You are on page 1of 2

30418 Federal Register / Vol. 70, No.

101 / Thursday, May 26, 2005 / Notices

7208.26.00.30, 7208.26.00.60, Normally, if a respondent sources an 773(c)(1) of the Tariff Act of 1930.
7208.27.00.30, 7208.27.00.60, input from a market–economy supplier, Where an NME producer purchases
7208.36.00.30, 7208.36.00.60, the Department will use the average inputs from market economy suppliers
7208.37.00.30, 7208.37.00.60, input price paid by the respondent to and pays in a market–economy
7208.38.00.15, 7208.38.00.30, market economy suppliers (in market currency, however, the Department uses
7208.38.00.90, 7208.39.00.15, economy currency) to value all of the the actual price paid for these inputs,
7208.39.00.30, 7208.39.00.90, given input (both imported and where possible. See Final Determination
7208.40.60.30, 7208.40.60.60, domestically–sourced) used by of Sales at Less Than Fair Value:
7208.53.00.00, 7208.54.00.00, respondents, provided three conditions Oscillating Fans and Ceiling Fans from
7208.90.00.00, 7210.70.30.00, are met. First, the volume of the the People’s Republic of China, 56 FR
7210.90.90.00, 7211.14.00.30, imported input as a share of total 55271 (October 25, 1991). Where a
7211.14.00.90, 7211.19.15.00, purchases from all sources must be portion of the factor input is purchased
7211.19.20.00, 7211.19.30.00, ‘‘meaningful,’’ a term used in the from a market economy supplier and the
7211.19.45.00, 7211.19.60.00, Preamble to the Regulations but which remainder from a nonmarket economy
7211.19.75.30, 7211.19.75.60, is interpreted by the Department on a supplier, the Department will normally
7211.19.75.90, 7212.40.10.00, case–by-case basis. See Antidumping value the factor using the price paid to
7212.40.50.00, and 7212.50.00.00 of the Duties; Countervailing Duties; Final the market–economy supplier. See 19
HTSUS. Certain hot–rolled flat–rolled Rule, 62 FR 27296, 27366 (May 19, CFR 351.408(c)(1). The Department
carbon–quality steel covered by this 1997) (Preamble). See, also, Shakeproof declines to value a given factor using
order, including vacuum degassed and v. United States, 268 F.3d 1376, 1382 prices paid to market economy
fully stabilized, high strength low alloy, (Fed. Cir. 2001). Second, this average suppliers when the quantity is not
and the substrate for motor lamination import price must reflect bona fide ‘‘meaningful’’, because, in such cases,
steel may also enter under tariff sales. Third, the Department disregards the NME producer may not be able to
numbers 7225.11.00.00, 7225.19.00.00, all inputs it has reason to believe or purchase all of the inputs it needs for
7225.30.30.50, 7225.30.70.00, suspect might be dumped or subsidized. the input at that price. See Preamble, 62
7225.40.70.00, 7225.99.00.90, The Department is now considering FR at 27366. In keeping with its
7226.11.10.00, 7226.11.90.30, options to change certain aspects of its standard practice concerning factor
7226.11.90.60, 7226.19.10.00, current policy and practice regarding valuation, the Department also declines
7226.19.90.00, 7226.91.50.00, market economy input prices, and to accept prices when it believes the
7226.91.70.00, 7226.91.80.00, and through this notice, invites public transaction was not conducted at arm’s
7226.99.00.00. Although the HTSUS comment on the options detailed below. length. Finally, the Department does not
subheadings are provided for This notice is part of an ongoing effort accept prices of goods sold when it has
convenience and customs purposes, the by which the Department is considering reason to believe or suspect that the
written description of the scope of the modifications to its NME policy and goods may be dumped or subsidized.
order is dispositive. practice. The Department may solicit The Department is considering
[FR Doc. E5–2680 Filed 5–25–05; 8:45 am] additional public comment on other changes to the policy and practice
BILLING CODE 3510–DS–S
possible changes, as well. detailed above, in particular, to its
DATES: Comments must be submitted by interpretation of what constitutes a
June 24, 2005. ‘‘meaningful’’ quantity of an input
DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE sourced from a market economy
ADDRESSES: Written comments (original country. Under current practice, a
International Trade Administration and six copies) should be sent to Joseph ‘‘meaningful’’ quantity above which the
A. Spetrini, Acting Assistant Secretary Department will use market economy
Market Economy Inputs Practice in
for Import Administration, U.S. input prices to value all of an input is
Antidumping Proceedings involving
Department of Commerce, Central determined on a case–by-case basis. To
Non–Market Economy Countries.
Records Unit, Room 1870, Pennsylvania address a concern that basing the entire
AGENCY: Import Administration, Avenue and 14th Street NW, input value on a small amount of
International Trade Administration, Washington, DC 20230. purchases might not be the most
Department of Commerce. FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: accurate reflection of what a company
ACTION: Request for Comments. Lawrence Norton, Economist, or pays to source the entire input, the
Anthony Hill, Senior International Department is considering whether to
SUMMARY: In antidumping proceedings Economist, Office of Policy, Import apply certain criteria in determining
involving non–market economy Administration, U.S. Department of whether the amounts purchased from a
(‘‘NME’’) countries, the Department of Commerce, 14th Street and Constitution market economy supplier are
Commerce (‘‘the Department’’) Avenue, NW, Washington DC, 20230, ‘‘meaningful.’’ There is further concern
calculates normal value by valuing the 202–482–1579 or 202–482–1843. that our current practice may allow
NME producers’ factors of production, SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: parties to manipulate the Department’s
to the extent possible, using prices from margin calculations by sourcing just
a market economy that is at a Background enough of an input from market
comparable level of economic In an NME antidumping proceeding, economy suppliers so that the market
development which is also a significant the Department bases its calculation of economy price is used to value the
producer of comparable merchandise. normal value on the NME producers’ entire input, even though that party
The goal of this surrogate factor factors of production, valued, to the does not source the entire input from
valuation is to use the ‘‘best available extent possible, using prices from a foreign (market economy) suppliers in
information.’’ See section 773(c)(1) of market economy that is at a comparable the normal course of business. In such
the Tariff Act of 1930; Shangdong level of economic development and that situations, concern has been expressed
Huraong General Corp. v. United States, is also a significant producer of that the market economy prices the
159 F. Supp.2d 714, 719 (CIT 2001). comparable merchandise. See section Department would use to value an

VerDate jul<14>2003 19:11 May 25, 2005 Jkt 205001 PO 00000 Frm 00009 Fmt 4703 Sfmt 4703 E:\FR\FM\26MYN1.SGM 26MYN1
Federal Register / Vol. 70, No. 101 / Thursday, May 26, 2005 / Notices 30419

entire input may not be reflective of Internet at the Import Administration NOAA solicits comments on this action
actual prices. Web site at the following address: http:/ to ensure that the granting of these
These concerns, along with a general /ia.ita.doc.gov/. licenses is consistent with statutory
effort by the Department to examine its Any questions concerning file provisions related to the licensing of
long–standing policies, have prompted formatting, document conversion, federally owned inventions.
the Department to review its practice access on the Internet, or other DATES: All comments are due by August
concerning the use of prices paid by a electronic filing issues should be 26, 2005.
respondent to market economy input addressed to Andrew Lee Beller, Import
ADDRESSES: All comments and
suppliers. The appendix to this notice Administration Webmaster, at (202)
describes two broad approaches for applications must be mailed to: John H.
482–0866, email address: webmaster–
revising the Department’s practice in Raubitschek, Patent Counsel,
support@ita.doc.gov.
this area. The first approach would use Department of Commerce, Room 4835,
Dated: May 19, 2005. HCHB, Washington DC 20230.
market economy prices for inputs, but
Joseph A. Spetrini, FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CONTACT: For
would limit their use to the valuation of
Acting Assistant Secretary for Import further information, please contact Mr.
the imported portion of the input only.
Administration. Raubitschek at 202–482–8010.
Under the second approach, the
Department would continue to use Appendix SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: Pursuant
market economy import prices to value (1) Is it appropriate for the Department to 35 U.S.C. 209(e), the Environmental
an entire input if it found the quantity to change its regulations and end its Technology Laboratory, Oceanic and
of imports to be meaningful, but would long–standing practice of using market Atmospheric Research Laboratories
apply certain criteria for determining economy import prices to value an publish this notice to announce its
what constitutes a ‘‘meaningful’’ entire input? For example, should the intent to grant Vaisala, Inc. and Sonoma
amount. We invite comment on these Department use market economy import Technology, Inc. co-exclusive licenses
and any other options regarding the prices to value only the portion of the to the following patents:
Department’s practice concerning input that was imported, and use U.S. Patent 5,592,171 entitled ‘‘Wind
market economy inputs in NME surrogate country prices to value the Profiling Radar’’
antidumping cases. remainder of the input? U.S. Patent 5,872,535 entitled
Comments (2) Assuming the Department continues ‘‘Removing Buoy Motion from
its long–standing practice of using Wind Profiler Moment’’
Persons wishing to comment should
market economy import prices to value U.S. Patent 6,753,807 entitled
file a signed original and six copies of
an entire input, what should the ‘‘Combination N-way Power
each set of comments by the date
threshold be for the share or volume of Divider/Combiner and Noninvasive
specified above. The Department will
a given input sourced from market Reflected Power Detection
consider all comments received before
the close of the comment period. economy suppliers to qualify as The proposed co-exclusive licenses
Comments received after the end of the ‘‘meaningful’’ in order for the import will be royalty bearing and will comply
comment period will be considered, if price to be used to value all of the with the terms and conditions of 35
possible, but their consideration cannot input? U.S.C. 209 and 37 CFR 404.7. The
(3) Please provide any additional views proposed licenses may be granted
be assured. The Department will not
on any other matter pertaining to the unless written evidence is received that
accept comments accompanied by a
Department’s practice concerning the establishes that the grant of the licenses
request that a part or all of the material
use of market economy import prices. would not be consistent with 35 U.S.C.
be treated confidentially because of its
business proprietary nature or for any [FR Doc. E5–2677 Filed 5–25–05; 8:45 am] 209. Any comments, including an
other reason. The Department will BILLING CODE: 3510–DS–S application for a license in any or all of
return such comments and materials to the above-identified patents, must be
the persons submitting the comments mailed to the individual listed in the
and will not consider them in the DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE ADDRESSES heading.
development of any changes to its National Oceanic and Atmospheric Dated: May 3, 2005.
practice. All comments responding to Administration Louisa Koch,
this notice will be a matter of public Deputy Assistant Administrator, OAR.
record and will be available for public [Docket No: 050511129–5129–01]
[FR Doc. 05–10555 Filed 5–25–05; 8:45 am]
inspection and copying at Import BILLING CODE 3510–65–P
Administration’s Central Records Unit, Notice of Availability for License and
Room B–099, between the hours of 8:30 Intent To Grant Co-Exclusive Patent
a.m. and 5 p.m. on business days. The Licenses
Department requires that comments be CORPORATION FOR NATIONAL AND
AGENCY: National Oceanic and COMMUNITY SERVICE
submitted in written form. The Atmospheric Administration,
Department recommends submission of Department of Commerce. Proposed Information Collection;
comments in electronic form to ACTION: Notice and request for Comment Request
accompany the required paper copies. comments.
Comments filed in electronic form AGENCY: Corporation for National and
should be submitted either by e–mail to SUMMARY: The Environmental Community Service.
the webmaster below, or on CD–ROM, Technology Laboratory, Oceanic and ACTION: Notice.
as comments submitted on diskettes are Atmospheric Research Laboratories,
likely to be damaged by postal radiation National Oceanic and Atmospheric SUMMARY: The Corporation for National
treatment. Administration publish this notice to and Community Service (hereinafter the
Comments received in electronic form announce the intent to grant Vaisala, Corporation), as part of its continuing
will be made available to the public in Inc. and Sonoma Technology Inc. co- efforts to solicit donations in
Portable Document Format (PDF) on the exclusive licenses. Through this notice, furtherance of the purposes of the

VerDate jul<14>2003 19:11 May 25, 2005 Jkt 205001 PO 00000 Frm 00010 Fmt 4703 Sfmt 4703 E:\FR\FM\26MYN1.SGM 26MYN1

You might also like