Professional Documents
Culture Documents
=========================================
0. Let me start by sharing one of the most powerful short stories of Sadaat Hasan Manto,
written originally in Urdu, about the violent aftermath of the partition of India. Manto
wrote many heart-rending stories about the insane communal violence that raged over
both India and Pakistan immediately after 1947 when the revenge-cycles between Hindus
and Muslims claimed thousands of innocent lives. This is one of them:
JELLY
"At six in the morning, the man who used to sell ice from a push-cart next to the servicestation
was stabbed to death. His body lay on the road, while water kept falling on it in
steady driblets
from the melting ice. At quarter past seven, the police took him away. The
ice and the blood
stayed on the road.
A mother and child rode past the spot in a
tonga.The child noticed the
coagulated blood on the road, tugged at his mother's sleeve
and said "Look mummy, jelly."
I am disgusted even to imagine clots of human blood mixed with melted
ice looking like
jelly to a child. It suggests cannibalism. The clear hint that
the blood is from an innocent
victim of mass ethnic violence adds moral
nausea to my gut-disgust. I take no masochistic
delight in painful revulsion
or abomination. Yet, I like the story as a work of art. I would
even say that
it is a beautiful story. Why?
1. The puzzle of the hideous in art can be stated somewhat naively in the
form of a
seemingly inconsistent trio:
A] Positive aesthetic experience is a special cognitive-affective-creative
response to the
beautiful.
B] The disgusting or the ugly is simply opposed to the beautiful.
C] Yet, good paintings, plays or poems about the disgusting or the ugly are
quite normally
objects of aesthetic experience, in the West as well as
the East, in ancient as well as
modern times.
The puzzle does not look threatening at all because it seems that we can
question each
as the situation
is conceded,
the sharp opposition between the ugly and the beautiful also tends to
disappear. Although poems or paintings dealing with shrivelled senile bodies,
repulsive
metamorphose what is
utterly spurious.
Finally, the third proposition does not quite claim that the direct obejct of
aesthetic
turned to a
objects. It is perfectly
implying that he
distancing
of
such
digusting
sights--
nauseating
in
pornography of poverty
which
things.
would
it is like to be in the
Pornographic
include
enjoyment
present-day
of
television
(vairagya).
keep it unhealed."
After the old male partner of this beggar woman is murdered in a
gruesome way by
lines:
" Panchi put her arms round his neck and hung on his back. Bhikhu
leaned forward
inherited from
their mother's womb, nursed deep inside themselves, and which would
now live hidden under the fleshy folds of their offspring is indeed primordial.
This
darkness has ever defied the light of the earth in the past and will
future."
The aesthetic savour exuded by this story seems to be the hideous --the
beggarwoman
scene
to
create
profoundly
sense
of
the
inescapability of evil. And what is most puzzling is that we dont need to revel
in revulsion
It all begins with the cryptic recipe given by Bharata the 1st century
father of Indian
the
conjunction
consequent/expressive effects
of
determinant/
excitant
causes
delusion, anxiety,
feeling of emptiness etc. and the savour of tragic sorrow emerges out
of
these factors among the spectators. This account is then generalized for
other art-
differences of modes of
such as pride,
transient accessories in
most crucially--
it is not
Hideous, and
the Peaceful. The original use of that term "rasa" ranges over a variety of
interconnected meanings : a fluid that tends to spill, a taste such as sour,
sweet or salty,
are
the
exploited
at
different
junctures
of
complex
Aesthetic
and
disgust
blends with horror in the macabre, on the one hand, and blends with
laughter in
terms the
colonization, Oriental
voluptuous erotic
and pass
intricate
theories
of
making,
communicating,
enjoying,
suffering, interpreting and assessing art that are already available in Sanskrit
theoretical
course, the
that is no reason
contemporary examples or to be
Anandavardhana.
subject of a masterly
disgust.
5. The determinant/excitants of disgust are listed by the first century text
Natyasastra 6/34
as follows:
"Perceiving or hearing about things hated from the bottom of one's heart,
naturally
The transient
1 See paintings titled " The Cook", "The Jurist" or "the Gardener" by
8
The
emergent stable
by
vultures, the fragrance and the stink and the clever use of
be the poem by
Yeats called "Crazy Jane Talks with the Bishop" that ends as follows:
" A woman can be proud and stiff
When on love intent
But love has pitched his mansion in
The place of excrement;
For nothing can be sole or whole
That has not been rent "
The idea of beautiful people defecating traumatized Jonathan Swift. His
disgust is
leavings".
10
(Columbia
is by Ksemendra himself)
world-theater". Shakespeare's
imncomparably superior
samadhi, the Hindu God Shiva who presides over the arts
of music,
percussion and dance has made his abode in the cremation ground. A
A contemplative imaginative practice of what it is like to be dead is not after
all a
5. I do not claim that Abhinavagupta has said the last word about the place
of the repulsive
the second part of which is devoted to the topic of the ugly. "The aesthetic
attitude
coughed out that loose tooth that had travelled from her
mouth to his."
Ksemendra, unfortunately, calls the above skit a literary failure because it
See K.C. Bhattacharya's Studies in Philosophy (volume I and II) edited by
Gopinath
Bhattacharya ( Originally Progressive Publishers Calcutta
1958, Reprinted by Motilal
Banarsidas, Delhi 1978)
3
12
body-odours match
love
each other for ever and the novel ends with what Abhinavagupta would call a
restful
unobstructed enchantment with eros--an "intrepid love" that defeats the
ugly hand of time.
6.
Following K.C. Bhattacahrya's footsteps I want to enrich the Indian
aesthetics of the
Indian Bharatanatyam or
Odissi, but it is best expressed when left unsaid. Take the Borges
story The
Cruel Redeemer Lazarus Morell. This ruthless swindler cheated Negro slaves
as well as slave-owners for a living. He would promise to free a slave in the
American
unrelenting
irony
climaxes
at
the
end
when
he
reports,
in
an
his horse:
" I told him I had no time to hear him pray. He turned around and dropped
on his
knees and I shot him through the back of the head. I ripped
genteelly "
well. It feels
contrast. Besides,
together in a single
of the
Opera where humans living in the gutter enagage in gory and repulsive play
with
beautiful heroine is
as an extreme
counterpoint to the sublime beauty of the woman and her music. The
representation of the dark obscure nature of the "phantom'"s tragic love for
the singer
language as in Aristophanes or
a shade of pain as in
well-told stories about sadly funny gross acts of the inmates of madhouses.
Fourth, the hideous can emerge as a prop for artistic relish when it is shown
to be
be erotic or agapic.
King of the Dark Chamber where the queen never can see the
face of the
king because he might be too unbearably ugly. In the climax the queen, once
frustrated by her misplaced love for an externally handsome lesser king,
finds her own
4 A Bob Dylan song uses this trope of the amorous hideous rather
straightforwardly:
" You know I love her
Yeah I love her
I am in love with the ugliest Girl in the World.
If I ever lose her I will go insane
I go half-crazy when she calls my name.....
The woman that I love she has two flat feet
Her knees knock together walking on the street
She cracks her knuckles and she snores in bed
She aint much to look at but like I said
You know I love her
15
religious merit. One day St. Catherine could not take it anymore. While
dressing her open sore, she threw up on the patient's body. She had to
somehow overcome
her and
blessed her by allowing her to drink blood from the side of his own crucified
body. This story is told with pious devotion by Raymundus Venies in his Life
of Santa Caterina(part II, chapetr11). I am sure it awe-inspringly shows, for
some audience , the greatness of humility and compassion only through the
use of the most disgusting details. In the Buddhist collection
of pali poems
by ancient nuns called "Therigatha", we have the classic story of Shubha the
Yeah I love her
I'm in love with the ugliest Girl in the World"
I am grateful to Connor Roddy, my research student, for procuring me
this example.
Neither K.C.Bhattacharya nor Abhinavagupta would have perpaps like
this Bob Dylan
song. But when someone enjoys these lyrics (and Dylan
songs are often admired only
for the lyrics) K.C. Bhattacharya's idea
that the enjoyed quintessence of ugliness
can be manifested through "patient faith of courageous love" seems to
explain it pretty
well.
16
beautiful maiden who found the man who tried to seduce her in a mangogrove to be mentally sick because he was inebriated with the beauty of this
youngnun's eyes. Out of kindness for this sick man who did not realize the
worthlessness of bodily beauty she simply cut out her own eye-balls and
offered it to the seducer thereby scaring him away in repentence and horror.
Such therapy of one's own or another's desire is a common subject of many
traditional religious literature.
Fifth, the most widely practiced transformation of disgust to dispassion
thatAbhinavagupta called "pure": the serene sense of vanity and fragility of
earthly pleasures.
This is done in many ways. Sometimes by bringing out the lurking spectre of
over-feeding and satiety that haunts all human consumption. Sometimes it is
done by showing behind every human revelry the ugly entrails of mortality.
Examples and discussion of this abound in Shakespear's Hamlet and the
Sanskrit epic Mahabharata. At the end of the great war which forms the
center of that epic, the righteous hero Yudhisthira laments looking at the
battlefield where rotting deadbodies are piled up: " The earth has lost her
youth,everything smells of death, everything is shrivelled , old and ugly. Is
this what we fought a war for ?"
Abhinavagupta has connected this notion of "pure" hideousness with the
notion of purity (sauca) in patanjali's Yogasutra where it is linked up with a
certain disgust at one's own gross body. This disgust transforms itself into a
tranquil dispassion which embraces death without any sadness and goes
beyong pleasure and pain.
But most delicate and in a deeper sense Romantic is the sixth mode: the
absorption of the hideous for the sake of the sheer thrill of sensing every fold
of
embodied
existence.
Every
chiasm
and
tiny
wisp
of
apparently
blackened with the poison of sensory intake of the ugly in the mirror of his
own or another's work and recognizes the Shivahood of his soul.*
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------* I am grateful to my colleague Lee Siegel and my research assistant Connor
Roddy for helpful discussion and references.
Arindam Chakrabarti
Department of Philosophy
University of Hawaii at Manoa, Honolulu, USA.
19