ii

What people are saying about Marketing the Church:
"This book is about understanding our culture and how to communicate the gospel effectively to people. The church needs to pay close attention to things like their website, name, logo, etc. Do these things help or enhance our ability to reach our culture? If not, are we willing to do whatever it takes to be effective communicators of truth?" Ron Sweet Pastor First Evangelical Free Church "All truth is God's truth and Marketing The Church takes wise concepts that are working in the corporate world and hands them to the local church. Mr. Daehn's ingenious book empowers the church to become a better steward, investing our God-given talents for that day when He returns to take account." Heath Vogel Pastor Washington Christian Church "In Marketing the Church, Michael Daehn has done a wonderful job of presenting the basic principles by which congregations and para-church ministries can present themselves and the saving message of Christ to contemporary cultures. Combining biblical perspectives with the best insights from current marketing research, Marketing the Church is thoughtful, entertaining, and at points, disturbing. It is a valuable read for Christian leaders." Dr. Mike Pabarcus Academic Dean, Professor Saint Louis Christian College

iii

"I find the book well balanced and insightful, putting to rest peoples qualms about combining marketing and ministry." Tony Deerfield Bass Player Skypark (Music Group) "This was my second round of reading the marketing book, so I found myself looking for the new information section (for churches). It was easy to find and apply the information. Job well done. " Dr. Kendall Brune Director of Development Saint Louis Christian College "God has made many tools, talents and resources available for churches to communicate to a modern audience. This book shows you how to sell the message, without selling out... " William Good Communications Pastor West County Christian Church

iv

v

vi

vii

viii

Marketing the Church: How to Communicate Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context Michael Daehn
Michael@MarketingeTheChurch.com

www.MarketingTheChurch.com

Special Thanks to Douglas Lay for editing the text Cover Design by Nexdesign Studios www.NexdesignStudios.com

ix

Scripture Quotations from
The Message by Eugene H. Peterson, copyright (c) 1993, 1994, 1995, 1996, 2000, 2001, 2002. Used by permission of NavPress Publishing Group. All rights reserved.

Marketing the Church: How to Communicate Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Copyright © 2007 by ShineFish Books. All rights reserved. 328 Bellezza St. Louis, MO 63021

x

For Michael J. Daehn (Dad)

xi

xii

Table of Contents
Foreword………………………………………………17 Preface………………………………………………....19 Introduction…………………………...…………….…23 Key 1 Find Your Advantage………………….………...25 Key 2 Define Your Purpose……...…………………….47 Key 3 Create an Image…………………………...….….69 Key 4 Implement Promotions…..…………………........93 Key 5 Build Relationships…….…………………...…..147 Key 6 Gain Feedback………...………………….……169 Key 7 Adjust to Changes…………………………...…185 Conclusion…...……………………...….…….……….191 Church Marketing Resource Guide…………………....193

xiii

xiv

xv

Marketing the Church

16

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Foreword
You hold in your hands the first book of its kind, a blend of the sacred and the secular, marketing businesses and marketing the Church. Are the two compatible? The Seven Keys to Marketing Genius: The Complete Guide to Increasing Your Marketing IQ was my first book, and I was trying to think of a way to get churches to use this same information to become more effective at communicating their message of evangelism. I was struggling with how to re-write the whole book especially for churches, should I remove all of the non-church specific information? As I sat praying in my backyard one day, the answer came to me, you don’t have to re-write the whole book, instead add to the book you have, make it better and incorporate notes, examples and applications specifically for churches. “Great, thanks Lord,” I said and started working. Up to that point I felt God tugging at me to get this book written. It has been a goal since I wrote the original Seven Keys text. Since then I have worked with several churches and Christian organizations. Thanks to their real world input this book is much better than it would have been alone. This is a marketing book with an explanation of how marketing principles apply to churches. It is not what I consider a Church Growth book. Church Growth is another discipline and there are folks much better qualified to speak on the topic than me. They can tell you how many chairs to have in the auditorium and how many parking spaces you need to increase attendance. The focus of this book is more on communicating who you are to the outside world. As you read you will notice sections highlighted with gray background like this one: these are the sections added with information specifically for marketing churches. The nonhighlighted sections are from the original text. To get the most from this book you should read both sections together in succession. The information will flow better and make more sense. Several sections are focused on applying the information specifically to your church but will not make sense apart from the standard text. Since you
17

Marketing the Church

have read this far, I am challenging you to finish the journey. I guarantee there is information in this book that will help your church communicate better, and I know God has a word for you personally on how to become better at evangelism. Michael Daehn St. Louis, MO April 2007

18

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Preface
Should you be reading this book? If you are involved in the Church in any of the following ways: □ Pastor/Preacher □ Minister □ Member □ Childcare worker □ Small group leader □ Small group member □ Church attendee □ Janitor □ You are a Christian □ You would like to become a Christian □ You know Christians You should be reading this book. It will give you a better understanding of the purpose of the Church and your role in helping that come to fruition. Should the Church use Marketing? The first question that comes to mind is whether marketing belongs in the Church at all. There are many people today saying the Church needs to learn how to market itself and use modern marketing techniques, but is this biblical? Is this an example of the secular creeping into the sacred? What should be the response of the Church? What is the Church? This section is not a theological or denominational treatise; it is a brief summary of the common beliefs foundational to all
19

Marketing the Church

Christians. The Church is a body of believers that holds to the orthodox teachings of the historical Christian Church. This body believes Jesus Christ, the Son of God, came to earth in flesh and blood to teach human beings and to repair the broken relationship between God and Humankind by offering himself as a sacrifice for sin. After burial, Christ rose from the dead and appeared to his disciples before being taken up into heaven. The Church relies on the witness of those who had contact with Christ; they recorded this experience in the Bible. The Church is composed of individuals across the globe who share these orthodox beliefs in common. What is the purpose of the Church? The purpose of the Church is to be the representation of Christ on earth. Members are to go into all the world teaching, preaching, and baptizing others into the name of Jesus Christ: Jesus, undeterred, went right ahead and gave his charge: "God authorized and commanded me to commission you: Go out and train everyone you meet, far and near, in this way of life, marking them by baptism in the threefold name: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Then instruct them in the practice of all I have commanded you. I'll be with you as you do this, day after day after day, right up to the end of the age." (Matthew 28:18-20) The common term used by churches to describe the process of sharing their faith is evangelism. Have you been called? Yes, you have. First, all people are called to a relationship with God through his Son Jesus Christ. But wait, there’s more. As a Christian you are also called to use your unique gifts and abilities (Key 1) to accomplish the great commission by evangelizing and sharing this message with others. Some people speak about having a calling to ministry. The truth is, all Christians are called to ministry in unique ways. Although there is a tendency to split the Church into priests and followers, the Bible says all Christians are priests: But you are the ones chosen by God, chosen for the high calling of priestly work, chosen to be a holy people, God's instruments to do his work and
20

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

speak out for him, to tell others of the night-and-day difference he made for you—(I Peter 2:9) In fact, Biblical references to God’s calling are not to individuals but to his people as a whole, first to the Jewish nation, second to the Church. The Church has been called to a purpose; its members also are called to a purpose. So if you are a Christian, you are already a priest; it is part of your job description. The question is: What sermon are you preaching? What is Marketing? Marketing refers to the process of communicating and delivering a product to a target audience. A product may be a physical good, service, or even a message. The goal of the marketer is to understand the target audience to best implement and sustain communication that continues ongoing relationships (Key 5). Do we have a match? Is there a connection between the Church, which sounds spiritual and theological, and Marketing, which sounds business, like and worldly? At first glance it may not seem so, but that is because of the different terminology being used. But look again. Is there a common denominator between these two pursuits? The core vocation of Christians is to share the Gospel (effectively communicate with people), while the sole purpose of marketing is to effectively share a message (effectively communicate with people.) Purpose of the Church: Effectively communicate with people Purpose of Marketing: Effectively communicate with people Yes, we have a match: effectively communicate with people. Marketers are selling a message. Think of the campaigns for breast
21

Marketing the Church

cancer awareness, The American Lung Association, and antismoking campaigns. The purpose is to get a message across, the same task of the Church. Purpose of this book The purpose of this book is for you to learn from the discipline of marketing how to become more effective at communicating with people. The stakes are much higher than in traditional marketing because the product in this scenario is a message of hope that brings people into relationship with God, grows Christ’s kingdom, and fulfills your calling as a Christian to be faithful to the purpose you have been given. The payoff is having your heavenly Father say to you, “Well done, good and faithful servant!” (Matthew 25:21)

22

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Introduction
So you want to be a marketing genius? It is not as difficult as some say, and you are well on your way since you are reading this book. The Seven Keys to Marketing Genius is certain to increase your marketing IQ whether you are a seasoned professional or a beginner. There are more approaches to marketing than Christian churches have denominations. In the case of churches, each denomination holds certain principles and beliefs in common; that is what makes them Christian. In the same way, there are certain principles that are always involved in the process of marketing. This book will lay the foundation for sound marketing strategy while at the same time challenge common assumptions. It can be fun to take a rebellious approach, but you have to know the rules before you can break them, so keep reading. Many marketing books jump right into the promotion process where instructions on how to broadcast the marketing message are described in detail. The problem with that approach is that if you are sending out the wrong message, it will not only be ineffective but counterproductive. That is why this book begins by creating a sound strategy upon which to base the promotion process. Because what you are communicating is so important, this book starts with defining the message that you are going to broadcast. Key 1: Find Your Advantage outlines a process for determining what advantage your product has over the competition. Having an advantage is core to competing today, but without the right team in place to promote the message, long-term success is doubtful. Key 2: Define Your Purpose helps you set a direction for your company and your product. Once you know where the company is going, Key 3: Create an Image describes the process of communicating an identity and brand to the target audience. The nuts and bolts process of getting the message across to consumers is laid out in Key 4: Implement Promotions. Key 5: Build Relationships tells you how to sustain long-term success and establish protected relationships with customers. To gauge the effectiveness of your marketing efforts, you must use Key 6: Gather Feedback. Since our world is in constant
23

Marketing the Church

flux, it is necessary to use Key 7: Adjust to Changes in order to remain competitive in the marketplace. I hope this book will give you a grasp on the big picture and define a format for thinking about the marketing process. Once you understand the form, I pray you are bold enough to demonstrate your freedom to customize, tweak and bend the rules to suit your purposes. What you do with the information is more important than remembering a list of facts. As Einstein said, “Imagination is greater than memory.” The Seven Keys to Marketing Genius is a springboard to increase your marketing IQ. These concepts are intended to provide fertile soil in your mind in hopes that your own unique ideas will germinate and grow into the next marketing revolution. Note: To get the most out of this book you should get the Companion Guide. This guide provides study questions for each chapter to help reinforce the information. It also contains worksheets and a complete marketing plan outline to help you put your new found genius into action right away. Visit the marketingenious website (www.marketingenious.com) to find out more.

24

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

1
Key 1: Find Your Advantage
All marketing focuses on communicating to customers the advantage of your product over the competition. To compete in the marketplace, you must find what your company or organization offers better than the competition. What unique competitive advantage do you offer? What are the distinctive competencies that separate you from the pack? A SWOT analysis will help you find your advantage. God is Better As a Christian, you already know that what you are presenting, the Gospel, is better than what the competition, the world, has to offer. The challenge is to present the Gospel in a manner that leads the way and is superior to what the world is offering. For example, the majority of Christian t-shirts are copies of brand names or popular phrases such as:

7-11

Playstation
25

Marketing the Church

Coca-Cola

Pepsi-Cola

While I’m glad to see that both Coke and Pepsi are represented, these are still bold face forgeries. This is only a small sampling of what is available, but you get the idea. Some of the shirts are downright inappropriate such as one that says “Get Stoned...Like Paul.” The shirt looks like it is about smoking pot, but wait, it’s actually a biblical reference. I think that works about as well as a Bible themed casino- it’s not a good fit. What messages are these shirts sending? That Christianity is a cheap, unoriginal imitation? That Christians are unaware of or are not concerned with stealing intellectual property? Dozens of Christian t-shirt makers have been sued and/or have gone out of business for copyright violations. Do an internet search of Christian t-shirts and see how many designs are overt copies of popular advertising campaigns. Thou shall not steal. (Exodus 20:15) As followers and promoters of the creator, Christians should be leading the way in creativity and setting the standards of artistic expression. The world should be looking at Christian works in awe. The work of Christians should move others to inquire about their source of inspiration.
26

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

But in your hearts set apart Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect. (I Peter 3:15) Before you can give an answer, you must give people a reason to ask the question. A good example of Christian excellence is the series of Christian children’s videos called Veggie Tales. These stories are done with excellence and have moved from the Christian bookstore to the aisles of Target and Wal-mart. Non-Christian parents are buying these videos for their children because of the quality of the work produced. Well done Veggie Tales creators, you are a model to Christians everywhere. Members Only Christian T-shirts are usually made by Christians for Christians. Non-Christians are not going to understand if you are wearing a shirt depicting a bloody hand with nails in it that says “His Pain, Your Gain.” It is more likely to freak them out than make them want to talk to you. I am glad people are not ashamed to communicate they are believers, but if the purpose is evangelism, this is not an effective means. These shirts tend to make the wearer a part of the Christian club, and they look cool to other Christians, but they are a barrier to communicating with non-Christians. What is more important to you? Alternatives An alternative is to wear shirts with an arbitrary phrase that starts conversations that readily lead into a Christian discussion. When people see these shirts it piques their curiosity and can lead to a meaningful discussion. Check out these shirts by Apologia Share Wear:

27

Marketing the Church

Darwin’s Eyeball

Chemical Love?

unknown god

Nietzsche is Dead

These shirts are creative and original with the intention of starting conversations. (www.apologiasharewear.com)

Channel 24 Syndrome In St. Louis there is a local Christian station on channel 24. I have ambivalent feelings when I flip on this station. The pastor that runs the station can frequently be seen on camera in his 1970’s polyester powder blue suit making appeals for aid to the local homeless population. Programming is comprised of little known syndicated programs interspersed with video footage shot at the local church with the classic 70’s wood paneling in the background. These shows are of well-meaning if untalented individuals who sing hymns and special numbers reminiscent of the performances of William Hung on American Idol. The pastor is a godly man who has done a great deal to help the homeless population in the city, and he has the best of
28

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

intentions. What bothers me is the image of Christians and Christian programming being portrayed. The channel is considered a joke by most people in the community and an example of the lack of quality Christians have to offer. I have seen the same problem in productions by churches and Christian organizations, as long as it is Christian or has the church name on it, it is good enough. They seem to believe people are going to buy the product anyway since it is Christian, so why put the extra effort to recruit or develop talented people to provide a quality product? If you are representing Christ and saying that following him is the better way to live, you should reflect that in your work. Christians should be setting the standard in every way, including artistic expression and professionalism.

SWOT When I suggest organizations perform a SWOT analysis, they usually confuse me with the exterminator. However, the SWOT analysis process is not about swatting insects, but about finding the advantage of an organization or a particular product. SWOT is an acronym that stands for strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. A SWOT analysis is best performed before going to market with a product or developing a new business enterprise. If there is no competitive advantage then it is not likely the company will be sustainable. Many of today’s most successful companies had every piece of strategy written on paper before laying a single brick. It is better to see on paper whether a business is viable before investing valuable time, money, and other resources. Generally companies start off in a haphazard fashion and get to a point where they decide to get more organized. They hire a consultant who recommends going through the process of a SWOT analysis. There is much more at risk for these existing organizations. What if they discover they have no real competitive advantage in the market? For these organizations, a SWOT analysis can be a nerveracking experience because so much is at stake. Should they close
29

Marketing the Church

up shop and go home if they don’t find a competitive advantage? Maybe, or they might decide to shift their strategy to one better suited to their skills. The good news is that many discover, or rediscover, why they have been able to compete to date. The SWOT analysis helps them to regain their focus and concentrate on their core competencies. For those new to the SWOT analysis, a good exercise is to do a personal analysis to determine your individual strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. If you are starting a new company, it is useful to analyze an organization with which you are extremely familiar. This helps you to become comfortable with the process. As you can see, a SWOT analysis can be done on many levels. A SWOT analysis may be performed for an individual, organization, or corporation. Certainly when considering a new product launch, you should use this process for the product itself. In this section I am referring to creating a SWOT analysis for an organization.

Implementing a SWOT Analysis A SWOT analysis can be done on many levels. In my role as a university professor I have my students perform a personal SWOT in order to get a grasp on the concept. They list their individual strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats. I then take them through the process for their school as a whole. I ask for input from the whole class and write their answers on the whiteboard. In organizations that have different departments, I advise having each department perform a SWOT, as well as a SWOT for the whole organization. When creating a SWOT, it is best to get all the stakeholders into a room and create the SWOT together on a whiteboard. For larger organizations when this is not possible, distribute questionnaires to all the stakeholders. Gather the information and create an analysis based on their feedback. A combination approach involves giving questionnaires to all stakeholders and then getting team leaders and managers into a room to create a final version
30

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

based on feedback from the managers’ and the other stakeholders’ input. To begin the SWOT analysis, gather information from as many stakeholders of the company as possible. Stakeholders are any persons who have an interest in seeing the organization succeed. This includes owners, managers, employees, partners and key customers. Once you have identified the stakeholders, present each with a SWOT questionnaire. Next, cull together all their input into a master analysis. The SWOT analysis begins by having stakeholders list the strengths of the organization. These are internal elements that are positives for the organization. Things like products, people, and corporate culture are all strengths. Being first to market with a product, having a well-trained staff and organizational alignment with mission are all strengths. Next, dig deep and honestly consider the weaknesses of the company. Even the strongest organization has weaknesses. It is better to be aware of these weaknesses and address them in the proper manner; otherwise they will fester in the background until they eventually take over and destroy the positives. Weaknesses are internal elements that are negatives for the organization. Weaknesses can also be people, products and corporate culture. Being last to market, a poorly trained staff and organizational misalignment are all weaknesses. Have participants write as many weaknesses as possible, but try to get at least five before proceeding. Typically companies have two extremes when completing this portion. Either the participants are naïve and over positive, or pessimistic and negative. Neither is conducive to a productive analysis. Every company has a weak flank; it is best to understand vulnerabilities and take necessary precautions. On the other hand, do not allow this to become a gripe session for every disgruntled member of the company to complain. Make sure to bring forth realistic and useful information that can help the corporation create an action plan to succeed in the future. The next letter of SWOT stands for the O in opportunity, but we will come back to these at the end and skip to the threats for now. Threats are external and negative environmental factors beyond
31

Marketing the Church

the control of the company. The word threat connotes fear; as well it should, because these external elements have the potential to kill your company. Competition, changing consumer tastes, and copies of your product by others are all examples of a threat. Be honest, what threatens the livelihood of your company? Talk of weaknesses and threats can leave you feeling deflated. Now is the time to turn that frown upside down and look at the many opportunities afforded your organization. Opportunities are positives that result by being proactive and capitalizing on the issue. Go back to the list of strengths, weaknesses, and threats and decide how each can be a positive opportunity. This is an easy task for the strengths, but is more difficult with the weaknesses and threats so you will have to be creative. For example, how can lack of training be an opportunity? Answer: the company can train its people the proper way without their having to unlearn a great deal of information.

SWOT Template To get a template to for a SWOT Analysis and other resources visit the Marketing the Church website (www.marketingthechurch.com). Talent Show Have you ever taken a spiritual gift analysis? Think of it as a SWOT analysis for Christians (there are several free versions available online). Just as companies should take people through an individual analysis, churches should do the same. It also helps to determine the strengths of the organization as a whole. For instance, if 75% of your church members are well suited to a homeless ministry, then it is a good fit for the church to implement such a program. Of course all Christians are called to ministry: But you are a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people belonging to God, that you may declare the praises of him who called you out of darkness into his wonderful light. (I Peter 2:9)
32

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

But God gives individual Christians different gifts and abilities to accomplish his purpose: There are different kinds of gifts, but the same Spirit. There are different kinds of service, but the same Lord. (I Corinthians 4:12) Once you have determined your gifts, make sure you are using them in a meaningful ministry. Don’t Bury Your Talents Remember the parable of the talents: Then the man who had received the one talent came. 'Master,' he said, 'I knew that you are a hard man, harvesting where you have not sown and gathering where you have not scattered seed. So I was afraid and went out and hid your talent in the ground. See, here is what belongs to you.' His master replied, 'You wicked, lazy servant! So you knew that I harvest where I have not sown and gather where I have not scattered seed? Well then, you should have put my money on deposit with the bankers, so that when I returned I would have received it back with interest. (Matthew 25:24-26) Make sure when the master returns that you have done something with the talents and resources he has given you and your church. Not Sure If you are not sure where your talent lies, then give it a try. The best way to discover your passion is to try different things. God will reveal to you where your passions are, but often it happens in the process of attempting new things. The same is true for your church. There will be some trial and error, but if you are truly following God, he will lead you in the right direction. Rick Warren, talking about riding God’s wave, uses a surfing analogy to describe God as creating some killer waves; it is up to us to throw our board in the water and hang on. So rest assured, it may be a wild ride, but God is in control.
33

Marketing the Church

SWOT Analyzing Inside the Outdoors When I was contacted by Inside the Outdoors to do some marketing consulting, the first thing we did was perform a SWOT analysis. Inside the Outdoors is a wonderful program affiliated with the Orange County Department of Education that provides schoolage children with hands-on environmental education experiences. The organization is comprised of three programs. The Outdoor Science School program places students in a camp setting for a week to get them immersed in an environmental learning experience. The Field Program provides field trips to local harbors, beaches, and parks so that students are able to participate in an outdoor classroom for the day. The Traveling Naturalists program takes the outdoors to the students by bringing a van full of animals to local schools for assemblies. I met with the leaders of the individual programs to create a SWOT for the whole organization. They were given the SWOT form to fill out before the meeting. There was some difficulty and confusion during the process of whether their answers should concern Inside the Outdoors as a whole, or should they answer for their individual programs. We decided to create a SWOT for the whole of Inside the Outdoors since the marketing plan that was being created was for the organization as a whole. I recommended that it would be beneficial for the various programs within Inside the Outdoors (and I recommend the same for any organization with subprograms or departments) to create a SWOT and a marketing plan for each of the programs at a later date. One of the side benefits of the process was that the leaders felt as if they were all a part of the same team for the first time. They realized that their resources, goals, and identity were interdependent on the other programs. Inside the Outdoors had so many strengths that choosing a particular one to promote was difficult. In the end we decided the hands-on approach to education was their distinct competitive advantage. Competitive Advantage What sets your company apart? What areas are unique and cannot be easily copied? This is a crucial discovery for organizations. Your competitive advantage is what sets you apart
34

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

and makes up the message that is broadcast by means of the integrated marketing communication process. This is where the rubber meets the road. You should come to one of three conclusions: 1. There are things about the company that are unique and not easily duplicated so they are better than the competition. 2. The company is just like the competition, no better no worse. 3. The company is worse than the competition. Take a deep breath and go back to the list of strengths on the SWOT analysis to determine what items are distinctive to the company. When determining the competitive advantage of the company, I caution you to avoid basing it on a supposedly unique product. It is very difficult to have a sustained competitive advantage based on a product in our modern technological age. In the past, a technological innovation on a product could give a company the advantage for decades since others were not able to copy the product easily. Today successful products can be, and often are, copied in a matter of weeks if not days. Many software applications are copied (though not necessarily legally) almost immediately. For these reasons, it is very difficult, if not impossible, to hold a competitive advantage based on technology or a technologically superior product. There has been a shift to the intangible elements of customer service and other value-added components dominating the marketplace. Competitive advantages today are usually based on service, reputation and longevity.

Gifts On one level the competitive advantage of Christianity is that it is the truth. For this reason it is superior to all other belief systems. (This sounds like an arrogant statement, particularly in our culturally relative society, but based on my experience, scientific research and education, it is true.) Pragmatically speaking, each local
35

Marketing the Church

church is endowed with certain gifts and resources to uniquely impact the needs of their community. This could be considered their competitive advantage, the competition being what secular society offers as an alternative.

First to Market Being first to market with a new product can provide a sustainable competitive advantage when marketed properly. This may sound like a contradiction to the above paragraph, but it is not. Being first to market with a product can establish the image of the brand in the mind of consumers (Key 3). The competitive advantage is the identification of the company as being the originator of the product, not the product itself. Rollerblade was the first inline skate company and is synonymous with the product. All other inline skates are copies of Rollerblades in the minds of consumers. By being first to market, a company has the opportunity to establish itself as the originator and to paint all competitors as copycat, inferior products. They also have the ability to be the first to create relationships with customers (Key 5). If you are first to market, concentrate on establishing a brand image (Key 3) and building relationships with customers (Key 5). Do not promote how no one else has anything like your product because tomorrow there will be a copy.

Tired of Poor Service I went to a tire store for new tires. I walked in and waited patiently while the clerk was on the telephone. After a few minutes, I started to pick up on his conversation; he was talking to a friend about baseball cards. I was not pleased and walked out of the store. As I got to my car, he came out of the store after me and asked what I needed. I said I needed tires, but since he did not have time to greet me, or ask me to wait a moment, or in any other way acknowledge my presence, I was going to go somewhere else. I also told him plainly “I can get tires anywhere.”
36

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

While this is a customer service issue, it also illustrates the point that tires are the same anywhere. They are merely round pieces of rubber as far as I am concerned and there are about 12 tire stores within a 5-mile radius of my house. I am going to go to a retail location where my needs are met: not just my need for tires, but my need for civility and courteousness from the sales staff.

Tired of Poor Services There are more churches available, and alternatives to church, than there are tire stores. Make sure you are making the most of the limited opportunities you have when people visit your church.

No Advantage If you find no unique strength(s) for your company or product then there is no competitive advantage. If this is true in your case, I recommend you do not spend any more time, money, or other resources in development. Either find a way to differentiate or find another way to make a living. Fortunately there is the ability to add value through great service and by creating and sustaining relationships with customers (Key 5). If this is true, why are there so many companies out there that are doing the exact same thing as their competition yet continue to exist? Some companies have found a way to communicate a unique market position to their customers, even if it is only a matter of perception. Some have great relationships with existing customers and are subsisting on their patronage. For others, it is just a matter of time until a shake, out narrows the field and puts them out of business, as witnessed by the demise of thousands of mediocre Internet companies in 2000. To use scientific terms, “only the strong survive,” so a thinning of the herd will take place sooner or later. Science also teaches us that only one species at a time can occupy a particular
37

Marketing the Church

niche. The same is true in business. If you do not have a competitive advantage then you will not survive for very long.

One Church It is not possible for the Church as a whole not to have an advantage but there may be reasons for local congregations to change their outlook. Are they truly meeting a unique need in the community? Could resources be better spent by joining and partnering with another church or meeting in a home? I used to preach in two rural churches. They were both out in the hills of Missouri and were only about 2 miles apart. Each church had a building that could seat about 100, but each congregation would have 7-10 people on a Sunday. I could not understand why they did not meet together. The congregations knew each other, and I was paid by each church to come and preach the same sermon. Do you see the advantage of these two congregations meeting separately other than to maintain tradition? If nothing else, one church could have saved the $35 they were paying me.

Only One Do not panic if you find only one unique strength that can be considered a competitive advantage. Be thankful you have one at all. Many find through this process that they have none. There is the threat of the competition catching up to you when you only have one area of expertise, but marketing a company or product is actually simplified by having one dominant advantage instead of trying to communicate multiple messages at the same time. Some companies find that they began by capitalizing on a unique strength, but have since strayed away from their original competitive advantage. This loss of focus on their core will catch up with them. Companies cannot keep their position in the market
38

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

without maintaining a competitive advantage, even if they are able to survive for a time on the returns from earlier success. In one case I facilitated a SWOT analysis for a private university. The school is located in the heavily populated Orange County area of Southern California. We determined that one of the distinct strengths the school had over the competition was the location of the campus on a beautiful green hill away from the congestion of the surrounding cities. Comparable schools in the area were all located in the middle of busy streets and intersections. Few others had the same amount of green space as this university. For the competition to copy the advantage of this university they would have to purchase and tear down neighboring commercial areas and turn them into grassy knolls. This is a difficult if not impossible proposition for them, which makes this feature a distinct competitive advantage for the university. Right now the university is in the process of developing much of the green space and putting up new buildings. While the university has other strengths and advantages, I am curious to see how this will affect their ability to compete in the future since they are removing one of their only irreplaceable and irreproducible competitive advantages.

Tough Love This is the most difficult concept for churches to grasp. They are accustomed to supporting, at least verbally, any good idea. The problem is that the enemy of the best is the good. There are thousands of good ideas and ministries churches can support, but you must focus on the best ones for your church. I love hockey, and trying to become a professional hockey player is a good idea. The problem is that I am not very skilled and will never reach a professional level. Therefore, the best thing for me to do to make a living and feed my family is to write books, teach, and consult, not practice hockey 8 hours a day. I have seen many churches pouring resources into lifeless ministries because somebody volunteered to lead a group. Meanwhile there are many worthwhile and effective opportunities
39

Marketing the Church

that are not implemented due to a lack of material resources and mental energy. For example, Ted has been leading the fishing ministry for 30 years. The only people involved in the ministry are Ted and the 6 guys who have been fishing with him for the last 3 decades. Young Chuck, however, has an idea to develop a skateboarding ministry. Since he has several friends looking for a place to skate on Saturdays, he approaches the pastor. Unfortunately, the pastor tells Chuck that the parking lot is reserved for the fishing club, but he will present the idea at the next church leadership meeting to see if anything can be done. The above example is fictional. What is not fictional is that I have seen groups of new people involved in a new and growing ministry crammed into the hallway of a church because all the rooms were already filled with long time Christians getting together for their regular meetings. It is easy to blame the pastor for these problems, but he can only juggle so much, it is up to the members to fulfill their obligations as part of the “priesthood of believers.” Christians should proactively look for and make room for the Chuck’s who are trying to meet a need and minister to people outside the church. Are the ministries at your church filled with Teds or Chucks? Intentional Ministry Guide If you are looking for a way to identify and support effective ministries at your church, check out the intentional ministry guide on the Marketing the Church website (www.MarketingTheChurch.com).

Perceived Value and the Quality Myth Many people try to compete either on price or on quality. Their ads tout their product as the low price leader, or the best quality available. These are both ambiguous descriptions that have little rational value. It is not wise to base your marketing message on
40

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

either of these. Price, as we will discuss later in the text, is not a competitive advantage because it can easily be copied almost immediately. Your competition need only match your price, and your perceived price advantage will vanish. Why wouldn’t quality be a competitive advantage? The reason is that quality is relative, subjective, and determined by the consumer. Ask five friends what constitutes quality and they will usually give you different answers. What you are promoting as quality may not mean the same thing to your customer.

Learn From Coca Cola In the 80s Coca Cola was winning the cola wars. They were dominating Pepsi in sales and things looked good. The new CEO of Coke wanted to go further. What bothered him was that Pepsi consistently beat Coke in blind taste tests. The CEO reasoned that this was because Pepsi had a better quality product. I think he was right. If tests based on what people prefer based on how the cola tastes is a measure of quality, Pepsi was better. The CEO decided to do something to improve the quality of his product. His answer was New Coke, which was a copy of the sweeter, less carbonated taste of Pepsi. The result was a tremendous backlash from the Coke faithful. Consumers were disgusted with Coke for changing the recipe they had loved for years. Cases of old Coke were being auctioned like fine vintage wine. The CEO wisely gave in and brought back the old formula as Classic Coke. New Coke seems to have disappeared since then, and all that is available is Classic Coke, now called just Coke again. This illustrates the point that New Coke was better in physical quality due to taste tests than Classic Coke, but Classic Coke was perceived as being the original and therefore of higher quality. The moral of this story is that quality is in the mind of the consumer. Define Quality The word quality is used so much in the marketplace that it no longer has significant meaning. Everyone claims that they are
41

Marketing the Church

high quality. Please understand I am not saying an inadequate product will work. Your product must live up to the promises it makes. If you say your product kills athlete’s foot, your product needs to deliver. Besides potential lawsuits, people will catch on to the validity, or lack thereof, of your claims. The problem is when companies say they provide quality without defining what they mean. It is generally assumed by consumers that you are making the best product you can. I usually come across this problem when developing mission statements with businesses. I worked with a restaurant that wanted to make “providing quality” part of their mission. Sounds nice, but how do you really provide quality? I pressed for answers and found they meant “treating customers and coworkers with respect in a clean and family-oriented environment.” These specific descriptions of quality are easier to measure and to communicate to customers. Quality Pattern While individual definitions of quality differ, there is a pattern to buyer behavior. In general, whatever is the leader in a category is perceived as being of quality. In other words, whatever sells the most is usually seen as being the real thing or the name brand. Others are seen as imitations, copies, and therefore not as good as the original. Even if the products are identical in every other way, imitators are perceived as having less quality. Counterfeit Religions It is interesting to note that most false religions, unless they are based on antichristian or satanic beliefs, compare themselves to Christianity. In fact many of the world’s religions praise Christ as a prophet or great teacher and follow many of the basic tenets of the Bible. For example, most Buddhists are very moral people and live exemplary lives, but instead of worshipping God, they believe they are God. The fact that cult leaders refer to the Bible for validation shows that Christianity is the genuine article. Many false teachers use biblical practices to suggest their faith is authentic. This is because the Bible is true, and humans recognize this at some level,
42

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

they are created for relationship with God and are attracted to truth. Counterfeit religions use biblical truth to lure people in but twist the scriptures with damning results. Satan did the same thing in the garden. God told Adam and Eve not to eat of the Tree of Knowledge or they would die. Satan, disguised as a serpent, twisted God’s words: The serpent told the Woman, "You won't die. God knows that the moment you eat from that tree, you'll see what's really going on. You'll be just like God, knowing everything, ranging all the way from good to evil. (Genesis 3:4-5) But they did die; they died to a life of paradise in direct communion and communication with God. False religions are still promising paradise through knowledge and the ability to become like God. This is an old ploy, but if you look at what the religions of the world promise, people are still buying it today.

Tagline The tagline is a distillation of the competitive advantage into a single word or sentence. The tagline will appear on every piece of promotional and organizational communications material. For the tagline to be effective, it must reinforce the unique competitive advantage of the company. A simple and easy to remember tagline is best. Try to use literary tools like rhyming and alliteration. It is also helpful if it clarifies the purpose of the business when the name does not clearly do so. The purpose is to get the company’s competitive advantage stuck in the heads of customers. The more complex and convoluted the tagline, the less likely this will happen. Many taglines do nothing to clarify the advantage of the company. Nike says to “just do it.” Just do what? And what does this have to do with their advantage? Why is this company a better choice for me as a consumer than their competitors? The answer to all these questions is “I don’t know.” I don’t think they could tell me why they are better if I asked the CEO himself, probably because they have not gone through the SWOT process. That’s great if you have a few hundred million dollars a year to spend on advertising to
43

Marketing the Church

keep your company in the mind of the consumer, but most companies don’t have such resources. Nike is a major market force today, but they are weak on this point of promoting their competitive advantage. A savvy marketer could give a competitor a way to overtake the shoe giant and give Nike a run for its money (pun intended).

Get Your Hands on Nature In the case of the Inside the Outdoors SWOT analysis, we discovered the distinct strength of the program is the unique handson science education that takes place in the various programs. After taking the organization through the SWOT analysis and recognizing this advantage, we determined a good tagline would be “Get Your Hands on Nature.” It is simple, easy to remember, and captures the essence of the program. Another positive is that this is not a typically passive tagline, but one that calls for action.

Where the Journey Begins While doing marketing consulting for a church, we determined one of the competitive advantages was its location overlooking the airport. Known for the annual air show, the church property is prime real estate to watch the yearly event. One of the biggest outreach events each year will be inviting thousands to the campus to watch the air show. While developing a tagline and logo for the church, we agreed the tagline: Where the Journey Begins, is easily identifiable for members of the church and the community. Church members identify with the idea of the Christian’s journey through this life culminating in a reunion with God. Community members identify with the airport and the annual air show. In designing a new logo, we incorporated the dual image of an airplane, for the airport, and a sword, representing the Bible (see a full explanation of the logo in the Illustration on page 72). This change in the logo and tagline occurred at the same time a building campaign was launched. To be consistent and provide synergy, the tagline was incorporated into the building campaign as: Building for the
44

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Journey.

What and Why Completing the SWOT analysis provides an organization with an assessment of the potential for success. It is best to do all of this on paper before investing time or money. Smart new companies today have everything planned on paper before a single brick is laid. The SWOT analysis illuminates the competitive advantage of the organization, which provides a basis for all marketing activities. Once you have discovered your advantage or the “what,” you must now determine your purpose or the “why” of the organization by defining your purpose.

45

Marketing the Church

46

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

2
Key 2: Define Your Purpose
Why are you in business? What are you trying to achieve? How will you measure your success? Answering these questions is vital to defining your purpose and Key 2 will get you started.

Mission The overarching purpose of an organization is described in its mission statement. The mission is the most important strategic element of any organization. It is also one of the most overlooked and misunderstood. A mission statement defines the raison d’être of the company. The mission gives purpose and meaning to daily activities. A mission statement is to a company as a thesis is to an essay. Neither makes sense without a clear statement as to what is to be accomplished. In a well-written essay, every sentence supports the thesis. The thesis of this book is that there are seven keys to marketing success. Every sentence is written in support of this thesis. In the same way, every activity of a company should be in concert with the mission statement. The mission clearly defines for all stakeholders what the company is striving to achieve. The mission is a filter for every decision made, from banal details to watershed movements. “Does this fulfill the mission?” should be the question everyone asks when making decisions that affect the organization. Some mission statements are several pages long, while others are just a word. Here are some helpful guidelines for creating a mission statement: • Make it memorable. It may be great, but if people can’t remember it, the words are useless. In most cases, brevity is more effective than exhaustiveness.
47

Marketing the Church

• •

Make it relevant. If it does not connect with the various stakeholders of the organization, people will likely ignore it. Make it theirs. You must get input from as many people as possible or they will not buy into the mission. Remember this axiom: “involvement equals commitment.”

I recommend that people create a personal mission statement for themselves before going through the process of helping to create one for their organization for two reasons. First, people have a better understanding of the process and the value of creating a mission. Second, they will be able to determine whether their personal values are in alignment with those of the organization.

Backwards Creation A great tool for creating a mission statement is to start at the end and work backwards. What do you want to accomplish? What do you want people to say about the organization 50 years from now? In seminars I have people create a personal mission statement. To visualize the future, I have participants pretend they are at their own funeral. I ask these questions: • • • • • Who is present? Are there loved ones, family, coworkers, friends, teachers, coaches, and/or children? What is each one saying about your life? Do you like what they are saying about what you accomplished with your life? If you could choose, what kind of things would you want them to say about you?

In doing this exercise over the years, I have discovered a similarity in people’s responses. Typically, people want to be remembered as kind, friendly and contributing to society. I ask, “How many people said they would want their loved ones to remember them for the cool car they drove?” I have never had
48

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

anyone raise his or her hand. I also ask, “How many of you have that as a current concern?” Many people do raise their hands in response. There is an inconsistency between what most people value and what they are busy pursuing. The same principle is true of organizations. Based on the responses to these questions, people are usually able to formulate what is most important to them. When they stop and reflect, they can see whether they are currently living their lives in a way that will get them to the point where people will say about them what they want them to say. The mission statement defines what the person or organization values and the standards they pursue. To create powerful mission statements see the Seven Keys Companion Guide. Accomplishing the mission is dependent upon setting and reaching goals.

The End As Christians, we will give an accounting before God of what we did with our lives and the resources he gave us to bless others. And I saw the dead, great and small, standing before the throne, and books were opened. Another book was opened, which is the book of life. The dead were judged according to what they had done as recorded in the books. (Revelation 20:12) What will you say when you stand before God? What will he say to you? Hopefully he will say: “Well done, good and faithful servant! You have been faithful with a few things; I will put you in charge of many things. Come and share your master's happiness!” (Matthew 25:23 NIV) Mission Builder Now you can access a template for writing your mission statement on the Marketing the Church website (www.marketingthechurch.com).
49

Marketing the Church

Gooooal! In Los Angeles there is a famous soccer announcer that shouts “gooooal” at the top of his lungs every time someone scores. If you have seen an international soccer match, you know that every time there is a goal the announcers get very excited, the fans go crazy, and the players go nuts and run around the field, often ripping their shirts off their backs. Setting goals does not usually connote excitement, but reaching goals does. In order to fulfill your mission, short- and long-term goals must be set and measured to evaluate progress. To learn how to create measurable goals worth celebrating, see the Seven Keys Companion Guide. Review, Reevaluate and Revise While the mission is the guiding force, it is still a work in process. If you have done the hard work of creating a mission statement, it will come to mind whenever making decisions. The mission should be reviewed, reevaluated and revised at least twice a year. You should evaluate how well the organization is fulfilling the mission. If it is aligned with the mission you can feel confident that you are on the right path. If not, then you will need either to refocus the energies of the organization or to revamp the mission statement to more closely fit with the true values of the organization. I wrote my personal mission statement, then reevaluated and rewrote it several times. I still review it frequently but have not revised my mission for several years. On the other hand I have changed my behavior several times by reviewing my mission and realizing when I get off track.

Discovering Mission Writing a mission statement is often more a matter of discovering a mission than creating one. In the illustration of the funeral, most people have an idea in the back of their minds of how they would want to be remembered. Many people have never taken the time to contemplate what is really important to them, and often once they do, they see their values do not align with how they are
50

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

living their lives. The most important things to them, like family and relationships, usually get put on the back burner due to pressing concerns like finances and the daily grind. Creating a mission puts life into context and helps to determine not only what is truly important but also whether or not you are on the path to accomplishing the important. Discovering a Church’s Mission While working with the leadership of a church (the pastor, associate pastor and worship pastor), I took them through the process of mission development and the importance of alignment within the church. The leaders, enthusiastic about a church mission, derided the current mission that had been framed and placed on the wall by the preceding pastor. “Most people do not know it is there, where it came from, or why it matters,” I was told. The plan was to develop a new mission statement relevant to the current members. I recommended, as I usually do, they gather input from the various stakeholders of the church through town hall meetings, surveys, and internet submissions. To my chagrin, the 3 leaders decided to write the mission themselves. I did not understand how they could expect to see different results by following the same process. Apparently this was the same way the current mission statement was created, the former pastor wrote it, framed it, and hung it in the hallway. An interesting thing happened, the mission they created was very perceptive and captured the essence of the congregation. The pastor presented the new mission in a sermon, and the church members became very excited and felt like a part of something positive. In this case the organization was already functioning with a common purpose, but highlighting and celebrating this purpose was inspiring and life giving. The leaders knew their congregation well enough to know this was the purpose of their church without going through the process of gathering input. What was this inspiring mission statement? I wish I could remember, but it was not that profound. Checking the church’s website, I do not see any mention of a mission statement, and I have not received any responses to my inquiries as to how things have
51

Marketing the Church

progressed. In some ways I would rather not know what happened. I hope the momentum has kept building and the church has continued to grow and be a dynamic force in the community. My fear is that there is a new mission statement on the wall, an example of another irrelevant relic. So it is not always necessary to get input, but it provides accountability not only from the leadership but from the congregation. Asking people to share their opinions is a powerful exercise, even if you think you know their response. If you receive input, the mission becomes the people’s mission for the church instead of the pastor’s mission for the people. You are probably saying “that sounds great, but we don’t have time for something like that.” Most churches say they do not have time, but what are you doing that is so important? Since a mission statement determines what is important and what you should be doing with your time, shouldn’t you do that first? Mission building gets to the root of why you are here as a person and why your church exists. Can you think of a better way to spend your time than examining these issues?

Quality People It is often more difficult to do this as an individual than for an organization or product. It takes a great deal of introspection and personal discipline. I recommend having people on your team who are capable of thinking at this level, because they will likely perform better and provide a greater overall contribution to the organization. When I present this exercise in seminars, I find a great deal of resistance. I think the reason is that people feel uncomfortable with how out of alignment they are with their own values and mission in life. The reason I perform this in traditional business settings is because it lays the foundation for understanding the mission and alignment of the overall organization. Heart Issues I am convinced the main reason I get resistance to this process in the secular world is that it concerns heart issues. It forces
52

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

you to examine what you are doing with your life, and how that contributes to the organizations you belong to. Many do not consider this a topic for professional discussion, but the most successful business people understand and apply these principles in their lives and organizations.

Alignment I was trying to park my truck and I banged into a curb pretty hard. For the next few weeks, until I got it repaired, whenever I took my hands off the wheel, my car would veer to the left. My truck had become misaligned. Have you ever driven a vehicle that is out of alignment? When you drive down the road, you have to hang on to the wheel with both hands or the car will swerve into the next lane. If the car is out of alignment enough, it can actually try to pull you right into oncoming traffic with disastrous consequences. As bad as that sounds, imagine a car with wheels pointed in different directions, some going forward, some in reverse. How far do you think a car like that would travel? (See figure 2.1.)

Figure 2.1: Misaligned Vehicle Obviously a car this far out of alignment would not get you to your desired destination. The same is true for organizations that are out of alignment. In every organization people have an agenda.
53

Marketing the Church

People have an understanding of why they are there and what they are supposed to be doing. Sometimes their understanding is correct and at other times they are way off base. Even when members of the organization are not sure what they are supposed to do, they still come to their jobs with a perception of what they think they should accomplish each day. This is just as true for the President and CEO as it is for the guy sweeping cigarette butts in the parking lot. Where each fits into the makeup of the organization is demonstrated in figure 2.2.

Figure 2.2: Sample Company

You can substitute the titles in your company for those in the illustration. For the organization to function efficiently, every level must be headed in the same direction. In reality, different levels do not typically head in the same direction. Everyone does what seems right in his or her own eyes. Without an overriding purpose that everyone is aware of and buys into, people will drift off in their own directions as seen if figure 2.3.
54

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Figure 2.3: Company Misalignment

It is not altogether uncommon to find companies that look like the one in figure 2.3. In fact, unless the leadership is intentional about alignment, it is more likely to observe misalignment than alignment. You can see how different levels are working directly against the others. Sometimes this is intentional when you have disgruntled employees disobeying company policies or, even worse, sabotaging the progress of others out of jealousy or bitterness. It is difficult for a company to make much progress when everyone is doing his or her own thing. So how does a company become aligned? Everyone must understand and buy into an overriding purpose. You should already know where this is heading. This overriding statement of purpose is most commonly called the mission statement. After creating a
55

Marketing the Church

mission statement, the task of leadership is to get the personnel aligned with the mission of the company as in figure 2.4.

Figure 2.4 Alignment of the Company with the Company’s Mission

Your Arrows Substitute the various roles in your church for the ones in this chart. Add or delete rings to suit your purposes. Now, draw some arrows to represent how closely aligned you think the different levels of your church are right now. If you have a mission statement in place, draw the arrows in the direction that represents how closely each group is pursuing the mission.

56

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Individual Missions Everyone has a purpose for his or her life that he or she pursues. Some people work for money while others want to contribute something meaningful to society. Sometimes their mission is conscious, but often it is not. Regardless of their awareness level, if the mission of individual members and the mission of the company do not align, there will be major problems. You will see the same results as putting a wheel on a car that only drives sideways; the car will not function properly. For this reason, members must have an alignment of their personal missions with that of the company.

Powerful Lessons A great way to teach your church about mission statements is to take the members through the process of creating an individual mission statement. Help them discover how God has uniquely gifted them to fulfill his purpose on earth. When this occurs first, the transition to discussing the mission of the church is easier to comprehend and accept.

57

Marketing the Church

Figure 2.5 Alignment of the Company’s Mission with Personal Mission This is where hiring practices become important. First, the organization must be able to articulate its mission. Next, interview questions must be asked to determine whether a prospective employee would add momentum to accomplishing the mission or be a driving force in a different direction.

Career Counseling What do you do about the company’s current members with a conflicting mission? They should be counseled to get on board or to seek work elsewhere. Not only do they hold back the company, they are not going to be happy working for a company whose purpose conflicts with their own. The sooner they move on, the better for both parties.
58

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Sin Do you realize that the word sin is an archery term that means to miss the mark? When you sin you are not living as a redeemed person and staying on the trajectory God has set for you, you are off target and missing the mark. Being out of alignment and sinning are synonymous terms. How aligned is your church? Are you hitting the mark?

See the Principle There is another layer to the alignment picture. To be successful at any level, a mission must align with principles. Principles are universal truths or laws, such as gravity. If you walk off a cliff, what happens? You go straight down and make a splat. It does not matter whether or not you believe in gravity, the principle exists and you will live (or die) by the consequences. In the same way, there are principles involved in marketing. The more you understand these principles and align to them, the greater the likelihood for success. As a university professor I typically demonstrate this concept by having my students make paper airplanes at their desks. I then have them aim their creations at a particular target and send them flying. A chorus of giggles occurs as a flood of paper airplanes crosses the room. Usually only one or two come close to the objective. Planes thrown forward fly sideways, do loop to loops or take a nosedive right into the floor. I ask my students whether they think they could make a better airplane if they were well-versed in the principles of flight. Do they think a pilot or an aircraft engineer could design a better airplane? Invariably, the answer comes back “yes, of course.” Understanding gravity, acceleration, lift, thrust, velocity and the other principles of flight help aircraft designers make better flying aircraft. The more the designer’s craft is in harmony with these principles; the more likely the plane is to fly. In other words, their mission of creating an aircraft must be in alignment with the
59

Marketing the Church

basic principles of flight in order to be successful. Likewise the marketer, who understands the basic principles of marketing, or the seven keys to marketing genius, is more likely to be successful.

Biblical Principles What is the source of these universal principles, truths or laws? God, of course. To be successful in business you must align with biblical principles, or you will not be successful in the long run. This is a powerful apologetic and proof of God. There is a terrific opportunity for churches to minister to professional and business minded people. Churches should be leading the way and setting an example of professionalism in how they communicate and treat their employees, volunteers, and guests.

Figure 2.5 Alignment of Mission and Principles

60

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

To harness the power of alignment, every level must be in harmony. All your circles must be parallel and all your arrows must be pointing in the same direction (see figure 2.6).

Figure 2.6 Alignment of Personal & Company’s Mission and Principles

Synergy One plus one equals three or more. In the world of math, that does not add up correctly. When it comes to people, it is called synergy. Synergy is people coming together to accomplish more than they could do individually. Sports teams talk about the chemistry of a team being important. There have been many teams that did not look like much on paper, but together they were able to win championships. In construction, a single block of wood that is one-by-one inch thick could hold up ten pounds of weight. Two single blocks of wood stacked together would logically hold up twenty pounds of weight, but instead can hold up one hundred pounds of weight. The two blocks together can do exponentially more than they could do alone.
61

Marketing the Church

These are examples of synergy. Alignment within organizations creates powerful synergy. When everyone is working together for a common purpose and going in the same direction, they can become virtually unstoppable. This momentum will carry over into the marketing process, particularly in the area of promotion (Key 4).

Synergy of the Trinity There is a prayer in Judaism called the Shema, it begins by stating the Lord God is One. So why do Christians believe in a Trinity? Are these concepts in conflict? Not necessarily. Christians believe in the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Together they are one cohesive unit, yet they are separate entities. This is too short of space to elucidate all the mysteries of the trinitarian union, but it does illustrate the point of individuals coming together as one unit or team for a singular purpose. The Body of Christ Synergy is illustrated in the myriad of believers that comprise the singular body of Christ on the earth. As separate individuals we are frail, broken, and imperfect; yet as a corporate body, we are the unified physical body of Christ on the planet, powerfully working together for a common purpose. We are able to do more together than we could ever do alone. Why God chooses to use us in this way is beyond our comprehension, but the fact that he does is evident in scripture and by looking at the work accomplished by God through his Church every day. God has a purpose for us to accomplish, requiring us to work together. Divine Synergy As Christians we are blessed with the gift of the Holy Spirit in our lives; we do not have to make decisions on our own, we can rely on the Spirit working within us and our brothers and sisters. It is wise to listen to the leading of our co-Church members. Though we might get confused in our own minds, God is able to lead us all
62

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

together in his direction if we are willing to work with and listen to each other.

Vision Though the terms mission and vision are typically used interchangeably, there is value in defining them as different tools. While the mission is a snapshot of how the current day-to-day activities of the organization look, the vision is a future-oriented picture of where the company is going. The mission and vision must be in harmony with one another, but they are distinct. The vision is more of a stretch of the imagination, a best-case scenario of what the company can look like; it defines the destiny of the organization. Another important aspect of the vision is that it is visual. It should be an actual physical picture. Usually this will coincide with the distinct competitive advantage of the organization and the logo, but not necessarily. People need a picture they can visualize (Key 3). To create a vision for your company see the Seven Keys Companion Guide. Conflicting Missions What happens when the members of an organization do not agree on a mission? Conflict. The conflict will be resolved eventually by everyone agreeing on a common mission, individuals leaving the organization, or the dissolution of the organization itself. I did a mission-building workshop for a small and growing company I worked for called XCOM. I had the different members work through their personal missions and what they felt the company’s purpose should be. It became apparent that one of the owners, Betty, had an opinion of why we were working together that was very different from one of the other owners and most of the employees. Betty felt the main purpose of XCOM was to make a profit. Her partner and most of the employees were there to build a legacy
63

Marketing the Church

and a company that would be respected. I was at a bit of a loss at the time, because I had not expected this to happen. There was no way to agree on a mission for the company in the hour we had set aside for this meeting. I recommended that we think some more, and I would take everyone’s ideas and create a draft to e-mail around for approval. My draft, which was a compromise of the conflicting missions, was rejected by Betty and the other employees who had their own versions they preferred. Needless to say, I was never able to create a concrete mission for XCOM. I also watched these conflicting values play out during my time there. Betty and the other owner and employees had petty arguments and did not get along. I could see that the root problem of most of these arguments had to do with a different view of why the company existed. Betty was viewed as a penny-pincher who only cared about money. Betty viewed the others as being irresponsible with company resources. Who was right? I think they both were right in a way. It is irrelevant who was right or wrong; the point is that they would always have a difficult time working together, since they were going in different directions. One of our brightest employees who had been vocal in the mission-building workshop just picked up and left one day. He was there to create a unique company and leave a legacy; this was in conflict with the way Betty was trying to run things. Because my role with the company was also not clearly defined, I was moved around to different departments a couple of times and finally was made the marketing director. I had a big problem because I did not know what I was trying to market. I could not get a clear answer on what exactly our business was doing and who my target market was. Definitions of what we were trying to do changed from day to day and week to week. This is understandable since some days we were trying to build an identity as an innovative company, and the next day we were talking about jumping into a popular market and doing the same things as our competition to make some quick cash. The company did not have a mission, and the personal missions of the stakeholders were grossly misaligned. I had a few ideas for marketing promotions, but the lack of a definitive purpose and a commitment from management to allocate
64

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

finances meant they were never implemented. I sat at my desk and listened to the owners feud about what the company was trying to do. I tried to think of something productive to do with my time, but had no real purpose to pursue. I felt guilty taking a paycheck, so I advised my boss to lay me off and use me as a consultant if he wanted to do any marketing in the future. A couple of months later, citing a lack in sales, I was taken up on my offer and laid off. Betty and the other owner never did get along. The fighting grew more furious and finally the ownership disbanded. Could creating a mission statement have saved this situation? Probably not, but it could have saved some aggravation. The inability to agree on the purpose of XCOM and create a mission was a clear indication of what was to come. From the beginning, they should have either come to a consensus or decided to part ways. This would have saved time, money and heartache.

Schisms If you do not think specific mission and vision for your congregation are important, consider the great schisms in the body of Christ. I have attended churches that are a part of the Christian Church/Church of Christ restoration movement. This group split over the use of instrumental music in worship, whether or not to use a piano when singing the Sunday morning hymns. Do you think perhaps these folks got off track from the mission and vision of the global Church and the specific goals of their congregation? In the end it was probably a power struggle or a clashing of divergent personalities. Having a clear mission for the local body can keep your priorities straight, get everyone on track, and lead to some synergistic solutions.

Natural Alignment Not all organizations struggle with alignment. Some great companies have neither gathered all their people in a room to draw a
65

Marketing the Church

bunch of circles on the board nor had mission-statement writing marathons. However, to be successful, they did have an implicit and tacit understanding of these common elements. They may not have verbally defined their purpose, but they acted with a common purpose in mind. If your organization has not created a mission statement, it should do so right away. If your organization has diverging missions for each department and is totally out of alignment, this process will provide a platform for discussion and get you all on the same path. If you have been acting with a common purpose already, then the process will be simple. Having a defined purpose provides a way of attracting and retaining like-minded employees, members and customers.

Long-Term Focus The story about conflicting missions at XCOM should illustrate the necessity of having a definitive purpose for any activity, corporation or organization. To go through the above exercises can be exhausting. Even those organizations that see the value of defining their purpose have difficulty putting in the effort and resources to do this kind of planning. There are scores of organizations that ignore these strategic tools and still survive. The question is what kind of organization do you want to be? Do you want to have a short-term focus and be overtaken by a betterorganized competitor down the road? Do you want to provide a workplace that allows people to participate in the strategic process and find fulfillment in their work? Do you care about attracting and retaining quality employees? If you want to market your product or company for the long term and create a protected relationship between members, employees, and consumers, you need to put in the effort (Key 5). You must invest time and energy into creating and/or defining a strategic plan for the company. Doing so will provide a firm foundation for enduring success. Once you have defined the “what” and the “why” of a company, it is time to start communicating this identity to customers.
66

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Scaring People The long-term perspective is the best strategy for evangelism. Some people are “scared” into accepting Christ by well meaning friends who tell them they will go to hell or get left behind during the rapture. Is this the best start to a walk with God? I understand that this will be the case for some people no matter what, and hopefully they mature in their faith down the road. But, as you evangelize people, I ask that you focus on God’s love and sacrifice. There is something more significant and long term about responding to love rather than punishment. While a student at Cal State Fullerton, I witnessed a group of people shouting at students in the courtyard with a megaphone that they were going to hell. I asked one of the guys why they were using such a harsh approach. He said it was a great feeling to get out there and speak up for God, it was a real rush. Every once in a while someone would even pray with them. This approach sounds selfish to me. Evangelism is not about the feeling I get, uncomfortable as it may be, but it is about putting this wonderful message into a context people can understand so they will have an easier time responding to God. That is the message of this book. Figure out how your audience communicates and what they understand, then share the message (Gospel) in a way they can grasp. At Cal State I took the long term approach and joined a fraternity. In the process I was able to share my faith with every member of the fraternity as a brother and friend. I spent some late nights talking with guys in the fraternity house about what it means to be a Christian. I did not have to yell at them nor persecute them; I treated them like family. Which method do you think is closer to the approach of Christ? You have to be in this for the long-term, and people are more likely to respect and respond to your message when they recognize that fact.

67

Marketing the Church

68

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

3
Key 3: Create an Image
The purpose of advertising is to promote image and awareness. Before you can implement promotions (Key 4), you must create an image. An image is both a concept and a physical visual representation. I am not an artist, nor do I pretend to be one, so while I understand the importance of creating a unique and powerful image, I have not been blessed with the ability to create visual images. Therefore, this section provides an analysis of proper strategy, not artistic instruction. If you do not possess the artistic skills yourself, I recommend you hire someone skilled in graphic arts to help you turn your strategic image into a physical visual reality.

Icons As a Christian the term image can have negative connotations. Over 400 years ago, the Church experienced great schisms over the use of icons and imagery during the Reformation. It even has a fancy name: the iconoclastic controversy. One of the reasons churches used images, beautiful stained glass and great works of art, was because the majority of the population was illiterate. The people could not read the Bible, but they could relate to stories being told by the images around the church. This was the height of visual stimulation, so the Church filled the genre with themes dedicated to God. During the Reformation, godly men and woman did their best to get back to the biblical roots of worship by removing any items added through human tradition or absent from the biblical authors. Statues and iconic imagery were seen as being idolatrous, taking on too much importance in the lives of the believers.
69

Marketing the Church

Both sides in the controversy have a valid point of view, but as is the case in most situations, the extreme side of the position is not the best approach. No, you are not to have any gods (or idols) before God: You shall not make for yourself an idol in the form of anything in heaven above or on the earth beneath or in the waters below. (Exodus 20:4) But you are to sacrifice everything to the service of God: Therefore, I urge you, brothers, in view of God's mercy, to offer your bodies as living sacrifices, holy and pleasing to God—this is your spiritual act of worship. (Romans 12:1) Therefore, it behooves your church to use the many resources, modern media, and methods of communication available to them to reach the culture for Christ.

Visual Orientation How many times have you heard a friend say a movie was stupid, but you should see it anyway because the special effects were great? This is an example of looks being more important than content. There have been several movies that weren’t good movies, but had great special effects and therefore set box office records. On the other hand, there are great films that are not widely seen because they do not have enough visual appeal. I have a friend who will not watch black and white movies because he finds it too great of a distraction. Society in general is becoming increasingly visually oriented. In their book 13th Gen, the authors Neil Howe and Bill Strauss describe how generation X (also known as 13th Gen) grew up with color televisions and video games and therefore seeks visual stimulation. Posterior generations like Generation Y continue to be enamored with the visual. Some have criticized this trend of form becoming more important than function and looks more important
70

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

than content. While you may not think this is a positive direction, the implications are clear: to compete today, you must have the right look. It is not enough to have a good product; you must also be able to attract the attention of the audience. The look should enhance the image of the product while maintaining alignment with the mission (Key 2) and promoting the competitive advantages of the organization (Key 1). Logo The logo is a visual representation of the organization or the product. The logo must be used to reinforce the competitive advantage of the organization and tie into the vision of the company. A good portion of any target market is going to respond to either the logo or a combination of the logo with other marketing elements. Besides being visual, logos also have the advantage of being global. Billions of people around the world understand the Nike Swoosh. Unlike names or fancy fonts no translation is necessary. For these reasons, I cannot overstress the importance of the logo in modern marketing communications.

West County Christian Church While working with a church in St. Louis to update their logo, our goal was to create something meaningful for the members of the congregation and identifiable for the people in the community. The solution was to develop a logo with ties to traditional Christian symbols and attributes of the region. Here is what we came up with:

71

Marketing the Church

72

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Visit the Marketing the Church website to see the full color version (www.marketingthechurch.com). If you like this logo, then you will love the brothers and sisters at Nexdesign Studios. They have great talent and the heart to use it for God’s glory. You won’t believe how friendly their prices are for churches and non-profits. I have worked with them on several projects besides WCCC, and I highly recommend you contact them for help (www.nexdesignstudios.com).

Colors and Style The use of proper colors is sometimes overlooked. Certain colors evoke certain emotions. For example pink is probably not a good uniform color for police officers. Careful consideration should be made about what colors appropriately express the image you are trying to convey. Because this is so important, I suggest getting assistance from a professional artist who understands the use of color and style when creating an image for your organization.

White Do you ever see imagery in the Bible of God being black or dark? No. The consistent descriptions are that he is light, white, bright and radiant. The saints are also clothed in white. Our sins are made white as snow. They will walk with me, dressed in white, for they are worthy. (Revelation 3:4b) A study of the Bible reveals that there is powerful meaning and imagery in the use of colors.

73

Marketing the Church

Anthropomorphic Brands Key 5: Build Relationships details the crucial nature of creating a connection with consumers. People are more likely to feel connected to a person than to an inanimate object. For this reason many smart companies have created a personality to represent their product. There are three typical ways to connect the product to a personality: Connecting to a Person- The brand is attached to a person, typically the founder such as Ford motors named after Henry Ford, or Dell Computers named after Michael Dell. Connecting to a Personality- While Microsoft is not a personal name; most people connect the company to its founder, Bill Gates. In the case of Disney, the personality has shifted from Walt Disney to Michael Eisner. Creating a Character- Mr. Whipple was created to represent a sometimes-embarrassing product: toilet tissue. The Doughboy is a giggling little character for Pillsbury. By creating a personality, companies provide someone that people can relate to on a personal level. Images that connote personality do better in the marketplace than impersonal or generic brands.

Incarnation The above is consistent with the biblical doctrine of the incarnation. It is much more difficult to relate to a God up there in the clouds than to a flesh and blood person that walks the earth. Jesus came so you could know the Father and to live life abundantly: If you really knew me, you would know my Father as well. From now
74

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

on, you do know him and have seen him. (John 14:7) A thief is only there to steal and kill and destroy. I came so they can have real and eternal life, more and better life than they ever dreamed of. (John 10:10) How is your church connecting with the community? Is it perceived as a building where people drive to, causing traffic jams on Sunday mornings? Or are you seen as a living, breathing community impacting people?

Consistency To reinforce and promote an image, the organization must use its logo and tagline at every opportunity. All marketing materials should look the same, feel the same, and share the same style. In other words, to achieve synergy all marketing communications should be in alignment with one another (Key 2).

Foreshadowing To use the Bible as an example again, there are several themes consistently used. The idea of a redeemer begins in Genesis, and the theme is used throughout scripture. There are twelve sons, twelve tribes, twelve disciples, and twelve thrones in heaven. Christ is pictured as a suffering servant in Psalms, Isaiah and the prophets. Even though God is very intentional and consistent, we still get the message wrong sometimes. He continues, however, to use the same imagery or variation on the same theme repeatedly because he knows it is the best way to communicate the message with hardheaded humans. Your Church must do the same thing in all of its communications, internal and external.

75

Marketing the Church

JAAIDK What in the world is JAAIDK? It’s just another acronym I don’t know. I am amazed at how start-up companies that are establishing their identity try to use acronyms. They reason that many of the most successful companies use acronyms. What they don’t consider is the millions or billions of dollars spent by those companies to establish an identity before they were known by their initials. Most organizations are not in a position to spend that kind of money to get their names recognized. I recently purchased a game called ACRONYMITY. It is a trivia game with over 5,000 acronyms as questions. You are given the letters and have to come up with what they represent. A category and hint are also given, because many acronyms stand for more than one thing. (For example, in marketing the term CRM stands for both customer relationship management and cause related marketing.) Trying to communicate with acronyms can be very confusing, especially for customers. Do yourself a favor and use a name people can remember.

UMG I was trying to explain this concept to a friend who was starting a new graphic design company. He created a great logo with the letters UMG. Do you know what UMG stands for? Neither does anyone else. He explained to me how many big companies are known by their initials and use them as a logo. I explained that those companies had spent millions of dollars to get into the minds of their customers before being known by initials. This gentleman is a graphic artist so I also explained that I would expect an artist to be able to create a logo that represented his company better than these three letters. He told me the way he designed the three letters was unique and would be enough to garner attention from his target audience. The problem with that line of reasoning is that advertising is aimed at creating image and awareness for new customers. So by definition, the people he targeted would not be familiar with the company nor the acronym. If UMG is one day a household name
76

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

for graphic arts, I will eat my words (but he still will have spent unnecessary millions before people could identify the company).

The Biggest Offenders Churches may be the biggest offenders in this arena. Have you ever heard medical doctors talk? They order 10cc’s of peroxdotycocclyn, get an EKG to check your RPG, and then send you for a CATscan. Meow? How about the lawyers who object to your writ of habeus corpus? Overruled! Unless you are one of them, you probably have no idea what they are talking about. The problem is that most church members talk the same way. They use so much jargon it is hard for a non-Christian to have a conversation with them. Do you banter about such terms as sanctification, sacrifice, resurrection, worship, praise, sheep & shepherding, scripture, and redemption? Do you talk about your quiet time, your walk, giving it up to God, and WWJD? Do you ever stop to wonder how strange some of these things sound to regular un-churched people? Is any of it really necessary? If you did not grow up in the church, you discover you need to learn all this terminology to fit in with the other Christians and to understand what they are talking about. You also tend to move away from your old life, including your non-Christian friends and activities. This is normal and often a healthy process. But this should not be the case for mature Christians. If you are maturing in your faith, you must move beyond the Christian bubble you have created to protect yourself from outside “worldly” influences. You are called to share your faith, a faith compelling you to go into all the world and spread the Gospel with non-believers: Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age. (Matthew 28:19-20) You must communicate with people in their language and culture. Paul, while visiting Athens, used the pagan idols around him to start
77

Marketing the Church

a compelling discussion with the community about the one true God: Paul then stood up in the meeting of the Areopagus and said: "Men of Athens! I see that in every way you are very religious. For as I walked around and looked carefully at your objects of worship, I even found an altar with this inscription: TO AN UNKNOWN GOD. Now what you worship as something unknown I am going to proclaim to you. (Acts 17:22-23)

WWJD? Jesus, speaking to the people who really needed him, did not use confusing aphorisms. How did he approach them? He catered the message to the particular person with whom he was speaking. In this case a rabbi, a woman at a well, and a rich young man: Jesus answered, "I tell you the truth, no one can enter the kingdom of God unless he is born of water and the Spirit. Flesh gives birth to flesh, but the Spirit gives birth to spirit. You should not be surprised at my saying, 'You must be born again.' The wind blows wherever it pleases. You hear its sound, but you cannot tell where it comes from or where it is going. So it is with everyone born of the Spirit." "How can this be?" Nicodemus asked. (John 3:7-9) The Samaritan woman said to him, "You are a Jew and I am a Samaritan woman. How can you ask me for a drink?" (For Jews do not associate with Samaritans. Jesus answered her, "If you knew the gift of God and who it is that asks you for a drink, you would have asked him and he would have given you living water." (John 4:9-10) Jesus looked at him and loved him. "One thing you lack," he said. "Go, sell everything you have and give to the poor, and you will have treasure in heaven. Then come, follow me." At this the man's face fell. He went away sad, because he had great wealth. (Mark 10:21-22) For each person, Jesus tailored his approach and terminology to fit his or her understanding. To the Rabbi, he spoke about flesh, spirit and birth, familiar terms to a Jewish theologian; to the woman at the
78

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

well, he talked of living water; to the rich young ruler, he spoke of selling one’s possessions. As Larry Dogget, Professor of Missions at Saint Louis Christian College, puts it, “Jesus did not use Xerox evangelism. He did not use the same approach for everyone, but he couched the truth of his divinity in a context the hearer could understand.” The reason why Jesus is recorded in the Bible as telling stories about sheep, shepherds, fishing, and farming is because he communicated with shepherds, fishermen and farmers. Jesus was keepin’ it real by talkin’ their lingo, which gave him street cred and that’s why he got his props. You dig? So if you are following Christ’s example, you are doing the same thing, taking biblical truths and putting them into a context modern people can understand. Instead of talking about vines, rocks and tares- try PC’s, PDA’s, and cubicles. Jesus had a real problem with the religious people of His day, the Pharisees. Because they so greatly convoluted the word of God, people no longer understood it or gave up trying to follow it: "Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You give a tenth of your spices—mint, dill and cummin. But you have neglected the more important matters of the law—justice, mercy and faithfulness. You should have practiced the latter, without neglecting the former. You blind guides! You strain out a gnat but swallow a camel. (Matthew 23:23-24) Obviously Jesus did not think too highly of these folks. He called them hypocrites, blind guides, and vipers. So please follow the example of Jesus and not the Pharisees by making the Gospel truth available to people in a way they can understand and relate to easily. About the worst thing you can be today is inauthentic. In our culture you do not necessarily need to be moral or follow a standard other than being original and being yourself. This is actually good news since you can be yourself and share about God. That is what people are looking for, and you will see that people do respond to genuine faith.
79

Marketing the Church

Willowcreek Willowcreek Church, lead by Bill Hybels, in the Chicago area has seen phenomenal growth through their seeker sensitive approach to doing church. They intentionally remove all of the Christian jargon from their speech. They are open and friendly to people who are not familiar with Christian culture or tradition. Over the years Willowcreek has grown to become a catalyst and resource for change in American churches. Is your church seeker sensitive? Take a look at your mission statement, if it says you are about reaching the lost, then you better promote a culture that is conducive to reaching outsiders. As Carl Barnhaus used to say, “You got to get the hay out of the loft onto the barn floor where the cows can get at it.” High falutin’ church talk ain’t gonna do it folks, speak so people can understand the message.

Faking It A unique thing about Willowcreek is that the leaders and the congregation buy into and believe in what they are doing; they are not faking it. This is not about watching your language or making people shake hands; it is about stirring in people the urgency to reach out to those in need of the Gospel message. A big frustration I had with a church I attended was the “outreach” services at Christmas and Easter. We were all encouraged for weeks to be sure and bring family, friends, and neighbors to the special service. This was to be a time to let people know we were a cool and hip church that did things differently. Yet, the services were not really like a typical Sunday morning service. Why not? This was a cool and hip church on a weekly basis, so why not have the same type of service? (I am talking about the style not the topic; it makes sense for the topic to focus on the holiday.) If visitors were to return, they would be attending a different style of church service from what they had experienced on special occasions. Why not be yourself and invite visitors?

80

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

SBG I worked for a company called SBG (I am using the acronym here for anonymity). I was in charge of marketing and had just finished the beta version of the website. The co-owner of the company, after spending many hours and dollars on design, told me to leave the company logo off the website. He explained that he did not think the logo was a good match for the company. I can understand his not liking the logo. What I do not understand is why he did not say anything before we had printed letterhead, business cards, and now a website with that logo. He told me many companies do not have a logo and picked up a magazine to show me all the companies that just had their name with no logo. There are many companies without a logo that just write their brand name in a font. A name written in its own unique and often-copyrighted font is a great branding tool. This is not the same as having a logo. When creating a visual presence and establishing a relationship, you should use all the branding tools available. A unique font and a logo are a minimal necessity. I told my boss that I respected his view. I felt it was my duty as the marketing director to point out the advantages of having a logo on the site, but I would respect his wishes. When it came time to launch the website, I did not have the heart to leave off the logo, particularly when the rest of the company loved the logo. I decided to leave the logo on the site. I was laid off a few weeks later - just a coincidence I’m sure.

The Numbers Game Would you like a V, 500 or 505 today? Not sure what I am talking about? These are the names of different personal digital assistants (PDA’s) made by Palm. I have worked in retail sales since I was a teenager. I had the opportunity to sell Palms for a while. It was difficult for me as the salesperson to keep it all straight, and the customers were very confused by all the numbers. Science has shown that it is easier for people to remember names than to remember numbers (another reason to attach products to a personality).
81

Marketing the Church

Eventually Palm came out with a new line of products. The high-end PDA was called the Tungsten T, and the low-end PDA was called the Zire. I was encouraged that Palm had learned from its mistake and now was using names that people could remember. But then Palm added the Tungsten C, the Tungsten W, and the Zire 71. If you are wondering what the 71 meant, nobody seems to know. These PDAs were all different prices with different features. This is even more confusing than just using numbers. At least in the past, each Palm had its own number; now different Palms had the same name too. Please do not name your product a number. Numbers are not attractive and do not have the ability to build relationships with people like actual names can (Key 5). Here is another tip: do not mix numbers and letters. Ever notice that it is harder to remember your license than your phone number? That is because our brains are made to handle either numbers or letters. Mixing the two only adds confusion. Stay away from names like Marketing4U. Besides being confusing and causing problems when creating a web address, they do not look professional.

Marriage The label reads: New Betty Crocker chocolate cake mix with real Hershey’s Chocolate Syrup. A popular trend is to partner with other companies or organizations to promote a product, but is this a good idea for the two companies? There are pros and cons to these types of partnerships. On the plus side, they can gain the synergy of combining the recognition of both companies. Those who do not know or trust Betty Crocker may be sold because they love Hershey’s. Each company gains access to the prestige and clientele of its partner. Minuses are when people do not buy the product because of the partner. Those who do not like Hershey’s (this does not include me, I love Hershey’s) will probably choose an alternate cake mix. When you partner with another company, you give up control of your most important asset: your brand image. If for some reason
82

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

the reputation of your partner is disparaged with your name attached, this has a negative impact on your image as well. The best way to understand partnerships is to look at a marriage. In the right circumstances, a marriage is a beautiful thing. It represents two coming together as one to do greater things than they could alone. Just as in marriage, the two should be independent and come together for mutual benefit, not because they are needy and are worthless alone. Breaking a partnership or violating the trust can end in a nasty, costly divorce. So if you decide to partner, choose wisely because it is a great commitment with risk involved.

Church Partnerships How does partnering apply to churches? Every time a vendor is allowed to sell its wares in the church lobby or advertise in the bulletin, your church is giving an implicit endorsement. Be careful about whom you choose to represent your church: Do not be yoked together with unbelievers. For what do righteousness and wickedness have in common? Or what fellowship can light have with darkness? (2 Corinthians 6:14)

Promises, Promises Brands are promises. The image presented by your brand promises to deliver on the commitments made by your marketing communications with consumers. Break your promises, don’t deliver on what you say you can do, and your image will be tarnished. Live up to, or better yet exceed, expectations and your relationship with customers will grow stronger. Meeting time and convenience needs is a major benefit to most consumers. For this reason many brand promises are based on providing more time or convenience. More importantly, brands themselves meet time and convenience needs.
83

Marketing the Church

When you look at an aisle of toothpaste boxes, you do not know which one will best meet your needs. If you see Brand X which you know and trust that says “whitens teeth better,” you can save time by grabbing that box of toothpaste and moving to the next item on your shopping list. But if there is a plain label brand that says it also will whiten teeth, do you try it? How do you know you can trust this product? You can take time to compare the labels and ingredients with the name brand. The only way you will know for sure is to take it home and try it. There is risk involved and potentially a lot of wasted time. It is safer, quicker, and more convenient to use the brand you already know and trust. Recently people have become more willing to try nonbranded items. Over time there has been an increased acceptance of non-branded items. However this is usually done at the expense of the brands themselves. Non-branded items or brands distributed under the retailer’s name are often placed right next to the branded products on the shelves to gain credibility. Do you remember the introduction of non-branded items to the supermarket? I remember a whole aisle of “generic” items packaged in plain black and white labels. You could buy a six-pack of white cans that had scrolled across the front in black letters “beer.” I enjoyed a large bag labeled simply “jellybeans” that had different sized jellybeans cast off from some candy factory as imperfect. If you are not old enough to remember the generic aisle, you might wonder where it went. Those items are still in the store, but the grocers wisely changed their strategy. Stores today have their own house brand names that usually include in the title Select, Choice, Premium, or President. Technically these products are no longer non-branded or generic. They carry the brand image of the store and rely on the trust the consumer has with the particular retailer. The reason for the shift is that plain generic products did not sell as well as those with at least a nominal amount of branding by carrying the name of the store. Brands are important because they are the guarantee and promise of the brand maker that the product is what it says it is.

84

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

What Does Your Church Promise? I’m not talking about the basics, like living a Christian life, but the details of how your church lives out the Christian walk. Are you a skateboarding church, a cowboy church, a postmodern church? If a teenage boy rides into your church on a skateboard, will he receive startled glances because your church is not equipped to reach skateboarders? If so, he will likely grab his stick and leave. Sometimes churches try to be everything to everyone yet end up reaching no one. A sharp focus on the mission and talents of your church from Keys 1 and 2 should help you find an identity. Being a skateboard church is not the best fit for most congregations. But can you imagine how excited a skater would be to be singing in the sanctuary and half-piping in the parking lot while worshipping God in both places? That’s cool.

A Word Keep it short and sweet. Consumers are inundated with a plethora of messages daily. The simpler and easier-to-remember the message is, the better. Companies should be able to describe themselves in a few words or, better yet, a single word. Much more than a sentence is not usually going to be remembered by the customer anyway. Think of the brands that have taken over the identity of a product: • • • • • Kleenex Ping Pong Band-Aid Rollerblade Roto-Rooter

Most people don’t even know that these are brand names because they come to represent the item itself. This is the goal of any brand marketer. Going directly counter to the strategy of a word standing for your product is the practice of line extension.
85

Marketing the Church

What’s Your Word? If you were to ask your congregation what one word describes their church, what would it be? Friendly, happy, spiritfilled, judgmental, open, closed? Would you get the same response from the pastor, the elders, and/or the community? What one word would you like to see represent your body? What can you do to make it happen?

Avoid the Line Extension Trap1 If you follow the prevailing logic of most modern companies, you will inevitably fall into this trap. Line extension is using an existing brand name or image and extending it to new products. Sounds like a good idea, right? Why not use the equity of your known brand to draw attention to a new product? The reason is that you tend to confuse customers as to what your brand means, and in the long run this strategy decreases overall market share. For example, in 1978 7UP was the lemon lime Uncola with a 5.7% share of the soda beverage market. Trying to capitalize on this significant market share, they created 7UP Gold, Cherry 7UP, and assorted diet versions. Logic would dictate that with a greater product offering they would have gained a greater share of the market. On the contrary, their sales plummeted to 4.2%. Line extensions confuse customers. Why do so many companies use line extensions if they tend to fail? I’m not really sure why they continue to ignore the data, but here are some possible reasons: • They don’t do their homework. If companies took the time to investigate the lack of success of line extensions by other brands and companies, they might think better of the idea.

1

Ries, Al. Focus: The Future of Your Company Depends on It. ©1996 HarperCollins Publishing, New York, NY. I highly recommend reading this book for a thorough explanation of line extension and the power of focusing a brand.

86

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Ego. They feel so successful with their current brand they think they can carry the momentum to the next item by slapping their name on the label. They also don’t think the seven keys to marketing apply to them. Copycats. Everyone else has line extensions so they reason that it is the proper strategy, not taking into account the number of line contractions that frequently occur. Appearance of success. An insidious feature of this trap is that line extension usually has initial success. Consumers are usually curious about the new product with a familiar name and will try the new item initially, but long-term sales plummet. Some line extensions become market leaders further muddling the argument. But in those cases, it is usually because their direct competitors are also using line extensions such as Diet Coke vs. Diet Pepsi. Appearance of growth. Most executives are paid to come up with ideas on how to grow the brand. By concocting new versions of a brand, it appears as though they are earning their paycheck since there are more items in the market with their brand name on the label. Appearance of cost effectiveness. It would seem that extending a brand would be cheaper, since the company already has a place in the mind of the consumer. On the contrary, it often costs just as many, if not more, marketing dollars to educate the public about the new product line. In many cases, brands try to reeducate their consumers about what their name means. They are changing the promises made by the original brand.

Denominations Denominations are a form of line extension. All of these different groups call themselves Christians and claim to be part of the church. The problem is that they use a variety of names: Catholic, Protestant, Baptist, Methodist, Reformed Southern Presbyterian, etc. This is very confusing. Although this book is not
87

Marketing the Church

an explanation of how to unite all of the denominations, this illustrates the point of why line extensions are not a good thing. Remember, people coming to your church for the first time probably are not aware of what the differences are or why the differences exist; they are just confused. The founders of the Restoration movement came from a Presbyterian background. When they were determining a name for their new church, they decided on the name Christian; to them it made the most sense. Churches from this movement are officially called Christian Churches. Part of their inspiration was to reduce the denominational factions and work on restoring the church as a whole. They figured if the body was going to unite under one name that the name Christian would be a logical choice. In marketing terms they attempted to contract the extension of the line by going back to the original name. So in Christ we who are many form one body, and each member belongs to all the others. (Romans 12:5)

No Splashing An example of line extensions is V8 Splash. V8 aired a commercial where a person drinking the new line of product is shocked to discover there is no tomato-y aftertaste. After decades of advertising and millions of dollars trying to get consumers to recognize V8 as a tomato beverage, they change the rules. In my book, this is a classic example of the line extension trap, and what not to do. Of course there are times when it is a good move to expand a company by offering more products. A better strategy is to use cobranding (same company, different brand names). Coke has found success in this area with Sprite. Imagine if Coke had named its product Lemon Lime Coke. Sounds strange, but think of the brands that have gone that direction. There is Pepsi Blue, which I still am not sure if it is berry colored, or berry flavored and I don’t really care to find out. The new Mountain Dew Code Red is another confusing moniker, why didn’t they just come up with a new name? But even
88

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

a giant like Coke does not learn from its own success and follows with Lemon Coke. Each product needs its own image and word associated with it. If you feel you have significant market share where you are and you need to expand into new markets, cobranding is the better route. Proctor and Gamble has built an empire on co-branded products. Silly Companies Why don’t they learn? You would never do such a thing at your church, or would you? Do you identify programs for diverse groups with the same name? Does your church have a Men’s Ministry for Women? It may sound strange, but I have come across even more bizarre titles.

Narrow Your Focus The 20th century taught businesses the power of specialization. Line extensions go against this theory by trying to make one brand all things to all people. As the saying goes “jack of all trades, master of none.” People may not realize it at a conscious level, but they do categorize and choose brands known for a particular specialty. For this reason, marketers must narrow the focus of their product. The brands that stick in the brain are those that have a narrow, sharp, and focused tip. The broader the description and lines of a brand, the less likely it is to pierce the consumer’s psyche. It is helpful to picture the brand as an actual object penetrating the brain tissue of the intended receiver. Imagine the customer standing in front of you with the top of his or her skull sawed off. The squishy gleaming brain matter is sitting exposed before you. If you are using a broad, expansive tool, it will not get past the gray matter. By creating a narrow focused point, the brand is able to puncture the brain tissue. I know this is a grotesque illustration, but I bet I got it to it stick in your brain.

89

Marketing the Church

What is Your Church’s Focus? If you were to strip away all of the programs, services, and board meetings, what would your church be about? What is the main focus? What are you trying to accomplish? Once you are clear on your focus, put all of the programs, services, board meetings (OK maybe not board meetings), and marketing back into place with this narrow focus in mind. Now you are a more efficient and lean functioning body.

Greatest Asset The greatest single asset of your company or organization is your image, also called brand or brand image. Why is this so important? Customers and partners relate to you based on how they perceive your reputation, behavior, and corporate personality. The same principle holds true of individuals. We trust people who are trustworthy, treat us with respect, and keep their word. The image of the organization must be in harmony with the purpose (Key 2) and consistently promote the competitive advantage (Key 1) that gives a rationale for choosing your company over the competition. Please realize that you cannot fake an image. Eventually your true self will be revealed to customers. You can spend billions of dollars promoting the great service you provide, but if salespeople treat your customers rudely, that money is wasted. Make sure you understand your advantage (Key 1) and that your whole company is in alignment with a purpose (Key 2) before promoting an image. Your image can be taken from you or destroyed by your own actions. Once you have made the investment to create an image, protect it at all costs because it is your greatest asset.

Reputation A brand in business represents the company’s reputation. What is your church’s reputation among members and in the community? How do non-Christians perceive you?
90

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Indecent Exposure Many people think any kind of exposure must be good. They say, “Look at the attention that company got from doing that wild publicity stunt.” Not all publicity is good, as we will discuss in Key 4: Promotion. A public relations department helps to ensure that your public perception is positive. If you gain exposure for your product, make sure it is for the right reasons and is sending the message you want to send about your brand image. While many feel it is important to “just get your name out there,” I disagree. You want your name to be well known for the right reasons. It is of no benefit if your name is known for being shoddy. Though Hitler, Stalin, and Charlie Manson are well known and publicized, they are not exactly popular fellows. The word for such exposure is infamy.

Sound Strategy If you have done the hard work of finding your advantage (Key 1) and defining your purpose (Key 2), you should not have much difficulty in creating an image (Key 3). The image is an expression of what the company is about. The important thing to remember is that you must stay focused and clearly communicate a concise message to the target audience. Now that you have a sound strategy, it is time to use promotion to communicate your message to the marketplace. And don’t forget to pray!

91

Marketing the Church

92

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

4
Key 4: Implement Promotions
Promotion is the nuts and bolts of the marketing process. The promotion element is what most consumers see and think of when you mention marketing. Before we tackle the promotion process, there are a few points to consider first.

Ideal Customer Who is your dream customer? If you are selling a hair growth product, the ideal customer is likely to be bald, or balding, and have a disposable income to spend on your product. When thinking of the ideal customers, try to envision them as actual persons standing before you. Where do they live? What kind of lifestyle do they enjoy? Determine as many traits as possible that characterize your ideal customers. Are they male or female? What is their age? Their income level? These demographic questions help you target your market more accurately. Be as specific as possible, because the more demographics you find for your ideal customers, the better equipped you are to meet their needs. Ideal customers will become advocates for your product, as discussed in Key 5: Building Relationships. The goal is to discover the ideal customers, then meet their needs better than the competition by using your competitive advantage(s) (Key 2).

Isn’t the Church for Everyone? Yes, the Church is for everyone, but the style or gifting of your particular local congregation may not appeal to everyone. If you try to appeal to everyone, you are more likely to appeal to no one. So if someone is looking for a rock and roll style Christian
93

Marketing the Church

music service yet you sing hymns, he or she might be better off attending another church. The competition for churches is not other churches, but Satan. As long as people are going to church somewhere, you have won. Therefore, you need to do your homework, stop making excuses and figure out the best way to communicate to the local people walking in your doors (or find out why they aren’t walking in the door). The great Christian philosopher Francis Schaeffer speaks of the Church’s challenge of meeting the unique demands of its age. This means that in every era the Church faces new competition for the hearts of people. It is incumbent upon each generation to define and meet the ideas that sets itself against the knowledge of God. We demolish arguments and every pretension that sets itself up against the knowledge of God, and we take captive every thought to make it obedient to Christ. (2 Corinthians 10:5) You must determine what influences your particular church body is opposing and how best to face them in a modern context.

Target Market Ideal customers, as pictured above, are persons for whom your product is an exact match. They will compose a larger group of your target market comprised of individuals who will likely purchase the product. You may be creating a new market, accessing a previously untapped market, or entering a mature market with plenty of competition. If doing the latter, be aware that you have your work cut out for you. You can be successful, but the odds are against you unless you position yourself properly. Use your competitive advantage to show your product as an alternative to the mainstream brand. If you are more focused on a particular segment of the market, you can steal market share from the big guys. For example, if I were to start my own shoe company, I would be facing plenty of competition since the shoe market is already saturated by big companies with big marketing dollars to spend. My only hope would be to focus on one piece of the market.
94

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

If I designed a shoe for tennis only, and called it the Racquet, I could go after the tennis portion of the market. The big name companies make all kinds of shoes, as well as clothing and other sporting goods. By focusing specifically on the needs of tennis players, I could attract the attention of that segment of the market. The big guys can’t compete because they have already marketed themselves as making shoes for all sorts of athletes. Use their line extension against them. The best they can do is co-brand and come into the tennis market segment under a new name, but you have the powerful advantage of being there first. I play hockey, so I will use an example of what I have seen happening in the hockey equipment market. The majority of the hockey market is comprised of conservative players with a love for tradition. The big names in hockey equipment have been around for generations. In the 1980s a new company called Itech designed a plastic face shield for helmets. This is a great name since their product was a new technology that protects the eyes. Hockey players accepted Itech because it was a new product focused on an area that had little, if any, special attention paid to it previously. Itech was the first face shield on the market and gained a positive reputation. Years later Itech started making sticks, gloves and helmets. They lost their identity as a face shield. What does a pair of gloves have to do with eye technology? The name no longer matches the product and becomes a hindrance instead of an enhancement. Itech should have stuck with making face shields. Now they look like all the other hockey equipment companies minus the history and prestige. Today there is another face shield on the market, Excel 1, which is known only for making face shields. Players think of face shields when they hear the name Excel 1. Mention Itech and no one is sure what product is meant. The question is whether Excel 1 will learn from Itech’s mistake or will they start making gloves also? More importantly, will you learn from their mistakes?

Saddleback When Rick Warren started Saddleback Church, he researched where the population was moving in Southern California. He is now
95

Marketing the Church

running one of the largest churches in the country on what used to be barren land. Rick Warren targeted a specific market for the church and presented the Gospel in a context the population could understand; consequently, he has been wildly successful. Of course he does not take all the credit and feels privileged to be a part of what God is doing in the area. To read the full story, check out his book The Purpose Driven Church.

The Four Ps Most descriptions of marketing include the four Ps, which are product, price, place and promotion. Some add a fifth P that stands for packaging (which can just as easily be covered as part of the P of product). Others have six or seven Ps. Rest assured the following four-P approach provides a suitable explanation of marketing. If you want to understand marketing, you have a firm foundation if you can remember these four simple Ps and what they signify.

Product The product is the item or items provided by the company for the consumer. Products are both tangible and intangible. Products may be physical items or a service provided. Many physical products also have some value-added service that accompanies the delivery of the physical item. Packaging is important because it is part of the product itself. Many people judge a book by its cover, so make sure you do not skimp on the packaging.

Price Any economics student can tell you that price is a matter of supply and demand. The market will bear a certain price point and settle into equilibrium. This is not very helpful when trying to
96

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

determine the price for a new product. Price is a very confusing area of marketing for many people. The reason is probably because price is one of the most misused and abused marketing tools. Traditionally, there are three ways to set the price for a product: Competitive Parity- charging the same price or average price of the competition. Standard Markup- always adding the same percentage markup to the cost of products (i.e., cost plus 50%). Zero-Based Pricing- receiving a small margin per item with a high volume of sales. The problem with all three of these methods is they do not take into account the customer’s perceived value of the product. Let’s assume I am going to sell hats. The hats cost me $10 to make so I decide to sell them for $15. What if the people buying my hats only think they are worth $5? I am in big trouble. I cannot afford to sell hats for less than they cost me to make, but if that is the perceived value to my customers I will not sell any at $15. On the other hand, what if customers love my hats and would actually be willing to pay $20 per hat? I am cheating myself out of $5 per hat. So how do you know what people will pay? Do the research before going to market. Either hire a market research firm, or do it yourself if you are on a budget. If people are willing to pay less than your cost to produce the hats, you will be avoiding disaster by knowing this information ahead of time. If people are willing to pay more than your perception of a fair price, you can be even more successful than you imagined. Your price must be based on the perceived value to the customer. Price is a double-edged sword, and many companies find themselves falling into the trap of competing on price. Price is NOT a competitive advantage by definition because it can be copied easily and immediately by the competition. Price wars with the competition hurt everyone. Customers will be happy at first because they will get better deals, but be disappointed in the long term when prices go back up or their favorite company goes out of business. Price wars destroy the perceived value of the product in the marketplace. Even if your company wins the price war by
97

Marketing the Church

undercutting the competition, customers will feel cheated when prices return to normal levels. I went to McDonald’s to get my 39-cent hamburger the other day, and to my dismay what had been 39 cents the previous six months is now all of a sudden 79 cents. I felt cheated, but if they had not been 39 cents the week before when I bought them, I would not have felt that paying 79 cents was a big deal. Like billions and billions of other people, I have been going to McDonald’s since I was a child. A few years ago they panicked and jumped into price wars with their competition. This was a mistake. By creating their own “value menu,” they started looking like everyone else. There is now nothing special about going there because they are just like their copycat competition. I just heard on the radio that McDonald’s is closing almost 200 locations. It does not sound like the low price strategy is working2. Low price is not a valid competitive advantage, yet companies spend millions of dollars saying they are the low price leaders. Low price has no distinguishing characteristic about it, particularly when everyone is saying the same thing. Companies are also telling their customers to shop based on price. Therefore, if their competition has a lower price, they should go to them. Let me repeat, companies are paying for advertising that tells their customers not to be loyal, but to shop based on low price! Besides encouraging a price war and creating disloyalty, this violates Key 5: Building Relationships. By telling people that the lowest price is the best criterion for choosing a product, companies are discouraging customer loyalty based on reputation or quality of service. This practice is so prevalent that it is no wonder many people are confused about the proper place of price in a marketing plan. The good news is that after reading this, you now know better than your competition.

2

McDonald’s has turned things around since I first wrote this section. They have been offering salads and healthier meals to attract bigger sales. These new products are not value priced. In fact many of the new offerings are the most expensive things on the menu. McDonald’s has been able to regain market share by differentiating away from price. They must have read my book.

98

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Price Church is free, right? Not really. It costs your visitors something to attend: fear, possible harassment, and if nothing else, time. Treat your visitors like paying customers. You will do a better job and they will appreciate your respect. Passing the Plate Passing the plate for offering is not visitor friendly. I have family members who believe the Church is in business to make money, that is why the Church passes the plate. When I explain to my family they do not need to give to the offering, they still feel pressured to put something in when the plate is passed to them. Although the speaker gives a disclaimer that it is not necessary for visitors to give, my family still feels obliged to put in money under these circumstances. Although giving to the Church is a sacrament and a responsibility for all Christians, does it need to be done publicly? Perhaps it would be better for Christians to give in secret? When you give to the poor, don't let anyone know about it. Then your gift will be given in secret. Your Father knows what is done in secret, and he will reward you. (Matthew 6:3-4) An alternative is to give members a way to tithe by placing offering plates in the back of the church, or by letting members mail in their offerings. People already motivated to give will find a way to present their offering without a plate being passed to them in their seat on Sunday morning. Think customer service; don’t scare away your customers (visitors) by being inflexible.

Place Ask what are the most important attributes that contribute to business success, and many will say location, location, location.
99

Marketing the Church

Where your business resides is indeed an important consideration. Opening an air conditioner store would likely be more successful in Arizona than in Alaska. Place also deals with distribution and logistics, a world unknown to most consumers. They don’t question how the milk got to the dairy aisle; they just pick up a carton and move on to the next item on their list. The steps involved in getting milk from a cow’s udder in Kansas to a pasteurized, homogenized, vitamin A&D fortified skim milk carton in a Safeway store in Oregon are fairly complicated. Each step in the distribution process is an opportunity for enterprising individuals to make a profit, and/or for manufacturers to keep costs low through disintermediation. Often it is more cost effective for manufacturers to focus on their competencies and to allow distributors to capitalize on their specialized abilities of distribution. The Internet revolution turned the traditional distribution model on its head. The question for most retailers today is whether to be a brick-and-mortar or a click-and-mortar store. Brick and mortar is a traditional physical location where consumers can visit a building to purchase products. Click and mortar is the name given to Internet businesses parodying the brick and mortar description. Companies expanding either on-line or to physical locations should avoid the line extension trap by giving each location its own identity. The Internet site should have a different name than the physical store and vice versa. Al and Laura Ries in their book The 11 Immutable Laws of Internet Branding call Law #1 the Law of Either/Or.3 Your business should be either on-line or a physical location, not both (at least not with the same name and branding). They also give some tips on determining the best choice for your product: • Is the brand tangible or intangible? The Internet tends to be a medium for tangible products and a business for intangible products (banks, stocks, insurance, etc.).

3

Ries, Al and Laura. The 11 Immutable Laws of Internet Branding. © 2000 HarperCollins New York, NY. Another great book from Al Ries written with his daughter Laura.

100

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Is the brand fashionable or not? Fashionable products (like clothing) tend to use the Internet as a medium, while non-fashionable products (like computers) tend to use it as a business. For clothes, how do you know if it will fit, what it will look like, and will it be comfortable? Is the product available in thousands of variations? If yes, then the Internet tends to be a better choice, because it is difficult for a retail store to house thousands of products. Half of customers leave retail stores without making a purchase because the item is not in stock. You should narrow your product line in retail, or you will lose customers who cannot find the model they want in stock. If you use the Internet, then a wide selection is a competitive advantage. Is low price a significant factor in the brand’s purchase? If yes, then the Internet tends to be a business. The ability to check many prices quickly is making the Internet a price-sensitive medium. This makes it difficult to make money with the Internet as a business. Are shipping costs a significant factor compared to the purchase price? If so, then the Internet tends to be a medium. Self-service has taken over the marketplace because it is more economical.

The Rieses recommend using the Internet as part of the overall integrated marketing communications strategy regardless of product. If the Internet site is not the business itself, then the Internet should still be used as a medium to promote the physical locations. One thing is certain, the Internet is a powerful IMC (integrated marketing communications) tool that is here to stay. We will cover the use of the Internet and interactive tools more in depth in the next section on promotion. Promotion Promotions are what most consumers relate to when discussing the marketing process. Promotion involves carefully
101

Marketing the Church

blending various elements of marketing communications to work in harmony with one another, enhancing, complementing and synergizing into a dynamic interactive message with the target audience. When done correctly, integrated marketing communications or IMC tools become the culminating force, which brings your marketing efforts to fruition. If you have done the hard work and laid the proper foundation by Defining Your Purpose (Key 1), Finding your Advantage (Key 2), and Creating an Image (Key 3), then you are more than ready to Implement Promotions (Key 4). Many companies don’t put in the effort to form their strategy first; instead they jump right into promotions. But what are they promoting? What is their purpose? What is their value proposition (competitive advantage) to the customer? What image are they trying to project? It makes sense to understand Keys 1, 2 and 3 before trying to tackle the promotion of Key 4. Think of each of the following methods: advertising, public relations/PR, sales promotion, direct marketing, and Internet/interactive as tools in your IMC toolbox. Like my dad used to say, “Don’t use a screwdriver when you need a hammer.” Always pick the right tool for the job. At the same time, IMC tools work together, hence the term integrated. An engine and four tires will not get you far, but put them together with the right parts and you have a speedy Ferrari. So use as many appropriate tools as possible to generate a synergistic marketing promotions campaign. The following descriptions are in no particular order.

IMC TOOL #1 ADVERTISING What is Advertising? Advertising is defined as paying a fee to create image and awareness. Effective advertising is aimed at new potential customers and always promotes the distinct competitive advantages of the organization. Sounds simple, right?

102

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Forms of Advertising There are the three main forms of advertising. Print advertising consists of magazines, newspapers, journals, brochures, flyers, etc. Broadcast advertising is found on radio, television, film, and other formats. Then there are various forms of interactive advertising including word of mouth, mobile ads on automobiles, tshirts, Internet sites, etc.

Current Customers Have you noticed how you receive advertising for products you already purchase? How frequently do you view or hear an ad for a product you currently use? This is a violation of the true purpose of advertising: to create image and awareness. You are already aware of the product, and you must have a favorable view of its image since you are purchasing it. Building on current relationships with customers (Key 5) is very important, but advertising is not the proper tool. If people are already customers, then advertisers should already know who they are. Advertising to current customers is not necessary and, besides being wasteful, can in some cases be counterproductive. I sometimes receive advertising material from companies of which I am already a loyal customer. In some ways, I am offended they do not know who I am. It’s like calling your mother on the phone and giving her a detailed explanation of who you are as though she does not already know. She would think there was something wrong with you. Advertising is aimed solely at potential customers, while current customers should receive targeted communications that acknowledge their unique relationship with the company. Don’t overlook the importance of the term potential. By potential I mean someone who would actually purchase the product. The majority of people are not ever going to buy your product no matter how much advertising you do to them, so why spend your finances trying?

103

Marketing the Church

Hitting the Target Television commercials are the most widely recognized form of advertising. When I ask my marketing students on the first day of class for an example of marketing, they usually talk about television commercials. Usually their favorite commercials are beer commercials (remember, these are college students). Budweiser and Bud Light have some of the funniest commercials. Many people have seen these commercials and will even imitate the characters. I often ask my students to raise their hands if they have seen a particular Budweiser commercial and if they like it and/or think it is funny. Almost all of the students raise their hands. Then I ask them, “How many of you drink this beer?” In all of my classes only a few, if any, raise their hands. Do they not drink beer? No, they just drink different beer from the ones advertised by Anheuser-Busch. This leads to a discussion about targeting new potential customers. Most of the people who see these commercials are not, and will not ever be, customers for Anheuser-Busch, so who cares what they think? There is no return on the advertiser’s investment for these students to see the commercial. The advertiser is paying to reach this audience who does not buy the product; therefore there is no return on investment for this audience. While no advertising can be perfectly targeted, the more targeted, the better. When unintended viewers are receiving your message, you are wasting money. Even worse, if they do not like the advertising (i.e., think it is funny), you might be creating antagonists out of potential future customers. The more targeted the message, the more effective, the less expensive, and the greater the return on investment. We will go more in depth into this concept in Key 5 when we look at the Marketing Funnel.

Accountability So if mass advertising is so ineffective, why do people do it? First of all, they obviously have not read this book and are misinformed. Most people do what they see others doing, or what has worked in the past. There is also an entire industry based on “the bigger and more creative the better” ideology. Advertising executives give each other awards for creating unique
104

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

advertisements. Unfortunately I see a lack of accountability in the current system. Bottom line, it does not matter how good the production quality is for an advertisement; what matters is whether people buy the product. It is a good strategy to use high standards for creating ads, but it has to be a means to the end of consumers understanding the message and buying the product. Some of the worst produced advertisements (i.e., infomercials) are successful because they sell the product.

Stewardship Your church has a big responsibility to be good stewards of the resources provided by God. Make sure you do your homework when paying for marketing communications. Hire or work with gifted people who are able to maximize the impact of your efforts. ShineFish (www.shinefish.com) specializes in helping churches and non-profits maximize their limited finances while taking advantage of their unique gifts and status.

Nissan A few years ago Nissan ran a series of ads with an old man standing in a field. The camera would fly around and then circle around his face. What did the ads mean? What were they trying to say? What advantages were they trying to promote? No one really knows, but the ads were creative. Speaking with an employee at the Nissan offices, she said she had no idea what the ads meant, nor did anyone else in her office. They were confused and did not really like the campaign. Eventually, Nissan changed the campaign, but what exactly they were trying to communicate will remain a mystery. Are you willing to spend millions of dollars to create a “cool” ad that no one understands? Raisins Oh, those adorable California raisins, dancing across the table! Can you hear them singing, “I heard it through the
105

Marketing the Church

grapevine”? Who did not love those darling claymation creatures of the 80s? They were so popular they even had their own Saturday morning cartoon. And you would think that the sales of California raisins must have been prosperous during this time, but you would be wrong. Sales of California raisins actually declined during the campaign. This proves there’s a big difference between entertainment and selling the product.

Got Sales? Arguably, one of the best-known advertising campaigns of all time is the series of got milk? commercials. I love these commercials; they are hysterical. But as you can probably guess, they have not to date improved milk sales. In fact, they are considered successful because milk sales stopped declining for a while. Maybe I have high standards, but I expect a campaign to improve sales, not keep them stagnant.

ROI The criterion for success must be the ROI, return on investment (i.e., people buying the product), not people liking the advertisements. I believe advertising agencies have tended to avoid being specific about returns for two reasons. One, they don’t really know how effective they are because they do not have systems in place to truly measure effectiveness. Second, they know there is a lot of waste and they do not want to discourage their clients. That’s why advertising talks about making impressions on viewers. If this is the case, just say “I don’t do impressions,” and ask for sales to be made instead. Typically, sales are the measure of success, but as any statistics student will tell you, correlation is not necessarily causation since there are other intervening variables. In English this means that just because sales increased does not mean that the advertising was the cause; it could have been something else. For example, if you run a radio ad for hot dog buns on the fourth of July and sales
106

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

spike for that weekend, it is not necessarily because of the ad, but because more people are barbecuing for the holiday. In fact, if you are not measuring effectiveness, you could be running counterproductive ads. What if more people would have bought your hot dug buns, but they did not like the ads so they bought another brand, or ate hamburgers? You could deduce from the spike in sales that the ad had been effective, when in fact you could have sold more with a better ad, or no ad at all. If you are not measuring properly, you will waste money and, worse yet, you could be paying to cause damage to your image.

Internet Bubble In the late 90s the Internet was riding high as the vital component of the information revolution. Internet company founders were getting rich overnight. Investors were pouring billions into what appeared to be the next big thing. By 2000 there seemed to be trouble, and many Internet companies started to go out of business. A major reason why the Internet bubble burst is that people were basing their business model on the selling of advertising on their sites. The remarkable advantage of the Internet as we will discuss further below, is that it is measurable. The Internet does not try to guess how many people look at a site, or click on a banner ad, or purchase a product from a banner ad for that matter, it can actually measure all of those things in real time and real numbers instantaneously. This is a Copernican revolution in terms of advertising. It was also the death of many of the businesses based on selling Internet advertising because they were still trying to sell based on impressions, but such fantasies are not needed nor tolerated in the Internet world. Linkage So if advertisers seem to be unaccountable for results, what is the answer? This is a complex problem, and if you can figure out an effective answer, you will be rich. It is impossible to completely measure all advertising, but some methods are better than others. I
107

Marketing the Church

have already mentioned the capabilities of the Internet to evaluate sales. If you need hard numbers, the Internet is a tremendous tool. For other advertising methods, use some kind of linkage that can be tracked. If you send coupons to consumers, place a code on them so you can track which ones were redeemed and by whom. If you do a television commercial, add a web address or telephone number on the screen. Place the same information in other media, such as magazines. When consumers log into the site or call, ask them how they heard about the company. You can also set up unique web addresses for specific ads to see which ones are more effective. If most of your inquiries are coming from the magazine ad, then you can ditch the television commercial and its costs. All your advertising should provide some kind of linkage that provides you feedback about its effectiveness. Without this data, it is difficult to justify advertising costs. This information is also vital in creating more targeted advertising and building relationships with current customers (Key 5).

Inward-Focused Jargon Many companies fall into the trap of inward-focused jargon. That’s why we see so many acronyms. They expect people to know, or want to figure out, what XYZ means. You may have noticed I used the acronym ROI above, but was sure to immediately explain the meaning. I hate to bruise corporate egos, but I have to tell them that most people don’t really care what their acronym means. Using terminology that makes sense to you but not to new potential customers in advertising is counterproductive. Marketing, and advertising in particular, is about communication. The more clear and simple the message is the better. Instead of trying to be cool, just try to be understood. If you can do it in a cool way, that’s even better, but cool without understanding is just a waste of money. Brown? UPS started a campaign where they asked, “What can Brown do for you?” Since I am interested in marketing, I asked, “Who is Brown?” and started investigating. I wrongly assumed that Brown
108

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

must be the name of their new package-tracking software. I spoke with a UPS representative that told me Brown was the nickname for UPS given to it by the employees. So the answer to the mystery of what Brown stands for, and why they are spending millions of dollars on advertising, is that it means UPS. Do you see anything wrong with this picture? If not, start rereading this section from the top. Why spend so much money to advertise a second name for the same company? They already have spent millions to distinguish their three-letter acronym of a name in our minds; now they want to throw more cash at an extra name? Why spend so much money to confuse people? This is a sign that UPS has become inward focused. They are more concerned with having fun with an inside joke of a nickname than in reaching their customers.

Should Churches Advertise? In most cases it is not the best use of a church’s limited resources to pay for advertising. Typically you will not be successful trying to use a hard sell approach to get people to come to your church. It is very unlikely someone will attend a church after seeing a traditional advertisement. If your church does decide to advertise, hopefully the time is donated, the best way to leverage the opportunity is to promote events or other sales promotions (see IMC Tool #3). Use the ad to invite people to the church for a barbeque, a concert, or a Christmas play. People’s hesitation to visiting will be lowered and thus more people will respond.

Alternatives Good advertising promotes image and awareness of the distinct competitive advantage(s) of the product to new potential customers. There is a world of difference between advertisements based on sound marketing principles and those produced for the amusement of the creators. With all the potential dangers and
109

Marketing the Church

expense of advertising, is there a better alternative? Yes there is, read on…

IMC TOOL #2 PUBLIC RELATIONS/PUBLICITY Free Advertising? What if I told you that you could receive free advertising that would be more effective than any you could possibly purchase, would you take it? Welcome to the world of public relations (PR) and publicity. PR/publicity is non-paid coverage by the media. Smart and/or thrifty organizations use the media to their advantage. The advantages of PR and publicity to send marketing messages is that it is free and that it is more credible with the recipients, since it is assumed to be provided by an objective source. The disadvantage is that there is little or no control over what is reported, and a negative or distorted marketing message can be reported.

Sewn of the Same Cloth What’s the difference between PR and publicity? That depends on whom you ask. I distinguish the two by separating them into proactive and reactive forms of the same process. Publicity is actively seeking media attention or offering a particular message to news and community organizations. PR is handling and/or spinning public perceptions and reports about the company. Corporations have caught on to the benefits of PR/publicity and usually employ a PR person or department. Now you know what happens to all those athletes majoring in PR. Typically, coverage comes from news agencies like local radio and television stations that are called to cover an event sponsored by the company. Coverage is free, but be careful because you have no control over how you are represented. Opening a new factory that provides local jobs may seem like a positive boost to the economy, but the media may portray you as an eco-terrorist destroying precious habitat. Remember to use the right tool for the job. PR and publicity may not cost money, but it could cost your
110

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

reputation. In some cases when media response is in doubt, it is better to pay for advertising so you can control the message. In the long run, this is cheaper than defaming your image and trying to rebuild. Don’t overlook the importance or the value of positive PR and publicity, but be aware of the risks involved.

PR for Churches If your church is living out the Gospel and making a difference in the community, you will simply need to share what you are doing with the media. I hear complaints about how the media has a negative view of Christians and portray them harshly, but what are you doing to change that image? Is your church doing good by clothing the homeless, feeding the hungry, and caring for the fatherless and the widows? Let the media know what your church is about. There are plenty of good reporters out there who would love to do a feel-good story. Imagine the impact your church could have if every time someone opened the newspaper there you are! Imagine people saying, “Oh look what that Marketing Genius Church is doing today. Do they ever stop doing good?” In a way the Bible is a PR piece. It is not paid advertising, and the people who wrote were recording the facts like it was news. In fact the word Gospel means Good News. So the next time your church does a service project, make sure to share the Good News with your community. PR Help A low cost way to get great press exposure is to write and distribute a release on the Internet. You have a great deal of control because you are crafting the release and making it available to the media. To find out how to leverage this low cost high impact tool check out the PR Zap! website (www.przap.com).

111

Marketing the Church

IMC TOOL #3 SALES PROMOTION

Promoting Sales Sales promotion is a good way to break into a market by providing a motivator for new customers to try your product. Sales promotion is usually confused with personal selling because the term sales is used. While they work well when used together, they are very different techniques. Personal selling is the process of interaction between the seller and the consumer while sales promotion is the use of specific incentives or rewards to induce trial of a product.

Churches Can Do This Don’t get hung up on the terminology here. I am not asking your church to become a used car sales lot. What you are selling is the invitation to attend your church and ultimately to accept Christ. The tips in this section will help you reach that goal, and still be Christian in the process.

Inducing Trial Sales promotions typically offer a discount, rebate, or reward for trying a new product thus reducing the perceived risk for new clients to try a product. For example, if I can buy the new Brand X toothpaste for half price with a coupon, then theoretically I have reduced the risk of trial by 50%. The idea is that once the clients try the product, they will be sufficiently impressed to continue to purchase the product at the regular price. You are demonstrating to the consumer faith in your own product by providing incentives.

112

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

What Risk? What risk is faced by the people that attend your church for the first time: Persecution, financial loss, humiliation, loss of family, embarrassment, wasting time? What steps can you take to minimize the risk for your visitors?

Types of Sales Promotion There are many types of sales promotions. Most of what we see is on the consumer side, but a majority of sales promotions are given to wholesalers and sales people for selling a product. Most consumers are familiar with coupons as a popular form of sales promotion. Some others include buy one, get one free; free with purchase packs; bonus-size packages; in-store specials and sales; contests; loyalty programs; sweepstakes and rebates. Most sales people work on some kind of commission where they receive a percentage of what they sell. They also receive all sorts of promotional items, such as t-shirts, key chains and coffee mugs with the sponsoring company’s name emblazoned on the front. These giveaways to sales people are commonly called tchotchkes. Many times sales of individual products will also provide sales people with an additional reward called a sales performance incentive fund (SPIF). So a shoe salesman may make a 2% commission on every pair of shoes sold, but he also may make an extra $5 when he sells a pair of Nikes.

Buyer Beware Sales promotions given to sales people can cause problems for consumers and retailers. If you have unscrupulous or untrained sales people, they are likely to sell a customer a product that he or she does not need so that they can make a SPIF. Many retailers stopped providing incentives because they had too many problems with sales people pressuring customers to buy items with incentives, which lead to declining sales. When purchasing products, I will ask
113

Marketing the Church

the salesperson whether their recommendation is based on using the product and/or if they get a commission. I have been in retail sales for many years and have never sold an item because I got a SPIF, but it was tempting. I liked to sell the item with a SPIF because I made more money, but it was not worth my integrity. This was not always the case with my coworkers. I worked for the national nutrition store GNC where we received no commission, but we did get a SPIF on certain items. One customer returned a product my coworker sold her because she had trouble sleeping when she used it. My coworker told her we were out of the product she asked for (which was a lie) and that this one would do the same thing (which was also a lie). He also did not tell her that the guarana in the product is a form of potent caffeine even though she said would be taking it before bedtime. What did he get for compromising his integrity by lying to a customer and disrupting her life by keeping her up all night? $2. Manufacturers, to boost sales of their products, often use SPIFs. They are usually effective, but they must be done carefully and given to trustworthy persons. In the meantime, be wary if a salesperson is a little too excited about a product, and don’t be afraid to ask questions.

Sunday School Challenge A church I attended promoted a Sunday School challenge to increase the attendance at Sunday School for a month. A big tote board, placed in the front of the sanctuary, showed all of the attendance figures. The pastor would review each week’s totals and reveal which class was in the lead. It reminds me of the sales board we had when I was in a high-pressure sales environment as a financial advisor. The intentions were pure; it is a great thing to want to increase attendance in Sunday School, but how might visitors feel? Are they thinking that they are simply part of the big contest? Are they really cared about by the people who invited them? Would they have been invited without the contest?
114

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Putting together incentives that appeal to internal and external people is tricky. This is true in business and in the church. Be creative and sensitive to your customers (visitors) in the process.

Rethinking Rebates Those ads in the paper have some great prices, but then you read the fine print and it says, “after rebate.” Why do companies use rebates? When I ask most people this question, they say it is because a lot of people will not send in the rebate form and the manufacturer keeps the money. Does this sound like a good strategy? It is not wise to have people angry with you because they missed a rebate deadline, or to think you are manipulating them out of their deserved cash. This is the opposite of building relationships (Key 5) with customers. Rebates tend to confuse people and, by their nature, are manipulative. They say the price is one amount, but you pay another. You have to cut off this code, copy that receipt, jump through a hoop and do it by a deadline. Do you really want people associating this unpleasant experience with your company? If you can afford the rebate, a better alternative is to lower the price, or offer a short-term promotion. I hate filling out rebate forms, so I beg you manufacturers, for the sake of humanity and my personal sanity, please stop the rebate confusion.

Linking Sales Promotions It is important that sales promotion activities are used in conjunction with advertising and public relations/publicity activities. So if you are going to promote a sweepstakes, place the details in an advertisement. Let’s say you are giving away a dream vacation. You could place an ad in a magazine with a sweepstakes entry form. The form should be coded so you know the magazine and the date and can track the effectiveness of the ad. The consumer is exposed to two IMC tools at the same time, which provides synergy.
115

Marketing the Church

Promotions should also link to the product when possible. If you sell pasta, you could give away a trip to Italy; that also reinforces the authentic nature of your product. IMC tools work best when linked to each other as well as provide the manufacturer the ability to track consumer information. Christian Incentives Make sure your incentives to visitors fit in with the overall mission and purpose of the church. I have heard stories of churches giving away microwaves and trips to Las Vegas to encourage visitors to attend. Things like a free concert, a Christian CD, or a complimentary retreat weekend are more appropriate for churches.

Turn It Off Sales promotions should be used for only a limited time and should be turned off quickly. Always have an expiration date - the shorter, the better. Long-term expirations diminish urgency for consumers. Often they will set the offer aside and forget about it until it is too late. Another reason to limit their duration is that extended or continual sales promotion activities lead to a devaluation of the product in the eyes of clients. If there is always a coupon available for half off, they will not ever want to pay full price. The goal is to get customers to use the product and then pay the regular market price. Unlimited sales promotion for an item is not really sales promotion; it is a lowering of the price, which is not a good idea. As we discussed earlier, using price as a marketing tool is a trap because it could lead to a price war.

No War Excess sales promotions by one company usually lead to retaliation by competitors. Each side continues to lower the
116

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

perceived value of its product until both are in trouble. Consumers are usually happy but, in the long term, price wars affect everyone. If one of the companies goes out of business, then people lose their jobs. In other cases, one company outlasts the competition and is able to take over the market. They then raise their prices higher than they were at the start. I’m for a free market economy and I believe that the market corrects itself, so you have the freedom to lower prices and use sales promotions as much as you desire, but smart businesses will differentiate away from price.

Don’t Send Coupons to Customers If you have read this section so far, then it should be obvious why this is a bad idea; but just in case I’ll reiterate the reason. Coupons (and sales promotions) should be used to induce trial. Since current customers have already tried the product, there is no need to induce trial.

Retaining Customers In the advertising section, I warn not to send advertising to current customers but to send them targeted customized communications. Customer retention and loyalty programs are a way to show gratitude, promote continued use of the product, and encourage customers to be advocates to family and friends. Frequent shopper cards, premiums and thank-you letters are a few ways to express appreciation and build relationships (Key 5) with current customers.

Firing Customers A big complaint I hear about using sales promotions is that people do not use the product without the incentive. My parents own an Italian restaurant. My father tried running some coupons in the direct mail pack, but he was not happy with the response. He says the only people that used them were paying in pennies and
117

Marketing the Church

looking for more deals. They also did not return later to make fullprice purchases. The first problem is poor targeting. The wrong people got the promotion. This is another reason why you should not run promotions indefinitely. If ideal customers that enjoy the food had gotten the coupon, they would have tried it and then returned to pay full price. If you do get customers that are not ideal, or worse yet are anti-customers, fire them. These are not the kind of people with whom you are trying to do business. They will only look for bargains and try to take from you. They will not build a positive reciprocal relationship with you (Key 5), so fire them.

Firing Members I’m sure there are a few faces that come to mind when you read the above headline, all churches have some problem people. My friend Craig, a Children’s Minister, affectionately calls some of these people EGR’s (extra grace required). I am not referring to people who need patience and grace, they need your church. But, some folks are quarrelsome, blasphemous, and/or are destructive to the congregation. Paul gives an example of what to do with these kinds of people: Holding on to faith and a good conscience. Some have rejected these and so have shipwrecked their faith. Among them are Hymenaeus and Alexander, whom I have handed over to Satan to be taught not to blaspheme. (1 Timothy 1:19-20) Paul was not happy with these guys. They were having a negative impact on the church body, and Paul does not put up with it for long. It is noble to be longsuffering, but you must make sure your church is not being destroyed in the process.

118

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Cause Related Marketing A very effective sales promotion strategy is the use of cause related marketing in which organizations create or partner with other charitable organizations or causes. When teaching my Sales Promotion course at the university, I use a book I highly recommend reading called Brand Spirit.4 Cause related marketing is a great concept, because it is a win/win/win/win for the company, its employees, the charity and consumers. The company wins because they have an increase in the perceived value of the product since they are contributing to charity. They are better able to differentiate themselves from competitors. The employees of the company win because they are helping to contribute to society through their efforts. It can be difficult to find meaning in your work, particularly if you are making mundane consumer products. On the other hand, if your company contributes to a good cause, it brings meaning and purpose to your activities. Obviously this is a win for the charity since they are receiving needed funds. Lastly, cause related marketing is a win for the consumers since they are helping a worthy cause with their otherwise ambiguous consumer purchases. When possible you should match the cause to the product. There are two ways to go about cause related marketing campaigns. Either start your own, or partner with an existing philanthropy. We spoke of the pros and cons of partnering earlier, and the same principles apply here. For those who have the resources, creating their own charity or foundation is a wise choice since they wholly own the entity and its image. So if you want to promote your new dog food Fluffy Time, you should start the Fluffy Time Foundation to rescue fluffy dogs. Portions of the sales from Fluffy Time dog food go to support the foundation. The foundation directly correlates to the product and reinforces a positive image in the consumer’s mind. The foundation is a great way to achieve free publicity. The public views you as a caring company thus increasing your perceived value. Besides differentiating yourself from the competition, studies have shown
4

Brand Spirit : How Cause Related Marketing Builds Brands by Hamish Pringle & Marjorie Thompson

119

Marketing the Church

that people are willing to pay a premium to purchase products that help a cause. The employees of the company can feel good about helping these fluffy little creatures to live a long and healthy life. The Fluffy Time Foundation receives funding to help our fluffy friends in need. Consumers can buy your product with a smile, knowing they are helping others.

Sincere Causes If the above sounds like crass commercialism, it could sound the same way to consumers. That’s why causes must be sincere. If the company and its employees are not truly behind the cause, then the campaign could backfire. Many people have been critical of the plethora of products that have partnered with various breast cancer charities. They have been questioned as to whether they are trying to help women or sell products. I believe this is especially the case when companies are asking consumers to mail in yogurt lids and admonishing them to “help lick breast cancer.” In my mind, there are a lot of things wrong with this tagline, but I will let you use your imagination as to why. Filling out a rebate form is bad, but mailing in sticky lids is even worse. There are few things more difficult to send in than a yogurt lid. If you do cause related marketing, do it for the right reasons and with sincerity, or it will have a negative impact on your image.

Old Cause, New Tricks There has been more cause related marketing lately, but is this a new idea? Cause related marketing has been going on for the last century, but it is increasing today. When modern marketing began in the Western countries, the population was living on a subsistence level. Advertising promoted the value of products and went into technical details of what the item could do for the customer. In the late 60s there was a cultural and financial shift. People had more money and they were tired of the same old advertising. People were also disillusioned with materialism, so ads
120

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

started to emphasize the emotional. Perfume ads talked about how the scent made you feel like a woman, not how big the bottle was. Today we are living in one of the most prosperous times in history. People have also realized consumer products cannot provide for emotional needs no matter how appealing the advertising. At the same time there is a lack of community. People, especially prosperous people, like to give to society. Since there is a distrust and lack of participation in traditional institutions like churches, many people do not have an outlet to give to their communities. Consumer products come to the rescue. Cause related marketing meets additional time and convenience needs of consumers by letting them have their Duncan Hines cake mix and contribute to charity too. For psychology buffs, I will point out that this pattern correlates with Abraham Maslow’s hierarchy of needs model. Consumers used to be just scraping to survive so advertising appealed to their base needs of survival. Next there was advancement to the next level of emotional needs. Finally today, we are at the pinnacle of the hierarchy: self-actualization, fulfillment by giving to others.

Churches and Cause Related Marketing A big reason why Cause Related Marketing has gained ground in the business community is because fewer people are attending and/or giving at church. This has created a vacuum because people were created with the desire to give, it makes them feel good. When businesses partner with a charity, they are giving customers a way to connect with the community and feel good about giving. Take advantage of this opportunity, and look for ways your church can partner with local businesses to share the wealth, it’s a win for everyone.

121

Marketing the Church

Use Them for Good, Not Evil Sales promotions are a powerful tool. When done right, they can be very effective. When misused, they can bring disaster. Many times the success or failure of sales promotion is dependent upon the sales people.

IMC TOOL #4 PERSONAL SELLING Sell it Personal selling involves the people of the organization that directly interact with clients. Even if they do not realize it, the people that interact with the public are “selling” the organization by the way they speak, behave, and represent themselves. Personal selling is a form of direct marketing because there is direct contact with clients and potential clients. Smart organizations make sure their sales people are aware of their importance and equip them for the role. They also mine the treasure trove of information available from salespeople and have systems set up to perform the task of gathering this data.

Called to Sell As a Christian you were called to the world of selling, selling the Gospel. Of course we call it something different: evangelism. As is the case in a typical business, the same holds true for Christians, everyone is responsible for sales and marketing. This does not mean you have to be a slick salesperson that goes door to door or greets everyone that walks in the church. It does mean that you play a part in the process of selling (or evangelizing) whether you like it or not.

122

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Lifelong Personal Seller Personal selling is a topic near and dear to my heart. I have worked various retail positions for almost 20 years. My first job was working at a drugstore when I was 15. I was a part-time soda jerk at the snack counter and part-time front counter salesperson. I have worked for a sporting goods store, two health food stores, a hockey pro-shop, and a store that sells paper and electronic planners. I have also spent hundreds of hours on the phone as a financial advisor and telemarketer. I have learned a thing or two about sales over the years.

On the Front Line Ask any general how battles are won and lost, and they will tell you the frontline soldier makes the difference. Even in this modern age of computers and unmanned drones on the battlefield, it is still the humans running the machines that make the difference. In marketing, the salesperson is the one on the front lines and makes the difference to marketing success.

Christians on the Frontline It does not matter how great your pastor is, how nice the building looks, or how much parking is available if the members of the church are not friendly, outgoing, and genuine. The individual members of the church are on the front line. Your Church’s success depends on how well the members reach out to people.

The Weakest Link Poor personal selling tends to be a weak link for many companies. You can do all the advertising and promotion in the world, but it will not matter if your potential customers and customers are not treated well by the salespeople. This is called
123

Marketing the Church

providing good customer service. The term is a misnomer for many businesses; in fact a consumer advocate has labeled these the “customer no-service departments” of companies. Often the promotions can create expectations that the sales staff are not prepared to meet. When I worked for the nutrition store GNC, they did extensive advertising. They ran numerous television ads and had several beautiful full-color ads in all the exercise magazines. They had to be spending several million dollars per year on these ads. At the store level, we were paid minimum wage with no commission, but we did receive occasional SPIFs (see definition above). I knew nothing about vitamins and health products when I started, and was looking forward to learning about them on the job. GNC did have a training program, but in my case I received no training from my manager. I like to learn new things on my own so I was motivated to learn about all of the health products. I studied the books in the store and read all the labels on the packaging. I would ask customers questions such as “What are you using this product for? Is it working well for you? Have you tried the GNC brand?” I was able to get into the minds of my customers. I learned a great deal of good information by surveying people on what worked and what did not. I also tried all the popular products to see what worked for me. I was then able to make recommendations to customers based on personal experience. I did a good job at GNC and the customers liked me. I was praised for selling the most “gold cards” (a frequent customer discount card) on a regular basis. I was very knowledgeable about the product because I was personally motivated to learn. On the other hand, I had a coworker that had been there before I started but knew very little about the product, did not like health foods, did not interact with customers, and sold items that would get him a SPIF even if it was not a good match for the customer. If you owned this store, which employee would you rather have wait on your customers? As a customer, which of us would you prefer to wait on you? While I enjoyed working at GNC, I had to leave to get a better paying job.

124

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Bright Flight Bright flight is the process of all the smart people leaving a business. Typically, this happens because the smartest and most talented people realize when a business is not run well or they are not being compensated adequately. If you want to attract and retain quality people, you must pay them what they are worth. Bear in mind that studies have shown money is not the primary motivator for most people. Employees are willing to receive less pay for pleasant working conditions. Pay is a motivator, but how employees are treated is also a big factor in their dedication to a company. It is probably cheaper to treat people with respect than to pay them enough that they will work at a job they do not like. You must either pay your people well or treat them right. You are better off doing both.

Church Flight If you do not provide a way for your members to get involved and participate in ministry, they will leave. I have spoken with several frustrated pastors who cannot get people to step up to the plate and participate. At the same time, I and some of my talented friends, have been extremely frustrated by the lack of opportunity to serve. People who are willing and able to serve will seek out the opportunity; if they are shut down, they will look elsewhere. This does not necessarily mean they will serve at church, however. My passion and gift is teaching. I teach, coach, and write books like this one, it is what I want to do; it is what God has gifted me to do. While speaking with an assistant pastor, I mentioned I would like to use my teaching skills to minister at the church. He informed me that only he and the senior pastor did the teaching. He said if I felt strongly about using my gift I should look elsewhere. He then gave the example of a young woman who approached him wanting to sing more; he told her to find a church with a larger music program. I found another way to serve by coaching a local youth hockey team. Coaching was a great experience, but the problem was
125

Marketing the Church

I had little motivation to try to minister at my church again. Why do I have to fight the pastor to serve at my church? Because I equate service and ministry with worship, I have difficulty with a pastor telling people they cannot minister (i.e. worship) at his church, and they should go somewhere else. The role of paid staff and pastors is to get people into ministry and to support them in their efforts, not to do all the ministering themselves without volunteers. If your church is struggling with getting people involved, then ask yourself what systems are in place to get people plugged in and connected in ministry. If you have not had anything in place for years, or the pastor has always done everything, then your longtime members are probably comfortable with the arrangement. You might still be able to inspire them to get involved, but the people that really want to be a part of ministry will have left a long time ago. It is not too late.

Training Pays Studies have shown that the average return on investment for training is 20 to 1. That means for every $1 you invest in your employees you should see a $20 return in productivity. That’s a tremendous return not found in most places in the business world. Training helps businesses to attract and retain quality people. Quality candidates are attracted to companies with good training programs. When hiring people, you have three alternatives. First, hire someone and train him or her to do the job well. Second, hire someone who already knows how to do the job. The problem with this choice is that it is much more expensive to hire someone who already knows how to do the job. Third, pray for a miracle because if they do not know how to do the job and you do not train them, it will have to be a miracle for them to succeed. Train your people.

Christian Education This is an area of strength for churches in the United States.
126

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Most churches appreciate education and spend time enlightening the congregation through sermons, small groups, seminars and retreats. In fact, Christians founded the majority of the educational institutions in the United States. One area of weakness, however, is a lack of real world knowledge about culture and business. How many books have you seen like the one in your hands that integrates modern business practices with Christian application and scripture?

Five Factors for Personal Selling Success First, let salespeople try the product. If your product is as good as you think, they will become advocates for the product (Key 5). Second, train them in the product. Knowledgeable salespeople are confident and will help establish a positive relationship with customers (Key 5). They are less likely to make mistakes and tend to be more satisfied with their job. Third, provide a pleasant environment. The best people look for and stay in good working environments. Fourth, pay salespeople well. Proper financial compensation is another way to keep and attract quality people. Last but not least, get feedback from your salespeople (Key 6). They will feel valued and you will cull priceless information.

IMC TOOL #5 DIRECT MARKETING Go Direct Direct marketing is a customized message for a specific target audience. Some information is already known about this audience to whom relevant targeted advertising materials are sent. To be effective, research has to be done about prospective customers before sending these materials.

Buying Lists Has your church bought a list to do mailings to the
127

Marketing the Church

surrounding area? If you did, you probably discovered that this is a very expensive process and usually results in only a few, if any new visitors. I applaud the effort to use marketing techniques to enhance communication; the problem with this approach is that direct mail does not work well for anyone anymore, let alone churches.

Get the Facts Several companies sell marketing lists that contain names of people that fit a particular demographic. These can be useful in some cases, but you are still reliant on the quality of research provided by an outside source. The best way to find information is to get it yourself. Most organizations already have a relationship with current customers and should be implementing tools to better serve them. You can provide a valuable service to your customers by offering them products of use to them. You can also annoy them into the arms of competitors with useless, ceaseless, irrelevant marketing. Gain feedback (Key 6) from customers then adjust your marketing messages (Key 7) to make your offerings relevant and build a better relationship (Key 5). Your best recipients for direct marketing are those people that are pre-qualified or self-qualified. This means they have already expressed an interest in your type of product either directly to your company or through a third party source. Many people would welcome your advertising since they are in the market for your product. The process of getting pre-approval for the sending of marketing materials is called permission marketing (I recommend reading Seth Godin’s book by the same title). Empower Your Members Instead of buying lists, get information from your members on whom to contact. Ask if they know anyone who could benefit from receiving an invitation to the church. Ask for addresses, or even better, email addresses. You will save a fortune on postage. Put together a packet of materials you can mail, email, or hand out to friends and neighbors. Saddleback Church put together neighbor welcome packs that
128

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

looked like mailboxes. The packages were available in the lobby for members to take to new people moving into their community. Inside were valuable coupons, maps to the area, and an invitation to visit Saddleback, listing all of the programs and child care options available at the church. This puts the responsibility to market the church and evangelize neighbors on the shoulders of the members. It is not up to the leadership to knock on every door in the community to get new members. Though many people think it is, direct mail is not a shortcut to relationship building (Key 5) because is does not have the same results as personal interaction or attention. The role of the leadership is to equip the individual members to be able to reach their communities: To prepare God's people for works of service, so that the body of Christ may be built up until we all reach unity in the faith and in the knowledge of the Son of God and become mature, attaining to the whole measure of the fullness of Christ. (Ephesians 4:12-13)

Join the Club I lived in Southern California during the Card Club boom of the 90s. Most of the major grocery store chains had their own clubs that provided discounts to holders of their store’s club card. On one level, I thought it was a little silly since I was not really a member of a club. I knew I just got the sale price on items that a few years before were available without a card. On the other hand, I was studying marketing in college and thought it was a great idea for stores to get to know their customers better. They had my name, address, phone, age, and knew how often I shopped and exactly what I purchased. This is an incredible amount of information to have about your customer. I kept waiting for the stores to send me a coupon to try a new chocolate chip cookie. They could tell from my purchases that I was an ideal customer for chocolate chip cookies. I never received that coupon, nor any other customized marketing materials. Why
129

Marketing the Church

not? Why would they not use all the information I was freely providing them? My guess is they had too much information and did not know what to do with it. Or perhaps they never saw the value of the information and just thought I would buy more because I thought I was in a special club. I felt they were wasting my time by filling out a form and carrying around a stupid plastic card. Why go to all the trouble if they were not going to follow up and solidify the relationship with customized offerings and marketing messages? All but one of the area chains gave up on the cards. They started running promotions about how they had done away with the cards. Another store advertised how you never needed a club card in their store in the first place. A few of the chains changed hands, and that is when things got really confusing. I went to a large grocery store on the weekend and needed my card; I went back during the week for something I forgot and they had changed the name of the store. All of a sudden, the cashiers were laughing and assuring me I did not need a card anymore when I checked out my groceries. About a week later, I went to the same store and I needed my card again because the store had changed ownership again (if this seems strange, remember it was California where anything is possible). Confused? So was I. I did not mention the names of the stores because I honestly cannot remember which was which. I still go to that store, but I am not sure what the name is anymore. I hope you understand by reading this book that confusing the customer, especially about your brand name, is bad. Marketing is about communication and helping people to understand, not be confused. The card clubs were not limited to grocery stores. Drugstores, gas stations, and pet stores are among the other retail locations offering club discounts. While there are still many companies that continue to use these cards, and I hold a few of them, I have yet to see a personalized marketing message from any of them. This is a waste of valuable data about customers (Key 6) and a missed opportunity to strengthen relationships (Key 5).

130

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Catalogs I have seen some good examples of direct marketing from catalogs. I used to receive a catalog from FranklinCovey, the company that sells time management planners. I purchased a set of calendar pages by mail order, and the next year I received a catalog about two months before my pages expired. The catalog had my name on it with a personalized message that said something like, “Michael, your pages will be expiring in October, and we have some great new products to choose from. Your Monarch size products are available on page 22.” I was very impressed. I felt good that they knew who I was and were giving me information to make my life easier. They were actually meeting my time and convenience needs instead of giving me more unsolicited advertising to sift through or throw in the trash. I am sad to say that I no longer get those personalized catalogs. I started getting about one non-personalized catalog a month from them that I usually threw away because it was too many. I was also not happy that all of sudden they did not know who I was anymore. I had slipped back into the anonymity of the mass market. Now, for some reason I do not get any catalogs from them at all. My marketing professor was a big fan of a running store in San Diego that sent him personalized catalogs. While in the store, they measured and tested his foot. They were able to determine what kind of runner he was and his unique pronation (the angle of the foot striking the ground). They smartly entered his information into their database and would send him personalized catalogs. Their message said something like, “Hello Nick, it has been six months since you bought your Reebok running shoes. Based on your running style, you probably will need to replace them soon. Turn to page 17 to see some suitable replacements.” This is a great use of collected data to focus marketing efforts (Key 6) and to build relationships with customers (Key 5).

Dear ________, Before you get too excited about personalization, realize that it must be used correctly. When I receive marketing pieces with my
131

Marketing the Church

name on them from companies I have never heard from, I am not flattered but fearful. I think, “How did they get my name and what do they want from me?” Anything that says “Dear Micheal Dahane” goes straight in the trash. And if someone calls and cannot pronounce my name, I know the call will be short. Fake friendliness does not build relationships (Key 5), it prohibits them. Knowing that names can sometimes get on lists for unsolicited material, I have used pseudonyms. When I signed up for a free muscle magazine I used the name Michael Steel Daehn. That way anything I receive with the name Steel shows me who sold my name. Besides it is fun to see a muscle magazine come with the name Michael Steel Daehn printed on the front. If you want to test a company, use its name as your own. So if I sign up for the ACME catalog, I would put Michael ACME as my name. Anytime I get unsolicited mail for Michael ACME, I know ACME is the culprit.

Direct Mail Thankfully, my mailbox is only a few short steps from the dumpster. I walk over and throw away handfuls of advertising and handfuls of the advertisers’ cash. The rate of return on direct mail has been steadily plummeting over the years, and response rates remain only a fraction of a percent. If that does not frighten you, then perhaps the widely circulating e-mail encouraging people to mail advertising back in the postage-paid envelopes might get your attention. Of course, this wastes even more of the advertisers’ money, but the point is that people are not only irresponsive to unsolicited mail, but becoming hostile as well. Unless you have data that shows your mail piece is of value to the recipient, you should invest your money in another tool. If you do use direct mail, make sure it is tailored to the needs of the recipient like the catalog example above. Terminix had a successful direct mail campaign that sent notices to homes in the path of an infestation of termites. In this scenario Terminix was providing useful information about a potential problem and offering a solution. This was not mass advertising since they only sent the pieces to those homes that were in danger.
132

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

E-Mail E-mail has tremendous advantages. There are not the same costs involved since you do not have to pay printing and postage fees as with direct mail. The best situation is when people are able to sign up for your e-mail list from your website. This is permissionbased marketing that has been proven to work wonders. I love the St. Louis Blues hockey team. I regularly receive emails from the Blues Hotwire that provides me breaking stories about the Blues. The team also informs me of jersey sales, and ticket prices. Do I mind getting this kind of advertising? No, as a fan and a customer with a strong relationship with the team, I welcome this kind of information. Many teams and companies have used e-mail effectively in this manner. “Spammer” is the worst thing you can be labeled in the e-mail realm. “Spam” is a term coined for unwanted and unsolicited e-mail. To avoid this, always provide a way for recipients to remove themselves from the e-mail list and do not send unsolicited e-mail.

Rebirth of the Newsletter If there is one marketing tool churches seemed to have mastered it is the newsletter. Since I have attended different churches over the years, once a month I receive various church newsletters. Depending on the size of the church, the newsletters can vary from an actual letter to a fancy tri-fold color brochure. If you are in charge of sending these pieces, you know how expensive and time consuming it is to mail them, and postage fees are still increasing. What should you do? The Internet to the rescue! There are some amazing things you can do with email you may not have considered before. For starters, you can allow people to write their content by giving them access to a shared folder or program. So after Pastor Dave writes his monthly Pastor’s Corner message, he can email it to you so you can copy and paste it into the electronic newsletter. Members subscribe themselves to the newsletter on your website and update their account if their address changes, cutting down on your
133

Marketing the Church

administration time. As people subscribe, they check interest categories. For example, a young family with children might elect to receive children’s ministry updates by checking that particular category. If they do not like bowling, they would not check the box to receive information about the bowling ministry. When you send out the newsletters, you decide what people will receive based on what interest categories they checked. If you are sending an update to the frog gigging party, you only send it to interested parties. When you send information about the church catching on fire, you would send it to everyone since they should all be interested. Give access to the leaders of different ministries to allow them to send information to those interested in their particular ministry. Imagine a newsletter with 20 different articles laid out on a table. You take a pair of scissors and cut out the items that are of particular interest to people based on what they chose when they subscribed. Then you mail only those items of stated interest from the newsletter in an envelope to their house. In the past that would have been an arduous task; today it is possible to do quickly and easily, with email Church newsletters! Besides the ability to customize, which strengthens relationships (Key 5), email is much less expensive than printing and mailing. The information is more current and up-to-date. If there are any printing or communication errors, they can be corrected immediately with a follow up email. A final advantage is the presentation. You can do incredible things with email newsletters without needing any special publishing training. With a few clicks, you can send full color photos and graphics. If you are dealing with professional people, you have the added advantage of looking technologically savvy, giving you and your church additional credibility. To learn more about using powerful email tools to enhance your church’s communication, visit Max My Mail, they can help (www.maxmymail.com).

134

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Telemarketing While writing this I just got a phone call from the Southwestern Bell phone company for Mr. Agrusa, the name of my father-in-law. I explained he does not live here, and the caller asked if I was the phone decision maker. I wisely said “no, my wife is” and the caller said “thanks anyway” and hung up. I wonder how much money Southwestern Bell wasted to interrupt me while writing this wonderful book? Well, at least it gave me a great illustration. Actually, that phone call was rather distracting so I decided to take a break and did not continue writing this until the next day. As I got back into the groove and starting writing again, guess who called? Southwestern Bell called asking for Mr. Agrusa again. Their marketing is beginning to feel a little more like harassment. In fact, consumer groups are trying to make such calls illegal. To help consumers, there is now a device called the PhoneZapper that is available to block unsolicited calls. I have some friends who enjoy telemarketing calls as a chance to play mind games with the callers by using funny voices and acting like imbeciles. Once when asked how much he spent on long distance calls, my friend responded, “I do not have a phone.” The problem is that a phone call is rather personal. Of course, we want to build a personal relationship with customers (Key 5), but we must earn the right to be heard. Telemarketing is a poor advertising tool because it is a very personal tool being used with strangers and non-customers. Telemarketing is a good tool when the prospects have pre-qualified themselves, and/or the call is being provided as a client service. Following up on a sale to make sure everything is working to the client’s satisfaction is a great way to cement an already established relationship and bolster future sales.

You Make the Call Email is wonderful for general communication, but it is not as effective as the telephone for a more personal connection. My small group leader used to call me every week to see how things were going. I was impressed he was not only spending his valuable evening calling me, but he was also calling every member of the
135

Marketing the Church

group. His simple call demonstrated to me and to the others his great concern and love for us. Because I felt valued, I wanted to remain connected to the group and to the church. Of all the small groups at the church, his was the only one growing like crazy, and people were leaving to start new groups because so many people were attending. (When a new group was formed, we referred to it as birthing a group, not splitting a group, now that’s good marketing.) Encourage your group and ministry leaders to stay connected to their people by adding the personal touch of a phone call.

Network and Home Marketing Companies such as Avon, Tupperware, and Herbalife changed the traditional channels of distribution. These organizations use what is called network or home marketing. There are no retail locations. Individuals sell the product to friends and family; then either deliver the product by hand or have it shipped. There has been tremendous growth in this area over the past decade for two reasons. First, people enjoy buying from friends and family in a relaxed atmosphere. Many of the products are sold in homes, and the sales presentations are called parties. The second reason for the rise in popularity is that individuals begin selling to supplement their income. It is becoming an increasingly popular practice for one of the parents to stay home with children, and this business model provides a way to earn income without driving to an office to work. Look for this industry to continue to grow over the next decade. If you are marketing a new product, especially one that correlates to home use, this could be the best channel to use.

The Original Home Parties The early Church met in people’s homes. Though we have become accustomed to meeting in large buildings for services, the home church/small group setting is still very effective. It is much
136

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

easier to connect and share with 8-10 people in a home than 10010,000 people in a large sanctuary. Even if you belong to a large congregation, small groups are one of the best ways to integrate new people into your church.

Saturation? I sometimes tell my students that direct marketing is oversaturated. There is too much of what passes for direct marketing such as mailings, e-mail and telemarketing. However, since most of these efforts are not based on knowledge about the prospect, they are actually another form of mass marketing. True direct marketing has knowledge about the recipients and is providing relevant customized information they will likely embrace. People welcome marketing material that meets their time and convenience needs and makes life easier. What is needed is more genuine direct marketing, and less of what passes for direct marketing, but is actually a nuisance.

IMC TOOL #6 INTERNET/INTERACTIVE World Wide Wonder I began working for an Internet development firm in the summer of 2000. I did not know it at the time, but the bubble was already bursting. The Internet provided a tremendous boost to the economy as it revolutionized the way business is performed. Many of the companies founded were based on shaky business models. Traditional business plans provide a way to generate revenue - which many Internet companies did not consider. The demise of many of these companies was only a matter of time, and when the time came for the shakeout, many disappeared. What did not disappear is the power of the Internet to influence the way business, and in particular marketing, will be implemented.

137

Marketing the Church

“Custom”er A key feature of the Internet is the ability to interact with content. I have gone on ad nauseam in this book about creating a customized message for prospects and customers. The Internet provides a means for marketers to provide customizable content. Consumers can pick and choose not only what they view but how they view it. Once they have taken the time to customize content, they will not likely change to a competitor. The customized content builds a relationship between the company and the customer (Key 5). I was invited by a friend to join a hockey fantasy league on Yahoo! a few years ago. The league was free except for providing some personal information in order to register. I discovered that Yahoo! also provided me my own personal start page on the Internet. There was a link to my fantasy team and whatever other content I wanted. I could put news headlines, comics, team scores, maps and all sorts of other useful tools all in one place. Yahoo! allowed me to choose what items I wanted to have on my start page, a choice of colors, and how the information is laid out on the page. I discovered later that this same service is provided by my ISP (Internet Service Provider) Earthlink. I had already spent the time to customize my Yahoo! page so I did not bother with the Earthlink page. Since Yahoo! was the first to establish and then customize this relationship, I did not want to change. Yahoo! was able to reinforce and protect their relationship with me from competitors. I still use the Yahoo! page and they receive revenue from advertising posted on their site. Since I am in the hockey fantasy league, I see ads targeted at hockey fans. Eventually, I became disenfranchised with Earthlink and decided to switch to Yahoo! as my Internet service provider since I already had a great relationship with them before I was a customer. The important thing to remember is that people expect interactivity on websites. Several companies did not do well trying to provide video or written content that offered neither customization nor interactivity. Radio, television and print media are still available for communicating information and are well suited for most purposes. It is easier to watch television lying on the couch than to boot a streaming video on my PC while sitting at my desk. On the other hand, if I want to see a particular highlight, I can find a
138

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

copy on the Internet and play it on demand. Some cable companies sensing their vulnerability to Internet competition are developing some interactivity into their offerings through digital menus and video on demand.

Hit Me The second key feature of the Internet is the ability to track activity. Since the movements of viewers around the site can all be recorded and tracked, there is a plethora of data not provided by any other IMC tool. Most people think a “hit” on a website means that someone visited the site. Actually anytime your cursor moves over a link on a site it is counted as a hit. There are a few key metrics focused on by Internet marketers. They know what kind of software you are using to browse the Internet. Companies can tell how you found the site either through a search engine or a link and sometimes, more importantly, marketers see where you exited the site. I often will leave a site if I do not like or understand the design of a particular page. I know that I am sending a message to the company that there is a problem with that page for me. Just as with the club card data, there is almost too much information available to Internet marketers. There are several programs available to help companies make sense of Internet data. Collecting all this information is futile if it is not used to customize the experience and build stronger relationships (Key 5).

Sticky A site is sticky if people stay on it and/or return on a regular basis. Usually this requires providing information, entertainment, or services for viewers. To make a site sticky, make sure you add and update relevant content frequently. I set Yahoo! as my start page and view it several times a day. I have a lot of important resources listed on the same page so it is of great benefit to me.
139

Marketing the Church

Mystery Meat Mystery meat navigation is what web design expert Vincent Flanders calls the fancy rollovers on websites. These are the sites that have pictures of a square, a circle, and a triangle and you have to guess where each will take you when you click or roll over them. When you put your mouse over them, they will usually give you more information. So when you point to the square, it shows text that says “contact information.” Flanders urges designers not to make viewers guess where things are. They should be clearly labeled. What if street signs were blank until you shined a special light on them? Think of the accidents that would occur. While some of these designs are artistic, they are not appropriate for most websites that are trying to interact with customers and clearly communicate information. To learn better web design, I recommend visiting Flanders’ website (www.webpagesthatsuck.com).

The Flasher Another Flanders nemesis is the use of fancy Flash presentations. Flash is a software program that is used to create many of the animations seen on websites. There are two problems with Flash. First, it usually takes a long time to load. You do not want people clicking over to a competitor because they did not want to wait for your cartoon to load. The second reason is that most of the animations are commercials for the company. If the person is already on your site and ready to buy, why do you need to show them a commercial?

Check Please In many cases Internet users want to find relevant information and make a purchase as quickly as possible, so why make them wait? Mystery meat navigation gives unwanted challenges to customers trying to find the information they need. Flash presentations are equivalent to going to the cash register at Target and they say, “Wait. Before you buy anything from us, watch
140

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

our commercial about why you should shop at Target.” Faster computers may make the slow loading of web pages with Flash obsolete, but you should always allow your customers to make purchases as fast as possible by giving them quick access to the checkout.

Win/Win The Internet is a win/win situation in many cases. The Internet should be a key component for most modern businesses. It provides a place for prospects and customers to gain customized information about the company for less money than traditional printing and mailing costs. Customers can access information, catalogs, and forms on their own. You do not have to ship as many brochures since many people will just read the information or print it themselves. Many customers will also provide their own data entry. They prefer to go to a website and fill in their information, which saves on the cost of the company paying staff for the same task.

A Win for the Church The website is a great way to leverage the desire of your church members to contribute. Besides streamlining email and communications preferences, it is also a conduit for discussion and a place for members to share ideas. Most churches have an informal informational hierarchy. You have to know the right person to get permission to use a room or get an item in the newsletter. It can be frustrating and many people give up sharing their brilliant ideas. Design your website in such a way that people can interact with each other and the leadership can make sure none of the good ideas or people are falling through the cracks.

DISCus
141

Marketing the Church

Another interactive marketing device is the CD ROM. Unless you live in a cave, you have probably received many of these from AOL. Place the CD in your computer and it provides you with information about the product and a link to their website. The AOL disc also has software that allows you to use their service. Other companies have used CDs to send slideshows and music presentations of their product to prospects. An innovative company created business cards with contact information printed on the front and a playable CD on the other side. I like the idea of these cards, but they are costly to produce and should only be used with targeted customers that can benefit from the information. In most cases, it makes more sense to invest in a quality website and put your web address on your paper business card.

Look Before You Leap I worked with a church desiring to video tape the services, print hundreds of copies, and make them available to the members on DVD. Besides the time and copying costs, they were going to pay a professional videographer. I asked them to consider how many people were actually going to take the DVD home, prepare a bowl of popcorn, put it in the player and sit and watch it. When you think about it, that is not a likely scenario. Sermons on tape or CD are popular because you can listen to them in the car, but watching a DVD is a big commitment. I recommended they tape the service for posterity and for anyone who might be interested. Make a couple of copies, and put them in the library. You can also post the video on the website for free. There is no reason to pay a videographer for a static presentation like a sermon. Since it is essentially one shot, I volunteered to set up my video camera and tripod for free. The moral of the story is that just because you can do something, particularly with technology, does not mean it is the best approach or best use of your resources.

142

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Here to Stay Internet and interactive communication is here to stay. You should be using this tool as either the primary means of distribution or as a complement to your other marketing communications.

The Christian Connection According to the Pew Internet Project, over 20% of Internet users (nearly 20 million) have used the Internet to seek spiritual and religious information, and on an average day more than 2 million people are getting spiritual material online. You need to work with a company that has its priorities straight. If you do not have an adequate website in place, you should contact my good friends at Christian Technology Solutions who are doing business by the book (the Good Book) (www.christiantechnologysolutions.com).

The Importance of Synergy 1+1=11 This equation is impossible in the world of math, but not in the world of synergy. Synergy is when the sum is greater than the individual parts. Working together they can do much more than they can do alone. The Christian Church is the representation of Christ’s body on the planet. The Church is made up of frail, failing human beings, yet together, and with Christ as the head, it is the most powerful force on the planet. The same is true of marketing communications. The more the communications tools are integrated, the more synergy occurs and the more powerful the promotion. Thus the title integrated marketing communications.

Golden Ticket
143

Marketing the Church

If you are a child of the 70s like myself, you remember a magical place made of chocolate rivers, candied flora and mushrooms with marshmallow filling. I am speaking of the inside of Willy Wonka’s chocolate factory, from the film Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory. I show this film to my marketing students to demonstrate the powerful synergy of the Wonka marketing promotion. Five golden tickets are placed randomly in Wonka bars. Wonka throws the whole world into a frenzy looking for the coveted tickets. The news media covers the process, reporting on the finding of tickets. One girl’s father has his factory of workers opening hundreds of boxes of Wonka bars looking for a winner. In this film, chocolatiere Willy Wonka is implementing a powerful and popular sales promotion. He knows his target audience of chocolate consumers would love nothing more than to see inside his secret chocolate factory. He gets free publicity from the news-hungry media who cover every second of the campaign. Wonka does not have to pay for advertising; the news media does it for him. A powerful synergy is created between the two elements of sales promotion and using publicity that sells thousands of Wonka bars.

Congruency Provides Synergy Linking the various tools together into a cohesive, collaborative package provides synergy. Each tool must provide a consistent look and feel. If printed advertisements use a dog and the color orange with an Arial font, then the brochures, coupons, letterhead, website and every other marketing communications tool must have the same elements. This repetition and consistency help people to remember and identify your brand. Have you ever noticed that the color of traffic signs is significant? Warning signs are usually yellow or orange, street signs are usually green and stop signs are red. Imagine if traffic signs were all different colors. Some warning signs were blue, some streets signs were yellow, and some stop signs were green. What if every city picked its own color of stop sign? Depending on the city you were in, the sign might be purple, blue or pink. You might recognize the octagon shape, but in this alternate universe, the
144

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

shapes are all different too. The signs would be more difficult to identify quickly. Thankfully, for safety’s sake this is not the case. But what happens when people are marketing their brands? Sometimes their logo is blue, sometimes green. Sometimes it has a circle around it, sometimes a square. All of these factors make it more difficult for consumers to identify the brand and, unlike in traffic, most people do not have much motivation to care. Companies should ask if there is consistency in the look of their website, in their print material and on television. Inconsistency confuses and distracts people. Colors and shapes are rather simple things to keep consistent, but what about the message? Are different claims being made on the radio than in newspaper ads? Are you touting your product as a high-end commodity that is hard to obtain and then printing coupons in the Sunday circular? Do you feature all men in some advertising and all women in other ads? Pick a look and feel, and implement it consistently across all marketing communications. No matter what style you choose, always make sure you are promoting your competitive advantage (Key 1). While that advantage is likely to stay the same over time, individual campaigns promoting the advantage can and should change over time lest they become stale. Keep the same message of promoting the advantage, but you need to present fresh perspectives and rephrase the message in modern contexts over time. When you update various campaigns, make sure to update them over all the platforms you are utilizing.

You Can Do This I recently visited a church where they had a rack of information about the various ministries. It was a hodgepodge of random information in various sizes, styles, colors and formats. It was a confusing mess that well meaning people had spent hours putting together. Make it easy for people to categorize and find information. What does your literature rack look like? What if you used specific colors of paper to reflect the variety of ministries offered at the
145

Marketing the Church

church: yellow for the Children’s Ministry, blue for the Men’s Ministry, pink for the Women’s Ministry? This simple idea can make your information resource area look streamlined and professional instead of like a messy coffee table.

Multiple Elements Provide Synergy The more tools you integrate and synergize, the more powerful the results. Hearing me lecture on this, a marketing student of mine at Concordia University, Chris Bowen, put together an excellent marketing plan using multiple tools. He was a baseball player and was familiar with the bat market. He chose to promote Rawlings bats. His idea was to have a traveling van bring Rawlings equipment to parks, retail locations, and schools. This gave customers a chance to try out the equipment before purchasing (sales promotion). He advertised the dates in local newspapers and on radio stations (advertising). Dates were also available on the Rawlings website (Internet/interactive). Every event promoted tobacco awareness and encouraged children not to use tobacco (sales promotion/cause related marketing). The van also visited local schools with the message of tobacco awareness amongst students (PR/publicity.) Local news stations and community organizations were contacted and encouraged to cover the events based on the tobacco-awareness activities (PR/publicity). Notice the consistency and synergy created by all these elements. They build, promote, and support one another. All of these promotional tools could be implemented for much less than most commercial television spots. The tools are targeted at likely users and the return on investment will be excellent. Needless to say, Chris received an “A” in my marketing class. You do not have to use all the marketing communications tools for every campaign. You should always avoid paying for advertising if possible. Some tools are not a good match for every situation. Typically the more tools you are able to implement effectively, the more powerful your message becomes. Ultimately the goal is to effectively communicate with customers in order to build relationships.
146

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

5
Key 5: Build Relationships
The Goal of marketing is to create long term relationships with customers. There are no shortcuts. It takes time and genuine concern to build genuine relationships with those you serve. First Date I did not kiss my wife on our first date because I felt it was inappropriate. I did not really know her yet, but I respected her as a person. Things worked out and we got married two years later. Many times marketers try to jump into a committed relationship without taking the time to court and woo their prospect. Building relationships is a process. Like dating, some techniques for meeting people and building relationships work better than others. If I were targeting a Bible-believing conservative girl, I would attend the church social instead of a strip club. For our first date, I would take her flowers and candy. I would wear my best cologne and finest suit. I would not likely talk about our wedding and children on the first date. If all went well, I would try for a second date. Hopefully down the road, our relationship would grow into something lasting. If we did get married, I would still need to do things to cultivate the relationship. I would treat her differently as my wife, and there would be new mutual expectations. If I ignored her or treated her as if I did not know her, then she would be offended and maybe even end the marriage. Though some people are able to have a good relationship with former spouses or girlfriends, there is typically a great deal of bitterness when the relationship ends. This is an imperfect analogy to the relationship between companies and consumers, but there are some striking parallels. You must provide something special to get the attention of new customers, and be on your best behavior. Once the customer is
147

Marketing the Church

committed, he or she should be treated like a valued partner, not a stranger. You need to keep doing the little things to let the customer know you care and are still committed. If you should alienate a customer, it is worse than never having been with him or her in the first place. Most people will tell everyone they know about their bad experience and why they no longer use your product. Unlike in love, in the marketing scenario, it is not better to have sold and lost than never to have sold at all.

Planting, Watering, Harvesting When people visit your church for the first time, they are not likely to come forward at the first altar call. Conversion, for most of us, is a process. If people are serious about putting their faith in Christ, they will need to seriously consider what that means, this takes time. God uses different people to contribute to the process of conversion: one person plants a seed, another one waters, while another one harvests. Although you may feel, at times, like you have had no effect on someone with whom you have planted the seed of faith, the good news is that someone else may water the seeds of the Gospel you so faithfully planted. That person may come to Christ long after you first shared your faith. Think of your own conversion. Was it not the influence of many people, not just one, who lead you to believe in Christ? What you do, how you treat people, even where you park (leaving room for visitors) are all a part of the process. God has you in a unique role to serve his purpose and exert influence where he wants it. But like the dating analogy above, it is better to be genuine and patient than to try to score on the first date. Let people move at their own pace, and realize you may be the seed planter in their life, not the harvester, God will take care of that.

148

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Too Personal Have you ever been on a date with someone who tells you his or her whole life story, with its deepest darkest secrets, and then wants to hear yours before you leave the parking lot for the date? It gives you the creeps and brings up your defenses instead of lowering them. Sometimes too much information can be a bad thing and marketers cross the line. Getting mail from a stranger that pretends to know my name and provides a laundry list of past purchases invites fear, not familiarity. Privacy is a dearly held privilege in our country and should be respected. Do not try to gain trust by using artificial marketing data. Use information to invite prospects into a relationship and earn their trust with superior products and services. Hugs Have you ever visited a church where a big burley guy gives you a hug at the door? Maybe you are that guy. I don’t want to hurt your feelings, but I am not comfortable hugging strange men in public. I appreciate your enthusiasm, but it gives me the willies. When traveling for my work I enjoy visiting other churches, but I do not enjoy the boy bear hug. The girl hug would be strange for other reasons, not the least of which is that I am a happily married man. Think about when someone visits your church for the first time. He or she is probably a little uncomfortable and nervous already. To help visitors overcome this foreign environment, extend a hearty handshake, give a big smile, and point them to the coffee and donuts, your hospitality will be greatly appreciated. Front Porches I met my friend Scott Ginsberg at an NSA (National Speakers Association) meeting. He was wearing a nametag that said, “Hello, My Name is Scott.” There was nothing unusual about this; we were all wearing nametags. His, however, was hand written in a different color than ours. Why? Because, Scott has been wearing a nametag every single day for over 5 years now. If you want to see
149

Marketing the Church

the status of how many days he is at today, check out his website (www.hellomynameisscott.com). Sounds a little odd, but Scott is one of the brightest and most innovative people I have met. The reason he wears a nametag is because it acts as a means of approachability. In fact, Scott has written two books on the subject. He is a professional speaker who works with groups who want to learn to be more friendly and approachable. Understandably he has worked with several churches interested in becoming a more outgoing congregation. Scott says if you want to start talking to people, you need a good front porch, like in the good-old-days when people would stop and talk to their neighbors on the porch. Today we need to figure out a way to make ourselves approachable by creating front porches that invite conversation and interaction. Scott explains this way better in his book: The Power of Approachability. If you are looking for innovative and powerful ways to get your church to build relationships with people, I would highly recommend reading this book or talking to Scott himself, he’s very approachable.

Multipliers The process of unsatisfied customers disparaging your reputation is called a negative multiplier. A customer is not happy with your product, so he or she tells two friends, and they tell two friends, and they tell two friends, and so on. I am sure you can figure out that the counterpart, a positive multiplier, is the goal. When you truly satisfy your customer, he or she is likely not only to remain a customer, but to advise others to become customers also.

Viral Marketing Is this something you can catch from attending business meetings? Here is a strategy in a need of a name change. Viral marketing is the name for positive multipliers at an extreme level.
150

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

The Internet provided a means for quickly spreading messages. When one person sends information to another on the Internet, it is called peer-to-peer communication. The use of e-mail has provided opportunities for messages to be widely broadcast peer-to-peer in a short amount of time. For example, Microsoft provides free e-mail accounts but attaches a short marketing message to the bottom of every e-mail that is sent. Budweiser saw great success with their “w’sup?” commercials. They made the commercials available in a format that could be e-mailed and it was shortly sent by millions to all of their friends. Soon everyone I know was saying, “w’suuuup?” It just kept spreading and multiplying, like a virus. For more tips on how to start your own marketing pandemic check out Seth Godin’s book Unleashing the Ideavirus.

Old School The original evangelists from Jesus’ day used viral marketing. How do I know this? No other kind of marketing existed. All communication was verbal, with an odd scroll thrown in here and there. So you could say that viral marketing is the way the church was started, Get verbal, and get back to the basics!

Fun with Funnels A funnel is a good way to think of the marketing process. The top is very broad and consists of using mass marketing techniques. Mass marketing includes items like mass mailings, national advertising, billboards, and airing commercials during the Super Bowl. The marketing message is sent to a broad audience with little or no discretion. Mass marketing is very expensive, difficult to evaluate, and has a low return on investment. Mass marketing is a stab in the dark, like trying to find needles in a haystack. The next section of the funnel narrows the target audience into market segments. The communications still appeal to a large
151

Marketing the Church

audience, but they are at least targeted to a specific market segment by means of the chosen media. Cat Fancy magazine, ESPN, and the Oxygen website each target a specific segment of the market: cat lovers, sports enthusiasts, and women, respectively. Next, we narrow the target audience further into niche or specialty markets. Harley Davidson, Barbie, and Macintosh computers each appeal to a specialty area of the market. The bottom of the funnel is the customized or one-to-one area of the funnel. The consumer being on a first-name basis with the product or service provider often characterizes these markets. Mike the mechanic, Bill the barber, Doc Baker are all one-to-one relationships in which the customer and service provider know each other personally. Through the use of technology and mass customization, these relationships can be available on a wide scale such as in the case of the “My Yahoo!” page. ROI ROI stands for return on investment. Every one of the techniques in the funnel will gain customers. The question is which technique will provide the greatest return on investment. A Super Bowl ad is sure to create interest and generate new customers, but at what price? The same amount of money spent at the bottom and targeted directly at ideal customers will produce a much greater return on investment. Two benefits of targeting the bottom of the funnel are the likelihood of a positive response and the kinds of relationships that are established. Relationships on the bottom of the funnel are more committed and not easily broken. One-to-one customers form the bedrock, the foundation, for any successful product line. These people are not likely to change to a competitor due to the mutual commitment they feel between themselves and the brand. Customers at the bottom of the funnel can and should become your best marketing tool. They are positive multipliers that spread the word to friends and family. There are three levels of the one-to-one section: the customer, the referent, and the advocate. The customer will continue to buy the product and not switch to the competition. The referent will continue to buy the product and will tell others about the product when asked (give referrals). The
152

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

advocate will continue to purchase the product, will actively promote the product, and will convince others to buy it. The goal of every marketer is to gain advocates for the product. To summarize, the top of the funnel is the most expensive with the least return on investment and the least amount of consumer loyalty, while the bottom of the funnel is the least expensive with the greatest return on investment and the greatest amount of consumer loyalty. Getting consumers to the bottom is the goal. Marketers should always be guiding their consumers to the bottom of the funnel where the costs are less and the relationships are stronger.

153

Marketing the Church

Figure 5.1 The Marketing Funnel© Phase I: Directing Consumers Toward the Bottom

©

2001 marketingenious

154

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Figure 5.2 The Marketing Funnel© Phase II: The Bottom- Leveraging Consumer Loyalty

©

2001 marketingenious

155

Marketing the Church

Take it from the Top Why would anyone market to a mass audience at the top of the funnel? There are three reasons marketers come in from the top of the funnel: lack of education, sloth, and lack of opportunity. The majority of people marketing products do not know anything about the marketing funnel. If you know anyone that needs to be a more effective marketer, I urge you to advocate this book to him or her. Millions of dollars are spent because that is just the way things have been done in the past, or that is what companies see from their competitors. If you want to lead the market, then innovate instead of imitating. On the other hand, some people are too lazy to work on building these types of relationships with customers. Often it is easier to pay for a television commercial or a billboard than to figure out how to establish one-to-one relationships with thousands of target customers. The final reason is lack of opportunity. Sometimes when marketing a new product, it is necessary to enter the market from higher up in the funnel. If this is the case, steer your customer relationships down the funnel as quickly as possible. For example, if you must enter the market by means of a national newspaper advertisement, link the ad to a customizable website or some other tool that allows the relationship to develop further and reduces the need for future mass marketing efforts.

The Christian Funnel Christians, particularly adult converts, have an inverted funnel in relation to non-Christians. If you are living a sinful life with sinful people yet decide to become a Christian, you should surround yourself with other Christians while disassociating your past by disconnecting from your non-Christian friends and family. If you are trying to stop drinking, it would be a good idea to stop hanging out with your drinking buddies at the bar. The Inverted Funnel looks like this:
156

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Eventually you will lose touch with your old chums, they do not really want to hang out with you anymore. As you surround yourself with a bevy of new Christian friends, you progress into finding a Christian mechanic, a Christian chiropractor, and even a Christian grocery store owner. While it is great to support Christian businesses, you have effectively cut yourself off from the world and created a bubble. If you subscribe to the monastic philosophy, then this is great news. If, on the other hand, you would like to live out the great commission by sharing your faith, you must venture back into the dark recesses of your old stomping grounds. Perhaps you cannot save your old drinking buddies, but there are plenty of other folks out there in need of hearing the Gospel if you are willing to associate with them. If you do not go, then who will? Who is better suited to reach the world from which you came? This admonition is
157

Marketing the Church

not necessarily for baby Christians, but if you are mature in your faith, what are you afraid of?

Word of Mouth Many of my marketing students say they want to use “word of mouth” to market their product. They have the right idea - get people talking about and recommending the product - but is it that simple? Can I just say “I’ll use word of mouth,” and it magically starts to occur? I say to my students, “That’s a great idea. How are you going to create this phenomenon and what are people going to be saying?” It takes planning and strategy to get the ball rolling. Marketers have to provide the something for people to talk about. Though creating advocates takes hard work and commitment, if you follow the seven keys outlined in this book you should have no trouble gaining them for your product. You will have a product with a distinct advantage (Key 1), and you will be clearly communicating that message (Key 5).

Daehn’s Marketing Question For any marketing decision, determine whether it is the best use of funds by asking, “Will it gain the maximum exposure to the target audience that builds relationships while avoiding wasted expense?” If you are spending your own money, you do not want to waste marketing dollars getting your message to the wrong people. If you are spending someone else’s money, you have the responsibility to use it to create lasting, protected relationships with product advocates. To achieve maximum success during the marketing process, continue to ask yourself the “Daehn question.”

Stewardship You are responsible for the money and resources God gives you to use for his purposes. Be like Joseph:
158

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

When his master saw that the LORD was with him and that the LORD gave him success in everything he did, Joseph found favor in his eyes and became his attendant. Potiphar put him in charge of his household, and he entrusted to his care everything he owned. From the time he put him in charge of his household and of all that he owned, the LORD blessed the household of the Egyptian because of Joseph. The blessing of the LORD was on everything Potiphar had, both in the house and in the field. (Genesis 39:3-5) This is all the more reason to ask the Daehn Marketing Question before you allocate your resources.

That’s a Keeper It is far less expensive to keep a customer than to get a new one. The best way to keep customers is to provide good customer service. It also is the best way to increase the return on investment. Many companies make the mistake of throwing dollars at the acquisition of new customers while ignoring current customers. A few dollars spent on customer retention through improved customer service, customized communications, and customer recognition programs will pay higher dividends than another mass marketing campaign to gain new ones.

How is Your Retention? How much turnover is there at your church? At a former church I helped plant and attended for over five years, the leadership would often take time to say farewell to members who were leaving, particularly if they had actively served and volunteered. When my wife and I left, they had no such ceremony. I can understand not saying goodbye to me, my constant analysis and critiques annoy some people (but make a good book). My wife, on the other hand, was actively involved in ministry and helped coordinate several events. Why was she not recognized?
159

Marketing the Church

Before getting too indignant, this really begs the question. How many people come for a month or two and leave unnoticed? The Young Marrieds class at my current church produces a directory; as I thumb through it, I see several couples who are no longer attending. In spite of the numbers in the class remaining steady at around 100 people, I wonder where the other couples have gone? Does it matter if the numbers are steady even though others are leaving? Are the couples going to another church, or are they not going to Church at all? Were they Christians looking for a nice place to worship or were they seekers looking for God? This breaks my heart. If you get nothing else from this book, I hope you at least focus your attention on the people falling through the cracks in your church. Marketing may get people to walk in your door, but keeping them from walking out the door is dependent upon meeting their needs and building relationships.

Wireless and Clueless Companies selling wireless phone service spend millions to attain new customers. Besides the advertising, they entice new prospects with free or discounted phones. These phones are sold below cost, so the only way the company can break even is for the purchaser to remain a long-term customer. But what happens when the contract expires? If the current customer wants to get a new phone, they have to change companies or pay full price for a new one. There are no incentives to remain a customer or to renew the contract. Companies are more focused on spending money to get new clients than to keep the ones they have. How many companies spend millions on slick television commercials that drive people into stores? Once in the store, disaffected, under paid and under trained employees treat the customer like a second-class citizen, while the advertised product is not what the commercial claims or is unavailable. Marketers should spend less on wasteful mass marketing campaigns and more on building relationships with customers at the point of sale.
160

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

DIRECTV took this to heart and made some changes. They took some of their marketing dollars and used them to enhance their customer service process. They improved their main line of personal communication between themselves and their customers: the call center. DIRECTV gave incentives to their call center workers by offering more training, benefits, and career advancement opportunities. The result was an increase in client retention and the amount of money spent on subscriptions by callers. They also won industry awards for customer service and retention.

Quid Pro Quo Quid Pro Quo is a Latin term meaning “this for that.” In other words, you give me this and I will give you that; one hand washes the other. This is not wrong in itself, but it often lacks the intangibles involved in most relationships. Building relationships with customers comes from a transformational versus a transactional perspective. Instead of each party getting what it wants and leaving, each is concerned with benefiting its counterpart. These interactions are often called win/win scenarios where each side benefits. Marketers need to treat their customers with respect and try to benefit them, not just take their money, if they are going to build committed protected relationships.

Piece of the Pie To approach life with the view there is plenty to go around is called the abundance mentality. This view holds that there is room in this world for everyone to prosper, and it is best to form cooperative, mutually beneficial relationships with others. Those that do not comprehend or believe in the benefits of interdependence often have a scarcity mentality. They think life is like a pie with only so much to go around. If other people are prospering, there may not be enough for them. They get upset at the success of others because they think it means there is less chance for their own success. To build lasting relationships with customers requires an abundance mentality that strives for the best situation for the customer and the brand. Customers should be viewed as
161

Marketing the Church

lifetime partners, not short-term sources of income. There is plenty of pie for everyone to share.

Napster For decades the record industry held a technological chokehold on the distribution of music content. Because they had exclusive control, record executives decided to charge large sums of money for their product. While perfectly legal, this is not a good way to build relationships with consumers. Ordinary citizens had neither the technology to create their own access to popular music nor the organizational ability to defy the practices of the record companies. With the World Wide Web that is no longer the case. Napster devised a way for individuals to share musical content from peer-to-peer over the Internet. Not only has new technology freed the access to musical content, it has also provided a way for formerly disconnected people to communicate, share, and lobby for change of music industry practices. The sharing of copyrighted musical content is illegal, but most consumers feeling like they have been fleeced by the record companies for years justify their actions. The record companies charged exorbitant rates for musical content through monopolistic practices for decades and thus angered their customers. Now these companies are scrambling to convince customers they should pay for their music again. Good luck! Similar industries would be wise to learn this lesson. Doctors and lawyers have used the same distribution methods for generations. By limiting access to information, these disciplines have been able to charge high fees for their expert advice. Today consumers can find much of this information on the Internet for free or at a fraction of the cost. I injured my foot and there was a great deal of swelling. I called my doctor’s office several times to have it looked at by a professional. While I was waiting for someone to call me back from the office, I jumped on the Internet website WebMD.com. In a few minutes I had diagnosed the problem and was treating the injury. When the nurse called me back a few hours later and I described the
162

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

symptoms, she began to give me treatment advice. As she was telling me to elevate it and keep ice on it, etc., I started finishing her sentences for her. She asked, “How do you know what I am going to say?” I told her that I had already looked up the problem on the Internet and was treating myself. I am not recommending forgoing medical treatment for selfdiagnosis, but it proves the point that we are not as reliant on these industries for information as we used to be. Doctors, lawyers, and other purveyors of information better adjust their practices and become more consumer friendly, or they may wake up to find themselves “Napster-ized” one day.

The Sherwin Marketing Matrix My marketing professor, Nick Sherwin, developed a process for understanding relationship building with customers. Sherwin classifies marketing tools into above-the-line, below-the-line, frontend and back-end. Above-the-line tools like advertising and public relations/publicity are used before a relationship has been established to create image and awareness. Below-the-line tools such as sales promotion, personal selling, and direct marketing are used after some type of relationship has already been established. The front-end tools should be used at the beginning of the strategy and transition to the back-end tools. Many companies use these tools out of order or inappropriately.

163

Marketing the Church

Figure 5.3: The Sherwin Marketing Matrix

Keep Your Word As discussed earlier, brands are promises. Every marketing activity is communicating a promise the brand is making. Companies need to live up to and honor their promises if they want to make and keep relationships with customers.

Humans Crave Relationship What is the greatest punishment inflicted upon hardened criminals? Solitary confinement. The worst thing that can be done to a person is to remove him or her from interaction with other people. The reason is that humans were created for relationship. I have had people tell me that in my business decisions I take things too personally. I retort that they do not take their business
164

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

personally enough. Business transpires between individuals and groups of human beings. Trying to depersonalize the process causes problems; it does not make things easier. People desire to have a relationship with your brand and will feel betrayed if you do not treat them with the dignity and respect required of human beings. Marketing is about the human communication process. To be successful you must treat people like people, not machines.

Manipulation If you read this book, I will give you a million dollars! Not really, but I did get your attention. How do you feel right now? Cheated? Humiliated? Indifferent? Welcome to the world of manipulation. It amazes me how much people hate to be manipulated yet, given the opportunity, think it will work well on others. I had a student in class give a presentation of how he was going to tweak his advertising copy to essentially trick people into buying his product. I asked the class what they thought of his ideas and they thought it was a great idea. I then asked how many people would like to be tricked and would they continue to do business with a company like this? They changed their opinion quickly. It is astounding how quickly people who would not like these techniques used on them adopt these manipulative strategies when given the opportunity to do it to someone else. A sound marketing strategy does not need nor condone manipulation. To have long-term, lasting success and strong relationships with customers, honesty is the best policy. To vary on the Golden Rule: market to others as you would have them market to you.

Personal Selling Revisited Personal selling is crucial to relationship development because most of the face-to-face interaction between companies and their customers takes place during this process. I reiterate my admonition that retailers would be wise to run a few less mass marketed advertisements and use the money to better train and compensate their employees. People may come into the store
165

Marketing the Church

because of the ads, but will only return if they have a good experience and positive interaction with employees. Otherwise there is little motivation not to shop at a competitor, particularly if they have a better commercial.

Personal Evangelism Revisited Your church is about the people. If the church is going to reach those people, every Christian and every Church member needs to understand it depends on them, and not just the paid staff, to connect with non-Christians, to meet their needs, to share the Gospel in a culturally relevant manner. Is your church relying on the paid ministry staff to grow the church? Is the paid ministry staff allowing the people to rely on them to grow the church? If that were the model, then the church would have stopped growing 2 millennia ago when Christ ascended to Heaven. But that is not His model: He trained his apostles to find people who did not know God, to share the Gospel to bring about conversion, to teach them to love God and others, which included training new followers. When a church is dependent solely on the paid ministry staff to reach their community, they are not following the biblical model.

Go Blues! The St. Louis Blues are the greatest hockey team ever. Sure, at the time of writing this they have not yet won a Stanley Cup championship, but they are still the best. I am speaking as a fan of the team. I am truly an advocate for the St. Louis Blues because I have been cultivating a relationship with them since before I was born (my mother went to Blues games while she was pregnant with me). We all know people who are crazy about their favorite team. This is the kind of relationship you want to have with customers. Ken Blanchard and Sheldon Bowles expound on this theme in their book Raving Fans about providing revolutionary customer service. Successful marketers create raving fans for their products.

166

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Go Blues! No Stanley Cup yet, but I am still a fan. They have a strong protected relationship with me, despite their lack of playoff success.

Protect Your Investment In today’s competitive marketplace, the best way to insure your investment is to establish relationships with customers. By building and cultivating these connections, you establish a protected relationship. People will continue to do business with you because they know and trust you. Make yourself invaluable to your customers, and they will likely be yours for life. You will also gain valuable feedback on how to improve in the future.

167

Marketing the Church

168

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

6
Key 6: Gain Feedback
How do you know you know you are on the right track with your marketing plan? To see how you are doing you have to constantly evaluate your efforts.

Measuring Up Gaining feedback is what tells you whether you are on the right path with your customers. You have already done the hard work of developing a roadmap for success in your marketing plan. Feedback will tell you whether you are on the right track or veering off course. A jumbo jet leaving New York for Rome sets an exact course to follow during the flight. If the trajectory from the point of origin is off by mere inches, the plane will land in another city or, worse yet, in the ocean. During the flight pilots are consistently checking their instruments and gaining feedback to determine if they are on target. They continually make adjustments to their flight path based on the information received from their instruments. Intelligent marketers use various methods to gain feedback on their efforts to keep them on course.

Method of Accountability Feedback determines whether the marketing efforts are worthwhile. I have spoken at length about the importance of determining return on investment. Measurement provides a way to evaluate the value of marketing campaigns. From the results, you
169

Marketing the Church

are equipped to make decisions about what is working and what is inefficient. If an ad agency is unable to show results proving the success of its activity, how do you know that money is not better spent elsewhere? Feedback must provide accountability and justification for the use of various marketing communications.

How Is Your Church Accountable? How many horror stories have you heard about the shady financial practices of churches? Sometimes it is intentional, but often people are thrown into a role for which they have no training. Accountability will stifle the former and alleviate the latter. There is a reason why attending to finances is called accounting. There is more to accountability than just the money. How responsible are you with people’s time? Do you start and end activities punctually? Are all of your meetings planned and executed with respect for the sacrifices made by those attending? Do you get feedback on the sermons and lessons? Getting negative feedback can be a tough pill to swallow, but the alternative is ineffective mediocrity, besides you may just find how good a job your church is doing. Often you only hear from the complainers; feedback gives members a chance to pat you on the back too.

Benchmarks When defining the purpose of the company, goals are set and certain standards are to be achieved. These goals or benchmarks provide a means for determining if the marketing process is on target. All feedback should be measured against the established benchmarks of the company.

170

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

What are Your Benchmarks? Besides mission, vision, and goals, what are the standards by which you operate? Do you have a guide for acceptable quality in your publications (also called a brand standards guide)? Check out a sample brand/communication standards guide on the Marketing the Church website (www.marketingthechurch.com).

Surveys Surveys are a good way to gain feedback from current and potential customers. Most people wish they could tell manufacturers what they want and how to make it, but are never given the opportunity. When constructing a survey, make sure it is easy to use and can be completed with minimal effort on the part of the participant. At the same time, make sure the survey will provide accurate, easily quantifiable results. Here’s how to create great surveys: • Start easy- Ask for the easy information first. Start with name, address and telephone number to get people warmed up, and then move on to the tough questions. I saw a church survey that had formatted the layout of their survey in such a way that the question “How much money do you make?” was centered at the top of the first page. While I was excited to see the church using a survey to improve the organization, I was concerned to see such a sensitive question jumping off the page at first glance. This design can cause respondents to stop filling in the questionnaire. Avoid response setting- Response setting is the psychological pattern of grouping answers in a similar pattern. For example, if you ask ten questions that all regard the performance of the company with one being disagree strongly and ten being agree strongly, some respondents will just go down the list and check all high or low responses without reading the questions. To avoid this occurrence, alter the questions. For example, make question one “The
171

Marketing the Church

• •

company does a good job” and the second question “The company is not doing a good job.” If they score a “ten” on the first question and you are getting honest responses, you should get a “one” on the second question. There should be at least one question where you reverse the positive and negative to determine whether you are getting honest answers or the respondent is giving response-setting answers. Use a quantifier- Quantifier simply means using numbers. To gain results that are easy to use, implement a quantifier into the responses. If you receive 1,000 surveys, you will want to be able to plot the results (such as a 90% customer satisfaction rating and a 50% approval rating of prices). If the responses are all fill in the blank, there is no way to put a number on the amount of customer satisfaction without it being a subjective, arbitrary number. By using numbers in the responses, you can quantify the results and make fancy charts and graphs. Internet surveys and Scantrons also make it easy to get the data into a usable format quickly. Avoid limited responses- Give the respondents room to vary their opinions. If the customers feel the service was above average they might give a 70%, but they need the option to do so. If the scale is from one to three, then they will probably give a two, which is 50%. If the scale is one to ten they will probably give a seven, which is 70%. Using a scale of one to ten is better than using a scale of one to three because it provides more options and will gain more accurate results. Allow for customization- Give respondents a place to write their comments and give feedback. While this is more difficult to quantify, it can provide information you never thought to ask or explain why some scores are high or low. Keep it short- Most people do not enjoy filling out surveys. Your first response motivator is to keep the survey short and easy to complete. Enhance the relationship- Use the survey to provide useful information to the clients and strengthen the relationship. Thank them for partnering with you. Getting

172

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

• •

people involved and interested in the company enhances commitment. Gain marketing information- Ask if there are any projects you can help with and/or if they know anyone else that could benefit from your product. Provide a response motivator- How do you get people to fill out a survey? Most people, unless highly motivated by an extremely positive or negative experience, will not take the time to fill out and/or return a survey. A response motivator must be attached to surveys to get a high percentage of them returned. Companies must provide some reward, product or service in exchange for a completed survey.

When I began doing marketing consulting for a graphic designer, the first thing I suggested was creating a survey. He already had a group of past and present customers, and a survey was a good way to measure the depth of the relationship and determine customer satisfaction. Some customers did business on a regular basis, while others stopped talking to the designer after their first project. We sent a letter that announced celebrating five years in business and thanked the customer for being a client. The letter also said we wanted to hear from them so that we could better meet their needs in the future. The graphic designer created five-year anniversary t-shirts and delivered them to his customers. Since he had only a few customers, and most of them were local, he delivered the surveys and t-shirts in person. When the survey process is done correctly, it greatly enhances the connection between the customer and the company (Key 5), especially when the customer sees his or her information put into action (Key 7). This is a proactive approach that asks for input instead of waiting for customers to call and complain or give compliments. The survey asked what we were doing well and what we needed to work on improving. It also asked the customers to rate their experience with the designer. Each question had a scale from one to ten with a space to write comments for each question. There was also additional space provided for open feedback from the customer. We asked if the customer had any projects that we could assist with in the future. Finally, we asked if they knew anyone that could
173

Marketing the Church

benefit from our services. By using this last question to ask for a referral we were able to gauge the strength of our relationship with the client and gain new business. The survey was a way to strengthen our relationship with the customers (Key 5), let them know we recognized them, cared about their business, and were taking steps to improve our services to them (Key 7).

Leveraging Surveys Besides the occasional big congregational surveys, you should be using surveys all the time, whenever possible. For every special event or retreat, survey the participants to see what went well, and what needs improvement. This may seem odd at first, but after a while people will get used to the experience and expect to be able to give feedback after the event. This involves them in the process and engages them further in the event. It is also an opportunity to ask for volunteers and contact information from folks to help next time, unless you already have enough volunteers, which is not usually the case in my experience. You can also use surveys as an outreach tool. Besides getting valuable information from potential visitors, it is a conversation starter. If you are asking parents in the community what kind of childcare, arts and sports programs their kids would enjoy, you are going to pique their interest in attending the church.

Web Overload We have already discussed the advantages of using the Internet for its ability to track the activity of viewers. The problem is that you can gather so much information that it is difficult to determine what is relevant and what to do with the information. Several software programs are available that allow you to get these statistics and put them into a usable format for analysis and presentation. I also recommend hiring a service to advise your company on useful application of the information. Another option is to install an Internet marketing department in the organization.
174

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

The bottom line is that the Internet is a vital component in the modern marketing communications process, and the smart companies will devote resources to leveraging its use.

Minister of Communication Businesses figured out they needed a new chief executive, the CIO (Chief Information Officer). There is an increased reliance on technology coupled with rapid changes in the way technology is changing and developing. Realistically your church needs either a full time minister, or capable volunteers who are seeing to the demands of information technology and communication. If not, you are going to fall behind quickly. Who is in charge of communications for your church?

Personal Selling One More Time This is the third time I implore you to value employees. Front-line salespeople and customer service representatives are the face of the company. This interaction is reciprocal. Not only does the salesperson communicate the marketing message of the company to the customer, but also customers directly relate their responses to the company representative. I have had hundreds of interactions with customers in my years as a salesman. Customers would channel their complaints and compliments directly to me. I would often urge them to complete a response card and submit it to headquarters, particularly if I agreed with their comments. My fellow salespersons and I would sadly, yet honestly, explain that the company did not listen to us, but they might listen to them if they took the time to fill out a response card. You should talk to your front-line sales people to gather feedback. Smart marketers use this valuable, timely, and already paid-for resource for gathering information. This is a win/win/win for the company and a win/win situation for the customer and salesperson. The company wins by gathering accurate data. The salespeople win because they feel valued and as if they are making a
175

Marketing the Church

contribution. The company wins again because the salespeople are more committed to a company that cares and listens to what they have to say. The customers win because they are being heard and are getting the changes they want. The company wins a third time because the customers are happier and more committed to a continued relationship. Based on this reasoning, why would any company not invest in gathering information from its salespeople? Sadly, most companies do not know any better. Lucky for you, you read this book and can beat the socks off your competition. I must admit I have my own motives for emphasizing the role of salespeople in the marketing process. The first reason is that I have spent so many years being ignored as a salesperson I desire to reform the industry and make personal selling an honorable and enjoyable profession. The second reason is that I am tired of receiving sub-par service. I have worked very hard to be friendly, outgoing, and meet the needs of my customers, and I expect the same when I go shopping. Once I had a customer remark to me that he appreciated my service and my knowledge about the products in my store. While I enjoyed the compliment, I did not feel as if I did anything extraordinary besides talk with the man and answer his questions. He said he was in the process of improving the customer service for an Internet software company he was consulting. I told him the names of some excellent books on customer service I recommend. He laughed and said that stuff was too advanced; these people just needed to learn some manners and how to be polite. Who is to blame for poor customer service? Obviously, the salesperson needs to take responsibility for his or her actions and many salespeople do not care. But companies are also to blame for not spending time or resources on a vital component of the marketing process. They blow millions on television commercials in hopes that customers will visit their stores, yet only pay their salespeople minimum wage. Any customers that do shop based on the commercials will certainly be turned off by poor service. It is a strange paradox that in an age when service is a buzzword and everyone in business is talking about great customer service, good customer service is such a rarity.
176

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Customer Service for Churches One purpose of this book is to translate terminology for some of the better practices of business into a language and context Christians can understand. However in this instance, customer service is the mindset and terminology I recommend. While working with a Christian college I realized one of their biggest deficiencies was customer service. Many, though not all, of the staff had the attitude that they were doing the students a favor by talking to them or meeting their needs. They need a paradigm shift, to succeed in business you treat your customers like they are the boss. Customers pay employee salaries, and if students decide to go somewhere else, the employees are out of a job. My recommendation was to provide customer service training with step one being to understand this fact: students are the customers. I am not putting down the staff; several have never been trained. These are good people who have made many sacrifices to work for a Christian college. It is the responsibility of the college to invest in their staff, to give them proper training, and to help them reach their full potential. Moments of Magic Shep Hyken is a master of magic and customer service. He has taken his love for magic and turned it into an entertaining presentation on how to provide great service for customers. Shep says there are moments of interactions with customers that can be turned into either moments of magic or moments of misery. Read more about Shep’s magical approach to customer service on his website (www.hyken.com). He has books, videos, presentations, and a free newsletter, I’m a subscriber and an advocate (Key 5).

Feedback Cards For physical locations you should provide cards for your customers to be able to communicate with you. Allow them to leave
177

Marketing the Church

the card with a salesperson or to mail it in to the company at their leisure. Make sure you put a stamp on the card to encourage their sending it back. To avoid postage expenses, provide a web address where customers can leave feedback. A contact/feedback section should also be a part of any web-based business.

Brochure Response Card While creating the brochure for West County Christian Church, we decided to attach a response card. On one side people can give their name and contact information; on the other side they can write their questions and comments before turning the card into the leadership. Take a look at the brochure on the Marketing the Church website (www.marketingthechurch.com).

Warrantees Warrantee cards have been used for a long time. Besides adding value to the product for customers, warrantees are a tremendous way for marketers to gather data about customers. Be careful not to make the response card too long, or few customers will take the time to return it.

Trading for Data People are willing to provide marketing information in exchange for certain benefits. My marketing professor was fond of creating events or concerts that were almost free. The only charge for admission was to fill out a response card. For example, he would stage a jazz music festival and get the names and addresses from the attendees. The response cards would ask if they were interested in receiving jazz music information and offers from vendors. After the event he had created a list of pre-qualified marketing prospects. Another way to trade for data is to have contests and giveaways that reward respondents with gifts or the chance to win a large prize.
178

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Many early Internet sites gave away free products or information in exchange for registering with the site. Be careful not to give away the store or to create a climate where there is no possibility for paying for the expense of gathering the data. Many early Internet companies went bankrupt before they could take advantage of all the information they had gathered.

Steal this Idea Build your marketing communications around inviting people to the building to become familiar with the church grounds and to start to meet people (Key 5). While they are there, get information from them. Besides contact information, find out why they attended this event, what other events would be of interest, and what it would take to get them to attend church. What visitor-friendly events do you have at your church? What events could you start right away?

Test Marketing Try your product in a test market before you fully develop it. The results may help you determine whether you should double production or scrap the project altogether. If you are thinking of carrying a new product line, try it out in some test cases first. One retail store I worked with tried a few bags from a company to see how they would sell. The product was very popular and we sold all the test models. The company worked out a deal and carried a large selection of the product from the vendor. In another case we carried another bag style that few if any people bought. We sent the rest of the test models back and said “no thanks.” If you have the ability to test market, take advantage of the opportunity.

Market Development Groups A few companies have seen success with developing a testmarketing group amongst prospective customers. Mercedes selected
179

Marketing the Church

a group and asked questions about what type of sport utility vehicle they would like to see in the future. To thank the participants they gave them hats, t-shirts, key chains and kept them abreast of the development. Once the new automobile became available, most of the participants were dying to buy one. The automaker had developed a strong relationship with this group (Key 5) and was creating the design based on the feedback gathered (Keys 6 & 7).

Confidentiality Unless your company is in the business of selling information, do not sell or share your information with other entities. If you want to destroy a relationship in a hurry, give your prospect’s name to others. This is tantamount to adultery in the customer-to-company relationship. Promise confidentiality and keep your word. If you do intend to share the information, be sure you have the permission of the customer first. Focus Groups I had the privilege of attending a focus group for an insurance company. Rows of comfortable seats and a hot Chinese food buffet awaited the heads of the company paying for the research, not the participants in the focus group. The participants in the study were eating hot dogs and potato chips. I was perched with company officials behind a large two-way mirror and enjoyed a hearty meal while watching the focus group participants gush about what a great idea the insurance product was. Were these accurate responses? Would these people really buy the product if they were not sitting in a focus group? In the end the CEO and founder summed up the results, “Well, I do not think we really learned anything we did not know, but it was an interesting thing to watch.” I have to agree with his assessment. It was hard to tell if any of those people would actually buy the product in real life based on the advertising material they were given to evaluate, but it was surely fun to watch, and our food was excellent. I am glad they were footing the large bill for the exercise and that I got to come along for the ride.
180

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Research Pitfalls Two dangers in the research process are over-researching and overemphasizing results. There is tremendous value in gaining feedback, but some companies are paralyzed by overanalyzing and therefore do not act. They continue to gather information, but are not sure what the data means or what to do with the data. Some opportunities will be missed if they are not grasped immediately. There comes a point in time when marketers must act on the best information available and use their judgment. There is always risk involved in making business decisions. That is why not everyone is in business, and those who take the risk are rewarded with success or failure. Making some kind of move leads to a better understanding of the situation. For example, if I am not sure how to price my hockey sticks, I would do some initial research to determine the price. The results range from $50-60. Eventually, I am going to have to go with my own decision. If I price the stick at $55 and sell very few, I will adjust the price down to $50; but if I never enter the market, I am not going to get the additional information I need to adjust to changes (Key 7). The second danger is overemphasizing research. People behave differently when being observed. When respondents are asked questions on surveys, in focus groups, or interviews, they tend to give favorable responses. There is a big difference between what a customer says they will buy on a survey and what they actually buy when strolling down the supermarket aisle. Researchers have named the phenomenon Heisenberg’s principle of uncertainty after the great atomic physicist. Do your homework; get as much information as possible and then act. Once you have implemented a promotion, gain more feedback and adjust to changes (Key 7). You can never do enough research to know anything will work without a doubt. As in every other facet of life, marketing requires an element of faith.

181

Marketing the Church

Faith Movement Since I just used the faith term and this is a down-to-earth treatise on the science of marketing, allow me to elaborate. First of all, every decision we make is based on an element of faith. Nothing in life is certain, even science tells us that. I cannot prove beyond a doubt that you are reading this book right now, and neither can you. There are two kinds of faith: reasonable and unreasonable. Reasonable faith is based on a certain amount of evidence and information while unreasonable faith is based on little or no information. Unreasonable faith also is the kind of faith that goes against the evidence. Here is an example to illustrate the point. Let us say I am going to drive from Los Angeles to Las Vegas in my car. I have a large gas tank and should be able to make the trip on half a tank. If I have not filled my tank in a week and my fuel gauge says empty and the little yellow light is on but I have faith I can make it to Las Vegas, then I am acting on an unreasonable faith. If on the other hand, I go to the gas station, put the nozzle in the tank, watch the numbers roll on the pump, pay my $37 for gas, get in the car and see the needle go up to full and the yellow light go off, then I am acting on a reasonable faith that I can make it to Las Vegas. In either case, I am still acting on faith that I have enough gas to make it to Las Vegas, but in the latter scenario my faith is based on reason and evidence. The point of this philosophy lesson is to communicate that your marketing decisions should be based on reason. You will never have the exhaustive knowledge necessary to guarantee success. Some information may even be skewed by the methods used to obtain the results. Nevertheless, you must have some evidence upon which to base your decisions. This is the difference between reasonable and unreasonable marketing decisions. Get as much information as possible and then use the information wisely to implement changes.

More Faith There is more at stake here than selling widgets. Your success or failure at marketing- communicating the Gospel, will
182

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

affect whether people come to Christ or not. Yes, it is a matter of faith, and ultimately we are dependent on God for the results, but you have your part to do. God has given you reason and intellect, use all the resources at your disposal to effectively communicate the Gospel. God will do the rest. But the one who received the seed that fell on good soil is the man who hears the word and understands it. He produces a crop, yielding a hundred, sixty or thirty times what was sown. (Matthew 13:23)

183

Marketing the Church

184

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

7
Key 7: Adjust to Changes
The final piece of the puzzle is to go back where you started and begin again. Marketing is an ongoing communication process that never ends.

Constant Change There are only two constants in business: change and people that think they are saying something profound when they tell you the only constant in business is change. Of course there is change, or I would be writing this book on a cave wall instead of on a laptop PC. The difference in the past couple of decades is the rate of change. Computers have greatly affected the way we gather information and implement communication. Advances in healthcare have extended the lives of modern people. Radio, television and film have increased the scope of mass communication. Companies must consistently assess their position in the marketplace and make necessary adjustments to remain competitive.

No Change Some things never change. Like islands floating in a river of uncertainty, there are truths that remain no matter what occurs in the environment. These are universal principles that will continue despite any technological advances created by humans. These are the ideals that the company’s mission statement is based upon and the direction in which the company seeks to align itself. The Seven
185

Marketing the Church

Keys to Marketing Genius contains principles that will continue as long as people are people. The details on how to apply some of these principles will change over time. Smart marketers gain feedback (Key 6) and constantly adjust to changes in market conditions.

Biblical Principles The source of the principles discussed in this book originate from God as communicated through scripture: But what the LORD has planned will stand forever. His thoughts never change. (Psalm 33:11)

No Laurels You cannot rest on the laurels of past achievement. To be successful in the long term, you must continually evaluate (Key 6) and improve your marketing efforts. Past accomplishments will not assure future success. As Janet Jackson put it, “What have you done for me lately?” Some companies fall into this trap by creating line extensions. They try to play on the success of a previous brand instead of doing the hard work of applying these seven keys to a new product. There are no shortcuts, and past praise will not provide future sales. In hockey the best teams are disciplined and the players take short 40- to 50-second shifts. A professional team will have four lines of players that take turns on the ice. In hockey a shift on the ice takes the energy of sprinting a 100-yard dash. The best players give everything they have and use all of their energy. As a coach, I want my players to come to the bench tired because that means they used everything on the ice. Each line skates their hardest and comes to the bench for a short rest. In marketing you should either keep playing hard or go to the bench and have a seat. To go through the motions or coast around because you scored a goal last week will not cut it. Marketing requires all your energy and resources. If you do not put
186

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

everything into your efforts or rely on yesterday’s victories, I guarantee you will lose today.

The Good Old Days Look at the grand churches of Europe, many of them built by the Roman Catholic Church. Today, they are partially full; many have closed their doors because the leaders lost their ability to communicate in a relevant manner. Don’t confuse sticking to biblical principles with being a stick in the mud. Jesus was an innovator in his day. The Sermon on the Mount was a re-telling of Old Testament principles in a contemporary context for Jesus’ audience. You can be modern, relevant, and hold to conservative fundamental principles at the same time. You can’t go back to the good old days, so don’t be a grumbler like the Israelites in the desert: Why is the LORD bringing us to this land only to let us fall by the sword? Our wives and children will be taken as plunder. Wouldn't it be better for us to go back to Egypt? (Numbers 14:3) In this desert your bodies will fall—every one of you twenty years old or more who was counted in the census and who has grumbled against me. (Numbers 14:29) Ouch- no milk and honey for these complainers. How about you and your church? Are you ready to move forward into the Promised Land? Are you giving it all you have to reach your community for Christ?

The Revisit and Revise Ad Infinitum Continuum Implementing the seven keys is an ongoing process. Continue to revisit and revise these elements by asking these questions:
187

Marketing the Church

• •

SWOT- Have there been changes in the market place? Is your competitive advantage still unique? Are there ways to stay ahead of or hedge competitors? Are there internal or external threats on the horizon? Mission- If you have done the hard work of creating a mission statement, it will come to mind whenever making decisions. The mission should also be revisited and revised at least twice a year. Evaluate how well the organization is fulfilling the mission. If it is aligned with the mission, you can feel confident that you are on the right path. If not, you will need either to refocus the energies of the organization or to revamp the mission statement to more closely fit with the true values of the organization. Goals- Are you on the path to meet or exceed your goals? Are the goals still realistic? What new goals should you be creating for the future? Alignment and Synergy- Is the company and product still in alignment with the mission? With universal principles? Is there alignment and synergy between the stated competitive advantages (Key 1), the purpose (Key 2), the image (Key 3), the promotions (Key 4), the relationships that are being established (Key 5), the data that is being gathered (Key 6) and the changes that are being made (Key 7)? Relationships- Are you establishing, maintaining, and affirming long-term, protected relationships with customers and employees?

You should ask these and other questions over and over again on a regular basis. Once you are satisfied with the results, start over again.

Reflection You are never done. Continue to evaluate your progress, and ask God to show you the next step for your church: Search me, O God, and know my heart; test me and know my anxious thoughts. See if there is any offensive way in me, and lead me in the way
188

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

everlasting. (Psalm 139:23-24)

Show Them the Results Few companies do a good job of gathering data, and even fewer are good at implementing the necessary changes. What is rarer still is the company that gains feedback (Key 5), implements changes (Key 6), and shows the customers the results of their feedback (Key 7). Imagine the feeling customers get when they see their ideas implemented by a company. Can you imagine the affinity they will have toward that company? This is a powerful tool that not only gets the company on the same page as the customers but creates a powerful dynamic relationship between the marketer and the consumers.

Involvement=Commitment Involvement equals commitment; this is true on many levels and in many areas of life including the marketing process. The reason why showing the implementation of feedback to consumers is so powerful is because it intricately involves them with the product. Take the example of Mercedes who test marketed the SUV. By the time they were ready to manufacture the vehicle, the study group involved felt very committed to the project and wanted to make a purchase. The whole marketing process is about involving consumers with a product in hopes that they will begin a long-term commitment to its use (Key 5). Showing customers how you have implemented their feedback is a tremendous win/win tool in this process.

189

Marketing the Church

190

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Conclusion
So you finished the book, congratulations. I hope you had as much fun reading it as I did writing it. Do you feel smarter? Like a marketing genius? You should! You now know the importance of finding your advantage (Key 1) so that you have the edge to dominate the market with your product. You understand why you must define your purpose (Key 2) so your company and your product can drive towards meeting the needs of customers. You are adept at creating an image (Key 3) that is consistently irresistible. You know the ins and outs of implementing promotions (Key 4) that have the power of synergy. You are well versed with how to effectively build relationships (Key 5). You know how and why to gain feedback (Key 6) in order to effectively evaluate your efforts and adjust to changes (Key 7). Congratulations, you are now a marketing genius. If you have a fairly good understanding of these seven keys you are way ahead of the competition, and most marketing and advertising professionals. I have one request, and that is for you to be an advocate for this book. If this book was helpful to you, please recommend it to a friend, relative, professor, or publisher. I appreciate your partnership in increasing the marketing IQ of the world. Communication Genius OK, so becoming a marketing genius may not have been your goal, but how about a communication genius, or expert evangelizer, or Gospel guru? Use the tools in this book to turn your church into something amazing. Use the information in this book to effectively reveal the remarkable nature of what you are communicating: a loving God who sacrificed his son to repair a broken relationship with us. If you need help, check out the resources I listed in this book or contact me directly: michael@marketingthechurch.com. I would love to hear from you and get your feedback. God bless you! So be careful to do what the LORD your God has commanded you; do not turn aside to the right or to the left. Walk in all the way that the LORD
191

Marketing the Church

your God has commanded you, so that you may live and prosper and prolong your days in the land that you will possess. (Deuteronomy 5:32-33) I Need Your Help I have a passion to share the message of this book with pastors, ministers and non-profit leaders. I believe the tools in this book will help them be more effective in reaching the lost with the message of Christ. Please help by sharing this book with the people you know that could benefit. If you can not afford to buy them a copy, then loan them this one, it’s OK with me. I am happy as long as the word is getting out. Get the latest info and resources at the Marketing the Church website (www.MarketingTheChurch.com). Thank you for reading and sharing this book.

192

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Church Marketing Resource Guide
Visit the Marketing the Church website for updates and active links (www.MarketingTheChurch.com) Christian Technology Solutions If you are looking for a full service website and technology provider then look to Christian Technology Solutions to meet your needs. www.christiantechnologysolutions.com marketingenious marketingenious is your one stop shop to increase your marketing IQ. There are tons of free resources and they will help you find ways to be a better steward of your finances while reaching more people through effective communications. www.marketingenious.com marketingenious University The new home of Marketing Your Church 101 (MYC 101). If you like this book and want to get you team on board then take this course together. MYC101 will get you team on the same page and help you write a marketing plan in a few weeks. www.marketingeniousUniversity.com Nexdesign Studios Nexdesign Studios specializes in web design services for the nonprofit sector and provides a discounted rate on standard web design services to those that qualify. www.nexdesignstudios.com HOPE International University Located in beautiful sunny Southern California, HOPE International University is great place for you to get a sound Christian education that is relevant in the real world. They have been equipping servant leaders since 1928. www.hiu.edu

193

Marketing the Church

PR Zap! PR Zap! specializes in Internet press release distribution. Tell the story of your church or organization in a news release format and grab the attention of thousands of reporters and Internet users. www.przap.com

Rock Harbor Church Exciting and innovative Church in Costa Mesa California. www.rockharbor.org Saddleback Church This Rick Warren lead ministry in Southern California is a great example and provides some neat resources for other churches on their website. www.saddleback.com Windsor Crossing Church Looking to take a friend to a church with a low cringe factor? Windsor’s approach to music, speaking and ministry is user friendly and promotes an attitude of excellence. www.windsorcrossing.org Saint Louis Christian College Saint Louis Christian College has been educating Christians and graduating leaders for over 50 years. Strategically located in St. Louis County the campus provides many ministry opportunities in urban, suburban, rural and global settings. www.slcconline.edu Scott Ginsberg Scott is that guy with the nametag and the expert in networking and building relationships through approachability. He’s also a fun guy. www.hellomynameisscott.com Shep Hyken’s Moments of Magic Magician, author, customer service guru- these are just some of the ways to describe Shep. If you want to turn your church into a magic place to be, Shep can show you how. www.hyken.com
194

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

ShineFish ShineFish is your source for Christian based marketing and design Help. Whether you are looking for a creative team, website building, logo creation or media communications ShineFish is dedicated to helping church and para-church organizations thrive. www.shinefish.com University Praise Church Cell church model congregation in Fullerton, California ministering to post modern people. www.universitypraise.org West County Christian Church Vibrant and growing congregation in St. Louis, Missouri that is embracing the power of modern marketing tools to increase communication. www.wcccstl.org Willowcreek Church The purpose of this church in the Chicago, Illinois area lead by Bill Hybels, is to help your church grow. Great leadership resources, tools and seminars. www.willowcreek.com

195

Marketing the Church

196

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Visit the Official Marketing the Church Website for more information and an up to date Church Marketing Resource Guide

www.MarketingTheChurch.com
197

Marketing the Church

Let Your Light Shine
ShineFish is your source for Christian based marketing and design help. Whether you are looking for a creative team, website building, logo creation or media communications ShineFish is dedicated to helping your church or para-church organization thrive. In the same way, let your light shine before men, that they may see your good deeds and praise your Father in heaven. (Matthew 5:16)

www.shinefish.com

198

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Get YOUR Team Moving in the Same Direction

You can have a marketing plan for your church in as little as 7 weeks.

Find out more at:

www.marketingeniousUniversity.com
199

Marketing the Church

Max My Mail
Maximum Impact Email Marketing

Are you leveraging the power of email marketing? Email marketing is cost effective, gets immediate results, is targeted, and simple. Email marketing is an affordable way to stretch a tight marketing budget - and whose isn't these days? Unlike direct mail, there is virtually no production, materials or postage expense. Email marketing is 20 times more cost effective than direct mail, and can cost as little as fractions of a penny per email.

Free 60 day trial at: www.maxmymail.com
200

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Nexdesign Studios

Nexdesign Studios specializes in web and graphic design services for the nonprofit sector and provides a discounted rate on standard services for qualifying organizations. Catch your wave with Nexdesign Studios.

www.nexdesignstudios.com
201

Marketing the Church

Christian Technology Solutions
Over 20% of Internet users (nearly 20 million) have used the Internet to seek spiritual and religious information- on an average day more than 2 million people are getting spiritual material online. -The Pew Internet Project You need a website solution from a company with Christian principles. You need Christian Technology Solutions.

www.christiantechnologysolutions.com
202

Communicating Your Church’s Purpose and Passion in a Modern Context

Increase your marketing IQ further by visiting the marketingenious website

www.marketingenious.com

Check out the free Marketing Toolbox on the site for great marketing tips and tricks

203

Marketing the Church

Marketing The Church Book Order Form Name: Organization: Shipping Address: City: Phone: State: Email: Zip: Title:

Marketing The Church is $19.95 per copy plus $6 for shipping and handling. Please include your check for $25.95 with this form when placing your order. Mail to: Marketing the Church Book Order c/o ShineFish Books 328 Bellezza Drive Ballwin, MO 63021

Make life easier by ordering online at:
MarketingTheChurch.com

Need more than 10 books? Save up to 50% with bulk orders!
Check the website or Contact Michael Daehn for details: 636.236.5718 Michael@MarketingTheChurch.com
204

Sign up to vote on this title
UsefulNot useful