You are on page 1of 21

?

...


...

2



2 (..2507)

2507



100 17 2558
5 13.30 15.30 .
2
www.puey.in.th/index.php task=view&id=12

100



15

1.
3


4





state capture regulatory capture5

100
3

, , ,
8 .. 2549.
4
, , , 21, 4, 2546.
5
state capture

state capture , regulatory capture
state capture, regulatory capture
The World Bank, Anticorruption in Transition A Contribution to the Policy Debate, Washington D.C. 2000 ,
xv-xvi; Oleksiy Omelyanchuk, Explaining State Capture and State Capture Modes: The Cases of Russia and Ukraine, Budapest, 2001.
Http://www.ualberla.ca/CIUS/stasiuk/st-pdf/Explaining State Capture.pdf , 31 2015; Boehm, Frederic , Regulatory Capture Revisited Lessons from
Economics of Corruption, Ph.D Economics, Anti-Corruption Training & Consulting (ACTC), and Research Center for Political Economy (CIEP, Universidad Externado
de Colombia), Working Paper,July 2007. State
capture, regulatory capture

Petty Grand Petty Corruption


()
Grand Corruption
state capture



7


8

2. 15
9 2
Petty Corruption
Grand Corruption


2542 2557
6

, . , ..
2537, 1.
7
, , Freidrich Ebert Stiftung, 2557 . .
8
Prakash Chander, Address, The XI Annual Conference of the Asian Law & Economics Association,
, 10, , 2558, 105, , .
9


()

10
? 10 4.811
9012 2
3 2542
2557 3 ( 1)
1
..

2542

2557


(10%)

10

4.8


()

9,722

5,016

15,400

1,648*

() (2557
)

( )

, , ,

, , ,


15


EDI
10


, (.) 2557, www.trf.or.th
11
. 6.
12
2542 = 15,400 2557 4,949 2557 1,648


13


( Corruption Perception Index CPI )
(Transparency International TI 1)
1 (CPI) (TI)

CPI


CPI
14
CPI 0 100 100

1 CPI
15 ..2541 ..2556 CPI
15

13
14

2557, , 48-49.
, , 3-4.

61 2542
102 255615
2556 ( 5, 53 94 )
2541
430
63
36
500,000

16

..2535
30 -50
17
.. 254318
600
43.6 50.3
6.2




15

1998 2013 85 175


:
,
2541, 179, 209
17
, 20 2533.
18
, , .. 2543
: , 2543.
16

?




2556
63 4,298,584,817
(30 )



...

10 19 2558 ...
180

4.3 20
21


. (.1) (.)
( .) Directors
Certification Program (DCP)

19

30 2556. 4.3 ; 22 2558


... 179 . 25 2558. 19 2558.

21
, , 24 2558 12.
20


? ?
4.3 ?

2554

200
5
20 ...
22
4 ( 2557) ...
46,141,038 23

...
19124


.1 .


.... ...

22

, 27 2558;
200 , THAIPUBLICA, 25 . 2554. Thaipublica.org/2011/supoj-robbery-game/ 27 ..2558.
23
46 , Thai Publica 1 2557. ...
.. 2542

24
... , 1 2558

... 25
?
CTX 9000

..2546 . CTX 9000
26 .
.
.. 2547 (...)




CTX
26

.



.. 2549
... CTX
25
(.)
2
.. 2551 ...
.. 2554

25
26

, , 26 2554.
7 CTX: ... Thai Publica, 27 2555. Thaipublica.org.2012/09/ctx.3/ 27 2558




... ... ..

27 . ... 9 255528
28 2555 ... ...
. CTX
29
31 2555 . ...

...[] 30


? 31
CTX 9000


?

2 ...

...
27

, ... ,10 2557 73.


, ... , .
29
Thaipublica 27 2012. CTX 9000

30
, ... , 75.
31
, ... , 75.
28

10



2 3


32








33



(
)



?

...

32

collusive corruption Prakash Chander, Address, 2558, .


... ,,
, 2529.
33

11

state capture


15 Petty Corruption
Grand Corruption

3.
4 (1)
(2) (3) (4)





34
35


... 36

34

, 30 2558
PPT. (TDRI), .. 2549
36
. ... 14 ..2557. www.isranews.org/isranews-scooplitem/32873-matee-77701.html 4 2558.
35

12





37 (moral man)

38





(economic rent)




2500 2510


(2523- 2531)
(2532 2534, 2535 2548)

37

, 30 2558
. ,
8 2549; , ..
7 2548 .
38

13

2502 2516
2524 2534



39 .


. ...
...
40

.. 2540



.. 2541

200
254041





39

. . 184.
. 340 41.
41
. . 344.
40

14








2
42









? 43
?44


42

Marc Saxer. In the Vertigo of Change: How to resolve Thailands transformation crisis. , Openworlds,
2557.
43
, : ,
, ..2558, 4 4.2 .
75 77 j (53.3)
4 1.3 21.3.
44
. , 84.

15


45





46
2

(patrimonialism) 47
19


2530 (... 2540
)
2550


1 1 48

45

World Bank, Anticorruption in transition. A Contribution to the Policy Debate, Washington D.C. 2000.
Michael T. Rock , Corruption and Democracy , DESA Working Paper No.55 ST/ESA/2007/ DWP/55, August 2007.
47
Marc Saxer, In The Vertigo of Change. 234.
48
Saxer. The Vertigo of Change 218 - 232
46

16

4.
? ?
(moral man)



John Dalberg-Action 1st Baron Acton (1834-1902) Power tends to corrupt, and absolute
power corrupts absolutely


...


?
?
49
49

Acemoglu, Daron, James A. Robinson, Economic Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy, Cambridge University Press, 2006.

17

?

17 44
50

















2550



51

50

, , 3.
, / ? , , 21
2558 . Acemoglu, Daron and James Robinson, Economic Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy; Acemoglu, Daron,
51

18





3




52
30






(...)
(...) (...)







Davide Ticchi, and Andrea Vindigni, A Theory of Military Dictatorship, American Economic Journal: Macroeconomics, 2 (1): 1-42; Acemoglu, Daron, Oligrachic vs
Democratic Societies. Journal of the European Economic Association 6: 1-44.
52

,
, 2541.

19

.



state capture
regulatory capture
25

20

21

Rate