You are on page 1of 146

Reg No

Name of
Requester

Date of reciept Request In Brief

05-0001

L.P.Yadav

06th Dec 05

Inquiry/Suspension details of an Ex
8(1)(j)
employee

REFUSED

7th Dec 05

Details of land surrendered to MP


Govt for transfer to housing society.
Correspondence details after 1998 NA
with society regarding transfer of
land

Details of land surrendered provided.


Correspondence details not available in
records

7th Dec 05

Details of land proposed to be


surrendered to MP Govt and
markets included in surrender plan .
NA
Ownerships rights to be given by
Govt. Comments on statements
published in local newspapers

Since proposal of surrender is under


consideration it is not possible to give
details. Ownership rights is to be decided by
Govt -hence no comments. No comments on
news published in local dailies

7th Dec 05

Details of legal and illegal liquor


shops on BHEL land and measures
taken by BHEL for removal of illegal
NA
liquor shops. Measures taken by
BHEL for Education on harmful
effects of liquor.

No legal liquor shops on BHEL land 1- shop


operates illegally. State Government
authorities have been requested for removal
of same. Education comes under purview of
government hence no role of BHEL.

7th Dec 05

Under which approval land has


been allotted to AIMS while the
proposal of land surrender is
pending with Central / State
government.

Land has been allotted after approval of


Board of Directors and it has no relation with
proposal of surrrender of land.

05-0002

05-0003

05-0004

05-0005

C.L.Arya

C.L.Arya

C.L.Arya

C.L.Arya

Sec if
refused

NA

Reply In brief

05-0006

05-0007

05-0008

05-0009

C.L.Arya

No of makets developed by BHEL


and the objectives of the same and
details of t he markets where only
plots were allotted. Details of
plots /shops allotted to sons and
daughters of BHELemployees.

NA

Only two markets developed by BHEL


records of objectives are not available as
same are very old. Only 29 shops
constructed and balance plots were allotted.
Details of plots allotted to sons and
daughters are not available.- records being
very old.

C.L.Arya

7th Dec 05

Certified copies of lease deed along


with maps given by MP government
to BHEl,Bhopal. Terms and
NA
conditions and area wise proposal
of surrender plan of surplus land .

No lease agreement between BHEL and MP


Government. Since proposal of surrender of
land is under consideration comments
cannot be given.

12th Dec 05

Procedure for allotment of land on


lease /license. Details of land
allotted to Vivekanand Vidyapeeth
NA
initially and for extension
subsequently. Whether land allotted
after board approval.

No land allotted on lease. Procedure exists


for allotment on license after board
approval. 2,40,000 sq.feet land allotted to
Vivekanand Vidya Peeth in 1987 after
approval of ED as per rules prevailing then.

12th Dec 05

Details of water supply from Upper


lake to BHEL and details of
NA
agreement for payment of water tax
to government.

Records of agreement being very old are not


available. Payment for supply of draw water
falls under MP irrigation act and there is no
need of Board/ Government approval of
same.

C.L.Arya

C.L.Arya

05-0010

05-0011

05-0012

05-0013

05-0014

C.L.Arya

C.L.Arya

C.L.Arya

C.L.Arya

C.L.Arya

12th Dec 05

Details of fees charged for parking


of vehicle on BHEL land. Details of
trees cut from land in front of
Carmel School.

NA

No fee is charged for parking & no land is


earmarked for parking. No information
available on plantation and cutting of trees in
front of Carmel school.

12th Dec 05

Details of taxes levied by BHEL on


Commercial establishments/ shops.
Taxes levied by Municipal
Corporation Bhopal and details of NA
authorization to BHEL for
collection of taxes by Municipal
Corporation.

BHEL has not been authorized to levy taxes


on commercial establishment /shops. Details
of taxes collected by Municipal Corporation
are not available.

12th Dec 05

Details of illegal colleges on BHEL


land. Details of water and power
consumption by such colleges and
actions taken against them.

No illegal colleges on BHEL land.

12th Dec 05

Details of registered organizations


authorized for discussions on basic
NA
problem of shop owners and
markets

Shops have been allotted only on license


basis. No shops have been allotted on lease /
ownership basis. Problems related to the
shops and markets are discussed with
Trade Association.

19th Dec.05

When was the information received


regarding details of Arrival of SC/ST
Parliamentary Committee to BHEL
NA
Bhopal and modus operandi
adopted for discussions with
General public / representatives etc.

The information was received on 18th


October 2005. and the modus operandi was
decided by the Officer In charge of
Parliamentary Committee.

NA

05-0015

C.L.Arya

19th Dec.05

Details of shops/ public


conveniences in BHEL market.
Details of road construction and
future plans.

NA

Area wise details of shops given. Records of


Public convenience and road construction
not available.

05-0016

C.L.Arya

19th Dec.05

Details of service carried out in slum


NA
areas and rehabilitation details.

Last surveys carried out in 88,89 &2002.1200


slum dwellers rehabilatated .154
rehabilatated in 2005.

05-0017

C.L.Arya

19th Dec.05

Details of welfare measure for SC


/ST related to employment health &
Education etc. Details of SC/ST
employees not promoted in last
three years.

Rules and regulations are available for


protecting interests of BHEL empolyees .
Further standing orders conduct discipline
and appeal rules can be referred.

NA

Reservation related to SC/ST are in line with


Presidential directives. All SC/ ST employees
found fit by DPC have been promoted

05-0018

C.L.Arya

19th Dec.05

What are the standards employed


for protection of interests of BHEL
Employees. What are the standards
in practice for allowing BHEL
NA
employees to participate in social /
political activities. What are the
standards for prevention of
harrrasment of employees.

05-0019

R.S.Agarwal

21st Dec.05

Details of tender in 2004-05 by BHEL


for advertisement through News
NA
Papers / Electronic Media

No tender has been done during 2004-05.

30th Dec 05

Rules and regulations related to


employment on compassionate
grounds. Relief and benefits to
wards of deceased employees for
compassionate employees

NA

There is a provision for employment on


compassionate grounds and relaxation up to
5 years is given to wards of deceased
employees.

2nd Jan 06

Allottement of land for rail ticket


booking authorized agent.-Reply
sought against letter written to ED
on the subject

NA

No provision of allotment of land to travel


agency. Hence no reply given by ED.

05-0020

05-0021

Indramani Pandey

Anil kumar Jain

05-0022

Indramani Pandey

31st Jan.06

Age limit for employment on


compassionate grounds. Is ITI and
apprenticeship training necessary
NA
for compassionate grounds Details
of welfare facilities for wards of
deceased employees.

05-0023

Rajendra Kumar

30th Jan.06

Details of an ex-employee

8(1)(j)

Refused

17th Feb.02

Details of lease/ license of Dr.


Ambedkar Educational Instititute
and details of cancellation of land
allotted to Siddarth Model School

NA

Case being more than 15 years old, records


not available.

NA

Case being old (1993) records not available.

NA

Records not available

05-0024

Shivaji Jadav

Relaxation up to 5 years. The necessary


qualification for the post need to be fulfilled.
Received applications are registered and all
possible help rendered for employment. Self
employment programmes are organized from
time to time.

05-0025

Shivaji Jadav

17th Feb.02

Actions taken against letter written


to the then HR Minister regarding
promotions and cancellation of
lease given to Dr. Ambedkar
Institute.

05-0026

Shivaji Jadav

17th Feb.02

Details of charge sheet and details


of Inquiry against the applicant.

17th Feb.02

Details of printing and other costs


related to Books namely ED BOOK,
NA
Escoda, Power compaque published
by P & PR.

No such books published by P & PR or other


department of BHEL,Bhopal

20th Feb.06

Details of Recruitment of trainees


for catering department
.Appointment details of 2
candidates.

Details of recruitment furnished vide writ


petition sl. No 3513 of 1997. Appointment
details are personal details and have no
public bearings hence details not furnished.

05-0027

05-0028

Kailash Mishra

Satish Thomas

NA

05-0029

05-0030

05-0031

Ramesh Kumar
Singh

Shivaji Jadav

M.Hasan

9th March 06

Details of apprentices trained in


fitter trade between 1990 -1993 and
merit list. Details of employment
NA
given to apprentices of fitter trade
between 1991-97.

Records of training and merit not available.


Details of employment not available in
compiled form.

10th March 06

Procedure for record retention and


disposal. Procedure for keeping
records sought by President ,PM,
Ministers etc.

Copy of WMI on the subject furnished.


Records are kept in individual files and
maintained up to 3 years after retirement.

14th March 06

Employment details of 2 employees


and authencity of pay slips
8(1)(j)
furnished by these employees to
applicant.

Refused

Refused

NA

05-0032

M.Hasan

14th March 06

Employment details of an employee


and authencity of pay slips
8(1)(j)
furnished by the employee to
applicant.

05-0033

Saifuddin Saifi

21st March 06

Details of CBI raid in CDC in 2003


and actions taken thereof.

81(h)

Refused - Matter still under investigation.

05-0034

Harihar Mishra

22nd March 06

Details of an ex-employee

8(1)(j)

Refused

STATUS OF REQUESTS RECEIVED UNDER RTI ACT IN 2006


Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

applicant
06-0001

S.S. Ghura

19th April 06

06-0002

S.S. Ghura

19th April 06

Inspection &
13-May-06
obtaining of records
of fixaiton of pay for
self retiring &
on 24th 13-May-06
Inspection
June
06 of records
obtaining

NA

Refused Fee not paid


Non Judicial Stamp
attached

NA

Certified copies of
relevant recorods
provided

of fixaiton of pay for


self retiring on 24th
June 06
06-0003

Rajkumar Pandey

21st April06

Details of W.C. seats 18th May 06


& Contractor who
had erected same in
factory /hospital

NA

Records not available


in a compiled form

06-0004

Saiffuddin Saify

25th April 06

Details of Executives 8th May 06


of CDC (traffic
department) in year
2003

NA

List of 7 executives
details furnished

06-0005

Shailendra
Maheswari

22nd May 06

Details of deduction 22nd May 06


from amount paid as
deposit by Shreeji
Marketing for cutting
of Trees

06-0006

OP Gandhi

15th June06

Record of
Promotion, Salary &
Arrears

8(1)(j)

As it is not a public
matter hence it is
refused..

As it is not a public
matter hence it is
refused..

29th June 06

8(1)(j)

Appeal rejected by
appellate authority
06-0007

Indramain Pandey

26th June 06

Qualification &
Procedure of
Compassionate
appointment

14th July 06

NA

Complete details
furnished

Decision of CPIO
upheld by Apellate
authority

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-0008

applicant
MW Siddiqui

3 rd July 06

Detailed list of
1st Aug.06
executives of
complete BHEL who
were promoted to the
grade of AGMs
between 01-01-2003
to 24.05.2006 & total
number of executives
superannuated /
Retired during this
period.Is strength of
employees of BHEL a
factor in sanctioning
the number of posts
at GM & ED levels in
BHEL.

NA

Detailed list of
executives of various
units of BHEL
furnished . With
regards to sl no.2, the
strength of employee
is not a critical factor
in considering
sanction of posts of
GM &ED levels in
BHE..

06-0009

RP Singh

3rd July 06

Inspection of
22nd July 06
complete record ,files
noting documents
related to second
time apointment of
Sh.Shekhar Dutta of
BHEL,New Delhi &
records related
promotion of
Sh.V.k.doli as
AGM,BHEL, Bhopal&

NA

The required
informaiton of Sh.
Dutta is provided &
agrred for inspection
of records at
mutually convenient
date. Regarding
query no.2 as it is an
individual matter
records can not be
made available for
inspection under
section 8 (1.e).& 8
(1.J)

06-0010

MW Siddiqui

4th July 06

Details of targets- at 24th July.06


the beginning of the
year & RE for the
years 2002-06 for T/O
and profit before Tax
and Actual
Achievements for
BHEL Bhopal &
Complete BHEL
Corporation. And
also records file
notings of additional
charge given to
GM(P&D,Q),Sh.Prabh
at kumar

NA

The data of
BHEL,Bhopal&
corporate is provided
& Query at point no.2
idoes not involve
large public interest
hence not provided.

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-0011

applicant
MW Siddiqui

5th July 06

Details of grant since 28th July.06


2003-04, Balance
sheet ,Income
Expenditure
Statement & total
income &
expenditure of BHEL
Shikhamandal since
2003-04 to 2005-06.

NA

Grant given by BHEL


to Shikha Mandal &
the total income &
expenditure of the
BSM provided . The
account of 05-06 are
under audft and
hence the data is not
provided.

06-0012

MW Siddiqui

6th July 06

Details of
14th July 06
expenditure to be
incurred on the
Golden Jubilee Block
being made on the
Southernside of
BHEL Bhopal Plant
and actual
expenditure made till
30.6.06.Breakup of
proposed
expenditure to be
incurred on the Civil
Work, Development
of common facitilites,
Installation of
machine tools, & All
other items.

NA

The summary of
expenditure & breakup provided.

06-0013

MW Siddiqui

6th July 06

Details of quarters
3rd Aug.06
alloted in BHEL
Township to NONBHEL organizations/
individuals & arrears
of license fee/amount
of rent/ norm & policy
of allotment and
quantum of rent to be
charged from Nonorganisations/
individuals.

NA

Number of quarters
allotted to outsiders (
other than ExEmployees) are
provided alongwith
licence fees charges
from
orgainsation/Individu
al for each type of
quarters. With regard
to arrears of the
license fees, the
compiled informaiton
as on 1.7.2006 is not
available.Regarding
Norms/Policy of
allotment to
outsiders, the
quarters were given
to the organizations
in the past depending
upon the justification
and approval of the

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

06-0014

applicant
MW Siddiqui

7th July 06

No.Of ( N3N4,type3rd Aug.06


III,B,type etc)quarters
there in BHEL
Township &No of
quarters vacant &
Plinth area of each
quarter& details of
the vacant quarters
whose doors &
windows are
damaged
/stolen./FIRS/Reports/
Complaint have been
lodged with Police &
records of anti theft
squad & review by
head of Township
Administraiton &
relevant minutes of
meeting etc.

NA

06-0015

MW Siddiqui

10th July 06

No of Jhuggies
3rd Aug.06
exiisting in BHEL
Town ship as on 1st
Jan.2003-2006. Had
steps have been
taken to prevent the
construciton/formaito
n of new Jhuggies .
Also estimated
expenditure incurred
by BHEL in supplying
free electricity and
Water for existing
Jhuggies and reason
for not dis
continuing the
facilities & The steps
taken by BHEL to
stop / reduce the
expenditure

NA

Reply In brief
Reply to the point -1
is provided & the
data regarding period
of vacancy of each
type quarter is not
available The
compiled form of
informaiton in the
case of vacant
quarters with
Damaged windows
/doors/ stolen are not
available.To prevent
thefts the matter is
takenup with police
as well as state
authorities from time
to time.In order to
protect /safeguard
the property of BHEL
Bhopal quarters, the
township , security
Department is in
No survey of total
jhuggies in the
Township
Administration was
conducted for the
required years.
Regarding
encoarchment
patrolling by the
Eviction Cell is being
done & no free
supply of Electricity
& Water supply to
any Jhuggi area by
BHEl.No separate
metring systmem in
jhuggi area & hence
actual expenditure
can not be quantified.
The efforts are being
made by BHEL for
disconnecting the
facilities.

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-0016

applicant
MW Siddiqui

110th July 06

Details of the BHEL 7th Aug.06


employees who are
the members of any
Vidhan Sabha or
Nagar Nigam or
Nagar palika / other
local body & how
much amount is
drawing from these
bodies on account of
salary sitting
fee,allowance
perks ,reimbursement etc.&
actions taken for
gatheing information
from these perosns&
the rules for giving
permission for these
by BHEL

7(9)

No information is
available and also
compilation would
disproportionately
divert the resources
of the public
authority hence the
same cannot be
provided as per
section 7(9) of the
RTI act.

06-0017

MW Siddiqui

12th July..06

The names of the


28th July 06
main contractors ,
Suppliers of
machines tools and
other facilities to be
installed in the
Golden Jubilee
Block of BHEL,
Bhopal & value of
order placed on each
of the parties
till30.06.2006

NA

The name of main


civil contractors
,suppliers of
machines and other
facilities to be
installed in the
Golden Jubilee is
provided. Regarding
the value of orders
settled with the
suppliers is a
confidential
matternadalso a
sensitive informaiton
hence not provided
under Sec 8-1(d)

06-0018

MW Siddiqui

13th July.06

Details of budget of 10th Aug.06


BHEL Bhopal
Township for the
years 2003 - 07, &
total actual
expenditure till 200506 . details of
development
/improvement
activities carried out
& expenditure
incurred by BHEL
Bhopal Township
since 01/01/05.How
much is the income
of BHEL BHOPAL
Town Department
major account heads
in the financial year
2003-04,04-05 & 0506.

NA

The year wise


Budget, expenditure
and development
activities carried out
provided.

Reg No

Name of the

06-0019

applicant
MW Siddiqui

06-020

MW Siddiqui

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

15th July 06

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Procedure & actions 10th Aug.06


taken by BHEL &
Govt. Of India &
procedure followed
by BHEL for dealing
with the case of
appointment of
independent
directors. procedure
followed by BHEL for
dealing with cases
brought before it for
comments /opinion,
eligibility of the
person and is
concurrence of BHEL
management
obtained to the
appointment of
independent
Directors
appointemnt.

NA

The details of
10th Aug.06
License fee charged
by BHEL Bhopal for
N3,N4,Type-III,Btype
quarters from
BHELemployees &
Non-BHEL
organizational/
individuals & the
name ,Designaiton &
staff no of the senior
most BHEL
employees staying in
each type of quarters
amount of HRA
he/she is entitled if
not staying in the
quarter..

NA

Reply In brief
The Government of
India nominates a
persons for
appointemnt fo an
Independent
Directors on the
Board of BHEL &
BHEL Board inducts
him as a Director to
hold office till
conclusion of next
Annual General
Meeting and eligible
for appointment in
that meeting Also
Governmet only takes
company's views
with respect to the
conflict of interest in
the biusiness of
BHEL before
appointment of a
persosn as
Details of License
fees charge from
Organization/individu
al is
525/725/1500,3350/for each type of
quarters provided &
the details of name
,Designaiton and
staff no of senior
most BHEL employee
staying in each type
of quarter is not
available in compiled
form.If the employe
wants ot move to his
own house or rented
accommodaiton the
employee is entitled
for HRA equal to 15 %
of his / her pay as per
company rule.

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

06-021

applicant
MW Siddiqui

17th July 06

The details of
10th Aug.06
License fee charged
by BHEL Bhopal for
N3,N4,Type-III,Btype
quarters from
BHELemployees &
Non-BHEL
organizational/
individuals & the
notation value of
House Rent
Allowance
entitlement of
employees staying in
BHEL Township.

NA

06-022

MW Siddiqui

18th July 06

No.of Guest
10th Aug.06
Houses /transit flats
functioning at Delhi,
Mumbai, Kolkotta and
Chennai by various
unitsof BHEL &the
monthly/yearly
rentpaid to the House
owner by such units
and rules & details
for the Bank
guarantee if
furnished to the
House owner for
taking guest
House/transit flats on
rental baiss.

NA

Reply In brief
Details of License
fees charge from
Organization/individu
al is
525/725/1500,3350/for each type of
quarters.& name &
details already
provided with
application No
BP/CPIO/06/0020 dtd
15.7.06& the name
,Designaiton & staff
No of senior most
BHEl employees
stating in each type
quarter is not
available in compiled
form.& Notation value
of House Rent
Allowance
entitlement of
employee is not
Available records
furnished unitwise

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-023

applicant
MW Siddiqui

19th July 06

Details of Type III,C- 10th Aug.06


3,N4,N5 N6 and
Banglow quarters of
different sectors of
BHEL Township&
basis of allocation of
budget for the
maintenance of these
quarters & roads.
Expenditure incurred
on maintenance for
these type quarters &
roads for the years
2003-06 . How much
amount had been
spent in each sector
for maintenance of
these quarters &
roads

NA

06-024

MW Siddiqui

20th July 06

Details of land area


10th Aug.06
where earlier TRT
quarters existed in
Govindpura
utilization of land at
present & future
plans for utilizing this
land & steps taken by
BHEL to stop /
prevent
encroachment on this
land

NA

06-025

Sunil Kumar Patahk

21st Aug.06

Details of
3rd Aug.06
Temporary/Permanen
t Works as per
Manual of BHEL
Bhopal and no of
contract employees
employed in such
works . Details of
agreements from
1994 onwards

NA

Classification of
Temporary and
permanent work does
not exist . Contract
workers are
employed by
contractors. Details
of agreements can be
provided on
submission of
additional fee of Rs
182 only for 91 pages

06-026

Manoj Singh Jadon

21st July 06

Details of agreements 16th Aug.06


between BHEL
Bhopal , Labour
contract United
front , unions etc

NA

Details provided
alonwith list of
contractors

Details of quarters in
various
neighbourhood is
provided & The
budget is allocated to
township on overall
basis &the
neighbourhood
breakup of
expenditure is not
availabkle & the total
expenditure on
maintenance of
township is given for
respective years. No
record is being
maintained
neighbourhood wise
as the budget is
given on overall &
internal planning is
depending as per the
requirement of
Land area where
earlier TRT quarter
existed is 22 acres&
at present the land is
lying vacant& in
future will be utilized
as per company
requirement. Regular
patrolling of the area
is being done by
Team of Eviction Cell
of Town
Administration Deptt
& by the Security
Deptt.

Reg No
06-027

Name of the
applicant
Jaichandra
Yadav

Date of Receipt Request In Brief


21st July 06

Date Of reply

Details of allotment 10th Aug.06


of Shop. No.10 of Lal
Bahadur Shastry
Market and subquent
tansfer of allotments

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief
Refused- Personal
Matter

8(1)(j)

06-028

MW Siddiqui

22nd July.06

Total Expedniture
16th Aug.063
incurred by BHEL for
establishing G/H at
Noida

NA

Details such as
expenses on
modification,
reconstruction
furnishing and
maintenance
provided

06-029

Karnail Singh

24th July 06

Details of land to be 21st Aug.06


returned to
Government &
recommendations for
allotment to Housing
socities including
Vijaynagar Society

NA

No such
recommendations
made by BHEl,
Bhopal. Hence other
questions are
irrelevant

06-030

MW Siddiqui

25th July.06

Details of Tenure /last 16th Aug.06


position held in
companies by
Sh.Shekhar Dutta and
other details such as
no of shares held in
each company,
product and service
range of each
company

NA

Details of Tenure /last


position held in
companies by
Sh.Shekhar Dutta
provided. Other
details not available

06-031

MW Siddiqui

26th July.06

Budget estimates for 25th Aug.06


activities planned at
the concluding
fucntion of Golden
Jubilee Year and
details of expenditure
already incurred

NA

Various activities for


the concluding
fucntion of Golden
Jubilee Year are
under finalisation.
Hence details not
available

06-032

MW Siddiqui

28th July.06

Manpower (in
25th Aug.06
different categories)
of Medical Deptt. Of
BHEL, Bhopal as on
24th June2001 - 24th
June 2006

7(9)

Compiled Records
not available. Hence
details not provided
referring sec 7 (9) of
the act.

Decision of CPIO
upheld by Apellate
authority . However
apellate authority
also directed to give
latest list of
employees which
was furnished .

Reg No
06-033

Name of the
applicant
MW Siddiqui

Date of Receipt Request In Brief


29th July.06

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

No of patients
25th Aug.06
reported for
treatment in different
disciplines of
Kasturba Hospital
and dispensaries
during the yrs ended
on 24th June2001 24th June 2006.

7(9)

Reply In brief
Compiled Records
not available. Hence
details not provided
referring sec 7 (9) of
the act.

06-034

MW Siddiqui

31st July.06

Details of Hospitals 16th Aug.06


empanneled by BHEL
fo referring
employees and
whether BHEL
employees can avail
such facilities as per
their choice

NA

Extract of Personnel
Manual Para E5 -4.3.1
and list of Hospitals
empnneled provided

06-035

MW Siddiqui

1st Aug.06

BHEL Corporation
16th Aug.06
Turnover & PBT for
last 10 years absolute figures & %
growth

NA

BHEL Corporation
Turnover & PBT for
last 10 years absolute figures
provided

06-036

Chimanlal Arya

2nd Aug.06

Mininmum
qualification
requirements
-Refractionists and
Dialysis technicians
and details of such
employees

29th Aug

NA

No recruitment of
Refractionists and
Dialysis
techniciansin BHEL
Bhopal for last many
years

06-037

Chimanlal Arya

2nd Aug.06

Mininmum
29th Aug
qualification
requirements -for
direct Appointment of
civil/Electrical/Mech.
Diploma Holders,
Refractionists and
Dialysis technicians

NA

Mininmum
qualification
requirements
provided

06-038

Chimanlal Arya

2nd Aug.06

Details of the
present Medical
technicians (X-ray )
in BHEL,H'bad&
Jhansi

NA

There are No Medical


technicians (X-ray) in
BHEL,H'bad& Jhansi

06-039

Indramani Pandey

29th Aug

Reference of the
4th Aug.06
previous application
of the applicant

Fee not paid Quoting


same MR No hence
request rejected

Decision of CPIO
upheld by Apellate
authority . However
apellate authority
also directed to give
latest records of
patients of OPD and
same has been
furnished

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-040

applicant
RS Thakur

03rd Aug.06

Managements
30th Aug.06
propsal of
Distribution of
Terrywool Suiting
cloth to BHEl Bhopal
Employees during
Golden Jubilee
celebrations& details
of Quality of cloth
and procedural
details of purchase

NA

No such proposal
made by BHEl,
Bhopal. Hence other
questions are
irrelevant

06-041

MW Siddiqui

03rd Aug.06

Policy of
16th Aug.06
remployment to
retired employees
and Details of retired
employees
remployed by BHEL

NA

BHEL does not


remploy retired
people

06-042

MW Siddiqui

05th Aug.06

Details of "Societies " 2nd Sept.06


acting as Labour
Contractors. No of
contract labourers
being supplied by
each. Rate of
Commission, total
amount paid by
BHEL. Fringe
benefits given by
BHEL

NA

Name and Regn.of 5


societies supplying
contract labourers to
BHEL Bhopal are
provided & no.of
contract labourers
supplied by each
society keeps on
varying from time to
time. Commission
not paid .
Consolidated inf on
amount paid NA. No
fringe benefits/
facilities are provided
to the societies by
BHEL except office
premises.

06-043

MW Siddiqui

14th Aug.06

Permission to inspect 2nd Sept.06


& take note and
extract of the
documents of more
than 11000 BHEL
Quarters.

7(9)

The demand is
contrary ot the
provision under
section 7(9) of the Act
and as such
permission is not
granted.

06-044

Vijay Kumar.D,(A.P)

9th Aug.06

Informaiton of DC
4th Sep.06
Gen.Traction
Motors,Transformers
& traction electrics
used in shunt motors
etc

8(1)(a) & (d)

Information desired
is of Commercial
confidence and no
public interest
involved. Hence inf
not provided.

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-045

applicant
MW Siddiqui

14th Aug.06

Policy of recarpeting 12th Sep.06


of BHEL Township
roads.

NA

Approx. 172 km
asphalted road exist
in BHEL town ship &
no laid down policy is
in this reagard &
recarpeting work is
taken depending up
on the requirement &
Budget availability &
no spec ific tme
interval fixed .Part
repairing work was
carried out on the
said during 2004
before August 2005.

06-046

MW Siddiqui

17th Aug.06

Strength of
12th Sep.06
employees in BHEL
during the period of
2003,-2006 in various
grades

NA

with regards to
Strength of
employees
informaiton for the
desired date is not
available.&
manpower posiiton
as on
31/12/2002,31/12/2003
,31/12/04 & 31/12/06
provided.Regarding
query No.3 , a,b c &d
has been included &
e & f , sauch details
are not maintained
seperately.

06-047

Abdul Sarvar

17th Aug.06

Reason for rejection 13th Sep.06


of quotation BP/HRTX/ST/E-008 dtd
8.5.05

NA

Under the cited qtn,


only four parties were
found technically
qualified and duly
constituted Tender
committee followoed
he due procedure of
doecuments
verification. The
tender could not be
finalized as the rates
were not found
suitable.

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-048

applicant
MW Siddiqui

18th Aug.06

Details of BHEL
16th Sep.06
Perosns of C&D type
quarters ( allotted
/Occupied)

NA

THE INFORMAITON
SOUGHT
REGARDING
ORGANISAITON &
DATE OF
OCCUPATION IS
PROVIDED . &
DESIGNATION &
PAYSCALE OF
INDIVIDUAL & & THE
CURRENT OFFICAL
ADDRESS IS NOT
AVAILABLE.The
cumulative arrear on
the given date is also
given & the dtae
since rent is in
arrrear is not
avialable in compiled
form.

06-049

MW Siddiqui

21st Aug.06

Details of the BHEL


Employees who
sought permission
form BHEL for
contesting Vidhan
Sabha/Local Body
election.

7(9)

Compiled list not


available. Refused
under sec 7(9)

06-050

MW Siddiqui

23rd Aug.06

Factors that weighed 16th Sep.06


in favour of 2nd
tenure appointment
of Sh. Shekhar Dutta.

NA

Reply given .
Apppointment done
by Govt of India

06-051

MW Siddiqui

24th Aug.06

Expenditure incurred 16th Sep.06


in maintenance of ED
Bungalow.

NA

Quaterwise
expenditure details
not maintained.

06-052

Harish Mittal

25th Aug.06

Action taken by
BHEL against the
applicant's
application.

7(9)

Compiled list not


available. Refused
under sec 7(9)

16th Sep.06

21st Sep.06

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-053

applicant
MW Siddiqui

28th Aug.06

Permission of
27th Sept 06
Inspection of records
& take note in extract
of golden jubilee
celebration

NA

The demand is
contrary to the
proviison under
sectuion 7(9) of the
Act and not given
permission.The
committee
constituted for the
purpose is furnished
& no amount was
entruested to
individual GMS.the
expenditure
incurredvis a visd
budget sanctioned is
being compiled at
present and can be
given after it is
compiled.

06-054

MW Siddiqui

30 th Aug.06

Preparation of
27th Sept 06
Budget
proposal/actual
budget
proposed/approved
proposal in resopect
of Medical
Department for the
year 2002-06.

NA

The budget
proposals are framed
keeping in view the
past expenditure and
likely change in cost
of medicines
/referrals. The year
wise budget and
actual expenditure
relaitng to medical
from the yeat 200106 and budget
amount for the year
2006-07 is furnished.

06-055

MW Siddiqui

4th Sep.06

Details of agencies 3rd Oct.06


who are authorized
for rendering service
of various categories
of BHEL retired /
voluntary retired to
BHEL Bhopal.

NA

Informaiton on direct
diployment of retired
employees furnished
category wise. The
procedure of
deployment &
selection also given

06-056

Sh. Nagendra Singh

5th Sep.06

Name & details of the 3rd Oct.06


quarter No 459-497
D2 B-Sector allotted

NA

Details of quarters
allotment furnished

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-057

applicant
Jaichandra
Yadav

8th Sep.o6

Details of No of
3rd Oct.06
shops & amount
received by BHEL in
the time of allotement
& details of transfer
of allotments of
Shops in Lal
Bahadur Shastry
Market near Foundry
gate.

NA

Informaiton furnished
. No shops alloted ,
only plots alloted
records of which are
not available as these
are very old( 30-35
yrs)

06-058

LD Agarwal

8th Sep.o6

Details of
28th Sep.06
methodology
followed/ adopted by
BHEL to ensure
meeting the basic
requrement of
establishing the
reasonability of
prices

8(1)(a) & (d)

06-0059

Mohan singh
Raghuvanshi

11th Sep.o6

What is the status of 22nd Sep.06


Registered unions of
BHEL,Bhopal after
the stay order of Hon.
Highcourt of MPIR
Act and if ID Act
leveied or not.

Matter under
Supreme
Court

Contrary to the
party's claim very
limited items are
being procured by
the respective groups
within BHEL Bhopal
on single party
basis& no
informaiton is
maintained in a
format form.and
information asked by
sh.L.D Agrawal is in a
commercial
confidential nature
and the same is
exempted under
seciton 8(1-a) & 8 (1d).& the reasonablity
of the prices is
decided by the last
purchase price and
indent estimaiton , &
INFORMAITON
desired is not
covered under RTI
act . Since the matter
is under decision in
Supreme court
informaiton can not
be furnished.

06-0060

B.S.Rajput

11th Sep.o6

What is the cost &


quantity of the
momento given by
BHEL to the
employees and
others inconnection
with Golden Jubilee
Celebrations .

28th Sep.06

NA

Total 60,000/- pieces


were bought . Out of
this 41,700 were sent
to other units. And
Purchase cost Rs.
35.36/- per piece incl.
cost of packing.

06-0061

Mohan singh
Raghuvanshi

11th Sep.o6

Reasons for not


28th Sep.06
upgradation of
grades AB9 & S3A
after the payrevision
of 1996-97.

NA

Desired informaiton
furnsihed New scale
of A9A, introudeced
on receommediaitons
of sub committee of
Joint committee dtd
4.11.2000.

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-0062

applicant
MW Siddiqui

16thSep.06

Details of persons
12th Oct.06
who were proposed
for the positon of
Independent
Directors of BHEL by
DHI,Governmento of
Indian ahd where
commen6ts form
BHEL were sought
for the proposed
appointment..

8(1)(e) & 8(1)(j) disclosure of


Informaiton exemted
under section 8(1-e)
8(1-j) hence refused.

06-0063

MW Siddiqui

20thSep.06

The periodicity of
16th Oct.06
white washing and
painting of doors and
windows etc of A,B,C
& D type of Quarters
toegther with
Bangalow located at
A sector ,Berkhera
indcluding ED
Bangalow.reasons
for if not maintainig
of periodicity.

NA

Desired informaiton
furnished . Periods of
white washing &
painting furnished.

06-0064

MW Siddiqui

20 thSep.06

What is the minimum 16th Oct.06


wage being paid to
contract labourers
engage in BHEL and
DR Workers/ workers
apdi theough
continegncy bill by
BHEL at vArious
units and Office s at
Delhi and if DR
workers / workers
paid through
contingency bill if
poasted outside their
mother units are
being paid minimum
wage in thsoe cities
at the rate
prtescribed by the
State Govt for those
cities. Whether the
minimum wage being
paid in various units

NA

Informaiton
furnished. The wages
are being paid by
BHEL in line with the
rates prescribed by
the respective State
government. Daily
Rated waorkers are
not being posted
outside the unit.

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-0065

applicant
MW Siddiqui

21st Sep.06

Details of the
16th Oct.06
Transit Flats/ Guest
House at A1/26 and
A1/147 safdarjung
Enclave New Delhi
were takne on rent by
BHEL, Bhopal & a
house / flat in DLF
Colony Gurgaon was
taken on rent by
BHEL to keep the
furniture s and other
equipments of
vacated transit flatrs.

NA

Complete Details
fgurnished.

06-0066

MW Siddiqui

3rd Oct.06

No of flags/ posters/
no of files carrying
out for golden
celebration

7(9)

The golden jubilee


expenditure details
have been uploaded
on BHEL Bhopal's
website . Compiling
of further details is
not possible and the
same is exempted
under section of 7 (9).

06-0067

Abdul Sarvar

3rd Oct.06

QTN
31st Oct.06
No/BP/HR/TSX/STE/0
08 dtd 8.5.06

NA

Desired informaiton
has no relevance as
the tender had been
rejected due to nonm
suitability of rates
quoted by the four
parties.

06-0068

Karnail singh

18th Oct.06

Documents regarding 16th Nov.06


land returned by
BHEL

8(1)(a)

Returning of land is
in a sensitive state .
Disclosure of such
informaiton is
exempted under
Section 8(1-a) of the
act.

06-0069

Abdul Sarvar

24th Oct.06

Details of qtn of Bus 16th Nov.06


on rental basis

NA

Qtns of 4 parties are


technically suitable
as per the norms of
the committee. The
quoted rates are not
suitable hence
rejected.

31st Oct.06

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

06-0070

Abdulapplicant
Sarvar

1st Nov.06

Qtn of Bus

25th Nov,06

06-0071

Anil kumar Bhave

3rd Nov.06

Discrepanciews in
preparation of pay
during deputation

30th Nov.06

Sec if
refused
7(9)

8(1)(j)

Reply In brief
Qtns of 4 parties are
technically suitable
as per the norms of
the committee. The
quoted rates are not
suitable hecne
rejected. Compiling
of further details is
not possible and the
same is exempted
under section of 7 (9).

The informaiton
sought is in
individual nature.
Hence refused under
Section 8(1-J) of the
act.

06-0072

Kamil Kidwai

9th Nov.06

Shop No.72,
Vijaymarket,
Berkhera

6th Dec.06

NA

Desired informaiton
furnished in detail.

06-0073

MW Siddiqui

9th Nov.06

Details of electricity 6th Dec.06


bill leveid by BHEL to
Shop etc

NA

Complete informaiton
furnished.

06-0074

MW Siddiqui

9th Nov.06

Property Tax paid by 6th Dec.06


BHELBhopal to
Bhopal Nagar Nigam

NA

Complete details
furnished

06-0075

K.Balu (Regd. In
Ranipet unit)

9th Nov.06

litigaiton regarding
promotion of any
BHEL Employee

NA

Regarding litigation &


Promotion of any
employee of BHELinformaiton not
available in a
compiled form hence
exempted under
section of 7(J) All
other details
furnished

06-0076

Kailash Malviya

13th Nov.06

Suggestion given by 12 th Dec.06


CBI during CBI Raid,
agaisnt Shop no 72
of Vijay market

NA

Complete details
provided.

06-0077

FS Sahu

13th Nov.06

Provide self
Payscale of store
keeper & Reward
scheme

6th Dec.06

09th Dec.06
8(1)(j)

The informaiton
sought is in
individual nature.
Hence refused under
Section 8(1-J) of the
act.

Reg No
06-0078

Name of the
applicant
Atul Purohit

Date of Receipt Request In Brief


21st Nov.06

Details ofBHEL
Sports Club

Date Of reply
18th Dec.06

Sec if
refused
Refused as
Sports
authority is
independent
body

Reply In brief
Sports Club is an
independent
Institution and it has
its own rules &
regualitons hence
the desired
information can be
obtained from the
concerned authorites
only.

Reg No

Name of the

Date of Receipt Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

06-0079

applicant
Atul Purohit

21st nov.06

Details & Terms &


Conditions for land
allottment of Carrer
School

18th Dec.06

NA

Complete details
furnsihed as per
available records.

06-0080

Abdul Sarvar

29thNov.06

Details of Tender
TSX/ST/E-008

18th Dec.06

NA

Desired informaiton
has no relevance as
the tender had been
rejected due to non
suitability of rates
quoted by the four
parties.

06-0081

Chiman Lal

1st Dec.06

Appeal procedure for 26 th Dec.06


RTI request

NA

Details of appeal
procedure alongwith
the relevant form -C
furnsihed.

06-0082

Chiman Lal

1st Dec.06

Comments to letter
abjbvs/ 004 ,006 dtd
20.11.06

27 th Dec.06

NA

The desired details


form the concerned
department are not
clear hence reply was
not given by the
concerned deptt.

06-0083

MPPTCL,Jabalpur

4th Dec.06

Request of order
copy - Order No
4558531/ 15.2.06 &
rate of contract

26 th Dec.06

8(1)d

Informaiton sought
pertians to third party
& would harm the
competitive positon
of a third party so
the desired
informaiton is
exempted under
sec.8(1)d of the act

06-0084

Narendra Varma

6th Dec.06

MW Siddiqui

9th Dec 06

compensative
4th Jan.07
appointment
Details of employees 6th Jan.07
who were given
special benefits in ED
Sect. of Sh. R.C
Aggarwal, S.N.Roy &
P.T. Deo.

NA

06-0085

Desired informaiton
furnished.
Complete details
furnished. However
file notings not
furnished but
reasons for giving
special increments
given.

06-0086

LD Agarwal

13-Dec-06

9th Jan.07

NA

06-0087

MW Siddiqui

20th Dec.06

Regarding opening
Tenders
Position of ED &
GGMs in BHEL

6th Jan.07

NA

06-0088

Kamalesh Solanki

23rd Dec.06

Details of Narendra
Verma

6 th Jan.07

NA

8(1)(j)

Complete details
furnished.
Complete informaiton
furnished.
The informaiton
sought isof
individual nature.
Hence refused under
Section 8(1-J) of the
act.

Reg No Name of the

Date of
Receipt

Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

applicant
07-0001

Shailendra Tiwari

9th Jan.07

Details of signing authorities of 23 rd Jan.07


ACR/PMSR/E Map Repot of self
for the year 1987-2006.

8(1)(j)

The informaiton sought is of


individual nature. Hence
exempted under Section
8(1-J) of the act.

07-0002

MW Siddiqui

22nd jan.07

Details of renovation works of


BHEL quarters.

15th Feb.07

NA

Presently there isa no plan


for renovation of any type of
quarters located in BHEL
Bhopal township & Routine
repair & Maintenance work
has been taken approx. 300 B
& C type of quarters for
porviding accommodaiton to
newly recruited supervisors&
Artisans trainesses

07-0003

Chatur Singh

24th Jan.07

Details of SC/ST Employees in 19th Feb.07


BHEL Bhopal belongs to
Balvihar, Anand Nagar

NA

Pay Rs.224/- (2Rs per page)


for required information
avaialble in BHEL,Bhopal.

07-0004

KS Puri

24th Jan.07

NIT NO WE&CS/1006/05 dtd


26.10.06

19th Feb.07

NA

The decision was taken


according to the Work Policy
20.0.M/s. Rathi & Sons had
paid a D/D of Rs.85,000
earlier and had paid the
balance amount Rs.15,000/videD/D on 30.10.06

07-0005

Sunil Kumar Tiwari 25th Jan.07

Documents of Hanuman Temple 19th Feb.07


located in Pilani

NA

Documents required are not


available with BHEL, Bhopal

07-0006

Sangeeta
Maheshwari

5th Feb.07

Details of deduction from


5th Feb.07
amount paid as deposit by
Shreeji Marketing for cutting of
Trees

8(1)(j)

Refused

07-0007

Secretary,BHEL
Nishaktijan Vikas
Samiti,Bhopal

17th Feb.07

Status of Deduction of Rs.50/- 12th March 07


p.m. from the salary/wages of
64 members of the samiti and
remit the same in SBI,HET
Bhopal

NA

Reply sent by HR on 30th


oct.2006. sielent points of
reply included.

07-0008

Ajaib Lal Nar

20th feb.07

Details of shop allotted to Sh.


Vijay Singh in Gandhi market

NA

No shop has been allotted

07-0009

Kailash Mishra

22nd feb.07

Details of printing policy &


12th March 07
details of books printed in last 3
years.

7(9)

Details of prninting polcy


given detai;s of bokks
published not available in
compiled form

07-0010

VK Agarwal

23rd Feb.07

Photocopies of documents
8th March 07
submitted at the time of joining
BHEL Tiruchi

8(1)(j)

Refused

07-0011

Harish mittal

26t Feb 07

Photo copies of appoint ment


23rd March07
order of trainees joined in BHEL
Bhopal after 94-95.

8(1)(j)

informaiton refused

07-0012

MW Siddiqui

7th March 07 Inspection of reords related to 30th March 07


agreement & inventory of Guest
houses in Delhi.

NA

Records inspected.

07-0013

Chiman LalArya

22nd March
07

Actions taken on lter dtd 20th


Nov2006.addressed to CMD
through Town Administrator.

19th April.07

NA

No action deemd fit by TA


hence ltr not forwarded.The
informaoiton givne now is
not clear

07-0014

MW Siddiqui

22nd March
07

Applicabiliyt of various acts in 20th April 07


BHEL, Bhopal namely
prevention of damage of public
property, West Benagl
prevention of property act

NA

Details provided.

07-0015

Kailash Mishra

23rd March
07

Why records are not been


computerized in P& PR

NA

Records are computerized


base of requirements of
roganizations

07-0016

Kailash Mishra

23rd March
07

Insp, of records related to letter 21st April 07


printed duribng golden jubilee
celebrations

07-0017

Shreeji Marketing

07-0018

PN Sharma

23rd March
07
29 th March

Details of bills/ payment &


refund of security deposit7
ApplicaBILIYT OF mpir Act &
details of members of unions
for 1971-2007 & details of
labourers employed by a
particular society.

07-0019

Manmohan Nath
Sharma

10th April 07 Details of bill paymento of


particular supply.

12th March 07

20th April 07

Records inspected on 27th


April 07

21st April 07

NA

Details provided

25th April07

Partial 7(9)

Status of applicability of act


given & other informaiton not
available in compiled formhence refused.

10th April 07

NA

Details provided

07-0020

MW Sidddiqui

16th April 07 Details of godown taken on rent 11th May 07


for keeping g/h furniture and
expneses on rent & storage

NA

M/s. Duropack ,5,DDA


Community Centre, Gitanjali
Enclave, New Delhi was
engaged for composite work
of packing & loading.No
details such as period of hire,
monthyly or total rent of
godown are known to us.

07-0021

MW Sidddiqui

18th April 07 Details of CISF personnel


11th May07
posted in BHEL Bhopal in last
three years & other details
regarding payment duties ect of
CISF Personnel.

24

Exempted under Section 24


of the Act

07-0022

Shailendra Tiwari

20th April 07 Request for a copy of letter


21st May 07
letter given to individualin 2002

NA

Copy of letter No
TBPA/PF/11860094 dtd 9.3.02
provided

07-0023

MW Siddiqui

3rd May 07

Rule/ Procedures in respect of


giving acknowledgments for
letter submitted by employees

21st May 07

NA

Required informaiton
provided

07-0024

Kailash Mishra

4th May 07

Shreejee Mktg

8th May 07

Details of letters printed during 4th June 07


CEO Meeting
Details of qtn for cutting of
25th May 07
nilgiri trees submitted by the
party.

NA

07-0025

Personal inspection of
Records has been done
required information for loss
occurred has already given
vide BP/CPIO/07/0017 dtd
21.7.07.& balance amount
paid on 11.5.07No provision
for FIR for loss. Details of
cut down trees enclosed in
annex-1.

07-0026

MW Siddiqui

17th May 07

Detailed list and main


objective(s) of M/s. Mckinsey &
Co since the

NA

Required information
provided

07-0027

Kailash Malllvya

18th May 07

12th June 07

NA

07-0028

MW Siddiqui

19th May 07

Case No3184- photocopy of


records
Detailed list and main
objective(s) of M/s. Hewitt
Associates since 1.4.98

14th June 07

NA

Required informaiton in 14
pages is provided
Required information
provided.

07-0029

MW Siddiqui

22nd May 07

Details related to children


strudying in BSM schools

12th June 07

NA

Eastimate list of children


studying in JNS,RHS,RKS
&VHS has been provided.

07-0030

Rajesh Sood

28th May 07

Land surrendered by BHEL


Bhopal forISBT

12th June 07

NA

No land has been


surrendered by BHEL Bhopal
for construction of ISBT

07-0031

Rajesh Sood

28th May 07

Drawing to be submitted to
BHEL Bhopal for seeking
construction premission

12th June 07

NA

As per licencse agreement,


six copies of drawings are
required to be submitted to
BHEL Bhopal for technical/
administrative permission for
doing any construction
workin the licensed premise

NA

07-0032

MW Siddiqui

30th May 07

Details related to Quality control 25th June 07


of supply and services by
various divisions of Town
administration.

NA

Required information
provided.

07-0033

Ajaiblal Nar

9th June 07

Details of shop allotted to Sh.


Vijay Singh in Gandhi market

4th July 07

NA

BHEL has not sold any land


to such a person & no
records available for
allotment of shop to that
person in Gnadhi market

07-0034

Sreejee Marketing

12th June 07 Details of qtn for cutting of


nilgiri trees submitted by the
party.

11th July 07

NA

The required inforation had


already been given against
BP/CPIO/07/0017 dtd 21.4.07

07-0035

Vinod Kumar
Mishra

23rd June 07 Documents/ copies of Caste


10th July 07
Certificates of some particular
canidates submitted by them
while appointment

8(1)(j)

Required informaiton
refused.

07-0036

MW Siddiqui

2nd July 07

Factors & Weightage are


24th July 07
considered for promotion of
employees of BHEL Bhopal for
selecting an employee for
promotion

NA

for points 1,2,4,5,6&7 of


request pertains to
promotion policy of BHEL &
available in internet site of
the unit and can be accessed
by all the employees.

07-0037

Shailendra Tiwari

3rdJuly 07

Date of movement of the


application between various
executives and names of the
executives who handed the
same of the application dtd
24/27 April 07 of Sh.S.Tiwari

NA

No procedure of keeping
track of the documenyts sent
no different deaprtments . As
such the desired informaiton
is not available

07-0038

MW Siddiqui

6th July 07

The subject matter/area covered 3rd Aug 07


in Wave 1 & 2 studies.Record of
Quality control done of supply
an services from 1.4.2007 to
30.6.2007

Partial 8(1)(d) Replied & inf given suitably


except for that exempted in
8(1) (d)

07-0039

Kailash Malvya

9th July 07

BP/CPIO/06/0076 dtd 11-12-2006

07-0040

Ravi Goyal

10th July 07

Details of working women in


computer section of Kasturba
Hospital from Blew Computer
Center

07-0041

MW Siddiqui

10th July 07 Details of tender for white


washing work of
RKGS,Berkhera by Township
civil division

07-0042

Vishnu Ramteke

12th July 07

07-0043

MW Siddiqui

24th July 07

NA

Information given suitably

24th July 07

NA

No regular employeesof
BHEL in computer section of
Kasturba Hospital. The work
of scomputer section of
Hospital has been
outsourced to the Blew
Computer, Barkhera.

3rd Aug 07

NA

The same can be inspected


in the office of TAD on 20th
Aug.07

Details of the Promotion of the


requister

NA

Required information is
related to reasons which
cannot be provided

12th July07

Proceedure and documents that 3rd Aug 07


describecompletely the
grievance redressal scheme/
systems for all cat. Of BHEL
Bhopal employees upto the
frade of ED

NA

Required informaiton given

07-0044

Govind Kushawaha 16thJuly 07

Documents/ copies of Caste


8th Aug.07
Certificates of some particular
canidates submitted by them
while appointment

NA

Photo copy of the docuemnts


given

07-0045

Kailash Malvya

16thJuly 07

Information Regarding EO
Court Case No 3184/2003

8th Aug.07

NA

According to the records


available,No advise has been
taken against the above
casehence no informaiton
given to Points 1--7. for point
No8, No reply available &
Point No.9 & 10 No
informaiton demanded by
CVT

07-0046

Bina Awasthy

18th July 07

Marking System in promotion - 3rd Aug.07


marks awarded to the
requistee under the Education
qualification.

NA

The applicant has been


awarded 20 marks for her
qualification both in June
2006 and June 2007 during
consideratin of promotion to
next higher garde.

07-0047

MW Siddiqui

20th July

Total budget of BHEL,Bhopal


for advertisement of its
products & different activities.

NA

Separate Budget has not


been sanctuioned for
creating awareness and
other activities amongst
Actual Budget for 2006-07 is
Rs.6,41,000/- & for 2007-08 is
Rs. 2,33,000/- for other local
public all the relevant
particulars have been
displayed on the web site of
BHEL,Bhopal

16th Aug,07

07-0048

MW Siddiqui

28 th Aug.07

Detailes of Executives posted in 21st Aug.07


HRM at
Bhopal,Trichy,Hyderabad &
Haridwar units of BHEL

NA

The number of Ezxecuitves in


HRM of BHEL Bhopal is 24&
Executives of BBHEL Bhopal
who were directly recruited
into the executive cadre is
14& 6 execuigves
discharging welfare
functions designaiton wise is
4

07-0049

Sandhya Bhowmik

3rd Aug.07

Paymnet status of Sh.G.K.


Bhowmik

16th Aug.07

8(1)(j)

Required inofrmation
refused as it is in personal
nature.

07-0050

MW Siddiqui

03rd Aug 07

Record/ Documents about


publicaiton of book
ABHIDRISHTI

20th Aug.07

NA

called for inspection of the


same

07-0051

Shreejee Marketing 4th Aug.07

Non receipt of deposit amount

31st August 07

NA

Some photocopies of
documents needed to
process the balance
payment.

07-0052

Sanjay Sharma

7th Aug.07

Details of Smt. Rita Sharma,


21st Aug.07
Computer Operator , computer
section in Kasturba Hospital.

8(1)(j)

Required inofrmation
refused as it is in personal
nature.

07-0053

Lata B Rawat

9th Aug.07

No of Qualified National
9th Aug.07
Supplioers listed for supplying
Mechanical components to
BHEL Bhopal

81(d)

No classification as National
Supplier in our vendor
master & BHEL Bhopal does
not manufacture Hydro
Carbons Turbines Regarding
list of vendors ,their
addressd etc is of
commercial confidence
hence not given .

07-0054

Manoj Sigh Jadhon 10th aug.07

Details of BHEL Land allotted to 8th Sep.07


Educational / social Institutions

NA

List of land/ building allotted


to various educaiton
institutions & the area /land
allotted to various
educational institions,
Security depost and licence
given as Annexure-1

07-0055

Manoj Singh
Jhadon

Details of unions & regular


8th Sep.07
employees & Contract Labours

NA

payment given to varioous


samities by CLC Deptt.
during last 5 years

07-0056

Chandresh Sharma 13th Aug.07

Details of Medical status &


Matrimonial status of late.
Ramesh Chandra Sharma

4th Sept 07

NA

No indication of Smt. Mira


Devi in the office records &
Medical record

07-0057

MW Siddiqui

14th Aug. 07

Copy of the notification/ circular 4th Sept 07


that gives eligibility period for
promotion from one
Group/Cadre to another
Grou[/Cadrefor the promotions
effected during year 2007.

NA

Fee of Rs. 20/- to be paid for


the informaiton.

07-0058

Kailash Malviya

25th Aug.07

Details of the compromise


meeting with BHEL
Management & Invalid
Possession Holders.

NA

Required informaiton given

07-0059

A.K. Naik of Jhansi 27th Aug 07

Details in which circumstances 10th Sept.07


the Promotion/ increment
facilities given to the CAE
passed out employees.

NA

Benefits ( 2 increments + 2
yrs weightages) admissible
to all theCAE panel
Employees who opt and join
Finance function &
increments have been
merged in the basic pay& No
provision for promotion to
the post of ppprobationary
Accountant in the new policy.

07-0060

Sanjay Thul,Raipur 31st Aug.07

Representation of SC/ST &


20th Sept.07
Details of Post Vacant which are
reerved for SC/ST

NA

The desired information is


not available in the desired
format.Inf available on
website and can be
downloaded

07-0061

S.U. Sheikh

Payment details of Sh.


J.P.shrivastav

NA

Required information given

10th Aug.07

1st sep.07

20th Sep.07

19th Sep.07

07-0062

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0063

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0064

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0065

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0066

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0067

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0068

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0069

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0070

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0071

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0072

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0073

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0074

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0075

S.U. Sheikh

1st sep.07

07-0076

MW Siddiqui

7th Sep.07

07-0077

MW Siddiqui

7th Sep.07

07-0078

Chandrensh
Sharma

07-0079

Payment details of Sh.


J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Payment details of Sh.
J.P.shrivastav
Documents related to receipt of
book in BHEL Bhopal

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

19th Sep.07

NA

Required information given

18th Sep.07

8(1)(h)

The matter related to


publication of Book
"ABHIDRISHTI" is under
investigation by our
Vigilance deptt. Hnece
regretted.

Details of dates of amount of


22nd Sep.07
service charges/ profit Margin
paid by BHEL , BPL to the
Samvida Shramik Kalyan Samiti

NA

Detailed information given

7th Sep.07

Details of PF/ gratuity , pension 18th Sep.07


etc of Sh. Sharmai

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

Manoj Singh
Jhadon

18th Sep.07

Detailed copies of agreement


between Contractors

NA

No. of Contract Labours


works in various societies &
facilities given to them are
informed.

07-0080

MW Siddiqui

20th Sep.07

Inspn of the records of PANDAL


FOR MAIN FUNCTION OF
GOLDEN JUBILEE

7(9)

Voluminous Relevant details


put on internet

07-0081

MW Siddiqui

21st Sep.07

Inspn of complete records


related to the audit of expn. In
Golden Jubilee Programme.

18th Oct.07

7(9)

Information on 2 out of 3
points given

07-0082

Ashok Kumar

27th Sep.07

Status of applicant's
application.

15th Oct.07

NA

Detailed information given

07-0083

Manoj Singh
Jhadon

1st Oct.07

details of some Contaract


labours

13th Oct.07

NA

certain workers are working


in various societies are given
& regarding payment,
records are not available in
BHEL.Bhopal

07-0084

Archana Verma

3rd Oct. 07

Return of Rs.10,000 in regard to 13th Oct.07


Traffic Park, Bherkhera

NA

Detailed information given

07-0085

Smt kumari Devi

12th Oct.07

State of P/F, VRS Payment,


13th Oct.07
Gratuity. Leave Encashment etc.

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

07-0086

Shreeji Marketing

12th Oct.07

Cutting of Niogiri Tres

13th Oct.07

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

07-0087

Jitendra Soni

13th Oct.07

Details of Sh.R.S. Singh

13th Oct.07

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

07-0088

S.U. Shikh

17th Oct.07

Details of Sh. J.P.Shrivastava

14th Nov.07

NA

Therequired details given

07-0089

N.R Pandey

17th Oct.07

Details of Sh. J.P.Shrivastava

14th Nov.07

NA

The required details given

07-0090

Shashi Gupta

26th Oct.07

14th Nov.07

NA

Payment details given

07-0091

MW Sidiqui

30th Oct.07

Payment details of Sg,


Chandrashekar Gupta
Minutes/ decision of JCM Held
on 22nd Aug.

07-0092

Manoj Singh
Jhadon

1st Nov.07

Various infrmaiton regarding


various aspectsof BHEL
activities.

26th Nov.07

7(9)

The required information are


not given in one appeal as
they are lengthy.

07-0093

Manoj Singh
Jhadon

5th Nov.07

List of Contract Workers

26th Nov.07

7(9)

The required information are


not given in one appeal as
they are lengthy & are not in
compiled form.

11th Oct.07

28th Nov.07

Minutes & Circular No


AA/HR/362(viii) dtd 10th
Oct.07 are furnished.

07-0094

D.D. Pathak

19th Nov.07

07-0095
07-0096

A.K. Shrivastava
A.K. Shrivastava

20th Nov.07
20th Nov.07

Details of 2nd shift duty of


9/10/03
Decision on the appeal
Admissibility of C/L during
suspension
Details of approx. number of
CLS & amount paid as
commission by BHEL to
Contractors

3rd Dec.07

NA

The required details given

15th Dec.07
15th Dec.07

NA
NA

The required details given


The required details given

07-0097

MW Sidiqui

21st Nov.07

13th Dec.07

NA

Details of PF/ no. of contract


labours for the last 3 years
are given

07-0098

Ajay Shankar Tiwari 27th Nov.07

PF,Gratuity and other detai,lsa


of Tarabhai

15th Dec.07

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

07-0099

MW Sidiqui

27th Nov.07

NA

The required details given

07-0100

H.C.Gupta

28th Nov.07

purpose of dumping of Big


13th Dec,07
stones slab near pipl;ani police
stn
Details of stationery items
15th Dec.07

07-0101

MW Sidiqui

6th Dec.07

Re carpoeting of Roads of
Piplani,Bharkhera,G'pura &
Habib Ganj

22nd Dec.07

NA

Required informaiton given

07-0102

Majid Hussain

11th Dec.07

Details of the paperspublished


inHindi/English/ Urdu

9th Jan.08

7(9)

point no 1,2,6,7,8 are note


available in compiled form
&3,4,5 &9 are replied .

7(9)

STATUS OF REQUEST
Reg No Name of the
applicant

Date of
Receipt

08-0001

HC Gupta

3rd Jan.08

08-002

MW Siddiqui

3rd Jan.08

08-003

Lachcuram Arya

8th Jan.08

08-004

Krishna Kumari Gupta

21st Jan.08

08-005

Krishna Kumari Gupta

08-006

Shailendra Raikhwad

21st Jan.08

08-007

Shailendra Raikhwad

30th Jan.08
30th Jan.08

08-008

Santosh Kumar

5th Feb.08

08-009

Ram Sharma

08-0010

Amardev Singh

13th Feb.08
14th Feb.08

08-0011

Urmila Gupta

15th Feb.08

08-0012

Shyam Verma

19th Feb.08

08-0013

Urmila Gupta

22nd Feb.08

08-0014

Gendalal Yadav

25th Feb.08

08-0015

Dhirendra Sigh,N.delhi

25th Feb.08

08-0016

Goverdhan Naryani

4th March 08

08-0017

Govind Kushwaha

5th March 08

08-0018

AK Shrivastava

6th March 08

08-0019

Akbar khan Gouri

29th March 08

08-0020

Akbar khan Gouri

7th April 08

08-0021

Satish Kumar

15th April .08

08-0022

HC Gupta

16th April 08

08-0023

M.Farooq

23rd April 08

08-0024

Akbar khan Gouri

25th April 08

08-0025

Kailash Malviya

25th April 08

08-0026

HC Gupta

26th April08

08-0027

Sh. Mukesh Kr. Yadav

30th April 08

08-0028

Ravi Sethi Amritsar

6th May 08

08-0029

A.K. Shrivastava

15th May 08

08-0030

Mukesh Kr. Yadav

26th May 08

08-0031

Raj kumar Agarwal

27th May 08

08-0032

Smt Prabhavati Yadhav

6th June 08

08-0033

Gurmeet Kour

4th July 08

08-0034

A.K. Shrivastava

15th May 08

08-0035

Akbar khan Gouri

18th July 08

08-0036

A.K. Shrivastava

25th July 08

08-0037

Nandmer

28th July 08

08-0038

Deepak Chatterjee

28th July 08

08-0039

Laxman Prasad C/o


Vivek Sharma

2nd August 08

08-0040

Nandmer

6th August 08

08-0041

13th August 08

08-0042

18th August 08

08-0043

19th August 08

08-0044

20th August 08

08-0045

27th August 08

08-0046

1st Sept 08

08-0047

1st Sept.08

08-0048

3rd Sept.08

08-0049

3rd Sept.08

08-0050

4th Sept.08

STATUS OF REQUESTS RECEIVED UNDER RTI ACT IN 2008


Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Reward Scheme of 2007

29th Jan.08

Inspn of records of re-carpeting of


roads
Payment of ancillary to artisans Mfg
slings under Works Engg,

1st Feb.08
29th Jan.08

Copy of Technical Collaboration


Agreement for VCBs upto 36 KV

18th Feb.08

Detailed certified copyof Technical


18th Feb.08
Collaboration Agreement of Industrial
Machines

Details of DGR Seurity guards


Details of Contracts & their
contractors
RETURNED WITH ORIGINAL DUE TO
NON SUBMISSION OF FEE
Details of Sh. R.S. Tiwari of Kasturba
hospital
Details of Coming Union Election in
BHEL. Bhopal

28th Feb.08
28th Feb.08
5th Feb.08-

6th March 08
7th March 08

Details of Technical Collaboration


Agreement

18th Feb.08

Details of chemicals purchased by Mr.


Amit Choudhary from M/s Blow
enterprises in the year 2000

6th Mar.08

Documents pertaining to collaboration 6th March.08


of VCBs up to KV with Siemens

Details of qtr No 82/N1/A

6h March 08

Tender NO CDC/E-00255 &256

21st March 08

Details of Shop. No 34, F Sector


Berkhera

28th Mar.08

Details of ,attendance, monthly pay etc 21st March 08


of a certain employee

Details of standing orders

21st March 08

Details of Delivery details of the son of 31st March 08


St. Nazeema Khan, w/o shri Mohd.
Akbar Khan

Details of Delivery details of the son of 30th May 08


St. Nazeema Khan, w/o shri Mohd.
Akbar Khan
Details of Joining procedure in the
company

12th May08

12th May 08
Attendance of Sh. K.C. Jain & O.P
Shrivastav & details of housing loan
etc.
Details of MPIR Act, Taxi &Retainership 12th May 08

Attendance of certain persons

12th May 08

Details of penalty imposed on CH


Tiwari

22nd May 08

Details of returning of certain letters & 20th May 08


records of certain employees

Details of a particular person

30thApril

All India Tender No CDC/RC/E-00255&


00256

22nd May 08

Information related to land situated in


J.K. Road and records of decision
taken by Civil court on 22/02/99

12th June 08

Details of documents like Caste


Certificate, others of a certain
employee

23rd June 08

List of registered vendors with BHEL,


Bhopal

23rd June 08

Details of Service period, member of


family as per records of Shri Nimar

2nd July 08

In formation of Contract labousr of M.P. 22nd July 08


Mahila klayan Samiti( ladies) who has
worked in TBG, BHEL Unit
Details of 2nd Appel to High Court,M.P. 12th June 08
by BHEL & other details
Attendance details of certain persons 22th Jul7 08

Various information regarding Standing 5th August 08


order no 55
details regarding notings of Unit and 6th August 08
Corporate Vigilance

details regarding notings of Unit and


Corporate Vigilance

6th August 08

Details of Laxman Prasad

21st August 08

ACRs of the requester

30th August 08

Information regarding working period


of self in IMM Section as a contract
worker

21st August 08

Details of payments on death to


relaives of Late Sh Jagdish Singh

21st August 08

List of Employees who were on Tour to


Indore from Bhopal during last two fin
yrs
Photocopies of suspension
,Revocation etc
Reasons of denial of promotion from
Artisan Grade1 To Astt. Engineer/
Technician
Status of a particular Contractor &
contract given during last years
Copy of Agreement of Artisans for
appointment in BHEL and date of birth
of artisans recruited
Quarters allotted to various societies
by BHEL
Details of MOU /agreement for joint
venture with NTPC
Records/ docuemnts related to book
Abhidrishti published on occasion of
Golden Jubilee

I ACT IN 2008
Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

NA

copy already given by HR on


23.01.08. Copy again given

NA

A particular date given for


inspection & inspection done
For produciton of slings, the
heavy work like lifting/dropping
of job is done through cranes.
For production of slings, the
ancillary is being given.

NA

Appeal at
Corp Level

NA

The informatin is sought for


Technical Collaboration Agreement
forn VCB from 1991-92 to 1994-95.
There was nothing like Annual Price
list for the enquired components. As
per BHEL systems, the retention
period for purchase order files is five
years. The desired informaiton is for
period between 1991 to 1995 which
is almost 13-18 years old as such no
records are available for the said
period.

NA

Partial
8(1()e)
7(9)

The informatin is sought for


Technical Collaboration Agreement
forIndustrial Machines from 1991-92
to 1994-95. Tehcnical Collaboration
Agreement with M/s. Siemens AG
was for a period of 10 years from
1981-91. The collaboration had
ended in 1991.There was nothing
like Annual Price list for the enquired
components.BHEL systems, the
retnetion period for purchase order
files is five years. The desired
informaiton is for period between
1991 to 1995 which is almost 13-18
years old as such as no records are
available for the said period.

The process of appointment,


police veritifivation etc are done
by the society.,
Records not available in a
compiled form.

NA
NA

Required details furnished


No information about Coming
union election of BHEL, Bhopal
till date.

NA

NA
NA

The informatin is sought for


Technical Collaboration Agreement
forIndustrial Machines from 1991-92
to 1994-95. Tehcnical Collaboration
Agreement with M/s. Siemens AG
was for a period of 10 years from
1981-91. The collaboration had
ended in 1991.There was nothing
like Annual Price list for the enquired
components.BHEL systems, the
retnetion period for purchase order
files is five years. The desired
informaiton is for period between
1991 to 1995 which is almost 13-18
years old as such as no records are
available for the said period.

The records are kept for 5 years


only & the request sought isof
2008 records NA .

The informatin is sought for


Technical Collaboration Agreement
for VCBs upto 36KV from 1991-92 to
94-95.For Request III & iv As per
BHEL systems, the retnetion period
for purchase order files is five years.
The desired informaiton is for period
between 1991 to 1995 which is
almost 13-18 years old as such as no
records are available for the said
period.

NA

Sec (3)

Allotment has been done on


24.7.2003 & the pending amount
up to March 08 is Rs. 8,637 /Regret the request due the
request of any compny for
providing information under
RTI Act 2005,

NA

8(1)(j)

The shop is allotted to Sh.


Santosh Kumar Jaswani from
1.1.81 on licence basis &
renew al of licence is pending
No relationship to any public
activity or interest hence
refused

NA

The informaiton sought does


not exist on records , The query
relates to interpretation of
standing ordrs and reasons
theerfof for taking decsion.
CPIO is not obliged to comment
on reasoons and interpretations

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

Appeal rejected
by Apellate
committee

NA

Required information given as


information although personal
is being sought in public
interest

NA

The procedure is the same as is


applicable to other candidates.
For joining the candidate has to
resign and get relieved from
present employer.

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

Appeal rejected
by Apellate
committee

Partial 7 (9) No amdt in MPI R Act of 2005,


Records not available in
compiled form
8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

Partial 8(1)j Required documents given


& 8 (1)e
8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused
Returned in original due to non
submission of fees in the form
of D/D/ Cash

Appeal rejected
by Apellate
committee

partial 4(1- Out of 38 parties, 26 parties had Appeal rejected


b-Viii)
submitted bids agaisnt E00255 by Apellate
23 had qualified & 3 parties had committee
been rejected & out of 34 parties
against Tender NO E00256, 22
parties had submitted bids& 17
paries had qualified for opening
& 5 parties had been rejcted

NA

Copies of records of decision


taken by Civil court dtd 22/02/99
has been furnished

NA

Required documents furnsihed


as information sought is in
public interest

7(9)

The informaiton sougt is not


available on BHEL Intenet and
furher compilation of
informaiton would indeed
disproportionately divert the
resouceces of the company

NA

Mr Nimar has joined in the


company in 7.12.966 as regular
employee & retited on 24.8.007.
No records availabe regarding
family status

Appeal rejected
by Apellate
committee

NA

The said ladies are related to


MKS therefor the samiti has the
real responsibilirty to take
decision.

NA

Copy of the H.C order and other


details furnished
No relationship to any public
activity or interest hence
refused

8(1)(j)

NA
8(1)(h)

Required informaiton given


suitably
notwith standing anything
contained in the Act. Ther shall
be no obligation to give any
citizen information which
would impede the process of
investigation or apprehension
or prosecution of offenders.

8(1)(h)

notwith standing anything


contained in the Act. There shall
be no obligation to give any
citizen information which
would impede the process of
investigation or apprehension
or prosecution of offenders.

NA

No such person is working in


BHEL, Bhopal

Partial
8(1)e
8(1)(j)

8(1)(j)

ACR ratings furnished


inspection of DPC records not
allowed
No relationship to any public
activity or interest hence
refused
No relationship to any public
activity or interest hence
refused

Appeal at CIC
level

For Request III & iv As per BHEL systems, th

est III & iv As per BHEL systems, the retnetion period for purchase order files is five years. The desired informaiton is for period between 19

releeved for present employer.

of investigation or apprehension or prosecution of offenders.

n is for period between 1991 to 1995 which is almost 13-18 years old as such as no records are available for the said period.

ion of offenders.

SUMMARY OF RTI CASES REGISTERED AT HEP, BHOPAL


Upto April April 2006- Jan 2007-till
2006
Dec 2006
Dec 2007

Requests Recieved
Information given

34
28

88
67

102
80

Information Refused

21

22

CLAUSE WISE DETAILS OF REFUSAL


Section 3
Section 7 (9)
Section 8 (1)a

Inf can be requested by


citizens
Dispproportionate
diversion of resources
Inf. may affect
economic interests of
the state

8
1

Section 8 (1)d

Inf. Related to comm.


Confidence/ Third party

Section 8 (1)j

Inf of no public
interest/personal inf.

Section 8 (1)h

Inf may impeded


process of investigation

Section 8 (1)a
&d
Section 8 (1)e & Inf available in fiduciary
j
relationship

12
1

2
1

Others -

Matter under court, NASports authority

SUMMARY OF RTI CASES OF 2006 - INFORMATION REFUSED


Sec if
refused

Reg No Name

Date of recpt

Request In Brief

05-0001 L.P.Yadav

06th Dec 05

Inquiry/Suspension details of an
8(j)
Ex employee

REFUSED

05-0023 Rajendra Kumar

30th Jan.06

Details of an ex-employee
regarding reservation during
service

8(j)

Refused

14th March 06

Employment details of 2
employees and authencity of pay
8(j)
slips furnished by these
employees to applicant.

Refused

05-0032 M.Hasan

14th March 06

Employment details of an
employee and authencity of pay
8(j)
slips furnished by the employee
to applicant.

Refused

05-0033 Saifuddin Saifi

21st March 06

Details of CBI raid in CDC in 2003


8(h)
and actions taken thereof.

Refused - Matter still under


investigation.

05-0034 Harihar Mishra

22nd March 06

Details of VRS of an ex-employee 8(j)

Refused

05-0031 M.Hasan

Reply In brief

SUMMARY OF RTI CASES OF 2006 - INFORMATION REFUSED


Reg No Name of the

Date of
Receipt

Request In Brief

Date Of reply

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

applicant
06-0005

Shailendra
Maheswari

22nd May 06

Details of deduction from amount paid as 22nd May 06


deposit by Shreeji Marketing for cutting
of Trees

8(j)

As it is not a public matter


hence it is refused.

06-0006

OP Gandhi

15th June06

Record of Promotion, Salary & Arrears

8(j)

06-0016

MW Siddiqui

110th July 06 Details of the BHEL employees who are


7th Aug.06
the members of any Vidhan Sabha or
Nagar Nigam or Nagar palika / other local
body & how much amount is drawing
from these bodies on account of salary
sitting fee,allowance perks ,reimbursement etc.& actions taken for
gatheing information from these
perosns& the rules for giving permission
for these by BHEL

7(9)

As it is not a public matter


hence it is refused..
No information is available
and also compilation would
disproportionately divert the
resources of the public
authority hence the same
cannot be provided as per
section 7(9) of the RTI act.

06-027

Jaichandra Yadav

21st July 06

Details of allotment of Shop. No.10 of Lal 10th Aug.06


Bahadur Shastry Market and subquent
tansfer of allotments

8(j)

Refused- Personal Matter

06-032

MW Siddiqui

28th July.06

Manpower (in different categories) of


Medical Deptt. Of BHEL, Bhopal as on
24th June2001 - 24th June 2006

25th Aug.06

7(9)

Compiled Records not


available. Hence details not
provided referring sec 7 (9) of
the act.

06-033

MW Siddiqui

29th July.06

No of patients reported for treatment in


25th Aug.06
different disciplines of Kasturba Hospital
and dispensaries during the yrs ended on
24th June2001 - 24th June 2006.

7(9)

Compiled Records not


available. Hence details not
provided referring sec 7 (9) of
the act.

06-044

Vijay Kumar.D,(A.P) 9th Aug.06

Informaiton of DC Gen.Traction
Motors,Transformers & traction electrics
used in shunt motors etc

8(1)(a) & (d)

Information desired is of
Commercial confidence and
no public interest involved.
Hence inf not provided.

29th June 06

4th Sep.06

06-052

Harish Mittal

25th Aug.06

Action taken by BHEL against the


applicant's application.

21st Sep.06

7(9)

Compiled list not available.


Refused under sec 7(9)

06-058

LD Agarwal

8th Sep.o6

Details of methodology followed/


adopted by BHEL to ensure meeting the
basic requrement of establishing the
reasonability of prices

28th Sep.06

8(1)(a) & (d)

Contrary to the party's claim


very limited items are being
procured by the respective
groups within BHEL Bhopal
on single party basis& no
informaiton is maintained in
a format form.and
information asked by sh.L.D
Agrawal is in a commercial
confidential nature and the
same is exempted under
seciton 8(1-a) & 8 (1-d).& the
reasonablity of the prices is
decided by the last purchase
price and indent estimaiton ,
& there is no public interest
in the informaitonsought .

06-0062

MW Siddiqui

16thSep.06

Details of persons who were proposed for 12th Oct.06


the positon of Independent Directors of
BHEL by DHI,Governmento of Indian ahd
where commen6ts form BHEL were
sought for the proposed appointment..

8(1-e) 8(1-j)

disclosure of Informaiton
exemted under section 8(1-e)
8(1-j) hence refused.

06-0066

MW Siddiqui

3rd Oct.06

No of flags/ posters/ no of files carrying


out for golden celebration

31st Oct.06

7(9)

The golden jubilee


expenditure details have
been uploaded on BHEL
Bhopal's website . Compiling
of further details is not
possible and the same is
exempted under section of 7
(9).

06-0068

Karnail singh

18th Oct.06

Documents regarding land returned by


BHEL

16th Nov.06

8(1-a)

Returning of land is in a
sensitive state . Disclosure of
such informaiton is
exempted under Section
8(1-a) of the act.

06-0070

Abdul Sarvar

1st Nov.06

Qtn of Bus

25th Nov,06

7 (9).

Qtns of 4 parties are


technically suitable as per
the norms of the committee.
The quoted rates are not
suitable hecne rejected.
Compiling of further details
is not possible and the same
is exempted under section of
7 (9).

06-0071

Anil kumar Bhave

3rd Nov.06

Discrepanciews in preparation of pay


during deputation

30th Nov.06

8(1-j)

The informaiton sought is in


individual nature. Hence
refused under Section 8(1J) of the act.

06-0077

FS Sahu

13th Nov.06

Provide self Payscale of store keeper &


Reward scheme

09th Dec.06

8-1(j)

The informaiton sought is in


individual nature. Hence
refused under Section 8(1J) of the act.

06-0083

MPPTCL,Jabalpur

4th Dec.06

Request of order copy - Order No


4558531/ 15.2.06 & rate of contract

26 th Dec.06

sec.8(1)d

Informaiton sought pertians


to third party & would harm
the competitive positon of a
third party so the desired
informaiton is exempted
under sec.8(1)d of the act

06-0088

Kamalesh Solanki

23rd Dec.06

Details of Narendra Verma

6 th Jan.07

8(1) (j)

The informaiton sought isof


individual nature. Hence
refused under Section 8(1J) of the act.

07-0021

MW Sidddiqui

18th April 07 Details of CISF personnel


11th May07
posted in BHEL Bhopal in last
three years & other details
regarding payment duties ect of
CISF Personnel.

24

Exempted under Section 24


of the Act

07-0009

Kailash Mishra

22nd feb.07

Details of printing policy &


12th March 07
details of books printed in last 3
years.

7(9)

Details of prninting polcy


given detai;s of bokks
published not available in
compiled form

07-0080

MW Siddiqui

20th Sep.07

Inspn of the records of PANDAL


FOR MAIN FUNCTION OF
GOLDEN JUBILEE

7(9)

Voluminous Relevant details


put on internet

07-0081

MW Siddiqui

21st Sep.07

Inspn of complete records


related to the audit of expn. In
Golden Jubilee Programme.

18th Oct.07

7(9)

Information on 2 out of 3
points given

07-0092

Manoj Singh
Jhadon

1st Nov.07

Various infrmaiton regarding


various aspectsof BHEL
activities.

26th Nov.07

7(9)

The required information are


not given in one appeal as
they are lengthy.

07-0093

Manoj Singh
Jhadon

5th Nov.07

List of Contract Workers

26th Nov.07

7(9)

The required information are


not given in one appeal as
they are lengthy & are not in
compiled form.

07-0100

H.C.Gupta

28th Nov.07

Details of stationery items

15th Dec.07

7(9)

07-0102

Majid Hussain

11th Dec.07

Details of the paperspublished


inHindi/English/ Urdu

9th Jan.08

7(9)

point no 1,2,6,7,8 are note


available in compiled form
&3,4,5 &9 are replied .

07-0076

MW Siddiqui

7th Sep.07

Documents related to receipt of 18th Sep.07


book in BHEL Bhopal

8(1)(h)

The matter related to


publication of Book
"ABHIDRISHTI" is under
investigation by our
Vigilance deptt. Hnece
regretted.

07-0001

Shailendra Tiwari

9th Jan.07

Details of signing authorities of 23 rd Jan.07


ACR/PMSR/E Map Repot of self
for the year 1987-2006.

8(1)(j)

The informaiton sought is of


individual nature. Hence
exempted under Section
8(1-J) of the act.

07-0035

Vinod Kumar
Mishra

23rd June 07 Documents/ copies of Caste


10th July 07
Certificates of some particular
canidates submitted by them
while appointment

8(1)(j)

Required informaiton
refused.

07-0049

Sandhya Bhowmik

3rd Aug.07

Paymnet status of Sh.G.K.


Bhowmik

16th Aug.07

8(1)(j)

Required inofrmation
refused as it is in personal
nature.

07-0052

Sanjay Sharma

7th Aug.07

Details of Smt. Rita Sharma,


21st Aug.07
Computer Operator , computer
section in Kasturba Hospital.

8(1)(j)

Required inofrmation
refused as it is in personal
nature.

07-0078

Chandrensh
Sharma

7th Sep.07

Details of PF/ gratuity , pension 18th Sep.07


etc of Sh. Sharmai

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

07-0085

Smt kumari Devi

12th Oct.07

State of P/F, VRS Payment,


13th Oct.07
Gratuity. Leave Encashment etc.

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

07-0086

Shreeji Marketing

12th Oct.07

Cutting of Niogiri Tres

13th Oct.07

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

07-0087

Jitendra Soni

13th Oct.07

Details of Sh.R.S. Singh

13th Oct.07

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

07-0098

Ajay Shankar Tiwari 27th Nov.07

PF,Gratuity and other detai,lsa


of Tarabhai

15th Dec.07

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

07-0006

Sangeeta
Maheshwari

5th Feb.07

Details of deduction from


5th Feb.07
amount paid as deposit by
Shreeji Marketing for cutting of
Trees

8(1)(j)

Refused

07-0010

VK Agarwal

23rd Feb.07

Photocopies of documents
8th March 07
submitted at the time of joining
BHEL Tiruchi

8(1)(j)

Refused

07-0011

Harish mittal

26t Feb 07

Photo copies of appoint ment


23rd March07
order of trainees joined in BHEL
Bhopal after 94-95.

8(1)(j)

informaiton refused

07-0053

Lata B Rawat

9th Aug.07

No of Qualified National
9th Aug.07
Supplioers listed for supplying
Mechanical components to
BHEL Bhopal

81(d)

No classification as National
Supplier in our vendor
master & BHEL Bhopal does
not manufacture Hydro
Carbons Turbines Regarding
list of vendors ,their
addressd etc is of
commercial confidence
hence not given .

SUMMARY OF RTI CASES OF 2008 - INFORMA


08-0015

Dhirendra Sigh,N.delhi

25th Feb.08

08-0017
08-0019

Govind Kushwaha
Akbar khan Gouri

5th March 08
29th March 08

08-0022

HC Gupta

16th April 08

08-0024

Akbar khan Gouri

25th April 08

08-0026

HC Gupta

26th April08

08-0031

Raj kumar Agarwal

27th May 08

08-0035

Akbar khan Gouri

18th July 08

08-0037

Nandmer

28th July 08

08-0038

Deepak Chatterjee

28th July 08

08-0041

Virendra Singh

13th August 08

08-0042

Ramjith Singh

18th August 08

08-007

Shailendra Raikhwad

30th Jan.08

S OF 2008 - INFORMATION REFUSED


Tender NO CDC/E-00255 &256

21st March 08

Details of ,attendance, monthly pay etc 21st March 08


of a certain
employee
Details
of Delivery
details of the son of 31st March 08
St. Nazeema Khan, w/o shri Mohd.
Akbar Khan
12th May 08
Attendance of Sh. K.C. Jain & O.P
Shrivastav & details of housing loan
etc.
Attendance of certain persons

12th May 08

Details of returning of certain letters & 20th May 08


records of certain employees

List of registered vendors with BHEL,


Bhopal

23rd June 08

Attendance details of certain persons

22th Jul7 08

details regarding notings of Unit and


Corporate Vigilance

6th August 08

details regarding notings of Unit and


Corporate Vigilance

6th August 08

Information regarding working period


of self in IMM Section as a contract
worker
Details of payments on death to
relaives of Late Sh Jagdish Singh

21st August 08

Details of Contracts & their


contractors

28th Feb.08

21st August 08

Sec (3)

Regret the request due the


request of any compny for
providing information under
RTI Act 2005,

8(1)(j)
8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity
or interest
hence
No
relationship
to any
public
refused
activity or interest hence
refused

Appeal rejected
by Apellate
committee

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

Appeal rejected
by Apellate
committee

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

Appeal rejected
by Apellate
committee

7(9)

The informaiton sougt is not


available on BHEL Intenet and
furher compilation of
informaiton would indeed
disproportionately divert the
resouceces of the company

Appeal rejected
by Apellate
committee

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused

8(1)(h)

notwith standing anything


contained in the Act. Ther shall
be no obligation to give any
citizen information which
would impede the process of
investigation or apprehension
or prosecution of offenders.

8(1)(h)

notwith standing anything


contained in the Act. There shall
be no obligation to give any
citizen information which
would impede the process of
investigation or apprehension
or prosecution of offenders.

8(1)(j)

No relationship to any public


activity or interest hence
refused
No relationship to any public
activity or interest hence
refused

8(1)(j)

7(9)

Records not available in a


compiled form.

Reg No

Name of the
applicant

06-0006

OP Gandhi

06-0008

MW Siddiqui

06-0010

MW Siddiqui

06-0011

MW Siddiqui

06-0012

MW Siddiqui

06-0013

MW Siddiqui

06-0014

MW Siddiqui

06-0015

MW Siddiqui

06-0016

MW Siddiqui

06-0017

MW Siddiqui

06-0018

MW Siddiqui

06-020

MW Siddiqui

06-021

MW Siddiqui

06-022

MW Siddiqui

06-023

MW Siddiqui

06-025

Sunil Kumar Patahk

06-026

Manoj Singh Jadon

06-028

MW Siddiqui

06-033

MW Siddiqui

06-034

MW Siddiqui

06-041

MW Siddiqui

06-042

MW Siddiqui

06-049

MW Siddiqui

06-051

MW Siddiqui

06-052

Harish Mittal

06-053

MW Siddiqui

06-055

MW Siddiqui

06-0064

MW Siddiqui

06-0078

Atul Purohit

06-0085

MW Siddiqui

Request In Brief

Record of Promotion, Salary &


Arrears

Sec if
refused
8(j)

Detailed list of executives of


NA
complete BHEL who were
promoted to the grade of AGMs
between 01-01-2003 to 24.05.2006
& total number of executives
superannuated / Retired during
this period.Is strength of
employees of BHEL a factor in
sanctioning the number of posts
at GM & ED levels in BHEL.

Details of targets- at the


NA
beginning of the year & RE for the
years 2002-06 for T/O and profit
before Tax and Actual
Achievements for BHEL Bhopal &
Complete BHEL Corporation. And
also records file notings of
additional charge given to
GM(P&D,Q),Sh.Prabhat kumar

Details of grant since 2003-04,


Balance sheet ,Income
Expenditure Statement & total
income & expenditure of BHEL
Shikhamandal since 2003-04 to
2005-06.

NA

Details of expenditure to be
NA
incurred on the Golden Jubilee
Block being made on the
Southernside of BHEL Bhopal
Plant and actual expenditure
made till 30.6.06.Breakup of
proposed expenditure to be
incurred on the Civil Work,
Development of common
facitilites, Installation of machine
tools, & All other items.

Details of quarters alloted in


NA
BHEL Township to NON-BHEL
organizations/ individuals &
arrears of license fee/amount of
rent/ norm & policy of allotment
and quantum of rent to be
charged from Non- organisations/
individuals.

No.Of ( N3N4,type-III,B,type
NA
etc)quarters there in BHEL
Township &No of quarters vacant
& Plinth area of each quarter&
details of the vacant quarters
whose doors & windows are
damaged
/stolen./FIRS/Reports/Complaint
have been lodged with Police &
records of anti theft squad &
review by head of Township
Administraiton & relevant
minutes of meeting etc.

No of Jhuggies exiisting in BHEL NA


Town ship as on 1st Jan.20032006. Had steps have been taken
to prevent the
construciton/formaiton of new
Jhuggies . Also estimated
expenditure incurred by BHEL in
supplying free electricity and
Water for existing Jhuggies and
reason for not dis continuing the
facilities & The steps taken by
BHEL to stop / reduce the
expenditure

Details of the BHEL employees


7(9)
who are the members of any
Vidhan Sabha or Nagar Nigam or
Nagar palika / other local body &
how much amount is drawing
from these bodies on account of
salary sitting fee,allowance perks
,re-imbursement etc.& actions
taken for gatheing information
from these perosns& the rules for
giving permission for these by
BHEL

The names of the main


contractors , Suppliers of
machines tools and other
facilities to be installed in the
Golden Jubilee Block of BHEL,
Bhopal & value of order placed
on each of the parties
till30.06.2006

NA

Details of budget of BHEL Bhopal NA


Township for the years 2003 - 07,
& total actual expenditure till
2005-06 . details of
development /improvement
activities carried out &
expenditure incurred by BHEL
Bhopal Township since
01/01/05.How much is the income
of BHEL BHOPAL Town
Department major account heads
in the financial year 2003-04,04-05
& 05-06.

The details of License fee


NA
charged by BHEL Bhopal for
N3,N4,Type-III,Btype quarters
from BHELemployees & NonBHEL organizational/ individuals
& the name ,Designaiton & staff
no of the senior most BHEL
employees staying in each type
of quarters amount of HRA
he/she is entitled if not staying in
the quarter..

The details of License fee


NA
charged by BHEL Bhopal for
N3,N4,Type-III,Btype quarters
from BHELemployees & NonBHEL organizational/ individuals
& the notation value of House
Rent Allowance entitlement of
employees staying in BHEL
Township.

No.of Guest Houses /transit flats NA


functioning at Delhi, Mumbai,
Kolkotta and Chennai by various
unitsof BHEL &the monthly/yearly
rentpaid to the House owner by
such units and rules & details for
the Bank guarantee if furnished
to the House owner for taking
guest House/transit flats on rental
baiss.

Details of Type III,C-3,N4,N5 N6 NA


and Banglow quarters of
different sectors of BHEL
Township& basis of allocation of
budget for the maintenance of
these quarters & roads.
Expenditure incurred on
maintenance for these type
quarters & roads for the years
2003-06 . How much amount had
been spent in each sector for
maintenance of these quarters &
roads

Details of Temporary/Permanent
Works as per Manual of BHEL
Bhopal and no of contract
employees employed in such
works . Details of agreements
from 1994 onwards

NA

Details of agreements between


BHEL Bhopal , Labour contract
United front , unions etc

NA

Total Expedniture incurred by


BHEL for establishing G/H at
Noida

NA

No of patients reported for


7(9)
treatment in different disciplines
of Kasturba Hospital and
dispensaries during the yrs
ended on 24th June2001 - 24th
June 2006.
Details of Hospitals empanneled
by BHEL fo referring employees
and whether BHEL employees
can avail such facilities as per
their choice

NA

Policy of remployment to retired


employees and Details of retired
employees remployed by BHEL

NA

Details of "Societies " acting as NA


Labour Contractors. No of
contract labourers being supplied
by each. Rate of Commission,
total amount paid by BHEL.
Fringe benefits given by BHEL

Details of the BHEL Employees


who sought permission form
BHEL for contesting Vidhan
Sabha/Local Body election.

7(9)

Expenditure incurred in
NA
maintenance of ED Bungalow.
Action taken by BHEL against the 7(9)
applicant's application.
Permission of Inspection of
NA
records & take note in extract of
golden jubilee celebration

Details of agencies who are


authorized for rendering service
of various categories of BHEL
retired / voluntary retired to
BHEL Bhopal.

NA

What is the minimum wage being NA


paid to contract labourers engage
in BHEL and DR Workers/
workers apdi theough
continegncy bill by BHEL at
vArious units and Office s at
Delhi and if DR workers /
workers paid through
contingency bill if poasted
outside their mother units are
being paid minimum wage in
thsoe cities at the rate
prtescribed by the State Govt for
those cities. Whether the
minimum wage being paid in
various units in para 1 above is
at par with the minimum wage
prescribed by the respective
State Govt.

Details ofBHEL Sports Club

Refused as
Sports
authority is
independe
nt body

Details of employees who were


NA
given special benefits in ED Sect.
of Sh. R.C Aggarwal, S.N.Roy &
P.T. Deo.

Reply In brief

As it is not a public matter hence it


is refused..
Detailed list of executives of
various units of BHEL furnished .
With regards to sl no.2, the
strength of employee is not a
critical factor in considering
sanction of posts of GM &ED
levels in BHE..

The data of BHEL,Bhopal&


corporate is provided & Query at
point no.2 idoes not involve large
public interest hence not
provided.

Grant given by BHEL to Shikha


Mandal & the total income &
expenditure of the BSM provided .
The account of 05-06 are under
audft and hence the data is not
provided.
The summary of expenditure &
break-up provided.

Number of quarters allotted to


outsiders ( other than ExEmployees) are provided
alongwith licence fees charges
from orgainsation/Individual for
each type of quarters. With regard
to arrears of the license fees, the
compiled informaiton as on
1.7.2006 is not available.Regarding
Norms/Policy of allotment to
outsiders, the quarters were given
to the organizations in the past
depending upon the justification
and approval of the competent
authority.

Reply to the point -1 is provided &


the data regarding period of
vacancy of each type quarter is not
available The compiled form of
informaiton in the case of vacant
quarters with Damaged
windows /doors/ stolen are not
available.To prevent thefts the
matter is takenup with police as
well as state authorities from time
to time.In order to protect
/safeguard the property of BHEL
Bhopal quarters, the township ,
security Department is in
existence under the control of
Sr.DGM (Vigilance/Security.) They
review the work and take
corrective action from time to time
accordingly.

No survey of total jhuggies in the


Township Administration was
conducted for the required years.
Regarding encoarchment
patrolling by the Eviction Cell is
being done & no free supply of
Electricity & Water supply to any
Jhuggi area by BHEl.No separate
metring systmem in jhuggi area &
hence actual expenditure can not
be quantified. The efforts are being
made by BHEL for disconnecting
the facilities.

No information is available and


also compilation would
disproportionately divert the
resources of the public authority
hence the same cannot be
provided as per section 7(9) of the
RTI act.

The name of main civil


contractors ,suppliers of machines
and other facilities to be installed
in the Golden Jubilee is provided.
Regarding the value of orders
settled with the suppliers is a
confidential matternadalso a
sensitive informaiton hence not
provided under Sec 8-1(d)

The year wise Budget, expenditure


and development activities carried
out provided.

Details of License fees charge


from Organization/individual is
525/725/1500,3350/- for each type
of quarters provided & the details
of name ,Designaiton and staff no
of senior most BHEL employee
staying in each type of quarter is
not available in compiled form.If
the employe wants ot move to his
own house or rented
accommodaiton the employee is
entitled for HRA equal to 15 % of
his / her pay as per company rule.

Details of License fees charge


from Organization/individual is
525/725/1500,3350/- for each type
of quarters.& name & details
already provided with application
No BP/CPIO/06/0020 dtd 15.7.06&
the name ,Designaiton & staff No
of senior most BHEl employees
stating in each type quarter is not
available in compiled form.&
Notation value of House Rent
Allowance entitlement of employee
is not clear.& as per company's
rule the employee is entited for
HRA equal to 15 % of his/ her basic
pay.

Available records furnished


unitwise

Details of quarters in various


neighbourhood is provided & The
budget is allocated to township on
overall basis &the neighbourhood
breakup of expenditure is not
availabkle & the total expenditure
on maintenance of township is
given for respective years. No
record is being maintained
neighbourhood wise as the budget
is given on overall & internal
planning is depending as per the
requirement of respective areas

Classification of Temporary and


permanent work does not exist .
Contract workers are employed by
contractors. Details of agreements
can be provided on submission of
additional fee of Rs 182 only for 91
pages

Details provided alonwith list of


contractors
Details such as expenses on
modification, reconstruction
furnishing and maintenance
provided

Compiled Records not available.


Hence details not provided
referring sec 7 (9) of the act.

Extract of Personnel Manual Para


E5 -4.3.1 and list of Hospitals
empnneled provided

BHEL does not remploy retired


people

Name and Regn.of 5 societies


supplying contract labourers to
BHEL Bhopal are provided & no.of
contract labourers supplied by
each society keeps on varying
from time to time. Commission not
paid . Consolidated inf on amount
paid NA. No fringe benefits/
facilities are provided to the
societies by BHEL except office
premises.
Compiled list not available.
Refused under sec 7(9)

Quaterwise expenditure details not


maintained.
Compiled list not available.
Refused under sec 7(9)
The demand is contrary to the
proviison under sectuion 7(9) of
the Act and not given
permission.The committee
constituted for the purpose is
furnished & no amount was
entruested to individual GMS.the
expenditure incurredvis a visd
budget sanctioned is being
compiled at present and can be
given after it is compiled.
Informaiton on direct diployment of
retired employees furnished
category wise. The procedure of
deployment & selection also given

Informaiton furnished. The wages


are being paid by BHEL in line with
the rates prescribed by the
respective State government. Daily
Rated waorkers are not being
posted outside the unit.

Sports Club is an independent


Institution and it has its own rules
& regualitons hence the desired
information can be obtained from
the concerned authorites only.

Complete details furnished.


However file notings not furnished
but reasons for giving special
increments given.

Reg No

Name of the

Request In Brief

applicant
07-0009

Kailash Mishra

Details of printing policy &


details of books printed in last 3
years.

07-0012

MW Siddiqui

Inspection of reords related to


agreement & inventory of Guest
houses in Delhi.

07-0019

Manmohan Nath Details of bill paymento of


Sharma
particular supply.
Shailendra Tiwari Request for a copy of letter
letter given to individual in 2002

07-0022

07-0023

MW Siddiqui

Rule/ Procedures in respect of


giving acknowledgments for
letter submitted by employees

07-0026

MW Siddiqui

Detailed list and main


objective(s) of M/s. Mckinsey &
Co

07-0028

MW Siddiqui

Detailed list and main


objective(s) of M/s. Hewitt
Associates since 1.4.98

07-0029

MW Siddiqui

Details related of children


studying in BSM schools

07-0032

MW Siddiqui

Details related to Quality control


of supply and services by
various divisions of Town
administration.

07-0035

Vinod Kumar
Mishra

Documents/ copies of Caste


Certificates of some particular
canidates submitted by them
while appointment

07-0036

MW Siddiqui

Factors & Weightage are


considered for promotion of
employees of BHEL Bhopal for
selecting an employee for
promotion

07-0037

Shailendra Tiwari Date of movement of the


application between various
executives and names of the
executives who handed the
same of the application dtd
24/27 April 07 of Sh.S.Tiwari

07-0038

MW Siddiqui

The subject matter/area covered


in Wave 1 & 2 studies.Record of
Quality control done of supply
an services from 1.4.2007 to
30.6.2007

07-0042

Vishnu Ramteke

Details of the Promotion of the


requester

07-0043

MW Siddiqui

Proceedure and documents that


describecompletely the
grievance redressal scheme/
systems for all cat. Of BHEL
Bhopal employees upto the
frade of ED

07-0044

Govind
Kushawaha

Documents/ copies of Caste


Certificates of some particular
canidates submitted by them
while appointment

07-0046

Bina Awasthy

Marking System in promotion marks awarded to the


requistee under the Education
qualification.

07-0047

MW Siddiqui

Total budget of BHEL,Bhopal


for advertisement of its
products & different activities.

07-0057

MW SIDDIQUI

Copy of the notification/circular


that gives eligibility period for
promotion fromone Group/
Cadre to another Group/ Cadre
for the promotions effected.

07-0058

Sec if
refused

Reply In brief

7(9)

Details of prninting polcy


given detai;s of bokks
published not available in
compiled form

NA

Records inspected.

NA

Details provided

NA

Copy of letter No
TBPA/PF/11860094 dtd 9.3.02
provided

NA

Required informaiton
provided

NA

Required information
provided

NA

Required information
provided.

NA

Eastimate list of children


studying in JNS,RHS,RKS
&VHS has been provided.

NA

Required information
provided.

8-1(j)

Required informaiton
refused.