You are on page 1of 22

c

cccc

cccccccc c
ccc
ccc

ccccccc c
c
cc


cc c c c


cc
c
c cc c ccc c
 c
 cc c c c c c c c
 c
c


c 

c
c c 
 c
 cc


c

!c c" 
 c c c

 c
c!  c
c c ! !ccc


c c c ! !ccc

c
#$c c
 cc c

c %
 c
c

 cc

c c
ccc cc cc
c c  c %
 c 
!c  c
c c
!
!c  c
c c&c  c c


!cc c%
c c c % c  
c
 cc
c c' c c c
c
cc c 
c c( c"  c


 c  c

c
)c c
 c c
 cc c 
!
 c
c c"  c
 
c 
c*+ cc, c c
 c
c
 c cc c
 ccc c c


 c cc 
cc cc c-  c
 c  cc c


c- c, c c c


cc c c 
c c c
c
(c c c c cc c c%  c


 c c
c c c 
!c ..
!c 
!
 c

c c( c"
c!
%
!cc
 c
 
 c


/c
vMithraism and Christianityvcc0) c  c
1*22*3c
@  
     

 

 


     
       

 

     

  
 
       


 

  
    

 
 
 
 



  
  
   
!    
    
 
    
    
   
 

     
    
 
 

  
 
     
  
" 

  
  # 
  
     
   
 



 
  $

   
 
ñ   
" c

c c


c c 
!c4 ! c
 c
c 
c c
c . 
!c c5c c6 c
  c c  cc c

c c! c
%
 c c
 
c c c cc 
c
  c


 c  c


c c c c 
!
 c
%c
 c c c %
 ccc"
c
c c

c c%
 c c c)  c
c ccc c
 c
  c   c4
cc
c c! ccc
c c  c

!c

c
 7c
"
c c .   c c  ! 
 c
c
c
c%
 c c
c c    c c

  cc


ccc ! c
c c c


 c
c cc4
8ccc c! ccc
c c   c4
8c

 cc 
c

!c
% c
c 

  cc c

c

 cc"   c c"
c   c 
c
 cc c
 % c c 
 c

c
c
9) 
c#c $c c
!cc  c c c c

c c4 ! c  c 
c
% cc c
!c
c  
!c! cc"
c
c :

c
c

c 
 c4
c  c  c c   c
c;2c
"c
ccc*2c c c cc c
c c 

)
 c#$c c   c c c! cc
c  c

!c c
c% 
 cc c4 ! c
 
c#$c<c c c  c c   c c
c c c  c c
c
% cc c
4   c c c c c-  c#$/c
vO   v    
   

"
c
 8 c c  c4
c c

!c*2c c
c c cc c   c % c 

 c
%
 c  c  .. .

c
c4 !
c
 c  c

c c


c
c  cc
 c
c
c.c
cc
%c c  c c=c
  c
ccc  c
 8 c %c  
!c c
c c  c  8 c   c
!c
c
c c

c
 cc ! c c c  cv4
c c
c c
  c  c c   c c c


cc
c 
cc,
 
c c c ccc
 c c cc c(c- cc: cc
! c
4 ! c c
c 

 c c vc c
%c
v  c  c!  c
!. cc4 ! c c
c
  c9) 
vc
 c cc c c cc c


c
c
c  c


c c 

c
c c6 c
  c5 c
c c c   c c
 8 c c
 c c cc


c c  !c

c
c

c c . c !
c-c
c c c   c
c c c
c
  c c
c c cc



c c c c
  cc 
c 
!
 c c
 . c c  c 
!cc 
c c 
!
 c c

 c
  cc


c
c !c
c c

  cc4 !
c c c c>  c
c c6 c
  cc c  c c
!
c


c  cc
% c
 c c! cc ! c c c

c? c
  8 c c c
c  c c c 
c
 c c c
5
c
c
c;@2"c c
c cc c
 c
  cc


cc
 % c c c! c c
c"

c   c
 c! c  c6 c   c



c : c c 
c

 
  
 ! 
"

"

c

c
%c  c c c
cA c
 c ccBc

!c c-  c c



 c c c c9c c c  
 c- c
4 c cc c  cc


c cc ! c
 cc
c  c %c cc cA c
c  c cc
 %c c
%cc c c c  cc
c c c  c

c
 c"

c ccc c
!
c

7c
cc
%c  cc c c
c c
 c c!  c  c c8"

8c
 c
cc c c  c c
c c

c
ccc c c c•aulinec

c
c c"

c   c
 %
!c c c
 

!c  c 
c
c
 c9  c c c
 
c
! cc9) 
c c c  c

 cv .  vc  c c!  c ! c !


 c
c"

c cc c 
c c !
 c c
 c c c
   
!cc 
c
c c
 c
."

c 
c c
c

c
#"  c*22C$c4 
c

c 
c c
"

c
!c cc 
cc1  c %
%3c
c 
!c c 
!c cc
c  c c
 c c
cAc*7C*c c*76Dc cc c

c c c8  8cccc  c
c
c  c cc
c c c
cAcC7**c c
c
c c

c   c
c"

c
c  ccadoptedc
c4 
c

c c  .
c( c
 
c c c c
  c  c  c
c
ccc cc c%
!
c1
c  c( c .
.!3c 
!c cc c    c c c!

!c
c c c %c 
c
c c
c c c
c % cc  c c"

c c  c
% c c c 
c c  c c
!
c  
!c
c c cAc c c"

c



c  c  c c4 
c


c  c c
< c c

c
?cc c c!c
c! c c c c   c
c c!ccc %c c!c
c c c
"

c  c  c c4 
c

cc
 !  c  c c c c
E   c c%
 c! c c
c
  c c
c
c
4 
c


c  c c c! cc c
( c"
c9  c c c   c c"

c
 c% F
/c
v{st Century Christian Ebionites: The Original
Christians?vcc0) c  c1*22@3c

 #
 

!$ 
"
9c
c


c! c c%c
c c
  cc c c ! c  
 c cc: c c
 cc c c
c 
 
c
c!c c c
  c  
%cccc c  
!c c
 c5 cc c  c c  c c  c c!c
9

c
c c .


c
cc c
c c  c c!cc? c
c  c  c
adoptionismc c  c  cmonotheisticc
 c? c c

cc cnegativec

 c1  c!
cc
8 ccc c
c c c c 3c?cc c
c1
c  3c9
c  
c c  cc
c c %cc


!c
c9 !c9
.
 
!c !
c)
 c c c  c   c
  c
c c c c
c
cc  
 c
  c c 
c   c? c c 
c   c
! cc
9) 
c c!   c !
cc
c
c c
  c  c c>  c c   c  c c- c 
c


 c c  c c   c
c

 c   c
c c
 c  c9
c1*+@.CC@"3c? c c
cc9  
cc c c=
 c

c
 cC*+"c? c c( c"
c9
c


c
 c cc
 c=
 c


cc c
+ c   c c 
c c c c cc



c  ! c c
c  
!c c
c

c cD c   c#$c
c%  c%
 cc c  
c=
 c
c
 cCD2"c c  c c c"
c  c c



c  c c c
c c c c%
 c
 
c c  c
c  c  c
 c5c c c
 c   c c  !
 c( c 
c c
 c !c c
cc c

c c c
 c c c% !c%
 cc=
 c



c c
cc cc%
c9
.


c c!
% c
c

c
 c c
c
=
 c c c c c cc
c  c c cc
 c? F

 c! c %

!c 
!
c
c
 
!c%

c c

  c   c c

c) 
 c c

!c c
%c c
! c 
!c

c cc 
c 
 c c !c

c


c
c c;222. c !c c !c?c c9
c
 c %
%c c  ! c c c c 
!
 c  c
c"
c c
ccc %c c c
c c



c  cc %c c c!
!c! cc
c?   c c=
 8c%
 c c
 c
 c c c c8 !cc
8c  c  c  c

c c c
 c
c c
  c   /c
vÃrian Christianityvcc0) c  c1*22D3c

cc 
c

7c<
c 
c c c

c  c c) c c c c

c c

c cc c
c
c! 
c
c !c
c . c

c cc% c*22c c
c   c c c 
cc c= c  c
 cc
 8 c  c)
 c c c c

 cc c 
 c 
c 
 c
c
 c
c c c 
c
c c   c
 cc
 
c c c> cGc c
cc4 
c'c( c

7c< c c( .
 c
 cc


c c
c cc
c
 c  cc


c c
 % c
c 
c  c  c c"

c c 
c .
 c c 
c .

c  c c c
c
% c cc
% c
c c c c


c  c c c c  c% .

 c

c
c c

 c c c
c cc


c  cc %c

c
 c c( c"
c
c c c c



c
!
c c c c c
 

 c c  
.=
 c4 
c



c c 
c
!c
c1 cc %c
%c c c
3
,
!c c
 c  c

c  
c c
c
c
c c  !ccc c %c


c cc%
c  c  c c
  c
  c( c 
c4


%c5 
 c c
-% ., c9%
 c cc 
 c cc
c
 c cc


c c   c c
c
c c c  c
? c c  c c 
c  
c  c cc  c


cc
%c
c cc5 c  c c
  cc

 c  c  c c c-c
c  c
 c 
c  c 
c  c cC@+/c
vJost Christianitiesvcc5 c"  c1*22C3;c



 c
 
c
c 
!cc


c c cc
c c  !
c c% c!  c  !c  c
c c
  ! c c c%
 cc c  c
c c c
% c c c /c

v@istory of Western •hilosophyvcc5 c(c


1;H6@3*c
? c c
 cc  
c"c  c  c
 c c c 
!c c8 c 8c c 
!c

 cc
c cA
 
 c c /c
vOesus Mysteriesvcc> cGc c#5c
(%
$c1;HHH3Cc
-c c c c
!
c
 c cc



c
c< c  c c c<c

cIc
% &
 
 ' ( ")
  
 

" *
v4t •aul - @istory, Jetters, Influences and Instructions;
Gnosticism and Mithraismvcc0) c  c1;HHH3c
 c! 
c

 c c
c"

c c
c% c
 c

cc c
 c   c
c

c c
c c 
%c c 
c c


c
 cc c
c4 
c


c
 c
c c

 c
c c c
 c c  ! c!
c c . 
!c
c
c

c 
!c c cc c c
%  c c?  
!c
 
c  ! c
 c  % c  cc c4 
c

c c
 cc
c 
!c 
c
 c

  
 cc



c
!
c 
c 
!c
  c!c
 c
c c! 
. c

c
<
c( c c
c 
c

!c c c c
 % cc"  c c4 
.=
 c

c

c c c! 
c

 c c9
c   c !c
c 
! c c  c c c c


c c c  c c c c %c
%c c cc

c

c c( c
"
c c c
c 
c cc c8 %8cc c

c   c c c  !c c  c
  
c  c  c cc-

c c c
! c c  c c

c
c c 

c
c

c c c=
 c ccCD;c
c c c c
 ! c c
 
c !
 c8 8c"  c

c
c c
cc c
c

 cc c  .=


 c c 
c cc 
c
 
 c
c c< c c% c c  c c c c
+ c   c
,
c c  cc 

 c  c c)
 c


c
% 
cc
 + (, 
& ( ,
 &   


" c  c c c cc c



c

!
 c  c c  c
c %
c4 ! c
  c 
!
 c
c cc c 
!
c
  cc


c9c cc8c
c
 c c c% c  c
c
c c c


 c c   c cc c c
  
!c  c!. cc c
c4
 c
 c c c  c
!c %c

c c


 c  c
c  c c
 c 
!
 c
c
c
c c  

!c  cc


 c>
 c   c

cc


c
%
c 
 c  c


c c  
!c
 c   c cc  c 
!
 c

!     

 
 #   
  


       
   #        
 
# 


 %
 
    
   & 

  ' 
 

 (
       

  #   

  
       


   (       
   

 
           

  
 
   

  

 )%

   
  

 
 

 *#   

   


 
  
  
 

   
       +
   

 
  

         
  
   
 

    
,  
 
   

    
   
   
  & 
@      
$ & &   
    
 
-./0%
120%1
   
 
       

  $ 
& &     

 
 
 
#  
  @   
       


#  
    


 
  #  
  
   

c c 
 c
c  c c
%  c .

 cc 
!
c 
c  c % c c c

 c
c: cc
c c%
c
c

 c

c c c  c
c c c c c

  c c%
 c  c
c
c
c c
c% c cc c=c ! c
c
c


cc c
)
c

 c   c#$c


? c  c c c c% cc c, c- c
- c
c  c cc %
c c! 
c  ) c
 c c c c c


c> c) c
c cc: cc
  c c c
)
 c c !
!c c c %
!c
c
 !cc c  c
c c  c  c c c
 cc 
!c 
c  c c) c
cc 
c
c
c c cc
c c
 c c % c  c c)
 c c
c c
c  c c cc c c c

 c
 c c
c
c
c cF  c
c  /c
9c

c  c ! c  c  c c 
c



c% c c
c c cc
 c
 c c !  c
 
 c
c c
c c 
!
c  

 c
c  c  c
c c c
cc


c#c  c $c c



 c  c cc
%c c cJ c
) c c c  c c %
c
 
!c c
c

c   c c
c c  c c
 c c
F cc cK c% c? c

c   c c c  c  c c  c  c


 c c
 c  c  c c cc
 c 
c c  c  c c ccc

!
c ! !c c
c cc c
  c
c! c
c %c !c
c

  /c
vÄead 4ea 4crollsvcc-  c!c1*22;3&c


  
#,"&
 -.

,  /&) 
.  
  ( ,
 &
c c  c c ! c 
!
 c c cc c
 c c
c c
c c

cc  c


c c  c c c8
c


 8c
!
c c c c ! c  c c,%
c
 c  c c ! c 
!
 cc  ccc

c  c


c c: c c%c cc
c c 
c= c !c  c1c
cc c
- 8c
3c c ! c 
!
 c c  c
c c  c


c? c  c c!c c
 ! c 
!
 c
c  c c  cc


c
 c % 
!cactualc


c

 c= c84 ! c
  c

c c !c c c c 
 c c
c8c
c4   c    c5
c<  c
c,  c
c c ! c c  
!c
% c !c
c c 
!cc
%
c c
   c  
c8 c %c c

 c  
 c
  c c c c
c %
 8c c
c ccc c  c c !c c
  c
c ccc
 8c  
!cL
!c
! c  c
c 
c
c c
c c c

 
c
c c
%
/c
vThe Triumph of the Moon: à @istory of Modern •agan
Witchcraftvcc4 c(c  c1;HHH3Dc
E   c
cc  c c c ! c c c
 .  c?c  c
c c ! 
 cc c
c
 c
c

c  c


c
c
c  c c
c
 c? c c) c 
c cc c c c
 
!cc c  c  cc c cc?c

c ! 
%c c 
c  c


c

c cc: cc c 


!.  c c   c

!
 c

 
   
 
   

   
c cc %c c c c c 
 cc
 
cc c 
!c c
c  c
c
 c c c

c c
c

 
c  c5 c 
c  c
cc
c c

c 
cc c)
!c cactualc

c c
%c<  c c  cc)
 c c
c  c  c
c c 
c  c c
! 
 c   c
cc)
  c c c

%c
c
c c c  c  c9 !c- c
4 c  c) c
c c! 
c
c c
c c


!c c   c !c% c
 c
c
c  !c
 
 c c
c c  c
c
c
c

c5
c c
 cc c

c
 cc

c ) c c c) cc c  c
 c c
 c : c c  c
 
 c



c5c c6 c   c c4 
c


c c%
 c  c 
c%

 cc c
 c
 
cc


c c c

 
!c
 
 c c   c  
c %c
 c c

!cc   
 c


c

c c  c c5

c 
c c
 c c
% c


4 8c
 c cc&cc c5cc c
5
c9c
)c c c
 c
c4 8c c
c  c c1
cc cc
%c c ) c
 c
 c% cD2c c   c4 8c 3c
 c c;Cc
 c1
 3c
c c

c
c c5
c  c c cc4 c
c  
c

!c c! 
c  c c
  c c ) c c c
 
 c c

!

/cc
v4t •aul - @istory, Jetters, Influences and
Instructions; Gnosticism and Mithraismvcc
0) c  c1;HHH3c
 c
  cc


c.c c c c c c
c  c.c
c c
  cc c!  c c% c
  c
   
!cc c
!
c

/c
v c9

 vcc>

c=
  c1;DDD3Hc
h +    ' #),


c

cc c* c   c c c c 
 c
% c 
c cc


c c  c  c
 
c c4 

c1 cc
 3c c

 cc c c c5!
cogomilscc
c

c 
!c c c c5 c c5!
c c

cc   c c? c c> c c 
c! 
.

!c
c
c c c
c  c

 c c
 
!c c c c
 ! cc c 
c c c c 
cc
c c
- cc> c c  c  c c9
! c# 
c

$c c
cc
c=  c? c c
c c- c
c> c c ccc c!  c :
c#$c c c
c 
c
c

 cc c c c
 
 c c
c
 cc c  c c
c c
! c c c
  c c
 cc c  !c#$c c c c
c
c !c Bc% c c
 c c! c
 c
#$c c c c c 
c  cc 
!
c
!  c c c
cc c cc c   c
  c 
 c c   c#$c
? cc  c c 
c c 
 c c  c
c c
 
c c  
 c cc   c% c c

c
 !c c cc
!c % c
c c=c
  c c ! c  c c
c%
c c

%c  c c c%
c  c
c c  
 cc c
c c
c% c
c c 
!
 c
c
c
cc
 c c 
c!  c c c%!
c


!c% c c!!c c c
c c c
c
% c c c
%c  c
c c  c) c
!  c9c)c c   c c c#$c c  c
c=c   c c
 c  c
c c )Bc c

c c c c  c c  c /c
v@istory of Western •hilosophyvcc5 c(c1;H6@3;2c