This is the 10-31-13 Court Order removing the minor child from the care and custody of the mother, Laura Beth Fleming (DOB 1-16-68) after a hearing occurred on that day and it was determined that Laura Fleming had her ex-husband falsely arrested so that he could not attend. The hearing proceeded despite the husband's absence and the court determined that the couple's daughter was "in imminent danger of physical and emotional harm while living in the home of the mother". The order goes on to state that "the Guardian Ad-Litem testified that "in his expert opinion as a Child Psychologist, the minor child is likely to become the victim of more domestic violence (at the hand of the mother Laura Beth Fleming) to include the potential of HOMICIDE should she remain in the mother's home."
The Guardian Ad-Litem further testified that the father, (James McLynas) is a "fit and proper parent" The Order goes on to determine "the mother did not rebut the expert's testimony and at times agreed with it and admitted the violence in her home". The Court further determined that "the mother further admitted under oath to being untruthful with police officers in the past". She also testified that she "Classified the 911 calls as a joke". The Court also determined that "the mother self reports that she suffers from PTSD but was unable to remember the name or the physical location of the doctor that diagnosed her ad testified that she takes Zoloft for this condition but was unable to remember the name of her prescribing physician or where or how she gets these medical prescriptions filled.
This is the 10-31-13 Court Order removing the minor child from the care and custody of the mother, Laura Beth Fleming (DOB 1-16-68) after a hearing occurred on that day and it was determined that Laura Fleming had her ex-husband falsely arrested so that he could not attend. The hearing proceeded despite the husband's absence and the court determined that the couple's daughter was "in imminent danger of physical and emotional harm while living in the home of the mother". The order goes on to state that "the Guardian Ad-Litem testified that "in his expert opinion as a Child Psychologist, the minor child is likely to become the victim of more domestic violence (at the hand of the mother Laura Beth Fleming) to include the potential of HOMICIDE should she remain in the mother's home."
The Guardian Ad-Litem further testified that the father, (James McLynas) is a "fit and proper parent" The Order goes on to determine "the mother did not rebut the expert's testimony and at times agreed with it and admitted the violence in her home". The Court further determined that "the mother further admitted under oath to being untruthful with police officers in the past". She also testified that she "Classified the 911 calls as a joke". The Court also determined that "the mother self reports that she suffers from PTSD but was unable to remember the name or the physical location of the doctor that diagnosed her ad testified that she takes Zoloft for this condition but was unable to remember the name of her prescribing physician or where or how she gets these medical prescriptions filled.
This is the 10-31-13 Court Order removing the minor child from the care and custody of the mother, Laura Beth Fleming (DOB 1-16-68) after a hearing occurred on that day and it was determined that Laura Fleming had her ex-husband falsely arrested so that he could not attend. The hearing proceeded despite the husband's absence and the court determined that the couple's daughter was "in imminent danger of physical and emotional harm while living in the home of the mother". The order goes on to state that "the Guardian Ad-Litem testified that "in his expert opinion as a Child Psychologist, the minor child is likely to become the victim of more domestic violence (at the hand of the mother Laura Beth Fleming) to include the potential of HOMICIDE should she remain in the mother's home."
The Guardian Ad-Litem further testified that the father, (James McLynas) is a "fit and proper parent" The Order goes on to determine "the mother did not rebut the expert's testimony and at times agreed with it and admitted the violence in her home". The Court further determined that "the mother further admitted under oath to being untruthful with police officers in the past". She also testified that she "Classified the 911 calls as a joke". The Court also determined that "the mother self reports that she suffers from PTSD but was unable to remember the name or the physical location of the doctor that diagnosed her ad testified that she takes Zoloft for this condition but was unable to remember the name of her prescribing physician or where or how she gets these medical prescriptions filled.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE SIXTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
OF THE STATE OF FLORIDA IN AND FOR PINELLAS COUNTY
LAURA MCLYNAS, CASE NO. 12-FD-006464
CASE NO. 10-FD-007346
Petitioner, vision: 25
and.
JAMES MCLYNAS,
Respondent.
TEMPORARY ORDER ON HEARING OF OCTOBER 31, 2013
THIS CAUSE came on to be heard on October 31, 2013, before the Honorable Patricia
Muscarella, upon the Guardian Ad Litem’s Motion for Hearing. Present before the Court were
the Petitioner, LAURA MCLYNAS, the Respondent's Attorney, CARIN M. CONSTANTINE,
(Co-Counsel for the Respondent SCOTT ORSINI, ESQ. was not present in the Courtroom but
was available telephonically) and the Guardian Ad Litem, DR. ROBERT EVANS. The
Respondent, JAMES MCLYNAS, was unavailable to attend the hearing and was thus excused
by the Court due to his arrest on an unrelated matter and his inability to obtain a release before
the Hearing and inability to obtain a Telephonic Hearing. The Court, having reviewed the file
and the argument of counsel, having taken sworn testimony, assessed the creditability and
demeanor of the witnesses, and having been otherwise fully advised in the premises, makes the
following findings of fact:
1, Ithas jurisdiction over the cause, the subject matter herein, and the parties hereto:
2. Pending before this Court is the Petition for Dissolution of Marriage with Minor
Children, case number 10-007346 and a Domestic Violence Injunction, case number
12-006464, among other various Motions and Pleadings that have been heard and
ruled on in the past. In additon, one Pleading contains an Appeal to the 2" DCA that
was not perfected and thus is now not an issue. Various collateral lawsuits are
pending and the original Dissolution case has now been complicated by the actions of
3° parties and the news media coverage of collateral i
ues;
3. A Trial Date has previously been set for December 9, 2013 and shall not be continued
for any reason. All outstanding issues shall be heard at Trial, barring another
Emergency concerning the minor child;
4. There is (1) minor child bor of this marriage, namely, J.M., a 10 year old female;5. The Guardian Ad Litem testified that he spoke to the minor child, her 14 year old
half-sister, the parties and various other professionals involved with the care of the
minor child and based upon these observations made a determination that J.M. is in
imminent danger of physical and emotional harm while living in the Mother's home.
The Guardian ad Litem also testified that there has been significant police
involvement within the last 30 days; that there is proof of Parental Alienation
whereby the Mother has instilled fear into the minor child that the Father is trying to
harm her: and that the level of sibling violence in the home has been elevated to
situation whereby the child is in need of protective services and that he, as a
Mandatory Reporter, is required to make a report to the Abuse Hotline per Florida
law and ethical and legal standards.
6. The Guardian Ad Litem testified that the minor child has been arrested twice in
October 2013, and was Baker Acted in early 2013 and has thus been exposed to
situations that she is not emotionally or psychologically able to cope with and is being
harmed currently by the Mother's inability to maintain adequate control of her
children and the domestic violence within the home.
7. The Guardian Ad Litem testified that, in his expert opinion as a Child Psychologist,
the minor child is likely to become the victim of more Domestic Violence, to include
the potential for homicide should she remain in the Mother's home.
8. ‘The Guardian Ad Litem testified that the father is a fit and proper parent to take over
the Time Sharing and decision making responsibilities of the minor child on a
‘Temporary basis and a permanent basis, but that the minor child still needs
counseling,
9. The Mother did not rebut the Expert’s testimony and at times agreed with it and
admitted to the violence in her home, although she classified the 91 | calls as a “joke”
‘on one occasion.
10. The Mother admits to having her 14year old daughter call 911 to report the actions of
the minor child of this action,
11. The Mother admitted, under oath, to being untruthful with Police Officers in the past
and that she had previously recanted some allegations, but those recantations will
likely have no bearing on the outcome of this case.
12. The Mother self reports that she is suffering from PTSD but was unable to remember
the name or physical location of the medical doctor who diagnosed her and testified
that she takes Zoloft for this condition, but was unable to identify her prescribing
physician and was vague on who refills her prescription.
Therefore it isORDERED AND ADJUDGED as follows:
1. The Responden/Father is hereby GRANTED 100% of the Time Sharing for
the Minor Child on a temporary basis starting on November 1, 2013;
‘The Court has continued the Return Hearing on the Domestic Violence
Injunction until December 9, 2013;
3. The Court GRANTS the Respondent/Father full Decision making authority
for the Minor Child relating to Healthcare, Education, Religion, and other
day-to-day decisions until further Order of this Court, an Order by a Court of
Competent Jurisdiction, or the filing and subsequent Rulings in a Dependency
case.
4, The Mother is GRANTED limited decision making authority should the child
have an emergency when in her sole care and there is no time to contact the
Father.
5. The Court reserves jurisdiction over this cause, reserves jurisdiction to enter
Orders to modify or enforce all previous Orders in this action, and reserves
jurisdietion to enter such other and further Orders affecting attorney's fees and
all other matters and enforcement thereof. The Court reserves jurisdiction to
hear all pending Motions and Pleadings upon proper Notice and reserves
ruling on any issue not specifically addressed in this Order.
DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers, in Clearwater, Pinellas County, Florida this 4th
day of November, 2013.
PATRICIA MUSCARI
Circuit Judge
Copies furnished to:
Ms. Carin M. Constantine, Attorney for Respondent
Petitioner, pro se
Dr. Robert Evans