Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mike Fallon had looked forward to going home for Christmas. He was about to
graduate from a large state university with a degree in accounting and a minor in
information technology. Since he wanted to work in a CPA firms tax division, he had
even taken a retailing class. After all, he would be dealing with retail customers with
his tax work. Still, the last thing he wanted to do at Christmas was discuss school
subjects. However, that is just what happened when the family got together for
Christmas dinner at his uncles home.
Mikes mothers youngest brother was a church deacon, and somehow he
changed the subject to the fact that so many nonparishioners wanted to use his
church for weddings. Most of these requests were declined because of the demand
by his current members. Somebody mentioned that with the number of people
without church affiliation increasing across the country, she had seen a number of
wedding chapels being built in middle- to large size cities. Thats when Uncle Bob
took you back to your school work, especially that retailing class.
Uncle Bob was the familys funeral director. He and his two sons owned and
operated the only locally owned mortuary in a city of 75,000. Over the past decade,
he pointed out, his business had been radically changed. No longer do folks want a
traditional funeral, complete with casket and burial at the local cemetery. Now, a
third of all funerals involved a no-frills cremation and maybe a social event
instead of a religious service. Since he is planning to remodel, he wants to know
what you think about his scrambled merchandising idea.
Bob then explains that he is thinking of eliminating the chapel with its stained
glass and pews and using the space for a multipurpose family center complete
with a catering kitchen in the back where the flower room used to be and adding a
12-foot screen for multimedia memorial presentations. In addition, he wants to
partner with a law firm to assist families with estate planning and making wills.
Finally, he questions whether he should just remodel the chapel with its current drab
entranceway into something brighter and cheerful, complete with an entryway
removed from the funeral home. By doing so, he could use the chapel for weddings
for the couples who were unable to locate a church.
Questions
1. Do you think coules would mind being married in a chapel located near a
funeral home, even if it had a separate entrance and was beautifully
decorated?
2. What would happen to those families who want a traditional funeral in a
chapel? Would your uncles lose their business?
3. What other creative ideas would you suggest your uncle?
4. What other data would you suggest that your uncle consider before making
any decision?
5. What should your uncle do?
Sears and Lands End also seemed at odds in their pricing strategies, and
ignored the differences in behavior among catalog shoppers and instore customers.
While the Lands End catalog places only limited amounts of merchandise on sale at
any given time, bricks & mortar stores have to observe local conditions and sales
seasons more carefully. For example, Sears stores in Sunbelt states maintained full
price on Lands End winter coats through March- when temperature easily hit the
70s and 80s. One executive stated that Lands End should not go on sale right
now. This was fine for the upper Midwest but not the Southern stores!
Recently when Sears executive examined the tepid sales of Lands End
merchandise in many stores, they concluded that an upscale customer was not
ready to shop at Sears, and that Lands End merchandise in stores should be scaled
back.
Unfortunately, this action will lead to further disappointment for the Lands End
customer base.
Questions:
1. Based on your knowledge of the two retailers, prepare a SWOT analysis for
each of them prior to the Sears takeover. Based on your SWOT analysis, what
are the pros and cons of the takeover?
2. What is the best strategy for Sears to use with Lands End?
3. Can a retailer seek to satisfy two different target markers, as Sears tried to do
with Lands End?
4. Should Sear sell off Lands End?
On entering the meeting, Pam Donnelly went directly to the point. She had
spent the past two weeks, before anyone knew who she was, roaming
throughout the mall and asking questions. Now she was proposing answers. Her
major task was to generate an increase in the traffic of buyers, not just visitors
who used the mall for social gatherings. To achieve this, she proposed the
following:
1. Remove half of the benches in the malls common area so that the mall could
rent this space to various seasonal vendors, such as costume jewelry over
Halloween. After all, during her tours of the mall she noticed that only the
elderly appeared to be using the benches, and she felt their prime purchasing
days where likely behind them. Besides, the vendors would not only attract
additional customers but also provide the mall with incremental revenue to
fund various new promotions.
2. Since it was doubtful that another large department store would move into
the current vacant space, she proposed subdividing half that space into
smaller stores that would feature products that would appeal to minority
groups, such as the trade areas large Latino population. The remaining space
would be used for some type of amusement area or park where mothers
could leave their children while they shopped.
3. Starting the next month, Ms. Donelly said that she wanted all shoppers
younger than 17 to have adult supervision on Friday and Saturday nights. She
claimed the policy was an attempt to create family- oriented atmosphere.
Donnelly said other malls, including the Mall of America, had already adopted
this idea, and it was the result of feedback from shoppers, retailers, and
community leaders. She added that she planned to beef up security to
enforce this policy.
4. Finally, since she felt the mall should be attracting a younger customer, she
was going to discontinue the policy of opening the common area at 6 A.M.
each morning for senior walks. She pointed out that this in no way
communicated that seniors were not welcomed at the mall but that it would
reinforce that malls image of having a family-oriented atmosphere.
Questions:
1. Based on Chapters discussions of both the creative and analytical approach,
are Pam Donnellys ideas sufficiently creative to attract new business (sales),
and what analysis should have undertaken before making these
recommendations?
2. What do you think of each of Pam Donnellys ideas? What population and
social or economic trends support your conclusion(s)? why?
3. Because she is the manager of the malls largest store, not only will other
managers look to Pat Snyder for advice but also she carries considerable
influence with Ms. Donnelly. What should Pat Snyder do? Why?