Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AGENDA
Review
Common Issues
Practice Grading
Presentation Scoring
Pauses
3
2-3
2-2
Voice inflection
Visual aids
2-1
1-2
1-1
Regardless
Common Issues
in Critical
Rebuttal
6
Example
Motion
Complete stance
Properly
paraphrased
stance
Example
Motion
SOT claim
Unclear claim
Example
Motion
Short answer I
Short answer II
Very unclear
stance
School uniforms.
COT answer
Grading
Scores
Claim: Agree
Support 1: Agree
Support 2: Agree
Details
Rebuttal
1
1
1
2-1
0
Claim: Agree
Support 1: Disagree
Support 2: Disagree
Details
Rebuttal
1
Normal
Normal
Normal
Normal
Claim: Disagree
Support 1: Agree
Support 2: Agree
Details
Rebuttal
3
2
2
Normal
Normal
10
Grading
Scores
Claim: Agree
Support 1: Disagree
Support 2: Agree
Details
Rebuttal
2
2
3
Normal
Normal
Claim: Disagree
Support 1: Agree
Support 2: Disagree
Details
Rebuttal
3
2
3
Normal
Normal
11
Example
First, the speaker says that most math competition winners are
of Asian descent. However, I strongly believe that most math
competition winners are not Asians. (support only, without
details)
First, the speaker says that most math competition winners are
of Asian descent. However, this is not true. (support). There
are a lot of math competition winners from western
countries. (detail)
First, the speaker says that most math competition winners are
of Asian descent. However, I dont agree with this. (support
only, without details)
13
QUICK EXERCISES
Motion
Main Ideas
14
QUICK EXERCISES
Grading
Ops
R1
R2
Det
Sample Response
I am now rebut the woman. She said capital
punishment has a long history. I agree with that. In
Korea kill criminals in the past. That is very good. And
that is make good society, no criminals! And cheaper
to kill prisoners. I dont like prisoners. So I think not
favor of capital punishment. Thank you for listening!
Reb
Notes
15
QUICK EXERCISES
Grading
Sample Response
Ops
R1
R2
Det
2.3
Reb
Notes
Structure
Opinion
16
QUICK EXERCISES
Motion
Main Ideas
17
QUICK EXERCISES
Grading
Sample Response
Ops
R1
R2
Det
Reb
Notes
18
QUICK EXERCISES
Grading
Sample Response
Ops
Support 1
Support 2
Det
2.3
Reb
Notes
Details
Rebuttal
19
Common Issues
in ListeningBased Speech
20
Example
Prompt
Improper opinion
Incomplete
opinion
I like to do BCI.
Prompt + short
answer
SOT opinion
Unclear opinion
21
Example
Prompt
Short answer I
Of course!
Short answer II
Maybe.
Very unclear
stance
It is 4D movies.
COT answer
22
MISSING OPINION
Sample prompts
Giga (C2-Wk1)
Mega (C2-Wk2)
Mega (C2-Wk4)
Giga (C2-Wk5)
Please read the topic guides first since many templates seem to be
opinions themselves.
23
SCORING DETAILS
Point
Example
2-3
2-2
24
SCORING DETAILS
Point
Example
2-2
2-1
More and more teenagers are getting plastic surgeries. First, plastic
surgery would make them beautiful. Second, many teens dont
want to get bullied.
25
SCORING DETAILS
Situation
Resolution
R1 = Normal
R2 = 0
Dets = 2.1
R1 = Normal
R2 = 0
Dets = 2.2
R1 = Normal
R2 = Normal
Dets = 2.1
R1 = Normal
R2 = Normal
Dets = 2.1
26
Did the
student add
student add
a detail to
an
at least one
irrelevant
reason?
detail?
Did the
Were both
Did the
Did the
student
reasons
student add
student add
explain
given a
a personal
an SOT
both
detail?
experience?
detail?
reasons
sufficiently?
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
No
No
No
Yes
Yes
Start
No
Yes
No
4.1
4.2
2.3
2.2
2.1
27
PARTIALLY-RELEVANT VS IRRELEVANT
DETAILS
Do you agree that living in a small town is better than living in a big city? Give two
reasons to support your answer.
I would want to live in a city. Because it's surrounded by
tall buildings.
There is a lots of people in the city and restaurant too. But
living in a city can be sick because it has a bad air like a
car, engine, or trucks like that.
Being in inside the city, parks can be intersting.
When you go out, you can see cars and bikes move and if
you opened the car window you can hear birds chirp an
motorcycle roaring. Moreover, I like eating ice cream, too.
28
QUICK EXERCISES
Prompt
Sample Response
Do you think
invisibility cloaks
would be more
*beneficial or more
*dangerous?
29
QUICK EXERCISES
Grading
Sample Response
Ops
R1
R2
Det
2.2
Notes
R1
Det
30
QUICK EXERCISES
Prompt
Sample Response
31
QUICK EXERCISES
Grading
Sample Response
Ops
R1
R2
Det
2.2
Notes
Ops
R1
32
QUICK EXERCISES
Prompt
Sample Response
Do you think
companies should be
allowed to advertise
in schools?
33
QUICK EXERCISES
Grading
Sample Response
Ops
R1
R2
Det
4.2
Notes
Ops
Det
Practice Grading
Actual responses
35
Motion
Main Ideas
1.
2.
36
Transcription
886720
For example, they can sell something new for people and they can
give tips in daily life. Secondly, they help make up people's minds.
If people can't buy what they want, they lose credibility to buy
something new. Lastly, you said they give misleading statistics and
they make false claims. But when people watch or see an
advertisement, they'll surely consider credibility and suspect an
exaggeration. In this reasons, I think governments should not
regulate advertisements.
37
886720
Claim
Correct
Rationale
Support 1
Support 2
speaker's opinion.
Details
2-3
Rebuttals
Comprehensibility
Presentation
both supports.
Rebuttals should be 1: The
students third Support
attempts to rebut the
38
Motion
Main Ideas
1.
2.
39
Transcription
889895
No, fast... fast food can advertisements. First, fast/fat food is just
customer's choice. For example, when I want to eat fast food, we
can give money to them and eat. But that not companies' fault.
They know fast food is bad but they eat it, so
theres/theyres/theirs fault. Second, fast food can easy to eat. Its
comfortable and it needs just short times. It is easy to eat. In
conclusion, I talk about fast food advertisement should not be
allowed on TV.
40
889895
Correct
Rationale
Claim
Support 1
Support 2
Details
2
2-3
allowed/should be allowed to
advertise.
Support 2: The support does not
clearly relate to the idea that fast
Rebuttals
Comprehensibility
Presentation
2.1
41
Motion
Main Ideas
1.
2.
3.
42
Transcription
970316
..dont think that family history is the biggest factor for the
success. Because firstly, if you just try hard, we do not need family
history. Because the family history exactly you don't need it. And I
think try harder, trying harder is more important than family
history. And also secondly, they says that family history equals the
DNA but one's smarts, smartness is more important than the
familys DNA.
43
970316
Claim
Correct
Rationale
Support 1
Support 2
Details
2-2
Rebuttals
Comprehensibility
Presentation
2-1
the ideas.
44
TRPs
kids
3. use different marketing techniques
at schools
4. provide materials and supplies
5. sponsor contests or programs
45
Transcription
952604
46
952604
Correct
Rationale
Claim
Comprehensibility: The
Reason 1
Reason 2
Details
2-2
Comprehensibility
Presentation
logical manner.
47
TRPs
tattoo
3. think about the risks
4. may cause an infection
5. do not let young people get
tattoos
48
Transcription
1020358
49
1020358
Claim
Correct
Rationale
Opinion: missing.
Reason 1: The idea that
Support 1
Support 2
Details
4-1
Comprehensibility
Presentation
2
2-2
50
TRPs
tattoo
3. think about the risks
4. may cause an infection
5. do not let young people get
tattoos
51
Transcription
1044144
52
1044144
Correct
Rationale
Claim
Reason 1
Reason 2
Details
0
2-2
TRPs.
Reason 1 (2): The first part of the
statement It has become very
popular but we think about the
risks supports the idea that it is
Comprehensibility
Presentation
2-1
53
54