dimensions: 10.8mx28.2m and 15.5m height. There are 4 stories, 3m height each and
the ground floor 3.5m height.
As loads acting on structure we have modeled:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.

Self weight of elements: it is calculated automatically by the program.


Finishes: 1.5kN/m2
Non structural internal walls: 3.0kN/m2
Live loads: 2.0kN/m2 for each floor and 1.0kN/m2 for roof.
Snow: 1.6kN/m2

After completing the modeling of the geometry and loads it is time to define
earthquake loads. In Robot there are implemented many codes for earthquake. In our
case we used EN1998-1-1:2004.
The first step is to generate the Modal analysis case. In order to do this the user
has to access the Analysis Type command from the Analysis Menu. Below it is
presented the Analysis Type window. In this window we can see the load cases that
were defined earlier (1-5). To define Modal analysis press the New button.

By pressing the New button another window opens and here we have to select
the Modal option. As the windows shows the other options are not yet available
because in order to access them the modal analysis has to be already defined.

Alter selecting the Modal option and pressing the OK button the program opens
the window where the user can select the parameters for the modal analysis. This
window is presented bellow.

In this window the user must indicate the number of modes that the analysis will
calculate. Depending on the type of structure that is calculated and form the personal
experience the user has to indicate a number of modes. In our case we have indicated
70 modes. The most important rule is that after calculation, in the modal analysis results
table, the Relative mass on X and Y direction to be more than 90% in the last calculated
mode (in our case in the 70th mode). If this is not happening the user has to increase the
number of modes until this condition is fulfilled.
Another important option in this window is the Disregard density option. Now the
check box for this option is not checked. This means that the program will transform the
first case Self weight into masses automatically. So it is important that in the Load to
mass Conversion window the user not to convert this case into masses. There are
some cases where the user wants to have full control over the conversion of the loads
into masses and in this case the Disregard density option will be checked and the user
will indicate to the program to convert the self weight case into masses manually and
can also increase this mass by using a coefficient.
The user can select one of the three analysis modes:

Analysis Mode - modal


The modal analysis of the structure will be conducted. n vibration modes will be
found, the iterations will be completed if a convergence condition is reached.
Activation of Sturm Check, which allows for searching for the omitted
pulsations, is possible.
Analysis Mode - seismic
During modal structure analysis, n vibration modes will be selected (not
necessarily in the appropriate order). Those eigenvibration modes will be set, which are
important to seismic analyses, therefore those which are characterized by a large mass
participation factor.
A Sturm Check is not possible for this structure analysis mode.
Analysis Mode - seismic pseudomodal
Spectral and seismic analysis will be conducted using the pseudomodal
method. This should be used only when applying classic analysis methods based on
modal decomposition results in a very long structure analysis time.
The recommended option is the modal as we selected in our model. The other
two options are useful when there are problems with reaching the 90% relative mass
condition.
After selecting the modal analysis parameters press the OK button and return to
the Analysis Type window. As we can see now we have a 6 th case named Modal.

The next step is to generate the seismic analysis case. Press the New button
and see the New Case Definition window. Now, after defining the Modal case, there are
available all the other analysis types.

Select the seismic type and the EN 1998-1-1:2004 code, and press the OK
button. This will open the EC8 Parameters window presented below:

Parameters of a structure seismic analysis depend on a seismic code used


during calculations of a structure influenced by seismic impact.
The code dependant factors are editable for EN 1998-1-1:2004 General code;
their values can be changed in the national annexes.
To complete the seismic analysis according to the rules given in a code, define
the following parameters.

Value of the ag coefficient = 2.35m/s2

Behavior factor q (see the tables 1, 2, 3 and 4 of the code) = 3.9

Spectrum (design, elastic) = Design

Spectrum type (type 1, type 2) = type 1

Direction (horizontal, vertical) = Horizontal

Ground type (A,B,C,D,E,Envelope) = D

We can also indicate an eccentricity to the mass distribution by pressing the


Eccentricity definition button. The following window will open where we can indicate an
absolute value (in meters) or a relative (%) value on one or two directions

The next step is to indicate the direction definition parameters by pressing the
Direction definition button in the dynamic analysis parameter dialog to define the
direction of spectral/seismic excitation.

The Resolution of a force (seismic/spectral) into directions option generates


three seismic cases differing in direction of excitation. The excitation direction (X,Y,Z)
defined at the top of the dialog is appropriately resolved for the case, (X,0,0) (0,Y,0),
(0,0,Z). The names of the newly created cases contain information indicating which
direction the excitation is defined. Therefore, values defined in the X, Y, Z fields are
components of the excitation vector. Select Use normalized values to scale component
values so that the resultant vector is a unit vector.
Cases are generated as soon as the dialog for defining seismic/spectral
analysis parameters is closed.
Here we can also define combination between the three directions:
-

Newmark combination
Quadratic combination

In our case we have selected only Newmark combinations.

After selecting all the parameters and closing the window we will see that in the
Analysis Type window the program generated seismic cases(7,8,9) and Newmark
combinations (10-21).

The next step is to indicate the Load to Mass Conversion parameters in the
following window.

You can define loads/masses at once for all calculation purposes. It is not
necessary to define separately static loads or masses taken into account in structure
analyses (static and dynamic, respectively). On the basis of the pre-defined static loads
one may create masses to be used during dynamic calculations.
To convert static loads to masses, do the following.
1.

Determine the cases for which conversion of loads to masses will be carried
out. Provide the numbers of load cases; define the direction of the conversion
process and the multiplication coefficient to be applied to the value of the static
load.

2.

Determine the set of directions in the global coordinate system (X, Y, Z) along
which the masses will operate.

3.

Determine the dynamic analysis case that will use the masses created from
loads. Select Add Mass to Global Mass so the masses created from loads will
be taken into account in all cases of dynamic structure analyses.

4.

Click Add.

You can also delete or modify a load case as necessary.


Concentrated forces are automatically converted to concentrated masses,
distributed loads to distributed masses, and moments to rotational masses. Select
Loads > Mass table to view converted masses in the table of masses. Mass values are
presented in the table as weight values (acceleration of gravity is applied). Masses
created due to the conversion process are marked CNV in the Memo field to
differentiate them from user defined masses. The mark denotes the origin of a mass for
the benefit of the conversion procedure.
Note:
Conversion of loads to masses is always carried out at the beginning of
calculations. It begins with the removal of the masses generated during the previous
conversion. The change of the contents of the MEMO field in the table of masses may
result in a mass not being removed during conversion, which leads to duplication of
masses.
In the Added masses table, the Conversion of loads tab presents data
concerning masses (read only and printable). Individual table columns are as follows.

Converted case a number and a name of a converted case.


Conversion direction depending on a selected direction X+ / Y+ / Z+ / X- / Y/ Z-.

Factor - a dimensionless coefficient.

Mass direction - X, Y or Z.

Case - a number of the modal case to which a load is converted or dynamic for
all cases.

Now that all the parameters are indicated we can close the Analysis Type
window and perform a Calculation of the structure by selecting from Analysis menu the
Calculation command.
After the program finishes calculation we can read the first results about the
seismic analysis by selecting from the Results menu/Advanced/Modal Analysis. In the
table below we can see the results:

Here we can see that our structure has a period of 0.19 sec. This means that
the structure is very rigid.

Also we can see that the mass participation condition is fulfilled as in the 70 th
mode we have 92.39% on X direction and 90.64% on Y direction (values indicated by
green circles). In the case that these values were less that 90% we would have to
change in the modal analysis parameter window the number of modes (increasing it)
and recalculate the structure until the condition is fulfilled.
Before reading the results on bars there is one more important thing to do. We
have to indicate for each case the Combination Sign in the Analysis Type window.

The top part of the dialog consists of the following fields.

Case - The number of a seismic or spectral analysis case


Main mode The number of the main mode for determining the sign of the
given combination.

Click Set to ascribe the selected mode to the seismic or spectral case.
The middle part of the dialog contains a table for the seismic and spectral analyses of
the current structure. For each type of analysis, the table presents the following data.

Case number

Case name

Main mode (user defined in the top of the dialog or 0) - The sign of the results
for this mode will be assumed for the entire combination.

If a main mode is set to 0, then the combination sign calculated from the formula for
calculating CQC or SRSS combinations will be assumed.
The bottom part of the dialog box selects the default type of calculations to be applied in
the case of seismic combination.
CQC - Complete Quadratic Combination
SRSS - Square Root of Sums of Squares
10% - 10% double sum
2SM - double sum.
In order to choose the main mode on each direction we have to return to the
Modal Analysis results table. Here we can see with red circles the values that indicates
the main modes for each direction.
The rule is to see for each direction which mode has the biggest value for
Current mass. In our case we can see that in the X direction we have in the 2nd mode
71.29% , in the Y direction we have in the 1st mode 70.68% and in the Z direction we
have in the 4th mode 45.76%.
With the definition of the main modes we have finished the modeling of the
seismic cases according to EN1998-1-1:2004. Now we can proceed to the design of the
structure elements.