Professional Documents
Culture Documents
- on 11/17/2015
If we want things to stay as they are, things will have to change Do you
understand?
Giuseppe di Lampedusa[2]
Preamble
The genesis of this paper was a recent trip we took to Lanka as election
observers for the August parliamentary elections. During the elections and
after we had the opportunity not only to visit many cities in the north, east
and the south but to speak to a cross-section of its inhabitants. What
follows is the result of our observations, our reading and our discussions
about Lanka, not just during our recent trip but also in the course of the
past decade.
The elections have given rise to optimism in some and cynicism in others
who see the new government concealing an attachment to the bad
practices of the past beneath a professed devotion to reform. We do not
know which view is true. History is a capricious beast and the present is
hard enough to comprehend; predictions are difficult to the point of
impossibility. Nevertheless, we offer tentative conclusions, both optimistic
and pessimistic.
We start with a very general outline of the historical background of the
issues. Then go on to discuss issues like: good governance, accountability
and fairness, the possibility of a more economically inclusive and just
society, Sinhala Buddhist hegemony, and life in the north six years after the
civil war.
Background
Lanka lies off the southernmost tip of India, an island the shape of a
teardrop. It is a multi-religious and multi-ethnic country of over 20 million
the army and the navy. They look less like camps than permanent
settlements, with rows of neat buildings. Many had extensive golf courses
attached to them, the grass lush in contrast to the surrounding countryside.
We were also told the army had numerous market gardens. We did not see
any of the many hotels that they also operate in the area. It is estimated
that between 80,000 and 160,000 troops are still stationed in the region.
The land expropriated to house them and the numerous golf courses, hotel
complexes and market gardens represents land denied to many rural
refugees. 80,000 to 160,000 troops in a small peninsula with a population
estimate to be around 600,000 seemed not only omnipresent but
oppressive.
We felt that oppression at one of the wayside stops when two lorry loads of
troops dismounted. They were young recruits impeccable in their short
haircuts, crisp uniforms and sense of privilege. They were no threat to us
but there was an immediate change of mood. If we as outsiders felt that,
one wonders what the locals would feel.
Our sense of being in an occupied country heightened when our driver had
to register our entry into the peninsula. We felt we were entering a foreign
country under military occupation, with one side speaking Sinhalese, the
other Tamil. This feeling was reinforced by the number of war memorials for
the Sinhalese troops who died during the conflict. One of the more
disturbing ones we passed was in Kilinochchi (which had been the
headquarters of the Tigers): a dynamited water tower with the message
that this is what the Tigers did whilst the Singhalese troops liberated the
Tamils. It is undeniable that the LTTE committed war crimes, but so did the
Government forces. What was disturbing was that these monuments served
as a symbol of Sinhalese Buddhist domination. Where are the Tamil
monuments and graves for the dead?
The scars of war were not generally evident in the North. The railway was
running again, a brand new station had been built and the roads were free
of potholes. It was only in the side streets that we could discern traces of
the conflict. The Jaffna library had been rebuilt and the walls of the fort had
been reconstructed, giving us fine vistas of the shimmering Indian Ocean. A
tourist ignorant of the citys recent history would have concluded this was a
city that had not experienced conflict and was experiencing a building
boom.
Evidence of the psychological damage caused by 36 years of war could be
seen in a large billboard in front of one of the municipal buildings in Jaffna.
It depicted a nuclear family with phone numbers and help groups for people
who were victims of domestic and sexual violence.
When speaking of these matters with a former vice-chancellor of Jaffna
University we were given an elite view of this problem. Though reticent in
talking about it, he did point out that many young people are disrespectful
of their elders and many elders have resorted to extreme forms of corporal
punishment to deal with the problem. There is a burgeoning drinking and
drug problem amongst the youth of the peninsula. The solution lies partly in
the hands of women, as many are now, because of the war, de facto heads
of the household. It seems that under customary law they are also the
inheritors of the family assets. (Customary law, as often noted by historians
and cultural commentators, has also preserved the power of the dominant
caste in the peninsula.) In addition, around 70 per cent of tertiary students
are women. Another hopeful sign is that caste distinctions are gradually
being eroded. These things could be interpreted as the beginnings of a
revival in Tamil culture. We are not convinced.
income whilst the lowest 40 per cent make do with 17.8 per cent. Individual
debt aside, national debt is now 79 per cent of GDP. The educational system
is not producing the quality graduates the country needs (the elite educate
their students abroad or in private and expensive international schools). For
the students that graduate at the tertiary and secondary level there are not
enough jobs and university positions to meet their expectations. Very little
is spent on health services. Many families are forced to rely on the
expensive private health system and are reduced to penury as a result.
Another looming health issue is dengue fever. It is on the rise, especially in
the western provinces there were 20,000 reported cases in the first six
months of 2014.[13]
In the decade since we last visited Colombo has grown exponentially. Its
roads and pavements have received a facelift, with a spiders web of
highways now threading the city from the airport and major cities like
Kandy and Galle. Travelling on the highway from the airport to the city was
like a magic carpet ride. It was devoid of the traffic that mars so many
major thoroughfares in the city, the reason being that the majority of the
residents of Colombo would not be able to afford the toll. (This depends on
the size of the vehicle and ranges from Rs 200 to Rs 600.) It is likely that
many could not afford to buy and run a car.
The highway was built with money borrowed from the Chinese and built
mainly by Chinese labour. It is reminiscent of the megalomaniacal
infrastructure built by the Kim dynasty in North Korea and at the height of
Ceausescus dictatorship in Romania. These grandiose projects benefit only
the elite and leave the country and its inhabitants further enmeshed in
debt.
Once you reach the environs of the city the traffic crawls, snarls and snakes
its anarchistic way around the city. There are still traces of its fine colonial
architecture and pockets of fine modernist buildings, but these magnificent
spanking new international airport which, on the day we were there, was
closed.
To tackle this lopsided development and endemic corruption the link
between powerful business interests and members of both bourgeoisie
parties needs to be broken. This means a more interventionist state in the
social democratic mould, a vibrant trade union movement and a strong
judiciary. Unfortunately the current Prime Minister Ranils track record
shows a strong ideological commitment to expanding the parameters free
market.
Conclusion
We must also take into account the fact that the government did not get a
resounding majority; a sizeable minority did not vote for them in the south,
as we were reminded when we took a taxi in Colombo. The driver, whose
English was excellent, enthusiastically joined in our endless political
discussions. He emphatically informed us that Sirisena had been bought
by the West: he was given $400 million to help him fight the election and if
he wins he will be beholden to the supporters of Eelam.
Fuelling this rancour are those tiresome intellectual courtiers of the
previous regime and Sinhalese exceptionalism: HLD Mahindpala and Dr
Dayan Jayatilleka[14]. They repeatedly and vehemently insist that
acceptance of the UNHRC report is tantamount to treason and a surrender
of the national sovereignty of Lanka. Refreshingly, this political mendacity
had no effect on those many voters who saw it as a smokescreen for the
autocratic inclinations of the Rajapaksa clan. Does that mean there is some
empathy for the plight of the Tamils in the north and east? Apart from a
minority of Lankan intellectuals, political activists and commentators, we
[1] Cohen, Leonard (1993) Anthem in Stranger Music, Jonathan Cape p. 373
[2] Di Lampedusa, Giuseppe (1969). The Leopard. Fontana, p. 28.
[3] Punchihewa, S.G. (2010). Sri Lankan constitution and democratic rights.
In Sri Lankan Guardian of 10 October 2010. Retrieved
from:http://www.srilankaguardian.org/2010/10/sri-lankan-constitution-anddemocratic.html
[4] Nagaraj, V. (2011). The Sri Lankan army is selling vegetables. In The
Guardian of 28 January 2011. Retrieved
from:http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/jan/28/sri-lanka-armymilitary
[5] Ramachandran, Suda (2015) Sirisena reins in Sri Lankan Executive
Presidency in Asia Times May 4, 2015 Retrieved:
http://atimes.com/2015/05/sirisena-reins-in-sri-lankas-executive-presidency
[6] Our respective reports as election monitors for the August 2015
parliamentary elections.
[7] The Official Language Bill better known as the Sinhala Only Bill was
passed in 1956. It made Sinhala the official language of Lanka. In the fifty
nine years since its passage the island experienced: numerous riots,
pogroms, acres of verbal invective and miles of printed bile and a thirty
year civil war that ended in 2009
[8] Anagarika Dhaarmapala (1864-1933). Born Don David Hewavitharana,
he was also known as Venerable Devamitta Dharmapla. In the latter half of
the nineteenth century he, like many others, was caught up in the wave of
Buddhist revivalism that swept Sri Lanka (then Ceylon). It was engendered
by two theosophists, Madame Blavatsky and Colonel Olcott, who set up a
number of Buddhist schools on the island. He changed his name during this
period to Anagarika (one who does not inhabit a house) Dharmapala
(guardian of the Dharma) and played a pivotal role in linking Buddhism as
practised on the island to the anti-colonial struggle. His rhetoric was
unfortunately heavily infused with racial imagery and Sinhala
exceptionalism. He eventually broke with the theosophists over their idea of
a world religion. In the later stages of his life he went to Northern India to
revive Buddhism where it had lain dormant for over a thousand years,
rebuilding a number of temples and monasteries.
[9] Arumuga Navalar (1822-1879). He played a pivotal role in revival of
Hinduism in the north and the east of the island. Navalar was one of the
early adaptors of modern Tamil prose, introduced Western editing
techniques, and built schools (in imitation of Christian mission schools) that
taught secular and Hindu religious subjects. He was a defender
of Saivism against Christian missionary activity and was one of the first
indigenous citizens to use the modern printing press to preserve the Tamil
literary tradition. He published many polemical tracts in defence of Saivism,
and also sought and published original palm leaf manuscripts. He also
attempted to reform Saivism itself an effort which sometimes led to the
decline of popular deities and worship modes and confrontation with
traditional authorities of religion. Some post-colonial authors have criticised
his contributions as parochial, limited, conservative, and favouring the
elite castes. Within his anti-colonial message and struggle the tone of his
campaigns and crusades was largely essentialist and anti-modern.
[10] Balachandran, R. C. (2015) Post-War Systemic Breakdown Blamed for
Jaffna Riots in The New Indian Express. 22 May 2015. Retrieved:
www.newindianexpress.com/world/Post-War-Systemic-Breakdown-BlamedFor-Jaffna-Rape-and-Mayhem/2015/05/22/article2827962
[11] In particular Hoole, Raj (2001), The Arrogance of Power: Myths,
Decadence and Murder, published by University Teachers for Human Rights
(Jaffna).
[12] See: UN Human Rights Boss Urges Creation of Hybrid Special Court in
Sri Lanka Colombo Telegraph September 16 2015. Retrieved:
www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/un-human-rights-boss-urgescreation-of-hybrid-special-court-in-sri-lanka/
[13] See Hettige, Siri (2015), Towards a Sane Society, Sarasavi Publishers,
for a fuller exposition of these matters.
[14] An example: Jayatilleka, Dayan (2015) Prince Zeids War on Sri
Lanka.Colombo Telegraph September 16, 2015. Retrieved:
https://www.colombotelegraph.com//index.php/prince-zeids-war-on-srilanka.
Posted by Thavam