You are on page 1of 2

Criteria

Format

Research

Quotations

Clarity and
Effectiveness
of Exposition

Social and
Cultural
Dimensions
of Bodies and
Technology

Level 4
Follows all of
the
formatting
directions in
the
assignment
instructions.
Richly
detailed
description of
where you
did your
research,
who you
interacted
with, and
what you
observed
and/or did.
Quotes are
clearly
attributed to
the author or
informant,
they are
explained,
and their
relevance to
your
discussion is
compelling
and
convincing.
Clearly and
persuasively
written with
excellent
examples,
and wellorganized
transitions.

Level 3
Follows most
of the
formatting
directions

Level 2
Follows some
of the
formatting
directions

Level 1
Few of the
formatting
directions
have been
followed.

Level 0
Unsatisfactor
y

Mostly
detailed
description of
where you
did your
research,
who you
interacted
with, and
what you
observed
and/or did.
Most quotes
are clearly
attributed to
the author or
informant,
they are
explained,
and their
relevance to
your
discussion is
compelling
and
convincing.
Most of the
paper is
clearly and
persuasively
written with
good
examples
and wellorganized
transitions.

Some
detailed
description
of where you
did your
research,
who you
interacted
with, and
what you
observed
and/or did.
Some quotes
are clearly
attributed to
the author or
informant
and an
attempt is
made to
explain them
and their
relevance to
your
discussion.

Few details
of where you
did your
research,
who you
interacted
with, and
what you
observed
and/or did.

Unsatisfactor
y

Few quotes
are
attributed,
explained,
relevant, and
support
points

Unsatisfactor
y

Some of the
paper is
clearly and
persuasively
written with
some good
examples
and wellorganized
transitions.

Unsatisfactor
y

Excellent
discussion of
the social
relationships
and cultural
beliefs
associated
with
technology
and the body.

Good
discussion of
the social
relationships
and cultural
beliefs
associated
with
technology
and the body.

Some
discussion of
the social
relationships
or cultural
beliefs
associated
with
technology
and the body.

Paper is
difficult to
read and the
argument is
difficult to
make out.
Paper has
few if any
good or
relevant
examples.
Little or no
discussion of
the social
relationships
and/ or
cultural
beliefs
associated
with
technology
and the body.

Unsatisfactor
y

Comprehensi
on of
phenomenolo
gy, discourse,
and politicaleconomy

Course
Readings

Analysis of
Data

Significance
of the
Technobody

Phenomenolo
gy,
discourse,
and politicaleconomy are
explained
and applied
in a way that
demonstrate
s excellent
comprehensi
on.
Excellent use
of more than
three
separate
course
readings to
support
discussion
and analysis.

Phenomenolo
gy,
discourse,
and politicaleconomy are
explained
and applied
in a way that
demonstrate
s good
comprehensi
on.
Good use of
at least three
separate
course
readings to
support
discussion
and analysis.

Excellent use
of research
data to
identify and
explain the
relationship
between the
body and
technology.
Excellent
discussion of
the social
and cultural
significance
of the
technobody
that
addresses all
of the
questions in
the
instructions.

Good use of
research
data to
identify and
explain the
relationship
between the
body and
technology.
Very good
discussion of
the social
and cultural
significance
of the
technobody
that
addresses
most of the
questions in
the
instructions.

Concepts
from are
either
explained or
applied in
ways that
demonstrate
some
comprehensi
on.

Concepts
from are
either
explained or
applied in
ways that
demonstrate
little or no
comprehensi
on.

Unsatisfactor
y

Less than
three
separate
course
readings,
and/or some
effective use
of readings
to support
discussion
and analysis
is.
Good use of
research
data to
identify or
explain the
relationship
between the
body and
technology.
Mostly good
discussion of
the social
and cultural
significance
of the
technobody
that
addresses
some of the
questions in
the
instructions.

Less than
three
separate
course
readings,
and/or
attempts to
use readings
to support
discussion
and analysis
is.
Attempts to
use research
data to
identify or
explain a
bodymachine
relationship.

Unsatisfactor
y

An attempt is
made to
discuss the
social and
cultural
significance
of the
technobody.
Attempts to
address
some of the
questions in
the
instructions.

Unsatisfactor
y

Unsatisfactor
y

You might also like