Test Preparation
To prepare to conduct the usability tests, I visited UnionStation.org on my HP EliteBook
laptop using Google Chrome for my browser. I walked myself through each task and noted what
happened as I tried to complete them. Those notes are below.
Task 1: You are bringing your grandmother to Union Station for a Sunday afternoon
outing. She cant walk more than about 50 steps at a time. Determine whether or not there
will be a wheelchair available for her to use during the visit.
I initially clicked on Plan Your Visit in the main navigation. This brought me to a page
with admission information, hours, maps, parking information, and amenity information. The
section titled Amenities and Transportation was closest to what I believed I was looking for. It
was at the very bottom of the page. I am concerned this may deter visitors from finding the
information. The information under this section is very brief, providing a link to another more
detailed page. Wheelchairs are mentioned, but in just one word and in the middle of the
paragraph. Visitors could easily miss that crucial word. Clicking on the link Guest Amenities
took me to a page with more information on things like ATMs, Lost and Found, and Wheelchairs.
There I found the answer to the task, although it is somewhat ambiguous. It gives the location
where wheelchairs can be picked up but states that wheelchairs are available on a first come
first serve basis for our guests at no extra charge.
Task 2: You want to plan to see an Extreme Screen movie during your visit, so you want to
secure tickets in advance. Determine what is playing on Wednesday, November 25.
From the Guest Amenities page, I clicked on Plan Your Visit. Near the top of that
page, in the Admission Information section, are ticket prices for various parts of the station,
including the Reigner Extreme Screen Theatre. To the far right of the prices is a link where I was
prompted to Buy Tickets. I clicked on this and it took me to a page listing movies. I was
initially unsure of how to find out which movies would be playing on Wednesday, November 25
until I noticed that below each movie section to the right was a timeline of when they would be
playing; for example: 10/13/2015 To 4/2/2016. I determined that Robots 3D and Jerusalem
will be playing on November 25.
Task 3: Go through the steps of buying two tickets for an Extreme Screen movie on that
day. Determine whether or not you can choose the actual seats so that you and your
grandmother will have wheelchair-compatible seating.
I chose to buy tickets for Robots 3D. I first clicked on a button that said Add to Basket
under the Robots 3D picture and description. On the next page, when prompted to enter the date I
wanted to purchase tickets for, it gave me a drop-down list of dates such as Tues 11/3/2015.
This was hard to read and confusing to pick to correct date in a huge list of numbers. After
finding the correct date, I clicked another Add to Basket button which then took me to another
page where I chose how many tickets I wanted. On the next page, I was provided with the total
amount. There was a small button near the top of My Tickets section that said Select Seats
with an icon of a mouse choosing from a row of boxes. I clicked on this and was taken back to
the previous page where I chose the number of seats I wanted. I initially thought I did something
wrong and so repeated this action. However, the same thing happened and I realized this was
simply a misdirection. I determined that users cannot choose specific seats when buying tickets
online.
Task 4: Youd like to spend time walking around Union Station during your visit, but you
want to be sure enough areas of the station will be wheelchair-friendly. Go through the
steps to send an email to the appropriate person/department to inquire about wheelchair
access throughout all areas of Union Station.
It was hard to maneuver back to the home page. Clicking on the logo at the top of the
page did not bring me back home. The site I was on was a separate site from UnionStation.org
with the address BoxOffice.UnionStation.org. I had to reenter the address to get back to the
actual site. After returning to the home page, I clicked on Contact in the main navigation. This
page had the phone number of Union Station and a list of emails for different departments. I was
unsure of which department would be the best to contact. I decided on Visitor Relations. I
clicked on the provided email address and an email message popped up with the address already
entered.
Choosing Participants
Tester 1: Krystal Brier
Krystal Brier is a 19 year old female. Ms. Brier is from Cameron, Missouri, a small town.
She is currently a student at Northwest Missouri State University. She is also a Resident
Assistant in Hudson Hall on campus. Krystal spends an average of 24 hours a week using the
web. She estimates that the split between browsing and social media is 50/50. Some of her
favorite websites are Facebook.com, Buzzfeed.com, and Pinterest.com. She has never visited
UnionStation.org. When asked if she considered herself a high-experience or low-experience
user of the internet, she hesitated but said high-experience. After a moment, however, she said,
Maybe I would be medium? But that isnt an option, so high. Although she self-identified as a
medium-to-high-experience user, based on Krystals previous interaction with the web and her
low experience with the site she is my low-experience tester.
Environment for Tester 1
Location of the test: I went to Ms. Briers residence hall room on the second floor of
Hudson Hall. Ms. Brier spends most of her free time in her room and goes there to relax.
When she is out of her room, she is at class, at meetings, working on school work, or
interacting with residents. Her room is the one place where she can have privacy and
wind down from the day. It is where she spends the most time browsing and web. She sat
in her rocking chair while I conducted the test, as that is the spot in her room she most
being slow. The browser she used was Google Chrome. The only browser add-on was Ad
Blocker. Her screen resolution was 1366 x 768.
Location of test: The test was conducted at Jacks parents house in Omaha, Nebraska.
Although he technically lives in Virginia, he feels extremely at home in his parents
house. This is where he gets to relax when he is home. Jack sat on a couch in his living
the doors and windows were all open, providing nice natural lighting.
Technical environment: Jack used a MacBook Pro for this usability test. His browser
was Google Chrome and it had multiple browser add-ons. One add-on was Google
Hangouts, a messaging app. Another was Motorola Connect, which allows the user to see
incoming texts and calls through Google Chrome. He also had Google Cast as an add-on
which connects to Chromecast through Chrome. Finally, he had Destiny Item Manager
which is an app for the video game Destiny. Jack was connected to the Wi-Fi in his
house, which he noted is really fast.
Test Results
Initial Site Thoughts
Tester 1 Report: To get to UnionStation.org, Krystal typed union station into the
search bar and clicked on the websites link from Google. The page took roughly 2
seconds to load and Krystal did not comment on the load time. Krystal noted the
following about the site, Wow, colorful. I can look at events, plan to go to the Union
Station I guess, and I could connect with them. I can look at news, like announcements
about Science City and daVinci. I can explore. They have restaurants, thats cool! Oh, I
like these banners that list the restaurants. Thats a cool design. Theres the hours and
maps, thats really nice to have. Theres a lot of information on this one page. But its
mapped out nicely. Krystal took her time looking at each aspect of the page and scrolled
through the whole front page. She scrolled using the tracking pad, which she did for the
entire test. Her facial expressions during this part were pretty neutral, except for a bit of
Task 1: You are bringing your grandmother to Union Station for a Sunday afternoon
outing. She cant walk more than about 50 steps at a time. Determine whether or not there
will be a wheelchair available for her to use during the visit.
Tester 1
Krystal immediately started scrolling after I read the task. She scrolled to the bottom and
clicked on the About Union Station link. She scrolled through that page and said Theres
nothing there. She scrolled to the bottom of the About Union Station page and clicked on the
Building Map link. She said was looking for places wheelchairs could go. She asked me to
restate the question, so I did. She was very flustered at this point, squinting her eyes at the screen
a lot. She kept looking at the map for a place where wheelchairs would be located. The said
Well there isnt even an elevator here so I dont know why they would have wheelchairs. She
returned to the home page and said I dont know. I asked her what she would do next if she
was stuck but really wanted to find out and she said, I would probably call them, but as she
said that she scrolled to the bottom again and said, Wait, guest amenities! She clicked on that
link and upon arriving at the Guest Amenities page, looked and scrolled and found the
Wheelchairs section. She read it and said What if we came late and there were no
wheelchairs?
Tester 2
After I read the task, Jack said Oh man, like he was unsure of what to do. But he
immediately scrolled to the bottom and looked at the available links. He hovered briefly over
Facility Rentals but ultimately, and pretty quickly, right-clicked on Guest Amenities and had
it open in a new tab. I asked him if he was considering clicking on another link and he said, If
this doesnt work, I will probably go back and click on Facility Rentals. However, he found
the Wheelchairs section right away on the page and said That was pretty easy, maybe I got
lucky.
Answer: There are wheelchairs to use on a first come first serve basis.
Completed: Yes
Task 2: You want to plan to see an Extreme Screen movie during your visit, so you want to
secure tickets in advance. Determine what is playing on Wednesday, November 25.
Tester 1
Krystal said, I remember seeing something about tickets, and went back to the home
page. She scrolled down to the section with banners and under the one labeled Screens &
Stages found the Reigner Extreme Screen Theatre. She clicked on this and found that this page
had primarily general information about the theatre, like features of the screen and projectors.
She said, I dont think theres any ticket stuff here. She clicked on the red button labeled
More Info without really reading the text above it and that took her to a page where she could
request to rent out the theatre for an event. She backed out and tried to click on Events Here
but it was just text. She then clicked on, underneath the Events Here headline, a specific movie
- Jerusalem. At this point, Krystal was getting frustrated. She read the dates it would be playing
and said, Well it doesnt say it wont be playing on November 25. She hit the back button and
did the same for Robots 3D and The Martian. Through this time-consuming and clunky action,
she determined that Robots 3D and Jerusalem would be playing on November 25.
Tester 2
Jack closed out of the Guest Amenities page he had opened on a new page, and back on
the home page clicked on the top tab Plan Your Visit. He scrolled down and determined that
the whole Union Station would be open on November 25. He then said, I dont think I can do
anything else useful here. So he clicked on the top tab Events Calendar. He maneuvered it to
November 25. He initially clicked on Robots 3D, but then said, Well if it shows up here, it must
be playing that day, so he clicked the back button. He then looked at the other movies listed for
November 25 and said, SoRobots 3D and Jerusalem will be playing.
Completed: Yes
Another recommendation I have for this task to improve UX is to revise the wording of
Plan Your Visit. I understand why they chose that language, but I am not sure that it connects
well with users. Krystal did not once consider it for this task and Jack clicked on it, but was
confused by the content. The wording also makes it seem like the page will have more interactive
features, which it does not. I would recommend changing the name of that tab to Visit Us. This
more accurately describes what the user will find on the page: ticket prices, maps, and hours.
Changing the wording would improve the heuristic Match Between System and the Real World.
It is important to speak the users language. I would not be surprised if UnionStation.org
believed themselves to be doing so by using the wording of Plan Your Visit, but the testers did
not respond to it.
Additionally, Krystal struggled a lot with this task and that stemmed from her initial click
on the link Reigner Extreme Screen Theatre. Her experience would have been much quicker
had that page had a red button labeled Buy Tickets on it. It only makes sense to have that
function available on a page dedicated to the Extreme Screen. Most people will want to buy
tickets, not look at specs.
Task 3: Go through the steps of buying two tickets for an Extreme Screen movie on that
day. Determine whether or not you can choose the actual seats so that you and your
grandmother will have wheelchair-compatible seating.
Tester 1
From the page she was on, Reigner Extreme Screen Theatre, Krystal clicked on The
Martian. She then remembered that she had decided in the last task that that movie would not be
playing on November 25. She backed out and then noticed the Events Calendar tab at the top
and said, Oh, look at that! Jeez, that wouldve been nice. She clicked on it and maneuvered the
calendar to November 25. From there she chose Jerusalem and clicked the red More Info
button underneath it. On the next page, she clicked Buy Tickets. On the next page, she said,
All I can do is add to basket in a puzzled tone, and then asked Do I have to be a member? Oh,
wait, no. I asked her why she thought that and she said because of the gray banner at the top that
said Members must be logged in to see discounts shown in shopping cart. But she clicked the
red Add to Basket button. She was then prompted to enter the date. She scrolled through the
dates and said out loud Eleven twenty-five before choosing the correct date. I asked her why
she said that out loud and she said, Its kinda confusing to have to put it in number form. After
she chose the day, she hit an Add to Basket button again. Next she selected the number of
tickets. Then she said, I guess I cant choose seats, but I prompted her to keep following the
process. The next page was the checkout page. She saw the Select Seats link and icon and
clicked on it. When it redirected her to the page where she chose the number of seats, she said I
guess it doesnt work.
Tester 2
Jack chose Robots 3D from the Events Calendar page. He clicked the red More Info
button and then clicked the red Buy Tickets button. He was prompted to choose the date and he
said, This is annoying. I already told them which date I wanted when I chose it on the
calendar! After choosing the date, he clicked the Add to Basket button and said, I cant
choose my seats. I told him to keep going. So he chose 2 tickets and clicked Add to Basket
again. On the next page, the checkout page, he saw the Select Seats link right away and clicked
on it. He said, Oh, weird. Hold on, let me do it again. It redirected me. He scrunched up his
face in a confused, concentrated face. He actually clicked Select Seats three times just to make
sure it wasnt working and he said, It seems like the website is broken. He then clicked on
Assign Owners to see if that would let him pick the seats, but he determined it would not. He
said, Okay let me try another movie. Maybe because this one is 3D? He went through the
whole process again with Jerusalem but decided it was not possible.
I believe adding a calendar function would improve the heuristic of Error Prevention. In a dropdown selection full of numbers, it would be extremely easy to choose the incorrect date. With a
calendar, the visual aspect helps the user see both the day of the week and the actual date.
Finally, the actual goal of this task was to select specific seats that would be wheelchair
accessible. This is not currently possible, as both testers determined. However, the frustrating
aspect is that it seems like it is possible because of a small icon labeled Select Seats. Below is
a screenshot showing the icon, which is circled.
Both testers clicked on this believing it would allow them to choose specific seats. What it
actually did was take them back to the page where they selected the number of tickets they
wanted to buy. They both repeated the action, perhaps believing it was their own mistake.
However, they ultimately put the blame on the website itself, with Jack saying, It seems like the
website is broken, and Krystal saying, I guess it doesnt work. This needs to be changed in
some way. I would recommend first that they do put in a function where the user can choose
specific seats to buy. This will aid people with disabilities and make their site, and theatre, more
inclusive. If, for some reason, this is not possible, then the name of the icon needs to be changed
to something like Select Number of Tickets to accurately represent what will happen when the
user clicks on it.
Task 4: Youd like to spend time walking around Union Station during your visit, but you
want to be sure enough areas of the station will be wheelchair-friendly. Go through the
steps to send an email to the appropriate person/department to inquire about wheelchair
access throughout all areas of Union Station.
Tester 1
To begin the task, Krystal clicked on the Union Station logo at the top of the page she
was on. She realized it was not a link to the home page and so clicked the back button roughly 4
times to get back to the actual site. She clicked on the Contact tab in the top row of tabs. Upon
arriving at the Contact page she said, Whoa, thats a lot of emails. Her initial reaction was to
say, I dont think theres a specific email for this, but after a few more seconds scrolling, she
said, Oh Visitor relations, thats what I would email. She clicked on it and a blank email from
her school account popped up.
Tester 2
Jack tried clicked on the Union Station logo at the top of the page once, and then twice
quickly, but saw it didnt link to anything. He audibly sighed and then clicked the back button to
get back to the home page. He scrolled to the bottom of the page and clicked on Contact Us. At
this page, he looked at all options and said, Visitor Relations seems like my best bet. He
clicked on their email and because he didnt have email set up on his computer, it opened up his
email app and prompted him to set up an account. He said he would copy the link and paste it
into an email via his Gmail account.
Completed: Yes.
emailing the correct department instead of clicking to the Contact page. It would also ensure
that users are emailing the correct department because the website would put the emails in the
appropriate places. Below is an example of how this recommendation might look, with the
changed section circled.
Testing Conclusions
Completion Rate:
Both Krystal and Jack had a 100% completion rate, completing four out of four
tasks. This is much higher than the average task completion rate of 78%. There are a few
things I believe contributed to this high completion rate. First, I think Krystal would have
given up on the first and third task had I not encouraged her to keep going. I felt that from
pushing her to keep going, I would gather more information from the test and better see
potential areas for improvement on the site. Jack also might have not completed the third
task because he said I cant choose my seats, but I encouraged him to keep going by
telling him to pretend he really wanted to see this movie.
faced less frustration as he completed the tasks easier, but he became noticeably agitated
when the website did not work the way he wanted to. Both Krystal and Jack were relaxed
and not in stressful situations during the tests, so I believe their frustration came purely
from the tasks and website. Users have low patience and it is extremely important to
remember that when building and designing websites.
However, even as you scroll down, the aesthetic remains. The website uses a neutral
color pallet of gray, tan, and red. The red is used sparingly, primarily for buttons like
More Info or Buy Tickets. This coloring of the website is appealing to the eye and
does not overwhelm.
The most important aspect of this heuristic, though, is that the content of the site
is necessary and relevant. The Visitor Info section on the home page is a great example
of the minimalist design utilized on this site.
As shown above, this section is extremely helpful to users looking to physically visit
Union Station. It is full of information, including hours, a map, parking information, and
ticket information. However, it does not look cluttered and there is no irrelevant content.
There are buttons that can lead users to other pages that go deeper into the subjects, but
this is a solid, succinct overview on the home page.
Another example of UnionStation.orgs minimalist design can be seen on their
About Us page. It is designed well and shows their personality.
Above is a screen shot of the first section of the About Us page. It is a simple design
that looks clean and professional. The use of a blueprint as the feature picture shows their
strong connection to their history and roots. And the copy underneath is descriptive,
engaging, and simple. It is not necessarily functional copy, but it does work to describe
the environment and experience of Union Station adventurous, historical, and inclusive.
This page is aesthetically appealing but there is also a purpose to everything on the page,
which is why I believe UnionStation.org is already succeeding at Aesthetic and
Minimalist Design.