You are on page 1of 46

7r

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 1 of 46 PageID #:1

WILLIAM M. SCITMALFELDT,
3209 S. Lake Dr., Apt 108
Saint f,'rancis, WI 53235
Pro Se Plainfiff
Y.

PATRICK G. GRADY
Aka oPaul Krendler'
1103 N. Chesapeake Ct.
Palrtine,lL60/D,47
SARAH R PALMER
501Redd St
Reidsville, NC 27320
Defendanb

SR

)
)
)

United States District Court


for the Northem District of Illinois

I
i
)
)
)

t:16-cv-07150
ludge Sara L. Ellis
Magistrate Judge Young B. Kim

c
RECEI

VE

JUL

I I Z0t6

BRUTON

-THOIIIASG
CTERK,
U S DISTRICTCOURT

COMPLAINT FOR DEFAMATION PER SE, CTYIL CONSPIRACY, FALSE LIGIIT


InwAsIoN oF PRTVACY, HARASSMENT, TNTENTTONAL rNX'LICTTON Or
EMOTIONAL DISTRESS, STALKTNG AI\[D MTSAPPROPRIATTON OF PLAINTIFF'S
NAME AI\ID LIKEIYESS
COMES NOW PlaintiffWilliam M. Schmalfeldt, Sr. with this complaint for defamation
per se, civil conspiracy, false light invasion of privacy, harassment intentional infliction

of

emotional distress, stalking, and misappropriation of plaintiffs name and likeness. These tortious
acts were committed by Patrick G. Grady, who blogs under the pseudonym "Paul Krendler" at

http://thinkinemanszombie.com; and by Sarah R. Palmer, who blogs under at least two


pseudonyms: "The Dread Pirate Zombie" at http://billysez.wordpress.com, and as "Ashterah" on
various other web sites. The purpose was to increase their blog followings and donations thereto

by smearing the reputation of Plaintitrwith false allegations, private information and defamatory
mistruths.

,na

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 2 of 46 PageID #:2

PARTIES

1.

William M. Schmalfeldt, Sr., is a 6l-year old widower residing at3209

S. Lake

Drive, Aparftnent 108, Saint Francis, Wisconsin. He took an early disability retirement from the
federal government

in2Oll

and media liaison for the

after working for the National Institutes of Health as a writer/editor

NIH Clinical Center. He retired due to the advanced condition of his

Parkinson's disease, for which he was diagnosed in 2000. When his wife died in June 2015,

Plaintiffdecided to move from his home in Maryland and relocate in or near Milwaukee,
Wisconsin. Since 2014he has been subjected to near daily defamation and harassment from
defendants.

2.

Patrick G. Grady resides at I103 N. Chesapeake Ct. in Palatine, Illinois. On

information and belief he is a systems analyst for a company called Capgemini at one of their
Chicago area offices. He is a self-described sufferer of bipolar disease and has, in the past,
blamed his wife for limiting his success by insisting he hold a steady job. One of his children is a
young adult, suffering from spina bifida. In April 2014, Grady began blogging under the
pseudonym of "Paul Krendler," the name of the character played by Ray Liotta in the movie

"Hannibal." The entire subject of his blog at http://thinkingmanszombie.com is dedicated to


defaming and misrepresenting the reputation of Plaintiff. Plaintiffleamed of "Krendler's" real

identity through a variety of means, including the identification of 50 images posted on his blog
where the metadata 1 indicates the images were uploaded to the web site by Patrick Grady

(Exhibit A). On information and belief, "Krendler" has never specifically denied that he is
Patrick Grady, as he seems to prefer playing games with the Plaintiffrather than either admiuing

M"t dut is information embedded in online images that describes how and when and by whom a particular set of
data was collected, and how the data is formatted, including the name of the person who either shot or uploaded the
image onto a website.

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 3 of 46 PageID #:3

or denying this fact. Defendant Grady obtained a restaining order against Plaintiffusing
o'hate
blog"
fraudulent information, never mentioning to the Court that he was the author of a

directed at Plaintiff.

3.

Saxah Palmer resides at 501 Redd St.,

in Reidsville, NC, where she, on

information and belief, cohabitates with an individual named Chad Rakes. According to her
husband, Michael Palmer of Inyokern, California, Defendant Palmer was committing adultery

with an unidentified individual when she abandoned him and one of her two daughters to flee
across country to cheat on her boyfriend and husband with Iv{r. Rakes. Her elder daughter moved

with her after facing charges of shaking her infant son. On information and belief, the
adjudication is sealed, but Defendant Palmer's husband revealed to plaintiffthat the daughter
was given a choice

ofjoining the Army or going to jail, leaving Defendant Palmer to raise the

damaged child. Palmer also obtained a restraining order against

Plaintiffafter demanding that

Plaintiffstop contacting her and stop mentioning the damaged child. This gives rise to the much
used defamatory comment "toddler stalker" used in reference to

Plaintiffby both defendants.

JURISDICTION AND Vf, i\tTJE

This court has general andpersonaljurisdiction overbothdefendants as

Defendant Grady is an Illinois resident and Defendant Palmer as this case is filed as a diversity
question under 28 U.S.C. $ 1332(a)(l) as all parties reside in different states and the arnount in

conhoversy exceeds $75,000.

5.

Venue is appropriate under 28 U.S.C. $ l39l(bX2X3) as Defendant Grady lives in

the forum state and a substantial portion of the events giving rise to the complaint occurred in

Illinois.

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 4 of 46 PageID #:4

6.

This court has subject matter jurisdiction to hear cases where complete diversrty

of citizens applies. Plaintifflives in Wisconsin, Defendant Grady lives in the forum state of

Illinois, Defendant Grady resides in North Carolina The amount in controversy exceeds
$75,000.

TIIE CTVIL CONSPIRACY

7.

Defendants Grady and Johnson have worked closely to coordinate their attacks on

Plaintiff. Although not a tort unto itself, Civil Conspiracy is firrnly established in case law.2
FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION

8,
a case

Defamation Per Se

Illinois recognizes that certain statements constitute defamation per

se.3

To prove

of defamation per se, the Plaintiff must establish the defendant(s) made a false statement

about the

plaintifl there was an "unprivileged" publication to a third party, fault by the

defendant(s) of "negligence" or worse and the publication damaged the plaintiffs reputation

a.

Painting Plaintiffas a Child Pornographer

9.

Defendant Grady has stated on his blog that Plaintiffis a child pomographer.

"To state a claim for civil conspiracy, the plaintiffmust allege facts establishing: (l) an agreement to accomplish
by concerted action either an unlawful purpose or a lawful purpose by unlawful means; (2) a tortious act committed
in furtherance of that agreement; and (3) an injury caused by the defendant." Kovac v. Barron. 2014lL App (2d)
12l 100.

will always be considered defamatory and are assumed to harm the


need to prove that harm. In Illinois, a statement that does any of the following

These statements are so egregious that they

plaintiffs reputation, without further


things amounts to defamation per se:

.
'
'
'
o

accuses the

plaintiffof committing

crime;

indicates that the plaintiffis infected with a loathsome communicable disease;


indicates that the plaintiffis unable to perform or lacks integrity in performing his or her employment
duties;
attributes to the plaintiffa lack of ability or otherwise harms the plaintiffin his or her profession; or
accuses the plaintiffof engaging in adultery or fornication.

Solaia Tech., LLC v. Specialty Pub'g Co., 852 N.E.2d 825, 839 (I11.2006).

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 5 of 46 PageID #:5

BILL SCHMALFELDT HIMSELF ENGAGES IN SEX ACTS WITH


I-INDERAGE CUB SCOUTS INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO
URINATION ON SAID CUB SCOUTS, PERFORMING ANAL SEX ON
LTNDERAGE CUB SCOLTTS AND FORCING LTNDERAGE CUB SCOUTS TO
ORALLY PLEASURE ADULTS AND EACH OTHER. (All Caps In Original,
Thinking Man Zombie Blog. July 6, 2016.)

BILL SCIIMALFELDT IS A CHILD PORNOGRAPHER, WIIICH IS


X'UCKING DISGUSTING EVEN IF IT IS NOT IVECESSARILY A CRIME.
(AlI Caps in Original, Thinking Man's Zombie BIog, March 26,2016.)

10.

Defendant Palmer also refers to Plaintiffs comedic work as Child Pomography.


Those skits describe situations that can be characterized in my opinion as being
sexually charged, which any modernday feminist will tell you crosses the line
into pomography in her opinion. They involve children in these sexually charged
situations. Hence my personal opinion that they can be classified as child
pornography. (From her Billy Sez blog, luly 2,2016.) @mphasis original)

11.

Defendants are free to hold whatever personal opinion they care to hold.

However, the Supreme Court decided in Milkovich v. Lorain Journal Co., 4Vl U.S. I (1990)

...the Court immunized only pure, evaluative opinion. Thus, a pure, deductive
opinion, which is provable as true or false on the basis of objective evidence,
carries no immunity. One asserting such an opinion is subject to liability under the
same constitutional protections that apply to all factual assertions. (1d)

12.

Child pornography is codified in statute in all 50 states and in US Law. In the

United States, there is no such thing as audio child pornography. Therefore, one cannot hold an
opinion thatarecorded comedy bit, not intended to arouse prurient interest, not utilizing actual
children, is child pornography just because one says so. It is a determinable fact. Thus, a pure,
deductive opinion, which is provable as true or false on the basis of objective evidence, carries

no immunity.

b.
t,

!f *.

Painting Plainffias a cyberstalker, Adjudicated Harasser and


*ToddlerstalkerD.

Page Keeton, Defamation and Freedom of the Press,54 Tex. L. Rev.l221, l24g-Sg (1g76)(discussing the
difference between deductive and evaluative opinion).

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 6 of 46 PageID #:6

13.

Plaintiffhas never been convicted of the criminal charge of cyberstalking.

Although Plaintiffhas restraining orders in place against him, those orders are civil orders only
and they were obtained through the understanding that

Plaintiffis so encumbered with his

Parkinson's disease that he was unable to travel to far-flung states across the continent. Yet,
Defendants porhay Plaintiffas if he was actually convicted of the crime of Cyberstalking.

14.

On June 16,2016, Defendant Grady posted on his blog:


Given that (redacted's) co-defendant is none other than adjudicated online
harasser, toddlerstalker and demented, cyberstalking DUMBFUCK Bill
Schmalfeldt, one supposes the lack of thoroughness in the story could be excused
as a dual matter

15.

of self-preservation and professional courtesy.

On March 26,2016, he wrote:

BILL SCHMALtr'ELDT IS A CYBERIIARASSE& WHICH IS A CRIME.


BILL SCHMALFELDT IS A TODDLERSTALKER WIIICH IS A CRIME.

16.

On March 18,2016,he wrote:

Bill Schmalfeldt - adjudicated harasser, adjudicated cyberstalker (of adults,


children AND senior citizens), liar, dementia addled, turdrolling,
shitsniffing PLAGIARIST. @mphasis in original.)

c.

Other Heinous, Untrue Allegations Made by Defendants

17

As part of his campaign to vilifu the memory of my deceased wife, on

information and belief, Defendant Grady posted a comment to Plaintiffs blog containing a link
to a photo indicating a freshly autopsied, very young female corpse being sexually penetrated.
Rather than admit he sent it. Grady stated on July

7,2016:

BILL SCHMALFELDT PUBLISHING ON HIS BLOG PHOTOGRAPHS OF


DEAD BODIES IN A POST.AUTOPSY STATE BEING SEXUALLY
VIOLATED

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 7 of 46 PageID #:7

18.

It is true that Plaintiffpublished

heavily-edited, blurred out, unrecognizable

copy of the photo, the allegation made by Grady is not true and is defamatory.

19.

On March 16,2016, Defendant Grady wrote:

It's just that the Defamation-Proo{ Shitsniffrng, Turdrolling, Demented Five State
Toddlerstalking Dreadfrrl Friendless Pro Se Garnma Terrorist Scrotum Sucker
knows so much that just isn't so.

20,

Grady claimed on many occasions that Plaintiff has lied about his military

service.
Stolen Valor veteran DUMBFUCK Bill Schmalfeldt loves him some FOIA now!
And let's face it...it takes a tool to know one.

21.

Defendants have been actively engaged in an unsuccessful effort to have Plaintiff

evicted from his Apartment. Defendant Grady wrote on March 26,2016:

lfihen retired idiot with no self<ontrol or internalftlter decides to record ond


distribure audio su depictions of minorslrom his Catholic Church owned and
operated apartnentr l thinh his landlords should hnow. Free Speech means you
arefree to deal with the consequences of your speech, as DUMBFUCK Bill
Schmalfeldt isIuAy au,are bat usesforgol tldealwithit #DUMBFIICK
#ChildPornographer.

22.

Defendant Palmer admits altering a comment I made on her blog to completely

change its meaning into something defamatory. She wrote on her blog on July 7,

20t6:

No. Won't be closing. Not any time soon. And certainly NOT for a brilliant
parody that I've said several times was a modified comment. Tough cookie. Bill
Schmalfeldt chose to comment on this website. He chose to try to humiliate one
of my commenters with his usual vile filth. He got edited and definitely got what
he deserved as a result.

23.

As the above actions are textbook cases of Defamation Per Se, untrue statements

of a defamatory and heinous nature, meant to damage PlaintifPs reputation. Plaintiff is not
required to prove actual damage. He will seek punitive and statutory damages.

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 8 of 46 PageID #:8

SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION

- STALKING

24.

Plaintiffrealleges the content of paragraphs I through 23.

25.

To prove a case against Defendants for stalking, the Plaintiffmust prove

Defendants knowingly engaged in a course of contact specifically directed at him, and


Defendants should have known that this course of contact would cause a reasonable person to
fear for his or safety or the safety of a third person

26.

Defendants Grady and Palmer seem to take great pride in keeping track of every

move Plaintiffmakes. Plaintiffrecently decided, more than ayear after his wife's death, to look

into the possibility of dating. He did not discuss this with anyone outside of Facebook.

27.

On July 5,2016, Defendant Palmer made a veiled threat toward a lady Plaintiff

was considering for a first date, and indicated her knowledge of what he had written in his dating

profile.

Makes you wonder if the lovely (redacted) would be willing to "stand up to" the
evil RWNJ Bill Schmalfeldt said this to. After all, if she responded to his ad, then
she knows that he is seeking his Liberal Warrior Queen. Or does this fall under
the category of "not withering at taunts"? Inquiring minds want to know.

28.

In a July 2 post, Defendant Grady headlined: "Dating Tips for the Demented,

Disabled, Not-So-Recently Widowed Senior Citiznn," he posted a YouTube video of the song

"Suicide is Painless."

30.

When Plaintiffchanges Twitter accounts in an effort to shake offthe stalkers, they

somehow manage to find it and alert their readers so the harassment can continue. Same with

Plaintiffs Facebook Account and pen

nannes

Plaintiffchooses to utilize. When Plaintiffdecided

to move from Maryland to Wisconsin, Defendant Grady posted a photo of Plaintiffs new

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 9 of 46 PageID #:9

residence two days before Plaintiffsigned his apartrnent lease, (Exhibit B). This can only be
done through a coordinated, conspiratorial effort to cyberstalk the Plaintiff. Defendant Palmer

not only admitted on her blog that she stalks Plaintifi she promises to continue to do so. (Exhibit

c)

31.

The above referenced actions all reflect and support allegations Stalking

740ILCS 145. Plaintiff will

seek punitive darnages, including apeflnanent injunction against

defendants to halt their stalking activities.

THIRD CAUSE Of ACTION - False Light fnvasion of Privacy

32.

Plaintiffrealleges the content of paragraphs I through 31.

33.

To prove a claim of False Light Invasion of Privacy, Plaintiff must show that the

defendan(s), acting with reckless disregard, placed him before the public in a false light in a
manner that was highly offensive to a reasonable person. The elements of false light include
falsehood, offensiveness, identification of

plaintifi public disclosure

and fault on the part of the

Defendants. The above allegations, in addition to being defamation per se, also qualiff as False

Light Invasion of Privacy.

34.

If

readers are left to rely on the writing of Defendants to form an opinion about

him, they will come away with the conclusion that Plaintiffis a cyberstalker who harasses his
victims by stalking them, with his deranged love of child pornography that should be enough
reason to have him evicted from his residence.

35.

Defendants consistently use the phrase "Google

Bill Schmalfeldt" when

an

uninitiated third party or employer challenges their harassment of Plaintiff. They fail to mention
that every website which has a negative word to say about Plaintiffis penned by one of their

right wing hack confederates. This is an example of a very successful "Google bombing" created

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 10 of 46 PageID #:10

for no reason other than to ruin whatever chance Plaintiffmay have to enjoy the rest of his life or
to find companionship.

36.

Plaintiffis, in fact, a humanitarian who volunteered for experimental brain

surgery lrl.2007 at the Vanderbilt University Medical Center to test the survivability of Deep

Brain Stimulation in the earlier stages of Parkinson's disease. Plaintiffis a song-writer, a singer
(although he does not claim to be a good singer), a voice actor, a blogger and podcaster. An
accurate depiction of

37.

Plaintiffwould include all those things.

The above referenced actions all reflect and support allegations of the Illinois tort

of False Light Invasion of Privacy. Defendants are engaged in this conspiracy to ruin Plaintiffs

life, and it will cost thousands of dollars for Plaintiffto scrub the Internet of the filth posted in
his narne. For this reason, Plaintiffwill seek compensatory and punitive damages.

FOURTH CAUSE OF ACTION

Harassment

38.

Plaintiffrealleges the content ofparagraphs I through 37.

39.

To prove a cause of action for Harassment in Illinois, the Plaintiffmust establish

defendants made an obscene or indecent comment or request with the intent to offend, threate&
or annoy Plaintiff.

40.

Plaintiffhas been visited by police on several occasions because of false

allegations made by Defendants. Plaintiffhas been threatened with eviction because of the false
allegations made by Defendants. Plaintiffhas been irreparably harmed by the harassment
Defendants.

l0

of

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 11 of 46 PageID #:11

41.

As Plaintiffs wife lay dying on the morning of June 17,2015, on information and

belief, Defendant Grady, using one of his many pseudonymous account online, sent an e-mail to

Plaintiffasking:
"Could you get the old girl to hang on for another day? Ihave the 18ft in the
Death Pool."

42.

On information and belief, defendants are responsible for and are major

contributors to several websites created to continue ttre defamation started on their blogs. They

include:

https:/&iwifar.ms/threads/bill-schmalfeldt-william-matthew-schmalfeldt-parky-bill-theliberal-erouch.20827l
https://lolcow.farm/ptlres/2600 I 4.html
http ://billschmalfeldt.tumblr. com/
https //twitter.com/ehostradioonlin
:

https ://encvclopediadramatica. se/Gail_Schmalfeld#Gail_Schmalfeldt

43.

The apparentpoint being, Plaintiffmust be condemned to live his life alone and

unloved, and his late wife somehow deserves to be the zubject of mockery.

44.

The above referenced actions reflect and support allegations of Harassment under

720 ILCS 5. Plaintitrintends to ask the court for punitive damages, including a permanent

injunction against both plaintiffs to cease their harassing activities.

FIFTH CAUSE OF ACTION - Misappropriation of Plaintifrs Name and Likeness

45.

Plaintiffrealleges the content of paragraphs I through 44.

46.

Defendant Sarah Palmer in particular is misappropriating plaintiffs name and

likeness for personal gain. Her blog uses the Plaintiffs full name in the title of her blog @xhibit

11

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 12 of 46 PageID #:12

B) to drawthe people who these and other blogs have used their online writings to
a

vilifr.

She has

well-positioned Donation button to PayPal, and she refuses to remove Plaintiffs name from

her blog title.

47.

@XHIBIT D)
Plaintiffwill

ask for recovery in the amount of all donations received through

Defendant Palmer's PayPal Account during the time she used Plaintiffs name as the title of her
blog.

SIXTH CAUSE Of'ACTION

- Intentional Infliction

of Emotional Distress

48.

Plaintiffrealleges the content of paragraphs I through 47.

49.

To prove a claim for Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress, Plaintiffmust

establish:
(1) that the defendant's conduct was extreme and outrageous;

Q)thatthe defendant intended to cause or recklessly or consciously disregarded the


probability of causing emotional distress;
(3) that the plaintiffsuffered severe or extreme emotional distress; and

(4) that the defendant's conduct actually and proximately caused the plaintiffs emotional
distress.

50.

Plaintiffinvites the court to think of something more emotionally distressing than

seeing his adversaries mock the death of his wife.

51.

Defendant Palmer changed her avatar several times to resemble a decomposing

corpse of a woman.

52.

Defendants both used the occasion of the anniversary of PlaintifPs wife's death to

mock her demise.

53.

Defendants allow commenters to refer to Plaintiffs wife as a truck stop whore.

t2

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 13 of 46 PageID #:13

54.

Defendant Grady has made similar comments about Plaintiffs late wife in his

blog. On information and belief, Defendant Grady was responsible for creating a website called
"turdsrfood.wordpress.com" that included obscene images and language and defamatory
comments about Plaintiffs relationship with his late wife.

(EXIIIBIT E) It was removed on

Plaintiff s request to Wordpress.com,

55.

Plaintiffasks if there can be any other reason for this sort of behavior other than

to cause extreme emotional distress in a grieving widower.

56.

As this emotional distress is directly responsible for accelerating the progression

of Plaintiffs Parkinson's disease symptoms, Plaintiffplans to demand compensatory and


punitive damages.

PRAYER F'OR RELIEF


WHEREFORE, Mr. Schmalfeldt asks the court to find that the defendants are liable for
defamation per se, false light invasion of privacy, harassmen! stalking, intentional infliction

of

emotional distress and conspiracy to committhe above. In addition, Plaintiffasks that Defendant
Palmer be held accountable for misappropriation of plaintiff s name and likeness for personal
gain. He asks this honorable Court to ORDERthe following:

From each defendant, $150,000 in compensatory darnages and $500,000 in

punitive damages for defamation per se.

ii.)

For each defendant, to be assessed the cost of an Internet Reputation Repair

Specialist to remedy the false light caused by defendants, the choice of specialist to be approved

by Plaintiffand the Court.

l3

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 14 of 46 PageID #:14

iii.)

From each defendant $50,000 in punitive damages for stalking, and apennanent

restraining order from the Court to put a halt to any future stalking activities.

iv.)

From each defendant, $150,000 in punitive damages for harassment, and a

permanent restraining order from the Court to put a halt to any future harassment activities.

v.)

From each defendant, $150,000 in punitive damages for intentional infliction

of

emotional distress.

vi.)

From Defendant Palmer, the closing of her blog at billysez.wordpress.com and a

permanent restraining order to prevent creation of any subsequent blogs that invade Plaintiff s

privacy.

vii.)

A finding from this Court that the defendants were engaged in

a conspiracy to

commit the above acts.

viii.)

Any other such relief

as the court may deem

Respectfirlly submitted this 8tr day of July, 2016.

just and proper.

ilr/*

William M. Schmalfeldt, Sr., pro


3209 S. Lake Dr., Apt. 108

Saint Francis, WI 53235


414-249-4379
bschmalfeldt@twc.com

t4

se

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 15 of 46 PageID #:15

EXHIBIT A

METADATA FROM 50 IMAGES ON THINKINGMANZOMBIE.COM PROVING THEYWERE


UPLOADED BY PATRICK GRADY, AKA "Paul Krendler."

DdcInr:elfrraft
lt(Ea iDSE tds//il.speitirkirgffimbi..ddwpffir^,plodtA0l6/0rclratr+
7

idc-

t F P El

jrr?rr--596

ila

CJd.
F.23b.a5@3.ed..ro.Ei[
.E)
'-- --- '-r=li*:IAtJPEG
--_^

ilg
rmtGrx"..t-*
Nocda.F
6.b
tf,AtfinGr
-

Wtr d t&c rb LrEr trct cdcr rd.*.


tatdE tb.lb.IGl
d
cF
IIIB turb EitGErfly
b DUinl-Io.SrCdaSpc
ItaG@o&pdaSergIm&oin
k@adb.

L."_-i

q!t?l?

1!?t

!I

vi.

toroFm

llcltutulldt
Effi -

ftir gtutp

of

mdu

ir

ao&d

in 4336 byEs

(4rk)

Hy,hict

itt8l

,lfrhz2l3'igft

Drc/IIEOrigitr

d.

15

drF,

23

brql tr,3

,.IGlrY:,,l3'lp{t

lrrlc Dac

d,

15

dF, A ha{6 lirq

r.on t.o
3Ecd.to

I&SeTre(}fuirl

hbSeTtrDiftircd ',
JI
(20fllbrrEtirydt)
udint
Pddiry

(2p60b!,cbirydd)

XPAfu

tuy,hbr

OtbE
tu&

r@tRr-

Edcrffi!-Iibm.h
'Ik8|a iry

tryrE.pffiiq@i3l&|ffiA4llMtorcrG
11.iBlFfr

!eG16.fttrff.
EXItr - tH.

SiE !p

ffi
DG/f!@

OiitiDl

d d.d- i. dd
i. /1336 bya (42*)
lndy,ffi
,lac'G!:rt ll:52s

Sob

SO

lfe Tr
Se Ie

Prddrg
PdilC

XP.tut6

td9C!..19-rr

,L*r.,rls:rs
ld9dE19tu.lr

GE-Ih

O.ltIEI
lXliliEd

ll
IT

:2r@bry6H!-y.la)
:2'060 brB t&rt da)
G.dy, tuict

?6r

Click image

rd D cdc& c&Foe

hr r

rllh

(57r rb

O t e

Surely Mr. Hoge understands lhat truth is, l'm


an absolute DUMBFUCK

l?zllr-vyat,l-awttg,>

..--..---_-t_--_

ACc drphFrl

?frl3l]irdtoorurtP,

cdy,ffi

______]
tuazairi t39o?ilt.ar+o"roo
q!@dul
15

rm

b isle:clck thi! rexr

lo show hrstoSram

of

tb diginl)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 16 of 46 PageID #:16

Bdc

Imege

Targci

Inbrnrtirr

iDts

I6/o5xwer

hnp://io.wpxmrrthinkinsmnombic.sr/wPconDn/uplcdsn0

Anist

Gndt,h

Dolr:

Mry

5,

od,

C2

hi6c)

2015
I

&r.

GitEm

2:3O.orPM
22

h@l

mi!E,

32

jPg?*{2

d tFiH)
o& {o, eeiaS ie.fF d@

rt

75%

eiftt

(56% thc

of thc

aigirl)

rnr3 E R.dto orumpt

3
dUS

gnt#IPfi

Ftlc:

e it' i" iE] Uein inugc dilplrycd hc

You know Gail is a very common name.


@paulzkrendler. HEY? Like my new tattoo?

61629 byr6 (60 kilobyta)

C.{a
Emdtr$

Wh&rrr
wirt

oab

Appay

*.d* J * *U"Oaua -n pont,


rd Mr;tD bmxa tnrtcoln nrdmly.

VYAIITilNG3 No @la-rC.o

rd

b d&

cdcddod

iq.

6lc

F!6L. Sc lry Inrodnion b Di8itsl-lm8e Coltr SP.eg

vi. lmgoFem

H@'s ttc fqll data:

EXIF

thir

gup

of

m&a

qsded

is

in

ktisl

Grdy,Pn

Dar/T:mOrigiul

2tl605:lE t4:30oe
2

dodi

&t,

ctr&Ih&

2ll6:difll

SubSeTmOrigiml

t2

Sub

22

4324 byld (a2k)

h!,

l4:30.oe
2 ldhs. I dry, 22 hdn,

STim Digiti4d

Dic,

32

6d. rlo

oiG,

32

!.d1

a2

Pdding

(2O60 byt6

tiEy ddr)

Hding

(2160 byt6

biEy ddr)

xP Autho(

Crdy,Pll

oHH
BdcIE
T.B

.fo

r,*.utu
S.Infor.utlor

iry:

re:
Elc:

hq ,4, *p trtuhn*'nalEn\z,m6(
a im"w-5al

'aJ

iflJ

G-.dy'h
l2:lqswct.'*d.Fd)
Mnt3,rl6
r!d.rBr{ds,.t..ll&i,l*rfudU3ffi)
ed.2dryl
$l x2l2rw
6.731 tsyB (I blot B)

vir lm8(F!\mr

My&db6iry

I.k'r&iltu:
EXIF - 6 @p of @

i.d
tuy,ht

lMlEcad
c;rt*
Sub

k fic Aisirl

SubkTlErai|,d
Mq

in

43U Ur@

12:t9:a
,let:G
2lrd.2&r.13l@.{de
,LSSlztlg.a
2.!d.2@.13tu.-ds
76
76

(2D@by6Hrye)
(2.060bycbiry.&)
tu!,,hr

<12Y

te

tuaqdbaiad)
rr

uaio

o-mnr

g-Fo,or

Oh. @paulzkrendler, I am a far better writer


than you on my worst days than you will ever
be- This is nothing new to you, thief/plagiarist.

&FEb:
&
d D M
WA!aIFG: Nool6-.F
bdM-MEiffir.tult.
b tu *GB&Fd
Ed!@v
&*tu
IEtu&SG
& Fd&. * ny ln.du.ton ro Drarhl llq. cold SF
d-a c.t@
tuEEffi.

Gl6

t, t, 6!

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 17 of 46 PageID #:17

BdcIn*ehfrrnft
fuf,.f lmSt

tap/it.vpmiiilkiigMncm/*pmlialodr/I)16/o5
rcEt&.ir.t_5t!,

0 P P E Ut uoe

di.dryld

a 76&

rilt

thBl3t dloDrutift

S''a2l0tHtri
B:naU!6(23}jl.tt,r.l

Yl[llIlE: l{o cdr.F d


H't
d lh *l LttE

od mcobodH cola P(dE

ltta c&r rL:!.

Er tub EDcrEttEatt llu* rb f lb ffi &


rh r ctrrbdc.bFo6lG. Sc ry lillo.bclitr b Duihl-l4.

(58[ tb

of

tb aisinrl)

.l-Fold

Hey, @paulzkrendler. Why aren't you al work,


paying my salary? Get off of your doughy ass
and shake a tit. I wanna buy stufi. #wageslave
Cllick imqe

b isbrc:

click

6is Ert lo sho* hiiogm

Ilcblbfrltdir
Ef,IF

Anir

- tti: grydMdt
Grdy.hicl

i!

Ptddtrt

(zr(lbrt biEye)

Prdfirg

t2@brtrbiEyde)

h 424t brts (4,1L)

XPAUfu Grdy,Ptid

Bukranf llbrmfu
ftla

irta

htpr/il.spdotnilEDS'l@bi.dD/wp.@Edltplodr/r0l6uoarcrpnrcl8

jPg?w-J96

el P F El utn U*c drphFd

kr r 766 elh (fl5 &. c

SclxDrllldt I Ut

.l-

,.H

This is What Happens When You lgnore PGPK

billschmalfelcft.neU20l6/M/28/thi
ffiEaDu@ill,ml/rI@[@l
EEg6.rem6N!uESUmD
@EMM'rDEI''EilECE
mremlE-tulal[E^6
WAIIUNG: !b coh-rFoc

l|h rih-r

Brd

da

MM

d D dcdd.d cob.prdlc
llc-ctr td.*.

hE tut EbG a rlHr it-b th b tu dGDookF d


rtl r.d.U
&r.dh. Se ry lffitnE&n b Digibl-lmSE Cola SFB
tu@td( hct

IIc'stbtollda:
Ef,IF

rhis gmcp

dmda

mdod ii

AfiiT

tody,ffi.

DdfEOriliDl

Ila80*zt

4336 h/lB

(art)

145610

GicDie

!06, t d.F22 hUttu,3


,,,lft,,,,l4,6-.to

SbSeIbAiSinl

3l

cdtto

2d,tnEZlhLaaicaS

Ed*.

hbScTlmDigtiDd 3l

dlr)

Puin8

2160 b!/6 bisry

Milg
XPA(h

2@brEbiryd0)

ordy,IM

!ma8e tn

r$lst', (lr.I lhF lcil k\ \fh'$ hi\hErJm

..

d lic aigint)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 18 of 46 PageID #:18

Imge lnformrtim

Brsic

Ta4t i@9.:

hrp /hl *'Tr.codhrnkrnsruv0mbic.@dqptontn/uploadla)lffiCspturc


lTjps?u=588

Anist:

Ht,Plarl(t
(2

16

hci6c)

stt x 215 JPEG


21,465 byt6 (21

File:

itj t"

{$,

AiP[AX,2ltl6 l:51:l5PM (tire


ldhs, l0 &F, ?2 tds, $ oi|G,

Dale:

.!,i

u spcci6odl
r6dr {o, .mirt

ia.gF

lilr@

WAINING:

Eocoding:

If,indorrs

imcp

Breaking

Fat

displaycd

lsc e 7% with (5!r* tb aa

-.,'

of tbe qigiml)

rorcr

How QUEER! @paulzkrendter is a psychopath.


necrophile AND homophobe! Knock me over
with a feather. #queer

kilobyts)

olr
*
No @16{p.oe *"d"t. ;
rrrdmlv.
!d Mr Eb hffi! tst.r cen-b.dd"d

Cdu

of US

'.8r MEin

Prcflc:

IDt6 fd th. cbG tN uiuy vi*db rh i! lb lRcB 6h {.4 d


m obcdd olc Fo6b. S@ Ey InEodrction to DiSiEI lmagc Color Spoces
frmhflffiin.

siti
A+pl,

bk

b lt& iogr

via

lm8op @m

Hrc's thc full dala:

EXIF

tuti!il

indy,

Dete/freOrigiul

mlffi?Xl3:51:t5
2

P8Eick

lmrts.

l0 dry!,22

tm6,50

Ccste Dale

Dl6O0:26 l3:51:15

SubScTmOrigiml

fr

Se

Sub

Tre

ffilE,

l0 drF,22 hoE,

Dir6,

$ niffi,

16

r.6ds

16

!co& rlp

e8p

Digitized 56

bytc

dra)

binary

Paddmg

i2O6O

Pbdding

:2!60 byt6 biffiy dda)

XP

(42k)

this grwp of maadata is eocodcd itr 4336 bytes

Aurlu

3mdy,

huick

Basic Image Information


Iuget itrEgq

hllp://i2.wplodrhinkingmmszmbie.coDWontcnvupkilv2o IMM

hs! d

iq28326GPJER529.jps?w=s79

(Hy,Prtri.t

Artist:

Aprll

Dste:

File:

2016

26,

dod!,
hific)

(2

lO

dF,

(tim u

I 2:57:28PM
23 bds, 45 miEG,

+ei6cdl
E slcd rfo, Mi4

iDE. ti@

of US

x 321JPEC

',,
33.166 by!6 (32 ki.lobyi6)

t{Af,NING: Noobr-sp rctedaa ma m mbeddcd olcFo6b:


Colq
Eomding: wHcsdltrtthomhtdcdcrDdmty'
IE tB farh. rb& d eildy virdc *ta i!thtRGB cdelFe.d
uilt e dtcd&d @td po6lc. Soc my loedwrion lo Digilal-lmage Color sPrc6

tuffitufo(atb.

Aply dk t6l5 b lhL iD.!l

via

Im()psrom

Itqe's the foll data:

EXIF

this

gmp of nptadata ir moded

Artisi

Crdy,Patick

Da&/freOrigiul

?,16{4zX
2

CEste Date

Sub

Tirc Origiml

l0

l2:57:zs
23 bdra

&F.

45

(a2k)

Eic,

2t

.8r

2Ill6J,lz6 l2:57:x
2

Sub Soc

tdts,

in 4J36 bytes

Eoilk. l0 dry!.23 hat,45 dG.2A

15

Ss Tm Digiiized l5

Paddiog

(2060 byts biryy dda)

hdding

(2060 byt6

XPAutho

Gndy, Patricf

biuy

dd8)

r.@d5 !8r

7t% wltth (6095 tbc smof the aigiml)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 19 of 46 PageID #:19

BGic rn-gcldbrr&[
TLna iry:

hry://il wpe|ffi'dinaltue-mbiclod*FrnEnruPl()@l@llpturcl6.ipr?r<97

AftiS:
lh:

Grdr,hrrLL
/A,.n Zr,Dl6
C2

,lllt|l:t'&.

15

ffi)

lO:2llaTAM

dryl

(tud.Ffrd)
d
ry.

l|lffi, b @,8

...[fuba

b{e @

d Us

4tn - 9l tPU;

Filc:
,

byE (29 kifoarl/td)


tld rc qDbcddcd ola fo6ts
!r/IXNING: No @td{pe ddd
YyLdr..dM-ebhffiEooadlnrdcrytu b & RGB * F d
tEE fd & reb re td ?Gr tu*tnld@d@
b DSihl_Iryc 6ld SID.

z),791

Crln
EDcodq:

AFly &

ffi-& Gltld
*
Fdb. S; Ey
tuE!ffi.
!
b & baB vi. lasoPsm

H@'s rhe trll de:

EEF Ani$

this srmp of

Ddc/I.!c

Original

C@fe
Sub
Sub

it aco&d i! 4336 blG (a2k)


d&
tuy,P.EicL
,EL.OL2i,loz*-17
dg
15&rq2lffi.Alfu.3
2 dh.
m&?22to.*.a
!'..dh.
!5dE.2b.Ztu,Atdry
2

Se TiE Oriai..l
Se fim DiAitizGd

by6 bina, de)


da.)

P.ddiaa

(2'06()

Plddint

(2,060 hryG bin ry

Cddy, P.Eict

PAUTIE
TtAdiry:

da)l@(:4ut

n.prlilwp..(ilhi.tinr.rrrl1vr. jBtu=537

tI F F

[rn]

ul" reffid

3ch.tuld
Md:
l&:
ft:
k
Ma:

W'ffi
3;37:36w(!b-Ed4dd)
AEf,2r'Ia
b,atfu,rds.@@'*dUS
Gd.r5&,21
ffi)
gr*trc
gJO byB (53 blelB)

ry ffitu

erdL.*

EXIF - & ryd@L


l:eGidd

d
h4SrbYB(a*)
edy,m
mg.zltt.37:*

2ld.lt6.2l

bd.a&.Sd5

,s:34:*
,lail.2l
b.ltu.9dS
2d,156.2r
SlbktuGiad

SubkT
Hiry
Mr8

Datu

b BaiorlryG Cdd sF
I

H@'!tud&:

95
95

(2.60ly6birye)
(2.060U6bry&)

I:!.

zt wffi (ffi tu Igof tu daH)


0

l' .6n.r

Aaron \Nalker offred me a chanc to get out of


the lawsuit with my dignity intact, All I have to
do is.. eat it all!

wANrctM*-pl@aj-M*Fdh:
YybttdkdtG-tddeE.

6-E..#
tu@ttu.
Ad&db6lrvrlm&.ffi

i U.

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 20 of 46 PageID #:20

BdcInl3ebfurndn
ftr8lf iErgE h@r/r.vpmniiDtiugM6nbicm^rP.d@rtpldt20l6,lx,rct@+

ll jE?wdt6

P P E frfrt

iqc

diryhyd

bc

rr 77f,

rili

(59t

Sclwlblrftius
LFi r, rL ll Olr9AM (t're d .p*d)
!d, r7nr, t b,4' !3. tr -d tqrt

hre

hd&)

f.

ie

dIXl

Sr2ltJPBG

iEilc:

199t2 byrr

(2O

%XNfilG:

E'3d

lb G. dlb cigiEl)
.l.

Foe

#NorvPlaying, Bill Schmalfeldt - Urine Stream


Calibration Device on WMS-DB

billschmatfeldt.net
rfloryrB)

olc{E dda rd D d&d cda Fds


lh rrt htEt d c-r rir*.

frb

Click imsge

b jslale: cl;.k rhi terl

ro sho$ histogmm

lr.!B hft GDa E tiiat tirr* rb i b *GBqat+E d


rll r cd
&IdbSE E, Imedh b Digid-lutp Cold sp6
tucAirilb.

ttc,ctutolldc
EEF

ttir

gq

mda

ir caco&d h 433(' byE ('12&)

Ardr

(}dy,tuic,k

D-c/firOrLiEl

,lcil+2t llol:c

d"
17 drf, I b,,15 irE,ra
,la!aa:2a ll$lr9

Ch&Drc

Io

d, l? drtt. I h,{s.b,t{ En ry

tubScTlrrcGisiml

t5

56SocT1@Diti6z.d

t5

Pddntg

2o(lbyrabirry(b)

PsddinS

2,060by6birydr)

,pA&i

Endy,htrbk

B6krm3chforo lbr
TUSA

0FI E

imtG: hqJr0.wpe^niieirs@bi. .r/tP.@A4ledti/20l6,O{rc.Fr!3.imh'576

PD

32lltPll1ri-rrpi6
D*s'Ata7,rL
(2ld,29-ya2t hr,t)-+'5da+ldcira.tk.arrs
tre)

ugctw<ubtd,,!!)
'a8,,tgffi
d
r* LttEt

WAXN|IIG: No oola..p

frail

llI

tli-- rd6bFab.
tumffi.
l-,-E-

SE

d mabo&d e
lrracoll rfft.

!, Ido&din

b DiSibt-IugF

t-sAF*

i^E &;bfflql"t
Hclthcft[/h'
Ef,IF

thir

grqdncrrdrrir ocododh4S36tyt3(art)

Anis

tuy,hicl

hcfifEOriSiEl

2.LC*9, l5:Aall
2

Cccc Ddc

d,

2!rnF, 2t

2llC{l:ol
2

rdt

hL l, ic,{6 d

l5:25:tt

rdrya

2t

ha I fr,i5

SubSocTlre0rigirl

13

$bScTtEDtirbad

t3

Hiog

2OOty6liorydt)

Plddig

P,(l60br6biElrd-)

xPA{tr

(idy,ffi

te

rood ao

imr ddryu{ hrr

?}f,

rift

(6196

rb

t- rdh

Parcuum

lwould happily give Lee @stranahan the


opportunity to retract that statement, if such a
statement was made. By 6pm CDT. Tonight.

Colc

U.in

pdh
Co&or

sF

( lx LmaFC !r !$lutc: (lr([ rhir lerl

(o

\h,'*'hir',Fram

of

lb cisiEl)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 21 of 46 PageID #:21

Lhis

ffiil;"rick

krr

ro

shls hrskrsrd'

ffi-,lb@FdE

Hsr's

toIl

d-r:

EJrIF

lbn

gFo'tP

dddo

ir

o6&d in435

(''t)

byE.

W
f#*"f;g'rz&'0drP
tcLE,

sPPtsrm

55S

riit (aI5 lb c

4Enilr
i .U.---ctier-'3'r#*
drff

1Dc:
i

t"- -_ ,_-

iffil'#'"s,'mmsro*:*"*

ir'u
I

d r

ffi

Colo.

ie$oding:

cobcdddcolor

il hrrsr l.t.t c&rr "!=!:-

ffi;'M-

Hcc'stbfrlld.n:
Ef,IF - rti*

gIotrP

of E

&ric

fr*fiImoridEl
Cc.E Dlir
Sub

Sc'IIcOrigirl

sub Soc Tmc

Disitir.d

rtdo

i3

c'cod'd in 4336 b!/ts ('l2L)

cHy,PtEict
2arailh3l 17g)..6

rc bt /o'i.a
iilia.v*
,,tffi}3.l17:fr.$
rc b*,o rig
iti-atl*

30

Prddig

(2060byatinrYda)

Hing

(2!fl)bflG3titr-Yd-r)

XPA&.

Grdy,Eicf

55

5s

Ed {P

tc

pdb'

il@.E!&u

ffiill*,

i*t,*,.1r'k thii rtrr

ro

'hoe

hi.,toem

@'

of

b ai8iBl)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 22 of 46 PageID #:22

lh G.

ss1'rot tt'* 1t92


ffiir,znr
S::'#:"*l:#ffiffi.;'*T::
I

\ -_I

iCdr
I

--

liliiuYr"-txxt*:tt-t

<=-^
aln.\

imnq. trr r(orarr. \

nte=

encoding:

I
I

tlm'r

flll dtts:

tbE

thir graP of

ErIF -

dtda

it 'lcodld

iD

4336

(a8)

Attic

r.'d -o

OorttcOtiaut

Pl!fflI:3.1#* n &.'

CEGDrre

*ffilIii'#*.*.''""**

SoOS*lcOtgUt

70

Sub

Sc TirF Diti'iztd 70
.206i0 bt

Prddog

,2:m

Pi.ldog

2f

to bitrry dO)
dar)

bryro tiDrY

Gddy, Prtrick

XPArfu

Brct@c

,"* d'

ffifrHE,6***so/?pdd^ry16d/']016

PEu,a
ltlt lt Rldb OrumPl

.t' ;ffi

to backtrace
How lonq do you think it will take
i" it, ,o""", @Paulzkrendler?

il;;;;i"

ffiI["

Itrcrc'r

tEfrlldl*

Ecd i3'rod'd in it335 by{rs (42r)


Crdy,EEf
AiliTT
,rafih3l 1533'36
[Er/fimorigiul
iffi o-av.' zr u* 29 ti- tr !"d "r
,ala$3l 1533l!6
&o.bDG
icv.' zl u*ze ni- rl rd it
iff

EIffi -

Oir

grq

of

Subsocnreiioal

9)

tubS.cTcDigitid

5!)

Prldng
Plddint

tzPtourrr!.tt Yorl
(2060 b!/t6 bin-Y dr.)

XPAttur

3ndy.M

- i*:",",

'lick

r.hi'

trtr !o 5h{ histosrmi

of

lt! o

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 23 of 46 PageID #:23

6-ee6..r-ryo*Ya.4

ffi ffi1ffi
ci"-ffi;-tick

ff ,i.Tll,s-#?"Ifl l"ffi;'

ftis text kr :hov his(4{am

F"Gt

wre:rwg!rY!GlLtGl
=bhG-a

Elao-rrdrrt.

Hndrthcfoldre

Effi -

ttir

grury of nrodaa b acsdcd

t335

o'- (no)

Arrin

I]sf::'*e*2,G'rr.dr'
fffili:*H- 2r'd' !'d' {P

o.ianoo6nd
CrabDr

2s

fubS.cIb(}idDl l)
SoUSccl*Pigidd

t)

Pddnt

(2@br,EtirYdn)
(2160

Prdding

br6 ti!{Y

lo.rry,m*

XPATh

'b)
har

E P PBrrrrlr

frGageu,

,ffi_----arlrtIPEG(I7rilobv',E)
:'--'
r?.152h/E

tum*il&-

tlrc'3.bfrlde
EnF -

this gruP

drtt.rdr

b Gilo&'t in4336

b)E

('2t)

Altilr

Cf,dY,Eict

DG/fiGOdgbrl

ItrH*H-zr-cn'd*

CcdoDcc

ffif#f*-zrrirE

SubSccfreoriSirl

TI

Sub

SeTlcDigilirld

hdding

ep60byrr3binrYdnr)

hdding

(2P60btEtiur'b)

XPAilhT

Grdy,Plldcf

2eE

drP

i.utot",

'!ick

?6fi

this texr k) show hr$oPrrm

*flt (',* lt4crgrE

aiSbrl)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 24 of 46 PageID #:24

r-gtunr,

]OHH

*"-^-

t*r"**r**-**r--

BdcIn4che,nrfu
Tl(sEr iDsE:
ffi"tilff#ffi'*edn&P@^DMrm3

I P P EI rfa tce.ritparrtd hr ,_
-'

76*

tiii (t !r & c o16 a:qt}

6..offi
r 96sm1ltd
d wmuh $r6h d EEwsl bEyb YoR
qhl lo gay 6lry6
Ilr&ldJ
rcu snny wt ortrprilte

( li.\ rm.sc kr rwi.r.. .li( I dn l.\l

ro

\h4 hi.rylm

f-*lE@dins:
i
{

Il6b tt frll dnr


Ef,IF

thi.

gnqof tEda

AfiiT

ir

Orldy,

aotbd

4336 byB

iD

,Lilh3l

l3:a4:r6

3GGD-.

2ll6fil3l

l3:tt4:to

Sob Sc TiE (}iSiEf

63

subscfuDigitb.d

t3

P.ding

?r()bysbiryd.r)

BioE
XP Aurta

Hy,h.L

DdflGotitto

(,4.t)

Pti.t

2.060hr6 biEy

dr.)

Bdbrmrtcltrm&l
TkBff imsg

llt.

hqJ/io.vpm^hiltiDttn.ibbmrtrpoaftplcdrrx)16^)3
lc,p/otr.z-z.Iil'a=sn

! P F

E ff*nnrScdiCrydkcr76e rinh(s8r lb rE of

tbcigiurl)

Here's the thing. Sarah Palmer says


@paulzkrendler is Patrick Grady. Jane the Hate
Hag says Paul is Patrick. Were they lying then,
or now?
Click image to ielalei cl;ck lhis lerl

Apei,

&

rooL

t- iqe

vi.

IoSOFm

Hcrc'rtbcfolde:
EiXIf

6ir

gmop of

Artid

mda b d
Hy,hict

in

DlefiIreOrigirl

2ll5*]:21 l(}2E:lt

CrcdcDe

2Uailh,

Eotr, 9 dtr, 2 fEri:,9 fitt

d,9
fi

SnbSocIIreOr[iml

43i5 bl/ts (4.&)

lG28:l!

drF,2

lE!,

39

nic,

SubS.ctuDititiEd $
Padding

(2OO brrca

tiDry rrrr)

PlddDS

(2P60 b/!cs

tiorlr .rlr)

XPAfih

Gmdy,kbt

.te

2'

lcd

z'

rcd ry

10

ihow hislo8ram

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 25 of 46 PageID #:25

Bdm+pltrradr
prfo.rpmibi*irfpDmli.e/rpe/uPlod/2ol6,S/G9oG
l6istrdll

0 P P E rfa in*

Itltf irlE

&iirt

Gdt,ffi
iLtt lt'Ifa loZl3oAil (ad{.il.O
(J d,9d.rl2b,O!b,
xd
ry.r-.ha h{snEdug
E)
53,ItI'JEG
nsflWcz,b,d,ifi,.')

DG
Filc

d D dd.Ld odrFdc
WAlttr!rc! Xo ola-F ffi
lmrr
d th ri Lrsr lra ctr rd.*.

Cda
Emdiry:

fil3 lr t.dlo

(llDarFd bG

r 7r Tib

Drumpt

(59f lb rG.
&

dft

re

Silly people think the fact they received


unenforceable RTO's mean that DAwon't file
charges against Grady. How sweetly stupid.
CIkL imetr lo rolaE: clicl

Sii lert b \]nw Hflo8,m

YEda tbrtffiqarlE
d
Ebe Ets|
i.rrbrb
bDifibtrh.!!CohSPE
rtl--.*rH&dagcrylffldEi!
tucffi.

Alilr&t*r otiI.vhlos$e
B.d!lbft[dt:
Ef,IF

&ir

gq d@

id

i!'+336 brtst

Arrirt

(Hr,ffi

h/Ifo:Ori:irt

,tf,fi,d'tun55

CE&DG

,tf*r:Dtun36

d,9-'q2ha.otr,3t

d,9d.rq2

ba

(4rt)

-.dt

rtu, 3a..dt

lll

SdSoctuAiid $
subscfirlxftL.i 56
(2@brEliryd-)
MiE
MitrS

(2@tt{stltrrydn)

)eArih

(}dr,hid
llrbliRldoorunpt

Gtdr,ffi
lf,rtf r,tL l(}2&*AM (ud.rq6.O
(3 d,rdrya2ln 39-E,55td!q.daiq!bdfls

Aiirt
IHc

But thank you for mentioning the RO s. That


came up in the conversation with LE. I believe
the word used was "conspiracy." That's a
crime.

ffi)

Eb

$lrZf JPSG
ZtSrtWa(?z}j.ttal

d n cdcdH eFds
WttilII{G: No odanDc ffi
'F*r. d Dh rll Lrrsr t*cfu rrdr!.

Colr
EDdinS:

|GucureuErE
,ll-r.trrH&fdlcsc

ay

tu@htr-

AID' d6 d

tL ha.

vir

Erciiiuq-r
Imo&d<n b Difhl-lEt

IEgOFm

IIE'stufrtrd&
Ef,IF

tbgrurpof

Arrin

ffiirm&dh4336
Hy,Eit

Dts/fmOrigird

?|.I,ffiJDltl8:o

GticI)G

,'IfrI.iDlorJ8rtr,

Dd.9

drya

fc

19

bt3(4rt)
lbailt.!cd

d'9eF,2bi,rti-,55

tt
$tSeIbCigld
Strb ScclbDitilird 5{
Prdiry
Psing

)PAfu

(2P6Otya

tioryOa)

(2@t Ebiryda)

(Hr,m

Ecd

f.

Cold

SPE

Clicl image b islalc; clkl &is tcrt lo sho* hitu8mm

aiginl)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 26 of 46 PageID #:26

Bdclm.grhformefu
iaAc:

'IbrBcf

e F PEu.i"

hilp://z.wp.odthinhnpsmmbicadwPdEn/uploads/2ol603rctpdrc-

gjBtua

Grdy,Prffi

Attist:

hrcf 23,2e1a ll:5Zo3AM (ti@ dqei6od)


db, t5 &y, f k f t Eic, 2 t6.odr rao, l@inS iry dn@

Daac:

Filc:

oa

US

4Utr tloizIPECI
29173 bytrs (29 Lifob:/t6)

WAnNING:NooI,r-sF
Cdq
Etr@ditrg: WhdmudMrrtDt

Apty dk ra. b tir iryc vh Im8optem

Hc's tb foll

EKf -

dat!:

this grurp of

madna ir cuoded io 4336 byE (42L)

Anist

Gndy, htrick

DadTreOrigind

zalas.xl:zl ll;52o3

Crcarc Elarc

,16d8:23 ll:52J3

, ldhi,
3

Eodb,

Sub

SeTreOrigind

30

Sub

S Ti@

3()

Digiaizcd

15

drF, I lsr, lt Ei@,2


&r!, I hE, lt ci@.2

biry

PaddiES

(2,060 byt6

Paddirg

(2P6O

XPAuttu

Gndy, Prrricf

BGih

Edt

.AD

.ccdt

!!P

d^*r)

byt6 biurY d'r')

rnr8clnform.dm
htrp://p.wp.offi inliDryeombked@EolupllM

T4El idge:

Afii8t:

Gnt,PrlA

fE:

M.F.L

d,
ffi)
CJ

fo

2a,
9

fl
l:lJ!6PM (@

rfa

b.

dry1 B

tJ

@.?

d Fi6id)
I,sEst4

btc tu

dB

,StZxIXDJPEC

Frlc:

44,476 tDncs (43

kiIoU/B)

&
d o @b.ddEd @la lrcfiL:
olc-w
it ac&. rfifY.
r.t if- t- lc
fr.til'
vid-L fihE@*Fd
lEtutuSretd#v
SF
b DaidJry k
6-1 6b&&rdlc-Si
ry mh
tumffi
I
___

Colr

i
I

ED@dirg:

wA.RNNG:

No

dbBiryvLlmto?6m

Hfrt rb.

frrfl

da:

Ef,IF - thir gmry otrrc..tu

is

-.$o(H

iD

4336 hfta (42L)

AfiiS

Cr.dy, kick

DdcnlcOridill

2.1a$:2t 13:15:r

3d,9&F.23b,$

tu.7dS

CMEDTE

,l6cG:2t l3:15:s
3d,9&F,4lEL55

lncr7d@

sub

Se Titr Orisiql

sub

se

Tir

Prddiat
Pldditrt
XP

l@38@c'

15.ifftu=592

Autbtr

tt

Digitiz.d ll
(2,060

br/E

biry dr.)

h6 biry dr!)
Ckrdy, P.tick
(2'060

,D

Eilrm" irc

disLFd h@ d 764 ?ilth (54*

nr r ercto orumcr

rh.

!-

Gof

.ooor

Some questions answer themselves. Right, you


cowardly. nutless wonder? Get back under the
porch, @paulzkrendler

OE

cigit

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 27 of 46 PageID #:27

Imrgehformatim

Ba.dc

im8$:

TaEGf

il F ra; E uain ioe*c disptaycd hcrc ra 77% wltth (59% tbc arcaof tlr

htrpr/t).wp.@trVlhinkintlffisembie.oil/wP@nbnrlploads20l6/0lrcspm14.jpe?v=su

ff

Gr.dy,Ptri.t

Artist:

Mrrll

Date:

(3

25,

tmbs,

(tire

Zl15

12

PEift)

4:48:35PM
&ys, Zt hon, 25 oim,

id spei6!d)
rads.to, Miot

25

iDtE ti!@

dt

nri" r. Rrdio orumpr

Don't Let ME Stop You, Psycho.

std x 3:D JPEG


26843 bytes (26 hlobylB)
WARNING: No mlor-spoce mctsdrtr and no eobeddcd colc profilc:
Whdow rrd Mrc *b browr tnara cohr rEdmlt.
IErg6 fa tb rEb re Ed si.ldy viry8bb eha b tb 3RGB ob rp.c d
wili [ @bcddod ob pflc- Soc ay Inuoddion b Digit l-lmagc Colo. SpaG
fcmid@li!.

Colq
Encoding:

dhlmL

Apply

to

thb itugc via lrnSops.@m

Here's the full dara:

EIilF -

rhis group ofmetadala is encoded in 4336 bytes

Aftist

Grady,PaEbk

Date/fmc Original

I)15d13:25 l6:48:rs
3

SeTmeOrigiml

Sub

dDs,

X h6,

12 dsys,

2s

?,060 byts binary drts)

hdding

(2060

XPAuthor

Gr8dy, PaEick

imgs

hn6 bitrry

Datc:

trdlB.

14

23E

Ermding:

tc@&

sgo

data)

ll:51:l3AM (tim u {Eif.d)


tor, 25 mimE, 4 @dr t8o, cdrf

d.ys, I

Mc)
tfil x 9{ JPBG

Colr

26

htrp://i2.*pdrdthinlinslMvmbierom/wPcmEnr/uplods20l(103/snipl

(3

Frle:

l8o

Inform.tirtr

Gnay,ffi
*tuTtz,,,l6

Artist:

$d

)8

Padding

Bssic Imege

26

)8

Sub Scc Tirm Digitized

Tsrgfi

oiDG,

20l6dl3:25 l6:48:rs
3 ffi!.,
12 drys,I btr6,25 6ie,

CEat Date

(4rk)

15

the tull daa:

this

gmp of nadata

is

in 4336 byes

Anist

Gddy, Prtrick

Date/fEOrigiMl

20ladB:2{ l1:51:r3
3

Crdc

Se

Tre

Eod6,

f,{

drF, I hmr, 25 Din@,

20lafil:24 ll:51:13

Datc

SubSeTimOrigiml
Sub

US

byr6 (23 kilobyrE)

frlreirf.ilir.

EXIF

rd m *t"Oa"a -f- poonf"'


WAnNING: No @lor-sFa ltda
Whdorn ad Mr rnb tmrrrr ta- obs nrdnly.
tE fr tE Eb c ffi riHy Yi(rt& rb b tb !f,GB @b F d
rith E @tcdd.d cdfi pnlc. Se ry lnroduction to Digiul-lm8e Col6 Spoes

Alply dha blr b thi3 iESc via lmSOFm

He's

iEF li@

jp8?w482

Ed.

14

&rE, I

h,

2J

8i6,

53

Digitizcd 53

biuy ddr)

Ptdditrg

(2060 byt6

hdding

(2P6Ohrr6bin

XPAuths

G(dy,htick

ryde)

(42t)

rmd! rto

cdt rto

o i; i, iutu"tn

!..Fonoe

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 28 of 46 PageID #:28

OB@*D
Flb

&too

r@[rRL:

Ytr h!. It}l

BdcrmtcIfrruft
Ihgriim8s

0PPEua

tf,pr/o.wpsn/tbi0eillrt!!@Dbi.

Mrtl 2+raL ll5arilM (tic de..ii.d)


d, lia &!,a t h, ra Ei-. lt d {sdghletudl.I3
Hc)
CJ

ttl r ilBtPEG

Z)160@(20 tilotr6)

olc-p

WAIMIIB: l{o

rt lh

E;

rrD
hE htbttDGdtiH,
rii-rGddd*pe,Soc

ffi

nd Drdcd&d

6hFfb:

trr !r ttao&r rrart.

rt
Yit* tbilbtnGE&F
ry mddo b Diliul'ldSEColor SFg

tum*n&-

Hlrtbtufrllda:
EnF -

this

gry

of

nada

D&/IfDOrLfud

ryt3 (42f )

DI.GG:Alt.'z.tt
3

d,

&ya I

f4

h,2t ic,

lt d.!o

,,lfrE,.ll523t

CE&f

$bSeTm(}igirl
Sub

acod itr 435

ir

tuy,ffi

Afiid

litdF, t b,2{ nica It d..o

ffi,

SocTrcDigitizcd c7

PffiDg

,0f0by6binrydo)
byB

tiu!, du)

PUdrS

(2P60

XPAtihr

Gr.dy,hict

BaakImgc16ro&
Tl!8c itrgq

[\rdr;l--Dec:
i

tdD://i2.tpdr^tbtitrtmEmbicm@tuN52o16

)reiP5jPgk--t80

llsllcAM (lle

D,.rl?A,rL
I

lE

a.

rb.a

rd

dry..ifdl)
tc Ei*

irf, li@

dUS

l----iEk

6
d m G.ilG&d ooh ptfh:
No cda.r
[hao*r rdlftcrtD trUrEr ft-o&r rrar*.
WtINnlG:

dLts vir* tb i & tfGE c&F


lc
b lb trbGd
laroduio toDigihl-ldg!ColcSP
rll-rcdcdcldb.Scry

turtrd-

olbbob b d& iEB

Yi!

ID8OFm

ttrG'srb.frlda:
in 4336 byrrt (.rt)
d6da b d
Artilt
Grdr,ktt
2aL*rl ll:5h6
DidlbOrigitrC

Ef,IF

ltb gry

}E& Irdc

Edb,

l,(dryt, I h,2{

EiG,5rd.tp

,Lfi}l4u53r6
3

d,

drn I bi.2. ri-,6

$SsccTr(}igin l 37
$SSeIhDigi.id tt
Plddng

(2'(tr0byi3tinrrda)
(2,1160bt6biEy(b)

XPAdK

Gndy,PlEbt

Pdding

P P Elrfaa

areffi

h..'l$ rilt(fiE ee.dlt

rl
ra e crll lo
.Hcd[ Iid.tlxr dr. Ed t Ehd uh

AEly

.od Io

Oick inHgc tii i$laler clicl thir tert !o

so* hrsbgm

boEd

El

hd.y,

aiginl)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 29 of 46 PageID #:29

Bdc Im4e Informrtim


iEgc:

Tstga

el P P Efrfrin usc displaycdhaci 5l% wllh (266 tbraof &cqigiml)


it wl
M5. SlEman, th m sFB d dF $e Drprnmi
tdl litaty war b lnm who ii Bing r F.dcnl Cffrnmnl lP
&ar.

hup://i2.wperlr/lhinlingroszombirorvwFoErrupl@dsl2o16rc1/snip6jp8?w=880

Ani*

Gon, m.t

Date:

l[.-h a,2,,l(

Frk:

Yt)
ttlr{t4?/6tPE6

(3tld
t!d6,

f4

ll:53 s'l

AM(ri@ d

&F, t hd. 2. DiG,

rFcicdr)

io.!. ti@

tcoib ry,EilC

dus

!Nl s (r#lq,l.r{tu.,rdrh\tdr*l'nihlU6

4s3r7 u,vu(aatir@tca)
:

Cda

|:;A${EIG,

obr pmflc: l
d m cddcd -r".;,61",
cdor-sF mcoda J"d".-w.ardd
]tr'Bnra it-lrcD
rulaly.
ELi
Dm ft- o&r"mc.a
r-F
rit*
rb i b.f,GB @fr.Fd
IDaB falbrbG driH,
WAT!
WUNIITIG: N.
No

Enmding:

rtn
m
6k rf,lc. Sriti-a.d.d&d

ffim
fa@LtuDli!
1,.*_
Apply

olb lo.t n lhit iqt

via

Ey ltrEod$im b Digibl-lrEtc Col6

Sp.6

Sor I

lbF tlry

fird

!u.

Slry itr

tqrtf

Nintod!

__i

Im8OFm

H@'s lhc full ddr:

Ef,IF

this

grup of drddr

is

6odcd

Artid

Crdy,hrrbk

Dilc/frroriSinl

!!lffih2|ll:53:5t

Eod, l t dr'l' I hr,


2,.l'fg,,:,.ll:53'st

Cc&tu

SubSeTreOrigiul

td,

l.l&F, I tdr,

2,a

eitG, 7 @d. tto

2,l

Diffi

(2060 byt6

tinry d!ir)

hddilg

(2060 b!rr6

biry da)

,(PAuthc

Grrdy,

Imege

iDgq

r.od

t6o

Digitized (;,

SubScTre

Thrgct

6;'

hdding

Bdc

(42k)

io 4J36 byEs

Pllrbt

Informr&n
I I

jB?8597

Gmat,ffi
Itlutl 23, 2afa ,{: l6ooPM (tia r rpcifoa)
(3 tld,
t Ed !p, mtit
d.r., 2l kf, 3 aiE,

Afiisa:

Dae:

(l P P trl r*"t fuur

h[p/il.qrom/thinkingMbicffi/*p'mhuupleds/2ol60],carte

14

14

Thls

iofe

tire

gnrl7lrtHF6
Itpl6 byEs (lt lfloqnG)

Crln

iwArlu{c;N.-*l-{p*Md.r.d-"trdd"d-[".F"fi brl
]fvhdendMrcEbLicrt!-.*nndorry.
vir* tb in tu *GB cdrFd
h{a tutb EbGdrildy

Ming:

*i]b-o.&&
lamitui[

AFty d6 blt b tib ir!.

&pflc.

Sc oy tntoduim b Digihl"ltMgc Cd6 SFG

vi! ImgoFm

Hre's thc frrll do:

EJf,IF

this

gmpof dldatr

is

@od.d in 4336 h/trs (42r)

Anist

Crdy,tubk

D&/freOrigiDd

2Cl5:et:23 16:16o
3 oo.th+ I,[ &yt,2l bod,3 6i!G,

14

GEai! Datc

201J:(l:23 16:16o
3 ttrd, t4 drtt,2l ha

l{ !d

SubSeTiGorign l

41

Sc TimDigitized

43

Sub

biry de)

Pditrg

(2P6O byt6

PaddinS

(2'()60by!6birydir)

XPAurh

tuy,kict

&,

tco&.!D
rlp

Rrdlo

disDlaEd

Orumpf

ke

d 75%

ritt

(5796

tb

,'. Forh

I cannot tell you how pleased I am to have such


dimwits as adversaries. #lawsutt

of US

P.cilic)

Frle

13

of

tu qigiml)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 30 of 46 PageID #:30

Basic Imrge

imgp:

Talgct

Informrtim
hup://io.wp.odthintingMrombLl#vPonEr/uplorlszol6/03CaSe
l0jPg?*=56

OPP

i,Isth

Datc:

(3

2-1,

ldtl

14

(tire u

2016 3:14:ltPM
&yr,

22

ho6,

oinuB,

561Ttr

.8o,

.siu

ioAr

ti@

of tJs

JPEG

13J36 byte (13 kibtytcs)

Colq'WARITIING:No@lG-Wrrrd"tJ*-Uaaa*.proff,
Encoding: Wb&t ! rcd irrc tnb bmtffi ltal obrt rudmly.
I'qta fuft rrcbed ?i.ldy vir$b rhh lL IRGBoh rpcd
oh F6L, Se EJl Inhd@tion to Digit l-Irugc Cold Sp@s
fdmiifuDrin.

viti o ddcd
Apty odE

Elt

b thb iEsE vh lmgolEsm

HwltlEtulldara:
EIXIF

this goup of

rsadu

is cnodcd iD 4336 bt^6

tutisr

Gndy, Pstricf

the/freOrigiul

,l5dB:23 l5:l4lt
3

CErte

SubScTmOrigiml
Sub

mits.

lrf

d.F, 22 hdB, ?

2016S:23 l5;l4te

hc

ffib,

t,a

&F,

22

hrt,

(42k)

Eic,

3t

Eie,

3t t @ds .go

Sc Tim Digitizcd

(2p6obyEsUErdds)

(2pob!n6tiMyddr)

XP Anrhor

Crdy, Patbt

ahryd ituaq

hnpr/0.wp.codhinbrytlEe.mbic
re4urc2- l .ipeh=5la

codqHonl.nvuPkBdff

Aflfut:

Gr.dy,hdcf

fraE:

Mrrcb 23,2o15 3:l5rPM (tudpiH)

ffi,
14dry3,22 hd6, ? tu,
tuift)
SltrsllJPEC
43,193 byB (42 kilobyt6)
(3

A,ruiU

E rcodira:

ld

b tu iry

via lm8(\B-com

H@'s ttE full &hi

EISF -

this grup of

tctde

is

d@d.d

itr 4336 bylEs

Aftur

Gmdy, Pari,ck

DaE/TiE Origidl

m, .B.8l'tls:n
3

C!*DaE
sub
Sub

l6l

iry tu

of

@la FdIe:
U *
vyA.RITIING: No @IG-aFe -a.a
-bcdd.d
M- Eb bwarEdcetrrddYIyhdoE!a
d
t--6 k tu d re l'd ffy
vit-lc
?b b b flGB @16 F
ffi-a dbddod @ls rfib. Sa ry rndudon to Diaild hae Col6 SFs
faffii.fuuh.

ColG

AEly &

rSo

4E

hdding

Frlq

@dr

,18

Pfiitrg

56 Ti@ OrigiDil
Se Tirc Digiaizod

ffi.14&F,2

lffi,7

2,L.l,3:z, lstls.t

tu,3

3trd,l4&F.2lm.7tu.3dry
g

&
bins, de)
B bio6y d.b)

Paddi.g

(2S60 b)n6

Padding

(2,060 bl

xP Autlc

3rdy, P.Eick

vilh

(61%

U
EM6EE

*oci6od)

!od.

36

Prci6c)

Frlc:

ffain imgc dilplrycd hcr! d S04


ar/r!/!!a !',rk
lIE@lsG

Gildy,Hcf

Anisr:

.u.I

(42L)

dry

lb e

of thc

nitiul)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 31 of 46 PageID #:31

f,sis Imgc lnformrfun


'lhiEA im8:

l P PErvrein

ht&://i2.vp6rn^hinl(iD8rulzmbrcstry'wPmEn/uPloodB/2ol6,O3rctP@im?w-'G)

icmdy,Htt
d .F*cod)
DfrEt Zi, 2015 I l:52fiAM (*ry
(, no&, 15 d.yt, f bc, 3 I EiG, i|!, r.md..!o, ru&E iqc @

'ArtiEt
Date:

r
:
I

I-

Fltre:

tnltxti02IPEG

iDy3

lcda

of US

P..6c)

YIAINING:

No

olc-qc

Mdarr od m obcddcd olr prdle:


at-c&l rdolt.

VYbdo;rrrd DLc tc5 Lffi

fnmaing:

('1,(

( .,r'nI. t,' r\'hl(:.

lr.

I llrr' r(\l

1,,

.h,'a I',.k,,'r'i,

Hc's tic ftrll data:


EXIr' -

this

gurp of mcrld8lr

is cDodcd iD

Artist

Crdy,Parrict

Datc/T.rre Origiml

2e16:G:23 ll:52or
3

Crcrtc

db,

4336 b:/t6 (42k)

Ecb lso
&yl I h, 3l tu,49
ll:52ss
f5 &yr, I b,3! aic,,t9.@d.
$o
15

2elffi:Zl

Dit

ldb,

SubScTircOrigiml
Sub 56TlmDigitizcd

3()

Padding

(2060 byt6

30

Paddiry

biEy de)
(2O@byt6biryda)

XPAuthG

Cmdy,Pat ick

BdcIEGeIlforE
,Ib8diry:

&r
h,F/^l *Pdtunal*.-hE
a br'u'5s

$ F P [d not in*c disLyld

ll

hdE

nrrrrerrommrr

- z* rit6 (5!x

.h.

G dtu aiAirt)

" E!!il

Do the retards understand that I am required to


fill my briefs unless I want to yield the motion to
Walker? No, they do not.

H@'s tlE frrll da.:

EXIF - hir pp

ki{

Dde|rffiO.EiEl

CE&D&
sub Se
Sub

of

@.d.b it a.odcd in 4336 htE (4U


Grdy,ffi
,l@.22 t6:19.15
l!d.15&!E.21b.at!ic.
,la:Gt:z, l6:19.c

Tire OrigiEl

Se'I'rrc

,3
Digirizcd )3

tlta biry dar)

P.ddiu

(2'060

Iuitra
XP .{utlE

(2!6(} b!i.. biry da.)


Gr*y, F.Eicr

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 32 of 46 PageID #:32

BdcInrgeltrrDdn
ltSf iElE

bq/il,up@lniotiDf!!.Mbice/vPdb6l^rylodtrrx)l6,o3rcrFc
7.ipt?F-s06

0I

rUlb

A*c d+arrd

tc.

?6*

ttl3Lt.IoDnnft

rilh (t tl$ rt3 Gr dtu aitiuD


O .&|@

Surely Mr. Hoge understands that truth is, l'm


an absolute DUMBFUCK

t'

r ISIJPEG
t2 bXE (22

tilotrtB)

Click

YAIIIIIG: IloolcrpcE&rdmffi

frL&'r d Mr

rrD

t rtat tt--t

rrd.*.

image to

i$lalei clicl lhi( lcrl

b skD hiiory

lrPrdb

lkE,rtuh[dt
Ef,IF

ttir

gr{rry

dffi

&ric

Dolrrc(tirinl

ir acodcd in 4336 br/B

(4rt)

(Hy,hbt
Dtcf}.zt3-3,J,
3

dd,

t:td.ta23

baiS !ba3 -.d

llp

,l(ilh,,,3'jJ,t?
3 d.
lJAtL,23hr{6td-.3 codr3o

CErcDe
NubSeltuOrigbl
$rbSoGTEDiflba

,
,

MinS

(2rfl ttlB biary (b)


(2'0(lb!/EbiEy(b)

XPAfu

Crrdy,ffi

hddios

fircf
O d.
ffi)

l.d,l:trPtt (b

fa'rfa

rgdryt,zr h.,

llir?8t1xry12
l*r9c
l'r. rtilm

WAINUTaG: No

l,B[d

;il=-;H,=*qii..
tureffi
AFB/&dbEIqB

tu,

!
d.9dd)
54 d
ry,r-Ir

dE

tua. .+d

d E @b.ffi eFodle
il4.*,i.t.cfin

ij; ry Irmm

o ugid-hryECdasF6

"!.!.nl1.o*.e.

Aaron Walker's "paralegal," @wjihogc, makes


funny joke about my underwear. They are
grownups, these guys.
Dos mlorE crqJbl tlE weity ot

Schmanaldt's

I*
Errere
Iu

I@lrt

tulldt

,XIF - ttir a!ry ofD.a.drr it d

in 4136

byb (azl)

e.dy,htl

DG/II@Orili.d
GE&Ih.
SeTt@Oritinl

2ll6illclt l60l:u
brzff,gdS
3d,19&rr,2l
2lltlclElt 16d)l:lr
tu,3-d9
3d-r9&r.2lhrz
75
,,<

uncbrer?

,wiftoge

OAarmworthins Odi O\/rglilsvkdx

(,Bornbss{-E

vh lryoptlm

tr *e

fif:

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 33 of 46 PageID #:33

BsicrtDFlnlomfur
Tqd

idlSp:

ejFPid

hrp'rP *pfMmhnrtinsrunsOmh'.
I

jpE'v=s

kisu

Gr.dy,

DrGi

Mrrlr
Itlr f6,rfa

Frlc:

tixsx St5 JPEG

@2&rl2lEr.35

IO:57:!AM (@dFftd)
de.-@ba
@.12

iry

@dG

?3,tzt
2l tDda ol }ilobc)

Pediry:

ft*
e
Fdb. k ry lEdlmd

lt4E fue6Gdr#y
&
?il
kmffi-.p!!H
iS

Atty&dbA

H6'.

vd

of,

rE diaiur)

td-iE.d*r*--.@.e-H*

wm
ffiE
d
VyilIiIING:
No @lc-qE
YYLdo d M- r.i tdrtE c-.&!
]wur

Colfi

rh ra

lEtaaS*effi

LF-rU.dt-!d--rlE5d-H*

r&d$drdr
LF-rHtdr&d--lIEL-.-u.*
r-dqdbd-

m db.d.f.d

ild-ly.

61tr Fodlq

L!F-bHr-r.,.d--@.--HF
r-tssdrel
I

bbffE&Fd
b uaid-hac

Cold strg
l,

L.F-5H.dE.d--@.--HF
r&-IrB-bdr
tEd.'+.dtffr-r-@5--H*
t&!.E.dr*-

lmeop.m

dE ftrll de:

EEF

thirgupof

dd.hirGtdiD4336byE(au

3ildy, hEick
Mffc

O.iSiol

kk
Sub
Sub

Sd Tie
Se f'lG

Origiill
Digiciz.d

,la$:la
ro:t:s
dG,32ds
lt'd.2&rr2lf!l5
,la:BEl6 lo:57s
! lrrtr.2&F,2lEn.15 tu.32ds
%

biary d!b)
trn6 biry de)

Hding

:2160 b4/t6

P.dditra

:2060

xPAub6

3r.dy, PrEick

Br.dc Imege
:farget

ims:

hformatixt
l F F

hei//il).ep.coftflhinkingtmvrmbicrodwp<onEn/uplmd&u)16^)3
rcrPEre2.jPg?w=746

Artis*
Date:

E Uri" it agc diqlirycd hrc

rt ()gS wi.tth (36&

tb G

bd-ts.l&.h--E*Lrld.id-*

,Grdt,P.frB
Mrrctrf620f6 lo:59lrAM(tiwdrp6i6.d)
(3 tdts, 22 dryr, 2 h@r, 3 oittG, 55 rEd $o, @iDf

iE

ge

P.cift)

Frls

ii@

dtS

tr
bd-1ffi-l-lmE*4rr,dr.C-d
d.l&a*rd-.t-dirG-tildt-cd
,

1$xffiIPEG
&,a51 byts (El hlobyts)

WAXNING: No color-spec da
Colr
Enoding: tYirderrrdMr;bbcrtt

ud m abcdtLd ohr pofifa

ac&rrnrdmly.

vit*vb
i!th IRGB olatp.ed
lD!6 ftrth Ebcdrilf,
sii c r&d&d eh Fdk. Se Ey In8od6i6 b D8ilrlJmgc Cold Spdes

a-;tldrl-rt-c-

,.

-d&ffi.
,-d-ffi.r-.f*>Ed..j-*

t
di
,r.

U&..tt*-dF.---rt
---t-t.1&rqcEa.*Bd..C-ff

tl di

adt-c-

ffimi!fuilil

AEly ddt6L

blhir iol8

via

---b.l&rq-E*l4d-.d-ff

lmSoFm

Ca*

d-

Hc'srhefrlldaa
Ef,IF

this grurp of nnadaa is cnoded itr 4335 byt6 ( 42r )

Artist

Dar/T.rGigiul

3ndy,kick
20lafihl6loj90.
3

CEste

ha

D.dr,

tdb,

SubSc TimOrigioal

tt

SubSe Tirc Digitized

3E

Hding

22

2C1a.(B:15
22

d.F,

ltrr,

3a

DiltE,

55

t@d!

.8o

55

.cod

lfl

lG59o.
d.ys,

hE, 3{ diG.

byBbiryde)

2 15 cv 01516

l-7..r&

NJ FrH G/r416 Pqe

- - F

--cd

t Gfl

7 ot

9 MnI21

t ladt

-cn

of

lb uitiul)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 34 of 46 PageID #:34

ImegehhrodiDr

Bodc

imgc:

Tbgct

S F l'r lU] Inain inrse

hup://i2.wpedlhinlinglffis6mbLrodwp{orhruplcds/2016/03rc!pEE
z jw'!w431

this

Artist:

Grdt,ffi

Dte:

Mud la, rta lO:5lrBAM (timd!!ei6.d)


(3@b,22&y!,2kr,43 oi@.32 r.cds ..D,Mi{iog.ti@

dUS

Iry

6frx5ltlPBc
noj36 byes (40 kilotye)

qigiul)

Ompt

tuBRr&OMd

ar6ld.o"d
Rsel u(:!'ssr{F

w1 (:'*ril lf

j-'""'":r."

lmSOF.cm

via

Oc

RetEatrrg ore's se I F a sqn ol snrlri.l

WAruTalNc:No@l,r-spocurdrrradmobcddcdolcprcfilc:
Colq
Eomding: tYidorr[dMrrrrtbrwmmefobtrrdonry.
lu!6 tu6crtDe!Eriluy vi(ry* tu ittu tlGB 6bFd
sitt o .i6.d&d @b Fo6lc. Se ny lntrqlwtim to Digiul-lrug. Cold SFG
fdmiilmtir.
AIpl, olb lob b rbi iqc

R.dio

kE d 7l% viih (5o* tb raof

Repeating one's self is a sign of senility.

hd6c)

Frls

15

displsyd

-rr.rlrt.1!x1.

{,

ll

Hre's ttc frrll daa:

EIf,IF

this etqlp of EadElE is acod.d in4336 byts

(42k)

Antur

indy, Prtrict

Datr/frm Origiml

201afi:16 l05lr3
ai!E,3:I
3 Mnq22&y.,2 hli3

Crc{lE Datc

20ladB:16 lc5lo3
3

SubSeTmOrigiEl
Sub

SeTlm

db,

22

&F,

rdrgo

hod,{f DidG,32 i.cod ry

t6

Digitized

16

Padditrt

12'fiobyt6biffiydar)
:2P60 byt6 biury ddi)

XPAdhq

3rady.

Padding

Prtick

Bsic hD.SeIrforo.tittr
lkget imgc:

hrp: 42.wprudsinkinSIwvomhie

8 F F Ed Utio i*g"

ddwp conknUuplod-ol6xlJ

f@rcJPt?w=5S

Anist:

Grdy,m,

Dre:

MrEt 15, ,la I I :36d2AM (tiw d rp6i6cd)


(, td,23 dry!,2 tmr,43 d.!p,
Br-i"t iEac tl@

Fi.lc:

5t0r3ll
2a,t92

dUS

tuift)

JPEG
(24 kilobyta)

bps

WAlNlNc:Noolo(-sFEtrdstradmabcddedolrgo6le:
Colr
Eocodi4: Wl..rnrdMrcwDhmlc-celc:raaOyIDF f6 rb Eb G d rihty viild. rh b ih. lnGB ok tFa rd
ri& u atcd&d oolr EdL. Se [y ltrEDdEio, @ DigitallaraSc Cola SFG
h.miifuDtin.
AFly dh6 bolr b lhb iE8.

Hm's

the

EXIF

via

Im8OFffi

frrll dxa:

this grup of

Et

data is

in 4336 byt6 ( 42k )

Artist

Crady,Pdick

Dde/freigiDal

20l6rGhl5 ll:36oa
3

Mh.,

23

&F,

hqE.

clrde Dql!

2015:Ci:15 ll:36o2
3 dhr.2, dirr,2 k\

SubSeTimOrigind

75

Sub

Sc Tre Digitizd

dilplEycd

lhis ls R.dio Orumpt

43

3.cd

43

!@A l'o

75

Padding

(2P6O byt6

biry

Biot

(2O60 hyt6

bitrry dr.t)

XPAuthc

Gndy, Patick

d8tr)

tgo

tsr.t

76% wirfth (58% tbc

t.

ag

Fo{ow

Oh, @PaulZKrendler? ls Aaron filing something


today?

of

tu nisipl)

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 35 of 46 PageID #:35

thaa

r-ar

cola
Bd.E:

ffiEr!-6cF-

ff-r &
kmffi

Eilrfrha*c{.!e!!dbEr?cr

E ffifry

catl'ffi
.tl r aS rPGO
3a,ra3byErHbyE)
W llrallac! rboobF
fh t-IE
Eaa-a

Arti*
Filc:

OFP

H{1t;Pffi"*d@Fdhddrffi

d Dd&d&!rd?
tdc-t
[4.*-

dL- !i ry M

Ditil-I4.

i"-.."i J.*o.*

Bn-dffi
6ob SF

t*.d
t B-dh

Ad.r r! rDir-or5

H.ir.tEtollda
ErIF - ff. Fryd*

i.

-s,-d

b4raA hrb (ia.tt)

ffi

^rde
DG-

7'DrtrtJPBG

Eh:

35P5a b!/E3

(3

HroaryE)

nd edcoaaFd.:
E&
W IfUlaG: NoolGqs
td G.fd ld.*/.
E'L-D J ll- -- hG
t@
bDtd-laotu
rdrd&Fdbs-ry
h@ffi
-kG-Gdfi#--&ffi&Ed

Cola

BEod{a:

dbth.trI4S.E[

Ilar'. tu ftIf d&


EXIF - lS. aqt.trEgda

ir r-.H

io a33{t

Artia

e..ry,H.t

Dra/Ttuorltbl

,L*}al

ll:2xrsr

,rLr3L3l

tI:2351

Cn

eDc

Sub

Se TID Otistn f $

Sob Se TIE

hddry
PtddrS
XF

ad6aElh17Gl56?

Adt i

lXlitizca

{l

(2r@by5bltrrr.l-)
(2.060byge-yd-)
Odrlr,ffi

hrE (a2t)

SPE

cd,'

riii(5lr
ilDErcE s

tb sdttoci6hrl)
a'rys@

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 36 of 46 PageID #:36

TeBGt

I P P E urin im*s dipld


Cryarlfcflon

iDage her/i2.wp.odttri.tiogMbi.sE/spffittuploi.2ot6,O3
/6Ia& jpt?r--stl

Ard"r -'G..t,hl*

fo*, --1#ia; *.ra;AJr;;;tr.n,--*-

rs,Hib'6&y|''br,23'iG'2tdp'qi4c@dtAtI
i-..----i.-,Frle:
,StlTZl7tPEG
,,
l*,rrrIEqqltobr/6)
_:_ __--- _-.1
d rc crbcddcd coh F!6h r,
WIXNIIiIG: ilo odor+proc ffi
'Cob,WllNlltlG:ilooh+procffidrccoDcddcdcohpofh.
rWilrrdllrEDhor-rgtdc&rrrHy.
fmlne
WBrrd lh Eb hola taac&r rrddy.

tit* tb L lb ilGB o&Fd


haE tu rb wi re d,.d,
ritl sMo&prdb.Sc
ry Imo&aio b DiSitd-IdgrColor SFE
Fw.*ErrlEr[L.lg.

,itumifrD.il
tumifrDab.

igq*:9'-ei**Yyers

hG a 77*

riit

And I am not making predictions here, but


aren't the Hoge/Krendler Klowns gonna have a
TON of shit to eat if Sarah and Eric DO
default???
CIick imagc

b iv)laie: click tbi\ lert h \hoq hi\togrrtrr

il

------l

Il@'stutolldrr
i3 acodod

Afii$

Hy,hbt

IhodficGisitr l

2.L:Gl:cl0ql&{o

CrEdchc
SubSecTmOriginl
Sub

43:16 bylct (,12L)

4td,6d.r,qi ka23 oi*r,2t dry


2.lastr0!L18,9
drfo
a d,6&!tr,5 br'23 !iG,a
t6

SccTtre Digitbd 76

2rSObyBtinryda)

Pldding

b/r6 tiDry

Prdding

[2160

)(PAuth

(ily,ki:t

de)

::

Mskd Nol6

CeltEra

Gamera

Aulftor and Coplrrigm

Locstion

Cam6 rnlo not founcl.

Copyrqhi rct foud.

GPS @.dinales

XMP

EXIF
A'll-

G.dy, Prtrid.

OabTLn C,rlgaml

2O16102:25 I 5:45:Og

Cc.ffi

2O't6:0225 l5:.r5d)e

GicacTl@Ortam.

at

&aScrhr.oaeatd

at

P.ddlie

(Bindy dri. 206() b!n6)

XFLdlta

G.dy, P6frick

tb rca
l.Fcrcr

,,_,-L-._.,J

Effi - ttb tlqp dmcoddl

(60ft

XMP data not ldd

nol l@.d

of

tu

oat

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 37 of 46 PageID #:37

Camd!

CoryYlgh

M.l(rNon-

Loatld

Gam,era
Cffi

into rcl l@nd-

Autlror and Gopyrlght

Locdon

Copyright rcl twnd.

GPS

nol tound.

XMP

EXIF

XMP drta nor

Cndy, ffid(

AiS
Orbfrn

c6rdiEi6

fqrrd

2O16:(1118 1o:l.l:O5

Oradnd

Cr.ffi

2O16dP:14 tO:14dE

t.AAGIIEo'.lhd

a.[

&FGcrlrFri.ld

aa

Prd(fE

(Blruy d!r! 2(H) byle)

XF .rl'rr

Onry,Peld(

r**

trdrr@hilb&turso
q!$.frrMr.@b&yu
dd!e.i@lt

Camera

CoBYight

Locelion

XMP

EXIF

Maker Not s

rcc

Camera

Atrt{ror and Gopyright

Location

Camors inro not founc,

Copyrilht not tound.

GPS coordinatee n

XMP

EXIF
Arf.t
O.fTtn.dgan

Grady, Parnck
a

2O16:(P:19 13:02:39

Crt bo.b
g5s.cTmdeh.l

2()16:(}2:'19 13:02:39

$r.a.cTh.olgrhd

66

P..5rte

(Etinafy dsta

XHultrot

Grdy, Pfilck

66

2og) b)d6)

XMP data not tound.

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 38 of 46 PageID #:38

SarCr O..nt It il u/tEo I s.y nsly tllaneE.


ilo p.oDbrn wl0r paopb sayinc Ar.lrr*ord me,
thoulgh.

C.m

Copyrllllil

lrHypc(ib

X.trlraot

L6c.don

I(oC

Camera

ArUror and Copyrlgm

CImkrnono{lqnd,

C@yde,rt not

Locallon

fhrd.

OPg @rdln!t6

rEt til

xhtP

EXIF
AdIT
D-Thtltafr.a
CE-Otb

O,rdy,Prtslct

$Fado.ttnrortrf

5a

2o'lafiItg

XlrP cLL not lornd.

'1554:3l.

2OlO:(Ele l5:t&3a

6a

(Blnry(h2@blrtlr)

F!.!fr
FLrlta

Gfndy, Pd.l(

--p-5-

@t

lnsert pictLJrB URL

co9}'tstt

Cfil.

lrcaton

Xrc x&rl.ob

EITF

toc

Gamsra

Autror and Copyvbm

Locafon

Cr}.ler|rftbndfourd.

rygnnotiq,ld.

GIPS

xhlP

EXIF

XMP

ltt

Hy.[!t*

O-.rfn OdCl-

A]}16g:2e lg:a'l:46

ffib

*B@

i*cfir.Orlghd

50

oth.ryd

50

ft

l5:al:{8

P.fiie

rrrdiram!yt..)

naE

G'.

ry, Prtrlcl(

dllt

not lbrrrd.

coodntba noi tbqrd.

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 39 of 46 PageID #:39

Tur(tr ril

Emd.

{!F.r.azfr!.rd.. .(tttnr lo gidng

tlocl'

lo

6et rd pqf TE L lrLl

Coefiehr

Cltrr

nP

l-ocato.|

ELriaob

@&rFoo.t

Y::?:r(|**t-.ie.

tqc

Gamera

Autilror and Goptdgm

Locaton

CffiHotptb$d.

Coplrfiht rEttdttd.

GFS

noahr.tal.

xliiP

EXIF

)(lrP

A..u

@,kr*

hlhlollal-

,o1af,,,,15;tl7zr.

ry

coo.dr6

aottriJ

--lrall
faa.ot-rqEd
EI
ElraE

dnr rEtrc,Id.

?ol!tr,,1gr47,,'
$
$
@.:ydrnAEbld
6r,FllloL
,flxBDarorlraY

f3n'.rrlrlDE
DN'OIIGf,

,rDlYroall?a!am
cEraxlf

Carlrfa

Cop!,'ldrf

Locdo3r

EXF

Xrc

Crnaaa lfib not fourtd.

GraaE

Ann

Cfrrqr.

lffgh.l

2(,13:(E{l.

1+ffi

2(}tGffsa 1.-.g8Ei
1A

t8

Pldcro
ndlE

l-oca
GPIS

Gllld:t Ftrt

coor

XilP

EXIF

Cr.bot

IGC

Arrllror and Coryrltrm

Gamera

Dr-'rfn

hlarl{ob

(Blrryd.t 2(E b!n-)


erdy. P.t

&ut
Crt-O.b
ilE7

ur.tlGbd.Ei.,bG.
2OleS:Oa 1/l:5,,e

eroy.tu

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 40 of 46 PageID #:40


VYU \l(rJD

t glt l.t, ," l(LlllLLl-l DrELrgtr lllD llgrv

4PCtrLrl'rgrrL lf/(lJf/,

l-lrg.tglltlCtttL

already had a Google Maps photo of the complex posted online,

Good Afternoon, DUMBFUCKI


Posted: Ausust 26, 2015 | Autton P9t$..l(!9gljg.!l I Flled urdoG Adhdicatod__c.yMee*e, A9Ju-9Hte19&enkll*

gsq,

-c"enEs!re,eHB uqrggx:

ffLqE5-r-E

:,i:

rgsge.s, zu$ !trpsEe-gem, !if"i$!91&sbgv,

Ulloleinelevantmecould,never,evergetarcsponsafromit.

lt'sbeendoingsuch,a,srperlativejobof

i$norlqg this site (wink, win$ anO staying Oetorr.tnC radarwhererl can't see it tnfrOge;nudgel. lt's got
this neurfound self-control now, and it novsr goes sllently trolling where it's not wanted...othorwiss

how would ft know, and why would it oare Who was kolllng it soqoo veoery HABD?
Wait.

What?

i:

That's a response?

oh.
lguess it U, iin't it?
tt has

calld

me inelevant before, and itw-lll call me inelevant again. Makes no nevermird to me.

.,Because all it's told me so far tqday is:a) it is vlsiting every day ana

O)

*n"r"

it isgoing to live.

\rrCtLrJ

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 41 of 46 PageID #:41

Hule

:.',

{f4. .::,

Ppeuss'DUMEFUCK
i,..
,

''li

,:

UPDATE -- trra! evantit

. ] . .,

.]

lgtbrcviow::':

,.',,'
,]

ttrolling scnooovesnry haamard. As promised. Twoweeks,


ft visits evsJ aay ftom

ttt" Coppy wiRArmg:'Every. Day. lf it really warts me to go away...Two

I made a promisei arU t wlU

teep it, but not Uefore n:hOlds up iU ena of tfre Oeal. gut t k Dw t'il nerrer

tlaveto,because.;.Tlvoweeks,..lslmpossible..
And the dock fiJst raset again.

ftlwill

stop

'l\rrro

r"

l''

,.:

weeks,
:

i picrmlsc.:Ihe only rpquircment ie that it goqg away and stops'doi1g

urts: ,

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 42 of 46 PageID #:42

EXHIBIT C - From Defendant Palme/s blog, in which she admits

to stalking me and promises to

continue to do so.
https://billysez.wordpress.com/20L5/L7/27lnew-facet-of-the-schmycle-identified/

New Facet of the Schmvcle ldentified!


Posted on November 27. 201 5 by The Dread Pirate Zombie

This is the season of giving. And in that spirit, never let it be said that Bill Schmalfeldt isn't a
giver.

I'm being totally

serious here, people. Stop laughing NealNBob!

I know that this is merely a facet of Billy being "Above it All Bill," but I am very excited to
present to you all MORALLY SLIPERIOR/MORAL HIGH GROUND BILL!
I know, right? Holy crap!
Who died and put me in charge? Bwahahatrahahaaaat God, I love it. I love it so much.
You know, I could be mean and cruel, but I won't. Especially since I've been doing *this* longer
than *that* and all.
And I am incapable of hate. I hate no one.
Gee. Based on your behavior, a rational person would think otherwise
You lmow nothing about me. You

Bill.

don't lcnow about the wonderful, caring, loving relationship

hadwith Goil.
Bill, that's

problem. We know EVERYTHING ABOUT YOU. Why? Because YOU


SCREAM IT OUT EVERY DAMN DAY! And as for the wonderful, caring and loving
relationship you had, well, if that relationship included your public declaration that you needed a
new coffee pot while she lay dying, then I don't know what could be truly loving about it.
the

You don't know what itfelt like to sit there andwotch her die when there was nothing I or
medical science could do about it.

I've sat and watched a loved

one die, so I do know what it is like. You don't get extra special
points
brownie
for that in this life because many people have done so. It's kind of part and parcel
of the human condition unfortunately.

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 43 of 46 PageID #:43

I appreciate your moderating Hinckley's comment on the day she died. But do you lmow right
before she died I got an email from Howard Earl asking if I would ask Goil to hold out one more
day because he had the lSth in the pool?

You don't know that it was Howard Earl. I've seen the comment (it wasn't an email you dumb
bastard) that you posted when it happened. It is merely your suspicion/opinion that that is the
case. And you know what they say about opinions, right?
You, young lady, hove no moral authority to preach to me. By

fucked

your ownwords, your own liJe is

up.

OOOOOOH! High Moral Ground BilM'm so excited to see you! Oh, how ever can I respond!
Well, I guess as a member of the undead, by default yes, my life is fucked up. But there are
worse things than that you know.
Daughter in trouble for shaking o baby. Getting divorced. How about you take a breakfrom
worrying about my issues and worry obout your own instead?

Billy, I don't worry about your issues. I DOCUMENT them. And have fun laughing at the
monkey dances and how many times you step on your own crank. I most certainly don't worry
about them.

I am a real, /lesh and blood human being


of it. I'm done with it.

that you guys

hwe been treating like shit and I'm tired

Gosh Bill. There are all sorts of real flesh and blood human beings that YOU have been treating
like shit and we are tired of you doing it them. WE are done with it.

And now, someone is trying to get me kicked out my opartment.

So,

am going

tofight bock

You are going to fight back by adding more restraining orders to your collection? Because that's
where you are headed Bill. That's not fighting back. That's doubling down on stupid. How about
you QUIT HARASSING OTHER PEOPLE. Then people wouldn't be so up in arms about the
idiotic things you zue doing. You can start by stopping accusing various people of being Paul
Krendler when you really and truly have NO FUCKING CLUE who he is. Unless he really and
truly was you in your wonderful pretendy-land fantasy and then you just have to look in the
mirror to find him.

If you get hurt in the process, that's


I'm

on you.

Girl Zombie, Bill. There is honestly nothing you can do to hurt me. Not even suing me
for half a million clams hurt me. Made me laugh, yes. Hurt me? No. You are in Wisconsin. I
really don't feel like traveling there (even though it's actually pretty close now that I think about
it) and so will never meet you in person. And that's just DANDY for me.
a Big

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 44 of 46 PageID #:44

If I were you, Sarah, I'd start o new blog about gardening or whatever else interests you because
continuing to fan the Jlames of hatred against me is just going to get you burned.
Actually, I DO have a new blog that I've been cultivating about one of my life-long obsessions.
It's a whole lot of fun and has been keeping my obsessive-compulsive nature for starting projects
and not finishing them in check. Plus there are pretty things and what Zombie Girl doesn't like to
feel pretty? I can't think of one that doesn't.
But if you think I'm fanning the flames of hatred by simply keeping a record of your harassment
of others and poor treatment of others factually using YOUR EXACT WORDS, then you have a
problem Bill. Because I'm not going away. You memory hole things because you don't like
being held accountable.
Guess what?

I'm

here so that you are held accountable because the things you do to others who

never warranted them are unconscionable. And no amount of you being High Moral Ground
will ever change that.
Be well.

Bill

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 45 of 46 PageID #:45

EXHIBIT D

DEFENDANT PALMER MISAPPROPRIATES PLAINTIFF'S NAME FOR PERSONAL

PROFIT.

BILLY SEZ

- The Bill Schmalfeldt Feldtdown

Observer

Because Al! the Cool Kids Are


Doing lt

Ieftrl Oorrtflon

',{rl,;/q- 6

Case: 1:16-cv-07150 Document #: 1 Filed: 07/11/16 Page 46 of 46 PageID #:46

Uflil you

lu$

lllt

r'oitcd ryr November 7,2075 iN Paul K(endler-Clone

lmpatient Billy

t.-

ann a.1tr

is IMPAT|ENT

^rr A1 tr1A trt'I

Eil^r.l 1111 Ol,l E

D^^^

1 aI 11

t-\^^,,rm^n+

1 11