You are on page 1of 14

PROJECT

SUBJECT

: HILTON GARDEN INN BALI KUTA


: COMMENTS OF CONCEPT DESIGN

DISCIPLINE
REV./DATE
PREPARED BY

: MECHANICAL & ELECTRICAL


: 1 / 10 JULI 2014
: PT. MITRA INTI PRANATA

NO.

1.

COMMENTS

REMARKS

Plumbing Installation
- Hot and Cold water is required at all basins (both front of To be comply
the house and back of the house). Water temperature
must be pre-set at touchless faucets (D&C Standards
Section 2514.07)
- Grease interceptors must located outdoors in an area
serviceable without disruption of normal activities, and
out of guest view (D&C Standards Section 2504.01V)

Possible to located Grease Trap in basement floor


(HW : Yes, as long as maintenance vehicle is able to
acess and ventilation provided)

- Grease drains that are directed to grease traps must use To be comply
cast iron piping systems that allow mechanical cleaning
when blockages occur (D&C Standards Section
2504.01V)
2.

Fire Fighting Installation


- Concealed sprinkler heads are required in all guest areas Proposed with pendant sprinkler and standard wall
including the foyer area in the guestroom (D&C
type sprinkler. Concealed sprinkler only consider at
Standards Section 2516.03B)
main lobby area
(HW : Sprinkler at Guestroom Foyer area must be
concealed)
- Sprinkler is required in the bathroom of the guestroom if
the floor area is 5.1m2 and above (D&C Standards
Section 2516.03A)

299009078.xls

Not using sprinkler for guest bathroom


Sprinkler provided in public restroom
(HW : Sprinkler in not required in the guest bathroom
as long as it is below 5.1m2)

1 / 14

NO.

3.

COMMENTS

REMARKS

- Kitchen hood fire suppression system must be preengineered wet chemical water assist with UL 300
compliant type (D&C Standards Section 2516.03E)

For kitchen general area to be protected by pendant


sprinkler. Only for kitchen hood to be protected by
ANSUL, which will be provided by kitchen supplier
(HW : Need to coordinate with kitchen consultant and
provide the connection to the sprinkler system for
kitchen hood fire suppression system)

- Consultant to advise type of fire protection system


proposed for the electrical switch room.

Electrical switch room will protected with sprinkler


head and Fire Extingusher
(HW : Required by local code? We will prefer not to
have sprinkler in all electrical switchroom)

Mechanical Ventilation Installation


- Notice the design was not comply with our requirement. To be comply
Refer to D&C Standards Section 2514.06 for requirement
on air-change and temperature for different areas
- Kitchen exhaust must be solely dedicated to the exhaust To be comply
of grease laden vapours and must be separated from all
other exhaust systems (D&C Standards Section
2516.02E)
- Kitchen hood and exhaust ducting must not be
Not indicate material to be use in section 2516.02E. To
constructed of any material that is subject to corrosion or be proposed with SS 304 material
heat degradation. No galvanized metal is allow (D&C
(HW : Stainless Steel is acceptable)
Standards Section 2516.02E)

299009078.xls

2 / 14

NO.

4.

COMMENTS

Air Conditioning Installation


- Temperature design conditions are +/- 1C (2F) and +/5% RH (D&C Standards Section 2514.06)
- For temperature design of various areas, refer to D&C
Standards Section 2514.06 for detail

REMARKS

temperature condition to be comply with 1C, but for


RH with tropical location and near to beach area will be
maintained at 10%.
To be comply

- For VRF system, the following safety requirement must


comply:
a. Design all refrigeration systems and machinery
rooms to comply with ASHRAE Standards 15 and 34

To be study and comply.

b. For variable refrigerant flow system that use R-410a


in guestrooms, the room volume calculations must
include the following requirements:

299009078.xls

3 / 14

NO.

COMMENTS

1.

Room volume must be reduced from the entire


floor-to-ceiling measurement, and calculated
based upon the floor-to-bed height or 915mm,
whichever is higher

To be study and comply.

2.
3.

Room volume must exclude toilet room


Room volume must exclude the volume of any
fixed or portable case work

To be comply in calculation
To be comply in calculation

4.

Disregard any exhaust air flow out of the toilet


room and any supply air into the guestroom
from other ventilation systems

To be comply in calculation

5.

Accessible rooms must reduce the allowable


refrigerant volume by 50% of non-accessible
rooms

To be comply in calculation

6.

Refrigerant piping must not be routed in egress To be consider and comply as posiibble in refrigerant
corridors where accidental discharge may occur piping design.

7.

When the above requirements are unobtainable, To be consider with maintained the quantity of possible
an alarming device must be provided within
refrigerant leakage to room in below maximum safety
each guestroom for detection of a refrigerant
standard.
leak. In no case must the audible alarm be less
than 75 dBA at the pillow level in all
guestrooms, with intervening doors closed
during the alarm

c. Submit written documentation that indicates


compliance with safety codes for review by Hilton
Worldwide
- Ducted FCU must be used for all area. Wall mounted
units are not allowed

299009078.xls

REMARKS

To prepare and submit.

All guest room and public area will be use FCU with
ducting. For BOH and service area to be proposed with
Wall mounted type.

4 / 14

NO.

COMMENTS

5.

Vertical Transportation Installation


- Based on the drawings from Architect, 2 guest lift and 2
service lift was provided which is different from your
concept report. Clarification is required
- For time interval and waiting time, refer to D&C
Standards Section 2509.01 for requirement

REMARKS

Quantity type mistaken in concept report. Lift quantity


will be 2 units for passenger and 2 units for services.

To be comply

6.

Electrical Installation
- Redundant primary transformers that have 100%
Designed with 1 unit transformer only, the capacity
building load capacity is required (D&C Standards Section 120% from electrical connection demand. Provided
2514.08)
with 100% backup of generator set.

7.

Lighting Illuminate
- Lux level requirement need to comply with D&C
Standards Section 2514.08I

299009078.xls

To be comply

5 / 14

NO.

COMMENTS

8.

Telephone Installation / Data Installation


- I will forward you the D&C Standards for IT in a separate
email. Kindly refer to the standards for compliance

9.

Fire Alarm System


- Fully addressable system is required (D&C Standards
Section 2516.04C)

REMARKS

To be study and comply.

Proposed with Semi Addressable system, guest room to


provide with addressable detector and for bigger
room / public area provided with several conventional
detector as zoning area with an address for every zone
(HW : Public area should be fully addressable,
guestroom can be local hard wired single station)

- Smoke detector in the guestroom must be sounder based To be comply


with 75dBA at pillow level (D&C Standards Section
2516.04D)
10.

11.

299009078.xls

Sound System
- System operation matrix is required for review. Refer to
D&C Standards Section 2516.04E for sample

To be study and comply.

Lightning Protection

6 / 14

NO.

12.

COMMENTS

REMARKS

Others
- Security room and FCC
- IT room

- Towel area

- Water Pond

- Access Control
- Fire Staircase

299009078.xls

7 / 14

MEETING COMMENT 10 July'14 @HGI office


Singapore

For basins at Public Toilet only. The basins will use


automatic sensor and thermostatic mixing valve to
automatically mix between cold and hot water.
Grease trap will not maintained with vehicle. The
operasional proses will be use bag to collect grease
from grease trap, then throw it to wet garbage. Grease
trap to be prepared inside room with proper mechanical
ventilation.
To be study with alternative accoustic pipe. This pipe
should be resist when mechanical cleaning do to this
pipe.

Concealed Sprinkler will be use for public area and


guestroom foyer area.

Standard guest bathroom is below 5.1 m2, not required


sprinkler. Only for public toilet and Suite guest
mainbathroom will be protected with sprinkler.

299009078.xls

8 / 14

MEETING COMMENT 10 July'14 @HGI office


Singapore
Kitchen hood protect with water assist suppression
system which connected to general sprinkler pipe
system. Need coordination with Kitchen specialist.
Another thing shall discuss with kitchen specialist, that
the condensor of refrigerator to be air cooled.

Electrical switchroom will not provide with sprinkler.


Only prepare with portable fire extinguisher.

Ok

Ok

Kitchen exhaust duct will be use Stainless Steel SS 304.

299009078.xls

9 / 14

MEETING COMMENT 10 July'14 @HGI office


Singapore

Ok.

Ok.

Ok.

299009078.xls

10 / 14

MEETING COMMENT 10 July'14 @HGI office


Singapore

Refrigerant Gas Detector will be use. Just required with


individual system, not necessary to have centralized.

Ok.

All area will be use VRF system with duct type air
distribution.

299009078.xls

11 / 14

MEETING COMMENT 10 July'14 @HGI office


Singapore

Ok.

Ok.

HGI proposed with dry type transformer for safety and


maintenance free reason.

Ok.

299009078.xls

12 / 14

MEETING COMMENT 10 July'14 @HGI office


Singapore

Ok.

Full Addressable for all area. Detector will be use


addressable type. For guestroom detector should
sounder based type, and it's power use hard wire
normal cable (NYM).

Ok.

Ok.

To be use Electrostatic type (EF). Only use 1 pole to


protect all area.

299009078.xls

13 / 14

MEETING COMMENT 10 July'14 @HGI office


Singapore

Manager Security room and FCC located inside the


same room (Security Room)
Inside IT room are Manager IT room and Server room.
MDF/PABX located inside Server room.
Provided with emergency telphone (red colour head
set). There are other area should be provide with
emergency telphone, to be refer to D&C standard.
Pond will have fish koi inside. Water circulation system
shall be provide with filter and no chlorine treatment
allow.
Access control to be provide at door lobby to swimming
pool, and for each door of cooridor.
Not required pressurized fan, just open staircase wall to
open air.

299009078.xls

14 / 14