I ~

LieU.., /'

~

flQl::l¥l'1f~fhtm'

I

'~"'1'~~ 19 - 21 a~""fl~ 2526

~L'ij~"'l,;r,:'l"''lJIiI1:u. Openjrase fJflL~lJu.mfl1lJ1GiitfLIfLJ1~"t1I1~ Creative Commons Attribution nonconmercral-stare Ahke ~3.0 Unported License l1lUi!ll.!l"ifllllLi'ill.ill1nliul1.n1i"nil::u'IULLW"iGlDllit.1i1f..1~il ... Jih"ii...JLL\liI..J'ihn ,x'JJ1111i111i'n1D f1l"~1 lLiI::rrtl-J1,raf\lfIJlill_.l.f\llij,ltliitilL~U1ftUUWj}Lr.lUILW .. ,:nu.w~QmJ~-J d\J.U.GI':l:w.:ljLlhJ~m,j~1.I.

J' liVll'l 1

I

-2-

• ~. f .J .,J

t'h)"IWflUl"lnfl'VI,) ",Uqjqp rJ'),) l.J~flu~;:~'.ll··Hl"ll'lu\f,)ufl'" L ~tJ1n'U mn \I~t t11V11f') 1 f1~ U

lUn

, v VI-' t I ,J 'Gt I-'

1 t'lUWlJ"I in l.Jlh ::a"l ULL ~~\I t'I ')') l.J~flLL ~ ::'11fll.Jt'lfl,)"ll.J H)') Url"l'" 1 fltl"l" L UU1 ::lJ1J L l"m1 ~ L fI

11 lJ

I-' I. I-'..r I K I I-'

LLU1V1") \I L '11"1 ~"'U(1Jm nUflUi \l1fllJfI"I U'11U flm') 1m.! L ~m ::~\I \I') uFlmn UL fl::J LLl.Jl::fl·"I~UfI

..,. " ~. .

i');m ';u 1 t.fl u;') urn nnfl\l LL~Vl~")l nu L ;ffl~"I a~ 1::1 u~') Lfl"n~;,)u-V::;fl\l L iu') 1 U\lfl~

1~:flu l1J~\I L 1fl\l'11fl\l fl!)~,) ULL~ enr einum 1'~~'D"11'l.J vlt'lflfllU L fl jH~n lll~ ::tl\lfll.J ~;~

1-'" Y II.J . I-'

,::1f)L~u1ulJVlrlfl "1111 tL~f)-11VH~')lljO\!~il.,']ft;1Jnl.JU1Jl~int~ 1 LL~')i1ih::L~U

, , ~. c~"

I-' I-' '" '.J.J • I-'

u~~,,) rrn '3'11')") \I~~lJil.l11flU LL~:: 1l.J l '.ll L jfl\l'Vll::W\l1.l~flU1 t-H ilU11 ::flJ~fl'.llfllJ'11fl\l a"l 'lJ"I ~'.ll,)

~tt)f1,)"Il.J L ~U,)'.ll"'l ill;' U~n..J;i u1 fl1flUL ~fn :: ' .

~ ,

b 1l11U1fll1 Ufl1 :lJ')lJfl"t H'l) \ltT\I rtlJ--flI 1 L nfl\l

'.J ' .' I-' '.J • I

. 111:: L t)t.lff·)~OlflUtI)1"'1 -V::l.J'f}\I ~t fl L '11"'11,r "''D"1TlJUOlnUflU''l 1 1 L nUVlU"I UU~"J,)

~ 11 ~ 11~

,J ~ I-' I-' . I-' '

1 UU11UU 1 til,fl«rlti'VI')", ~~"'IJ),) 111H 1fl\! 11 L f1WiJU'l 1fl~U'l 11.JL 1Ju-5w.l"l fl i1fl"l1Ufll.Jfm·

, .".' U .,

I-' ..r 4 • ~'J 1-'. '.:§... I:f ') ......... .. ....., ..

rm '111"1'''' 'lJl'f)\I rt,)') l.J,') L lJUVl '::rlfl\lVl')fl"'l1 nflH"I 1 j 'D"11l.J~Q!Vl..:! 'L UL "11 U~fl,) afl1 LL~::1 .. If'l1,~'' J

l.b:flfllJOU '.frI'} ttl~~jUutl~~Vl,,) \I rn n Ufl\!i1;')ui"l~ill~flfl"l 1~t1~,)LLt'l ::'lJUi Urt1,) lJ~f1fl,),) l.J ~ ;",1,

~ . ~ ,

. • I-' J I-'

'lJfl\lLL1M~:;'lr)'m'1 Urt L nJ.Jfl"l r~flH,,) ~f1flUL 1fl..:! rj'D"UU~'l!L rtuUtJl.JL uum1fll1fl ULLU1LL~::

..r ... ~-=I.., .... ~.f .......-=1 5 .... '""... ..

L Ufl~"l 'lIt:l~ m 1 ') L rJ 1"1 ~~rtrJ1,)lJrl1lJ'Vlfl!)'lAlJ,) unu L uUYfW ~"'I U • 'lA~flLL~ :;')'fjfl') 1l"lflH"'I L '.ll\l Uflfl,) all1

II '.f ' '" ' J' r I J t

L'll'U')"'IU i1hn:: 1l.J l'l\ L 1 fl\l tifJLll.l~flfl:: 1 n1fl L f)tJ L ~;'n ::mJ"I 'I U\I L lJflrJ1U\l ~\I ')'1 rJ1"'1lJ~f)

rJ,),U L ;')11 L ~u')nlJ f l 'D"11 l.J~Q! L ~U~~flfll 1&UUU"'Il"'I fl1 eueu r 51inl.J~Q! L arUU~'lJfl\l fl ::-ru~n

1 I-' '.J.' t • , _.

~-l1 fIliilU'lm ~",.rt1~rrviU:f) U1fl'l flJ'Vl"'l'lfl"l UUlJ-)<;JJU"Jl1lJLLfl ::l.1i11 UUflU"l \ll7u~\I 1.ufiml"lfl"'l HIl

:l.lflfl. fl"'I111Bllii","I ULLfi::~"'I1~flH"l ~fJ;Ul ~uJnlJrl'D"Ul.J~Q! ~fi"llJ"'l H)f1°,) L uu1tJ1';;1u~

'1 .' . ".1 t 1-" t I:f .J I-' " . '

rnu l1Jn1fllJ'11fl.J~J·) lJ L iJUfl!) L nu L fltlfVM~flU'11"1 'l LLU-r~ LLrlrJ 1UL lJflVlfl", ltJ:nq;nlJ~mIVlfl') 'i

J .' .' .' . 1-'.... " V . '

L t1ftUULl11~'l u U'J'Vl"l'" LLfi ::'lJfllJ'lJ"'I u~'),) lJaUl1tJfllJ 1 fl1 uusnr ::vIlJ l11f1"Ju L iJu~Ul.J~' "if'lU

• t.. .,, . • .' I-'

L urn ::t:lU"'I-lU-lUlIV'{", LLrt'l!,)~ f)1)Ua'lrJ1"1l.J L ~flrJr~~afl~ L nm' ::Ut:llJf j'jj11lJ~t:y L a1ilul.J9\i'!\I "

t)flrJflmfJ'nfllCJn~:1Tht'f~~;' . t~~flrJ')'lJ~f)LLt'i::~YllJ L ~1)1 uti 1 ::"11"'1 i111 f1UU~ ~atn UU l

21 ,

",," v".- I 1." .i

llU1H ~n}mrUflt'iflWf'l-31 11 ,ll ~ ~U.;.J L tJfI'VflI n'h ~i1~rl y:ffi UllW ltlurll ~Oltltl\l ~\I p/j"llJOU\l

v ' I.' I' !

rlfl\l1.l,. ~a1Jl)lJ ~OfJrl'Yl Of)! j L tJ:ribl!ltllll r:wJI \l f'll uvn ~ rn'1 lJflfllL t'l ~f)1 j L ~'El\l 'lJ'El-3, "Yl:: -)'UrlO"

.... .... .! ... .r .,.J 'A<!I v I.' "" V ,

flU" Yl ~J'U'D'tlflll Ylt'l'tlfllJ'1 'V'UflT ::Vl-lUfl'U tJflVlm :lJl.J'1 flfYil PlJ"l lJ'lJflLL U-lll)'1 \l f'l ":l"l l.Jflflfl"'l'Urn -3 ,

I.' I.' V '.-

uum ul 'Uif-l PllJrl ::-)'UYl'fll fl-J j eunn !~I1ijjlJ'UbUlh ~'ll"l :nul Ylt]flfl,1 1 f)!UflI nls ~Lij'U~ L fln ::'"

"', ~ '"

.... I y.r "" V'-I:( 6) I.' • <!I "" '

fl'WflUl-J j surn 'U"iI'Uf!\I UblIltl"l fl":l"llJ'flflVl'U\l ~:lJ1J HllVl..J L 'Urn urn r i lJ'El-J L r!j1Hfl 'V tlfl ::a-3 flU

v ~ ~ ~

.J I.' '.r I.'

j Jl.J~\I L \I eu 1 "iI'([--'m!U?1'J1 l.J L ~'U'bjlfl1.1t 'UflJ'1lJ~"l L ! 'V"iIfl\l j ~lJ'tlu1'UlL\I 'U rnr ~flH"l ~flfl'U

J .. "'l.. -'i '1. fl !J... .."" ~ ~ • ..: ,;~ 1.1' /

L Hl\l "iIfl\l r !l'IiUlJ~QJ'V\l

\J;JJi!1 L 1J'U'L U llH Oil \I r jr!'1 arl j 'lI'Ul U'!,hllflq)'U'UO L ~'U'tl J..l'VI flLL'U1fl":l'UJ

') K ') q ~.- (1)

~lH 'VW'U jl 'U L 'U L 'll\llh ::'JYlr!"I ~rlnLfl ~fl!)ltllJ"I u

.- , I.' V I "'.1 I

1 'Ulh ::~'1JflI rrJVl'1 \I fJ'IijjlJ~qj"1lfl\ll Vltl m L "11"11 'V llJufl~~LL U') 1 'UlJVl L flJ 'V::

'iltJI tl"ilIllJ~! tlf'lJ"IlJa'U1 'VVl"rih~ mr ll'[Jfl1 J1''U L ':n-3 ijfi') t:lf1;:fuL VI~'[JU1)U VII f1Ll~;,,)tf~"l L V1~

.1 ' h' I.' '.!:I.,-

11llflflfl"'l-l QU UruWll'1"l \l r'ii 'IiHlJuru'llfl\ll VlU llJ '11 L nfl'V"l Of1lTVl"l,l'1,) Ul'1,) \l f'l')') lJ~fJVlH)fl'fllJf'l,) rru

.. - :.." '" ~ '" ,

I ., . " ' ,., .. ,., <!I ''''' ...... '''' •

, LbYl L UUL wn ::,L 'L-'~ 'VI Dfl')"1 lJfllJ L ~~1'llfl\l s ::U1JT j'Iir j~~~.L ~\! m 'V::~:D l m rn jtl[],,)fllJ~U,) U'U

.. 247:5 ' LifU'VflLf~;u'Vu~-liJrJU (lJOj"lrtlJ 2525) dj"lj::tI::L")fl! 50 ~Lr!H tlr:LVlfi-

, ,;.,., , ,

1.'", • .

lVlu~!:l'Ii'H~~Q11'1lnlJ~-:J 13~UU V)'JUt1'U dlrJOUD 1l5-1vi fJtlr::~"lj 14flf-l1ull'U'J'U

t j

.r ., .,.,,.,.... .... . 11 11 ~.... "'l "" .... • I""~ ....

'U L u'UtJfl~lJf'l'H j JUI flll ~:: r j 'IiU lJ~q] 8 fl 1 \I l'1 \I u llJ'U1J r ')lJ~\I fl rOlr.j 1J') f'l , "iJ~pflrl1 LIl\! "

J .... "" 1 ""'1:( . .- .

llfl:: L tl~tl'Uj ~'IinlJ'UruIlflflm \I 'UIlU 3fl1 ('V'I1 ZU"IlJ 1 'UtlfljOln~'jJ') ffi LlJHI U'U 2476

_. !J ~I

I

~lllJ'V'Ifl u, ~1Ji'l~~flj"llJ Wt'lM~fl')tJ'U 2494 LLfl::'V'i)lJWfl'V'l'U'[JlJ ~~'lI'Vj 'V'It'lfi~fl,)U'U 2514)

~ ,

') '" "".... .;.., ... '. "'l ')..r I.' .... J..... 1.1

t ~'l1'J\l j ::U ~ L rJUJflWJ1 jm flUIHIU")U~\I 43 ~fj l U'VIU,,)'U'U m ~ 'n Orl,)~f'lrt~VltJftfrl ueuu

nUL;"IlJ')LiJU~')ltl~rtru:r!llJlrlLL;,) L~trmHfIl'U~\I 10 flU 'VIO 16 nu LL~Lrlm1'Uj::uz L"lfl1ifltu::!jU"l f'llfl'V'lfl L tIl'Ufil j 'lrhlLli~\ll num Ku~m uufj1ij il.:l~ll!1!\! '1 ll;') j ")lJnu

'... ~... "" .... .1 ~.. C) 1.'1.'. .1 ...' v

1l.J~\I 8 U VljflflOUtlWW\I L1J'UflOl~j "iUI~'1lflrnUtYltJ'UlthuVIl,n j~-lO')"l rtlUfI:: 80 '1lfl-a

~, ~

• I:f (2" "' . ~ . .1 ...

'1I")\lj ::.\]:: L ")ml'1VllJfl' f'l,,)"Il..4luU?UVlI-l m n lJIl\lLLfi ~fl'H L UflU'ULLlJtN r j1i11lJlJtl!

f '.r ..... ~ v "" ."'f. "''1 n "" .... J J'

lJflU, , ~ ,L'll'UU L l'1"l fllJ L uum 'V'I~ ::Vltl 'U

) \I uqjVl"ll'1"1 \! j j'fi1 1lJ~QJ L 1 'Utlnf'lflYtu::l-
U\I'D\I~n \l titlfl.

1. 1 "" ... • 1 ~ 1'1 .... 1 "'" .., .J." .. ')

lJ'V"l nn jOl'Btl\! r ::U'EllJ j !i'IijjlJ~qjiJj ::'1I"l1lU L rlU'llIl\! V'l ::"lUI'lf)Ofl"l 1f'tf)~fl~::VI'1n nm 1 UtnJHH·U

e'

-

Vll1vDvn -.1 r j jJ~ n.J\tQ!~u nifl ~V1trom 1~0°,)V1Uflfum ftflU '1 m lJ L WlU') 1~ 1.fl~ah"11lJ ~f}"ilfl..;1 ,,~1 nu L UW'l ~vn 0 LiJiltJt'liltH nfl.YI flW~-.1 U~fl~UVl'l-.1«-.1F1lJ-m ~ d~ll-.1LL~:L nJut'l

.!j "",..._", .JJ y .. ' ... _;'"

\)fltJ!llJfl'.111.l-.1rNrlf1Hl'l -.3 '1 Vl t flU1'1l!}-.3 lJ!}-.31 ULL'I1'.11!}-.3fl~ :1J1Ufl'l1Vl"'l '11m nlJ!}~LLftl

f{ " X !"t 1 ~ r h 4... ~ ~....., J

tJ1'l 0L)fl'l ,.tUL ~Ul,l'L uu tJ Ll.J L tM'l :Ufl Ufl~tU~ j1l:nl.J~Q!LL1JlJ'n ~fltJ,.:; L Vftu'1J'f)~'f)-3ml1ItNl'I

""I " "".. ... 4 ( 5 J . ··11· • 4 .q ... .

t'hafl"'l'Yl"U~.'flLI11" L~U~'I1a !}1JlJ"'lU\)'I1 LVl"'lUU WlfttllJ\)-3fl1tu1r1t11lJ~Q!U1JlJ .

.... ;, .. ':'" " " , ,,, ."" .'

ft1 uttri~nf)];n~'I1l-lft,) umu ~flLLI'11'l ''I:: L '11'11 ~rl11lJV1lJ'l U'lJ!}~ f.r-In 1lJ1flj.f. ~-3LL"Un1.H MU13'1"

'y . .. ,.

~"., m 3M a::VI fl1.JlJrum VI'l-l ~'ln 0 .... 11 um:unu

. u ~

,. 1 'Ufl~il1rfjjUlJ\tQ!'lln'l11 VlU

y • • t

'1Ifl~n13:n'l1U"'l flUL ~. ~'f)

. .

~ I I • 4 il

"JJFi,)flft'lII'l llJ"l rlJ2 da'£l'U~3"'l flL)'VU{1 U1 jj]UlJ~~ utJ,. :.L Vl1'i

~ VlU; ~~"'l.~1 utJ~.:: L,_,Vlf'itWfl,) ,. L l1ftij'UlLtJtN 1jjJ11l!~9PJf)U'um

.• f),DL fl~J~u'U~u1l{1 'l in 'I1F1f'l1n1lJ~r,tulJlJLlI'l ~1.I,m MOll'lnU

VI'l Ul V1UflIUV1,. nllJ'tlu') -31,. ••• t: ( 6 ) ) ,

y' J t J .f, • . • ..,

L '11') '1 ~1,) tJ1 :: L ~UVlU,) ,,0,11-3 ~'11 nul 'UL r 'fl-lunFl-3 ':;~ll'U.llJ'VItI,) 0'VItl,)UWfltllJ"11 L i1J~-lUfl\i

'. ,

• V.!j " ~ ..r y. .q .J I.... 4 ... .:' II

1"1 m l::\)'f)~ mmlJV1ftfl L mNI'1U~ L flU")VlI') 1 S 'lf11lJ\fQjW11 U\)'I1 L flf)1tJ 1fll1JVlOL)w.nt. .. .,

-6-

tl W. fl. 2415 'nVlJ L tlUlP)tr1 L ifU1~1~tla1~'l! 'f)~1~';mH tlutJflL ;dlp)~11lJ~f'lLL~~t-laO

tJ" -...1 ,., ~ ... t .... 1 ~ "I I" 1.1

L1lJflllJ1Zfl'fl-l~ fl111f11lJ~qjlL~~,,') 'lim tin lot 'VIU" ~HHlJO "'if11lJ~011 O~HI-3~

''; I 4 ... ' ... • ,., .' ',., " " ,.,

1"l'JifrUln 101" flmU'f)~OUflfl'f)fllJ1 m 11::lJ'1l1~ L 1t)1 L 1U11-3"1n f'lfl'flu1 11m -rn LaOU'flU

I '

, I I ..f "... ") ,., ".1 t

lJf)-lfltl~~U, L 110lJ1j'if11lJ\tQjL t-l~OW'lnU11U1tw')om U l1tj~'fl~'VI1,) l:~fl1n

I • ' , '

nU'flu"'I-31,. 1:VtflllnULlf'lU1 L n:1J'VIl1l.~~'1I'fl~rj'ifUlJ~'-3. '1 m~~1~lJl'n-3:

... ....., t 1:1~' ~,., • "!'t ...

otJt-llJ"'IU L 1.I1UlH l'lUlJ,OUL VI') UU~HI VI 1 ern 1:: L m f'l1"l lJLL UU'flU"lJ'fl-lO!} L oamL uUt-lftO

, • . v' II

L 1') l::Uf'l1n flr j"l UL 'lIuL flnU . djUftU11 m l:m ~UlJ,) fli ~"l U"lJ'fl~ 1" :1Jt:}1J1j1J11lJUQj

" ~

,. . .

L a~\lUlJLLlJlJfl::-rUflO ~'fl O!)L OMtJnULLu-ifflLLa~~lJt')VlitJft'l urn 11iOflfl1U"'l lua::fi"'l ,.

ot ::lIJ·,)'ll'fl~1S1J') ft LflUL mn ::'fl~ -lrl~L UL ff.l~~aonr 1LlUfltl1U"l lLLfl::m nl1 ;nua~i

... 1:1 ~ " " t .f " ... ., ""

L atfl')YU '»J"A-l ~1"l lJL uU'flfl1 ::'1I'fl-lm ~~fl1JHlJ L'lIUU L 1"'1 OlJ11 'ifnlJ~QJ L WU-llJ"'l-l.

uJlJL ;"mnnu (uJlJ W~fI. 2489,2492 LLft::2511 )Lu;'f)if~~n;'fl-ltlo LaO;''' tJ1 u

11

!" ... );1" v.... t...'.... ..f...." ... .., "" "I I '.II'l1::U:: L 1ft1 'fl'U~U nLLlJ 1::lJ~1m lJl'1'fl t utlt,) 11 venm n ~m UlJ-l L flfltJtnt -3 1-3 \U 'fl LlJ

. . . .

L fJU-31 fl lL~~un1~"l~ruL ~"'I nlJU1:: LfJuri"lm lJd~, un"! :: L Vlf'll fll~L ~u1u L '.IIulYu

~ ,

1:1 .... "".Of I ....... ..., .J .J . ,.... .! ~ ,., ....

U'flOl'l f)UU U-llJlJqM11"l 1::'fl'iflJ"'I U1 fIi11lJ~LJ!mJlJf.lU '1 l'l01V1UflO!)L Oamftfl~U'.IIflLLU"Oll

• .t' • ',. ' ... .. ~ _. I . .

",ioo"l t L ",m U'flin ~ 1 tV!" 'f)l::lJ'fl~ LL?l L WU-l ~ mn rid j"l UVfllJfI1 ~IDw~~·.

v, ..tv. ... • •

(m U'fllJ1lJ1"l L uuf j1JUlJuruJ l'lfl'flUrlrurn VI'-.3 ~'lI"l 01 7LLfl:: L wr"l ::1)::UlJl\l1lJrl1tt'rl fi"l~rll

.~ t 1 1:1 1I~ , . v ..I

m 11'101ll L l'l1 l1ioo! ::uUt-lr~ ua::tl,. :n"I1~fIVI1U 0, r t tlftUtJ.lLUft~1j1J1111\tQfU'flflYln

,., ", t v

l::~'f) L ~u1.I"'ilVl-rf'l1'l1') lJ~lJ ~ V!~1'l1'fl"! euu f'ij 1m11lJUQJ t l'IUUft1 in l::L ~f'l1"llJw.n uluL~~

".... ... 11"

, "1:1')'" "" I 1

flW"l U111"l 0!)01 1QM\I L Ul'l"l ~ fI"'I UODVllJ, ULLft::01 1 L lJfN flU')" ,..,

• .1 ... ' .... I '. f "' J'.J v "'.'1. ~ .,

L W'lllJ"'UlJtlo·r1.~'flm \lu 1:: L flU

l,L Otl1'll'fl\l OlJlJ'l!VI') 01 ,.. nOlil t ::lJlJ r j 1f11lJ~QJ

... I .t' .... 1..1 'h ,. ... ...

1 VIti fl"Otn 1m U~1 1110P) L VI"lVlUr"onfl~ U"lJ'f)1J'lrl U'1J'f)\I II O!lWJ"l Un 1 j1fUlJ'UQ!UllJ

• • 1:1",,.,. , ".

mit '1 L \It'} 'UU u-lil1 f'll'l"l d 11l~"lJVlf)!)~lJ"l U Of rnr ::VI·"ILL~::wq~OulJm \I '1 ~"'fl~

, • '~.t'. v' ... , . ., .

UflO'YJ'fllJ'.II"lUL '.IIlJ-Yl,'U i lIuflu1') fl,111B1iif!iU1 ::"'01 fl!}flUm 1~0 ~·'f.ft\l~'n3inUa::~

tlBifl ~1 ::lJ~~m t·~f1'ifnlJ "1ft"! L ~~U L nulJnfl!}fY1 t~i1u"'fl1 ::vl1Jn~ ~fl')~~d\l'

-1-

I. .., ",,1 J.... At

n'D j :: 11 11 Ll ~l ::: f) j :: 1J ':rw m j VI"l \l r j 'fir 1j.J ~QJ ..r D"ln 1}:..:..'Bl;..;;:t1~'U~Lll.::.:.'Bl.;.;..\l..:..:j:;_."i....:" '1i:..:j...:.r.:..:lJ~'W.:.ii.(lJ..:..:L 1J=-'W;.::fJ;:_;rl_VI;....;..;..;fI"""fl'-o:.,)"l...;..lJ;;..;".

;' ',. f

rTvt ')Ui,lllr}J5' ')'W~1"l \l flI j l ~1:N ~~flf)l j f'j')"llJ L ~'Wfl[] l ~l1L flt1fVlfl'Wb ~'WVif1"l f)v,-)\l VI f1.DJ.1i)

r~ 'Iij nJUi.]j~\lflfll tI L ~1).UCIV1"'l ~~11iU;t)'u~'W ue ::'rrmL'l"l1 f)Vlif'l'J"llJHHl j \lG\l ~'Wm lJrl'I~1J

.. ~ "', ,OJ ,'" , I

'i. f)tIL ~lN"l :::'[)t1~ \l U\l m t1V1~\l !yU j :::'!t1l n ~'D'U'i~f.J ~f)I uu '\I~. rio 2490 U\l fl'J"llJVI-)'W 1 VI')

I , • 1 '

a'Wflrl'D'WLLf)'VlGflf)J r r ii'.On lJ'Wt1J ua:::1 'Wt~~f)llflflt,"l 'WflIW"lJ1)\l IIflnl~lJ"l un 1"''IiHlJ'WCJH'D-l'

";!II"" . .I !II" ,

!II ' t y

~n \l m 'Wllflrt\l ~fjJ"l m j i1nfl')'Wa :::Vl1)'W~m wu r j in rn t1iVl"l-l fl,)"llJflf)l 'U~i''W'D\l L ~tl')n,. fl'O'llJ

L ~'D~'W 1 'W'L'lf:flPl J"llJ L ~'Wfl[]VllJ"l t1tl-l ~fl'lltl..J r ~ 'IinlJ'WOJ~._J L nuu tlYN 'O'Dfl'DJ"l-l L ~'W~flfn t1V1t-l

!II' .I. !II"

'" _"'" ... .r ~ "" ... ~ .... 1. y

m rllfl'lrllJtI'W"'JtJ'W 2475 in ru unui rlJfl(l"l u L U'WUruVl"'l 'D'WL MilllJllf'l~N fl\l'Vl"'lU'f)\l'fJ'El

~ , ...

... ""'''''' ,~ , J ... .r.

« L flflVl fl'Wfl'Wnfl"l fln1'Vl"l 'WVI'W\l f)\l'W:

J .,. ':1 Q I~ K . . ,J ... x ~

Ll..l'ElV'H fl~"l ~VI !Jtl'lWll~"l'UL ntnnuns einum ~Vl"l"b'I'lfll.H'l"l r Ll..l'El'l

'.f!.l IJ.oj.' ... ~4'l1 J

L CJi'Utma'1 ~"Vl L rurm "fI[jVll..l"l un t ~ 'DUlJ~Qj'Nl..l L '1l'f)~ 11'f)'U L au 'U'Elfrn 1) l:; dJu

J : Y,J ..... Y K

L flHl'll LLflfI.JlJVllJl VlWU"l Vl'1l'El\l ~ euuuaen j eu »um ~ u tN al..l'r'lU'fifl"lWVl"l" 'El')U'1 l fl'1Ul Vlfl'U::U

. I~ f ~I "

~ urn WVlI \In!)Vll..l1 unm '1f"lflfl'1llJ L uun!)Vll..l,) Ufl'l flflLlfl:: L nUlLl..llJVlVi~ 'EllJf:)L nflU Vi" n!)Vll..l'l U

, ~ , ,

iu, ~'EllJ1~m lL nUVl~f1n"l j~:U~'1Il..lfll..llJ ~~LL ~u'Elul U~'1 L 'eN VII fH nUVl~f)f)"l1~O\lfl~ ,

~ ~

4 'I .,.fl '.r. 1)11

nUL \I au 1 '1I'11'El" f"l'1"1l..l L nu l1 \I ~ nLL\I 'lJ'El" al..l~u'Dm WVlI \I 'El",)Ull Vlna"l J L 'llu'U~1l..ll 'll,)ll::

• ') Y.... .,. ~ ~ '" • .... ~ • ~ ... J' ""1 !.I

VI') LVIi j 'finl..lhlCJJ L nfll..lflJ"Il..lVll..l"l 'UVl~ 'Eltlll,nflfl')'U.i L U'U~'El-:lLL "VI j'Eltl'El\l 'UU?JUl..l'l VI,)l..l fl

q "', f'

f"l111.n1.Jl..lfl~JI L ~"l1m:n suunsm 'Ufl"lYlVl,) \I n!)Vll..l1 U'1I'U\I r j'.J]J)' l..l~QJ'Eltlf) ~ n1.l1,) n!)f),)11U

VI') ~ll~\l)l1; 1 V>jii,:::l U~~flll;'1f)DVljJ"lufi'1Jf)') n ~'El-l~,) \I L nUL VIm nUCJa~'Unu Lla:: LiJu

, ,~-

'El\l;1.I,. ::n'Elll'ElU~ unr ::U1Uf)') ,. if -.1?ll.lllt1 :;1'fll'U':.iU l..l L ~U'1n-'U 1A~flfl 1') l..l L i1'Wfl~VIl..l,) ut1,,-afl

11 !II t

'1I'El-l rj'finfJ~Q11 flilll;:yr -.1 L i1'UVI~flfl"l rjn \I n~PiI tlfl;~ L d') L tUUi'n'UlJil'l flfl ~1'Uflfl '

J "41 I...... .ojJ ...... J' ~!.I ... ""

'11-3 nlJ L 'llVlanVlqH!)VI~lJfI'1Iw.n.a'ElU "1 VI') n L UUW'itl ::Vl'ElUl"I nrn "flnti\lU'Ell..ldlJflfln"l~ti

') f' ~ I •

fUB U,. euuue :;n j ~lJ1'Ufl"l ,. al..lWU'fit,n 'I f)') d LJ.J'El'l 'ElU') \I ViU\ll flUL UW'l :::

-9-

6') """" ~ ~ -=-J' "" .. ~

u t1 ::: luvn ~ n eunu '(If(J Wll Jf)~'El:WW"l \l if\! fljJ-fI") r L :W'D\l ~ ::Jj~'J unmn Ul~f1'1..r1 nJtJ.lu fl :::'lJ'El

ubMcWi'1l'c1\! II flDt1:l..1'1 tJtI f~jJj rlJ~qj'El~'1 '11 r f1fl'c1f)~ULl'l.r)Vl'l \l~r~jJjjlJ~Qtm ~~~WWU'I

Yl'El1 u

,

I J . I') s> , JI') "'''' I

f1'ElU'ElU ''1I'c1L~W1nrun~~'El;U'ItJ~'1\lflD~lJ'ItJ ~\l'El'~I,~~utJ~~~'\lnu

1 u~''l\l ll~~;f)~'lJ~lJ'I tJ'1l'D\l r jjJ1jlJhl.Lufuflr \l\nu,nutrflHru:::iv'l f1fl 'ElJ, \l L ~u~~,

it ••• L ~unn~lJl'tJ~' ~{lJ~'1 GJj~ i\l~'1;~tJflDL f1~m r~f1~r'El\l

11r:: L VIP! 'fi'uU:jJom~\l1 -; l~1llUr'nf)'Du~ 'Uf~'fjjrlJuQ!1~')'6Jjtl~

J ~v ~ ~ .~.. ti~

VI L~'WmU~f1'Hru~fI1;r ~f'El~::L ~'WL WU\l ~ tflur ::L

V~tr ••• " (10)

"' .,»

-10-

.!4' ~ 010 ... ' ..

~!'el1,)~lJi UfI-l II t tlfl~1 r~~ ")') ~fl!} L f)t1I'Vlfi,)VI'Uflfl-l f'l1.h ::flml 'fl"U') ~

ltft::~lh.lDffi1fl,) 1"l1'fl.,JllHfl')~ty'IlJU~'Aqj '1 VI'Hm rl1flf'lHH LLf)::~fi'flf)') 1~1ltlvh;

.J .... .... .. ...' I:I._; 0 : (1'1')

~ flU1fllJrJ,),)lJifuw'U'D"lI'fl-l am 1J'U L Vim UUfl1Jtl1\lj1 H!}!"

• t'$ "'. ..11 II €)"

in -:I VI') unm 'V L a~lJf)')u~m 'Ufn'l~yh fiHVlI \lfl[j~lJi Uft-lVlflft') ') ue 11 fliJ L l'

~ Jq.... .(~ "''''' -. " ..

VllJ"l UrJ1"llJfI\l "L 'flflfj, 1V1lJf'l 1IlJfiflf)'~Vl'llYH f'lHVll-.3 flD~lJ"l U fl,VI'Uflfl! 'DlJ LL t~'1 'fl\l nm j

1.1 ' .. .... d'. .., L I"'..... ".J ... q t t"} "

flf'l 1 'fl\l U VI \I 1 j ue ::VI~flf)') 1o,f'lq)"lItl\lfl')j uD1J~VI'U"lVltlflf'l Hl·H J lJf'I,)l lJ~'1V1lJ'H.JL VI

!.o!j q "I lI.r 1-,1 (12)

fI') 11U\lUU 1 flUlJfli run 1 "lI L WlJ L r.lJ 1 fl ll91 'llJ t "Jm',ft') U"

'\At 'elm 'VJ,l flU L UWi ::\)'1 '~fl~Vl') -.3 fl!lVllJ,) U ~'fl~,) 11 L ~'UlJ!QQjcWi~\I ~fI~'El\l 0

J I -

1J11~IflDVllJIU L~~\lVlaIU tliY1~U"lItl~flDVllJ,)U~\ltl~lJUj'flJ')'U

.... ..... 'Jq. .... J o!j .... ( 13 ) ~

"lI~\llJVllJQ!i~f)LlV1'lflDVllJ'HjVllJf'l1' l.Jfl"lfl[~fl,),) L W'flU f)'t)flDVllJ1 U j flJU'lJ~bV" 0 ,

'.r ,. t y.. " • v v -. II

l Via') UL lIUf1U ~\I L "lI°')1'V11 f'l\l 'V::lJ\ll Vl1 flf'l,)llJVllJ1Ul 1..1 L :n\l"ll't)\lf'l,)llJ L ~'UflnVllJ'HJLlVl .,

,

. .... II -4 • .!4 .. ,J'1 I:f II (14)

LnUf'l11lJVllJiUflfti~ ., If)UU\l1lJl~lJ't)flfl\lfl11lJ~\lVllJIUVl1't)L~~U,)''lJru'flULf)Vl\laU

fiU!l~ 11 iiumin 1 UM~ ~ ~ ~~ ll~~ Ul1~ :HJiiiWi~m 1ilif~Wl ifUftUI'@llJft111 nUl1:llrl :

• , ~T' yy •

mn \I u\ll ULL ')fl11<Jli f)') 1V! L 1U'Ut 1 f)rlJ,oVliwfl'lltl\lVl~n'.IJ1 13.1 d1ulJLllJlJ'flU"l \l Tj '.IJ11lJ\t~

.... .~ J ... "" 1 It h ' ...r . "" y

'll'fl\lfl ~1UflnuCJ!.m l rnnnus 'i,l'.IJ1!lJ'WllI'll'chi VlUfl'flU 'U~SYH\IVl,)U'fl\l'U In ::lJ1'Uf)') n rU'U1

..I 3J OJ !II !U

• • J::t 'Y , • Y t I

L <JlU1') u llJfl'D--1 a-lifu L ~U1') U'fllJ 'V~~fJ~a ::Vltl'UfltllJ! nn rn fliVl,) ~trruQn f'l1') lJ~f)Ll~::~\I W'i

4 • • J Y .......r I. Y

n,. :;VllJVI,) ~fY'l1 L lJil\ltlU"l \I U U'U'f)'U 'D\I'~ 1 YI'U"lJ11.h : L ~u1 'U\I') 'U~flH,) 'U LLflYl1,) 'V:::I <Jl

L nUlf~d'fl..j'fl~ll,) Uf'l1') 1.!L UU'VT\lr1U'fl~1 1 ra-u d~h..l;'t)~~')w L f'lT1 ::~1 ~ r'fl1'fNr1'U 'll'fl1; W'V,) ,.onVlrlU::~1'fl~1 \lVlli\l~wu,) tlllJ'fl~,) uUQJW"I f'l1"'llJVllJl u~ L n'Unm \I'1ltl\l Tj'.IJ11~\tQj:-

: ; 0' v 1

n f'l1,)lJif1Jau'1l'fl\l f<6'.IJ1JlJ'Urul 'U L ~'t)\l1 ~tH filJ L 'll')1lf'l·11i T "i'finlJuru

001 J1U, .:1 "':U"

~il ih ~<Jl') w1 rJU ~\ltll{fI'f)1,) L1jutlDufn*,~fl,) 1,llnf'l1't)\l1 eueu

... t'$.!4 "'."1':'.1 "" 1'1 ~ 1 q 1

1j'.IJ11lJ\tillflf'l't) UDuf)~tlu1:::~')~Lfltl ~\I lJlJf'l1,)lJVllJ')Ufl::: 1L~U

L W1i ::: L tJ~~fl,)1~t'flalJ~1ru')qjl aVlt1,)<Jlf) L nUT j'.IJJ,1lJ~Q!

-11-

• .• :I-'

" ••• 1"1,,), f j'lJn lJ'UQJ~I'1')1 :JJl~lJ'1 u l ~1.JfH'l'1 1 U~,) L ll'lllJ1 fl L TJ'U l ib\l

1111 U'VY'l..Jlh :'1l'l ;111 l'lu111u l u~ ~f)') 11 nuuut'l,,),)lJl1:JJ''H.J'lJD\J f'1! ~f,~flJ

:I.'~ -=l ", v ~'.JJ v II'

~ l 'lI U U l 'f) \l lJf'l '),)lJ L wt-r:n,} j 'jJ r r,lJ UGJ ~ U Ufl n~lJ'1 U'Vll fI tp filJfl.n l fI om

fl."I r11f1f)nNJll~llilejl"lLlm ;::n~l.;1 ut :n\l'Vlt)Hn~ l nu')') r~1i1 j.lJLLJ

. ':J.::l. , y \, t~) lJ f!J

~D fIJ]v1lJ1 un: flU')W't,1I1' If-hUlv~\l'(;jfl'illl\l r,~ L 1\mUf) L ~Ufn_j v',nn

':I-' . .....'1 ~':I-''' .:..t

'cirU')v'llll~utlflf'ljD\I llJ":n nun1 ~::;~~1tllJlvn~n',nn . L '1lUf-i'fi1 1lJ'ULJ

..;:.._:.;~;..;;;.;;;.-t-tlJ ~- i> ... :U<l

5~flt)H cJ f\J L fi~ ~~fjll LlJr'fll ~tll~tlf)f'l111,n:;uDlJ~,nrrf.i,ul '~r1'H tl\l

... . .,.1,1 .... '" 9

L'1lU 1 S'jJjjlJ~lyJ~U t~. \j.2432 j j'finJ.J~r.M~~ l "lJU 1~. M. 244

fj'lJHlJULUllJtrl 1 f'I ~. fie 2454 ~t'f)r~'1p'1JJ'UlllL ll~l'ql ~U 'V~. fie 2474

If, • 5J" 2:f.:. '" . ~... ." . :u ""f ... I

nrn lJl'llll1 flU'Uf)'~ 1') \l ~j'D ru H) \I 'D,u') ~m 'I "1 'llU L'llU j 1J 1'f)\I 11

'c)')Ul 'i'Di111I'lu l ~U'lJ'fl\ll flj 1, flH iJurJ~; 1 ;'D~1 1 j i)·jUlv '

"''''........,.. '" • lJ ~ .... q

UVllmn1J1'l D,'U')vlJ 1~,) j us ::::n')u')'vl'l~1 m rumr '~fl r e l1JUlJ

'. w w y , tI' •

ntn 1 s tl1 ::fI,)1 ~mn tJ ff~'fir 1:UUrufl',WUf1f1')') lJa:U~'U1r1'::~")') \!

fl','Ul ~ l VI~' i{u ••• ,~ ( 15 )

__...--..

II'

II fl,)1 :U~:Ul U l ~U~1 ,pi 'll.'fN f"l 'fijj :U1..u:lInlJ L 'VI'lU') j:U(U'lJ.'O\! II rn lv'lnn

.. lJ'"

y 'y J Y:I-' I

'fl','U1 'i'lJll\l u1.lflf'l 1fl\l II L ~uifru~l~ l ~Uv::flfl\l u unuu :flTIlJ')'~Jl uVlum ~:wnn 'UflU')\j

:lJ '" • :lJ

Y Y, ...• ' ~ ... , '" ~ . "'..- If., "I 1 :I-'

fI ")1 'I "1 LL fi") m j 1,fln'fl,U') 'V'cYI v L UU L ~ fl'l 'llll'lWt)l'lfl n lJ • 'W'Vl. \lll[]lJY1 LL f)~ L iH.H il n

ll:U~ 'Wfl :lM.,'i~~fI[J~lJ,)'tJfj~'fij rlJ~Q! 1 uvn \If)HOU;,)lJ· LL;'V::~flDl~~' u f! l!1.rjJ~c~~u

.., Y • • Yr.j Y t"l .J II' Y , . Y

L 'll~r \l unm v 1:u 1 fllJlJVliJ~Wi'lJ'flll')'Vlfh~Uflfln L flOfl'lfil r Vll"l ~flllO'UI v'lJ.'U~'~l1flf'l1fl-3

'1 ;t ~un1; 11,- :;~lJfI"I1~'-3f1') n~fl\l!'llfl-J lVlUL 11 L 'U\ll ~~ L1~dI},,~uu'U1\J';fln ~\J~::;

Y . '.. Y":I-" J

mnn u1 fl 'VI fI~ 1 ~1J 1lJ 1') 'll1;m t1'lJfl\lV'lj ::1JI"'1~:U l ~ 'VW r :'V~ 'VlllJ l mn L 'V') fluih L1 fl\l

, ,:J

Y .... ..1 • .

llfl1 sm n11'1f'l ffl\l tl.CJUf1tH:Ufl ~. n. 2430 ")'):-

-12-

" 1 Y4"j

ua ern m f)~:: fllJ II f):O~lJ,,) Uf)°')'Wt.lfl¥IT ~1J:-lJ L fl'l1I.~,,) W"

y'

w,. ~ T,,) 'l1fi') ~1 ') ')")

\

-13-

\

-aUftflHtu:; L ~ut1 m riJflrJ'V1JJ"'IuTJ'JJ1 !JJ;tQ!I, 'Uv11 L 'D-l l-l'El"l vl~~oi L ~'U

. '" J "'... ...... 0 . J:I ~. ~ 1 .oJJ t, '"

~'D~LflUJ~'D-lflUfl"'lrvnfl~'Di'U"'I~L~JJ'DlU ~-l'UIJJ~~~~ Uflrtu~J"'I UUfl~r'D-l'D"'I~

11 '. 11

~]jf'lrl "iL 'D-l~~:;"i·in~fl"'l r1 ;'e:il'UI "i~'U II;'U;W' 1 'U"lli)lJ~iU 1l~~lJf'lJrLlZi:;~L u'U

ufi'linJJ" i~ lJJ~ ~v:; dJ'U 1 u1l.J1; V1t-am ~1:;JJ'D-3n'U1 'Ull~'~"l''''l Lf)~f'lJ"IlJ;~fl1 'U

, 11

J GO"" cJ ~ 0

W'l-lW[}iUI v~fl ~ifl~ L l~U~ L vn"'l :::JJfl"'l1f1t.l.. "fl[lV1lJ"IUfliV1'U~~r:::lJ 1lJ r"'l 'TI"'I 'U.f1"l'W"

11 ,

.,f ...... 1 .,j,J ""...... I .¥ or::" '" J ~ 'J .:4

~'Ut)'Ufj~ tl VI n 'iJrdlJ L 'UUJJ~ L ~UUDUY1JJ"I \ 'TI'U'ULu'Url'U ".P~ L UUI'1'Ut'l;' l j fl~ VI flfl.HU'ilfl\l

... J .fl' 0"'. "'i ~"" '"

flDV1JJ"l U! :l'lir n.J~q.;~ll~~\l L ~f1'U"I j J-Jw.nJE)\lfr'J j viflflfliU"'I "i L flUU'lIl"VN llf:1fl:f.}V1JJ"'I'U

.., '. J .. ~ I' J . <v. ... 11 "'<I '" • "" or::" ...

j j'iJr 1JJ\fqjl~UfJ L "imn jJJtuL ",~flJif)f)'Dlm yj jmZ'l'WUl.Jf\Ufli L UftLW::: L ULUlfl1:ffi.l:; L -u'trl :;

J ') ~ ",r ') :'/ 0 -"l I . ... .:4""

'1J~\l~ :::-1\!f1fl 1l~ L 'U\l"'l 'UnflH"I 'Uv::: l 'TIfli L j un L ~vn:::':n J :::lJ'DlJ r jlli1:!~(J:l) ~ j'UUlJ ,

, ,

(Constitutionalism) 1 f1U~~flfl-a'Un~flf'lJ"'I JJ~f1llZ'l :;f'li th.JJJ~'D~~:::-r'UY1fl r :fffr nJ~lt

1'JJ~ ~ L wu~YiJlJVlflDnJJ"'I u~li~~f'UlJ"l L UUflt1. -3 ~ L ~"1 ~'U tL~U-3 'Lilu~L ;,1 vn'U;~tJ

') "'.1 '~

L alJ~1 'Uf'lJ"llJnJJ"l U~'f.)~lJ~lJ')~~'UI~ flfl"l Jf1fl m j~mtl'U'H:::U1ri,n~fj·i'Ul VU~:::

(20) . I'

mrn j :::VI,)'1Jfl\l f ~ml~ 1 'U1Jr :::-wM, ~~;~"l \l f'l~,)lJ~~ L v~'U') rlJOl'1J'D-3j :::lJ'01J

...

"'C)"'~ ",I t ') "

rl'linlJ'Ur~~:::-)'U~f) a:::Vlfl'Ul nL 'Vn.!l f1fltJI~ L ~ui~ L '1N"'I'UL ~U'U'1Jfl-3JJfl-3 L flat) L TIn

I' ,&< J I' •

l.lr"l"llQJtlf-ltFlfH:fll-l III 'il~ll..r"lJJjruttt1.Jfl[,J~lJ;HJ (De l' . esprit des lor~s)·lfltJ

t .r,' . lVJ '" J '..1 .¥ .. ,

~ ~~t)-:;~h:t+U,11 '1J'tl~niJ'l ilf)'U:.o,!1 Vl<.ll'D~J'lllla'f.)flJllJVllJ"l U'1J'El~ L vrl'U,) %1JtU~-3 JI 'Uf'ill

"J') ;JUf)"l jatnu,'UJ t a1.f1IWVn ~ f)') s L ~'D'l '1 'Wf11IJJ~lJw'U';n1JrfU jlJ~~!"

-14-

~,f1~.J1t1lJ"l tli,fi'UJn~'D11UJ1t1"ld ~~;tl\lvn VII \I fl1lJFllJ'flJm ~ll ~ ::fl,~tifl1t1aflfn 1 uunmin ~!

• ~ v ,

.J oq.... ...... ~.... ,~ ')...,j .... .J ~ .,. •

L Wt1WVlflHrflH'"luVl'fiL a~ n'"lW'1lt1..:! ~f"lfltl ue ~ L 'U'lJru:: L f'Itl1f1'Ul 'Yit1atl"llh..!'h1V1'litl'"l'U'"l ~

... r (21)

1. fltl'lltllJ'li1 rlJ'1l'fl\I.1~1J"l fi

...

• " I

.... 1:4...')( .,f'\ ~ ....... .r ...

.: r =lJ~lJ r )111" rlJ~~L 'll'U1,) 'U J lJ L ~ L WU\I ~::~lJ~'lJ'U3J'"l ~.fI ~'U~U"l 1

m 1 '11 tl\llJ'UHU1.f1tlfhW\I ~"lfl L U'Uwfl'lJtl"ffl"l n 11fiL'UmJ~\! 'rIfIfI ~ ::lJ1'UfI, Hlf)afl't)1tl\lc .

VI; \I fl. H~'f)\l~'H U'UlJ"llf1Ufi"~ Ua'lFllJfl::1'Uflfl .) fI;;awr :;1'l'llfl''"lra~;1 31 ~\l ~):;U I

• • "'.J il I I

t 'ULL\l1t1U\I L UUfI"l TlLflfl'l ~\lFl1"llJ L '11'"1 I, ~Vlrt T \I ~fl'D" \lU\lI. 'Utlfll~::fI 1 ::lJ1'UfI"l1l11~UU

, ,

. ",

LL11fi\I 'Vl'"l \I rn d L ~'f)\ll U ' "111 ~ L Vlfi'iJ 1.11.1 :n-l11f1f"11 'f)\IU'"l 'UL 11'El\l~fI'''l~UfWI1 ::d"l'll'"l'f1'"l'W

I ", .. \ ", ¥') v <'!I I ')

fl"l-l '1 nu fl1U'fl'l~U L 1t1~fli 10m\!1 fl L nfl'lJu L UU"l 'U L l.J'El\l1. flUf11"1lJ 13J'r~t1 L ~'lJ'f)\I d"l Hil1

~ 1 ~.:j'" ......... .... 11 ~. 'I-' • ... ".1 ~.r '1 s> <'!I 11

~" f}lJ'lI'flU\lflUaflflflULuU'TIU '1 ~"llJ~"lfllJL1t1~fI"I1MJ\llJ'lI'ULUlJ"l'UL~'fl\lU'U'1 ••••

f J r ~ ", ')'Y,¥ "'.)1'"

a1'U1f1 '\ 'I au"llJU. , •• L U'UfI"l s UflnUm" 'If)U'lJ''llJ •• , , " L 'Ufl'El'UYlU'lI'i)\llJVlU 1 fl~ lw

L ~'U3Ji LL;1t)\llJVllJ,)VI~~~'lI'f)\I "n!J~lJ"lUIl' fj 'liUlJM'JJl 'U J"IU:: l 1]un"lWfl :;;,[)'U1t11~flfl UU1t1rl~3'fl'flf1~1111 d~'1J'El'laiJ~U'lifl"ll~Vli '1'Eilu"l "it uf l L ~f1U"l nlru~'tl\lfl"l1 ~'''lOflUfj::

, I

Fl1lJf"llJ'fi,u, ~llfi em 1f1 r :;VlO,'1J'f)"] r sm fi L 1IU1:HH1nh"l nn 1 ::lnUfI"l1 L l1~tJULL11fi\l~"

, ~,

",,"'')'" ",. C) 11' '1

" 1"1 H[}H lJ'UtJ'lI'f) L 1t1V1', L 1hltJU~'U'~' l -vli°"lll f).,] 'Uti FI'l"ll.J1t1lJ'lU L.lJ L:~-llJlIIlI:'Ilil.

"'.,1..,31 "3 I I, ~~ ..:

~U"lVl'1J'tl\l r ii'liUl.l'UGJ ~<lU'tIl..lllflflfl') ~ tl'Dfll11~m.h ::alJ fl"l HUVl'H 1 flid 1 lJ'Utll'll '[) <11 VlU

<, ,- , ,J" _' . 11 "

tnt::lJ1'WfI"l1 L t1fitJULLllfi'llll"l -:i,fl1 d L ~,[)\l L uu J 'tl\llJ"I u~~Vliwft'"I'fI;1i..ll iffl\ll1t!

L~ 1'UfltmL~ffL~~U"l~lJ~'lI,[)'lnI1l,n~'f)"'U"l~;"l~:~1l1"1flDnl~'W~::LnUL1'El<l

". ..!I .. t <:l' '.J ",,4" v

'lI'tl~L~fl'U:dl.lru~d'tl~~lJfI"l1ru'1J'tl,,]flJU~~fl~L~Ul..l'lflfl1"1V1~::l..lW'Uj"lU'1J'tl\l~lJWU'lifl"l~VI"l'l

I' v ",

'tl',Ui vmn \I LlVllr"] u afl\l11t1 L ~'U~-.l iiVl~flllll-.l ~1"llJ~~'1J'f).,] 1 ::lJ'tllJ r.l'li11l.l~Ql L flt

• ",,,,~. • ", .J

uUl.l~\l1~L'lJ"llJ"Il..lUVlll"lVl'f)UlJ"lfl~'El~lJ~1jlufI"l1'Diu"luf"l1'lJ~lJ"lUFlJ"llJL'lI"lllLflu1nlJ

31 .

r j'li1 n.rwY'lI'fl-.llVluft"]~fiu::~fli1'flu;)fil'flfl;~fI;"I U~n-lft'li1 :-

.J "3.... "3 1

"v.;: LlJ'tlt~tl\l1J'linlJ~QJ L l"l~lJ~Uf"ll'l,lJtl\l'f):; 3f!"l~~1'llJ

L'lI,) 1 'Y'lI'rl~'lI"l'VH ~ f l'1i""lJ1JQ1~lJ"l tltl\l Ufl \Uflti1 ~ ! flU JfllJfI"l ~ t1flfl1t1'1lJ"l tiL ~~\I- fl'wam;tl1:: L 1JuaQJUJ"l1l1 ::'ll'l f"llJ ~'tl L tlUfI[}1t1lJ"l U

-15-

.... "".r.., :'l x. .,!J ~ ...

I'll JJl1flfl rl1,)lJf'lfJU ~n blru~f11,)lJ L UU II '('jOlon 1 ~'1l') flJJII 10m u'WL OM')

flolV.Ufl~fl1:}ru~F11,)lJL~U "rl1JnJJ~[i;' rlp~~tif)U flfiYH'ntJ 1t,$Q!tn~1J!~'ll,)fllJtl

.,1 ~l"- If' "" tv '" ..,

J.J!,) 0 -;;1 U'DU UU j ~1rJfJ') nrl !VI,) ~ !"I'J') J.JflflLl f, ern Hl'El-aVl,) -im r L J.¥D~ ?J'tNYl ~1'Wrlfl

~ ~ ~

I y' t t •

1 "- <':! ~ ..... 0 0;. '1 ...... <i"" "-

flfl11 fl1,) L lJU'VllJ,) 111UVl'IN 'll'D~~fjflfl'n 'flflfJtl,lli v l 'U1 ~1J'EllJ! ~ 1JU lJ'WLU L ~ r timJ "L lJU

.. !lJ'"

j') 0 ~jl 'U'lI'El\! ifjJlAfU1Jfl~l~VI,) \I 1:],UI v-B'U~Jbn U'UI r ~1Jr r lJ'Urul ;~~m 'Urn I"! L iJuflDVllJ'HJ

~ ~ ~v

60 YV_,j s> rJ 'I'" ') J 1 ~

~\I afltJOJJfll VlW..l'f.l,1.t) vUflf1"D~lJI1HlJtl~ t 'llDO,U') vm tJ l 'U'll'El1J L'llrmOO,VlUI') J l U

~ , ~ ~

, v v

fJ"1JHJJUD:{tUII 1~~flfllllJ~flJ,)fl1U l1f(nmnur ~'llI·fll.J!1 LiJ'UtJf'I~~VI'D'W'lltl\lf)l Hlfl~\I

~~ , ~v

I', •• J Y "V

U'WUtlJ.J j ::l,11 \I ~fll m Uifl..lW'W'1lfl,)WVI' \I tllU, -:"v-tJUi \I L'll'UVlO,Ull\lVl "!I H[!! t iJu~'lJa 1 t'VlO,

Y • '

L v'LLtJ'U~uvo,l VVl01" fI~ ilu rl11 j.j L UU II alJJl.IJI U! ~']j') f'IlJ~'l L iJwrflHru~ L 1:1'J~1 ::~'hVl flJ

V~ ..

I Y d t '"

"" _,j.....1 <!! ~ ~ '"

D'1llJ1 tJrl1,) l..lv.l..l') u"ilD\! "L on a') r L nu 10lJO,) ! un rl!ll ~ in U l l..lD'll1 l 1.1111 \I 0 Hll L VII UU

v , '. , ff' .: • Y

LU'Um.n, lllJflUi In,HlI (Hugno. Co.rta. fl.M., .121?) .. m~[Wi111')1U~VI~

'f..,.,. ,

(Bill of Rights !"I. fie 1869) ~lfl1 'lIll~-B~f)fjH lly-)f1'ElU'lII~)I~ L iJUUQ1Vlltn

.• v Y • '! . .

~\lifUllU m v~li'l..l')I, 'llll]1JItJfl!rollUI ~'lItl\l'l vi'iJ=D\ll ~'Ul rll\lf(JIj.] L ~'iJ~ L ~U"llJj.j')-nO

11

y <!!

tJllflrli.ll..:lf']'tl

1)

II •

,L 'El..:lVllJflPl'l,)lJV.lJ,)U 1 ill U",U~ fl')tiL VlY-)')1 :

,

-16-

, I ,

" •••• 1)" :;fl')fll.lntllru,)'lI'tl\lV'Jfl'll'Ur,)l.Jfl·'U~\I •• .1lJl6J.jillfl~,)"

~ :;,j"", , II,., I

VI"I\I mt l~'U'lVl'll'UU, 'It.~tll" ,)Hm U \I FlU 1 ~w,. t L 1') LlCJUflU L-TIU

«lI '.. ,.,..' ~

~~l.JllU~Ll.Jf~y,)fl,)" rl,)'lI'tI-.lW1::: tvl1fl~U HI'l LuutlBQ!l~"I'lIfl\l

U~flflr'tl\lU,)UL~fl\l 1.I":fI,)~Un'f)Vl')U~rVlt,)~11l.JLa~~lalu

SJ AI AI'!'i ..1 AI

U,U ll.Jfl \lLlfi :lh ::'l1,)'llWtm llJflt'll'q'l fl'lH'i') \I LUUfI') 1 VlYfQ,Ll.JP\I

~11 ::U}1tU1 :;a')VI~VI~ La r.fl,)Wl.1AllflfiQ lij'f)'llflU'El', Lflillf)1u

tltn~La:: LtlUfi •••• " (25) ~ .

<Z::'~'I~ -11 ~I'" ".l I.' AI Vii

L VI'U4flfi,) ")l.J,) VI \I v'l.JflU L l.J 1 f1~i1'J ')lJU1 ::a \I fl-DU lflVlv ::l.J')if.UVI,[)U~" flfil.Ja ') \I

... .J AI <) 'I .,.~ ~.J '

Via flf'lJ"ll.J L 'IlflVlT fl'tlfllJfl,)1 L flU L wvn :; l U1 \lQ,)1 Ul'lfl') am l V1UVI'J') 1fllJ\lVll.J')U'lIfl\l

, \ \

I I _ v

f!i'llHl.JW~ilU L ~flv',nmhu') vua ernr nr ::VI·''lI'tl\lT ju')a ua ::LL tn I. UlJ'lIfl\lWmU,) m r

VI') \I fj 'Ii; ;U~;'lIfl\ll. V1UnnVl"l'l'tl')'H ::;lJ~\lnu 1 fI~ uvhu'tl-.l'll"u. ~\I~l ::WU,)U,):UW lfllr')::;

'of v I I. '¥,,' , I I I 'I

f)IUu\lUfl'Jua"lUVlU\l fIT ::~'Un~ ]Ir:: L~u~~fll uVli.lllJ1 "lI'tlu~1,)'tl::1ri1111:Ufl1Hlu,)-J1r

I .. ~

, y. vI iI I AI

:n \I l' L UU1 ::I'l'tl\l LL U nuu ::1, Vlft'tl \I LL 'VIv') fill \I 'lI'tl" fl1"1l.J L ~'Uvr \I 'VI"I \I rn 1 uin \I 1r \I'f)U m r

~

... .., 'I II ~.~ ~.,f ...." "''':

l.Jfln~l.J"IU~j'Dr1l.J~Q}L~tlr"lfl!)LU'UI'l"lLl'UI'lU'lI'UlJ"I 'Ul:lLUuur,)fI[Jfl,)1tu'tlU"I\lVlU\lVI,)":)

'y iI I-' 1

fI"I1 d~'tl\l ua ~'El,)l~a"luvi,l ~iJ\I Ln~f)'J,)l.JtaflVltfl L'lI')lv11.1~\l1,)fI"Ir~fI!)Vll.nuf!i-

'I!1Tl.JWflUfI"I1 'f,nfl'fl',u') v'llfl 'l1 .... lu".a ~ 'fl LUU L #'f)\lm fl; L~;U 'l\,~t'f) L VI~'fl'U L~U L #f)\I

!l"(26) I' . . ~ iI

L~U"lnU UI'lI 'U'VI,)\llltlifn~ dJuvr -Jll~') flD~l.J"IUf.r!f1rl.JlJQ!'f)"I1 LUU L~U\I

, AI.J I "i • .{ I-' .... ~ ... "' ...

L flntl"lr".,f'fl L fl r fl 'l1J cu nn ft-J D ,Ui v~VI'fj'll,) fl'Vfl \I CJ1Jflrtf 'El \I fl U L UUfI,)f flr \I nU'lI"Il.Jfl1J

~ .

iI I " I '"

flJ'l.Jl,U,nU 1 U L ~ \lv·,nfl'f)·')U') vn1 fl ~\I L 'Il'UflTru~htltJ') \I II r ') \ll'tJ1 :;; T ,<JlflqHDm "l,)fl"lU

1!)'1l1J1 ::lwii1nr \ltiu'):u" Vlt'f)~"I'El"l v dJu LWU\I L~flu'f)nfl~"I')l ;Vl1 "IU ~\I'Ul U1JiUVlt'f)

, ,

f) 1.1 I I ,

L 1flU"I1UU1 l Uf)') 11 '1l't)·'Y1.nv1Jf)~'J 'f) \I'f)U') \I l '1l't.m"')'Utl \l~ai v') r fl'vlm'll'Ur ,)lJrt',LL VI"

. "

I .f I , II

iJ\ljJ')1'U~iJuiJv1uuu ur::L'VIflm\l '1 Ln'fluvhlaflw')n'Uuul.J1V1~

,

o!]Vll.J"Iuf ~'I!1 1l.J'UOJflflfll.J"I t ;flU LL~\ niJ'fluf. r VUVlU:llili~11n UVI·''Ufl\lv·')nfl'fl·,)U''Il'llB\I

...:a 1) .., , ~ v

iI I I

- -.... ~~ ~ ~

1'jll"ltl~,)u '1 flU1 ::uflUrj'fiHl.l\jQl L'Cl'JUUl.J'll'f)\lI'l::')i.ll'lflfl"l'VI L'IlU fl"lrU1J\lLLUfI

'" 1 I I

• "" .,....... ...,... .!j 11 ~......

'fl ,)U"Il'VI'U"I 'VI 1 :'VI"l,) \I r.l') U1J f ~"I r unit.ilnil'lLLfI :;I'la"l rn r rn 1 L fl o Ol'l\l ua ::'C1'V1'fi l a r .fl"lW

OJ OJ ,

, I.t' iI.J . 1-'1 v

'1I'iD\lf')]j!)r L~a"l'UL~UI'lU lflUVlWtlv::L~kl '1 flu1fl"l,) n1flLnflCJaiJ\I~U1r\ll\l'f)::;1fi1f1

-17-

-18-

Vltft)\ L ~Utl1 ~']"l wlVlulJ"lnf)~"l 1'JlJtt\lUr.HV1"l ~"l L Y'Jj,) ~ LVIi'll nm jtlj ~wq~t1B~-lij'l;

, ", ( 8)

~'ltl ...... J .... ..-.,SI. ""..,... .., 2,

L uu f1')lJVltmn"l 11 ~'IijjlJUO!1!-lllf)JruYi 'JlnU'C)\I L fltlJnUnll'll'f)\lYI ~'JU¥ln

.. 11~ ,,~

'f) ~ 1 Hl"')Ufl\lU 40 L UULL'U'JLLZi ~LLllll~;n"l 1 MnH'l~'t)"l v~~ L UUflrutl,. ~ 1 U'l!U'f)~ LL¥l1 'U'llru~

" , 3J

.J SI , ' ..

L ~U'"lOU'IJ'l'H ::nfnu L u'U~UlIr1 f')rlvn \I ~,]"ln.1Vll·i')1. VllJ'f)..:!YW"l fl,V"l flZ'l') 1 ~i(,)fl()n ur WrU"l1lJtu

OJ

.... J J' 1't1 .,

"lI'f),nj'IijjlJ~QJ'f)'U ~ Vl¥l"l\lDtln V"lfILl1J1J"lI'f)'i91:;')U¥lfl

.of.., "' .. I' " !II t... ~,SI'.., t .of

fI HUrl '"l'f)UI\I L 'IXU 1 f'l L flU']fJ L VlU v:; 1 nun j 'iii 'IiUlJ'UQJLL VI \I Z'lVlfl'l 'W 1 '1l L 'JU91

I '... 3J .,

I I IV' IV *

ilU1JfII. PI. 1936 :n-l'f)')v'Y~flLUUf:lfl\lLL\lZ'lD\llJlJVlj\lOU"ll,)lJOU nth,)~fll UflI'UVlU-l LUU

• 1J ,

m nViJ'U. r :;1JlJfl'')1 L ~'c)fI~\ll ;L uutlj :;'l!"l itI1 Vlt)d-l~u (1 flu1 ;VI~f)n') raVl~flfl L au..] L ~Df)

~\I;,) 1 tI fl. r i ~'lJf);r-l1 flU91 H LL~l :;f)') HN neu U'U L ~U\I;'JU~~iVll } LLrh Unf);') UVlrl\l

U-l fl-3Z'l\l ':Jut)') HJf)"lI') fl'IJ·')'U') v"ll'f)\I'W1J flf'l'f)lJihila;1 ;L ~u L f)lJ LL ~U'D'U L clmJ'f) \I V"l f)~') UVl,) ,

3J

']J'f)\l91 : 1UYlfIu;') "1JVlDQ!~ T j'IinlJ~r,M L.1Il;') i1LVl1JV ~ 1lJ1 ;'f1'"l,) lJVllJ,) U'f):; 1 n ZiU 1 UU\I'.

'. SI', 1

'llD\I f)') j v"')Of!'f)·')'U')vT j1ll ZiLL Zi :;n.1 ~lJfl H) \I aVl t L at fl,)YJa')U~flflt'l LLt'l')f) LL 'UUfl1Jflf) L "ll'U

J' ' J IV h"

n1JlII'"l. m n t1ftUULLtI~Ntlj ern Pll 'l! T j'IinlJ~QJ'Uu1Jl UlJ ui1~uirll dJuZ'l')uVlU\I'lll).\lu 1 inn U

91',) \ltI j ~L VlPl~;l)-lf)') "tJoijm'n1Jm~') 'f).,)1J,) vr! :;1U910 L dl)l ;,.\J..lf1\JY1·'f);olla1 inn a-TIfl;

3J '. 3J

.. I •

']J'f)\I fif1 L ft'f)j 0')11J 11 vVl60t)') 1LlUO'f)·')U') vf)~ 0') 1~fl'"lUj ')lJVl,) \JO') 1 L ~'f)~ 'll'f)\llh :;']') 'l!1J

, , ,

".of ~"'.of I ,,~ '.r ',J 1 ' J

nf! 91fl'f)fl~U llHfl')'(jVl'iILfl,.fl')W91"l\l ~ Of! LVlft')U'f)'),vlJ\lL'W'f) 7.MU')'ll'"l'UL'1Il)Vl,)'"f)')"

L~!l\lfJ.~l \I~ L ;')1 vnu LL;~\lf)j :;~'Un'L nUf)'l !u')f)d~~v~~~~f"l~,)lJVllJ,) ~~'~~~~')'~QJ

"" 6') .:I .,' • " Slq

'll'fl\l r j 'IiUlJ~tlJfl~n')w 1 '1! L ')U91 b U j') uearn [U1)') j LlJl)\I L lJ'UU91')') m v 1lJ 1 fllJf"l,),) lJ~lJ,) U

.., "'1.... '11 ... 'J....... ' .~

rt,) lJUU'f)fllJfI'l ~ ue :;flJ"llJ L"lI') vLLU1JVl ::''fU91f) L VI "I u'U fJ\I L ']UVlUfI 1'll') 1)') ,. "w"l U"

,

SI J 11 IV j" ~ IV'

91 ::1Uf'lf)tJVl1J,·~ L flU91\l 'll'f)~ L 091~ V"l HUr'iJ '11j jlJuru~~fn 'W 1 '1! L ')uVl1 ') ')'). :-

3J . .. , • »v

..... 11" ~ SI JJ llV~

" •••• 1J" Hl'l ,. j 'jjjj lJ'UruVl..:! Wi.~') um vlJllVl1Jl VlVlU') Vl'f)U 6VJ nnn

t ., • ! 11" Y

(~'fI 'U'qo1jV"lf1f1')j j') nfl'f)°,) t.n, V~1lI ~) r j'jjjjlJJf~U\I L 'U'UaVlt ,J

f'l'l"llJ L ~'f)fl,)U L 'U'W"I :;rlj')1J L VI"lVlTj'IinlJuruflf)l '] L 'Wl) 1~Htu,)'ll'"l'UL ']l)

1', '31Vll ''''' "t'

U¥l,) 'l~j:: L VlPl1J,. Hl"l L 'f)Ofl"l" T:ffl! !lJW~"lI'q-lfl~fl,)'W 1 '1l,L ,)U~flUfllJ .

VllJf!~ruf'l;,Zi~ 1 Jll;'f;l U::flfl,)UUO,) n lJl)~ Oft!, '"l fll) 1 Uj') U::Vl L n'U ~~1!L'W'f)']JulV11l11fl~\lf'l,),)lJrlO~\lnul'U~lJf"lU~\I~fl"lu(29)

-=~~~~~~,~~~~~~~;~~~~

-19-

-20-

• y ,

adUal~ 11JlLl.!1Vl,) '1ll1J1J L ~1UUlJ 1 Uft :1Uflfl'f.:ll lfl ruu ~ -.3 unun ,)llt~:~

. SI ,

IJ 1" y yl I

11W1U') m H1'D l U'fl\l 'flUWtialJrl1 r LLfl~flHru::'1lti\l rld') lJLLftfl~fl1J!,)fl[} 1 ~ l ~u 1 fltiU"l-.3 L flU

SI

'ifll"! nm r L l.l~uulLlIf,l\l '1l'D-.3 «-.3 f'llJUrlVl~-.3fl1 rllrhl.llLt'l em ~~uvJM~1I1VlUI m ,. rl1,)lJ~fI

, ~SI SI

1 y .. y .. . •

0'" 0 ~ .., ,~q

fi1,) lJWU') U"llJllflfltiIU') 'V"il-.3 a :::l~tiUVl fltilJULLlJflU"l rl,) rm fttiUrlUf'I 1 tirl!1'if} 1 ,. 111V1 13

1 y... '... y... J 5'" "" ') «,« .J

lJ') f)11Jfl,)HanlflJUVlt'lfl~fllJfl,)1 l1tl-.3'CiVl'.DLa1fl')WLUfl1arlrifl1n.HVl 17 Ut'l:: 18

~-3d1l1,)flD L 'Dflltll j rjtnlJ~Q!alfi't~' fll)fllJ,) 1 uilr ::: L Vlrirl ::-)Urlfl i f)U L 1m"! ::'fl~') \lrl\l fl-3flt)H(Petition of Rights 1627, Habeas Corpus Aet 1679 LLt'l:: Bill of . Rights 1(89) 'flLlJ1fl,) :(Deelaration of Independenco 1776, United States

I

LLt'l:: tJ1'lLrifl (Declaration

.r • l...r

m j L llt'lUULLll~-3 L '1IU1"lUl. nU

-21-

0/

4-'0,...0' 0 6; c:~ 'I' .<1 o6J~ Goo' q

~lJ'I'fU'JJ.f1I'!N'IIl,) \!ti'")'U') 'V L 1.rlr'lfllJl>lJ1JJ~';; l i~Qj'.U'C'll WtH,J'l'1i t t1f1fi'VllJ"i UJ"'i'Dr jjJUIfiJJ?1')')d.!

. <..-.... ail !lJ '.;.' SJ

s> I V I

<4 "I "" rJ

lUJ') tJfi r :: Lfl'f..Jf1 L lJlIl,) 'I ni U'iJ'tN {1j~1.fntA;1 ~Li L jtJrllJ1 nn 'J') LU.JJ"l 'V ::1fiJtn tn lJfl'l nluu iJ'lIti\l

, ~

V I . . V .f '. V vv ,

I'l ::-)'Uflfl1 'Jtitn ,j lrof)') lJ l-W'il 'U 11. s», Dicey 1 Yl L flt.n V1'.U'Dif\! L f1l'lllJ1'tJUL ~tl1J

V I I . !I' ,

1 'U L ~\! if\! f)JJ1·~1tn 1 'J'Dtn \! in ~ti1 -vl 'U'l') tt1 L f'l n ::11~'l r ~ 'JJJj lJW~'lItJ\l5\! f1tlH17 :-

,.IV

" •••• ~~lJi~~ffjr rlJQlil\lfil1Hl,d\l1 J~'JtJ~~flUVljjr rlJ 'hm I

zn ~UW'Url 'U~')')llJ r r~''Ji,1~fin'l r,vl,)'llluV!\I rS'JJrrlJ~L]( m~t "ll'U

~4"..,J . ~l :':l.:fl

~'V1 'JJ l 'W L 'eJ J m '!Nfl J'W5fllfll.fI l1 J'fYY1'(i'VI 'JJ l 'Urn r"lllJ'UlJ~'l 'JJ'l HU:: )

v . , , I

IV 00' ..... ~ Il~ .~

rliV1 r lJ L r'llL 'C\ 'J 'UlJ L 1 UUrlti'U t flfllJi l'l n flliW1fiJ1 nmn r Hlfllfl

-22-

• • 'I' It

~~VI~')u:n,m"VI'Ufl~'Vl~~"),u~flflfll 'Ufl~rn'l I>j ~lJ,)~~,)fl uml")'U

tf,~r~r!i'DU.lJ~Qi'lJ~'lV1",') ill! ~ l 'Vlr! d~J~l''U,,)'Ul.J''Ifl VI~fl1J1 ::nu

( L "ll'U'Vl L ~U'f)\l) vn Vl1 ,,)lLfl~'Vl~'lItl'l fl'U'Vl~Vlfl,) U L U'Ut:Jfl ••• Lf1f1lJl 'nflVl~flfl,) 1,n":l111'll'f)~ fJjjJ nl~~" (34)

, ' I •

"i ... .f ~",,'" !:f.""" ~"",'"

L flU'UU'U L lJ'f)'W L fl JI ::VI'n flLl'l 'lI'f)~ flT) lJ'alJ'WUjjJ ::VI,,),) ~ ~'VljjL i'l H11'W'lI'f)-l

,.. " ','I"'" ..,.f"'l ' .... ...

~flflaV1'f)'f)','UI ~'lI'f)'l f j u a ":I fl ~ ::'Vl, LVI L VI'U"llV!'lJ'Ut)'l fl ":I'llJVll.J"I ULLtl ::am urn 'W'f)ULLV1flV1"l 'l fl 'U

I ' 1. J

1 ::~r)"l \lfl£lVllJ,U f ~ jjJJlJ~qjlh :: L .fl'Vl'f)U'l '1 L "ll'U'lI'f)\J -5~ fltjHLLtl ::11 J :: L 1,r!V1 ::-)Ul'lfl'f)'U I>j

J ",.,1 ~.... ",,' '" ..... <!!..,. ...... • 1 "'I' ",J

~\ll.J'VllJ"l~fl~'VljjL~Jfl'lWa":l'U~flflflL1J'UV11fl'VI'UVlVlJ'f)v'flfl'f),'U,vJj flUuJ::lfl'Vl~\ll.J'VllJ"I

.f ' ,.. I J

1"1 fl L lJ 'f)~ uu ~tl'V'l fl"ll'U-tu11flfi 1'[}\I tJfl', VI'Ufl '11 nu '111 ULL fl:: L 'I su 1 'lI~'Vl ~ L a~ 1'1"1 'W'lI'f)'1lJfifltl

~ , 1

1 ')~ uf::ljjn~~Q! fl 'llJVllJ'lUUfl::am 'Ufl'l~~'lI'f)'1fl:f.)Vll.J,urjjjh-l.J'UQJ1 'VlU~fl'f) I

.f v .f 1'.,1 '" "" I '"

'11 'f)'! 11 r :: L fl'ViVl~'1 'U L 'f),~ u fl ::ft1U L VlV1~::'U ~'11.lJ'U"I VI 'V ::1'1'f)\I ~~ 'Un'U'Elfll'l 'f) 111LL~~c..!-')~-:r"

.,1 r: '1 '" • ",,'<!!.I .... •

VI":I'l16jj1Jl.JU['jH'VltJLU'U IIlJ'flLflflll VlJ'f) "lJ'Vla1u"'ll'f)\lfl!]Vll.JIU'f)U I>j nuuu

..I !II IV ,

~~flfl[}LflomVl1'f)t:JtlU'l~lJclLL~'U'f)'Un~ mr L llNu'ULLll"N fjjjnl.J~Qj~'f)u '1 n~

J ",' v v",, .. • '"

'f)'llL uullJ,nn'fl,) 1~1:l11 \I fll":l,)l.J t~flVl'1:)LLVlufm-)\I( Vl1'f)")'l ~l.JVI-)\I) Vl1'f).":I"l'Vl·,l VI~lJ

..' t s> . It",

flDLflom~fl1t'ln'U~i'l ~~1lJ 1 fl LlV1n L UUL ~Jfl::'ln'fl]j~\lf'n11.IL ~l!'~i'J'll'f).aallWWl:fl'l'W

'... • v

'Vl1_ ~ 'f)','U'l~ 'D'Il Uti l VI~U-v'iufl"VI'Ufl L 'VYlU'ln.Jl'UUVI'lfl[lVllJ,) U f jjj1 UJliQ! 11J :: L.~'U~mnu

d l VI~'f)'f)~M~,)" 1 in rl'f)r~jj1Tl.J'Uflm~~/::~uu'll'f)\l1 VlUv:;~'f)L m L nu'Vi'l L tl'Ui'\lufl1~1;;

2J ... 11 01

'" v",,, ... • .f '1 .:I l.f

LL~1 L 1'l -v:: 1 flf'l1,)lJVll.J,) Ufi":l'll.J L 'lI'l1 'V~ ~ 1 j 'f)U') ~ 1 J 1'l f) j ~ jjH l.JUt1J L Vltll u L tlfl1tUL "ll'UU

... 1101

v '" vv r " " .. • .. • tv

'lI'f)~f'I'lI'f)«\I L flV1'l1'f)\I Y rm tlVll1 in Y::~~1'U L ~u11r ~ 1 U"llUfl'f)U mm r ~fl1n 1 L fi 1"1 ::VI'f)u1lJU'f)U

11 11

",I 1 .... .:I.... ......:1 " ' <!!

LLl.J,)"I1::~\I L 'n ::'N a'VI~fl Haj j jjj1 l.J~QJ'lI'1:)\I ~'l jjf1tU1 5111 ::'1l'l'1ll!-vtlflYl'llJ fl ill ":Ifl'f) :

,," •••• r ~ ,r 1l.J'U~~\I mn U L U'U nJulJlJ'lI'f)\I fllnL~ft\l 'Q'f)fl'VI'l -irn n ~'f).,)

~ ril'l-' s> '1 "'Jl.J '1 ~ J v "'I

u fl ein j'Vl'U,) ~ ~ l ~LL U') L '11') L 'V 1 ~flVl ~ft L,'U j'l 'U:; t uu l fl! 'f)\I~::'VlJ)llt)\I

'k fl,)1,-L~fltJ'ULLlla~1 \lLL'l.n'Ulu1J')u l\,)~~Vll.J"'!u'll'f)~rSjj1~l.J~Q! .

L l1fl'l us ":Il.J~'1 m r 'iflat)'l5'U L n'U'VI, \I m r r lJ s 'f)~ f)'V L 11tlu'Uu11tl\l ~t:n 'Ul.J1 'rh1LLtlfl'l 'f)'f)fl L flU":InlJ-5u~lJfi,,)ll.Ja'~QJfl'f)'UVI~ ~I \I

~'l 1 L ~'D,,·n 'UUv-VUU LL~ ::fl'l11, '1lfu ~'l ua,Vlfuflo,VI'UflLL 'U1'U 1 uin U

"'.., '"

Vlaflfl,) 'U1'l'l \I '1 n (35 )

-23-

-24-

-25-

JY ~ '.f'!,! Y 0 C).... .... .,..,.

Vi f)'hHh1U L U'Wt'ltlUfl'lll~rt-.j tlt1fll U~lJU T ;jlJ'H;l 'Vtll.J1fI~fl'(1)lJ flrl'-u'tT

J .oij """"'" ~ ... #'

(W. M. 2506-2511) ,]\I~1JVltlflo/lflj ~1J'UjJ nl1£)'Jrl" 'il'O\I 'V'PlJV~fl~t'iHfl 'D'W~J'JWl ,

~ A ....... ""'J t ~ Y.., Y #'

( 2501-2506 ) UT :: L nu L j 'U\I "f'I'W,fl1JiI"I T'WlJfl8f1£lVlJJ"I U" flm J f'lLl ' " r '1fl ~'O\I L ~101JU

, ~

, 'Y I

flDVllI"I UUZ'l ::tlU1 ~ j)nJJL tltJJJflr~ , I, uin ui ~tl\l " U1J L U'W j"l n jl UDwhf1~iJ\I '1ltl\!

... ~"" J 1 v~ ,~ ... fl • "1 ... C) .Jx

j::lJtl1Jjl\i'JjjjJJUbiIL~j'WUJJ "l!\!'Y:: fl'VHflj"l::~fl'Ub'Untl'Wrt'E} 1 l! ~'1Vlj1Jl'WVlU

... iJ'"

Y .... 0.( • • ...., ~~ "', "" "" W'

1l'Ull'Wf1':1 H"l\l L flfl1'1f1LL.J1l11.J'mJJ'WI rn jVl')f~1m'1&''\f1flll tl mr~flVlI.J fiJI JJflflLllJ1JYl ~J'U

nn L ~uJnlJf'lJ' JJVlJJ"Itm~ ::lJl~lJ,)ViVl~,~

ttllj!~~lj~41 vFn"l~ 1. 'W'J j jFll~"I t1~.J irlJ~.J

J ' .f ill

fl1''ll.l L 'lllllJ 1. U\I T ::"'11', \lfl"l jir1J~f.lflrr~JJ'b®r~1:J'~j ':;'ll,) ml1 YlU~'W 1. flUViU jl 'WLL~J

Y " ,Y

L ~u(Ja'lJ'i] m r L 1t1'Wj 'VI nu 'Wi fl1,)l.J~fl'lll,.m:nll"fI fiJI JJfilrtf'l11JJ l '(I'll, 1~ f'lJI l_n°,) l ~u

11

;ll\liJff.i'DjjJJ'WruL il.J L nfl~'W'l~;,l,~'W,)uVltii\j 'Y'lflYlll'l II L umh ::rl" fl~"Hll.r'lruiu

~ ~'" ~

-26-

-27-

-28-

• I""........J ~ ~ , , I~ ....... q • I':""'~

II fl"l7lJ!l1fl UJ'D u W. 1'1. ~4V L uumr 'PI 1fl'VI,) -3'V1\)Y!) ••• fl') 7lJg;J1fl

'VI') -3 ~ 1 ~dflfl'l rtU 1 V1um 1 ft~'llul Urt f-3 ~'W llJ ••• fI'I¥l'VI'l >3 Wll ~'llfl>3 rt'W 1 'VIti

, . ~ ,..,

f'lrlflfl7:u1:l1~'1~ ~ (l47S-2:9yOl1'_\J1~ml~nfillm~1l~ lJ1 ~'ll'l \y flUU'W L lJ'UfI,)WVl '1::1, ~H VI L 11U Jl~P 0 llflO L UfI"lW'VI

eu l~1t1tl't)lJ L ~u1 f1~ U~ l"'ll't)-3~)li L 't)'IfltlLLfi1i1'V10f'1U L j'VI~UOUlJ,

If Jq '1 v J :II' 'tot' q I

'VI-.3 '1 ~lJf j'finlJ\lQjll,fl L '!IH j~?)U -i 1,.,"lllJ 1 'l} Uft L rltpi 1 ~1JHlJ~qJ

111 :;~V11illj ::ai'VIa'VI~L atfl"lW 'fi'\.a fll VI L 1il '11 Ll~~lmi'l.n v'VIl:~fllS"l

T) ;f , VI,,)f'l1"UJ1l UVlI>3'W ••• ~

:II

V

" •••• afl"lw." 1 't'llfl-3 nu 1'V1t1 ••• fI"l iJ1.Vlfl"'l rllnrt 1fl-3,. :u-qu~",r :J"l ~111 nu

ltlW"IMnq11ufl1; ••••• 111 ::'lli'll1i~: l'V111ih ::l!'l iu1mJ llJ 1 fl L lJfl

111 :'lli'1!u11JL flil ll.a'1!1u~'l.M.l VliuL U'Ulh ::'1I"lm.J1mJf'l.n!''I' '1

1 Ul1"l ,\VI~n1'11"'11-.lorl"l10u1" ~1 l'llIl-3~1 :'1!"l 'llul1J1 ::ullull1 :'1!"l ~111 nu ~fltlllf'll Vlull1 :'1!") ;111 flunLL~~~ t ••• ntn",11 fltla~l1n~~ Wll~'llfl-3

rt1i1 'VIti 1 U1 ::Uflutl1 :'J:j') m.J1 flU'VI!'Ji uin LLrl1 ••• w;J fIll~,,) 111i)-wi

1 V\ L ~ulfll l'll'iNtl1 ::'J:l"l ']jul us :Ut'lUtl1 :'ll");111 flUI'l1U llJ ••• ~, (43 )

'1 U\ii ue d:IWhY'lifu!li j L ~fl\l uruV###BOT_TEXT###quot;l flU L U'WlJa ~i Udafl'llfl-3 f'i11iHlJ'UUl

..l ":I)"" ..l :I)"

",,.!,I .Of. v,''' t '1 '1 J.f,.!,l '... J "'i ,t,

nf'lfluQlVl"l 'llfl-.lfli 11.1 1"}-3 urn UU lflU"l au L y L 'U'VIUf'l'OlL U1rt1")).l11?H '1!'t)l.I L tI-3 j :Vl1"l >3

..., .

. .: :###BOT_TEXT###quot; ,

fl1ri1llJ~Qlnll1l1L_cilr_~fin~'11 ~~_1J1_" ~'k1iL atfliwtlj:'1I"l mJ1VltlLLfi::l U~~flri"l1U1J~fl

, ....!'! ... v ., 1 v""4.... .... I .f

fl!)Vll.I1 usu L uurn rnr -3 numunum jUOfl1t'l-31I'lU ""1I11iflflv" t.H~flfl1 r r V\a"l UU1 :flfl1J

J ft. t

L nUflT:U 'Mn"ll.l L l!'t)u~ ~tiu L ~UW~~fl"lT L~fl~ a.flruu~ a.1UVlU'lflflfl"l ni1V1lJftjtJLLUUlL~ ~

~ ~

I ,,' . v.

L UflVl"l a"l1 :'ll't)-3U r 1fl"lf'l!lVllJi U 1 j1J11lJ1JqJ'llt'l--1 1 'VIulJ11 fltlfla'Dfi . tLl.ILLfl1Jl1lJ~QJn"l"

v " '''( tI'

Unf'l7fl~ j1'1l'il"l on in 1 W. 1'1. 2502 rn u 1 Vl 1t1' ::Ufl~11Bif)tt'll't)-l ~'fjl.lYi"a"'f1lm~'·"'lnr:: 1"111"

J. '" v..,. 1 "".1"1 " .., 6') '" .., v"" .1 q .1

'jNVI.fl"l 1rll.lrl1 -3 1 j1i11lJ1JqJ "lJ1 :"11') 'Jj'JJ LY1U" , ntl~ L Vlfl"l11Utfl-l "lJ1:: L WOlf'l"l" lJflf'ljfl~

t. . ,

tl1 :: n'lf11 'VIU 11.11 :u't)utlr :"1I"l mJ1 flU" (lJ'Hl1'l 20) "1Ifl~ 1i -3 Llflflfl1 ~ 1 ::Vl1"l-lV\ann"l T

f v v ..f""

~-3 L ftJurOW"l V"lflfl :;-1UflOn1Jfl1' l.I"alJ L V\~1111"l f'lV'I fluml-3 rlU 1 U~1fl'VI L tlU 11 -3'V1"l-3f11'1

$ ,

d:tfl\l8u L~UL111-3~fli1fl;uiun'Ul;~i-l '1 U"I '1 ;fli(\lL!lflLLrl:1W"ln~1·tU~'llfl-3

..f JV v "'.f ., I v 4 V V '"

"LLlJ~-3V11" 'VIfl'iN t)-3 '1]"l \lflUU 1 'Ull'lV\U'l L iJU~1't)tI"l-3'" ::'VI't)'UtI~ fl1,lJ~~flU7)VI-1-3'V1mL~

~

-29-

-30-

Wit~i 1.11 ::'1l1 ~tl1 nu

I.J~'" ~ v ' •

• ' L 'VIi'lll'VI'l 'Jf!I'JllJ~'l1J1 :'iXUfl'l rrutl1 ::'1li itl1 fltJ'IJrtl'lfl ::1\mnw1 fl~lJ'lU"1i1J1i

~::Ufl~'t)L min L bULll.l1J'fl~i 'l';~~r1Jfl1IlJ L';' 1ll1'fl-lwfJJu')ni d'VI-)~rjjjn1J~QJ'1J'D-l1 'IIlU

-.31,--

/'

---,)2=

.\

- 33 -

..... ..~.J 1J 'W Vl fl1J 1/J1~

t, Carl J. Friedrich, Constitutional Government and Democracy, New DeJ11:;L,

Oxfor-d & I B H Publishing Co., fourth edition, 1968, Prefaces to Third

~ .

and Second Editions,VI'W"l xi. - xvi ; Paul. Si gmund , 1I0a1"'1 Frti edr-i.ch t a

Contribution to the Theory of Constitutionalism - Comparative Coverrimerrt ", 1, 'U .r. Roland Pennock and John W. Chapman (ed:.), Consti tutiona-

1ism. Net,,)' York, Hm..r York University Press, 1979 VI'U,)' 34.

~ ~ ~ - ,

7J'tlf: '1 l flf1Vloi'W'O'l l ~tJJn'U l u 1l~1 :n'W tTItlU'llJ : fl miJufn j lDrH lL~ ~

, r

ij 'Dj nJ~qj1JIN rl"l 'llJj ~ l Vlfin1J j ::;1JD1J fl'1 j l1flf'l·j D'l7JD 'llVlu. fllru~ f ~ M,~m JJVI"l 1Vltl"l t1tJ

~ ~

~jjJJM,fl~j w.fi.2515 VlU1 7 ~ 8.

fljfln,fllJJ 2524 VlU, 16 - 37.

L~tl')n1Jf~1J'~'llflVlVl1j - 'VIJfi Lri'J'WU ;L~tJ'WL~'U~''lDDfl111J1'l L~fl~tltl

.. , ~

t.- .J ~ I ~ ~ '" ~ ,J 0 ,.. t '1 ¥, .J,¥ I ~

l'fl7JtllJftVltl1'l~'l UrlflLU'Ul1j~Lf1U~6flfl1jVll1LnU~'tl'lflfi1' ')l'UVlU flfi1,)f'1tl

5J

mfi1fj1JiZ'l~f1 'I"lft J. rl. 'iY)~~ jhj 'lUi J,t6~~ LnU'U"ltlflfj JJ'U~f ll~~JVI~1 fllru::

f ~1J,ft1 :::;Dtlfi VlVli j ll~ Lrltl~U~flo'll VI~'l t)','Uil'l f1tl1~Vli 'l f ~ 1JrJ JJuru ft~'n' ~ ~tl dJ'U

..I 5J .. lJ "

.... ~ 'I i-' r ,.

J""1Jitl'iiflWfi rr nu l'WVl"l'lrlHn'W7Ji~ f'lru~fj1J"lfl'llVl'W"ltl'\ntl fliJ'flU (n'Wtl1tl'W _!

.. , ,

. v" ~ v 4*

t'WJiflJJ 2500) ~f1'W"ltlf'lJ'l tlfltl1'lfi O~~fivfl')tl'W 2490 - ~JJfI'Y~U'ii 2491) ll,fl:::;

r ' I, •

'iim.nmnih..lVlj flriJ1 L~tlJ (flft"lflllJ 2519 .; rl~if'1lJ 2520) ;\I$h'WitJflf~lJ1.mt LnU

, , ", ...

Wft L r su LL~O L~i..l~JVI~"lf'1ru:r ~ 1J,) fl~\J~'W~rl'llL VI~\ltl°iUi ~ 1 Vltlll"l~tlfl,) j ~fu;~u'W~"l n

.. lJ ,

I ,J V ~I , '"

flOi~ 'lrJitlVlVl,) j l\ltl"l flVl~ ~~Vll11l7J'"l1l~ 1 'Wl1j ~ LflVlfj1J'Ifj'W~ Lf nu 1 fl

",I ~ I ~ ~

l~UflUJ"l 1w1j'Yu <TIU 'Wi JJ ll~ft\lIl'"l\J l~U1nu VI'W,) 3 - 9 ; ~Hru lflttl.:J"IlJ :

,

v G.'" ~ d" ~~ ~ (f' U r.j , ,.,

.!J[)VlJJitlJj'fjJJlJ~nJ. t'fI'WflVJlJr~wi1JJjru"lflij 'V'llJ'I"lf'1r'lVl 2 'V'l.fi.2523 VlUi 388 -1

-34-

i.I i.I i.I

4. Carl J. Friedrich, 'il,)~LLft'1 'VnJ1

Paul Sigmund, 'il"l\lllt'i'1· WU,

124 -12;-:".; 34 ... 35.

5. W. Ivor J ennl.nga, The Law and the Constitution, London, London

i.I

University Press Ltd., fourth edition, 1954, Vi'll, 37 ... 38.

i.I

VI'U'l 389

8. Herman Finer, The Theory and Practice of Modern Government, London,

Methuen & Co. Ltd., 1956

WU1 12.

Februa~ 5, 1982,

10.

~

Lf'lr'il~1lJ 'f),\lLLft'1 VlU") 28.

,

13.

W. Ivor Jennings tn \) LLft 1 VIti, 33.

...... ... ..," i.I 'I... ~ i.I i.I i.I

lVlt1 fI\lflJWIU 'f)') \I L'U 1Hl\l Lf'lT'f)\I,)lJ. 'f)')\lllt'i1 WU,) 22.

1'Wl1lti' -ifU'U"ll.J : a1:'l,iJ'Ufn1l~'f)\)Llt'i:;nnVll.J'ufj~Ql l m'"mrfl',r, ~fI

, : .. .. i.I

o. • ...... ~ q~ ~ ...

, Vl,r"Hl,)f'l1J'Vl 5 i"lru:;UflPl,rlm l.JVI''1'VlU')~U'j)HlJM'rlm l'J.M. 2524 VlU") 79.

11 •

12.

14.

·,151' 16.

i.I i.I i.I i.I .q

L su 1 fI L Uli'i flUtJ L 'ZIU'll L () \I.

11

i.I i.I I

"'WT ::;1' 1'1!fI'",f al UWT ::;111 'VlrllJ L~l'W1::;lal'tll.J L n~, L l1'f)U~1'Vl1 \I u flt'i \lY'lT :;1)j lJT ,)'1!, tlJ1U

, ,. 11

lLn~'ZIn"l111nf'lr'tl"ll~tI~tJ"lu . -ifU'tliJtJ~rllJ'UiU'1! .zJflf1U"l nnrurlm (T111r1l.J)

, 11

L 'tl1)rl"l r 1)') r L~'f) \I t)') TlJnflT 'tl\l'Zl'f)\I 1 'VlU I. fiT \I m T fI',!') a\l fll.JM')rlfl;Lt{l ::J,JUHUf'i J~fI;

,

- 35 ...

li~.fi. 2519.

, 'j/

,j ''-OJ ~J ""

n j "l.JV'jj ~ j "l t]j f)(]H~Jf)"l VI 1 'J"l rl1tJ j") 6Jlllj :; L ~(,!lf)j .J~tJ"l lJII Vl'fJ ~f1VllJ"l u l WllL Vl.J6Jl"l VI

, ,

J t ~ I ~

L 5 n. 2/8 llj ::mALl~:j ,)"DUC~l]Vl ~ j D'J j') -l~j :n'1lf)fjH£jfl') ')')rl1tJJ ,)'1lVj ~-

L l~il1f)j .J~tJ,)lJ.

,

20. Carl J. Friedrich

. I V ,'J ....

21. LlVl(HD"l.J lrltJ')f)'U ; John'Bowle, Western Political ThOlJg..~ London,

Jonathan Cape, 1<J5lr, Vl'U"l 402 - 403 ; H. Judd Harmon, Political

~ght: from PlatoW the Present, New York, HcGraw - l-Iill

v

Book Company; 1964., Vl'U,) 280 - 2F!!7.

cl ... 1 ... v

22. lJ. r , 1. L'l'!'UtJ llj"lllJ11, fl'Cl"l11fm'ltl'll'UJ,)lJj<]°"lllVl'l tl'li1mjf'l"l'lJtl\lflj~f1"l

, , ,

v~.fi. 2519 Vl~"1 84 L;'Ul;L~'UlrltJ~l~mHfl\l; Ll(l~l;;"l-Jl'Ulf)fi(j 'It''lf11f'tS-

9.J

... v ",'"

~~m , m j f'I:l:r'lj tl\l~V1~lJ'UHtJ'1l'Ufl1lJf):nVlj.ntJ l t~tJ f~~')~ -J f)HlllJ1tn 1t1tJ1~tJ

--" ,

w.n. 2523 VI'U,) 9. u. ~ .1. L'l'!VU' lln llJ,]

23.

D1Ll'Cl'J WW1116.

Dg.vio. }1,. Er..gol, Lm.:r and. Ej_rlgsr.d.p in Thai.Land, During the Roi{:,'n of King Chulnlongkorn, kxai Arbor. Center for SoUth"am Southeast Asian Studies,

v

ThoUnivorsi ty of Hichigan, 1975, Vl'U') 8. .

~.- ..

26, Gordon J .. Schochet., "Introdu~tion : Constitution, LiberaJ.ism, and tho

study of Politics" l'U . Pennock and Chapmarl (.:.ld.), ConstitutionalisEl

:;...0 y v

[) ') eu (l ') Vl 'U,) 11 - 1 2 •

-36 -

y y

VI.f'i.2524 D,'_'Ut)')

II

~'W, 81.

y Y Y I

28. L'll'W CarlJ. Friedrich 'B,-llLt)1 ~'W, 123 - 126 ; 1 llUlfllUll1 :nmJ

Lawrence word Beer" Consti tutionaJ.ism in Asia : Asian Views of the .American i:nfiu.ence. Berkeley, University of California Press" 1979

i

~'W, 9 - 10.

29. Derek J .R. Scott, Russian Political Institutions. London" George

,., v6'J v Y v c:I I

Allen & Unwin Ltd., 1958 ~'WI 89 L~ULfll'Ul.tlflUCJL"1JtJ'WlD'_' : l11H'lDl'Wlln:fwu

_' 11

~1erleFainsod, How Russia Is Ruled. Cumbridge, Harvard University

Press, 1956 ~'W,) 291-;.. 1921Lt):: 313 - 315.

v

30. f"l·11.11')f'lfu"lltl-lan.,~'W tll~l 'W Merle Fainsocl

t v

LLfl::1 ilr flLII 'W1Jr ermu ~U1 126.~ 131 •

31. Barrington Moore J r., Social Origins of Dictatorship -and Democracy,

51

Penguin Books, Prefa.ee Wl..n xii - xiii tLfl:: 413 - 483.

51 51

32.. Merle Fainsod tll'llll.'l1

~'W, 292 - 315 i Leonard Schupi.ro , The

Government and Politics of the Soviet Union. New York" Vintage Books,

1967, ~UI 93 - 94.

33·~' C.G.Weerama.1'J.try, ~quali.ty and Freedom : Some Third World Perspectives,

51 I

Colombo, Hansa Publishers Limited, 1976 ~'UI 13; 11l1f1D,1JU1 ::flDU

Adamantia Pollis and Peter Schwab, "Human Rights : A Western Construct w.i..th -L:i.Ini ted Applicability" 1 'W Pollis and Schwab, Human Rig~ :

QHltural and Ideological Perspectives.N~w York, Praeger Publishers,

1979 m.n 2 - 4.

34.~ A.V. Dicey, Law· of the Constitution. London,MacMilian and Co. Limited,

,.,

ninth edition, reprinted 1952 , ~'Wl 195 - 196.

- 37 -

36.

. D..J:19-Qpll.OSi tioll-l Vol.16, No.3, Summer , 1981, mn 317.

If" "'l ",.,J v' '" .. ' "1 <V

II vn ~T) ']j~i ~jjbl-llh ~'fjitti1i1Jfl~Vi J 'ill t lJ:r m il V~. fl. 2403 b UYJJ ;;:: J') ']j"vl'il fl L fl'?Ji

'"

~ ~.' Y 'v tI' v

1fi~ ~1JI'Vl'i1JJ l7JY~n ~1''D).J L mil L ~i'tlmn 'f)'lflm rrn 'ij1J..Jflj'Cilrn y~. fie 2521

-- !ij-"

v V VYV. .

Vitti 682 - 685 L~ulrHu1.l"lmJ[H~t1ULll'l.

jJ

38.

39.

40. 41.

42.

43.

v Y ... vv" v~

'V'J.fi.2508 m.l') 2 - 6 L~lilYH1.-ntlfltJCJL~tltlLu-l.

iJ •

. , I

11 flifl tl1JU~ PlJJ'VI~i'()i t1A'Ji lJ b ~U ?'nm J LlJ~tltlLl,U~'l j ;:; L Dtl1J n '11fll J l!,lJ1.\?)tl

iJ

• v ..

61 tl 'if tim! u ~

J.fi.103"

I v .,J ..,.., /..., "'l V "1 v v v r-j

U '(,1~..:I 'En 'l t mJ'Jfltlfl1J1JU'Vlfl 26 L ~1i b fI L '!.!'W 17JtlCJ l '?Jut! l {)\l.

iJ

v v I

"l"lJ ;;::rl(,]Jftif'8l1 UVJJ' ;:;1JI1tl'~lJ L ~\l'iJ\lr ;:;'V~vfjJJ L mnl '1illll1XJVld'llLfl,(Nv~r ::1JjlJJ'i'1l') ~1J,)'U

, iJ

v 'v s>

llfl'l 'lJm rUflflJ'O'lllml~Uf1 ll"l-.Ju~'J1 UUUMfl

J ~r.., """" tI'

litlJJfl-.J".n" • "L:J'D"J'(,IZ'!'lUg'Jf1f'i"l~lf1j"

1 7 t 1 8 u ~ ;;; 20 • 'Jr;:;']j"ljfu1fltl lh;:;'il-ru~ 14

L ;uli~L ~ulflu~l ~U1H ll'l'.

iJ

dJUtlilJU"If)flI'?J1J'l JJ.J.'J.LjU~ lJrllJJ6Jl.

'1.:'tl'1"1 AjJ i~. fie 2490 J lllJ~'lVi'Jii

44. Joseph J-. Spengler, "I'hoory', Ideology, Non - Economic Values, and Politico - Economic Deve'Lopment.", 1u R. Brc:.ibanti and J .,T. Spengler

(ed.), Tradition, Valu'll> and Socio - Economic Dovelopment, Durham,

i' t

Duke Univ~rsity Press, 1961, ~tll 4; LUHI'DitllJJ;:;f)ll1J Seymour :tv1.Lipset,

~tll 39 - 48 .

- 38-

45. Robert A. Dahl, E2.~archy : Participa~ion and Qpposition, New ,Haven,

Yule Univ~rsity Press, 1971, ~'UI 76 - 80.

-47. Dankwart A. Rustow, "Transitions to Democracy", QQ_mparative Politics,2

(April 1970) WW"l 337 - 364.

· .

40

41

i-' ~ IV

~DW~ijruilUD~~U~i~UJ~n,j

.-....... ......,_ ",_ ..........

IV I Y s- I 1 :I' I

'iJULL 1n~'?v",l n'U~'O~'VI'lflJllJ L 'iJi'l '~f1DuS'Ul Vl Inun flJiJJV!lJItJ'lJD'I

;r m j L 1J~tJUU tJ~N 1, v~ bflt(~JJtJji DU dJVPli J ~1hf1[;J'lID-Jml'Cn f)'iJ\i'l H L vflUi 'i!U~ ,n'I"\

.' .

vi' j/ y I Y I I ,

~'" r-l &.:! ~ Q '"-"'1 ~. ~' : ~ ., ,r:i.c:;.

A\l131 UlJ'I'VI~::: ,,'nfl,,) '1 1)9'11 JJl/l-a :::~~ll'l:r;Yi nflJilJf1l'ilJi UUfl~fl'l1nt~Y'J_11lJl~

!J ~:::'f1 j ~V)If1i j L D~ l ~uV!5f1 1~~'{;1 ~~~~-~~'~;~~~~tJ~~f1~ilJVIJJi tJ?1WJ'Hl~lJn')')l;1

I " ,'--""---'_'--. - . I . I s> I ~

L ~'DV1 r\)f1JllJ L ~U II 'VIi ~ ~ciii m j If JI f1J r 'f;:; L ~i.!L rjju"t~U V; r '0 'V :::r1'D ~ llJvrH,n-.Ju

,} <o:j I b' ~ A ~~I . "', <f' \l ' 1 "1 ~(3)

'M lJ1JDtll'lH flfli u l iJu l Hj~[L 'i,'1m,rErDtJ~1J~'U L t:n fl;D L f1t'lnllJ;;; j Ll'WU'OU JJ fl

v ~;.:=:-l ~ "'~_'_"i' _. ~' .. J 9,) fV ~i ~ ~.::i

~n'QfJ't.H mrlifl'iJ'O\l 'J'fjfli H1Cl\ll1JJ.DtJ 2 'WU. 'IJ\ll f1WnTD\lf1'W flfl lh ~f11 ru 1f1 L iJU'J'if

, ~ .

I , .. It· r J '

m j ~iff1 'V ::;iJf1~fl'i)Un1JCJ(;n:111J!J'lJD\l f1i 1 lllr;titiH Vr 'l ~IJ~ L fiVl~UnlJK\l f'llJ.-)<,;,U'1JHlJDUDt!

11 ....... .:.c'~-, - , .. ~

42

43

I I ,

1)-:] L r\mflu J 1lJ 1 11 b~u~ufl~n ,,1. 'u'N~ f1:l!f1I J l iJ'Ll'llom.J UflVlfjUDf1i mh ~r.Jj') i1.J1 flU

p_ -- •• ----

£/

Yl ~Y'UVlmn 'H~lJ't)\I'l III tH ~\I 'lJD\l rnr lJzfn rv~~~'t)fl1,)lJ~'llJL V1Z'l'11 'Urn n~fiJ1.J,) J ~1J'DlJ

J" ..: ,J ..: .<1 "'J .". I ~ ""

'j')'Ufwn \l V1fl'Gl'Hll 1]v m v~llfl'blllflU JI L ihJflDl1"Jr lJ 'VH U f' :';'Ir flfl

a: J .;' , ill I ill J 6J U J( 'I ,·14" d I~ M •

l~r 'l~H U'U 1 tll ?'l'DiJ') 'lumJv1(lf! umuu Ll'?l::: t W1'U L vmv:;;"bJJ.JD~'1 J~ l tlflYl

~

I . ~

V~LI ullJD\I f'l1i lJ~1J,) 'lI'I1D\l m j L tl~Ut\Lbl.l?l-.:j 3'1 nt\.'l..l1 flflLl ~" :::flI1{)r :::Vlr 'II'D \I rl1 f'lUU~lJ'VI1J1 'VI

.. . . . . . ",.,

I I I '-' I . I

n r ~'VI",)flr! 'VII" m n nD'H nUy1f1fll 1,1',U L rlJfli40~ unrn J 1 ']f1"")J') Ii rn n tl~mml1tN

• -. _'" , 0' .. _'. _.,- •. "." ".'_' .• 0/

")1> ........ ..-4<:1 1'" .. ~.,,_I( 01, I r "):1-' .,###BOT_TEXT###::

l1i1'V1'Wf'llJtJiI vH flU') , tlvlr1U:::'ll'Lh'l '11 UI~mnu' 1 vn,.!.')') l.n~J;-_; L VI\i"J')lJ1i1lJ"l UVl L ih.I'Clm 1:::

"" ... ,J'I> '1' .., i'; J. '.1

J ~tJ'IlU m 'V :::lJ1J \I 'D nn tl 'Vi fl~1 tJfI') 'llD \I fi '1 f'luc.J'i .. n flr r t tltrtl'~llL Uf: \I L ll\l OUi \I t llUVI

3J

ill :y. .{.-~ "4' "3 ""

L 'V') 'VI!! :;;'iJ')'llHlJl"IflI'ilJUfI J b 'EiUll,ll'l fl J :::1~ n \I nflH') nm J

,

~fl14i th\A f lJ'1ll~ "'l') •

·,

44

V iJ V.f JI , "t .. I II •

71tlf'lJJJJ'lJl'lflWi1 L ~WVlU"l'i;'ltn yVllJ L WtFHL71l WU-j'llf.l-3.f{;V1f11 1 '1m ~ L m~'\J

v J II' , y

W'l f)U--l1 'tt1f(:JilJ'tt1lJ'i rJlJ'Cl._j II iii n 1J~tnlllllf. -J 'Ln7lu"JJu "::-u~{n~c :: il l.Li-J ~ ~;~I ::1 tiL:'1-.1

• I v 6'

71'D-l u in'U 1 tJ1J1 U L ~tnJr ~fn J If,)flDJ ~<l ~ L 'v1'W:f ::u,) 'DJ' nJPfo~lJ'Ufl1 'Wf1~._j 'En ~f) Y·1nf1

or !iJ JJ

!, ",1 t 2-'"" "' .... ~ ,v "i>""

iltJ l 'WL :fl.l'l'1l'tl'lf),):fMfl'H,) U,rllflUllVlv:f-\lmnUu L1JUtJ'Cl;1::::VI't:l'WlJ,) 'f")f)llVl'D'W'Cl'1l'[)\lnJ ~ll~

!iJ . .

m J L llitlLLu~'1~~~,[) 11 r jllJ_~_~2~1'W1J1 U" lf~tJ;J'4.~ltl~.P~.,VlI_\lJ·}cnJl"'Lil~u, L 1,1fI'CJ~\ 7

I ,. v J 4' v V 1:iJ

U Vit1lJ J H),) fi1 'nl.~ ~ lUI ~JJD\l LI~D ' II rl~ 1,malUtJ1'tJ'I U ij ~ "]~ ~'W 11J~ vi1~Unl~D

::::

1 , .

~ r1l1 ~;'[)m -in J ::Vlf1 rf1i1~flvl flf')'')fl1,) UD\l f'llJVl'Cli J. Fi ~ 103 ~\l (J~ o/l nmrr umh ~ L t1f'i

, "!iJ

.J "

Vl ')') :-:-

45

1

"( .... J' J .... "", y ~ ¢~ !:f...... Jr.!'

.m 'J ::lj~~U~~'Uj1'1H flU":lfJll t fir ..!fl1",; 'H'J'i3AlJn"l! Wlh'l Llf; ~nlJ'i~'W':fifl,,)~~IVJI \lll')'l.i'"l 'il rjN~J'{]J'U

• t, .' s> I . y

N'IPi::um.J,,)-:l8-l L "i.a~tnfl:mLlfr)') lJ~flLL fl emrn d ::Vl"'l7Jtl-llJ T HY'l tJ1i'1 n~fl'),1''W 7J'D~'il'"l ran

~ ~

L utUlJ L ~tilJ~-:lll d \lU'il-rUfJ d ::;til~~L flf)fJ') n lI~fJ'Wlll1fl,l1 'WIrth ::L V1f'ltJ1 dun flll 11 ~n ~-l

,,,

~ "'l.... 1 "'. 00' y. ' ."f. ." 0 I ~

·~i.J'Uj" 'U 'U'Of) 'n 11 'V eu 'ih'1\l f1-:l1~f'l'U tWI WlJ'f)\I d ::fl1Jmnfl'OuGJ'tY) m d L 11 "jUULlllt'l'1 U fl'J

51 "

U\I t lim ~d'f)'l a :::l;'i.ni111~ '<:,)'U:::7J'O-.J~1.l1 L 'f),:J1, u1 An ~;") \I ue ::aiJ~U'fjfl,)'tj'ifn -:lfl')1.n 'ilt~

~ ~ .

... "4' "coy &JI t .,. "'l ....

llflfJf11-l1..\ II fl ::fi")1 lJl~Y)f)r() \lWU fl U t 'll~nYw 'y ::lJ,IJ'W'll ')UB'Il1Jl UfI.:! en Hru::tl 1.!lJl: t i'W

r J Y

Utj ::1jff)') T7J'El-:l if.:! fllJfl1 d L ~'El,mU\l 6') 111~~n') j L tl~UULtl1~:hn i;1~'lW!iJU'iltl\lflU

-------------

47

( Pc,tr:Ullonial)

49

50

II ~_~ IIl~'fJJtn.f) ') J' II U

f1.JLlYHLJ'f) :-

'--_-

51

o\l I.., ~ -=l.... • I"" . 1 6) iI.., .....

lI.lo • L !"l wQ,)"lW~nn f)') r. b UUj) H1!i~ t AH611ll-J rn 1l jJ~lmJllufi\!. b v1tlti,(,j:JJt!

'~r~4 '4I.t.r.... .f ')... . ""

LL9lL Uti!) HU'ii1;~ n 1HUtI\! L fl~~ L j)f)'::Il!L l:lV'J"l ::; ~ U~N fl~~lJr :: L .fWl~U\I

L vntlu ~ll ~\lfl:JJ::h~~ UYT jJ(L nf):fut '1, 'lJ.ff\lfllJ~j)~r::; LflVlv.U\! ~ll

if'lf'll.Jj:J"1!fl') r • 0 ·lfluvlu.n~CiJL\~,) f'l,),)l.JLL910f1'1'lr:1!n"l'l I I

rn nl.J~uULL~'l\l all\! LL1J1JU 1 '_;~"1! L ~U~\! '!IU"l UfluTlflllf)'l1J_ ~"l m,f1,),) f1r"l lHU~\I L t'ltnt L f)uur ::~iln'l1~Dullr ::~n~n'U:JJ,) LL'~n (om ':l~tl Lfluvn\lllr ::;~Pi'l(jTl;) iJf'l,)'ll.JUfIOfl'l\!nUL ;uif ••• i1 (:24)

~~"l1(U11f)U L urU]J L ~tl1J iunrn r:JJ'tl\!fl')I:JJ"l~jjIU'!lll\lnl r L 1J~UULLll~\I

..... '.~

52

• Vl"l'€ltJ L ~JJ'€l

5.1

53

\

:II I t I. \ .. / I s>

y;:;17)U1NVJ;:; l~l.lYh'JD.J")~l)l:tJ()l)f) lVl.l 3 ~Jl.l f)~")')Ml) 1l.l~Jl.lHJf)l.ll)f)y')m1,,)"fl')l.l

I s> 1 I v

Vlf'll.l:UtI :;~'H ~j, :;'i'fl'1J~f1~jJ~~flflj 't:l~ ~~'JiY~1 11;j Lll:tJl.lLLll~ ~,lb~ : (}j?JflmJ .J~l! LVl.lCJ=

rl"llJlJ"l ~1Uf1D 111~ :YJv"l HIll 1:"1 rn j flDfi 1'?J'fl..j flrllJ'll U"ll'UflC1"l \l ~J'Wi;1~"l tIfl"ll'\!,Vl"l \l L firl1j fl'V-

, v' Slc.y,J

rn j L~D..j ua ::;CJfi~lJ L tiIl..ji I:) ::;flI r fiflVI"l u V ;;;~!jtJ'ItJl 3..111r ::; lZufi mm.t:rn r LllfltJ'Uu11n..j 'V)')..j

. v " Y (\

'1 AT \I~r "l \I 'lJD.Jif -.lf1lJ 1 'VlU U"J~"l 'litl..jfl"l j L tl~tJUllUfl-.lLLfl em r cnflLnJ\I LiJUtJ:r 'I fl[jfl'l J ill t 1.1

~ .

CJ A" .... '1 s> dj 11'" '1 '""

m :1J1Ufl"lJ LlJ'El\l'1J'O\ll t1tJ 'Il\lllJ1')V:lJtl-.lflUL Ufl''l'U1.J')f)1.ummtltJ''I-.l rnmu 'Wfl1'lJtl\l

lJU L~\li11.J LiJWY~~ \I tl~fl~1.n ;iflJTIU'fi.fl"lVfWl-.l rrrr lntl.JLUh L uRu uue ::;'lJtI,)U'1J'El1J~"lu'ElDfll u

~ s> J,.I ft..(" _. ~.q Coo" ~

YlllJfi~lfl1.J L j lJfl14fl1tJ1JtJjVl'l fII nH'J,l1u"l r j 11j :;'jj"l6Jl"lflLLfl ;:;lln~l1~ m1.J 14fII r LlJ'O\I

rn j 1.JrVl"l j l ~'OrJ'01.Ji1C!Vl"l f11,)lJtl~j tlf'llln:; II fl'J"llJ l vrrJ'1J'O..j'jj,fiil ~,f) 1 nfl~f1 ~'1J'D\I

41.' 11 Q)

. v

If'lnVlnvf)''lj Lntl\ll hnFlj\l~j"l\l~f)~14'I

.r v I 2'

1 flU~.fl,)i"JVJ1.!"l'l14'll'f)\llL1.J1.J~tfl"lHIfu1 ~tl rnr lW'I :l1fifl7J"l'J;\lv·, Ln14rl'O\luf1.J

~ - ~

1; l ;'In1J'Ii! j lJ'll"l~~uJyu"l fllfi lh :f)'01.Jn1J'1 f1u1 ~j \I~;"l-.l D·"ltl"l'V'f j LL1J1J "j ,)~ufuJ;"

I v V 'I

tT \I FllJ 1 ViU~-.l lLflf)rl,) -.l v') flif -.l rsrm ttl flL fllj ..j ~ j ') \I Ll1J1Jibfifi tlU') -.l L'll 14'lI[)..ju'1 i Ufl;:; ~'!.Jflf)LLfl ;:;

"-:-- _ .___ .,--", . - - i

II.· VII I I V II J

~~'U L nu l~i"n:::1 14'1J'f}~1' 'lJ'H'l L ~[)14 1 'lIf1"'1lJl 14~l:::Qj ;:;~lJ1Vi LOflv~atL1Jnu14m.Jfi.

~ml~iJflv :::;tl-.l Il"l~Ullj..jflj ~;14'V"l f)ihfUJ1'1UUIlfl (28) v"'lf)JJj ::~llfl"lnu~ti111 ~1~

, . . .. . .

I t J'

fi,)~fl;~jJu1 VllJ :fi[)fl~fflJD\I L~141"l rns lUfluulll1fi\ll ;~'!.J~iJu'~11)f)"lU14tlf)u"l~djlJ

v vv ", r v . .. ,

1 tll flfl1U~tf)"l r 'lID..j j :1J1J'Q"lbll"l11fllJ" L flU lJ 'lI.,) 8:"l'U,) l~fl~"l'lilm j lJ'1 "Ilf)1n ..jUM11J t '07 ~Lf)fi'lflJ

11,. ;:; L wr.f '!tit III ~o liJul tll flU[)')f1Ufl"'l r r l ilJ'lJil~fl~lJ~tlflf'\j 8..j l'D..j LiJ14fh14''''Ifl''l "L)J~L1U-

.-; . " 11 ,

llUtl-.l'V"lflVJ'~ \I tlcr f)ft14ft~U14flf) 1 ~~I V ~ dfufl"l j r L ilJ'Vl·1f)"l;- L fltlDf4j ;:;Vlt [) 1 flU

54

55

56

It· v "

d~'f)tl,. ~ ch.l1!~iLnft"l1'viIA'J"ll.J l '1l"ll ~t)>3 u~n1 ~l'l1JVI'Hftl1 L U't)>3 n~"l J h'U

, ., I-' ...., IJ !

uanr ~Vl1JVlflNl.Jw'U'1ifn m'1"l \l 'f)·I'U1 'V . 'V·l L Uti 'V ~\l'f)>3 blllmlH:W~ At"l :::V1~\!3"l 1,1 :::ft"l1f1"l

., C'> v l:f ..• f v:'.

'1l't)\I f'lumUJf