You are on page 1of 298

;

:
David Cannadine

___ 1 9 _____
:

14, 105 53
./fax: 210 3250058
e-mail: nissos92@otenet.gr
:
:

: David Cannadine (ed.), What is History Now?


Palgrave Macmillan Ltd 2002
, 2007 .

:
: , Barbara Kouzelis
:
: ..
: -
ISBN: 978-960-8392-40-3

David Cannadine ( .)

2007

................................................................................................................. 9

David Cannadine
1. : ; -

...............................................23

Richard J. Evans
2 . ;

..................................................53

Paul Cartledge
3. ;

....................................................... 81

Susan Pedersen
4 . ;

............................................ 115

Olwen Hufton
5. ;............................................... I 55

Miri Rubin
6. TOY ;

................... 181

Alice Kessler-Harris
7.

............................................... 211

Annabel Brett
8. ;

.......................................2 4 3

Linda Colley
9. : ;

.................................................. 2 7 1

Felipe Fernandez-Armesto

........................................................................2 9 5


David Cannadine
,
( )
,
, 14
15 2001, 40
Macmillan
.. Carr ;.1
,

, :
Trinity
( Carr )
Palgrave Macmillan (
Macmillan).

,

.
,
, Judith Herrin, Warren
Boutcher, Peter Marshall, Philip Williamson, Lyndal Roper, Daniel
Pick Catherine Hall
,

10




.
,


,
,
:
Carr,
-

Carr -


( )
,
.

, ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , (
)

.
,
.2
; .. Carr
George Macaulay Trevelyan


1961.3 ,
Trinity

.
Trevelyan
,
1960 -
C arr-
. ,

,
, Carr
Trevelyan.
, ,

, Carr

revelyan.4
,
Carr
,
I960 1970,
( )
,

,

12_____

_________

______

______

_____


,

.5 G.R. Elton,
The Practice o f History (: Sydney University
Press, 1967) ( ,
) ( )
60 .. Carr,

,
,
,

(;) .6
,
1960 1970
Carr Elton :
The Crisis o f the Aristocracy, 1558-1641 Lawrence
Stone (: Oxford University Press, 1965), The Growth o f
Political Stability in England, 1675-1725 J.H. Plumb (:
Macmillan, 1967), The Making o f the English Working Class E.P.
Thompson (: Victor Gollancz, 1963) Africa and the
Victorians Ronald Robinson J.A. Gallagher (:
Macmillan, 1961). ,
, 1960
1970 Elton:
,
,
. ,
1970
, ;
:
1 -

____

_______

______

_____13



.
Lawrence Stone The Revival of
Narrative ( ),
Past & Present 1979
The Demise of Causation (
).7
Stone
,

.
80
:

,

I960,
.
, , Geoffrey Elton,
1980 1990 ,

,
Elton
Carr .8
,
, ,

,

14

,
,
- ,
.9

.
,

1960 1970.
, ,
-

. , ,

, ,
Elton
,


. , ,

I960,
,

,
. ,
,
,


.10
,
Carr ,

15


,

( )
,
,
,
,
. , 1960

,
,
,



.
, ,
,

:

,

.11

,
2 1 ,
.
,

.
,

16

Carr
, .

,
, --
.
,


-


.
,


.
.
,
.
,
,
.
,

:
.

,

, ,
.

17

,
aficionados12
.13
:
,


,
,


.
.
.

,
1960 1970,

, . ,
,
,
, .
,
, ,

. .

,
.
, , Carr ,

.

18



.
-
.

.




.14
-
.
-


20
( )
.
,
, , ,

,
. Carr
;
Carr. .
, ,
.15
- .

19

,
.
,

.

,
,
, , .
Josie Dixon Palgrave Macmillan,
,
,
,

.
Chase Publishing Services,
,

,
.
. Debra Birch,
, - ,
, ,
-

. ,
.. Carr, .

20


1. .. , ;, . , 70 -
, 1974. (...)
2. , .
J. Gardiner ( .), What is History Today?, : Macmillan, 1988.
3. , . R.J. Evans, Intro
duction, .. Carr, W hat is History? (40 .), : Palgrave, 2001, . ix-xlvi.
4. D. Cannadine, G.M. Trevelyan: A Life in History, : HarperCollins,
1992, . 221-222.
5. I960, . D. Cannadine,
Historians in the Liberal Hour : Lawrence Stone and J.H. Plumb ReVisited, Historical Research, 2002 E.J. Hobsbawm, From Social History to the
History o f Society, Daedalus, 1971, . 20-45.
6. J.P. Kenyon, The History Men: The Historical Profession in England since the
Renaissance, : Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1983, . 278-279 R.J. Evans,
Afterword, G.R. Elton, The Practice o f History (2 .), :
Blackwell, 2002, . 165-203.
7. L. Stone, The Revival o f Narrative: Reflections on a New Old
History, Past & Present 85 (1979), a. 3-24. . History and the
Social Sciences in the Twentieth Century, , C.F. Dalzell ( .),
The Future o f History, : Vanderbilt University Press, 1977, . 3-42.
8. G.R. Elton, Return to Essentials: Some Reflections on the Present State o f
Historical Study, : Cambridge University Press, 1991.
Elton
, .
9. , ,
J. Tosh, The Pursuit o f History, : Longman, 1991 R.J. Evans, In
Defence o f History, : Granta, 1997.
10. Q.R.D. Skinner, Meaning and Understanding in the History o f Ideas,
History and Theory VIII (1969), . 3-53.
I I. J. Scott, Gender and the Politics of History, : Columbia
University Press, 1988.

21

! 2. . (...)
13. . Jenkins, Re-thinking History, : Routledge, 19 9 1 A. Munslow,
Deconstructing History, : Routledge, 1996.
14. Lord Dacre of Glanton (H.R. Trevor-Roper), The Continuity of the
English Revolution, Transactions o f the Royal Historical Society, 6.1 (1991), .

122.
15. E.H. Carr, What is History;, : Penguin, 1964, . 30.

I
: ; -
Richard J. Evans
I
; .. Carr 1961.
Trevelyan
, BBC


, Carr
. . ,
. ,
, ,
.


. , Carr,

. .

.1
Carr,

24

,
. ,
.

.2 Carr

.
Carr
, ,
,
... , ,
,

, ,.
Carr

.

,
, .3
Carr,

.
.


.
,
,
,
,

; -

25

,

. Carr

, ,

.
, ,
Carr
, -
C a rr-
,
, ,
, ,..,



. ,
,
Carr
,

, ,

.4
Carr , ,
-
-
.
;

, .. Carr

26

__ _______ ;

. ,
,

Times ,

.5
Carr
. ,
,
,

- ,
. Carr,
,
.


,


.6
, Carr
,
- ,
I960,
,
.
,

. , ,
, ,
,

; -

27

-


1960.
,

.
,
,
, ,
,
.7
Carr

,
I960,
,
, , ,

- Carr , ,
, ,

.8 ,
,
, ,


.9

;

28__________________

____________________ ______ _____ .,

, ,

I960
.10
Carr
:

,
.
,


.11

,


,
,
.
, Carr,

.

. ,
,

.12

,
.

,

; - ________________

_____

____________________

,
,

.13

II
Carr ;
, :

1960,

, , ,
,

.

: ,

- ,
, ,
.


Carr

30


.14
, 1960
, ,
-

Carr

; ,
,

.


1968.

,

,
.
I960

Carr

.15 ,
1960
,

,
,
, ,
.
1970 ,

, .

; -

31

1970 ,
,
1950,


.

.

, ,
. , ,
I960,
. ^ - .
,

. ,
,

.16
,

.


,


. ,
, ,
,

. ,

___________________ ______________________________ ;


, ,
,
. -
-


1989-1990.

Carr ,
,
,
. ,
,
.
1990,
Carr
. , ,

,

,
, ,
.
,

. ,
,
. ,
.
. , ,

; -

33


,
.17


,
,
, .

-
. ,
:
,

, (
) ,

;18
~ 1990


.19
, Carr,
,
.


1990,
, ,
, ,

. , 2000

34____________________ __________ ______________________ ;


,
Carr,
,
, .



, , .

1970 1980,
.


.
, ,
.20
,
, ,
,
Carr,
.
, 1990
. -



. ,
, ^
,

; -

35

- -
.
, ,

-
, ,


(
, ,
,
) .
2000,



:
, (Rethinking History)
,
. ,
, .
.

.

.
,
2 1
;.
. ,
, 1990

36______ ________________ _____________ _________________ ;

.


1970 1980.
,
,
,
.21


.
, , , ,
, ,
.
Carr .

, .



13

19
.22




.


37

; -

,

,


.
,
.
, ,
,
, , ,
, : ,

,



. ,

,


.23

, Carr
,
. , -
-

, -

Carr

38


Carr, .

Ill
,
.
,

,
.
, ,
.
, ,
,


.

2 1 . .
1980

' ,

.
, ,

.
- -
,
(, )
, --

; - ___________________________________________________ 39



.

,
.24


.
, ,
,
1990
2000 ,
,
,
,
,

.





.25

.
, , U-57I ,
- - ,
Band o f Brothers, '

1990
,

10__________________________

_______________________


, -
.
.
, -
- ,
- .
8, David Starkey, 4
4 ,
17 -, ,
, 4,3
. .26

,
U-57I
,
, ,
0

.27 ,
, ,


. ,
,
, .
,

. , ,

, 1665, ,

; -

41

,
8;2


,
,

-
.


,
.
,

, Europe: A History
(: Oxford University Press, 1996) The Isles (: Macmillan, 2000) Norman Davies,

29
18 - Aristocrats Stella Tillyard
(: Vintage, 1993) Georgiana Amanda
Foreman (: Flamingo, 1999).
,
, ,
.
,
,


,

42


, , 47.000
38.500 1992 1999.
.
.
, ,
, 21
, ,
. , , ,
.30
,
.
,
, ,
, ,
.
,

,
.
, ,
. , ,
,
,
.
,
-
.
,

; -

43


.31

' .

, , . , ,

,
,

.

.

2 1 .
.. Carr;
,

. ,

-


, .
,
- :
, Lawrence Rees-
, ,
.
, 8, David
Starkey, -
, -

4 4 _____________________________________________________ ;

: ,

. , ,

,
,

.

. ,

,

,
,
.
. ,

,
, .


.

,

,
,
, .

,
Bond o f Brothers,

; -

45


, 1944,
' , ,
,
Stephen Ambrose, - .32
, ,

,

A.J.P.
Taylor, ,
,
Taylor .. Carr,
,
.33
,
Carr

.
,
,

-
Taylor
.
- G.M. Trevelyan, ,
Macaulay.

I960 , ,
, .

46

,


, Macaulay Trevelyan.

- -
,

1990. ,
- ,


.


,
. ,

,

.
Hayden White,

,




. -

; -

47

-

,

,
,
. Hayden W hite
David Starkey
Simon Schama.34
.. Carr
- Carr, ,
;

,

,
.
, Carr,

,
,
.35
Carr ,


:

,
.36


48

________

________________ _______________ T IJ IN A IJ IT p P jA ;

,
Carr -
;-

,
.37
Carr



,
.

,
,

.38
Carr ,

.

.
, Carr
, , .


39

, Carr

.

; -

49


1. .. Carr, What is History? (40 .,

Richard J. Evans), : Palgrave, 2001, . 5-6, 22-24' , ..


Carr, History and Morals, Times Literary Supplement, 17

1954,

.
2. Carr, What is History?, .., . 6.
3. , . 47-49.
4. .. Carr, A History o f Soviet Russia, . I: The Bolshevik Revolution I,
: Macmillan, 1950, . 5-6.
5. Jonathan Haslam, The Vices o f Integrity: EH. Carr 1892-1982, :
Verso, 1999 E.H. Carr, An Autobiography (1989), crto Michael Cox ( .),
EH. Carr: A Critical Appraisal, : Palgrave, 2000, . xiii-xxii.
6. Haslam, The Vices o f Integrity, .., . 146 Isaiah Berlin, Mr. Carrs Big
Battalions, New Statesman, 5 1962, . 15-16 H.R. Trevor-Roper,
.. Carrs Success Story, Encounter, 1962, . 69-77.
7. , , E.J.
Hobsbawm, Primitive Rebels, : Manchester University Press, 1958
E.P. Thompson, The Making o f the English Working Oass, : Victor
Gollancz, 1963.
8. Carr, What is History?, .., . 146-147.
9. . Cambridge Reporter 96
(1965-1966), . 627, 1013-1029, 1292, 1591, 1830, 1852-1853
Patrick Collinson, Geoffrey Rudolph Elton, 192 1- 1994, Proceedings o f the
British Academy 94 (1996), . 448-449.
10. Carr, What is History?, ., . 60.
11. , . 38.
12. , . 5 1-60.
13. , . 60-62.
14. Keith Thomas, The Tools and the Job, Times Literary Supplement, 7
1966, : New Ways in History Emmanuel Le Roy
Ladurie, The Territory o f the Historian, : University of Chicago Press,
1979, . 6 R.W. Fogel G.R. Elton, Which Road to the Past? Two Views o f
History, : Yale University Press, 1983.

50

15. Joyce Appleby, Margaret Jacob Lynn Hunt, Telling the Truth about
History, : W .W . Norton, 1994, . 202, 216 Peter N. Stearns,
Coming o f Age, Journal o f Social History 10 (1976), . 246-265.
, . Georg G. Iggers, Historiography in the Twentieth Century,
: Wesleyan University Press, 1997.
16. Harvey J. Kaye, The Powers o f the Past Reflections on the Crisis and the
Promise o f History, : University o f Minnesota Press, 1991 .
Robert F. Berkhofer Jr., Beyond the Great
Story: History as Text and Discourse, : Harvard University Press, 1995.
17. , . Richard J. Evans, In Defence
o f History (2 .,

), : Granta, 2001.

, . Alun Munslow, Deconstructing History,


: Routledge, 1996 Keith Jenkins, Re-thinking History, :
Routledge, 1991 , . Frank Ankersmit, Historiography and
Post-modernism, History and Theory 28 ( 1989), . 137-153.
18. Christopher Norris, Deconstruction and the Interests o f Theory, :
University of Oklahoma Press, 1989, . 16 Paul Boghossian, What the Sokal
Hoax Ought to Teach Us, Times Literary Supplement, 13 1996, .
14-15 Alan B. Spitzer, Historical Truth and Lies about the Past, :
University of N orth Carolina Press, 1996.
19. , . Richard J. Evans, In Defence o f History, :
Granta, 1997, . 284-301.
20. , . Sande Cohen, Historical Culture: On the
Recording o f an Academic Discipline, : University of California Press,
1986.
21. ,
, . David Mayfield Susan Thorne, Social
History and its Discontents: Gareth Stedman Jones and the Politics o f
Language, Social History 17 (1992), a. 165-188.
22. Stuart Clark, Thinking with Demons: The Idea o f Witchcraft in Early
Modern Europe, : Clarendon, 1997 Carlo Ginzburg, The Cheese and
the Worms: The Cosmos of a Sixteenth-Century Mille, : Johns Hopkins
University Press, 1992 [. .: To , . .
, : , 1994] Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, Montaillou,
: Scolar Press, 1978 Jean Delumeau, La peur en Occident (XlVe-XVIIIe
siecles), une cite assiegie, : Fayard, 1978 La peche et la peur: la
culpabilisation en Occident (Xllle-XVIIIe siecles), : Fayard, 1983.

51

; -

23. 2 1

.
24.
, Peter Novick,
The Holocaust and Collective Memory, : Bloomsbury, 1999 Tony
Judt, The Past is Another Country: Myth and Memory in Postwar Europe,
Istvan Deak, Jan T. Gross Tony Judt ( .), The Politics o f Retribution
in Europe: World W ar II and its Aftermath, : Princeton University Press,
2000, . 293-324.
25. Kingsley Amis, Lucky Jim, : Penguin, 1954,
' Iris Murdoch, Under the Net, : Chatto
and Windus, 1994 - Michael Ondaatje, The English Patient,
: Picador, 1992 [. .: , . . ,
: , 1996] Zadie Smith, White Teeth, : Hamish
Hamilton, 2000 [. .: , . . ,
: , 2001] Matthew Kneale, English Passengers, :
Penguin, 2000 Sebastian Faulks, Birdsong, : Vintage, 1993.
26. John Willis, Past is Perfect, Guardian, 29 2001,
, . 2-3 (
).
27. Mark C. Carnes ( .), Past Imperfect: History According to the Movies,
: Henry H olt & Co., 1996- Richard J. Evans, Is This the Past as we
Know it?, Independent, 12 2001, . 5.
28. Tristram Hunt, Back to the Future, Observer, 6 2002.
29. Ian Kershaw, Hitler 1889-1936: Hubris, : W .W . Norton,
1998 Hitler 1936-1945: Nemesis, : Allen Lane, 2000 [. .:
1889-1936. 1936-1945, ,

. . , :

Scripta, 2002].
30. Richard J. Evans, How History has become Popular Again, New
Statesman, 12 2001, a. 25-27.
31. Willis, Past is Perfect, .. Evans, How History has become
Popular Again, ..
32. Stephen E. Ambrose, Band o f Brothers, : Simon and
Schuster, 1998.
33. Kathleen Burk, Troublemaker: The Life and History o f A.J.P. Taylor, Niou
: Yale University Press, 2000.
34. Hayden W hite, Metahistory: The Historical Imagination in NineteenthCentury Europe, : Johns Hopkins University Press, 1987- Simon

52

Schama, Citizens: A Chronicle o f the French Revolution, : Alfred Knopf,


1989.
35. Carr, What is History?, .., . 17-18.
36. , . 38.
37. Ved Mehta, Fly and Fly-Bottle: Encounters with British Intellectuals,
: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1963, . 158 ( Carr).
38. Jonathan
Haslam The Vices o f Integrity.
39.
, . Richard J. Evans, Lying About Hitler: History, Holocaust and the David
Irving Trial, : Basic Books, 2001.

2
;*
Paul Cartledge
, ,
. ,
-
.

,


. ,
, Moses
Finley, , .1
Finley - ,
-

- , ,
- .2

,

. ,
Finley

, Arnaldo
Momigliano,

54

U TOPIA ;

. 1968 Finley,
, Momigliano:
, ,
Momigliano

;.


Momigliano
. ,
.. Carr Trevelyan .3
Carr , ,
.4 Finley



(
) . Finley,
- "

,
.
.

I
;

, , - "
.
,

55

.5
, ,
G.M. Trevelyan English Social History,

.
,
,
,


.
.6 ,

revelyan .7

Finley
, Eric Hobsbawm.
.
1972
:


, ,


.8
1929 Lucien Febvre Marc Bloch
Annales d histoire economique et sociale

:

56

1972 Annales: Economies, Societes, Civilisations Annales: Histoire, Sciences Sodales -


, .9
International Journal o f Social History,

,
, ,
,
.
:

,

.10
Rethinking Social History,
Adrian Wilson 1994.11 ,
, . ,
Keith Wrightson, , ,
I960
( Hobsbawm
1970) .
,
,

( ) ,


.12 ,
Wrightson,

,
.
Keith Thomas,

57

, (Times Literary
Supplement/TLS, 14 1994):
(,
.. Thompson
,
,
,
1970. ,
,

.)


;

,

.
,


. , ,

2 1 2001 TLS.


Peter Burke Asa Briggs,
Social History o f the MediaJ 3

Anthony Smith,
. ,


TLS: Encyclopedia o f European

5 8 _________________________________ __________ ______ ;

Social History from 1350-2000, Peter Stearns,


3.150 .14
Stearns
,
. ,

, Stearns

,
( ftabb) ,
, ,
, , - -
-

, [...]
, ,

Stearns .15

- .
,
, Journal o f Social History, International
Review o f Social History, Continuity and Change: A Journal o f Social
Structure, Law and Demography in Past Societies, Comparative Studies
in Society and History Social History (
) Histoire Sociale/Social History (),
.
tout court,

( ; ;)
(-)
, .16

- -

59

() .
-

;17


,

/ : , ,
,
.

.


, , .
,

, ,
, , .18

II
,
, ;19

.
,

.20

, , , -

60

(
)21
- - ,
,

22

.
Tom Gallant, -
-
,
^
-
, [
]
.23 , Gallant
,
:
,_
, ,
.
W.G. Sebald,
:

( wie es eigentlich gewesen ist von Ranke). ,

.24
,
, , ,
Gallant

61

,
,

. ,
, Gallant
,
, o Fernand Braudel,
Annales, , duree25,
(
) ,
(, ,
, ).


,
,
, ,
( )

.26
, ,


long duree,



.
"
^

Ill


, W.G. Runciman.
""'
'1*""*
'
, , (A Treatise on Social Theory),
, 1.170 .

- -
.27
,
,


.
. Runciman
,
, , .
, (Applied
Social Theory),
,
-
- 20 .
,
(Substantive Social Theory).


- -
Runciman
(. Ill, . xiii, . I) 28. ,

,

,

,
: (
), ( )
( ).

, Runciman,

, ,

29
,
.

. ,
Runciman,
, ,
,

.
- -
,
.
, ,
,

.30
- -
;
Runciman
.
,

64


,
, , ,
;
,
-
;
Runciman


(
,
).
,
,
.

. ,
, , , .
Runciman
, , ,
, - - 450

. Runciman,
-
, . : , 6 .. , (
, ,
)

;_____________

__

65

( ) , ,

.31

-
- ,
, -
, .32

IV
( ),
- The Evolution o f Inequality: War, State, Survival
and Democracy in Comparative Perspective ( :
, ,
) (1999), Manus Midlarsky
Runciman. Runciman
,
,

.
Runciman ,

,
. ,

,
.33
Midlarsky.

66_________

____________ _____________________________ ;

( )
,
,
,
.
.


,
.

.
Midlarsky

.
<
,
(.
221).34
,


,
( ),
. ,

Midlarsky,
, ,
,

,
. ,

67

Midlarsky
,
,
,

-
"
.

The Evolution o f Inequality
.
(Decline and Fall of Empires
and States) - ,
, , , , -


(Sources of Democracy) (. 186-189)


,
, ,
(
Midlarsky, , ).

V
Midlarsky
.
,
,

68____________________ ____

_______________ ______ ;

.
,
Christopher Browning Daniel Goldhagen,
, , ,

1942. Browning
Goldhagen
,

.

. ,

Stearn -
- ,
,
,


.35 ,
, ,


, .36 ,


, ,
. ,
,
:

; ,

69

,

,
.37

, Goldhagen

. ,
Goldhagen38
37
,

SS,
,
, ,

.
- - ,
. , Browning
,
Goldhagen
.


1942
- : 10
20
.

,
,
Browning Goldhagen.

70


,
,
, Ludmilla Jordanova

- -
.39

VI

. :
-
, .
,
, () 1960
1970 .40

,
; (
) ,
,
- -
;
.41 - ,
, -- . ,
,
Runciman, .

;________________________________________ 71

,
. ,
RichardEvans,
, ,
, -
,
-
.42
,
. ,
,
()

,
-
,
.43
; -
-

.44 ,
, ,
, , ,
.45
,
.
.

72

______________________________ ;

,
David Cannadine , ,

- - Geoffrey
Elton ( Richard Evans
G.R. Elton, The Practice o f History, 2 .,
: Blackwell, 2002). . Judith
Herrin
. , Richard Evans

.
I.
Finley: .. Finley, The Use and Abuse o f History,
: Chatto Windus, 1975 ( .: : Hogarth
Press, 1986) B.D. Shaw R.P. Sailer ( .), Economic and Social History o f
Ancient Greece, : Chatto Windus, 1981 : Penguin,
1983 . Progress in Historiography, Daedalus 106 ( 1977), .
125-142. : C. Ampolo, Storie greche: La formazione della
moderna storiografia sugli antichi Gred, Topivo: Einaudi, 1997 A. Cameron
( .), History as Text The W riting o f Ancient History, : Routledge,
1986 P. Cartledge ( .), The Cambridge Illustrated History o f Ancient Greece,
: Cambridge University Press, 1997 J.T. Roberts, Sociology and the
Classical W orld, Arion (2000), . 99-133 F. Hartog, La storiografia fra
passato e presente, S. Settis ( .), I Greci, . II. 2, Storia-Cultura-ArteSocieta, Topivo: Einaudi, 1997, . 959-981 A.D. Momigliano, The Classical
Foundations o f Modern Historiography, : University o f California
Press, 1990 G.W. Bowersock T.J. Cornell ( .), Studies on Modern
Scholarship, : University o f California Press, 1994 N. Morley,
Writing Ancient History, : Duckworth, 1999, . I
(What is History?
Morley
, ,

73

) P. Veyne, Writing History, : Manchester University Press,


1984, ( : 197 1).
2. : R. Syme, How Gibbon Came to History
(1977) ( , . A.R. Birley), Roman Papers III,
: O xford University Press, 1984, . 969-976, . 971.
Syme
. : S. Walia, Edward Said and the Writing
o f History, : Icon, 2001.
3. Finley, Use and Abuse, .., . 75 .
Carr
Finley, ,
Finley, Jesus
1955, Carr
Trevelyan 1961.
-
. Finley (
- ), .
Carr,
, Finley .
4. , Carr
, ,
Trinity ,
, , (
.. Carr, What is History? ( 196 i 2 . R.W.
Davies, 1986 R.J. Evans), : Palgrave, 2001)
. .
R.J. Evans
; Carr, . xi,

(., , . 7) ,
, . xviii,
; Carr, . 81,
, . G. Hawthorn,
Plausible Worlds: Possibility and Understanding in History and the Social Sciences,
: Cambridge University Press, 1991, ,
,

74_____________________________________________________ ;

, ,
Hawthorn '
, , ,
. Carr
(Evans, Carr, What is History?, .., . xii, xviii)
(1.22.4)
, Carr
19 (R.J. Evans, In Defence o f History, :
Granta, 1997/2001 , . 164-165 . , . 35)
.
5.

, . S. James, The Content o f


Social Explanation, : Cambridge University Press, 1984
James, . C. Bird, The
Myth o f Liberal Individualism, : Cambridge University Press, 2001.
6. G.M. Trevelyan, English Social History, : Longmans,
Green & Co. Inc., 1942, . D. Cannadine, G.M. Trevelyan: A Life
in History, : Penguin, 1997* . Evans, In Defence o f
History, .a , . 163. ,
, . P. Cartledge, La Politics, S.
Settis ( .), I Greci, . I, Noi e I Greci, Topivo: Einaudi, 1996, . 39-75.
7. , ,

Roberto Calasso Literature and the Gods, : Vintage, 2001, . 173,
,

, .


, , R. Garland, Daily Life o f the Ancient Greeks, : Greenwood Press, 1998.
8. E.J. Hobsbawm, From Social History to the History
of Society (1972) ( ) On History, :
Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 1998, . 6, . 99. ,
,

( ) ( , . 109).
9. P. Burke, The French Historical Revolution: TheAnnales School 1929-1989,
: Polity Press, 1990-

75

. Lepetit ( .), Les formes de experience: Une autre histoire


socio/e, : Albin Michel, 1995, G.
Stedman Jones, Annales HSS (- 1998), . 383-394.
10. L.J. Griffin M. van der Linden ( .), New Methods for Social History,

International Review o f Social History, : Cambridge


University Press, 1999. :
L.J. Griffin M. van der Linden, .
L. Isaac, L. Christiansen, J. Miller T. Nickel,
:
- .
H.J. McCammon,
:

.
G. Deane, .. Beck S.E. Tolnay,
:
.
R. Franzosi, :

.
C.C. Ragin, .
C. Wetherell, .
L.J. Griffin R.R. Korstad,
- .

-
McCammon:
[...]

(. 35).
11. A. Wilson, Rethinking Social History: English Society 1750-1920, and its
Interpretation, : Manchester University Press, 1994.
12. reductio ad absurdum ( )

What is [social, and so on] History Today? ( [
...] ;) History Today,
Juliet Gardiner, What is History Today?,
: Macmillan, 1988 . Evans, In Defence o f History, .., . 170, 351. To

76

,
, - - .
13. P. Burke A. Briggs, A Social History o f the Media: From Gutenberg to
the Internet, ; Polity Press, 2001.
14. P. Stearns, Encyclopedia o f European Social History from 1350-2000 (6
), ; Scribners, 2001.
15.
.

, Times
Peter Laslett,
- , , laslett
. (
, ,
- ,
,
. J.G.A. Pocock
, Annabel Brett .)
, , Keith
Thomas, ,
.
King Alfred, ,
( ,
. C.M. Haydon).
16. . , . 36.
17. Finley, Progress in Historiography.
18. O P. Abrams, Historical Sociology, ; Open Books, 1982,
-
, Abrams,
. Frank Parkin
,
(Times Literary Supplement, 23 1982, . 801).
19. , () (-) : L.
Jordanova, History in Practice, : Edward Arnold, 2000, . 5' .
Pearson M. Shanks, Theatre/Archaeology, : Routledge, 2001,
. 4 1-44.
20. A.D. Momigliano, Time in Ancient Historiography, History & Theory,
Beiheft, ( ), 1966.

; _________________

77

21. P. Burke, The Renaissance Sense o f the Past, : Edward Arnold,


1969.
22. D.P. Henige, Oral Historiography, : Longman, 1982 M.
Herzfeld, The Poetics o f Manhood: Contest and Identity in a Cretan Mountain
Village, : Princeton University Press, 1985 . P. Burke,
Varieties o f Cultural History, : Polity Press, 1997, . 3:
- 1989
( )
- , Durkheim,
- ( , . 45-46).
23. T.W. Gallant, Modem Greece, : Edward Arnold, 2001, . 75'
5 19
20 . Gallant
, . Risk
and Survival in Ancient Greece: Reconstructing the Rural Domestic Economy,
: Polity Press, 19 9 1.
24. To P. Burke, Eyewitnessing: The Uses o f Images as Historical Evidence,
: Cornell University Press, 2001,
.
25. . (...)
26. : . Le Roy Ladurie, Le Territoire de historien,
: Gallimard, 1973, . 169-186 (Evenement et longue duree dans
histoire sociale: exemple chouan) ( . 1979) . Burke, The
French Historical Revolution, .., . 61-64.
,
,
, ,

27. W .G. Runciman, A Treatise on Social Theory, 3 , :


Cambridge University Press, 1983, 1989, 1997. Perry
Anderson, London Review o f Books, 6 1989, . 6, 2
.
Jordanova, History in Practice, .., ,
Evans, In Defence o f History, ..
28. : systacts. (...)
29. : ordinal. (...)
30.

78

, (. I, . 20)
.
31. : patrimonial states. (...)
32. P. Cartledge, Democratic Politics Ancient and Modern: From
Cleisthenes to Mary Robinson, Hermathena 166, ( 1999, 2000), .
5-29.
33. M. Midlarsky, The Evolution o f Inequality: War, State Survival and
Democracy in Comparative Perspective, : Stanford University Press : Cambridge University Press, 1999.
,

, , .
, . . Van Wees ( .), W ar and
Violence in Ancient Greece, : Duckworth, 2000
, . . Raaflaub R. Rosenstein ( .),
W ar and Society in the Ancient and Medieval Worlds, : Harvard
University Press, 1999, D.R. McCann B.S. Strauss ( .), W ar and
Democracy: A Comparative Study o f the Korean War and the Peloponnesian War,
: M.E. Sharpe, 2001.
34. O Midlarsky A.C. Renfrew,
Polity and Power: Interaction, Intensification and Exploitation, C.
Renfrew J.M. Wagstaff ( .), An Island Polity: The Archaeology o f Exploitation
on Melos, : Cambridge University Press, 1982,


- ,
.
35. Evans In Defence o f History, .., . 182, , Stearns,

. , .. Carr


( P. Cartledge) Evans ( , . 164165).
36. G. Levi, On Microhistory, P. Burke ( .), New Perspectives on
Historical Writing, : Polity Press, 1991, . 93-113. O P. Burke,
History and Social Theory, : Polity Press, 1993,
:

79

( ).
37. j.C.G. Rohl, Ordinary Germans as Hitlers Willing Executioners? The
Goldhagen Controversy, W . Lamont ( .), Historical Controversies and
Historians, : University College London Press, 1998, . 15-21- R.
Eaglestone, Postmodernism and Holocaust Denial, : Icon, 2001, . 3034- C. Browning, German Memory, Judicial Interrogation
and Historical Reconstruction: W riting Perpetrator History from Postwar
Testimony, S. Friedlander ( .), Probing the Limits o f Historical
Representation: Nazism and the "Final Solution , : Harvard University
Press, 1992, . 22-36 Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the
Final Solution in Poland ( .: 1992- : 1998), :
Penguin, 2001.
38. D. Goldhagen, Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the
Holocaust, : Alfred Knopf- : Little, Brown, 1996.
39. Jordanova, History in Practice, .., . 6- .
: History in Practice
-
. ,
(. 207).
40. , ,
( .
Miri Rubin ). ., , Burke, Varieties, ..
D.M. Friedman, A Mind
o f Its Own. A Cultural History o f the Penis, : The Free Press, 2001.
41. To Evans, In Defence o f History, .., . 6,
,

. 361-362,

.
42. Evans, , . 165-170 (
) 183-190.
1990
(.
162). J. Arnold, History: A Very Short Introduction, : Oxford
University Press, 2000, . 86,
Evans - -
: , [ ]
,
. J. Tosh, The Pursuit o f History:

Aims, Methods and New Directions in the Study o f Modem History (2 .),
: Longman, 1991, . 96 (3 .: 1999),


. . 209-217 (
). . Bentley ( .), Routledge
Companion to Historiography, : Routledge, 1997,

.
43. Cartledge, La Politica, ..
44. , , W.G.
Runciman Doomed to Extinction: The PoUs as an Evolutionary Dead-

End, O. Murray S. Price ( .), The Greek City from Homer to


Alexander, : Oxford University Press, 1990, . 347-367,
, ,
, , -
( ) - ( ): Cartledge, Democratic
Politics Ancient and Modern, .. To Runciman
Origins of States: The Case of Archaic Greece, Comparative Studies in
Society and History 24 (1982), . 351-377, .
45. G.E.M. de Ste. Croix, The
Class Struggle in the Ancient Greek World. From the Archaic Age to the Arab
Conquests, : Duckworth, 198 1,

.

3
;*
Susan Pedersen
,
.
,
, ,

.

,


.

,
, ,
.

, .
,



.
William Gienapp,

8 2 ^_______________________ __________ _______________


,
, 1960 1970,
,
.1 ,

. ,
,
,

. ,

.
,
,
. ,
, (North American
Conference on British Studies - NACBS),

,
,
, ,
, .


. ,

-
Susan Grayzel
'
, Michael Saler Frank

;___________________________________________83

Pick
,
Erika Rappaport

,

Emilia Dilke Kali Israel.2

,
.

,
,
.
,

,

.
Peter Mandler


.

,
. , ,
,
.
,
,

84

. ,
,
,
,



.
NACBS
, ,

- ,
-
, .

, ,
, .

,
. . ,

:
,


.


,

(
)
.

85


,
.
:
,
,
,
- _
,


.
,
-
1970-


.
- ,


,
.
,
,

, . ,
,


.

86


,
, , .

.


,
.
, ,
,



( ),

. ,

, (
)
.
,
.
,
, ,

(
),
Histoire du Parti Radical Serge Bernstein
. ,

;________________________________ ________ 87



,



20 .
, (

) ,
,
,
,
(, ,
) ,
-,
. ,
, ,
,
.
Namier,


,

.
, , , .



88

. , ,
,
Maurice Cowling ,
.
,
,

-
.
,
,
.

.


(
),
.
,
, 1983, Re
thinking Chartism Gareth Stedman Jones -
,
(
) (
)
.3
Stedman Jones

, ,
,

89


-
, - 19
.4 ,
,



,

. ,
D ror Wahrman ,





, lames Vernon
Patrick Joyce
19



.5
,

,

,
.

90

,
,
,

-
.6 ,
,
,
,
,

.7
,

,

.

,

-

.

.

,
Maurice Cowling
20

8 1885
.. Cooke John Vincent

91

,9 ( Cowling)
1832
,

,
.
Michael Bentley, Cowling ,
,

1867
10 Bentley
,
,

.11 ,

, -
Jonathan Parry-

.12 ,


.

.
, ,
: ,
()

.13 ,

,
Gareth Stedman Jones,

92


, ( )
Eugenio Biagini ( )
Parry .




, - (,
, )-
.14 ( , Eugenio Biagini,
, Liberty,
Retrenchment and Reform,

,
.15)
;
;


-
-
. ^

,
. ,
( )

,
,

93

,

. ,
, ,
John Foster,
, John Vincent,

.
Peter Clarke-

,


.16
.
Colin Matthew
,
, Boyd Hilton
,17
,

,
-
,
,

. , ,
,


,
.

94





, ,


.


.
, ,
,
. Catherine
Hall, 1992, John Vincent, 1966,

:
19 ,

,

.
:
.'

Vincent - Jon Lawrence Miles


Taylor
" (
)
-19
Formation o f the Liberal
Party

,

95

.
(
), Vincent
.


- -
-
.
.
consensus,
( )
1920 1930
,
, ,
, ,
,
.20
,
,

(
) ,
. ,


( ),

.
,
: , ,
Philip Williamson, Ross

96

McKibbin ,
, Alison Light Susan
Kingsley Kent
,

,
"
.21
, , Williamson
,
McKibbin - -
,
, :


. ,
Williamson,
.22 ,
(
)

,

-, ,
,
,

.

;____________________________________

97

;

..

,
,

.
,

, ,
,

.

,

John Foster

.
. ,




,


.
. ,

9 8 ___________________________________________ _______ ;

,
,
- . ,

, ,
.
,
.
, ;

,


.

.
,
, ; ,
, ,
,
.23
, ,
.
,

/ /- ,

.

. ,

;____________________________________

__ 9?


(

),
( , ,
)
- xqc So^C.
.


,

,
. ,
,
,
, -

,


. , ,
:




.


, -

10 0 ____________________________________

________

,
, -
. ,

,
.
,
, , ( )
,

(
)
( )
, .
, ,
, ^

, .
,
, , ^^ .
, ,
,

(
)
. ,

.

,
,

,
.
, ,

( ),


xou
.
,

.

,
Structure o f Politics Lewis Namier Treasury Control
Samuel Beer, ,
,
(

)
.24



,
:
, ^

. ,
19
18 , -
Stedman Jones -
-

102

.
,
( )
:
( ..
Thompson) [...]
,
18
.25 , 18
,
, John Brewer Thomas Ertman,
- - .

(
),

, . ,


, ,
, (
)
(
).26



, ,


. , ^
,
. -

;__________________________________________103

, , ,
,
-
18
.

20 ,



.27 ,

.

,


- ,

-

,
.28 ,
:

,

,
.29
. ,
,
,
20 ,

J04

_____________

________________________________ ;

, ,


.


( ,
,
),

.30 , ,
()
,
.
,
, ,



.
,

,
.
,

' .
,

,
. ,

105

Landscape for a Good Woman, Carolyn Steedman





,
,
,
.31 ,
,
'
,
Ina Zweiniger-Bargielowska
: ,
,
,

.32 , ,




.
, ,
. ^^
,

-
- .


106

( )

,

-

. ,
1945,
.
,

,
. ,

,


.33

Ill

-


-




. ,

;__________________________________________ 107

,
.
<S
S
a!fc=-_- ........"" " '
1960
1970
-
.
,



.
,
,
.

,
.
- -

- ,

;
,


,


,

.

108

:
, Imperial Meridian C.A. Bayly,
British Imperialism Peter Cain Anthony Hopkins
Colonial Masculinity Mrinalini Sinha
.34
,
-

,
( )
- .
, Sinha -
-
. ,
,



.35
,
1970,

,

.
, ,

-
,
.

;_______________________ __________________ 109


. ,

,

,

, .

,
-



..
,

,
,


.
.

,

.

Thomas Ertman, Peter Mandler,

Robert Travers Philip Williamson


, Jeremy Knowles,
.
1. William Gienapp, The Myth o f Class in Jacksonian America, Journal of
Policy History 6.2 (1994), a 232-239, 277-281.
2. Susan R. Grayzel, Womens Identities at War: Gender, Motherhood and
Politics in Britain and France during the First World War, : University
of N orth Carolina Press, 1999- Michael T. Saler, The Avant-Garde in Interwar
England: Medieval Modernism and the London Underground, ; Oxford
University Press, 1999 Erika Rappaport, Shopping for Pleasure: Women in the
Making o f Londons West End, : Princeton University Press, 2000 Kali
Israel, Names and Stories: Emilia Dilke and Victorian Culture, : Oxford
University Press, 1999.
3. Gareth Stedman Jones, Rethinking Chartism, Lan
guages o f Class: Studies in English Working Class History, 1832-1982, :
Cambridge University Press, 1983, . 90-178.
4. , . Eugenio Biagini
Alastair Reid, Currents o f radicalism, 1850-1914,
Currents o f Radicalism: Popular Radicalism, Organised Labour and Party Politics in
Britain, 1850-1914, : Cambridge University Press, 1991, . 1-19
, , Miles Taylor, The Decline o f British Radicalism, 184 71860, : Clarendon Press, 1995 Jon Lawrence, Speaking for the
People: Party, Language and Popular Politics in England, 1867-1914, :
Cambridge University Press, 1998 Eugenio Biagini, Libert, Retrenchment and
Reform: Popular Liberalism in the Age o f Gladstone, 1860-1880, :
Cambridge University Press, 1992.
5. D ro r Wahrman, Imagining the Middle Class: The Political Representation of
Class in Britain, c. 1780-1840, : Cambridge University Press, 1995Patrick Joyce, Visions o f the People: Industrial England and the Question o f Class,
1840-1914, : Cambridge University Press, 1991 James Vernon,

;________________________________________ I I I

Politics and the People: A Study in English Political Culture, c. I8 IS -I8 6 7 , :


Cambridge U niversity Press, 1993.
6. To - Leonore Davidoff Catherine Hall, Family
Fortunes: Men and Women o f the English Middle Class, 1780-1850, :
University of Chicago Press, 1987. Oi Anna Clark Sonya Rose
, , : . Anna Clark,
The Struggle for the Breeches: Gender and the Making o f the British Working Class,
: University of California Press, 1995 Sonya Rose, Limited Livelihoods:
Gender and Class in Nineteenth-Century England, : University of
California Press, 1992.
7.
.
Barbara Taylor, Eve and the New Jerusalem:
Socialism and Feminism in the Nineteenth Century, : Pantheon Books,
1983 , . K.D. Reynolds, Aristocratic
Women and Political Society in Victorian Britain, : Clarendon Press,
1998. To ,
,
.
, Patricia Hollis, Ladies
Beet: Women in English Local Government, 1865-1914, : Clarendon
Press, 1987,
20
.
, ' .
Susan Grayzel, Women's Identities at W ar Susan Kingsley Kent, Making
Peace: The Reconstruction o f Gender in Interwar Britain, : Princeton
University Press, 1993.
8. Maurice Cowling, The Impact o f Labour, 1920-1924: The Beginning o f
Modem British Politics, : Cambridge University Press, 1971, . 3.
9. ,



. Cooke Vincent, The Governing Passion: Cabinet Government and
Party Politics in Britain, 1885-86, : Harvester Press, 1974, . 21.
10. Michael Bentley, Politics, Doctrine and Thought, Michael
Bentley John Stevenson ( .), High and Low Politics in Modem Britain,
: Clarendon Press, 1983, a. 130.

11. . Michael Bentley,


Public and Private Doctrine: Essays in British History Presented to Maurice Cowling,
: Cambridge University Press, 1993, ,
Bentley, Lord Salisbury's World: Conservative
Environments in Late-Victorian Britain, : Cambridge University Press,

2001.
12. Jonathan Parry, Democracy and Religion: Gladstone and the Liberal Party,
186 7-1875, : Cambridge University Press, 1986, . 3.
13. ,

. , ,
Stedman Jones
,

,

20 . . Gareth

Stedman Jones, Anglo-Marxism, Neo-Marxism and the Discursive Approach


to History, A lf Liidtke ( .), Was bliebt von marxistichen Perspektiven in
der Geschichtsforschung?, : Max-Planck-lnstitut fCir Geschichte/
Wallstein Verlag, 1997, . 194, 197, 205.
14. Biagini Reid, Currents o f Radicalism, ..,

(. 3)
, Miles Taylor -

(The Decline o f British Radicalism, .., . 3). O Jonathan Parry,
,
I960
(Parry,
Democracy and Religion, .., . I -2).
15. Biagini, Liberty, Retrenchment and Reform, .., a. 6-7.
16. John Foster, Class Struggle and the Industrial Revolution: Early Industrial
Capitalism in Three English Towns, : Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1974
John Vincent, The Formation o f the Liberal Party, 1857-1868, :
Constable, 1966 Peter Clarke, Lancashire and the New Liberalism, :
Cambridge University Press, 19 7 1.
17. H.C.G. Matthew, Gladstone, 1809-1874, : Clarendon Press,
1986, . 5 Boyd Hilton, The Age o f Atonement The Influence o f

;_________________________________ _________113

Evangelicalism on Social and Economic Thought, 1785-1865, :


Clarendon Press, 1988, 9.
Peter
Mandler, The Strange Birth o f Liberal England: Conservative Origins o f the LaissezFaire State, 1780-1860, Harvard University Center for European Studies
W orking Paper Series no. 19 ( , 1989), Pat Thane, Government
and Society in England and Wales, 1750-1914, F.M.L. Thompson ( .),
The Cambridge Social History o f Britain, 1750-1950, . I, Social Agencies and
Institutions, : Cambridge University Press, 1990, . 1-61.
18. Vincent, The Formation o f the Liberal Party, .., o. xiv, xiii. H Catherine
Hall ,

: . Competing Masculinities:

Thomas Carlyle, John Start Mill and the Case of Governor Eyre,
Male and Middle Class: Explorations in Feminism and History, :
Routledge, 1992, . 255-295.
19. Jon Lawrence Miles Taylor, Introduction: Electoral Sociology and
the Historians, Jon Lawrence Miles Taylor ( .), Party, State and
Society: Electoral Behaviour in Britain since 1820, : Scolar Press, 1997,
a. 2.
20. , . Bill Schwarz, The Language of
Constitutionalism: Baldwinite Conservatism, Formations o f
Nation and People, : Routledge, 1984, . 1-18.
21. Philip Williamson, Stanley Baldwin: Conservative Leadership and National
Values, : Cambridge University Press, 1999 Ross McKibbin, Class
and Conventional W isdom: The Conservative Party and the Public in Inter
w ar Britain, Ideologies o f Class: Social Relations in Britain, 18801950, : Clarendon Press, 1990, o. 259-293 Susan Kent, Making
Peace Alison Light, Forwer England: Feminity, Literature and Conservatism
Between the Wars, : Routledge, 1991.
22. Williamson, Stanley Baldwin, .., . 350-357.
23. Max W eber, Politics as a Vocation, H.H. Gerth C. W right
Mills ( .). From M ax Weber: Essays in Sociology, : Oxford
University Press, 1946, . 77-79.
24. Lewis B. Namier, The Structure o f Politics at the Accession o f George III,
: Macmillan, 1929 Samuel H. Beer, Treasury Control: The Co-ordination
o f Financial and Economic Policy in Great Britain, : Clarendon Press,
1956.
25. E.P. Thompson, Eighteenth-Century English Society. Class Struggle
W ith o u t Class?, Social History 3 (1978), . 141 Philip

Harling, The Waning o f Old Corruption": The Politics o f Economical Reform in


Britain, 1779-1846, : Clarendon Press, 1996.
26. John Brewer, The Sinews o f Power: War, Money and the English State,
1688-1783, : Alfred Knopf, 1988 Thomas C. Ertman, Birth o f the
Leviathan: Building States and Regimes in Medieval and Early Modern Europe,
: Cambridge University Press, 1997.
27. :
. History o f Sexuality, . I, An Introduction, : Vintage, 1980,
[. .: , . I, . ,
: ].
28. ., , Maurice Bruce, The Coming o f the Welfare State,
: B.T. Batsford, 19 6 1 Derek Fraser, The Evolution o f the British Welfare
State (1973) (2 ., : Macmillan, 1984). , Pat Thane
, (
Brewer) The Foundations o f the Welfare
State, : Longman, 1982.
29. To ..
Marshall, 1949, Citizenship and Social Class,
Class, Citizenship and Social Development, :
Doubleday, 1964, . 7 1- 134.
30. , . Family, Dependence,
and the Origins o f the Welfare State: Britain and France, 1914-1945, :
Cambridge University Press, 1993.
3 1. Carolyn Kay Steedman, Landscape for a Good Woman: A Story o f Two
Lives, : Rutgers University Press, 1986, 1987,
. 29-30, 121-124.
32. Ina Zweiniger-Bargielowska, Austerity in Britain: Rationing, Consumption
and Controls, 1939-1955, : Oxford University Press, 2000.
33. . R.J. Overy, W ar and Economy in the Third Reich,
: Clarendon Press, 1994, 9.
34. C.A. Bayly, Imperial Meridian: The British Empire and the World, 17801830, : Longman, 1989 P.J. Cain A.G. Hopkins, British Imperialism,
2 , : Longman, 1993 Mrinalini Sinha, Colonial Masculinity: The
Manly Englishman and the "Effeminate Bengali in the Late Nineteenth Century,
: Manchester University Press, 1995.
35. Mrinalini Sinha, Britishness, Clubbability, and the Colonial Public
Sphere: The Genealogy of an Imperial Institution in Colonial India, Journal o f
British Studies 40 ( 2001), . 491, 521.

4
;
Olwen Hufton

, |
- , ,

1950

Geoffrey Elton. ,

-cuius regio eius religio-

,
.
-
, , ,
Renier

.

. ,
,
Lambeth Palace David Knowles
,


. , Tawney


.
, .
,
, ,

Annales, ,
,
. ,

.

I960 1970,
. ,
Annales
, malgre Lucien
Febvre,
mentalites. ,
,
, .

I960, , ,
(
, ) ,
.
: ,
.
,
, ,

ZHMEPA;

117

.
.
. ,
, .

Archivium Historicum Sodetatis,
, .
, , Schurhammer, Rahner,
Tacchi Venturi, ,
.
,


,
. ,
, Michelet, , ,
,
, Aulard Mathiez.
,
.
,
,

.
,
. , ,
. , ,
,
.
,

.
, , ,
.

, ,
.

:
-
(
).
, ,
,
20 .
(, ),
.
^
, , .
1980
.
,

I

,
,
. , -

; ___ _____________________ _________L1?

,

.
.
Annales,
histoire serielle (
)
histoire des mentalites.
- 0 ,

,
doctorat es
lettres.
,

.
Lawre nee Stone
.1

.

-
- Berthelot du Chesnay,
. ,

17 Jean Eudes.
, Gabriel Le
Bras. Le Bras, 1930,

.
-

,
.
, ,
. ( ,
,

.)
Le Bras 1950,

. ,
. Etudes de sociologie religieuse2
.,
histoire serielle, , ,


.
.
,
,
.
,
, ,
.

, nous des Annales,
histoire serielle mentalites.
, ( )
~
,

;_____________________________________ 121

. ,
16 (

) ,
.

. ,

; Le Bras

.

.
. croyant/pratiquant,
,
,


. conformisme saisonniere,

,
,
.
.


,
Le Bras pratiquant
, -

122________________________ __________________ ________ ;

.
1950,
, , ...

.

19
20 , '
' .
. ,
,
,
.
,
.
Le dimorphisme sessuel
. ,
,
avant le mot, Le Bras .

,
,
,
.
,

non pratiquants 8%
,

.
. ,
, ^
1790

123

.


, -

- 19


.

,

. ,
,

. .
Berthelot du Chesnay

.
20


.
947
^ . .

(1905)
,
.

.

124

Le Bras,
. histoire serielle
mentalites:
. ,
Gerard Cholvy ,3

. ,
, ,

.4

; Le Bras


.

;
, ,
.

,
1960
, Lawrence Stone,5
Philippe Aries6 Jean Louis Flandrin,
.
.
-histoire serielle-
,
. ,
,

125

.

,
.
.
,
, . Jean Louis
Flandrin

. . }
, Lawrence Stone, 18
( ),
, .

,


.
16 ,
,

.

(
),
-
( 1%),
17 .
18
. ,
17
- ,

126

, ...
.


,
,


, .
.

II

1970 -
,8
, ,


20 .9

-, ,

- :
.
, ,


.

127



;. Emmanuel Le
Roy Ladurie Montaillou: Cathars and Catholics in a French
Village, 1294-1324,10
, 14 ,
.
, 13 , .

. ,
.
,
,
, (
) .
,
,..
,
. ,
,

.
,
.
Jean
Delumeau. .11
,
, Sin and Fear ( 1983). To 16
Annales
.

128

, 1977,

. To Sin and Fear, , .
. ,


.
16 [ - -
]
;. (
) :
( )
.
,
, ,
. , .
, Delumeau,
. ,
Delumeau


, .
, .
(...)
,
.

,
( )
. promotion
catholique,

. ,
,

. ,


: ,

, , ,

.


.


,
-
.
,

, .. Delumeau


- -
. ,
Delumeau ,
.
,
.

130

Delumeau,
'
.
Stone Flandrin
,
,
Delumeau

.
, , ,

. ,
,
.

. (
) ,
,

-
Delumeau.
, .
, doctorat es lettres
-
-, P/ete baroque et dechristianisation Michel Vovelle.12 O Vovelle (
)
(
histoire serielle),
.

131

.
ars moriendi.


. , , ...
, (
)
,
,
.
,
.
Vovelle,
doctorat es lettres .
, ,
18 ,
, -

1770 .
/

. ,
,
. Vovelle
,
( ),

. ,
,

132_______________ _______________ ________________

Pierre Chaunu13
.
Vovelle
. ,
Le
Bras ,

,
. .
Vovelle
Daniel Roche
. Vovelle

, ,
, .
Vovelle
.
Vovelle

. . Sam Cohn,
Death and Property in Siena, 1205-1800: Strategies for the
Afterlife,14 Vovelle
,
,

erede universalis.
, Vovelle
. Cohn
,
,

133

. ,
, 15
,
16 17
.
( , ,

.)

Vovelle,
.
,


,
.
, 16
Carlos Eire

. 15

III
,

, (
) -

. , ,

,
,

134________________

_____________________________ ;

. ,
.

,

.

.

. ,
16

autoconsienza
.


.
.
.
, ,

.
Margaret Spufford

.17 , ,
.
,
I960
1970.

135

, Tjflfiui. -,,
,
,
.
, / ;
,

,
. .
KiYrtu a m .a in jm fo n J S ^
, xa^noypaffifiiq.
.
,
,
. , ^
, ,

. ,
12 ,
-.
.
.
,
,


. ^
,

136


. , [1 1(4)]
[31] . , ,
,
/
- ,

.
,

. ;
; ; 20

,

,

, ,
. :

;
, ,
,

.

, .

;
.

137

,18

- -,
. ,
,

.
.
-ac u^rvocjotLEunopiou ,

,
. ,

,
.
,
,
.19
,
.
sanctuaires repit

limbo.20 ;
;
, ; ,,
^

ytjjrgono^
.

138

,
... -

. <^|^
Le Bras ,
8_5 6><;.
.

,
.
.
,

.
,
, .
,
.
,

.
;21


;
^ ^ ^ ^ ^
, iWYJtojaEfmoytiBSXt
, , t mv , ,
. Le Bras
,
1990

139

,
,
.
', ! . ^,,,^,
ogi
,
,22
,
.

Eamonn Duffy
The Stripping o f the Altars,23

.

,
.
,
,
1970.24



.
, , ,
, ,

, -
,

- -

,

140

___________________________________________ ;



.
.
,
,

, .

IV


20 - ^5-301:! >_
, .
,
,

. ,
,
frontieres de catholicite,
.

.
,
,
,
,
.

;___

______ ________ ___________

.
- ,
, 16
19 .
.
1528, , , , (
) ,

16 .
,
.
.
19 20 ,
, .
, ,
.
,
-,
.

,
. ,
,
(1992) Carlo Ginzburg.15 ,


,
,

142

.

.



,
.
16 ,
. ,

,
Francis Xavier Schurhammer26

. Memory Palace o f Matteo
Ricci Spence27
20 .


,
. ,
,


.
,
,
-
,
, -
,

.

143

,

,
.

, - piscatio ( )
( )-
.
, ,
.
,
.
:
.

;


.


, , ,

,

.
, ,


,
, .

200

144________________________________ ___________________ ;

,
,

. , ,
,
,
,
. , ,
,
.

.
-,
.
, ,
tout court,

.
,

.
,

,
.
, Wolfgang
Reinhard28

. , Maria
Antonietta Visceglia29

.

145



. Renata Ago
.30
16
, Ago

,
.
( giochi di scuadra
),
,

. ,

,
, , ,
- -

.

,
.

, - -

.
Ago

:
,

146

___________________ ____

__

___

, , ,
( )

. ,
, ,
,
.

V
,
Le Bras
.
en masse 18 ,

.

-


,
.

,
. ^-
^
^ ^ ^ ^ 5 < 5 5 ^ , JBUiDJBX*'

^ ^
.

147


, .

.


.
,

. ,
,

. ,



.31

.
19
, ,
. 220.000
1870,
.
,
Ruth Harris,32 33
, 19
, ( )
.
** I


- (

----- -r n ._T .l
,, '" "" ............... II 1-1

(:,^^5^^^^.^,<^;^^\^,.,>:(~
.

148

19 ,

.


.34 ,
,
20 . ,

.
; .
, ,
1920 ,

. 1995, Martine Sevregard
L amour en toute lettre Les enfants du Bon Dieu,
, ,
,

.


1990 1920.
-
-



. ,
1970 ,

.

149


,


status quo. ,
,

,
.
21
,

,
Marianne Elliott.35 ,

.
21 ,

. , ,

, , ,
,
.


1. L. Stone, The Family, Sex and Marriage in England 1570-1640 ( .), : 1979.
2. G. Le Bras, Etudes de sociologie religieuse, t. I, Sociologie de la pratique
religieuse dans les compagnes francaises, : 1955.
3. G. Cholvy, Histoire du diocese de Montpellier, : 1976.

150

4. L. Perouas, Le diocese de la Rochelle 1648-1724. Sociologie et pastorale,


: 1964.
5. Stone, The Family, Sex and Marriage in England, ..
6. P. Aries, Centuries o f Childhood: A Social History o f Family Life, :
1962.
7. J.L. Flandrin, Families in Former Times: Kinship, Household and Sexuality,
: 1979.
8. R. Po-Chia Hsia, Social Discipline in the Reformation: Central Europe, 15501700, : 1989 The World o f Catholic Renewal 1540-1700, :
1998.
9. H. Schilling, Chiese confessionali e disciplinamento sociale. Un bilancio
prowisoria della riserca storica, P. Prodi ( .), Disciplina dell anima,
disciplina del corpo e disciplina della sodeta tra medievo e eta moderna, :
1994, . 125-160" A. Prosperi, Tribunali della concienza: Inquisitori, confessori,
missionary, Topivo: 1996.
10. E. Le Roy Ladurie, Montaillou: Cathars and Catholics in a French Village
1294-1324, : 1980.
I I . J. Delumeau, La Vie economique et sociale de Rome dans la seconde moitie
du XVIe siecle, 2 , : 1957-1959 Catholicism between Luther and
Voltaire, : 1977 Sin and Fear: The Emergence o f a Western Guilt Culture,
: 1990 ( . : 1983) Rassurer et proteger. Le
sentiment de securite dans /' Occident d autrefois, : 1989.
12. M. Vovelle, Piete baroque et dechristianisation en Provence 1750-1820,
: 1973.
13. P. Chaunu, La M ort a Paris XVI, XVII et XVIII siecles, : 1978.
14. S.K. Cohn, Death and Property in Siena, 1205-1800: Strategies for the
Afterlife, : 1988.
15. C. Eire, From Madrid to Purgatory: The Art and Craft o f Dying in Sixteenth
Century Spain, : 1995.
16. L. Scarrafia G. Zarri ( .), Women and Faith, /: 1999.
17. M. Spufford, Contrasting Communities: English Villagers in the 16th and
17th Centuries, : 1974
18. C.W. Bynum, Holy Feast and Holy Fast The Religious Significance o f Food
to Medieval Women, : 1987 R. Bell, Holy Anorexia, : 1995.
19. L. Scarrafia, La santa degli impossibili. Vicende e significati della devozione
a Santa Rita, Topivo: 1990.
20. O. Hufton, The Prospect Before Her: A History o f Women in Western
Europe 1500-1800, : 1995.

;___ _____________

_________________151

2 1. L. Roper, Oedipus and the Devil: Witchcraft, Sexuality and Religion in Early
Modern Europe, : 1994.
22. . (...)
23. E. Duffy, The Stripping o f the Altars: Traditional Religion in England 14001580, : 1992.
24. C. Geerz, The Interpretation o f Cultures, : 1973.
25. C. Ginzburg, The Cheese and the Worms, : 1992.
26. G. Schurhammer, Francis Xavier: His Life and Times, 4 , :
1982.
27. J. Spence, The Memory Palace o f Matteo Ricci, : 1984.
28. W . Reinhard, Papstfmanz und Nepotismus unter Paul V (1605-1621),
: 1974.
29. M.A. Visceglia, Ceremoniale romani: il ritorno e la trasfigutazione dei
trionfi antichi, L. Fiorini A. Prosperi ( .), Roma la citta del papa,
Topivo: 2000.
30. R. Ago, Carriere e clientele nella Roma barocca, : 1990.
3 1 .0 . Hufton, Women and the Limits o f Citizenship in the French Revolution,
. 2 3, : 1992.
32. R. Harris, Lourdes: Body and Spirit in the Secular Age, : 1999.
33. D. Blackbourn, The Marpingen Visions: Rationalism, Religion and the Rise
o f Modern Germany, : 1995.
34. S.J.D. Green, Religion in the Age o f Decline: Organisation and Experience
in Industrial Yorkshire, 1870-1920, : 1996 J. Morris, Religion and Urban
Change: Croydon, 1840-1914, : 1992.
35. M. Elliott, The Catholics o f Ulster: A History, : 2000.

Baroja, J.C., Las formas complejas de la vida religiosa. Religion, sociedad, y


caracter en las Espana de los siglos XVI y XVII, : 1978.
Bell, R. Saints and Society. The Two Worlds o f Western Christendom, :
1982!
Berthelot du Chesnay, Les missions de Saint Jean d Eudes, : 1967.
Burke, P. H ow to be a Counter-Reform ation saint, K. von
G reyerrs ( .), Religion and Society in Early Modem Europe 15001800, : 1984, . 7 1-83.
Chatelier, L., Tradition chretienne et renouveau catholique dans le cadre de /
ancient diocese de Strasbourg ( 1650-1770), : 19 8 1.

152

Cholvy, G., Hilaire, ., Histoire religieuse de la France contemporaine,


: 1989.
Christian, W .A., Local Religion in Sixteenth Century Spain, : 1981.
Cousin, B., Le miracle et le quotidien. Les ex voto provengaux. Images d' une
societe, : 1983.
Gentilcore, D., Adapt Yourself to the Peoples Capabilities: Methods and
Impact in the Kingdom o f Naples,

16 0 0 -1800, Journal o f

Ecclesiastical History 45 (1994), . 269-296.


Hufton, O., Bayeux in the Late Bghteenth Century, : 1967.
Hufton, O., The French Church, crco W.J. Callahan D. Higgs ( .),
Church and Society in Catholic Europe in the Eighteenth Century,
: 1979, . 13-33.
Hufton, O., The Reconstruction o f a Church 1796-1801, G. Lewis
C. Lucas ( .), Beyond the Terror, : 1981, . 21-53.
Hufton, O., W hatever Happened to the H istory o f the Nun?, Royal
Holloway College Hayes Robinson Lecture, 2000.
Langlois, C., Le catholicisme au feminin: Les congregations a superieure
generate au X IXe siecle, : 1984.
Le Bras, G., Etudes de sociologie religieuse, . II, De la morphologie a la
typologie, : 1956.
MacCulloch, D., Thomas Cranmer: A Life, : 1998.
Peris, N., La religion populaire, mythes et realites. L exemple de la
France sous ancien regime, Colloques Internationaux du Centre
National de la Recherche Scientifique, : 1979, . 2 2 1-228.
Prodi, P., Lo sviluppo dell assolutismo nello Stato Pontifido. I, La monorchia
papale e gli organi centrali di governo, : 1968.
Prodi, P., The Papal Prince: One Body and Two Souls. The Papal Monarchy in
Early Modern Europe, : 1987.
Queniart, J., Les hommes, I eglise et Dieu dans la France du XVIII siecle,
: 1978.
Rahner, H., Ignatius Loyola: Letters to Women, : 1967.
Rahner, H., Ignatius the Theologian, : 1968.
Safley, T.M., Let No Man Put Asunder: The Control o f Marriage in the German
Southwest A Comparative Study 1550-60, : 1984.
Scattigno, A., Jeanne de Chantal: la fondatrice, G. Calvi ( .),
Barocco al femminile, : 19 9 1.
Schmitt, T.J., L' Organisation ecclesiastique et la pratique religieuse dans
Iarchidiacone dAutun, : 1957.

153

Schultze, W ., II concetto di disciplinamento sociale nel prima eta


moderna, Annali dell Istituto italo-germanico di Trento, x. 18, . 3 7 1411.
Scribner, R.W., Ritual and Popular Religion at the tim e o f the
Reformation, Journal o f Ecclesiastical History 35 ( 1984), . 49-77.
Tacchi-Venturi, P., Storia della compagnia di GesCi in Italia, 3 , :
1922-1938.
Venard, M., Reforme protestante, reforme catholique dans la province d
Avignon au XVIe siecle, : 1993.
Vovelle, M., Religion et Revolution. La dechristianisation de fan II, :
1976.
Vovelle, M., La Revolution contre IEglise: De la raison a IEtre Supreme,
: 1989.
Z arri, G., From Prophecy to Discipline 1450-1650, L. Scaraffia
G. Z a rri ( .), Women and Faith, /: 1999.

5
;*
Miri Rubin
Culture: The Anthropologists Account, Adam Kuper

, .1
konjo c ,
.
,

,
.2 ,
, ,


1970 1980, ,
,
,
. ,
-
, 1960 1970-


.

156

I
qj<
,
.
18 19
,

,
- KQijmc
.. onoi'ec *
, 9e<oppjftg_Q..EHjCaiX.
,

/ , / , /,

. ,
,
,3
- -,4
,
.
,
,

.
- -

. ,

157

,
:
,
, .
,
.5
,

,
,
-, -
.
,
.
;
;.
,
.. Carr,
.
, .. Carr
,
. ,
Bildung6

,
,
.
, ,


.
- - ,

158


.

, ,
20 ,
. ,

, ,

.
,
Ecole Pratique des Hautes Etudes
.
, Marc Bloch
Lucien Febvre, ,
,
,
- ,
, , ,

,
. Bloch Febvre

- Henri Pirenne,
, Annales
histoire economique et sociale, , Bloch,

1945
.7

, , , , ,
, ,

;___________

____

___________

_____ 159

, ,
.
,
, . ,
, evenement structure, histoire
toute courte histoire-probleme.s ,
,
,
histoire totale,
, .


.


- / histoire serielle- 9
, , ,
.10


.
;

;
,

. mentalites, representations
collectives , ,
, , .11
, 1968 , Annalistes

. , Maison des Sciences de

160

Homme, , -
, , Emile Benveniste,

.
Annalistes apvotivxqv ,



. , ,
,
,
, ,
1970,
.
,
- ,
- -
.

II

.
, ,
,12 ^
.
,
,
, ,
,

.

; ______

___________________________ 161

, .

,
.
, ,
, : ,
, , , .13
, , ,
,
.

: ,

;
, " ^.
, - -
, .
,

.

, ,
; droit de
cuissage 16

19 .14
; ,


16 17 .15
, ^
.

162

,
,
.
14
, ,
,
,

- ,
. 16 ,

.16

, ,
,
.17

,

1970 1980: ,
,
, , .

:
, ,

.
:
, . ,

163



.
, ,
,
, .18

.


. -
, -,
,
,
19, 1970
.
KsyapiKc frvQiee ^|<<>- .
. , ,
, .

,
, ,
,
,
.

:

, Roman de la rose, -
.20



,
.
,
.

,
. , ,

. Caroline
Bynum
(, ) .21 4 * --;
.22 2
, 1399,
,
, ,
.
,

, . ,
, ,

.
,
,
^ -, , -
- -
^: .

' ;______________________________________165


,
,

, , , .

,
: Carlo Ginzburg
,
400 - Natalie Davis
mis-en-scene

, 16 23 , Ruth
Harris
,
.24

Ill
,
5 ,
.

. , ,

.
,
,

.
,

166_______________

________________ _________________ ;

-
-


, .
-
Mary Douglas Victor Turner,25

, ,
,
.
6 ,
Clifford Geertz,
: , ,
.
,
,
: Geertz
,
, 27 -

, ,
,
.


, ,
:
,

.
Durkheim,

;_______________________________________ 167

,
, ,

:

.
,
28 ,

, -
, ,
-
.
,
,
(895-975)
. , ,
,
.29 \
-
1579-1580,
,

.30
,
6

, 17 .31
,
20

, .

- -
,
,
.

IV

1960 -
Keith Thomas Natalie Davis- ,
1980,
,
.



. ,
, ,

, ,

.
James Clifford George . Marcus 1982, Writing
Culture, .
Montaillou, Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, The
Nuer, E.E. Evans-Pritchard, o Renato Rosaldo
. , Vincent
Crapanzano

;_____________________________ _________ 169


.32
,

.

?
:
Tanya
Luhrmann,
Ray Raphael Claudine Fabre-Vassas

, .33

. ,
,


16
.
,

, , .
, .34
.35
,

,
.
:
, 1644

170

.

:

;.36 ,
: ,
.


;
,
;
1644
; -
-
,


.37


, Marshall Sahlins. Sahlins
,

.

- , . ,
, .

-, , -

;.............

........................................ .........

171

,38
.
,
,
,
, .
, Sahlins



. ,
,


. Sahlins
: -
, ,
.
, ,

,
.39 ,

, Kqi
.40

V

, ,

172

__

__ _______________________________________

.
,
41
,42 ,
.
,

,

,
. Stephen Greenblatt,

Clifford Geertz,


(;) - ,
, .43

: Englands Empty
Throne Paul Strohm

:
,

,

,

4 .44


- -

;_______________

____ _______

173

,
, ,
. Paul Strohm,

:45
,

,


.
oeuvre ,
.

, ,
,
,
.
,
.
,
,
,

- ,
, . -
,
.
,
-

174

.46

.

, , -

.
- .
, .47
- -
.

Christopher Clark, David Feldman,

Eric Foner, Adam I.P. Smith, Naomi Tadmor Miles Taylor


, Peter Burke Gareth Stedman Jones,
.
1. [ : culture. culture
, , civilization . (..)]
, : Harvard University Press, 2000, . .

, . William . Sewell, The Concept(s) o f Culture, Victoria E.


Bonnell Lynn Hunt ( ,), Beyond the Cultural Turn: New Directions in the
Study o f Society and Culture, : University o f California Press, 1999, .

3S-61.
2. Lynn Hunt ( .), The New Cultural History, : University o f
California Press, 1989 Bonnell Hunt, Beyond the Cultural Turn, ..
3. Nicholas Watson, The Politics of Middle English Writing, Jocelyn
Wogan-Browne, Nicholas Watson, Andrew Taylor Ruth Evans ( .), The

175

Idea o f the Vernacular: An Anthology o f Middle English Literary Theory, 1280-1520,


: Penn State Press, 1999, a. 331-352.
4. Jean-Claude Schmitt, The Holy Greyhound: Guinefort, Healer o f Children
since the Thirteenth Century, . Martin Thom, : Cambridge
University Press, 1982 (Le saint levrier: Guinefort, guirisseur d' enfants depuis le
X llle siecle, : Flammarion, 1979).
5.
, . Gabrielle .
Spiegel, The Past as Text The Theory and Practice o f Medieval Historiography,
: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1997' Brian Stock, Listening for the
Texts: On the Uses o f the Past, : Johns Hopkins University Press,
1990' , Paul Strohm Theory and the Pre-modern
Text, : University of Minnesota Press, 2000.
, . Lyndal Roper, Oedipus and the Devil: Witchcraft, Sexuality and
Religion in Early Modern Europe, : Routledge, 1994.
6. . (...)
7. Annales, .
Carole Fink, Marc Bloch: A Life in History, : Cambridge University
Press, 1989, . 128-165 . Peter Schottler ( .), Marc Bloch:
Historiker und Widerstand-Kampfer, : Campus, 1999.
8.
. Acton,
1895,
John Edward Emerich Acton, The Study of History, John
Neville Figgis Reginald Vere Laurence ( .), Lectures on Modern History,
: Macmillan, 1906, . 24.
9. Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, The
peasants o f Languedoc, . John Day, : University of Illinois Press,
1976 (Les Paysants de Languedoc, 2 , : SEVPEN, 1966)
, . Jean-Yves Grenier, Bernard Lepetit ( .), Les Formes de
experience: une autre histoire sociale, : Albin Michel, 1995, . 227-228
, . G. Stedman Jones, Une autre
histoire sociale? (note critique), Annales HSS Llll (1998), . 383-394.
10. Philippe Carrard, Poetics o f the New History: French Historical Discourse
from Braudel to Chartier, : Johns Hopkins University Press, 1992
Trajan Stoianovich, French Historical Method: The Annales Paradigm, :
Cornell University Press, 1976 Peter Burke, The French Historical Revolution:
The Annales School 1929-1989, : Polity Press, 1990.

Annales, . Les formes de

1 7 6 _________________

______________

/experience. Annales, .
Vauchez, Oexle, Little, Simons, Rucquoi, Klaniczay
Gurevich, Miri Rubin ( .), The Work ofJacques Le Goff and the Challenges
o f Medieval History, : Boydell, 1997, . 71-141, 223-248.
11. mentalite , . Peter
Burke, Strengths and Weaknesses of the History o f Mentalities,
Varieties o f Cultural History, : Polity Press,

1997, .

162-182'

Stoianovich, French Historical Method, .., . 120-12 1.


12. Patricia O Brien, Michel Foucaults History of Culture, Lynn
Hunt ( .), The New Cultural History, : University of California
Press, 1989, . 34.
13.
, . Piroska Nagy, Le Don des larmes au moyen age, ;
Albin Michel, 2000 Jean-Claude Schmitt, La Raison des gestes, :
Gallimard, 1990 Alain Boureau, Le simple corps du roi: / impossible sacralite des
souverains frangais XVe-XVIIIe, : Editions de Paris, 1988 Laura Kendrick,
Animating the Letter: the Figurative Embodiment o f W riting from Late Antiquity to
the Renaissance, : Ohio State University Press, 1999.
14. Alain Boureau, The Lords First N ight The Myth o f the Droit de Cuissage,
. Lydia G. Cochrane, : University of Chicago Press, 1998 (Le Droit
de cuissage: la fabrication dun mythe Xlle-Xxe, : Albin Michel, 1995).
15. Frank Lestrignant, Cannibalism: The Discovery and Representation o f the
Cannibal from Columbus to Jules Verne, . Rosemary Morris, :
Polity Press, 1997- Une saint horreur; ou le voyage en eucharistie, XVIe-XVIII
siecles, : Presses Universitaires de France, 1996.
16. Antoinette Molinie, Dun village de La Mancha a un glacier des Andes.
Deux celebrations sauvages du Corps de Dieu, Antoinette Molinie
( .), Le Corps de Dieu en Fetes, : Cerf, 1996, a. 223-253.
17. .
, . Lawrence W . Levine, The Folklore o f Industrial Society:
Popular Culture and its Audiences, American Historical Review XCVII (1992),
. 1369-1399, Robin D.G. Kelley, Natalie
Zemon Davis T.J. Jackson Lears, , . 1400-1430.
18. Edward W . Said, Orientalism, : Pantheon, 1978 [. .:
, . . , : , 19961.
19. : culture. (...)
20. . David Wallace, Chauser and the European Rose, Studies in the
Age o f Chaucer I ( 1984), . 6 1-67.

177

2 1. Caroline W . Bynum, Holy Feast and Holy Fast The Religious Significance
o f Food to Medieval Women, : University o f California Press, 1987.
22. Joan Wallach Scott, Gender and the Politics o f History, :
Columbia University Press, 1988.
23.

, . Robert Findlay, The Refashioning o f Martin Guerre


Natalie Z. Davis, On the lame , American Historical Review XCIII (1988), a.
553-571, 572-603.
24. Ruth Harris, Lourdes: Body and Spirit in a Secular Age, : Penguin,
1999.
25.

Mary Douglas

, . Sonya . Rose, Cultural Analysis and Moral Discourses: Episodes,


Continuities, and Transformations, Bonnell Hunt ( .), Beyond the
Cultural Turn, .., . 217-238, . 220-225.
26. A. Kuper, Culture, Identity and the Project o f Cosmopolitan
Anthropology, Among the Anthropologists: History and Context in
Anthropology, : Athlone Press, 1999, . 26-58, . 37.
27. . Robert Darnton, W orkers Revolt: The Great Cat Massacre of
Rue Saint-Severin, The Great Cat Massacre and Other Episodes in French
Cultural History, : Allen Lane, 1984, . 75-104 Roger Chartier, Texts,
symbols, and Frenchness, Journal o f Modem History LVII ( 1985), . 682-695
Dominick La Capra, Chartier, Darnton, and the Great Symbol Massacre,
Journal o f Modern History LX (1988), . 95-1 12.
Geertz, . Sherry . O rtner
( .), The Fate o f "Culture: Geertz and Beyond, : University of
California Press, 1999.
28. : order. (...)
29.
, . Caroline Humphrey James Laidlaw, The Archetypal Actions o f
Ritual: A Theory o f Ritual Illustrated by the Jain Rite o f Worship, :
Clarendon, 1994.
30. Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie, Carnival: A Peoples Uprising at Romans,
1579-80, . Mary Feeney, : Scolar Press, 1980.
31. . Roger Mettam, Dissemblers, Dissenters,
Guerrillas: The Huguenots in France after 1685, Historical Research (2002).
32. Renato Rosaldo, From the D oor o f his Tent: The Fieldworker and
the Inquisitor, Vincent Crapanzano, Hermes Dilemma: The Masking of
Subversion in Ethnographic Description, James Clifford George E.
Marcus ( .), W riting Culture: The Poetics and Politics o f Ethnography, -

1 7 8 _______ ________________

__

____

____ ;

: University of California Press, 1982, . 77-97 51-76, . .


James Clifford, The Predicament o f Culture: Twentieth-Century
Ethnography, Literature, and Art, : Harvard University Press, 1988.
33. Tanya M. Luhrmann, O f Two Minds: The Growing Disorder in American
Psychiatry, : Alfred Knopf, 2000 Ray Raphael, The Men from the
Boys: Rites o f Passage in Male America, : University of Nebraska Press,
1988' Claudine Fabre-Vassas, The Singular Beast Jews, Christians, and the Pig,
. Carol Volk, : Columbia University Press, 1997 (La bete
singuliere: les juifs, les chretiens, et le cochon, : Gallimard, 1994).
34. (
), . Robin D.G. Kelley, Mamas
Difunktional! Fighting the Cultural Wars in Urban America, : Beacon
Press, 1997,0. 17-23.
35. Clifford Geertz , . Available Light Anthropological
Reflections on Philosophical Topics, : Princeton University Press, 2000,
. V, . 89 -142.
36. Memoirs o f the Life o f Dr John Shaw, Surtees Society 65.
37.
, . Robin G.D. Kelley, Race Rebels: Culture, Poetics, and
the Black Working Class, : The Free Press, 1994, . 22,
[Sambo: ,
. (...)].
(
[ : nigger.
(...)]), John Langton Gwaltney, Drylongso: A Self-Portrait o f Black
America, : Random House, 1980, . Drylongso
, . . xxii-xxx.
, . Jacques
Ranciere, The Nights o f Labour: The Workers Dream in Nineteenth-Century
France,

. John Drury, : Temple University Press, 1989 (Le

nuit des proletaires, : Hachette, 19 8 1).


38. : instantiators. (...)
39. . Marshall Sahlins, Culture in Practice:
Selected Essays, : Zone Books, 2000' How "Natives Think, about
Captain Cook, for Example, : University of Chicago Press, 1995, Gananath Obeyesekereh, The Apotheosis o f Captain
Cook: European Mythmaking in the Pacific, : Princeton University
Press, 1992.

;____________________

_________

179

40. . Barbara . Rosenwein ( .), Angers Post The


Social Histories o f an Emotion in the Middle Ages, : Cornell University
Press, 1998. , . Hans Medick David W .
Sabean ( .), Interest and Emotion: Essays on the Study o f Family and Kinship,
: Cambridge University Press, 1984.
41. James C. Scott, Domination and the Arts o f Resistance: Hidden Transcripts,
: Yale University Press, 1990 Sherry B. O rtner, Resistance and
the Problem o f Ethnographic Refusal, Comparative Studies in Society and
History XXXVII (1995), . 173-193.
42. Rosalind O Hanlon ( . .), A Comparison between Women
and Men: Tarabai Shinde and the Cririque o f Gender Relations in Colonial India,
: O xford University Press, 1994.
43. Catherine Gallagher Stephen Greenblatt ( .), Practicing New
Historicism, : University of Chicago Press, 2000, . 1-19. Stephen Greenblatt, The Touch of the Real, O rtner, The
Fate o f Culture, .., . 14-29.
44. Paul Strohm, Englands Empty Throne: Usurpation and the Language o f
Legitimation, 1399-1422, : Yale University Press, 1998.
45. Paul Strohm, Chaucers Lollard Joke: History, and the Textual
Unconscious, Studies in the Age o f Chaucer, . XVII ( 1995), . 34-42.
46. Roger Chartier, Culture as Appropriation: Popular Cultural Uses in
Early Modern France, S.L. Kaplan ( .), Understanding Popular Culture:
Europe from the Middle Ages to the Nineteenth Century New Babylon: Studies in
the Social Sciences 40, : Mouton, 1984, a. 229-253.
47. John Toews, Intellectual
History after the Linguistic Turn: The Autonomy of Meaning and Irreducibility
of Experience, American Historical Review XCII (1987), . 879-907, .
882-883.

6
;*
Alice Kessler-Harris
- . Carr
Northanger Abbey
. ,
,
:
,
.1 Carr
.

.2 :
, ,
-
. ,
,
.

,3
, ,

( ) .
Carr , . Carr
,4

,
- ,
- .
,
, ,
.
, Carr , -

, - !- . , ;



. ,

.
,

,
, ,
,
.

I
Carr

.
Carr. ,
I960, Carr
,

,
.
, ,

Carr,

,
. I960,
Carr -
R.G. Collingwood,
-
.

,
' ,
, , ,
. , , , ,
.5
,
,
.6
;

.
Carr,
.


.7
, ,
.8 Carr

184

9 (, )

.



,
.


10
, , .
- , ,
- .
(
,
I960, )
Carr
.
Carr
.


-


.11 Carr,

1890.
,
.
Carr ,

. ;
-
.
,

.
, 1-963,
Carl Bridenbaugh



.12 ,

Carr
.
, ,
,
Carr
, ,
.


.


.

, (
, ,

)
.
(
,
, ),
. ,
,


.

. , ,

I960 ,


.13 ,


( ) , ,
. ; Carr
.
(
)

.



,
, .
,

187


:

.
.
. (,
, )

.
,
. jJia

- ,
Carr.
,
,
,
.
,
.
, ,
,

.
.
,
,

.
, ,
,
.

188

-

.

( , ,
, )
.
/ , ,

,

. -
, -
.
,
, . ,

,

, .
,
,
.14


,
, . ,



. , ,


20
.15 - ,
(
, , , ,
, , )
.
,
.

-
. , ,



, ,

; .

II
Carr


.1^
,

.
-

190


,

.
Carr :
,


.
:

. ' 7


,
,
.
,
.
,
,

Carr.
,

.

Carr. , ,
Carr
,
.18



.
: Struggle for the Breeches
Anna Clark Technology and Gender (
) Francesca Bray.19

.
. HX a ro lyn Steedman

,
.20 Sally Alexander Catherine Hall



2 ! Laura Engelstein Kathleen Brown

,

.22

19
, ,
. ,

,


. ,
Mary Poovey,
.23 , Joy Parr, Jane

192

Lewis .., ,

.24
,
.
,

. ,


,


.
, ,


.


. ,


. ,
,

.


.
,
,

193

.

,
.
, , ,
.
/

. Earl Lewis Bonnie
Smith,

. Lewis
25,
, ,
.26
,


,
,
.
;
,
: ^ -

-
.
,
1970 ,
.27

194

,


, . ,
,

,
,
.
,
.

,
, .
Martha Howell Leonore Davidoff
Catherine Hall, ,

:
(

)

.28
(
)


.
,

. Kathleen Canning

19 ,

195



, , ,
.
,

.
.

,

.29
,

]co ,
. 19 (
Mary Ann Clawson)



.30 ,
,

,

.31 ,


, ,
,

.32
,


.


.
.

( )
, ,
.
/ .
, Joshua Freeman Stephen Meyer

.33 ( ) .
, ,
,
.
( ) ,
, .

. , ,




.34

197

, ,
,
. , .
, Barbara Taylor Liz
Faue, ,
(
)
, , .35

. Joe Trotter, Tera Hunter Glenda Gilmore

.36
(
Theresa Liu, Barbara Hanawalt, Merry
Wiesner, Louise Tilly )


.37

W erner Sombart
;,
,
,
.

Ill
,

-

-
.
,
,
- Susan Pedersen
-
,
, . ,

, 1789.


,
,


.38
/ .
19 ,

,



.
,


.

,
, ,

199


,
,

.
: , ,
,
.39

.



, ,
, , - -
.

,


20
.40 20

- (
)

.41
,
,
,
,


.
.


,
.
,


. , ,

, ,
,

.

(,
,
).
.
, ,
. ,
,
.
, ,
, ,
.

. ,
, ,
- -
.

201

, ,
.42
, ,
.


.
,


. ,

- ,

,


,
.

,

.43
,

,
,
.
: , , ,

.

44

202




.



.


,
,

.


.

,
.45
(
)
,

,
. ,
,
-
46
, Antoinette
Burton Ann Stoler

.
Stoler, ,


.47
,

,

- .

,

.48


,
,
.





.49 ,
(

)

, ,
.50 ,
-

.
. , Annette Kolodny,
,
,
.51


,
.

IV
, ;

.
(
),

.

,


, .
,
:

.

, .



, .
, Edward
Hallett Carr .
.


* Charles Budd (Pete) Forcey,
.. Carr.
1. Jane Austen, Northanger Abbey, :
Penguin, 1995 [1818], . 97 [. .: , .
, ; , 2003].
2. ., , Olwen Hufton, The Prospect Before Her: A
History o f Women in Western Europe, . I, : HarperCollins, 1995, . I .
3. Austen, Northanger Abbey, .., . 98.
4. Jonathan Haslam, The Vices o f Integrity: E.H. Carr, 1892-1982, :
Verso, 1999.
5. Edward Hallett Carr, What is History?, : Alfred Knopf, 1962,
. 26.
6. , . 163.
7. .
8. , . 77.
9. : standpoints. (...)
10. Carr, What is History?, .., . 199.
I I . , . 96-97.
12. Carl Bridenbaugh, The Great Mutation, American Historical Review
LXVIII ( 1963), . 322-323.
13. Herbert G. Gutman, The Black Family in Slavery and Freedom, 17501925, : Pantheon, 1976 Eugene D. Genovese, Roll, Jordan, Roll: The
World the Slaves Made, : Vintage, 1976 Nathan Irvin Huggins, Black
Odyssey: The Afro-American Ordeal in Slavery, : Pantheon, 1977.

206

14. Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth o f the Prison,
: Pantheon, 1977 [. .: :
, . , : , 1989],
15. , . Sonya Michel Seth
Koven, Womanly Duties: Maternalist Politics and the Origins o f Welfare
States in France, Germany, Great Britain and the United States, 1880-1920,
American Historical Review 95 ( 1990), . 1076-1108' .
Linda Gordon ( .), Women, the State and Welfare, : University of
Wisconsin Press, 1990' Robyn Muncy, Creating a Female Dominion in American
Reform, 1890-1935, : Oxford University Press, 1991 Jane Lewis
( .), Womens Welfare Womens Rights, : Croom Helm, 1983.
16.
Joan Wallach Scott, Gender and Politics o f History, :
Columbia University Press, 1988. , .
Victoria . Bonnell Lynn Hunt ( .), Beyond the Cultural Turn: New
Directions in the Study o f Society and Culture, : University o f California
Press, 1999 Bryan Palmer, Descent into Discourse: The Reification o f Language
and the W riting o f Social History, : Temple University Press, 1990
Patrick Joyce, Visions o f the People, : Cambridge University Press,
1991.
17. Carr, What is History?, .., . 186.
18. , . 129.
19. Anna Clark, The Struggle for the Breeches: Gender and the Making o f the
British Working Class, : University of California Press, 1995 Francesca
Bray, Technology and Gender. Fabrics o f Power in Late Imperial China, :
University o f California Press, 1997.
20. Carolyn Steedman, Landscape for a Good Woman: A Story o f Two Lives,
: Virago, 1986.
21. Sally Alexander, Becoming a Woman: And Other Essays in 19th and 20th
Century Feminist History, : Virago, 1994' Catherine Hall, White, Male
and Middle Class: Explorations in Feminism and History, : Routledge,
1988.
22. Laura Engelstein, The Keys to Happiness, Sex and the Search for Mod
ernity in fin de siecle Russia, : Cornell University Press, 1992' Kathleen M.
Brown, Good Wives, Nasty Wenches, and Anxious Patriarchs: Gender, Race, and
Power in Colonial Virginia, : Institute of Early American History and
Culture, Williamsburg, VA/University o f N orth Carolina Press, 1996.
23. Mary Poovey, Uneven Developments: The Ideological Work o f Gender in
Mid-Victorian England, : University o f Chicago Press, 1988.

207

24. Joy Parr, The Gender o f Breadwinners: Women, Men, and Change in Two
Industrial Towns, 1880-1950, : University of T oronto Press, 1990 Jane
Lewis ( .), Labour and Love: Womens Experience o f Home and Family, 18501940, : Blackwell, 1986 Mary P. Ryan, Women in Public: Between
Banners and Ballots, 1825-1880, : Johns Hopkins University Press,
1990 Linda Kerber, Separate Spheres, Female W orlds, Womans Place: The
Rhetoric of womens History, Journal o f American History 75 (1988), a. 9-39.
25. : homespace. (...)
26. Earl Lewis, In Their Own Interests: Race, Class, and Power in TwentiethCentury Norfolk, Virginia, : University o f California Press, 199 1 Bonnie
G. Smith, Ladies o f the Leisure Class: The Bourgeoises o f Northern France in the
Nineteenth Century, : Princeton University Press, 198 1.
27.

1970, . Wally Seccombe,

Patriarchy Stabilized: The Construction of the Male Breadwinner Wage


Norm in Nineteenth-Century Britain, Social History 11 (1986), . 53-76.
28. Martha C. Howell, Women, Production, and Patriarchy in Late Medieval
Cities, : University o f Chicago Press , , The Marriage
Exchange: Property, Social Place, and Gender in Cities o f the Low Countries, 13001550, : University of Chicago Press, 1998 Leonore Davidoff
Catherine Hall, Family Fortunes: Men and Women o f the English Middle Class:
1780-1850, : Hutchinson, 1987 Dorothy Ko, Teachers o f the Inner
Chambers: Women and Culture in Seventeenth-Century China, , : Stanford University Press, 1994.
29. ., , Kathleen Canning, The Man Transformed
into a Maiden? Languages o f Grievance and the Politics of Class in Germany,
1850-19 15, International Labor and Working Class History 49 ( 1996), o.
47-72.

, . Mary Blewett, Def


erence and Defiance: Labor Politics and the Meanings of Masculinity in the
Mid-Nineteenth Century New England Textile Industry, Gender and History 5
( 1993), . 398-415.
30. Mary Ann Clawson, Constructing Brotherhood: Class, Gender, and
Fraternalism, : Princeton University Press, 1989.
3 1. Thomas Dublin, Women at Work: The Transformation o f Work and
Community in Lowell, Massachusetts, 1826-1860, : Columbia
University Press, 1975 Suzanne Lebsock, The Free Women o f Petersburg: Status
and Culture in a Southern Town, 1784-1860, : W .W . Norton, 1984.

32. Mary . Blewett, Men, Women, and Work: Class, Gender, and Protest in
the New England Shoe Industry, 1780-1910, : University of Illinois
Press, 1988.
33. Stephen Meyer, W ork, Play, and Power: Masculine Culture on the
Automotive Shop Floor, 1930-1960, Roger Horowitz ( .), Boys and
Their Toys: Masculinity, Class, and Technology in America, : Routledge,
2001, . 13-32 Joshua Freeman, Hard Cats, Construction W orkers, Man
liness and the 1970 Pro-war Demonstrations, Journal o f Social History 26
(1983), . 725-744 Sonya Rose, Respectable Men, Disorderly Others: The
Language of Gender and the Lancashire Weavers Strike of 1878, Gender and
History 5 (1993), . 382-397.
34.
, . Keith McClelland, Some
Thoughts on Masculinity and the Representative Artisan in Britain, 185019 15, Gender and History I ( 1989), . 164-177, Ava Baron, Questions of
Gender: Deskilling and Demasculinization in the US Printing Industry, 18301945, Gender and History I (1989), . 178-199.
, . Judith Bennett, Ale, Beer and Brewsters in
England: Women's Work in a Changing World, 1300-1600, : Oxford
University Press, 1996 Katherine Sheldon ( .), Courtyards, Markets, City
Streets: Urban Women in Africa, : Westview Press, 1996.
35. Barbara Taylor, Eve and the New Jerusalem: Socialism and Feminism in
the Nineteenth Century, : Pantheon, 1983 Elizabeth Faue,
Community o f Suffering and Struggle: Women, Men, and the Labor Movement in
Minneapolis, 1915-1945, : University of N orth Carolina Press,
1991 Angela W oollacott, On Her Their Lives Depend: Munitions Workers in the
Great War, : University of California Press, 1994.
36. Joe William Trotter, Black Milwaukee: the Making o f an Industrial
Proletariat, 1915-45, : University o f Illinois Press, 1985 Glenda
Elizabeth Gilmore, Gender and Jim Crow: Women and the Politics o f White
Supremacy in North Carolina, 1896-1920, : University o f North
Carolina Press, 1996 Tera W . Hunter, To Joy my Freedom: Southern Black
Womens Lives and Labors after the Civil War, : Harvard University
Press, 1997.
37. Tessie P. Liu, The Weavers Knot: the Contradictions o f Class Struggle and
Family Solidarity in Western France, 1750-1914, : Cornell University Press,
1994 Louise Tilly, Politics and Class in Milan, 18 8 1-190 1, : Oxford
University Press, 1992 Barbara Hanawalt, O f Good and III Repute: Gender and
Social Control in Medieval England, : Oxford University Press, 1998

209

Merry . Wiesner, Working Women in Renaissance Germany, : Rutgers University Press, 1986.
38. . Joan Landes, Women and the Public Sphere in the Age
o f the French Revolution, : Cornell University Press, 1988 Olwen Hufton,
Women and the Limits o f Citizenship in the French Revolution, :
University of Toronto Press, 1992 Joan Wallach Scott, Only Paradoxes to Offer,
: Harvard University Press, 1997.
39. Ellen Ross, Love and Toil: Motherhood in Outcast London, 1870-1918,
: O xford University Press, 1993 Anna Davin, Growing up Poor:
Home, School, and Street in London, 1870-1914, : Rivers Oram Press,
1996' Hendrik Hartog, Man and Wife in America: A History, : Harvard
University Press, 2000.
40. Thomas Dublin, Transforming Womens W ork New England Lives in the
Industrial Revolution, : Cornell University Press, 1994 E. Patricia Tsurumi,
Factory Girls: Women in the Thread Mills o f Meiji Japan, : Princeton
University Press, 1990 Emily Honig, Sisters and Strangers: Women in the
Shanghai Cotton Mills, 1919-1949, : Stanford University Press, 1986Leela Fernandez, Producing Workers: The Politics o f Gender and Class in the
Calcutta Jute Mills, : University o f Pennsylvania Press, 1997.
41. Ulla Wikander, Alice Kessler-Harris Jane Lewis, Protecting Women:
Labor Legislation in Europe, Australia and the United States, :
University o f Illinois Press, I99S.
42. Linda Kerber, No Constitutional Right to be Ladies: Women and the
Obligations o f Citizenship, : Hill and Wang, 1998' Alice KesslerHarris, Out to Work: A History o f Wage-Earning Women in the United States,
: O xford University Press, 1982.
43. Susan Pedersen, Family, Dependence, and the Origins o f the Welfare State:
Britain and France, 1914-1945, : Cambridge University Press, 1993
Alice Kessler-Harris, In Pursuit o f Equity: Women, Men and the Quest for Eco
nomic Citizenship in Twentieth Century America, : O xford University
Press, 2001.
44. Partha Chatterjee, Nationalist Thought and the Colonial World: A
Derivative Discourse, : University of Minnesota Press, 1998 Spivak
Gayatri Chakravorty, In Other Worlds: Essays in Cultural Politics, :
Routledge, 1988.
45. Ann McClintock, Gender, Nations and Post Colonial Perspectives, : University o f Minnesota Press, 1997 Vron Ware, Beyond the Pale: White
Women, Racism and History, : Verso, 1992 Ida Blom, Karen Hagemann

Catherine Hall, Gendered Nations: Nationalisms and Gender Order in the Long
Nineteenth Century, ; Berg, 2000.
46. ., , Peggy Pascoe, Relations o f Rescue: The Search
for Female Moral Authority in the American West, 1874-1939, :
O xford University Press, 1990- Judith Walkowitz, Prostitution and Victorian
Society: Women, Class and the State, : Cambridge University Press,
1980.
47. Ann Laura Stoler, Carnal Knowledge and Imperial Power: Gender,
Race, and Morality in Colonial Asia, crto Joan Scott ( .), Feminism and
History, : O xford University Press, 1996, a. 209, Stoler, Race
and the Education o f Desire: Foucault's History o f Sexuality and the Colonial Order
o f Things, : Duke University Press, 1995 Antoinette Burton, Burdens
o f History: British Feminists, Indian Women, and Imperial Culture, 1865-1915,
: University of N orth Carolina Press, 1944.
48. Mrinalini Sinha, Colonial Masculinity: The Manly Englishman and the
"Effeminate Bengal in the Late Nineteenth Century, : Manchester
University Press, 1995.
49. Ramon Gutierrez, When Jesus Came the Corn Mothers Went Away:
Marriage, Sexuality and Power in New Mexico, : Stanford University
Press, 1991 George J. Sanchez, Becoming Mexican: Ethnicity, Culture and Identity
in Chicano Los Angeles: 1900-1945, : Oxford, 1993.
50. Brian Roberts, American Alchemy: the California Gold Rush and MiddleClass Culture, : University of N orth Carolina, 1999.
5 1. Annette Kolodny, The Land Before Her: Fantasy and Experience o f the
American Frontiers, 1630-1860, : University of N orth Carolina,
1984.

7
;
Annabel Brett





;.
,
.
-

: , ?>
( ) , ,
; ( ).
,
, ,

,
.


.
, William J. Bouwsma,

" ,

,
,
-
-
, - -

,

.1 :
; -
2

, , (
) .3
,

per se,

,
:


,

.

:
,
, . , ,

-, , ,

213

.
.
,
- ,-


:
.4
-

. ,

,

,

.
,
.
Carr
;,
.
, - -
, , ,
,

.5 , Carr



. ,

214

,
18
.
R.G. Collingwood, Carr

;, ,
,
.

, .. Green F.H. Bradley,
Collingwood
,
.6
Collingwood,

,
.
Carr,


- C arr- .7
,
:
.

,
.

. , Bouwsma


-
-
Carr
Collingwood. ,
:


-


,

.
,
,
, .

.

I
,

.
I960

, ,
,
. ,
Quentin Skinner,

1950 1960
John Austin John Searle.8 Austin, How to Do Things
with Words, 9 Searle
Speech Acts,10
-
( 11 )-

.
,
,
, ,
, ,3
12
13 .

.

. ,
, , .
,
Searle Skinner
,
.'4
( ) .15
Skinner,

,

.

.
,
,

.

,
: ,
, ,
.

)
-
. ,
Austin Searle,
,
, .16

.

,
.
,
(

),


: ,
. .

,

(
)
.

,
, .
. ,

:

.
,
,
.

,
, ,
Begriffsgeschichte.17
,
. -

.
, -

,
.

,
J.G.A.
Pocock, Pocock Skinner

219

.18 '
,
- , , ..
,
.
,
,19 , .
Skinner Pocock
,

, , .


, ,
. ,
,
,..20 ,
: ,
,

. ,
.21

,
.

---
: , ,
-
. ,

220

( ) ,
(
), ,
,
.

, ,
,

. ,
,

,

. ,




, ,


.


,

.
:


.
,
()
.
,
,
. , -
- -
-
,
,
.
,
,
,
-
.22 ,
,
, . ,
, -
.23




.
-
-

.
,

222


(
).24 .

:
,
, .

( ).
,


, .

,

.
- Austin How to Do
Things with Words- ,
. ,


,
(
)
,
.
,

,
.

223


,25
,
( )26

.27

( )
, /.
( )


,

.
,
- . (
)
,
.
, ,
,
,

28

.
,

-
, -

,
,

:
,



, . [...]
[...]
.29

, -
. ,
,
, :
,
-

,
.3

/ /
, /

. ,
31 32
.


, ,
, -

, ,
. ,
-
- :


.33

, (

)
.34 ,
,
,
,35
:
;.36


. ,


. . ,
,
, (
)
. , ,

.
, . , Austin
-

226

- -,

.37 , ,
, -"

.
, , , "
. ,
- ,

.
.38
,
. ,

,

. ,
.
,
,

.
,
.39
: , .
, ,
,
.

,
, ( )
.40 ,
,

4^,

- -
.42 ,


, ,
43

,


.

, ( )
.
,
.

.
: ,

,
, .
,
, ,

228



.
,
,

.44 ,
,


,
( ),
.45
, ,
( )
:
,
. ,

-
.

/


( )
( ) -

.

.

,



. ,

,
,
, ,
. ,
,
,
,
- ,
,
:

-


.46

,
.

, ,
, ,
,
,

,
(!).
, ( )

230


,

,
.


- ,
-

,
.

,

.


.
,

20 ,
,
, ,
.
: ( )
, ,
,
.
, ,
:
Lucien Febvre outillage
mental,

231

, mentalite

Annales
.47 outillage mental mentalite


48 ,
,
,

, , ,
.
Roger Chartier,
Febvre, -

Annales-

/
.49
Annales, Jacques
Le Goff Chartier,
/ imaginaire social, ,
. Chartier,

:

,

,

.50

232

,

,
.



. Clifford
Geertz ,
,

.
Geertz
5'
,


.
Geertz ,
,
, ,
, .
, ,
Geertz ( ),52

(,
,..)
.53
,
.54
Jonathan
Sawday

233

( ) blazon55
The Body Emblazoned.56
, ,
, ,
, ,
, , ,

.
,

.
,
,
.
,
.

( ),
.57
Geertz

,58 Gallagher Greenblatt
, [...]

, ,
, ,

.59 Gabrielle Spiegel,

.60

234

,



.61 ,
, ,
: ,
.

II

,
?>. ,
, ,

, -
.
, ,

, ;.
,
;
-

,

.

, .

235



, ,

.
- , -

:

.
,
<< ^
,
Dominick LaCapra
.62

,
.
,
. ,

.
63
, .
, :

,
. ,
.
,
, -
,


.64

,


:
, ,
() .

Carr

,
.65
,
,
.


1. W.J. Bouwsma, The Waning o f the Renaissance ISSO-1640, :
Yale University Press, 2000, a. ix.
2. Roger Chartier,

. . R. Chartier, Intellectual History


or Sociological History? The French Trajectories, D. LaCapra S.L.
Kaplan ( .), Modern European Intellectual History: Reappraisals and New
Perspectives, : Cornell University Press, 1982.
3. . N.J. Christie, From Intellectual to Cultural History: The
Comparative Catalyst, D.R. W oolf ( .), Intellectual History: New
Perspectives, : Edwin Mellen, 1989, . 82.

237

4. ,
Quentin Skinner. , .
Q.R.D. Skinner, Meaning and Understanding in the History of Ideas, History
and Theory, . 8 (1969), . 393-408, J. Tully ( .), Meaning
and Context Quentin Skinner and His Critics, : Polity Press, 1988 .
J.A.W. Gunn, After Sabine, After Lovejoy: The Languages of Political
Thought, W oolf, Intellectual History, ..
5. E.H. Carr, What is History? (2 .), : Penguin, 1987, . 134135.
6.

Collingwood

, . D. Boucher, Texts in Context: Revisionist Methods for Studying


the History o f Ideas, : Martinus Nijhoff, 1985, . 39-71.
7. Carr, What is History?, .., . 21-27.
8. . Skinner, Meaning and Understanding Q.R.D.
Skinner, Motives, Intentions and the Interpretation o f Texts, New Literary
History, . 3 (1972), . 393-408, Tully, Meaning and Context,
..
9. J.L. Austin, How to Do Things with Words (2 .), : Oxford
University Press, 1975 [. .: ,
. , , 2003],
10. J.R. Searle, Speech Acts: An Essay in the Philosophy o f Language,
: Cambridge University Press, 1969.
11. : elocutionary. (...)
12. : illocutionary. (...)
13. : perlocutionary. (...)
14.
, Skinner
Austin,

. Skinner,


. . Q.R.D. Skinner, Reply to My Critics, Tully, Meaning and
Context, .., . 261-264.
15. ,
....
. Tully, Meaning and Context, , . 10. Reply
Skinner ,
-

238

-
- , . Skinner

. .
, . 225.
16. L. Wittgenstein, Philosophical Investigations (3 .),

, : Blackwell, 1968 [. .: ,

. .

, , 1977]: . 5. .
- -

(. 8).

17. [ . (...)] ,
. J.G.A. Pocock, Concepts and Discourses: A Difference in Culture?
Comments on a Paper by Melvin Richter, H. Lehmann M. Richter
( .), The Meaning o f Historical Terms and Concepts: New Studies in
Begriffsgeschichte, : German Historical Institute, 1996, . 47-58
M. Richter, Reconstructing the History o f Political Languages: Pocock,
Skinner and the Geschichtliche Grundbegriffe, History and Theory, . 29 (1990),
. 38-70.
18. , . J.G.A.
Pocock, The Concept of a Language and the Metier d' Historien: Some
Considerations on Practice, A.R.D. Pagden ( .), The Languages o f
Political Theory in Early Modem Europe, : Cambridge University Press,
1987.
19. : discourse. (...)
20. O Pocock, The Concept of a Language, , :
, ,
, , ,
,
(
).
2 1. ., , Skinner Palazzo Pubblico : Q.R.D. Skinner, Ambrogio
Lorenzetti: The A rtist as Political Philosopher, Proceedings o f the British
Academy, . 72 (1986), . 1-86.
22. , . L. Giard, Du Latin medieval au pluriel des
langues: Le tournant de la Renaissance, Histoire, epistemologie, langage, . 6
(1984), . 35-55, . 40-41.
23. . Biagioli, The Antropology o f Incommensurability, Studies in the
History and Philosophy o f Science, . 21 (1990), . 183-209, . 203.

239

24.
, . Skinner, Motives, Intentions J. Tully, The Pen is a Mighty
Sword: Quentin Skinners Analysis of Politics, Tully, Meaning and Context,
..,. 10-16,22-25.
25.

Spiegel, History, Historicism and the Social Logic of the

Text in the Middle Ages, Speculum (1990), K. Jenkins


( .), The Postmodern History Reader, : Routledge, 1997, . 180-283.
26. . 16, . . Jay, Should
Intellectual History Take a LinguisticTurn? Reflections on the HabermasGadamer Debate, LaCapra Kaplan, Modern European Intellectual
History, . 86-1 10, , 87-88.
27. O Skinner, Reply, .., . 276,

.
28.
, . Jay, Should Intellectual History Take a Linguistic
Turn?, ..
29. M. Foucault, What is an Author?, D.F. Bouchard ( .),
Language, Counter-Memory, Practice: Selected Essays and Interviews by Michel
Foucault, : Cornell University Press, 1977, . 113-138, . 113.
30. M. Foucault, L archeologie du savoir, : Gallimard, 1969, . 70
[. .: ,

. , ,

1987],
3 1. : authorship. (...)
32. : authority. (...)
33. . . 216 . 15 .
34.

Gerard

Genette
(, ,

, ,

..). . G. Genette, Paratexts: Thresholds o f Interpretation, . J.E. Lewin,


: Cambridge University Press, 1997.
35. . Pocock, The Concept o f a Language, .., . 25,

-.
36. Foucault, What is an Author?, .., . 138.
37. . Austin: J. Derrida, Signature
Event Context, Margins o f Philosophy, . A. Bass, :
University o f Chicago Press- : Harvester, 1982, . 307-330.

240

38.
, . . W orton J. Still ( .), Intertextuality:
Theories and Practices, : Manchester University Press, 1990.
39. , o Michel de Certeau

. . . de Certeau, The Practice o f
Everyday Life, . S. Rendall, : University o f California Press, 1984,
. xi-xxiv.
40.
, . J.E. Toews, Intellectual History
A fter the Linguistic Turn: The Autonomy of Meaning and the Irreducibility of
Experience, American Historical Review 92 ( 1987), . 879-907.
41. : episteme. (...)
42. I. MacLean, Foucaults Renaissance Episteme Reassessed: An
Aristotelian Counterblast, Journal o f the History o f Ideas ( 1998), . 149-166,
[episteme]
,
,

.
43. Pocock, Concepts and Discourses, .., . 47.
44.
, intentio operis,
, 1990. . U. Eco, Interpretation and Overinterpretation, :
Cambridge University Press, 1992, 64:
intentio operis
.
[...].
intentio operis;
.
intentio operis intentio lector
auctor.
45.
,
,
- -
,
, , .. Thompson Reception Theory and
the Interpretation of Historical Meaning, History and Theory, . 32 (1993), .

241

228-272. ,
(. . 15 )
, . ,

.
- (. ).
46. , . A.R.D. Pagden, Introduction,
The Languages o f Political Theory, .., . 2.
47. . Chartier, Intellectual History o r Sociocultural History?, .., .
18-32- R. Chartier, Cultural History: Between Practices and Representations, .
L.G. Cochrane, : Polity Press, Blackwell, 1988,
. 20-48 P. Burke, Varieties o f Cultural History, : Polity Press, 1997, .
162-182.
48. Febvre, outillage mental
, , ,
,
(Chartier,
Intellectual History o r Sociocultural History?, .., . 19)
Mandrou, mentalite , ,
, (affectivite) ( ,
. 23).
49. , . 29-32.
50. Chartier, Cultural History, .., . 9 -10.
51. C. Geertz, The Interpretation o f Cultures, : Basic Books,
1973, a. 452.
52. ,

, . C. Gallagher S. Greenblatt, Practising New Historicism,
: University of Chicago Press, 2000, . 1-19.
53. . S. Greenblatt, Renaissance Self-Fashioning from More to
Shakespeare, : University o f Chicago Press, 1988, . 4-5.
54. , . Spiegel,
History, Historicism, .., . 185-192.
55. . (...)
56. J. Sawday, The Body Emblazoned: Dissection and the Human Body in
Rennaisance Culture, : Routledge, 1995, . 196-212.
57. To - -
( )

242

__________________

___

-
.
58. Geertz, The Interpretation o f Cultures, .., . 30.
59. Gallagher Greenblatt, Practicing New Historicism, .., . 15.
60. Spiegel, History, Historicism, .., . 192.
6 1. , . 195.
62.
, . D. LaCapra,
Rethinking Intellectual History and Reading Texts, LaCapra Kaplan,
Modern European Intellectual History, .., . 83-85.
63. : sophia. (...)
64. . R. Rorty, Contigency, Irony and Solidarity, : Cambridge
University Press, 1989,
,
.
65.
(The Name o f
the Rose, . W. Weaver, : Picador, 1984, . 500) [. .: To
, . , : , 1999].

8
;
Linda Colley
.

,
1970.
,

. ,
,
.

.

,
, ,



.

; , .
,
, ,
,

244

______________

_____

_________

. , ,
,
, , ,
, (
) .
-
- .
.
. ,
, -
-
.
,
, - -
.
,

, , ,
, ,
.1
,
,
, - -
. , ,
;
;.
Dane Kennedy ,
, ,

. , -

;______________________ ___________ 245

, ,
,
,
. ,
, , ,
, ,
, , ,
,

.


, .2

,

.
.


.
, ,



.


( )

246______

__________

________

____

.
,
.

,
.
,
,
,
500
. ,

. ,
. ,
,
, ,
-
. ,

(
),


.
;, ,

.
,
,
,
. ,

; ______ ______

______ ____________247

longue duree. ,
, .

,

,

,

, ,
.
, ,
,
.
,
,
,
.

.

I

longue duree. Eric
Hobsbawm,
,
,
.
.3 , 17 18

248

,

,
,
,
.
.

-- ,
.

.4 ,

,
. 1899, , ,

[ ]
[...] ,

.
, . ,
,
Patricia Limerick,
, ,
19


.5

.
, 1988,

249

[...] []

, ,
.
,
,
-
, ,

-
:
.6 ,
20


,
,

,

, .
,
,
- ,
.





.
.

250________ ____________

_________ ________

____ ;

,

.
, -
- ,

. ,

.
,
.
,
,


.7


. ,
.

, -


- - .8


. ,

,

,

, ,
-- . ,

. ,
1759,
. ,


, , ,
..

.9


: ,

,
.
,

.
Dominic Lieven,



.10

1750 ,
, -

.

20

.. , ,
,
.
,

,
.
,

.
,

, ,
.
, J.R. Seeley,

.



.11
,
,
, ,
.


, ,


.
, ,
,
. , ,

. ,
,


.
. ,

1750

.12
. -

-

, - -
. , ,
,

, 20 -
-

;13 ,
.

254

II
:

,
,
,
. (
) - ,
,
Philip Morgan-
. ,
- -

, ,

. ,
1930,


,
, , ,

.14


, ,

.
,
.
.

______ ____________

____

255

, ,


.

,
:
, . ,
, ,
,

.

, , ,
. ,

,
,
.
, ,
.
David Armitage,


, ,



,

.15
.

256



1770 1780, ,

, . ,


.
, .16
,
( ) -
-
1793-1815
.
1815 ,
,
.17


, ,
,
. 1857 ,

,

, .

,
,
, , ,

.'

;______________________

257



,
.

. ,
,
17 , .
,
,

. ,

,
( )
. ,
.
Lewis Namier John Brooke,

,
18 19 ,

.19

.


.
.20
,
,

258


. ,
,

: , .

. , ,
( )

. , ,

.
, .

. ,

. , , ,


, ,


.
,
;,
,
, .21
,
,


,
.

,

. , , 1776
, ,

. ,
, 1815, ,
. ,
19 , ,
, 35% ,
20
80% ,
-

,
.22 ,
,
1914, ,
,
. ,


,
.

Ill
:

,
. ,
, :

. C.A. Bayly,
, ,

, ,
.
, ,

.

,
,

.23
.
0 , , ,


,
,
, ,
.

-

;________

_______________________ 261

. , , ,
, /
, / . , ,

,

.
, ,
.


: -

-

.
.

,
, .


.

.

.

,

262____________________________________________________ ;



, ,

.


.24
,
.
3.000
- - 3,7
.
6

, -

1947- 1,2
. ,
125.000
.
.
. ,

,

. ,

, , . 20
,
125
.25


,
.
,

, .
, - - ,
. 1715,

,
,
,

. 1850,
,

,
.26
19
.
, , CNN, youvx, non
,
.
,
,
, .


,
.

264


-

.

,

- ,
,
-

.


,
, ,


.27
,
- -

, ,

. :


,
, ,
. , /
,
,

265



( ),

. .
Kenan Malik
,

, .
, ,

.28
,


. ,
,
.

IV
.
(
) ;
.


.

,
. - -


, ,
-

longue duree
. .
.
: ,
,
.

.



,

.

,
.
, ,
,

( ),
( )

,

,
, ,

;____________

_________________ 267

, ,
,
. ,
. ' .. Carr
,
,


, .
, Carr,
[...] [
] ,
.29 .
,
,

,
- -

,
. ,
;
: .


I.
,
1960 . ,
,
, -
Africa and the Victorians, : Macmillan, 1961, R.

268_________________________

_____________

Robinson J. Gallagher, A. Denny-


,

.
2. , . Dane Kennedy, Imperial History and PostColonial Theory, Journal o f Imperial and Commonwealth History 24 ( 1996), a.
345-363 , , The Boundaries o f O xfords Empire, Inter
national History Review 23 (2001), . 604-622.
3. Eric Hobsbawm, The Age o f Empire, 1875-1914 (: Weidenfeld
and Nicolson, 1987), . 60 [. .: , 1875-1914,
. , , 2000].
4. . David Armitage, The Ideological Origins o f the British Empire,
: Cambridge University Press, 2000, . 100-145.
5. Frederic Bancroft ( .), Speeches, Correspondence and Political Papers o f
Carl Schurz, 6 , : G.P. Putnams, 1913, . VI, . I 19-120.

, . William Cronon, George Miles Jay
Gitlin ( .), Under an Open Sky: Rethinking Americas Western Past,
: W .W . Norton, 1992.
6. Edward Said, Yeats and Decolonization, : Field Day, 1988, . 2.

Donald
Quataert, The Ottoman Empire, 1700-1922, : Cambridge University
Press, 2000, Dominic Lieven, Empire: The Russian Empire and its Rivals,
: John Murray, 2000.
7. Lieven, .., . 17.
8.

, : . Anthony
Pagden, Lords o f all the World: Ideologies o f Empire in Spain, Britain and France
c. 1500-c. 1800, : Yale University Press, 1995.
9. . Richard W hite, The Middle Ground: Indians, Empires, and Republics in
the Great Lakes Region, 1650-1815, : Cambridge University Press,
1991.


.
10. . Lieven, Empire, ..
I I. The Expansion o f England, : Macmillan, 1883.

12. Dane Kennedy


2, .
13. , Richard Evans,
- -

.
14. J.C. Van Leur, Henk Wesseling, Overseas
History, Peter Burke ( .), New Perspectives on Historical Writing,
: Polity Press, 1992, o. 74 D. Morgan, Encounters between British
and Indigenous Peoples, c. 1500-c. 1800, Martin Daunton Rick
Halpern ( .), Empire and Others: British Encounters with Indigenous People
1600-1850, : University College London Press, 1999, . 68.
15. Armitage, The Ideological Origins, ., . 13.
16. . Emma Rothschild, Kings
,

17. J.E. Cookson, Political Arithmetic and W ar in Britain, 1793-1815,


War & Society, . I (1983), . 37-60 Philip Harling Peter Mandler,
From Fiscal-Military State to Laissez-faire State, 1760-1850, Journal o f Brit
ish Studies 32 (1993), . 44-70.
18. Michael W . Doyle, Empires, : Cornell
University Press, 1986, . 287.
19. . History o f Parliament The House o f Commons 17541790, 3 , : HMSO, 1964, . I, . 138-145 R.G. Thorne
( .), The History o f Parliament The House o f Commons 1790-1820, 5 ,
: Seeker & Warburg, 1986, . I, . 306-313.
20. , . Hew Strachan, The
Politics o f the British Army, : Clarendon Press, 1997.
21.

, .

Captives: Britain, Empire, and the World 1600-1850, : Jonathan Cape,


2002.

22. James D. Tracy ( .), The Political Economy o f Merchant Empires,


: Cambridge University Press, 1991, . 163.
23. C.A. Bayly, Returning the British to South Asian History: The Limits
of Colonial Hegemony, South Asia, . XVII (1994), . 1-25.
24. Captives, ..
25. Norman Davies, Europe: A History, : Oxford University Press,
1996, . 1068-1069.

26. J.A. Houlding, fit for Service: The Training o f the British Army 1715-1795,
: O xford University Press, 1981, . 7-8 Miles Taylor, The 1848
Revolutions and the British Empire, Past & Present 166 (2000), . 150-151.
27.
( ) A.G. Hopkins, Back to the Future: From
National History to Imperial History, Past & Present 164 (1999), . 198-243.
28. Kenan Malik, The Meaning o f Race: Race, History and Culture in Western
Society, : Macmillan, 1996, . 231-232.
29. E.H. Carr, What is History?, : Macmillan, 1961, . 145, 147.

9
: ;
Felipe Fernandez-Armesto
.. Carr

.1
What is History?, -
19 - ,
. ,
- , ,
-

.
, , , ,

,
, , ,
. -
-
,


,
, ,
. ,

1 /1 _____________________________

______________

, - -
-
Carr :
"
,2
, ,
,
. , Carr,

-
(
),
Hugh Trevor-Roper 1963 , [...] ,
[...].

[...]. .3
,

,
.
,


:
.4
, -

: ;_______

______________

______

_ 273


. , , :
. .
,
.
,
,
, . ,
, , , , , ,
, ,

.

I
'
.
. .
,


. ,
,
. .
, :

,
.

274

,
, :


.
.

.
,
-, , -
.



.
.
.
,
,
,
,

.
.
:
, .
.

.


: de haut en bas5

: ;____ ________ _______

_____

_________ 275



.

.
,

.
, ,
-
-
.
.
:
,
,

Sydney Pollard

1930.


.

1896,
,
,
,
.
.

.

276

,
.
;
,

.
Carr ,

.
,
Isaiah Berlin, Hugh TrevorRoper, A.J.P. Taylor .. : ,

,
.

.
-- (
), -
.6 Carr
. ,

;
;.
Carr
.

;
.
, .

: ;_______ _____ ________________ _________ 277

- -
. ;
. ,
.


,
.
. , Carr,
,
. Carr
, ,
.

nihil humanum alienum7
todo es historia,8

. ,
, , .


, .
, .

-

.
.
- , ,

278______

________

_______

____________

. ,

. ,

.

, . .. Carr,
,
.

-

.
. -
, ,
,


.
, ,

. ,
.
,
.
.9
. ,
Carr,
,
,
.
,

: ;______________________

____

______

279



,

,

.
.


,

.10 ,


.



.
,

16

,
, .11
:

280

______________

________

__

________ ;

,
, .
-
- Carr
, ,
,
.



- , ,


,
Luigi Cavalli-Sforza.12

.
.
,

.13
,
,
. ,
,
;
, ;
.

. ,

, ,
, .

: ;


, ,
,
.

II

;
;. Carr
,
. ,
, , ,
Carr
.
,
,
, .

,
.

,


. , ,
;
.


,

282

, .
Carr ,
Carr .14
,
,
.
.
. -

. , .
, .
,
Carr
, -
Alice Kessler-Harris-

. Carr
: , ,


.

,
Richard Evans,

.15 Carr
,
.
,
, ,
-

: ;



. . .
.
Carr

. ,

.
;,
, ,
,
.
, :
,
,

.
: ,
, .
,
,
.
,
, , .
,
,
,
-
Miri
Rubin .

284

.
,

.
,

:

. ,
.

Carr ,
, :
.
,
, ,
.

. Halbwachs



.16

:
,
.
,
.
, ,
.
Alan Baddeley,

: ;

285


.17
.
. . ,
Jack Goody,18

, ,
,

.
.
: ,
, .
.
, ,

,
.

,
:
, Daniel Schachter,
:

.



.
[] , .


. ,

286 ____

____

______

___

_____ ____ ________



, .19


.
,
,
.20 ,
, -
-
, . , ,
,
.
,
Carr
. London School
of Economics,
. ,
, ,
, .. Carr,
: .
Felix qui potuit rerum cognoscere causes.2I
,
,
.
,
.
,
.

.
-

: ;

287

.
.
LSE
.

Carr, ,

,
.
^ , ,
.
,
, ,
, .
.
,

.
16 ,
.

, , .
,
,
. .
.
Carr - , , , -

_____

____

______

____ ____________



.
Carr
.


,
, ,

.
.

Elizabeth Hallam-Smith 70%

. , ,
.
,

,

.

.
,

.
,

: ;

,
.

fonctionnaires22.

.
. - ,

. Carr

,

,
. A.J.P. Taylor
, .
Kenneth Clark .
Jacob Bronowski
.23
.
,
. David
Starkey, Simon Schama
.
Ad Familiares, Paul Cartledge ,
,
.
, ,
Richard Evans
.
.
.
.

290

________ ______

____ _____________ ________



.
.
'

-

.
,

,
,
.

,
.
,
,
,
. .
,

,

.
-
,

.
-
-
,

: ;

.
, ,

.
Millennium,
,


.
,
, ,
,
,
. ,
, .
.
.

:
Millennium,
.


.
,
.
,

.
;, . , ,

. ,

292

T IJ IN A I ;


,
,
. , , , ,

.
,

.
,
. ; ,
,
,
-

.
. ,
,

-
- ,
. ,
,
, .


1. .. Carr, What is History?, : 1964, . 42.
2. . W olf, Europe and the People without History, : 1982.
3. H R.. Trevor-Roper, The Rise o f Christian Europe, : 1965, . 9.

: ;

293

4. F. Fern4ndez-Armesto, Truth: A History, : 1997 R.J. Evans, In


Defence o f History, : 1997.
5. . (...)
6. : infotainment. (...)
7. . (...)
8. . (,..)
9. ,

. (...)
10. F. Ferniindez-Armesto, The Stranger-Effect in Early Modern Asia,
Itinerario xxiv 2 (2000), . 84-103.
11. F. Fernandez-Armesto, Continuity and Discontinuity in the SixteenthCentury New World. The James Ford Bell Lectures, ap. 39, : 2001,
. 18.
12. L. Cavalli-Sforza, History and the Geography o f Human Genes, : 1994.
13. F. Fern andez-Armesto, Civilizations: Culture, Ambition and the Trans
formation o f Nature, : 2001, . 4.
14. Carr, W hat is History?, .., . 24, 97.
15. Evans, In Defence, .., . 76-78.
16. M. Halbwachs, The Social Frameworks of Memory, On Collective
Memory, : 1992, . 96-124. . P. Burke, History as Social
Memory, T. Butler ( .), Memory: History, Culture and the Mind,
: 1989, . 97-113.
17. A Baddeley, The Psychology o f Memory, : 1992. . D.
Rubin ( .), Autobiographical Memory, : 1986 J. Prager, Presenting the
Past Psychoanalysis and the Sociology o f Misremembering, /: 1998.
18. J. Goody, Memory in Oral Tradition, The Power o f the Written
Tradition, : 2000, . 26-46.
19. D .L Schachter ( .). Memory Distortion: How Minds, Brains and
Societies Reconstruct the Past, /: 1995, . x.
20. Prager, Presenting the Past, .., . 185 Schachter, Memory Distortion,
.., . 17-18.
2 1. .
(...)
22. . (...)
23. Rita Bronowski, .


,
.
The Pleasures
o f the Past, History in our Time, The Rise and Fall o f Class in Britain
Ornamentalism: How the British Saw their Empire.
Historical Research Reviews in History.
O


Gonville and Caius. ,
In Defence o f History
, ,
Telling Lies about Hitler.
O


Clare,

.
The Greeks, Democritus and Atomistic Politics The Greeks:
Crucible o f Civilization,
. Cambridge Illustrated
History o fAncient Greece - Key
Themes in Ancient History Classical Inter/Faces. [

, :
,
: , :
, - ,
: , ]

Gonville and Caius .


Liberty, Right and Nature,
On the Power o f Emperors and Popes.
H

Leverhulme

London School of Economics and Pol


itical Science.
Richard . Colgate ,
.
Britons:
Forging a Nation, 1707-1837, Wolfson.


. Family Pol
icy and tiie Origins o f the Welfare State: Britain and France, 1914-45
After the Victorians: Private Conscience and Public Duty in Modern
Britain, Peter Mandler.

Leverhulme
Merton.
.
Europe: Privilege and
Protest 1730-1789, Women and the Limits o f Citizenship in the French
Revolution The Prospect Before Her: A History o f Women in West

ern Europe, I: 1500-1800. [


, ]


Queen Mary
.
. Corpus Christi: The Eucharist in Late Medieval Culture
Gentile Tales, - Framing Medieval Bodies.

The New Penguin History o f Britain.
H

.
-
, In
Pursuit o f Equity: How Gender Shaped American Economic Citizenship.
- Protecting Women: Labor Legislation
in Europe, Australia and the United States, 1880-1920 (1995)
U.S. History as Womens History ( 1995).

Queen Mary .
Civilizations: Culture, Ambition and the
Transformation o f Nature, Millennium: A History o f the last Thousand
Years Truth: A History and a Guide for the PerpJexed

.. C arr
;


,


.

; Carr
21 ,
Cannadine.
David Armitage
;


.
Norman Davis

.
Roy Porter
- ,
,
.
,

,

.
Asa Briggs