You are on page 1of 5

Case 1:11-cv-03028-PKC-SMG Document 95 Filed 02/03/16 Page 1 of 5 PageID #: 2013

FILED

IN CLERK'SOFFICf

U.S. DISTAICTCOURTE.0..Y.

* FEB O"l201i

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT


EASTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~1e1Hl!R8QKLYNOFACE

LARRY JACKSON,
Plaintiff,

VERDICT SHEET
l l-CV-3028 (PKC)

V.

JESUS TELLADO, STANLEY MACNEAR,


JOHN CZULADA, JAMES T. GHERARDI,
RYANN DUNN, ROBERT J. DEFERRARI,
KENNETH BRAUMANN, BEN KURIAN,
PETER BONETA, THOMAS E. REO,
MICHAEL FAILLA, and BRIAN E. HEEREY,
Defendants.

False Arrest
1. Has Plaintiff Larry Jackson proven by a preponderance of the evidence that he was falsely
arrested on August 22, 201 O?
Yes___L_

No- - - -

IF YOU ANSWERED "YES" ABOVE, PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION I .A.


OTHERWISE, PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION 2.

A. Has Plaintiff Larry Jackson proven by a preponderance of the evidence that any of the
following Defendants were personally involved in falsely arresting Plaintiff on
August 22, 201 O?
Defendant John Czulada:
Defendant James Gherardi:
Defendant Ryann Dunn:
Defendant Robert Deferrari:
Defendant Kenneth Braumann:
Defendant Ben Kurian:
Defendant Peter Boneta:

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

No~

No
No

No
No~
No
No

Case 1:11-cv-03028-PKC-SMG Document 95 Filed 02/03/16 Page 2 of 5 PageID #: 2014

./
Yes
Yes._ _~~
Yes_ _,\71____

Defendant Thomas Reo:


Defendant Michael Failla:
Defendant Brian Heerey:

--~--

No---~

No_~\Z~No _ _ _ __

PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION J.B.

B. Has Plaintiff Larry Jackson proven by a preponderance of the evidence that ay of the
following Defendants failed to intervene to prevent his false arrest on August 22,
2010?
If you answered "Yes" on Question I .A with respect to any of these Defendants, you
must answer "No" as to those Defendants here:
Defendant Jesus Tellado:
Defendant Stanley MacNear:
Defendant John Czulada:
Defendant James Gherardi:
Defendant Ryann Dunn:
Defendant Robert Deferrari:
Defendant Kenneth Braumann:
Defendant Ben Kurian:
Defendant Peter Boneta:
Defendant Thomas Reo:
Defendant Michael Failla:
Defendant Brian Heerey:

~::

Yes_ _ _ __
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

No._ _ _ __
No
No._ _..,_,~_
No. _ _:..<--J..No
No
No
No
No
No
No
,/
No

-----

V'

'2

PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION 1.C.

C. Has Plaintiff Larry Jackson proven by a preponderance of the evidence that any of the
following Defendants are liable as supervisory officers for Plaintiffs false arrest on
August 22, 2010?
Defendant Jesus Tellado:
Defendant Stanley MacNear:

Yes
/
Y es=-=-=--~J...-_"'_-_PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION 2.

No _ _/...:.,
__
No- - - - -

Case 1:11-cv-03028-PKC-SMG Document 95 Filed 02/03/16 Page 3 of 5 PageID #: 2015

Excessive Force
2. Has Plaintiff Larry Jackson proven by a preponderance of the evidence that he was subjected
to excessive force on August 22, 201 O?
Yes

No- - - - -

IF YOU ANSWERED "YES" ABOVE, PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION 2.A.


IF YOU ANSWERED "NO" ABOVE BUT ANSWERED "YES" AS TO QUESTION I, PLEASE PROCEED
TO QUESTION 3.
IF YOU ANSWERED "NO" ABOVE AND ALSO ANSWERED "NO" TO QUESTION I, YOUR
DELIBERATIONS ARE COMPLETE.

A. Has Plaintiff Larry Jackson proven by a preponderance of the evidence that any of the
following Defendants were personally involved in subjecting Plaintiff to excessive
force on August 22, 201 O?
Defendant John Czulada:
Defendant James Gherardi:
Defendant Ryann Dunn:
Defendant Robert Deferrari:
Defendant Kenneth Braumann:
Defendant Ben Kurian:
Defendant Peter Boneta:
Defendant Thomas Reo:
Defendant Michael Failla:
Defendant Brian Heerey:

Yes_~/~-

Yes- - - - Yes- - - - Yes- - - - Yes


,,,.
Yes=:::::::::,z:::::::=
Y
Yes e s =
Yes
Yes- - - - -

No+
No
No
~~-~,~&~~,,No
No
No
No
No

~./

,
/
v

PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION 2.B.

8. Has Plaintiff Larry Jackson proven by a preponderance of the evidence that any of the

following Defendants failed to intervene to prevent him from being subjected to


excessive force on August 22, 20 IO?
If you answered "Yes" on Question 2.A with respect to any of these Defendants, you
must answer "No" as to those Defendants here:
Defendant Jesus Tellado:
Defendant Stanley MacNear:
Defendant John Czulada:

M~d~U=<'Gh&onlio

Defendant Ryann Dunn:


Defendant Robert Deferrari:
Defendant Kenneth Braumann:
Defendant Ben Kurian:
Defendant Peter Boneta:

Yes

Yes~

Yes

y,.
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

'@?
~

/
,/

No- - - - No
No--\Z__,,,,...~

-----

No- - - - No- - - - No- - - - No


/
No=:::::::::::::.z:=::::::
No
~----

Case 1:11-cv-03028-PKC-SMG Document 95 Filed 02/03/16 Page 4 of 5 PageID #: 2016

Yes- - - - Yes---7'''-Y es._--1.\,,,_/


__

Defendant Thomas Reo:


Defendant Michael Failla:
Defendant Brian Heerey:

No _ _.:./o__,,,,,L-No _ __:\Z!___
No _ _ _ __

PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION 2.C.

C. Has Plaintiff Larry Jackson proven by a preponderance of the evidence that any of the
following individuals are liable as supervisory officers for Plaintiff being subjected to
excessive force on August 22, 20 IO?
Defendant Jesus Tellado:
Defendant Stanley MacNear:

Yes

Yes=:=:=:v::=~==

No~LNo _ _ _ __

IF YOU ANSWERED "YES" AS TO ANY OF THE DEFENDANTS WITH RESPECT TO QUESTIONS I OR 2,


OR ANY SUBPARTS THEREOF, PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION 3.
OTHERWISE, YOUR DELIBERATIONS ARE COMPLETE.

Damages
3. Has Plaintiff proved, by a preponderance of the evidence, that he suffered any actual
damages?

,~/_ _

Yes__

No _ _ _ __

A. If "Yes," please state the amount of damages to which Plaintiff has proved, by a
preponderance of the evidence, he is entitled:

/d- 1 ~o~ ooo

B. If "No," you must award some nominal or token amount not to exceed the sum of one
dollar:

$_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __
PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION 4.

4. Punitive Damages: Entitlement: Has Plaintiff proved, by a preponderance of the evidence,


that he is entitled to punitive damages against:
Defendant Jesus Tellado:
Defendant Stanley MacNear:
Defendant John Czulada:
Defendant James Gherardi:
Defendant Ryann Dunn:
Defendant Robert Deferrari:
Defendant Kenneth Braumann:

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

No
No
No
No
No
No
No

Case 1:11-cv-03028-PKC-SMG Document 95 Filed 02/03/16 Page 5 of 5 PageID #: 2017

No
No
No
No
No

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Defendant Ben Kurian:


Defendant Peter Boneta:
Defendant Thomas Reo:
Defendant Michael Failla:
Defendant Brian Heerey:

IF YOU ANSWERED "YES" WITH RESPECT TO ANY OF THE DEFENDANTS LISTED IN QUESTION 4,
PLEASE PROCEED TO QUESTION 5 ONLY AS TO THOSE DEFENDANTS.
OTHERWISE, YOUR DELIBERATIONS ARE COMPLETE.

5. Punitive Damages: Amount: Indicate the amount of punitive damages to which Plaintiff is
entitled from each Defendant to whom you answered "Yes" in Question 4:
Defendant Jesus Tellado:
Defendant Stanley MacNear:
Defendant John Czulada:
Defendant James Gherardi:
Defendant Ryann Dunn:
Defendant Robert Deferrari:
Defendant Kenneth Braumann:
Defendant Ben Kurian:
Defendant Peter Boneta:
Defendant Thomas Reo:
Defendant Michael Failla:
Defendant Brian Heerey:

YOUR DELIBERATIONS ARE COMPLETE.

Dated:

~bft!Mj 3, 2016