WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION

DATA
Water tank type 2 (shop drawing attached)

WATER TANK
W= 30t

1300mm

2700mm
1

2

WATER
WATER TANK
TANK
3mx4m
3mx4m
W=
W= 30t
30t

3

2700mm
q = 30t/3mx4m = 2.5t/m²

4

1250mm

2670mm

Frame load distribution (Live Load) :
- Frame 1
=
q1 = 2.5t/m² x (0.95m+0.165m) = 2.7875 t/m
q2 = 2.5t/m² x 1.5m = 3.75 t/m
- Frame

2

=

q = 2.5t/m² x 1.5m = 3.75 t/m

- Frame

3

=

q1 = 2.5t/m² x (0.35m+0.165m) = 1.2875 t/m

- Frame

4

=

q = 2.5t/m² x 1.5m = 3.75 t/m

D
A

E
F

B
C

WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION
REACTION (KN)
Column X
Y
Z
0.21
0.34
2.72
A
20.28
-4.89
151.02
B
C
14.41
4.55
110.69
D
-0.21
0.34
2.72
E
-20.28
-4.89
151.02
F
-14.41
4.55
110.69
2. MOMENT (KNm)

A
D

B
C

E

F

A
D

B
E

C
F

WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION

3. P-M Ratio

A
B
D

C
E
F

4. Shear Diagram (KN)

A

D

B
E

C
F

WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION

5. Deflection

According to SAP2000 analysis, maximum deflection is 0.75431 mm

WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION

LOADING
Load combination:
1.2 DL + 1.6 LL
DL (Dead Load)
LL (Live Load)

= SAP2000 analysis
= 30 t

REFERENCE
AISC Steel Construction Manual (LRFD Methods Design)

RESULT
result from sap2000 calculation :
1. Column reaction (KN)

D
F
A

E
F

B

C

Calculation of deflection by SAP2000 Previous design using concrete foundation Modeling water tank concrete foundation by SAP2000 . Weight Comparison between Water Tank Concrete Foundation and Water Tank Steel Foundation Weight comparison based on ultimate deflection.C B A WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION 6.

081 mm Moment Calculation by SAP2000 (KNm) Moment due weight of concrete foundation (KNm) .169 mm WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION Modeling water tank steel foundation by SAP2000 Deflection Calculation by SAP2000 Ultimate deflection obtained by concrete foundation load is 3.Deflection Calculation by SAP2000 Ultimate deflection obtained by concrete foundation load is 7.

hence the weight of steel foundation is considered structurally safe. After being analysed of PM ratio by SAP2000. Ultimate Moment by concrete foundation is greater than the one by steel foundation.WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION SUMMARY 1. Ultimate Deflection Concrete Foundation Steel Foundation 7.081 mm Difference 4.088mm 3. it could be concluded that steel foundation is capable of supporting water tank 2. meaning that the weight obtained by steel foundation is smaller than the one by concrete foundation. hence the weight of steel .169 mm 3. Ultimate deflection by concrete foundation is greater than the one by steel foundation. meaning that the weight obtained by steel foundation is smaller than the one by concrete foundation.

4 KNm 45. Ultimate Moment Concrete Foundation Steel Foundation 143.66 KNm Difference 97.4 KNm Moment due weight of steel foundation (KNm) .foudnation is considered structurally safe.74 KNm WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION Ultimate moment obtained by concrete foundation load is 143.

66 KNm .Moment max obtained by steel foundation load is 45.

33/m² x 1.WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION DATA Water tank type 3 (shop drawing attached) 3 WATER WATER TANK TANK 3mx3m 3mx3m 1 WATER TANK W= 30t 2700mm 2 W= W= 30t 30t 2700mm q = 30t/3mx3m = 3.0626 t/m .33t/m² 1885mm 575mm Frame load distribution (Live Load) : .33t/m² x (0.Frame 1 = q1 = 3.995 t/m D E A F B C .5m = 4.Frame 3 = q1 = 3.33/m² x 1.95m + 0.5m = 4.27m) = 4.Frame 2 = q = 3.995 t/m .

08 0.page 1 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION Column X A B C D E F REACTION (KN) Y Z 0.19 -6. MOMENT (KNm) D F A G B C D E A F B C .19 1.6 52.65 23.35 0.71 196.11 -0.16 -6.61 -0.41 6.4 6.35 2.62 52.6 0.57 -23.61 197.31 -0.

P-M Ratio D E A F B C 4.page 3 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION 3. Shear Diagram D E A F B C .

page 4 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION 5. Deflection According to SAP2000 analysis.0929 mm . maximum deflection is 1.

2 DL + 1.6 LL DL (Dead Load) LL (Live Load) = SAP2000 analysis = 30 t REFERENCE AISC Steel Construction Manual (LRFD Methods Design) RESULT result from sap2000 calculation : 1. Column reaction (KN) D E A F B C .page 5 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION LOADING Load combination: 1.

Weight Comparison between Water Tank Concrete Foundatio and Water Tank Steel Foundation Weight comparison based on ultimate deflection.C B page 2 oundation WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION 6. Calculation of deflection by SAP2000 Previous design using concrete foundation Modeling water tank concrete foundation by SAP2000 .

481 mm page 6 .478 mm Moment Calculation by SAP2000 (KNm) Moment due weight of concrete foundation (KNm) .Deflection Calculation by SAP2000 .081 mm WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION Modeling water tank steel foundation by SAP2000 Deflection Calculation by SAP2000 Ultimate deflection obtained by concrete foundation load is 0.169 mm Ultimate deflection obtained by concrete foundation load is 1.

hence the weight of ste foundation is considered structurally safe.page 7 foundation eight of steel foundation eight of steel WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION SUMMARY 1. meaning that the weight obtained by steel foundation is smaller than the one by concrete foundation.003 mm 3. hence the weight of ste .478 mm Difference 1. meaning that the weight obtained by steel foundation is smaller than the one by concrete foundation. it could be concluded that steel foundation is capable of supporting water tank 2. After being analysed of PM ratio by SAP2000. Ultimate deflection by concrete foundation is greater than the one by steel foundation.481 mm 0. Ultimate Moment by concrete foundation is greater than the one by steel foundation. Ultimate Deflection Concrete Foundation Steel Foundation 1.

3.4 KNm foudnation is considered structurally safe.35 KNm 21 KNm Difference 39.35 KNm Moment due weight of steel foundation (KNm) . Ultimate Moment Concrete Foundation Steel Foundation 60.35 KNm page 8 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION Ultimate moment obtained by concrete foundation load is 60.

Moment max obtained by steel foundation load is 21 KNm page 9 .

01m = 2.2325m) = 3.945m+0.7675m = 4.2325m = 0.3165 t/m q2 = 2.Frame 2 = q1 = 2.68t/m² x 1.68t/m² x (0.01m = 2.7675m = 4.2375m = 3.6231 t/m = 2.2325m = 0.7675m = 4.CULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION DATA Water tank type 4 (shop drawing attached) 7 2 4 WATER WATER TANK TANK 4mx7m 4mx7m R TANK = 30t 1 3 6 5 3535mm W= W= 75t 75t q = 75t/4mx7m = 2 7 2 4 2700mm 2020mm = 4.68t/m² x 1.Frame 7 = q1 q2 q1 q2 = 2.Frame 5 = q1 = 2.4941 t/m .3165 t/m = 2.68t/m² x 0.Frame 3 = q1 = 2.68t/m² x 0.6231 t/m q2 = 2.7068 t/m .0626 t/m 2006mm 2475mm 2020mm Frame load distribution (Live Load) : .736 t/m D E I C B J H A G F K .68t/m² x 1.16 q2 = 2.6231 t/m .2325m = 0.68t/m² x 1.5575m = 1.Frame 1 = q1 = 2.Frame 4 = q1 = 2.69t/m² x 1.0025m = 2.6867 t/m = 2.736 t/m q2 = 2.68t/m² x 0.7068 t/m .Frame 6 = .68t/m² x 1.68t/m² x 1.736 t/m .69t/m² x 1.68t/m² x 0.2375m = 3.

26 4.7 27.04 19.1 -0.92 215.81 282.53 117.85 1.34 -17.71 5.18 -6.63 2.47 0.96 93.05 -17.27 -2.39 34.77 -0.89 14. MOMENT (KNm) D E J C I B H A G K F D E A C I B H G A F J .48 -26.43 0.68 Column X A B C D E F G H I J K L M 2.17 2.CULATION page 1 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION REACTION (KN) Y Z 1.8 1.84 282.46 237.24 -2.01 218.78 -4.93 -6.07 31.07 35.8 14.09 4.47 3.17 1.34 237.96 29.4 -1.

Shear Diagram E D B I C H A G F .page 3 CULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION 3. P-M Ratio E D J C I B H A K G F 4.

CULATION n is 1. Deflection According to SAP2000 analysis.707 . maximum deflection is 4.0929 mm page 4 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION 5.

Column reaction (KN) E D C I B H A G F .6 LL DL (Dead Load) LL (Live Load) = SAP2000 analysis = 75 t REFERENCE AISC Steel Construction Manual (LRFD Methods Design) RESULT result from sap2000 calculation : 1.page 5 CULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION LOADING Load combination: 1.2 DL + 1.

A page 2 CULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION oncrete Foundation 6. Calculation deflection by SAP2000 Previous design using concrete foundation Modeling water tank concrete foundation by SAP2000 . Weight Comparison between Water Tank Concrete F and Water Tank Steel Foundation alculation of Weight comparison based on ultimate deflection.

478 mm WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION Modeling water tank steel foundation by SAP2000 Deflection Calculation by SAP2000 Ultimate deflection obtained by concrete foundation load is 0 Moment Calculation by SAP2000 (KNm) Momen due weight of concrete foundation (KNm) .481 mm Ultimate deflection obtained by concrete foundation load is 1 page 6 CULATION n load is 0.Deflection Calculation by SAP2000 n load is 1.

Ultimate Deflection Concrete Foundation Steel Foundation 1.003 mm than the one by d by steel foundation nce the weight of steel 1. Ultimate deflection by concrete foundation is greater than th steel foundation. hence the we .477 mm 3. meaning that the weight obtained by steel is smaller than the one by concrete foundation.771 mm 0. hence the we foundation is considered structurally safe.page 7 CULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION SUMMARY ld be concluded er than the one by d by steel foundation nce the weight of steel Difference 1. Ultimate Moment by concrete foundation is greater than the steel foundation. After being analysed of PM ratio by SAP2000. meaning that the weight obtained by steel is smaller than the one by concrete foundation. it could be con that steel foundation is capable of supporting water tank 2.

79 KNm page 8 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALCULATION Ultimate moment obtained by concrete foundation load is 81 Moment due weight of steel foundation (KNm) .foudnation is considered structurally safe.35 KNm CULATION load is 60. Ultimate Moment Difference 39.35 KNm Concrete Foundation Steel Foundation 81.41 KNm 13.

79 KNm page 9 .Moment max obtained by steel foundation load is 13.

85t/m² x 1.85t/m² x 1.08 .85t/m² x 1.2325m) = 3.544 t/m .44m x 2 = 11.85t/m² x 1.44m = 5.Frame 8 = q = 3.08 .85t/m² x 1.Frame 9 = q = 3.Frame 1 = q = 3.08 .85t/m² x 1.44m = 5.736 t/m M L Frame Frame Fy Fu 4 7 8 2225 4400 13 W= W= 300 300 tt 9 1925 = H200x200x8x12 = H250x250x9x14 = 250 Mpa = 400 Mpa Frame load distribution (Live Load) : .44m x 2 = 11.7068 t/m 5m = 0.3165 t/m 5m = 0.7068 t/m 5m = 4.Frame 7 = q = 3.6867 t/m 5m = 3.6231 t/m 5m = 4.Frame 5 = q = 3.544 t/m .85t/m² x 1.44m x 2 = 11.44m = 5.68t/m² 2700 2700 m+0.6231 t/m 5m = 3.08 .44m = 5.08 .6231 t/m 5m = 4.125m = 4.Frame 2 = q = 3.ION CALCULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALC DATA Water tank type 1 (shop drawing attached) 9 8 7 1 2 3 WATER TANK WATER 13 12 TANK 13mx6m 13mx6m 12 1 q = 75t/4mx7m = 2.Frame 3 = q = 3.Frame 10 = q = 3.Frame 11 = q = 3.3165 t/m = 2.44m x 2 = 11.Frame 4 = q = 3.4941 t/m 5m = 2.85t/m² x 1.85t/m² x 1.33 t/m .544 t/m .544 t/m .85t/m² x 1.544 t/m .85t/m² x 1.736 t/m 5m = 1.44m = 5.736 t/m 5m = 0.44m x 2 = 11.16 t/m = 2.Frame 6 = q = 3.

Frame 12 = q1 = 3.85t/m² x 2.71 q2 = 3.47 t/m q2 = 3.33 t/ q2 = 3.79 q2 = 3.125m = 4.85t/m² x 0.85t/m² x 1.79 E D C B A K J I M L S R Q L LOADING Load combination: 1.125m = 4.85t/m² x 1.33 t/ .9625m = 3.Frame 13 = q1 = 3.2 DL + 1.9625m = 3.85t/m² x 0.Frame 14 = .6 LL DL (Dead Load) LL (Live Load) = SAP2000 analysis = 300 t REFERENCE AISC Steel Construction Manual (LRFD Methods De M L K RESULT result from sap2000 calculation .7625m = 6.71 .85t/m² x 1.7625m = 6.2m = 8.85t/m² x 1.page 1 ION CALCULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALC .Frame 15 = q1 = 3.

02 -0.72 0 38.77 0 -43.24 0 23.41 3.19 19.12 4.58 0 7.51 -9.55 0.23 -24.97 -17. Column reaction (KN) E M D C B L A K J I L S R Q Column J M L K A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S REACTION (KN) X Y 0.12 -21.66 -18.2 -14.85 0.13 0.3 -26.85 -0.52 0 7.02 0.55 -0.12 4.19 .page 3 ION CALCULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALC 1.03 0 -36.13 0.43 12.39 0 0.18 0 0.77 1.

12 14.41 17.ION CALCULATION T U V W X 19.707 mm B A K J L S I R Q 4.51 -18.3 3. Shear Diagram E D C B A K J I 5.77 page 4 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALC 3.97 12.23 -21. Deflection S R Q L .43 24.66 26. P-M Ratio E D C m deflection is 4.9 9.

C deflection by SAP2000 Previous design using concrete foundation ethods Design) Modeling water tank concrete foundation by SAP20 J M L K Deflection Calculation by SAP2000 . Weight Comparison between Water Tank C and Water Tank Steel Foundation Weight comparison based on ultimate deflection. maximum deflectio page 5 ION CALCULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALC 6.According to SAP2000 analysis.

Ultimate deflection obtained by concrete foundatio page 2 ION CALCULATION er Tank Concrete Foundation WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALC Modeling water tank steel foundation by SAP2000 flection. Calculation of by SAP2000 Deflection Calculation by SAP2000 Ultimate deflection obtained by concrete foundatio .

771 mm page 6 ION CALCULATION SAP2000 WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALC Moment Calculation by SAP2000 (KNm) Momen due weight of concrete foundation foundation load is 0.477 mm .foundation load is 1.

294 mm is greater than the one by ht obtained by steel foundation dation. hence the weight of steel Difference 1. hence the weight of steel . it could be concluded rting water tank on is greater than the one by ht obtained by steel foundation dation.Ultimate moment obtained by concrete foundation page 7 ION CALCULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALC Momen due weight of steel foundation 000.

41 KNm 2.Difference Moment max obtained by steel foundation load is 67. Ultimate Deflection Concrete Foundation Steel Foundation 2.72 KNm page 8 ION CALCULATION WATER TANK STEEL FOUNDATION CALC SUMMARY 1. he foundation is considered structurally safe.823 mm . meaning that the weight obtained is smaller than the one by concrete foundation. After being analysed of PM ratio by SAP2000.385 mm 1. Ultimate deflection by concrete foundation is great steel foundation. it cou that steel foundation is capable of supporting wate oundation load is 81.

Ultimate Moment by concrete foundation is greater steel foundation.79 KNm .3. he foudnation is considered structurally safe.19 KNm 28. Ultimate Moment n load is 13.79 KNm page 9 Concrete Foundation Steel Foundation 132. meaning that the weight obtained is smaller than the one by concrete foundation.

44m = 5.FOUNDATION CALCULATION ng attached) ER ER TANK TANK mx6m mx6m = = 300 300 tt 10 11 14 5 2880 15 2880 6 14 10 15 11 2250 3525 q = 300t/13mx6m = 3.44m = 5.44m x 2 = 11.544 t/m ² x 1.544 t/m ² x 1.088 t/m ² x 1.33 t/m ² x 1.44m = 5.544 t/m ² x 1.544 t/m ² x 1.088 t/m ² x 1.44m x 2 = 11.85t/m² ² x 1.544 t/m .125m = 4.088 t/m ² x 1.44m = 5.44m x 2 = 11.44m = 5.088 t/m ² x 1.088 t/m ² x 1.44m x 2 = 11.44m x 2 = 11.

125m = 4.33 t/m m² x 1.9625m = 3.page 1 FOUNDATION CALCULATION m² x 2.79 t/m m² x 1.9625m = 3.2m = 8.71 t/m m² x 0.71 t/m m² x 1.33 t/m m² x 1.7625m = 6.125m = 4.47 t/m m² x 0.79 t/m F G M N H P O U V T 0 analysis l (LRFD Methods Design) W X .7625m = 6.

46 35.07 253.46 35.93 209.2 440.61 139.43 4 2.page 2 FOUNDATION CALCULATION F G M N H O U T CTION (KN) Z 4 2.91 5.93 P V W X .25 321.87 279.59 1.48 143.54 69.77 630 337 574.

87 279.209.4 143.91 page 3 FOUNDATION CALCULATION F G M N H P O U V W X T F G M N H U T P O V W X .61 139.07 253.

207mm page 4 FOUNDATION CALCULATION een Water Tank Concrete Foundation ltimate deflection. Calculation of foundation oundation by SAP2000 .maximum deflection is 7.

823 mm .y concrete foundation load is 2.385 mm page 5 FOUNDATION CALCULATION dation by SAP2000 y concrete foundation load is 1.

page 6 FOUNDATION CALCULATION foundation .

19 KNm FOUNDATION CALCULATION page 7 .concrete foundation load is 132.

79 KNm page 8 FOUNDATION CALCULATION o by SAP2000. it could be concluded e of supporting water tank e foundation is greater than the one by the weight obtained by steel foundation rete foundation. eflection Steel Foundation 1.823 mm . hence the weight of steel urally safe.foundation load is 28.

hence the weight of steel urally safe.oundation is greater than the one by the weight obtained by steel foundation rete foundation. Moment Steel Foundation 28.79 KNm page 9 .