You are on page 1of 2

CITYOFOAKLANDSECURITYGUARDSERVICESCONTRACTINTERVIEW(4/26/2013)SCORESUMMARY

A1PROTECTIVESERVICES
CRITERIA
Presentation
RelevantExperience
GuardQualification
ProjectKnowledge
ManagementQualifications

ABCSECURITYSERVICE
CRITERIA
Presentation
RelevantExperience
GuardQualification
ProjectKnowledge
ManagementQualifications

BMTINTERNATIONALSECURITY
CRITERIA
Presentation
RelevantExperience
GuardQualification
ProjectKnowledge
ManagementQualifications

RATER1
WEIGHTED
PERCENTAGE
Points
Score
1.50%
10
15.00%
1.50%
9
13.50%
2.00%
9
18.00%
2.50%
10
25.00%
2.50%
9
22.50%
CombinedScore
94.00%

RATER2
Points Score
10
15.00%
9
13.50%
9
18.00%
9
22.50%
9
22.50%
91.50%

RATER3
Points
Score
10
15.00%
9
13.50%
9
18.00%
9
22.50%
10
25.00%
94.00%

RATER1
WEIGHTED
PERCENTAGE
Points
Score
1.50%
8
12.00%
1.50%
9
13.50%
2.00%
10
20.00%
2.50%
8
20.00%
2.50%
9
22.50%
CombinedScore
88.00%

RATER2
Points Score
5
7.50%
9
13.50%
8
16.00%
8
20.00%
9
22.50%
79.50%

RATER3
Points
Score
7
10.50%
8
12.00%
7
14.00%
6
15.00%
9
22.50%
74.00%

RATER1
WEIGHTED
PERCENTAGE
Points
Score
1.50%
5
7.50%
1.50%
8
12.00%
2.00%
7
14.00%
2.50%
7
17.50%
2.50%
7
17.50%
CombinedScore
68.50%

RATER2
Points Score
5
7.50%
7
10.50%
7
14.00%
7
17.50%
7
17.50%
67.00%

RATER3
Points
Score
5
7.50%
5
7.50%
5
10.00%
5
12.50%
5
12.50%
50.00%

Ranking

Score

Total

Average

279.50%

93.17%
Ranking

Score

Total

Average

241.50%

185.50%

80.50%
Ranking

Score

Total

Average

61.83%

CYPRESSSECURITY
CRITERIA
Presentation
RelevantExperience
GuardQualification
ProjectKnowledge
ManagementQualifications

FIRSTALARMSEURITY&PATROL
CRITERIA
Presentation
RelevantExperience
GuardQualification
ProjectKnowledge
ManagementQualifications

Rater1:
Rater2:
Rater3:

PreparedbyMeiChan042913

RATER1
WEIGHTED
PERCENTAGE
Points
Score
1.50%
10
15.00%
1.50%
10
15.00%
2.00%
10
20.00%
2.50%
10
25.00%
2.50%
10
25.00%
100%
CombinedScore

RATER2
Points Score
10
15.00%
10
15.00%
10
20.00%
10
25.00%
10
25.00%
100%

RATER3
Points
Score
10
15.00%
10
15.00%
9
18.00%
10
25.00%
10
25.00%
98%

RATER1
WEIGHTED
PERCENTAGE
Points
Score
1.50%
10
15.00%
1.50%
10
15.00%
2.00%
10
20.00%
2.50%
10
25.00%
2.50%
10
25.00%
100%
CombinedScore

RATER2
Points Score
10
15.00%
9
13.50%
9
18.00%
9
22.50%
9
22.50%
91.50%

RATER3
Points
Score
9
13.50%
9
13.50%
9
18.00%
9
22.50%
9
22.50%
90.00%

JohnMendez
EdSilva
JaneLopez

OaklandPoliceDepartment
PublicWorks,CityofBerkeley
OaklandPublicLibrary

Score

Total

Ranking

Average

298.00%

99.33%
Ranking

Score

Total

281.50%

Average

93.83%