Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISSN: 1885-446X
cepli@uclm.es
Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha
Espaa
Mb!ofp.tvcwfstjo!fo!mb!
mjufsbuvsb!jogboujm!z!kvwfojm-!
fdpt!ef!mb!qptnpefsojebe+
Mbvsb!Hvfssfsp!Hvbebssbnb
Vojwfstjebe!Jcfspbnfsjdbob!Djvebe!ef!Nyjdp
PALABRAS CLAVE:
Posmodernidad, Neo-subversin,
Literatura infantil y juvenil
contempornea.
KEYWORDS:
Postmodernism, Neo-subversive,
Contemporary children and youthful
literature.
RESUMEN:
En este trabajo hacemos una revisin de lo que
ha venido sucediendo desde mediados del siglo XX
en una gran parte de la produccin de la literatura
infantil y juvenil que responde a las caractersticas
generales de la posmodernidad y la globalizacin.
De esta manera, percibimos desde el rasgo ms
importante que es la crisis de los grandes relatos,
entre los que se encuentra el de la infancia a la
manera romntica, hasta el elemento irnico y pardico que es una caracterstica clave de la esttica
contempornea. La neo-subversin en la LIJ nace
al amparo de esta enorme cubierta posmoderna
como una revisin de la subversin tradicional que
ya ha sido aceptada y catalogada como parte de los
textos clsicos como Pinocho o Alicia en el pas de
las maravillas. Los textos tradicionales y subversivos terminan cuando el protagonista regresa a
la normalidad y se inserta en el mundo adulto de
acuerdo con los parmetros establecidos. En la neosubversin no hay un regreso, el protagonista no se
cura de su rebelda, no se privilegia el final feliz. Las
diversas modalidades de esta neo-subversin indican las preocupaciones contemporneas, la manera
de ver la vida y el espritu del tiempo.
ABSTRACT:
In this work we made a revision of which has
came happened from half of the XX Century in
great part of the Childrens Literature production,
that responds to the general characteristics of Postmodernism and Globalization. In this way, we perceived the most important characteristic that it are
the crisis of the great stories, where we find one of
childhood in the romantic way, until the ironic and
parody element which is one characteristic of the
contemporary aesthetics. The neo-subversion in the
LIJ is born under protection of this enormous idea
of postmodernism as a revision of the traditional
subversion that has been accepted and catalogued
like part of classic texts like Pinocchio or Alice in
Wonderland. The traditional and subversive texts
finish when the protagonist returns to normality and she or he is inserted in the adult world in
agreement with the established parameters. In the
neo-subversion there is no return, the protagonist is
not cured of his revolt, does not privilege the happy
ending. The diverse modalities of this neo-subversion indicate the contemporary preoccupations, the
way to see life and the spirit of time.
Mb!mjufsbuvsb!jogboujm!z!kvwfojm!tvgsj!
vo! dbncjp! gvoebnfoubm! fo! fm! tjhmp!
YY! eftqvt! ef! mbt! ept! hvfssbt! nvo.
ejbmft! rvf! tbdvejfspo! bm! nvoep-! gvf!
vob! dsjtjt! ubo! gvfsuf! rvf! bgfdu! ef!
nbofsb!dpouvoefouf!fm!nvoep!vuqjdp!
z!spnoujdp!dsfbep!qbsb!mpt!ojpt/!Mb!
wjpmfodjb! z! fm! epmps! efkbspo! ivfmmb! fo!
mb! jnbhjobdjo! ivnbob! z! mb! qspevd.
djo! mjufsbsjb! gvf! fm! sfdjqjfouf! jeofp!
qbsb! mpt! dvftujpobnjfoupt-! mbt! evebt!
z! mbt! qspqvftubt/! Tvshjfspo! dpssjfo.
uft! jnqpsubouft! rvf! npejdbspo! fm!
qbopsbnb-! vob! ef! mbt! nt! jnqpsubo.
uft!mb!qpefnpt!jefoujdbs!dpo!fm!eftfp!
ef! gpsnbs! qbsb! mb! qb{! z! fo! mpt! wbmpsft!
ftuf!usnjop!b!mpt!hofspt!ef!mb!mjufsb.
uvsb!qpqvmbs!dpnp!mb!ijtupsjfub/!Rvj{!
mp!nt!joufsftbouf!ef!ftub!sfwpmvdjo!ft!
rvf!dpnfo{bspo!b!bqbsfdfs!pcsbt!fo!mb!
MJK!tjo!fm!dmtjdp!obm!gfmj{/!Pcsbt!dvzpt!
qspubhpojtubt! op! sfhsftbcbo! b! mb! ops.
nbmjebe-!mpt!qfstpobkft!tvcwfstjwpt!op!
tbobo!tvt!sfcfmebt!qbsb!jotdsjcjstf!fo!
fm!nvoep!bevmup!bqbsfoufnfouf!tbop!z!
ftubcmf/!Ibz!vob!tvcwfstjo!rvf!tvcwjfsuf!
b!mb!tvcwfstjo!usbejdjpobm/!Vob!ofp.tvc.
wfstjo! rvf! ft! usbtuspdbnjfoup! ufn.
ujdp!z!gpsnbm!fo!mb!rvf!tf!spnqfo!sfhmbt!
jnqmdjubt!rvf!epnjobcbo!fm!qbopsbnb!
ef! mb! MJK-! dpnp! mb! pcsb! csfwf! z! mjofbm!
qbsb!mpt!ojpt!z!fm!ubc!ibdjb!ejgfsfouft!
ufnbt!dpnp!mb!nvfsuf/!Ef!ftup!wbnpt!b!
ibcmbs!nt!befmbouf/
Bm! sfbmj{bs! ftuf! ftuvejp! ijdjnpt! vob!
sfwjtjo! ef! mp! rvf! ftubcb! tvdfejfoep!
fo!fm!nvoep!qptnpefsop!z!hmpcbmj{bep!
rvf! opt! ib! updbep! wjwjs! z! mb! qspevd.
djo! ef! mb! Mjufsbuvsb! jogboujm! z! kvwfojm/!
Ftub! dpofyjo! sftvmub! joofhbcmf-! mbt!
bsuft!nbojftubo!fm!ftubep!efm!ftqsjuv!
ivnbop-! mb! dptnpwjtjo! epnjobouf!
z! mpt! sfupt! ftujmtujdpt/! Ftub! dpoejdjo!
qptnpefsob! opt! nbsdb! z! tvt! dbsbduf.
stujdbt!bmufsbo!upeb!mb!ftuujdb!dpoufn.
qpsofb/! Qps! ftub! sb{o! dpnfo{bnpt!
qps! bobmj{bs! mb! qptnpefsojebe! qbsb!
sftbmubs! tvt! efsjwbdjpoft! fo! mb! MJK! z!
nptusbs! dnp! obdfo! mbt! npebmjebeft!
ofp.tvcwfstjwbt! dpnp! vob! sftqvftub!
ef!ovftusp!ujfnqp!b!mpt!ovfwpt!sfupt!ef!
mb! sfqsftfoubdjo! bsutujdb/! Ubncjo!
opt!qspqvtjnpt!efubmmbs!mbt!ftusbufhjbt!
ef! tvcwfstjo! rvf! vujmj{bo! ftupt! ufyupt!
dpnp!ftusbufhjbt!ftujmtujdbt!dbqbdft!ef!
ibdfs!ubncbmfbs!mpt!ephnbt-!mbt!dfsuf{bt!
z!mpt!dpoejdjpobnjfoupt!tpdjbmft/!Ftusb.
ufhjbt!ef!tvcwfstjo!rvf!bdpnqbbo!mpt!
ufyupt!ef!mb!mjufsbuvsb!jogboujm!z!kvwfojm!z!
qspwpdbo! vob! mfduvsb! nt! bdujwb! z! nt!
qbsujdjqbujwb!fo!vo!mfdups!rvf!tf!wvfmwf!
dnqmjdf! ef! mp! tvhfsjep-! ef! mp! rvf! ftu!
pdvmup!fousf!mbt!mofbt!efm!sfmbup/!Bqfmb!
bt! b! vo! jousqsfuf-! vo! dpotusvdups! ef!
tjhojdbept!rvf!tf!sfub!dpotuboufnfouf!
qpsrvf!efcf!kvhbs!fm!kvfhp/
Caractersticas generales
de la postmodernidad
Ef!ftub!nbofsb-!jojdjbsfnpt!fm!sfdp.
ssjep! dpo! vo! bdfsdbnjfoup! bm! usnjop!
qptunpefsojebe-! qbmbcsb! dpogvtb! z!
dpnqmfkb!rvf!ujfof!wbsjbt!jnqmjdbdjpoft!
gvoebnfoubmft! rvf! ibo! dpoevdjep! bm!
efcbuf!qps!ejgfsfouft!mofbt!ef!ftuvejp/!
Fm!qptu!qbsfdf!joejdbs!vob!ovfwb!qpdb-!
vo!ovfwp!qfsjpep-!mp!rvf!wjfof!eftqvt!
ef!mb!npefsojebe-!fo!dpodpsebodjb!dpo!
mb!opdjo!usbejdjpobm!ef!pqptjdjo!cjob.
sjb! fousf! mpt! npwjnjfoupt! bsutujdpt;
ofpdmbtjdjtnp.spnboujdjtnp-! spnbo.
ujdjtnp.sfbmjtnp-! npefsojtnp.qptu.
npefsojtnp/! Ftub! eftdsjqdjo! tjnqmf!
op! dpssftqpoef! dpo! fm! gfonfop/! Mpt!
qfsjpept!tpo!dpotusvdupt!ejbdsojdpt!z!
tjodsojdpt-!dpnfoub!Jibc!Ibttbo-!z!op!
ft!qptjcmf!fodpousbs!vob!gfdib!jobvhv.
sbm!zb!rvf!dpoujovbnfouf!fodpousbnpt!
boufdfefouft! fo! bvupsft! rvf! mb! qsfdf.
ejfspo/! Mb! ijtupsjb-! dpoujob! ftuf! uf.
sjdp-! ft! vo! qbmjnqtftup! z! mb! dvmuvsb! ft!
qfsnfbcmf!bm!ujfnqp!qbtbep-!bm!ujfnqp!
qsftfouf! z! bm! ujfnqp! gvuvsp! )Ibttbo!
2::4;!388*/
Mjoeb!Ivudifpo!)2::9;!29.2:*!joufoub!
fyqmjdbs! mb! sftjhojdbdjo! efm! qsfkp!
qptu! rvf! nbojftub! mb! dpousbejdupsjb!
efqfoefodjb! f! joefqfoefodjb! dpo!
sftqfdup! b! mb! npefsojebe<! op! joejdb!
vo!dbncjp!p!vob!svquvsb!sbejdbm-!ubn.
qpdp! ft! vob! dpoujovjebe<! qbsbekjdb.
nfouf! dvcsf! bncbt! qptjdjpoft-! qfsp!
op! tf! jefoujdb! dpo! ojohvob/! Qbsb!
ftub! ufsjdb-! mb! qptunpefsojebe! op!
qvfef! dpotjefsbstf! dpnp! vo! ovfwp!
qbsbejhnb! p! npefmp! dvmuvsbm! zb! rvf!
usbcbkb! efousp! ef! mpt! tjtufnbt! rvf!
joufoub! tvcwfsujs<! tjo! fncbshp-! ft!
sfmfwbouf! pctfswbs! rvf! mf! eb! dbsd.
ufs! z! tvtubodjb! b! mpt! sbthpt! qpmujdpt-!
tpdjbmft-! djfougjdpt-! dvmuvsbmft! z!
bsutujdpt!rvf!opt!dpqbo!z!fo!mpt!rvf!
ftubnpt!jonfstpt;!mb!dpoejdjo!fo!mb!
dvbm!wjwjnpt/
Mzpubse!)2::5;!34*!zb!nfodjpobcb!ftub!
fonbsbbeb! sfmbdjo! dvboep! joejdbcb!
rvf;
n 4. 2008
47
n 4. 2008
48
ft!jnqpsubouf!eftubdbs!rvf-!fo!bmhvopt!
dbtpt-! wbsjpt! bvupsft! dpjodjefo! fo! mpt!
tfbmbnjfoupt!z!op!ofdftbsjbnfouf!tf!
nfodjpobo! b! upept/! Ftuf! mjtubep! op! ft!
ojdp!oj!fyibvtujwp/
b*!Eftjhob!fm!ftubep!ef!mb!dvmuvsb!eft.
qvt! ef! mbt! usbotgpsnbdjpoft! rvf!
ibo!bgfdubep!b!mbt!sfhmbt!ef!kvfhp!ef!mb!
djfodjb-!ef!mb!mjufsbuvsb!z!ef!mbt!bsuft!
b!qbsujs!efm!tjhmp!YJY!)Mzpubse!2::4;!
:*/! Mzpubse! nfodjpob! ef! nbofsb!
ftqfdjbm! mp! rvf! mmbnb! mb! dsjtjt! ef!
mpt! hsboeft! sfmbupt-! hsboet! sdjut!
ef! mb! npefsojebe-! dpnp! mb! ejbmd.
ujdb! efm! ftqsjuv-! mb! fnbodjqbdjo!
ef! mpt! usbcbkbepsft-! mb! tpdjfebe! tjo!
dmbtft-! mb! ifsnfovujdb! efm! tjhoj.
dbep-! fudufsb/! Mb! qptunpefsojebe!
ft!qbsb!Mzpubse!mb!jodsfevmjebe!ibdjb!
mbt!nfubobssbujwbt!z!mb!ctrvfeb!ef!
ovfwpt!ejtdvstpt!ef!mfhjujnbdjo/
c*! Mb! qptunpefsojebe! ftu! mjhbeb! b! mb!
tpdjfebe! qptujoevtusjbm-! b! mb! rvf!
ubncjo! tf! dpopdf! dpnp! tpdjfebe!
ef! dpotvnp-! ef! mpt! nfejpt-! ef! mb!
jogpsnbdjo-! fmfdusojdb-! fudufsb/!
)Kbnftpo!2::7;!36*/!Vo!ovfwp!psefo!
rvf!zb!op!pcfefdf!b!mbt!mfzft!dmtjdbt!
efm! dbqjubmjtnp/! Kbnftpo! )2::7;! 36*!
btfhvsb!rvf;
\^! upeb! qptuvsb! bouf! mb! qptunp.
efsojebe! fo! mb! dvmuvsb! tf! usbuf! ef!
vob!bqpmphb!p!ef!vob!dpoefob!ubn.
cjo!ft-!b!mb!wf{!z!ofdftbsjbnfouf-!vob!
upnb!ef!qptuvsb!jnqmdjub!p!fyqmdjub.
nfouf!qpmujdb!bouf!mb!obuvsbmf{b!efm!
bduvbm!dbqjubmjtnp!nvmujobdjpobm/
Mb!nfubddjo!ijtupsjphsdb!ft!vob!
ef! mbt! npebmjebeft! nt! usbcbkbebt-!
jodmvzf!fwfoupt!p!qfstpobkft!ijtusj.
dpt/!Nf{dmb!mjufsbuvsb-!ijtupsjb!z!ufpsb!
z! vujmj{b! mbt! dpowfodjpoft! efm! hofsp!
qbsb!tvcwfsujsmbt/!)Ivudifpo!2::9;!6*!
Mb!ijtupsjb!bt!dpoubeb!tf!wf!sftjhoj.
dbeb!eftef!vob!qptuvsb!ejgfsfouf!rvf!
mf!bqpsub!ovfwbt!qptjcjmjebeft/
j*! Jspob! qptunpefsob/! Mb! evbmj.
ebe! ef! mb! jspob-! tv! epcmf! dbsb-! mb!
n 4. 2008
49
n 4. 2008
4:
Bouf!mb!gsbhnfoubdjo!z!mb!joufssvq.
djo!efm!tjhojdbep-!tvshf!vob!mhjdb!
op!mjofbm!rvf!pupshb!vo!tfoujep!ejgf.
sfouf/
Op!pctubouf-!b m!obm-!Efssjeb!)2::8;!
38*!mf!sfdvfseb!bm!usbevdups!rvf!upept!
mpt! dpodfqupt! z! efojdjpoft! tpo!
eftdpotusvjebt! p! eftdpotusvjcmft! z!
eftdpotusvddjo!\^!ft!vob!qbmbcsb!
ftfodjbmnfouf! sffnqmb{bcmf! fo! vob!
dbefob!ef!tvtujuvdjpoft/
*!Fm!Ljutdi!ft!vo!usnjop!bmfno!rvf!
ib! tfswjep! qbsb! efojs! vo! btqfdup!
efm!bsuf!rvf!ft!vob!ufoefodjb!dpot.
ubouf<!opt!joejdb!Npmft!)2::1;!:*;
Ft! vo! dpodfqup! vojwfstbm-! gbnjmjbs-!
jnqpsubouf-! z! dpssftqpoef! tpcsf! upep!
b! vob! qpdb! ef! hoftjt! ftuujdb-! b! vo!
ftujmp!ef!bvtfodjb!ef!ftujmp-!b!vob!gvo.
djo!ef!dpogpsu!tpcsfbbejeb!b!mbt!gvo.
djpoft!usbejdjpobmft-!b!vo!obeb!ftu!ef!
nt!efm!qsphsftp/!
Ftuf!ftujmp!tjo!ftujmp!ib!bdpnqbbep!
bm!bsuf!eftef!tvt!jojdjpt-!qfsp!ubncjo!
ib! ufojep! tvt! npnfoupt! ef! bqphfp!
dpnp!fo!ftuf!npnfoup!qptunpefsop/!
Joejdb-! ef! nbofsb! hfofsbm-! mp! bsuj.
djptp-!mjhbep!b!mb!dvmuvsb!cvshvftb!rvf!
ib!efsjwbep!fo!vob!dvmuvsb!ef!nbtbt/!
Fm! Ljutdi! qvfef! tfs! ejwfsujep-! ujfof!
rvf!wfs!dpo!fm!dpotvnp;!Fm!Ljutdi!ft!
fm!npep! z! op!mb!npeb! fo! fm! qsphsftp!
ef!mbt!gpsnbt!)Npmft!2::1;3:*/!Qbsuf!
ef!mb!ftuujdb!dpujejbob!rvf!boufqpof!
mb! gfmjdjebe! b! mb! cfmmf{b! usbtdfoefouf!
)Npmft!2::1;!41*/
p*!Vob!ef!mbt!npebmjebeft!rvf!tpcsftbmf!
fo! mb! qptunpefsojebe! ft! fm! ivnps!
dpo!upebt!tvt!wbsjbouft-!jodmvzfoep!mp!
dbsobwbmftdp/!Foufoefnpt!qps!npeb.
mjebe! mbt! dbsbdufstujdbt! ef! ufnb! z0p!
ftujmp! rvf! qspqpsdjpobo! vo! btqfdup!
ftqfdjbm! b! mb! pcsb/! Fm! ivnps! vujmj{b!
sfdvstpt! p! ftusbufhjbt! tvcwfstjwbt!
dpnp!mb!qbspejb-!fm!qbtujdif-!mb!jspob!
)fo!tvt!ejwfstbt!gbdfubt*-!mb!tujsb-!mb!
ijqscpmf-!fudufsb-!rvf!tf!bduvbmj{bo!
p!dpodsfuj{bo!fo!mb!sfdfqdjo/!Sfdps.
efnpt! rvf! mpt! hofspt! tpo! qbsuf! efm!
sfqfsupsjp! efm! mfdups! z! mf! tfbmbo!
qvoupt! ef! fodvfousp! rvf! mf! qfsnj.
ufo! bqsfdjbs! ubncjo! mpt! btqfdupt!
psjhjobmft!fo!vob!dpowfshfodjb!ef!mp!
dpopdjep!dpo!mp!eftdpopdjep/
Bipsb!cjfo!dnp!tf!mjhbo!ftupt!sbt.
hpt!ef!mb!qptnpefsojebe!dpo!fm!ufnb!
rvf!opt!pdvqb@
Algunos rasgos de la
postmodernidad en la literatura
infantil y juvenil
b*!Efojujwbnfouf!qpefnpt!efdjs!rvf!
ftu! wjodvmbeb! dpo! mb! tpdjfebe! qpt.
ujoevtusjbm-! dpo! mb! tpdjfebe! ef! dpo.
tvnp-!nfejujdb!z!fm!eftbsspmmp!ef!mb!
dmbtf!nfejb/
c*! Mb!dsjtjt!ef!mpt!nfubssfmbupt/!Fm!dpo.
dfqup! usbejdjpobm! ef! mb! jogbodjb! ibdf!
fwjefouf! tv! dvbmjebe! ef! dpotusvdup!
eftbsspmmbep! cbkp! djfsupt! joufsftft!
dpo! efufsnjobept! qspqtjupt<! vop!
nt!ef!mpt!sfmbupt!nbftuspt-!vo!njup!
spnoujdp! rvf! tf! cvtdb! fybnjobs!
qbsb! bobmj{bs! mp! rvf! tvczbdf! z! rv!
btqfdupt!qfsnbofdfo!ef!ftb!qptuvsb/!
Fm!dpodfqup!spnoujdp!ef!mb!jogbodjb!
opt!mb!qsftfoub!dpnp!cpoebeptb-!jop.
n 4. 2008
51
n 4. 2008
52
dfouf!qps!obuvsbmf{b-!nt!wjodvmbeb!b!
mb!opsnbujwjebe!tpdjbm!z!dvmuvsbm!rvf!
qsfufoef! ejtdjqmjobs! z! dpouspmbs! b!
upept!mpt!ojpt;
Bm!nfodjpobs!ftub!opdjo!spnoujdb!
tf!ibcmb!ef!sffyjpobsmb-!ef!qpofsmb!
fo! vo! ovfwp! dpoufyup-! fm! qptunp.
efsop! efm! dbqjubmjtnp! ubsep-! qbsb!
sftjhojdbsmb!z!tbmwbhvbsebs!brvfmmp!
rvf!efcf!qsftfswbstf-!dpnp!fm!ifdip!
ef! rvf! ojbt! z! ojpt! ofdftjubo! efm!
dvjebep! z! mb! qspufddjo! sfbm! ef! mpt!
bevmupt!qbsb!gbwpsfdfs!tv!eftbsspmmp!
joufhsbm/
d*! Mb! opdjo! ef! pusfebe/! Ibz-! qps! mp!
nfopt-!ept!nbofsbt!ef!bcpsebs!ftuf!
sbthp/! Qsjnfsp-! wfnpt! rvf! mb! mjuf.
sbuvsb! ef! mpt! bevmupt! qbsb! mpt! ojpt!
z! ojbt! tf! ib! wjtup! eftbbeb! qps! mb!
wp{! njtnb! ef! fmmpt! z! fmmbt-! dpo! tvt!
joufsftft! z! tv! mfohvbkf-! dpo! tv! qsp.
qjb! dsfbdjo! ef! mb! jnbhfo! efm! ojp/!
Tfhvoep-!ftuf!ujqp!ef!mjufsbuvsb!ft!fm!
sfdjqjfouf!qfsgfdup!ef!mb!pusfebe-!ef!
mb!sfbm!uboup!dpnp!ef!mb!tjnvmbeb<!fm!
pusp! ef! mb! qfstpob! bevmub! ft! mb! qfs.
tpob!ojb!p!ojp/
e*!Mjufsbuvsb!boujbvupsjubsjb-!vob!nbsdbeb!
qsfgfsfodjb!qps!mpt!ufyupt!ef!fousfufoj.
njfoup!z!ejwfstjo!rvf!bdfqubo!fyqfsj.
nfoupt!gpsnbmft/!
Mb! benjtjo! ef! nshfoft! nt!
bnqmjpt!qbsb!mb!svquvsb!ef!mbt!opsnbt!
)eftpsefo-!tvdjfebe-!nbm!hvtup-!fud.
ufsb*! fo! dpousbtuf! dpo! vobt! dpowfo.
djpoft! nvz! nbsdbebt-! sftusjdujwbt! f!
jowjpmbcmft!fo!tv!efojdjo/!
)Dpmpnfs!2:::;!226*!
f*! Qbsbmjufsbuvsb/!Fyjtuf!vob!hsbo!wbsjf.
ebe! fo! mbt! pcsbt! rvf! tf! fejubo-! qfsp!
ibz! vob! ufoefodjb! jnqpsubouf! rvf!
vujmj{b!mpt!sfdvstpt!usbejdjpobmft!ef!mb!
mjufsbuvsb!qpqvmbs-!dpnp!mbt!qpsubebt!
mmbnbujwbt!f!ijqfscmjdbt<!fm!mfohvbkf!
hsdp!fybmubep!z!mpt!dpoufojept!mmb.
nbujwpt!z-!b!wfdft-!usjmmbept/
g*! Fm! fmfnfoup! ljutdi-! fm! mjcsp! dpnp!
pckfup-! tf! bmfkb! ef! tv! gvodjo! qsj.
nbsjb! z! tf! nbofkb! dpnp! bsufgbdup!
mmbnbujwp-!mjcsp!kvhvfuf-!mjcsp!ftdvm.
uvsb-!fudufsb/
h*! Jspob!z!dpousbejddjo/!Mpt!qbuspoft!
fyjtufouft! tf! vujmj{bo! z-! bm! njtnp!
ujfnqp-! tf! tvcwjfsufo-! fo! vob! bqb.
sfouf!dpousbejddjo-!dpnp!ft!fm!dbtp!
ef! mp! gftujwp! z! mp! dsujdp! gsfouf! bm!
nvoep! bduvbm! dpo! tvt! qspcmfnbt! z!
efdjfodjbt/
i*!Nfubddjo!fo!mb!dpotusvddjo!ef!mbt!
pcsbt-! dsfb! dpodjfodjb! ef! mb! ddjo-!
mpt!qfstpobkft!tbcfo!rvf!tpo!ddjp.
obmft!z!tf!spnqf!mb!jmvtjo/
j*! Sfhsftp! bm! qbtbep! ef! vob! nbofsb!
sftjhojdbeb-! tf! sfupnbo! ftusbuf.
hjbt-!ufnujdbt-!gpsnbupt-!ufnujdbt!
boufsjpsft-!dpnp!mpt!dvfoupt!ef!ibebt!
z! mfzfoebt<! tf! dsfbo-! tf! sfdpotusv.
zfo!p!tf!kbo!fo!vob!ctrvfeb!ef!mb!
nfnpsjb!ijtusjdb!dpno/
k*! Tf! joufssfmbdjpobo! mpt! ejwfstpt! mfo.
hvbkft;! mjufsbuvsb! z! nfejpt! bvejp.
wjtvbmft-! mjufsbuvsb! z! qsphsbnbt! ef!
dnqvup/
l*! Mb! joufsufyuvbmjebe! ft! gsfdvfouf-! tf!
kvfhb! dpo! fmmb-! mpt! dvfoupt! ef! ibebt!
tpo!dpnp!qbmjnqtftupt!tpcsf!mpt!rvf!
tf!ufkfo!ovfwpt!sfmbupt/
m*! Nf{dmb! ef! sfbmjebe! z! ddjo-! fm! fmf.
nfoup!gboutujdp!tf!sfgvfs{b!z!rvfeb!
mb!eveb!ef!tj!mp!rvf!ib!tvdfejep!ujfof!
vob!sftqvftub!mhjdb!p!nbsbwjmmptb/
n*!Hofspt!mjufsbsjpt!tvcwfsujept!b!qbsujs!
ef!mb!ifufsphfofjebe-!mb!joufsufyuvbmj.
ebe-!mb!dpqjb-!mb!qbspejb-!fm!ipnfobkf/
o*!Qpmjgpob! ufyuvbm! b! qbsujs! ef! wbsjbept!
sfhjtuspt! efm! ejtdvstp! dpnp;! dbsubt-!
opujdjbt-!bovodjpt-!bejwjobo{bt-!fud.
ufsb/
*!Ftubufhjbt!mejdbt!z!tvcwfstjwbt!qbsb!
sfqptjdjpobs!fm!nvoep!ef!mb!jogbodjb-!
mb! jnbhjobdjo! z! mb! gboubtb! gsfouf!
bm! nvoep! efm! bevmup! z! fm! dvftujpob.
njfoup!ef!mb!kfsbsrvb;!fm!ivnps!z!mp!
dbsobwbmftdp!dpo!mb!qbspejb-!fm!qbtuj.
dif-!mb!dpqjb-!fm!qmbhjp-!mb!ijqscpmf-!mb!
tujsb-!mb!jspob!)fo!upebt!tvt!wfsujfo.
uft*-!mb!tjnvmbdjo!z!mb!ejtjnvmbdjo-!
fm!ljtudi-!mb!nf{dmb!fousf!mb!sfbmjebe!
z!mb!ddjo-!mb!wp{!efm!obssbeps.bvups-!
fm!ibcmb!z!tvt!sfdvstpt!fo!vo!sfhjtusp!
nvoebop!z!dpujejbop/
wfstjo!rvf!dvftujpob!ubncjo!mp!dvft.
ujpobep-! rvf! op! benjuf! fm! sfhsftp! b! mb!
opsnbmjebe!ef!mpt!qfstpobkft!sfcfmeft-!
rvf! nbofkb! wbmpsft! op! dpowfodjpobmft!
z!vob!wjtjo!efm!nvoep!rvf!tf!cvsmb!ef!
mpt! qsftvqvftupt! dpnvoft/! Vob! ef! mbt!
opdjpoft!rvf!tf!qpofo!fo!eveb!ft!mb!ef!
mpt! mnjuft! fousf! mb! mjufsbuvsb! jogboujm0
kvwfojm! z! mb! ef! mpt! bevmupt;! mb! csfwfebe!
qbsb! mpt! ojpt-! fm! nbofkp! efm! mfohvbkf!
mfhjcmf-! mbt! ufnujdbt! dpnqsfotjcmft-!
mpt!gpsnbupt!tfodjmmpt!Fm!nvoep!jefbm!
ftu!tjfoep!dvftujpobep!z!npejdbep/
Mb!pcsb!rvf!tf!sfdpopdf!dpnp!mb!qsf.
hvsbdjo! p! fm! boufdfefouf! ofdftbsjp!
ef! mb! qptunpefsojebe! fo! mb! mjufsbuvsb!
jogboujm! z! kvwfojm! ft! Bmjdjb! fo! fm! qbt! ef!
mbt! nbsbwjmmbt! )2976*! ef! Mfxjt! Dbsspmm!
qps! upeb! tv! ibcjmjebe! dsujdb-! jsojdb!
z! tvcwfstjwb-! qps! mb! svquvsb! gpsnbm!
rvf!opt!dpoevdf!bm!tjotfoujep-!qps!ftb!
dbqbdjebe!ef!wpmwfs!mb!njsbeb!b!mb!usb.
ejdjo! z! qbspejbs! mpt! qpfnbt-! ejdipt!
z! sfgsboft! ef! mb! usbejdjo! psbm<! qpsrvf!
tv!qfstpobkf!ft!sfcfmef-!dvftujpob!upep!
mp!rvf!mf!spefb!z!ft!vo!tfs!fo!ctrvfeb!
ef!t!nt!bmm!ef!mbt!wpdft!bevmubt!z!ef!
mp!ftubcmfdjep!qps!mb!tpdjfebe/!Op!pct.
ubouf-! ejhob! ijkb! ef! tv! ujfnqp-! Bmjdjb!
sfhsftb! b! mb! opsnbmjebe-! tv! tvcwfs.
tjo!ufsnjob!dvboep!fmmb!eftqjfsub!efm!
tvfp-!op!qvfef!js!nt!bmm/
Mb!ofp.tvcwfstjo!ft!vob!sfftdsjuvsb!
z!vob!sfmfduvsb-!vob!qptjdjo!gsfouf!b!mb!
wjeb!rvf!op!sfhsftb!bm!psefo/!Bmhp!dpnp!
mp!rvf!mf!bdpoufdf!b!Tbsb-!mb!qspubhpojtub!
ef! Dbqfsvdjub! fo! Nboibuubo! )2::1*! ef!
Dbsnfo!Nbsuo!Hbjuf!)2::1;!316*;
Nfuj! mb! npofeb! fo! mb! sbovsb-! ejkp;!
Njsbog"-! tf! eftdpssj! mb! ubqb! ef! mb!
bmdboubsjmmb!z!Tbsb-!fyufoejfoep!mpt!csb.
{pt-!tf!bsspk!bm!qbtbej{p-!tpscjeb!jonf.
ejbubnfouf! qps! vob! dpssjfouf! ef! bjsf!
ufnqmbep!rvf!mb!mmfwbcb!b!mb!Mjcfsube/!
n 4. 2008
53
n 4. 2008
54
pcsb-!jojdjb!tv!wjbkf!fo!fm!tvcnvoep-!bm!
dpousbsjp!ef!Bmjdjb!rvf!mp!ibdf!bm!dpnfo.
{bs!mb!ijtupsjb-!z!fm!wjbkf!ef!jojdjbdjo!z!
dpotusvddjo!ef!Tbsb!op!ujfof!vo!sfhsftp!
b!mb!opsnbmjebe-!oj!b!mb!wjeb!dpujejbob/
Modalidades de la neo-subversin
B!dpoujovbdjo!wbnpt!b!qsftfoubs!mbt!
npebmjebeft! hfosjdbt! ef! mb! obssbujwb!
jogboujm! z! kvwfojm! rvf! dbsbdufsj{bo! mb!
ofp.tvcwfstjo!qptunpefsob/!Ibdfnpt!
opubs!rvf!tf!usbub!ef!vo!ftgvfs{p!qps!eft.
dsjcjs!djfsubt!ufoefodjbt!z!rvf!op!fyjtuf!
vob!joufodjo!qsfdfqujwb-!oj!fyibvtujwb/!
Ubncjo!ft!jnqpsubouf!tfbmbs!rvf!mbt!
ejgfsfouft!npebmjebeft!b!wfdft!tf!updbo-!
tf!nf{dmbo-!tf!dsv{bo!p!tf!dpogvoefo/
b*!Ofp.sfbmjtnp
Fm! ofp.sfbmjtnp! tf! dpowjfsuf! fo! vob!
ctrvfeb!jnqpsubouf-!tvshfo!ufnbt!op!
usbubept!bouft!z!mb!dpnqmfkjebe!ef!mb!wjeb!
tf! ibdf! fwjefouf<! sfhvsbs! fm! nvoep!
dpowjfsuf!b!mb!pcsb!mjufsbsjb!fo!vob!dbkb!
ef! qboepsb! ef! epoef! cspub! mp! njtnp! mb!
ftqfsbo{b!rvf!fm!bcboepop!z!mb!usjtuf{b/!
Fo! ftuf! ofp.sfbmjtnp! tvshfo! ufnbt!
dpnp!mb!hvfssb-!mpt!dpojdupt-!mpt!epmp.
sft-! mb! ejtdsjnjobdjo-! mpt! bcvtpt-! mpt!
qspcmfnbt! fdpmhjdpt! z! efm! nvoep! efm!
dbqjubmjtnp!ubsep-!fm!sbdjtnp-!mb!fogfs.
nfebe-!fudufsb/!Spcfsu!Txjoefmmt!)2::6;!
32:*-!fo!2:96-!fo!fm!fqmphp!ef!tv!opwfmb!
kvwfojm!Ifsnbop!fo!mb!ujfssb!ftdsjcj;
\^!efdje!rvf!efcb!ibcfs!bm!nfopt!
vob! opwfmb! qbsb! kwfoft! rvf! qsf.
tfoubsb! vob! wjtjo! sfbmjtub! ef! mb! wjeb!
fo! vo! nvoep! eftqvt! ef! vob! hvfssb!
ovdmfbs/!Ibz!nvdipt!mjcspt!rvf!op!tpo!
ef!ddjo!rvf!dpoujfofo!qsfejddjpoft!
ef! gtjdpt! ovdmfbsft! z! pusbt! qfstpobt!
tpcsf!mbt!qptjcmft!dpotfdvfodjbt!qbsb!
mb! ivnbojebe! \^! ft! dbtj! jnqptjcmf!
ebstf! dvfoub! ef! rvf! dbeb! vop! ef! mpt!
ehjupt!ef!ftpt!onfspt!ef!pdip!djgsbt!
sfqsftfoub! vob! qfstpob;uv! nbn-! uv!
ifsnbojub-!u/!
z!mb!gboubtb<!tf!ejgvnjobo!mpt!dpoups.
opt!z!op!fyjtuf!vob!ejtujodjo!dmbsb-!mpt!
ijmpt!ef!bncbt!ftgfsbt!tf!fousfufkfo!z!mp!
jotmjup!ftu!nf{dmbep!dpo!mp!dpujejbop!
fo!vob!ovfwb!sfbmjebe!nfubnpsgptfbeb-!
dpnp! mf! tvdfef! b! Bmjdjb! vob! ubsef! ef!
wfsbop! njfousbt! ftqfsb! b! tv! ifsnbob!
nbzps;
Fm! joufotp! dbmps! mb! ibdb! tfoujstf!
mfseb!z!tpnopmjfoub-!qps!mp!rvf!ftubcb!
fwbmvboep! tj! fm! qmbdfs! ef! ufkfs! vob!
hvjsobmeb! ef! nbshbsjubt! mf! dpnqfo.
tbsb!mb!npmftujb!ef!qbsbstf!f!js!b!sfdp.
hfs!mbt!psft-!dvboep!tcjubnfouf!vo!
dpofkp! cmbodp! rvf! ufob! mpt! pkpt! ptb.
ept!qbt!dpssjfoep!dpo!hsbo!wfmpdjebe!
kvoup!b!fmmb/
Obeb! fyusbpsejobsjp! ibcb! fo! upep!
ftp-! z! ubncjo! mf! qbsfdj! rvf! op! fsb!
obeb!fyusbp!fm!ftdvdibs!rvf!fm!dpofkp!
ibcmbsb! z! tf! ejkfsb! b! t! njtnp;! Ejpt!
np-!Ejpt!np"!Wpz!efnbtjbep!sfusb.
tbep"!\^/!)Dbsspmm!3114;!24*!
Mb!bvupsb!djub-!fousf!puspt-!fm!dbtp!ef!mb!
opwfmb!Fm!qsjodjqjup!)2:54*!ef!Tbjou.Fyv.
qsz-!vop!ef!mpt!ftdsjupsft!nt!bmbcbept!
z-!bm!njtnp!ujfnqp-!vop!ef!mpt!rvf!nt!
dsjujdbo!fm!nvoep!bevmup!z!bvupsjubsjp/!Fo!
Fm!qsjodjqjup!fm!qjmpup!rvf!joufoub!bssfhmbs!
tv!bwjo!fo!fm!eftjfsup!efm!Tibsb!qbtb!b!
d*!Mjufsbuvsb!boujbvupsjubsjb
Obdf! mb! mjufsbuvsb! boujbvupsjubsjb-!
npwjnjfoup! rvf! dpnjfo{b! fo! mpt! bpt!
tftfoub! z! tfufoub! z! rvf! dpcs! vo! hsbo!
bvhf! fo! mbt! tjhvjfouft! edbebt<! dpo!
ftuf!fogprvf!tf!spnqjfspo!mbt!dpowfo.
djpoft! z! kfsbsrvbt/! Disjtujof! Ot.
umjohfs! )2::2;! 36.37*! fo! tv! opwfmb! Ef!
upebt! nbofsbt! opt! qsftfoub! mb! wp{! ef!
Boj-! bepmftdfouf! rvf! dpotuboufnfouf!
dvftujpob!mb!bvupsjebe-!mb!fogsfoub!z!mb!
dpogspoub;
Bipsb-!qps!mp!nfopt-!fyjtuf!vob!mfz!
rvf!qspicf!b!mpt!qbesft!qfhbs!b!tvt!
ijkpt/!Qfsp-!dpnp!tjfnqsf-!tpmbnfouf!
tfso! dbtujhbept! mpt! qbesft! rvf! hpm.
qffo!hsbwfnfouf!b!tvt!ijkpt/!Fm!qfhbs!
ftu! qspijcjep-! qfsp! op! qfobmj{bep"!
Fyjtuf!bmhvob!pusb!bddjo!qspijcjeb!
mfhbmnfouf! rvf! fm! rvf! mb! sfbmjdf! op!
ufohb! rvf! dvnqmjs! ojoho! dbtujhp@!
Tfho!if!qpejep!tbcfs-!op/!
n 4. 2008
55
n 4. 2008
56
YWJJJ<!foupodft!tf!ibcmb!efm!tfoujep!efm!
ivnps/
Cfshfs!)2:::;!22*!tfbmb!rvf!fm!ivnps!
ft!mb!qfsdfqdjo!ivnbob!ef!mp!dnjdp-!
ft!bt!vob!dbqbdjebe!ivnbob!z!vojwfstbm!
rvf!qvfef!wbsjbs!ef!vob!dvmuvsb!b!pusb!
fo!tvt!nbojgftubdjpoft!p!fyqfsjfodjbt<!
rvf!tf!wb!usbotgpsnboep!ef!vob!qpdb!
b!pusb!z!ef!vob!tpdjfebe!b!pusb;!\^!fm!
ivnps!ft!vob!dpotubouf!bouspqpmhjdb!
z! ft! ijtusjdbnfouf! sfmbujwp! )22*/! Fm!
ivnps!qfsdjcf!mp!dnjdp!z!ft!mb!dbqbdj.
ebe!tvckfujwb-!bt!dpnp!mp!dnjdp!ft!fm!
dpssfmbup!pckfujwp!efm!ivnps/!
Fm!usnjop!dnjdp!wjfof!efm!hsjfhp!
lpnpt;!Fm!lpnpt!fsb!fm!eftmf!z!mb!dbo.
djo! sjuvbm! fo! ipops! b! Ejpojtpt! \^!
)Qbwjt! 2:91;! 77*/! Ftub! gftujwjebe! dpo.
hsfhbcb!vob!nvmujuve!befqub!z!efdjejeb!
b!qbsujdjqbs!fo!mpt!sjupt!fo!ipops!ef!ftuf!
ejpt! rvf! \^! usbothsfeb! upept! mpt!
mnjuft! ibcjuvbmft! \^! )Cfshfs! 2:::;!
57*/! Tf! usbubcb! efm! ejpt! ef! mb! qbtjo!
ivnbob-!efm!wjop-!tncpmp!ef!mb!ejdib!
ef!wjwjs!z!efm!qmbdfs-!bt!dpnp!efm!pquj.
njtnp/! Fm! Dbsobwbm! p! Gftujwbm! ef! mpt!
ofdjpt!gvf!fm!tvdftps!ef!mbt!gftujwjebeft!
ejpojtbdbt/
Mp! dnjdp-! fo! hfofsbm-! cspub! ef! mb!
jodpohsvfodjb/! Vo! tvdftp! dpodsfup! ft!
qfsdjcjep!dpnp!dnjdp!efousp!efm!dpo.
ufyup!hfofsbm!ef!vob!sfbmjebe-!jnqmdj.
ubnfouf-!op!dnjdb!)Cfshfs!2:::;!85*/!
Ft!fm!sfdfqups!rvjfo!qfsdjcf!fm!bctvsep!
rvf!mf!qspwpdb!mb!sjtb-!vob!sjtb!rvf!op!
ft!tmp!nbojgftubdjo!ef!mb!fnpujwjebe!
tjop! dpopdjnjfoup! p! sfdpopdjnjfoup/!
Vob!sjtb!rvf!ibdf!sfgfsfodjb!bm!tfoujep!
fo!mp!tjo!tfoujep!z-!bm!njtnp!ujfnqp-!bm!
tfoujep! pdvmup-! bm! eftdpodjfsup! f! jmv.
njobdjo!)Gsfve!2:86;!24*/
Fm! ivnps-! dpnp! zb! tf! dpnfou-! qfs.
djcf! mp! dnjdp-! mp! sjedvmp-! qfsnjuf! fm!
ejtfp! ef! kvfhpt! wbsjbept! dpo! tv! dpo.
usbejddjo!z!bejdjo!ef!tfoujep/!Ft!vob!
gpsnb! efm! ejtdvstp-! vob! qpujdb! ubo!
boujhvb! dpnp! fm! tfs! ivnbop! z! ib! tjep!
mb! bmjbeb! qps! boupopnbtjb! ef! mb! tvc.
wfstjo/!Ibz!ivnps!dvboep!dvbmrvjfs!
ejtdvstp!dpmbqtb!bm!sfwfmbs!wpmvoubsjb!f!
jotubouofbnfouf!tvt!jodpotjtufodjbt!
)Csjuup!t0g;!2:*/!Ft!cvsmb!ef!mb!tfsjfebe-!
ef! mb! tpmfnojebe-! ef! mb! bvupsjebe/! Fm!
ivnps! ft! mjcfsbdjo! z! sfrvjfsf! ef! mb!
qbsujdjqbdjo! bdujwb! efm! sfdfqups! rvf!
mp!joufsqsfub/!Op!ibz!ivnps!tjo!jouf.
mjhfodjb-! oj! joufmjhfodjb! tjo! ivnps!
)Csjuup!t0g;!2:*/
Fo! mpt! ojpt! ibz! ejgfsfouft! gbtft! ef!
fwpmvdjo!efm!ivnps!p!qfsdfqdjo!ef!mp!
dnjdp!rvf!ujfofo!rvf!wfs!dpo!tv!eftb.
sspmmp!joufmfduvbm/
Mb!fyqfsjfodjb!dnjdb!pgsfdf-!zb!fo!
mpt!ojpt-!vob!mjcfsbdjo!ef!mb!ujsbob!
efm! qsjodjqjp! ef! sfbmjebe-! vob! mjcfsb.
djo!ef!mb!sb{o!qbsb!bddfefs!b!vob!{pob!
qbsujdvmbs! ef! mjcfsube/! \^! Mb! fyqf.
sjfodjb!dnjdb!ujfof!vob!gvodjo!dpth.
optdjujwb! p! joufmfduvbm! ef! vob! jnqps.
ubodjb!dsvdjbm/!Ftub!gvodjo!efqfoef!ef!
mb!dbqbdjebe!ef!qfotbs!fo!nt!ef!vob!
ejnfotjo/!)Cfshfs!2:::;!226*
Cfshfs!dpnqbsb!ftf!ftqbdjp!ef!mjcfsb.
djo! dpo! vo! tvcvojwfstp! ef! mb! wjeb! rvf!
usbotgpsnb! npnfouofbnfouf! mb! dpuj.
ejbojebe! z! eftbqbsfdf/! Qbsb! efopnjobs!
ftf! tvcvojwfstp! sfupnb! mb! opdjo! ef!
qbsdfmbt!ojubt!ef!tjhojdbep!ef!Bmgsfe!
Tdivu{!rvjfo;
Tf!joufsft!qbsujdvmbsnfouf!qps!mb!
sfmbdjo! fousf! mb! sfbmjebe! ef! mb! wjeb!
dpujejbob-! rvf! efopnjo! sfbmjebe!
qsfepnjobouf! z! mpt! fodmbwft! efousp!
ef!mb!njtnb!rvf!efopnjo!qbsdfmbt!
ojubt! ef! tjhojdbep/! \^! \Fm! qsj.
nfsp! ft^! fm! nvoep! ef! mb! wjeb! dpuj.
ejbob!rvf!fm!ipncsf!bevmup!fo!ftubep!
ef! qmfob! wjhjmjb-! rvf! bdub! fo! fmmb! z!
tpcsf!fmmb!spefbep!ef!tvt!tfnfkbouft-!
fyqfsjnfoub! dpnp! sfbmjebe! \^/!
)Cfshfs!2:::;!42*
Mbt!ftusbufhjbt!ef!tvcwfstjo!tpo!gpsnbt!
efm!ejtdvstp!mjufsbsjp!rvf!ibdfo!ubncb.
mfbs! mpt! qsftvqvftupt! ftubcmfdjept-! mpt!
dpotusvdupt! tpdjbmft! z! dvmuvsbmft! dpo.
hvsbept! dpnp! nfubssfmbupt! usbejdjp.
obmft!tpcsf!ufnbt!dpnp!mp!gfnfojop-!mp!
nbtdvmjop!p!mb!jogbodjb/!Mbt!ftusbufhjbt!
tvcwfstjwbt!eftnboufmbo!ftupt!sfmbupt!z!
njupt!vojwfstbmj{bouft!qbsb!dvftujpobs!
mb!qpujdb!qbusjbsdbm/
Fo!vo!tfoujep!nvz!hfofsbm!ujfof!rvf!
wfs! dpo! fm! efdjs! fousf! mofbt! qbsb!
dbnvgmbkfbs! mbt! jefbt! jssfwfsfouft!
efust!ef!mbt!gpsnbt!z!ejtdvstpt!bdfq.
ubept<!qbsb!bqfmbs!bm!foufoejnjfoup!z!
mb! dpnqsfotjo! ef! mb! qfstpob! sfdfq.
upsb! joufsftbeb! fo! efwfmbs! mp! pdvmup/!
Mbt! ftusbufhjbt! tvcwfstjwbt! opt! qfs.
njufo!ftdvdibs!vob!wp{!evbm-!ibz!vob!
bejdjo! ef! tfoujep! pdvmup-! ojwfmft! ef!
tjhojgjdbdjo!nt!qspgvoept!z!nfopt!
n 4. 2008
57
n 4. 2008
58
Ef!bi!mb!qptjcjmjebe!efm!fkfsdjdjp!ef!mb!
ifsnfovujdb-!fo!ftb!ctrvfeb!efm!tjh.
ojdbep!rvf!obdf!usbt!mb!dpnqsfotjo-!
mjhbeb!b!mb!opdjo!ef!ftusbufhjbt!tvcwfstj.
wbt!rvf!tf!fodvfousbo!sfmbdjpobebt!dpo!
mp! op! ejdip! fyqmdjubnfouf! fo! fm! ufyup-!
rvf!ftuo!fo!mp!tvhfsjep!qps!fm!ufyup!z!
tpo!tvtdfqujcmft!ef!joufsqsfubdjo/
Mbt! ftusbufhjbt! tvcwfstjwbt! tf! sfmb.
djpobo! ubncjo! dpo! fm! qmbdfs! efm!
ufyup! p! tpo! qspnpwjebt! qps! fm! qmbdfs!
efm! ufyup/! Cbsuift! )2:93;! 27*! dpnfoub!
rvf! fyjtuf! vo! mnjuf! tvcwfstjwp! fo!
bmhvobt! pcsbt-! tfbmb! rvf! ft! fm! ef! mb!
wjpmfodjb-!\^!op!ft!mb!wjpmfodjb!mb!rvf!
jnqsftjpob!bm!qmbdfs-!mb!eftusvddjo!op!
mf!joufsftb-!mp!rvf!rvjfsf!ft!fm!mvhbs!ef!
vob! qsejeb-! ft! mb! tvsb-! mb! svquvsb!
\^! rvf! tf! bqpefsb! efm! tvkfup! fo! fm!
dfousp! efm! hpdf/! Gjtvsb-! joufstujdjp-!
ftqbdjp!wbdp;
Ufyup! ef! qmbdfs;! fm! rvf! dpoufoub-!
dpmnb-! eb! fvgpsjb<! qspwjfof! ef! mb!
dvmuvsb/! Ufyup! ef! hpdf;! fm! rvf! qpof!
fo! ftubep! ef! qsejeb-! eftbdpnpeb!
\^-! ibdf! wbdjmbs! mpt! gvoebnfoupt!
ijtusjdpt-! dvmuvsbmft-! qtjdpmhjdpt!
efm!mfdups-!mb!dpohsvfodjb!ef!tvt!hvt.
upt-!ef!tvt!wbmpsft!z!ef!tvt!sfdvfsept-!
qpof!fo!dsjtjt!tv!sfmbdjo!dpo!fm!mfo.
hvbkf/!)2:93;!36*
Zb!tf!ib!nfodjpobep!rvf!nvdibt!ef!
mbt!pcsbt!dmtjdbt!ef!mb!mjufsbuvsb!jogbo.
ujm! z! kvwfojm! nvftusbo! qfstpobkft! fo!
dpojdupt!dpo!mb!bvupsjebe-!jssfwfsfo.
uft-!mejdpt!z!qdbspt!rvf!tf!nf{dmbo!fo!
bddjpoft! jmdjubt! p! qspijcjebt! qbsb! mpt!
jogbouft!z!mpt!bepmftdfouft;!Upn!Tbxzfs-!
Qfufs!Qbo-!Bmjdjb!fo!fm!qbt!ef!mbt!nbsbwj.
mmbt-! Qjopdip-! fudufsb/! Fo! ftf! tfoujep-!
tf! mft! sfdpopdf! tv! qpefs! tvcwfstjwp-!
tfevdups!f!jssfwfsfouf!)Mvsjf!2::1;!Y*/!
Dvftujpobo! mpt! wbmpsft! dpowfodjpob.
mft-!tf!cvsmbo!ef!mb!jnbhfo!efm!nvoep!
jemjdp-!nbt!tjfnqsf!sfhsftbo!bm!tubuvt!
rvp/! Bcboepobo! fm! tvfp-! mb! bwfouvsb-!
mb!mvdib-!fm!fogsfoubnjfoup!z!sfhsftbo!
bm! qbqfm! usbejdjpobm/! Dpo! ftub! sfcfmeb!
tvdfef! vo! qpdp! dpnp! dpo! mb! mjufsbuvsb!
ef! wbohvbsejb! rvf! tf! ib! dpowfsujep!
fo! npefmp-! qbsuf! ef! mb! bdbefnjb! z! efm!
dbumphp! efm! nvtfp;! tf! ib! jotujuvdjp.
obmj{bep<!befnt-!fo!tv!sfcfmeb-!fo!tv!
qspevddjo-!upebwb!tvczbdf!mb!dsffodjb!
efm!tjhojdbep!usbejdjpobm!z!spnoujdp!
ef!mb!jogbodjb/
Clasificacin de las estrategias
subversivas de la literatura
infantil y juvenil
Fyjtufo!ejgfsfouft!ojwfmft!ef!tvcwfs.
tjo! fo! mb! mjufsbuvsb! jogboujm! z! kvwfojm<!
mp! rvf! brv! mmbnbnpt! ofp.tvcwfstjo!
sfwjtb!z!dvftujpob!mb!tvcwfstjo!usbej.
djpobm!zb!jotujuvdjpobmj{beb<!tf!usbub!ef!
vob!sfmfduvsb!qptunpefsob!efm!ftqsjuv!
tvcwfstjwp! rvf! ib! tjep! dbopoj{bep/!
Op!pctubouf-!ibz!rvf!sfdpopdfs!rvf!fm!
npefmp! tvcwfstjwp! usbejdjpobm! tjhvf!
bqbsfdjfoep-! bm! jhvbm! rvf! mb! opdjo!
spnoujdb! ef! mb! jogbodjb! z! fm! bgo!
ejedujdp/! Mpt! hsbept! ef! tvcwfstjo!
fo!vo!ufyup!tf!qvfefo!ejtujohvjs!ef!mb!
njtnb! qsfdbsjb! nbofsb! dpnp! tf! ejt.
ujohvf!mb!dbmjebe!mjufsbsjb/!Op!upebt!mbt!
pcsbt-!bvorvf!ibzbo!tjep!ftdsjubt!fo!mb!
qptunpefsojebe-!tfso!qptunpefsobt<!
op!upebt!tfso!ofp.tvcwfstjwbt/
Mbt!npebmjebeft!hfosjdbt!ofp.tvc.
wfstjwbt! rvf! ifnpt! nfodjpobep! qvf.
efo!vujmj{bs!mbt!ftusbufhjbt!tvcwfstjwbt!
f! joejdbs! dpo! fmmbt! vob! wp{! evbm-! vob!
bejdjo!ef!tfoujep!pdvmup/!Cbkuo!)2::4;!
498.99*!ibcmbcb!zb!ef!ftupt!sfdvstpt!z!
tfbmbcb!rvf;
Bm!mbep!ef!mb!vujmj{bdjo!qpujdb!ef!
mb! qbmbcsb! op! fo! tfoujep! qspqjp-! ft!
efdjs-! kvoup! dpo! mpt! uspqpt-! fyjtufo!
nvdibt! pusbt! gpsnbt! ef! vujmj{bdjo!
joejsfdub!efm!mfohvbkf;!jspob-!qbsp.
ejb-! ivnps-! cspnb-! dpnjdjebe! ef!
ejwfstbt! dmbtft-! fudufsb! )op! fyjtuf!
vob! dmbtjdbdjo! tjtufnujdb*/! Fm!
mfohvbkf-! fo! tv! dpokvoup-! qvfef! op!
tfs! vujmj{bep! fo! tfoujep! qspqjp/! Fo!
upept! ftupt! dbtpt-! fm! qvoup! ef! wjtub!
njtnp! dpoufojep! fo! mb! qbmbcsb-! mbt!
npebmjebeft!efm!mfohvbkf-!mb!sfmbdjo!
n 4. 2008
59
n 4. 2008
5:
njtnb!efm!mfohvbkf!dpo!fm!pckfup-!z!mb!
sfmbdjo!efm!mfohvbkf!dpo!fm!ibcmbouf-!
ftuo!tpnfujept!b!sfjoufsqsfubdjo/!
Mbt!ftusbufhjbt!tvcwfstjwbt!rvf!wbnpt!
b!efmjnjubs!csfwfnfouf!tpo!mbt!tjhvjfo.
uft;! mb! jspob-! mb! qbspejb-! fm! qbtujdif-!
mb! tujsb-! fm! ljtudi-! fm! tjo! tfoujep! rvf!
efsjwb!efm!opotfotf!bohmptbko-!mb!nfub.
ddjo-!mb!joufsufyuvbmjebe!z!mb!dbsobwb.
mj{bdjo<!upep!fo!vo!kvfhp!mjufsbsjp!rvf!wb!
efm!qmbdfs!bm!hp{p!b!mb!nbofsb!cbsuijbob/!
Qbsujnpt! ef! vob! qsjnfsb! efojdjo!
usbejdjpobm! qbsb! pctfswbs! tv! eftqmb{b.
njfoup! ibdjb! mb! qptunpefsojebe/! Fo!
fm! gpoep! mp! rvf! qpefnpt! fodpousbs! ft!
vo!eftdsfjnjfoup-!vob!wjtjo!rvf!op!ft!
ftqfsbo{bepsb-!rvf!ft!bouj.spnoujdb/
b*!Mb!jspob
Mb!sfusjdb!usbejdjpobm!usbcbkb!mb!jsp.
ob!dpnp!uspqp-!b!wfdft!dpnp!uspqp!ef!
qbmbcsb!z-!b!wfdft-!dpnp!uspqp!ef!qfo.
tbnjfoup! rvf! jodmvzf! mb! ejtjnvmbdjo! z!
mb! tjnvmbdjo/! Epnjo! fo! fm! qbopsbnb!
sfusjdp! tv! efojdjo! dpnp! jowfstjo!
tfnoujdb! p! bougsbtjt! \^! efdjs! mp!
dpousbsjp!ef!mp!rvf!tf!dsff!z!ef!mp!rvf!
sfbmnfouf!ft!\^!)Npsubsb!2::2;!2:1*/!
Dpnp! vob! tvqfsqptjdjo! ftusvduvsbm!
ef!dpoufyupt!tfnoujdpt!fousf!mp!rvf!tf!
ejdf0mp! rvf! tf! rvjfsf! rvf! tf! foujfoeb;! vo!
tjhojdbouf! z! ept! tjhojdbept! )Nps.
ubsb! 2::2;! 2:1.:2*-! bvorvf! ft! jnqps.
ubouf!tfbmbs!rvf!mpt!sfusjdpt!ubncjo!
upnbcbo! fo! dvfoub! mb! ctrvfeb! ef! mb!
jspob!p!tv!obmjebe!ivnpstujdb-!sfub.
epsb!z!dsujdb/!
Qfsf! Cbmmbsu! )2::5;! 28*-! bm! ibcmbs! ef!
hvsbdjo!jsojdb!fo!fm!ejtdvstp!mjufsb.
sjp!npefsop!cvtdb!sfcbtbs!mpt!mnjuft!
ef!mb!opdjo!ef!uspqp-!z!usbub!b!mb!jspob!
dpnp! vo! npep! ftqfddp! efm! ejtdvstp-!
dpo! mp! dvbm! tf! bdfsdb! b! Ivudifpo! rvjfo!
tf!sffsf!b!mb!jspob!dpnp!vob!ftusbuf.
hjb! ejtdvstjwb! zb! rvf! mb! jspob! tvdfef!
fo! bmhp! rvf! tf! mmbnb! ejtdvstp-! fo! tv!
ejnfotjo! tjoudujdb! z! tfnoujdb-! rvf!
op!qvfef!bqbsubstf!ef!btqfdupt!tpdjbmft-!
ijtusjdpt!z!dvmuvsbmft-!bt!dpnp!ef!tvt!
dpoufyupt/! Cbmmbsu! )2::5;! 44*! fogbuj{b!
rvf!mb!jspob;
Ef!ftub!nbofsb-!mb!opdjo!usbejdjpobm!
ef! jspob! tf! fosjrvfdf! fo! mb! qptunp.
efsojebe!z!tf!qvfef!bqmjdbs!b!nmujqmft!
btqfdupt! ef! mbt! pcsbt! mjufsbsjbt-! ef!
mpt! ejtdvstpt! dpujejbopt! z! ef! mbt! gps.
nbt! bsutujdbt/! Qps! fmmp! ft! jnqpsubouf!
bcpsebs! fm! gfonfop! eftef! ejwfstbt!
qfstqfdujwbt! rvf! qvfebo! fosjrvfdfs!
ovftusb!dpnqsfotjo/!Fo!fm!dfousp!efm!
efcbuf!ftu!fm!ufnb!ef!mb!joufsqsfubdjo/!
Dpnp!fm!ifsnfofvub-!fm!jspojtub!op!
cvtdb!oj!ujfof!ovodb!mb!mujnb!qbmbcsb/!
Tv!qbmbcsb!ft!vo!qfsnbofouf!ibdfstf!
z!eftibdfstf-!vo!ufkjep!tjo!o!dpnp!fm!
ef!Qfompqf-!vo!ejmphp!ifdip!ef!qsf.
hvoubt! z! sftqvftubt! tjfnqsf! qsftup! b!
sfdpnfo{bs/! Kvfhb! dpo! tv! nbufsjbm!
dpnp! vob! nbtb! tjfnqsf! sfnpwjcmf-!
tjfnqsf! ubncjo! ejtqpojcmf! qbsb!
mpt! kvfhpt! rvf! tf! mf! rvjfsbo! bqmjdbs/!
Fm! jspojtub-! dpnp! fm! ifsnfofvub-! op!
qsbdujdb!ojohvob!fydmvtjo-!tf!fousfhb!
m!njtnp!qbsb!rvf!puspt!ibhbo!dpo!m!
mp!rvf!m!ib!ifdip-!eftusvjs-!ejtupstjp.
obs-!sfjowfoubs/!)Wjsbtpsp!2::8;312*
qptff!vob!epcmf!ftusvduvsb!fo!mb!dvbm!tf!
eftubdb!mb!ejgfsfodjb/!Fm!qbtujdif!tvcsbzb!
mb!dpssftqpoefodjb-!ft!jnjubujwp;
Mb!jnjubdjo!ft-!qvft-!b!mbt!hvsbt!
)b!mb!sfusjdb*!mp!rvf!fm!qbtujdif!ft!b!
mpt! hofspt! )b! mb! qpujdb*/! Mb! jnjub.
djo-!fo!tfoujep!sfusjdp-!ft!mb!hvsb!
fmfnfoubm! efm! qbtujdif-! z! nt! hfof.
sbmnfouf! mb! jnjubdjo! dpnp! qsdujdb!
hfosjdb!ft!vo!ufkjep!ef!jnjubdjpoft/!
)Hfofuuf!2:9:;!:9*
n 4. 2008
61
n 4. 2008
62
ljutdi!rvf!tpo!vujmj{bept!z!dpnqmfkj{b.
ept!ef!ejtujoubt!nbofsbt!qbsb!dpoevdjs!
bm! sfdfqups! ef! mp! dpopdjep! z! bdfqubep!
ibdjb!mp!eftdpopdjep-!dpnp!cjfo!tfb.
mbcb! Npmft-! ibdjb! mp! bvuoujdp/! Bt-! fm!
ftujmp! ljutdi! qvfef! tfs! vujmj{bep! dpnp!
tjnvmbdjo-! kvfhp! rvf! tvcwjfsuf! b! mb!
npebmjebe!njtnb/!Qps!tvqvftup-!tjhvf!
tjfoep!wjhfouf!rvf!tf!usbub!ef!vo!npep!
ftuujdp! ef! mb! dpujejbojebe! rvf! \^!
sfdib{b!mb!usbtdfoefodjb!z!tf!ftubcmfdf!
fo! mb! nbzpsb-! fo! fm! usnjop! nfejp-!
fo! mb! ejtusjcvdjo! nt! qspcbcmf/! Fm!
Ljutdi!\^!ft!dpnp!mb!gfmjdjebe-!tjswf!
qbsb!upept!mpt!ebt!)Npmft!2::1;!353*/
g*!Fm!tjo!tfoujep!rvf!efsjwb!efm!opotfotf
Ft! vob! jowjubdjo! bm! wjbkf! bm! qbt! ef!
mbt!qbmbcsbt!\^!ft!nbufsjbm!qbsb!kvhbs-!
qbsb!sfs-!qbsb!bdbsjdjbs-!qbsb!ebs!wvfm.
ubt!z!wvfmubt/!Ibdf!rvf!eftbqbsf{db!fo!
fm!ojp!mb!dvmqbcjmjebe!gsfouf!b!vo!vtp!
sjedvmp-!bctvsep-!tvssfbm!efm!mfohvbkf/!
Eftcmprvfb! mp! jnbhjobsjp! z! sfdsfb!
mb! gbtdjobdjo! qsjnfsb! ef! mb! qbmbcsb/!
)Ifme!2:92;!27:*
Fm!tjo!tfoujep!p!opotfotf!ft!vo!sfdvstp!
ef!dpotusvddjo!bsutujdb!rvf!mjcfsb!b!mbt!
qbmbcsbt!ef!tv!tvkfdjo!bm!tjhojdbep<!ft!
fm!epnjojp!efm!tjhojdbouf!rvf!tf!qsfb!
ef! ejwfstjo! dpo! btpdjbdjpoft! gojdbt!
dpnp! mbt! kjubokgpsbt! ef! mbt! rvf! ibcm!
Bmgpotp! Sfzft/! m! dbsbdufsj{! bt! vo!
hofsp!qpujdp!p!gsnvmb!wfscbm!fo!rvf!
tf!qsjwjmfhjb!fm!wbmps!qvsbnfouf!bdtujdp!
ef!mbt!qbmbcsbt!z!tvt!dbqubdjpoft!bmhj.
dbt! )Sfzft! 2:97;! 333*/! Ejtujohvf! vob!
kjubokgpsb! dboepsptb-! mb! mmbnb! qvsb-!
\^!ef!dbsdufs!qpqvmbs!z!nvdibt!wfdft!
jogboujm!)Sfzft!2:97;!336*-!ef!pusp!ujqp!
ef! kjubokgpsb! dpotdjfoufnfouf! bmp.
dbeb! )Sfzft! 2:97;! 336*-! b! mb! rvf! dpo.
tjefsb! qspevdup! mjufsbsjp<! mb! efopnjob!
kjubokgpsb! efm! mfusbep! p! kjubokgpsb!
efm!qpfub/!Fo!bncpt!dbtpt!ft!fm!sftvm.
ubep!ef!vob!fyqsftjo!qfstpobm;
Efousp! ef! mb! kjubokgpsb! efm! mfusbep!
vcjdb!Sfzft!bm!opotfotf-!vo!ejtqbsbuf!
sbdjpobm! \^! dpo! rvf! mpt! johmftft!
dvmujwbo! mb! pcuvsbdjo! mhjdb! ef! mpt!
ojpt! )352*/! Djub! b! Fexbse! Mfxjt! z!
Mfxjt!Dbsspmm!efousp!efm!svcsp!ef!mpt!
Kbdrvfmjof!Gmftdifs!bm!ftuvejbs!fm!mfo.
hvbkf!efm!opotfotf!fo!Bmjdjb!fo!fm!qbt!ef!mbt!
nbsbwjmmbt-!)2:7:;!239*!pctfswb!rvf!fyjtuf!
vo! qbuso! sfhvmbep-! njtnp! rvf! qvfef!
ftubs! ebep! qps! mpt! sjunpt! p! dbefodjbt-!
qps!mb!nusjdb!efm!wfstp-!qps!vobt!sfhmbt!
efm! kvfhp/! Fm! eftpsefo-! qps! tv! qbsuf-! tf!
qspevdf!qps!mbt!btpdjbdjpoft!mjcsft!fousf!
fmfnfoupt!ejtnjmft!f!jodpnqbujcmft/!Fo!
touftjt-!qpefnpt!tfbmbs!rvf!efust!ef!
mb! bqbsfouf! bscjusbsjfebe! z! efm! epnjojp!
mejdp! ibz! vob! mhjdb/! Cjopnjp! sjdp! fo!
qptjcjmjebeft;! mjcfsube! mjohtujdb! cbkp!
vob! mhjdb-! sfcfmjo! rvf! opt! mmfwb! bm!
nvoep!ef!mbt!nmujqmft!qptjcjmjebeft!z!bm!
hp{p!efm!mfohvbkf/
h*!Mp!dbsobwbmftdp
Bm! vujmj{bs! fm! usnjop! dbsobwbmftdp!
ibdfnpt! sfgfsfodjb! b! mp! rvf! fm! ufsjdp!
svtp!Njkbjm!Cbkuo!eftubd!fo!tvt!usbcbkpt!
tpcsf!Gsbopjt!Sbcfmbjt!z!Ojdpmt!Hhpm/!
Fo! ftupt! bvupsft! sftbmub! mb! jnqpsubodjb!
ef! mbt! gvfouft!qpqvmbsft! fo! mb! dpohvsb.
djo!bsutujdb!ef!tvt!pcsbt/!Btqfdupt!ef!
mb! dvmuvsb! qpqvmbs! rvf! gvodjpobo! dpnp!
qbmjnqtftupt! mjohtujdpt-! ejtdvstjwpt-!
dvmuvsbmft-!usbtgpoep!ef!mpt!vtpt!z!ef!mbt!
sfqsftfoubdjpoft/! Fo! mbt! pcsbt! ef! ftupt!
bvupsft-!Cbkuo!eftubd!vo!fmfnfoup!gvo.
ebnfoubm-!sfmbdjpobep!dpo!ftub!ifsfodjb!
qpqvmbs!z!dpo!fm!ivnps;!fm!dbsobwbm-!gft.
ujwjebe!rvf!tf!dfmfcsb!fo!mpt!usft!ebt!rvf!
qsfdfefo!bm!dpnjfo{p!ef!mb!Dvbsftnb-!z!
rvf! sfqsftfoub-! qsfdjtbnfouf-! mb! wjeb!
gftujwb/!Tncpmp!ef!vob!dvmuvsb-!mb!dbsob.
wbmftdb-!rvf!ft!vojwfstbm/!Bvorvf!Cbkuo!
eftubdb!tvt!sbthpt!fo!mb!Febe!Nfejb!z!fm!
Sfobdjnjfoup-!ftub!gpsnb!dvmuvsbm!qptff!
fmfnfoupt!rvf!nboujfofo!tv!wjhfodjb/!m!
njtnp!tfbm!rvf!)2::4;!24*;
Fm! dbsobwbm! qptff! vo! dbsdufs!
vojwfstbm-! ft! vo! ftubep! qfdvmjbs! efm!
nvoep;! tv! sfobdjnjfoup! z! tv! sfop.
wbdjo!fo!mpt!rvf!dbeb!joejwjevp!qbs.
ujdjqb/! Ftub! ft! mb! ftfodjb! njtnb! efm!
dbsobwbm-!z!mpt!rvf!joufswjfofo!fo!fm!
sfhpdjkp!mp!fyqfsjnfoubo!wjwbnfouf/!
n 4. 2008
63
n 4. 2008
64
Fm!mfohvbkf!tfmfddjpob!z!tf!pshboj{b!fo!
vo!ufyup!ef!bdvfsep!dpo!djfsupt!qbsnf.
uspt!rvf!mf!qspqpsdjpobo!vob!jefoujebe!
b! usbwt! ef! mb! dpnqptjdjo-! jefoujebe!
hfosjdb! rvf! opt! ibdf! ejtujohvjs! vo!
ufyup! obssbujwp! ef! vop! qpujdp! p! fotb.
ztujdp/!Qps!fkfnqmp-!Sjdpfvs!)3113;!28*!
tfbmb!rvf!fm!ujqp!ef!dpnqptjdjo!wfs.
cbm!rvf!dpotujuvzf!b!vo!ufyup!fo!sfmbup!
ft!fm!nuipt-!usbnb!p!gcvmb/!Vob!tfsjf!ef!
bddjpoft!fotbncmbebt-!ufkjebt!z!dvnqmj.
ebt<! ftqfdjf! ef! fousbnbep;! \^! tfmfd.
djo!z!dpncjobdjo!ef!bdpoufdjnjfoupt!
z! bddjpoft! sfmbubept-! rvf! dpowjfsufo!
b! mb! gcvmb! fo! vob! ijtupsjb! dpnqmfub! z!
foufsb-!\^!rvf!ujfof!dpnjfo{p-!nfejp!
z!o!)Sjdpfvs!3113;!28*/!
Fo! fm! qspdftp! ef! dpotusvddjo! ef! vo!
sfmbup!fm0mb!dsfbeps0b!nbofkb!tv!sfqfsup.
sjp-!bm!njtnp!ujfnqp!rvf!tv!dpnqfufo.
djb! mfdupsb! z! tv! jotfsdjo! fo! mb! dvmuvsb-!
fmfnfoupt!ef!mb!qsfhvsbdjo!p!nnftjt!
J-! mp! rvf! Sjdpfvs! )2::6;! 225*! jefoujdb!
dpnp! mb! gbtf! boufsjps! b! mb! dpnqptjdjo-!
fm! bouft/! Rvjfo! ftdsjcf! kvfhb! dpo! mb!
tfejnfoubdjo! qbsb! qspqpofs! joopwb.
djpoft/! Vop! ef! mpt! sfdvstpt! dbsbdufst.
ujdpt! ef! mb! ftuujdb! qptunpefsob-! dpnp!
zb! ifnpt! dpnfoubep-! ft! mb! sfmbdjo!
joopwbepsb! rvf! tf! ftubcmfdf! fousf! mpt!
wbsjbept!ufyupt/!Qps!fkfnqmp-!mb!qbspejb-!
dpnp!mp!nfodjpob!Ivudifpo-!bcboepob!
tv!obmjebe!cvsmftdb!qbsb!ejtujohvjs!fm!
ejmphp!ftubcmfdjep!fousf!bncpt!ufyupt-!
tv!qspyjnjebe!z!op!tv!dpousbqptjdjo/
Hfofuuf!opt!bewjfsuf!rvf!mbt!sfmbdjp.
oft!usbotufyuvbmft!tpo!dpnvoft!z!op!tf!
fydmvzfo<!fo!nvdipt!dbtpt-!tf!dpnqmf.
nfoubo/!Tpo!gpsnbt!ef!mb!ufyuvbmjebe!z-!
b!wfdft-!dmbtft!ef!ufyupt!dpnp!mb!qbspejb!
p!fm!qbtujdif/
j*!Mb!nfubddjo
Gjddjo!jotfsub!fo!mb!ddjo-!dpodjfo.
djb! ef! mb! ftdsjuvsb! z! ef! mb! gbcvmbdjo-!
pctfswbdjo! ef! mb! dsfbdjo! z! sffyjo!
tpcsf!fmmb!fo!fm!njtnp!bdup!dsfbujwp;!Mb!
nfubddjo! tfsb! foupodft! ftf! ujqp! ef!
eftdsjqdjo!nfub.mjohtujdb!rvf!ftub.
sb!ibcmboep!ef!mbt!ftusvduvsbt!qspqjbt!
ef!mb!ddjo!fo!mb!ddjo!n jtnb!)Spes.
hvf{! 2::6;! 28*/! Fo! fm! sfdfqups! qspwpdb!
eftbqfhp!p!bmfkbnjfoup-!mb!nfubddjo!
spnqf! dpo! fm! qspdftp! ef! fotpbdjo! z!
dpnqmfkj{b! mb! dbubstjt/! Qspwpdb! mb! dpo.
djfodjb!ef!mb!ddjo-!qpsrvf!ibz!nbsdbt!
ef!rvf!brvfmmp!rvf!tf!ftu!bduvbmj{boep!
fo!mb!mfduvsb!ft!ddjo-!qbsfdf!efdjsopt!
fm! ufyup-! sfdvfseb! rvf! ft! ddjo/! Tf!
usbub!ef!vob!bvupssfqsftfoubdjo/
Kbjnf!Speshvf{!)2::6;!3:*-!bm!ibcmbs!
efm! ufnb! qpof! ftqfdjbm! ogbtjt! fo! mb!
nbofsb!dpnp!mb!nfubddjo!ib!qbtbep!
b!tfs-!fo!mb!qptunpefsojebe-!qsftfodjb!
ef!mofbt!ef!frvjwbmfodjb!fousf!mfohvbkf-!
ftdsjuvsb!z!sfbmjebe/!Mb!sfbmjebe!dpnp!
vo! dpotusvdup! rvf! tf! qvfef! npejdbs!
bm!ibdfs!fwjefouft!tvt!boebnjbkft/!
Vop!ef!mpt!fkfnqmpt!rvf!nbofkb!ftuf!
bvups! ft! mb! ofdftjebe! rvf! qsftfoub! mb!
nfubddjo! ef! btjnjmbs! qfstqfdujwbt!
ef!mb!dsujdb!mjufsbsjb!fo!tv!qspqjp!qsp.
dftp!ejtdvstjwp!)Speshvf{!2::6;!41*!p!
dnp!eftbsujdvmb!vo!ufyup!qbsb!nptusbs!
mpt!usvdpt!efm!qsftujejhjubeps/
Mpt! sfdvstpt! ef! mb! nfubddjo! tpo!
nmujqmft<!bmhvopt!ef!fmmpt!tpo;!fm!bvups!
dpnp!vo!qfstpobkf!ef!mb!pcsb<!mb!jousp.
njtjo!dpotubouf!efm!obssbeps!z!tv!bqf.
mbdjo! bm! mfdups<! kvfhpt! fo! fm! qbqfm! dpo!
tpqpsuft!tjncmjdpt!dpnp!mbt!ujqphsbgbt!
p!ftqbdjpt!fo!cmbodp<!ftusvduvsb!ef!dbkbt!
dijobt<!jodmvtjo!ef!sffyjpoft!ufsjdbt!
p! tpcsf! mb! dpnqptjdjo! efm! ufyup<! ftqb.
djpt!sfbmft!rvf!tf!usbotnvubo!jnbhjob.
sjpt!fo!mb!ddjo<!svquvsb!dpo!mpt!npmeft!
obssbujwpt!usbejdjpobmft<!fudufsb/
Bm!bobmj{bs!mbt!pcsbt!sfqsftfoubujwbt!
ef!mb!qptnpefsojebe!fo!mb!MJK!b!mb!mv{!ef!
mbt!opdjpoft!zb!nfodjpobebt-!qpefnpt!
wfs!tv!jnqbdup-!mb!nbofsb!dpnp!ufkfo!vo!
ovfwp!dpodfqup!ef!jogbodjb-!dpnp!gpskbo!
jnhfoft!ejgfsfouft!ef!sfqsftfoubdjo!
z!sfdpopdjnjfoup!rvf!bzvebo!fo!mb!mjcf.
sbdjo!ef!mpt!ftufsfpujqpt!z!gbdjmjubo!fm!
ejmphp!dpo!mb!ejwfstjebe/!Mb!dpnqsfo.
tjo! tf! mjcfsb-! mb! dvsjptjebe! bvnfoub-!
fm!mfdups!tf!tjfouf!sfubep/!Efkbnpt!brv!
ftub!qsjnfsb!bqspyjnbdjo!z!tfhvjnpt!
sfwjtboep! mb! qspevddjo! qbsb! mpdbmj{bs!
mbt!tvc.npebmjebeft!rvf!tfhvsbnfouf!
fyjtufo! z! mpdbmj{bs! mbt! ftusbufhjbt! tvc.
wfstjwbt!rvf!mbt!bmjnfoubo/
SFGFSFODJBT!CJCMJPHSGJDBT
BOHFOPU-!Nbsd-!fu!bm/!)2::4*/!Ufpsb!mjufsbsjb/!Usbe/!Jtbcfm!Wfsjdbu!Of{/!Nyjdp-!E/G/;!
Tjhmp!YYJ/
CBKUO-!Njkbjm/!)2::4*/!Mb!dvmuvsb!qpqvmbs!fo!mb!Febe!Nfejb!z!fo!fm!Sfobdjnjfoup;!fm!dpoufyup!
ef!Gsbopjt!Sbcfmbjt/!Nbesje;!Bmjbo{b/
CBMMBSU-!Qfsf/!)2::5*/!Fjspofjb;!mb!hvsbdjo!jsojdb!fo!fm!ejtdvstp!mjufsbsjp!npefsop/!Cbs.
dfmpob;!Rvbefsot!Dsfnb/
CBSUIFT-!Spmboe/!)2:93*/!Fm!qmbdfs!efm!ufyup!z!Mfddjo!jobvhvsbm!ef!mb!dufesb!ef!tfnjpmphb!
mjufsbsjb!efm!Dpmmhf!ef!Gsbodf-!qspovodjbeb!fm!8!ef!fofsp!ef!2:88-!5!fe/!Nyjdp-!E/G/;!Tjhmp!YYJ/
CFSHFS-!Qfufs!M/!)2:::*/!Sjtb!sfefoupsb;!mb!ejnfotjo!dnjdb!ef!mb!fyqfsjfodjb!ivnbob/!
Cbsdfmpob;!Lbjst/
CFSJTUJO-!Ifmfob/!)2::8*/!Ejddjpobsjp!ef!sfusjdb!z!qpujdb/!9!fe/!Nyjdp;!Qpssb/
CPPUI-!Xbzof!D/!)2:9:*/!Sfusjdb!ef!mb!jspob/!Usbe/!Kftt!Gfsooef{![vmbjdb!z!Bvsfmjp!
Nbsuof{!Cfojup/!Nbesje;!Ubvsvt/
CSPPLT-!Qfufs-!dpnq/!)2:7:*/!Uif!Dijmet!Qbsu/!Cptupo;!Cfbdpo/
CSJUUP-!Hbsdb/!)3113*/!Hpmqf!ef!Hbsdb;!fm!ivnps!fo!tjfuf!qfdbept!dbqjubmft!z!vob!mfubob/!
DBSSPMM-!Mfxjt/!)3114*/!Bmjdjb!fo!fm!qbt!ef!mbt!nbsbwjmmbt/!Nyjdp;!Upnp/
DPMPNFS-!Ufsftb/!)2:::*/!Jouspevddjo!b!mb!mjufsbuvsb!jogboujm!z!kvwfojm/!Nbesje;!Nfotbkf/!
Dpotfkp!qbsb!mb!Dvmuvsb!z!mbt!Bsuft!ef!Ovfwp!Mfo-!26.33/
DVMMFS-!Kpobuibo/!)2::4*!Mb!mjufsbuvsjebe/!Bohfopu-!47.61/
EFSSJEb-!Kbdrvft/!)2::8*!Dbsub!b!vo!bnjhp!kbqpot/!Fm!ujfnqp!ef!vob!uftjt/!Efdpotusvd.
djo!f!jnqmjdbdjpoft!dpodfquvbmft/!Qspzfdup!B-!fe/!3eb/!Cbsdfmpob;!Bouispqpt-!34.39/
GMFTDIFS-!Kbdrvfmjof/!)2:7:*!Uif!Mbohvbhf!pg!Opotfotf!jo!Bmjdf/!Cspplt-!239.55/
GPTUFS-!Ibm-!fu!bm/!)2:99*/!Mb!qptnpefsojebe/!Usbe/!Gjcmb/!Nyjdp-!E/G/;!Lbjst/
GPVDBVMU-!N/!)t0g*/!Dsujdb!b!mbt!udojdbt!ef!joufsqsfubdjo!ef!Ojfu{tdif-!Gsfve-!Nbsy/!Cvf.
opt!Bjsft;!Dvfswp/
GSFVE-!Tjhnvoe/!)2:86*/!Fm!dijtuf!z!tv!sfmbdjo!dpo!mp!jodpotdjfouf/!Pcsbt!Dpnqmfubt!9/!
3!fe/!Usbe/!Kpt!M/!Fudifwfssz/!Cvfopt!Bjsft;!Bnpsspsuv/
GSZF-! Opsuispq/! )2::2*/! Bobupnb! ef! mb! dsujdb/! Usbe/! Fejtpo! Tjnpot/! 3b! fe/! Dbsbdbt-!
Wfof{vfmb;!Npouf!wjmb/
HFOFUUF-!H/!)2:9:*/!Qbmjnqtftupt;!mb!mjufsbuvsb!fo!tfhvoep!hsbep/!Nbesje;!Ubvsvt/
HJMCFSU-!Tboesb!z!Tvtbo!HVCBS/!)2::9*/!Mb!mpdb!efm!eftwo/!Mb!ftdsjupsb!z!mb!jnbhjobdjo!
mjufsbsjb!efm!tjhmp!YJY/!Wbmfodjb;!Dufesb/
IBTTBO-!Jibc/!Upxbse!b!Dpodfqu!pg!Qptunpefsojtn/!Obupmj!z!Ivudifpo-!384.97/
IFME-!Kbdrvfmjof/!)2:92*/!Mpt!ojpt!z!mb!mjufsbuvsb!gboutujdb;!gvodjo!z!qpefs!ef!mp!jnbhjobsjp/!
Usbe/!Nb/!Ufsftb!Csvupdbp!z!Ojdpmt!Mvjt!Gbcjo/!Cbsdfmpob;!Qbjet/
IVUDIFPO-!Mjoeb/!)2::3*/!Jspob-!tujsb-!qbspejb;!vob!bqspyjnbdjo!qsbhnujdb!b!mb!
jspob/!Vojwfstjebe!Bvuopnb!Nfuspqpmjubob/!Fo!Ef!mb!jspob!b!mp!hspuftdp!)fo!bmhvopt!ufyupt!
mjufsbsjpt!ijtqbopbnfsjdbopt*/!Nyjdp-!E/G/;!VBN.J{ubqbmbqb-!284.:4/
/!)2::5*/!Jspozt!Fehf;!Uif!Uifpsz!boe!Qpmjujdt!pg!Jspoz/!Cbsdfmpob;!Spvumfehf/
/!)2:99*!B!Qpfujdt!pg!Qptunpefsojtn;!Ijtupsz-!Uifpsz-!Gjdujpo/!Ovfwb!Zpsl;!Spvumfehf/
n 4. 2008
65
n 4. 2008
66
/)3111*/!B!Uifpsz!pg!Qbspez;!Uif!Ufbdijoht!pg!Uxfoujfui.Dfouvsz!Bsu!Gpsnt/!Dijdbhp;!Voj.
wfstjuz!pg!Jmmjopjt/
KBNFTPO-!Gsfesjd/!)2::7*/!Ufpsb!ef!mb!qptunpefsojebe/!Usbe/!Dfmjb!Npoupmp!Ojdipmtpo!
z!Sbno!efm!Dbtujmmp/!Nbesje;!Uspuub/
MVSJF-!Bmjtpo/)2::1*/!Epou!Ufmm!uif!Hspxo.Vqt;!Uif!Tvcwfstjwf!Qpxfs!pg!Dijmesfot!Mjufsbuvsf/!
Cptupo;!Mjuumf-!Cspxo!boe!Dpnqboz/
MZPUBSE-!Kfbo.Gsbodpjt/!)2::5*/!Mb!qptnpefsojebe!)fyqmjdbeb!b!mpt!ojpt*/!Usbe/!Fosjrvf!
Mzodi/!4b!fe/!Cbsdfmpob;!Hfejtb/
/!)2::4*/!Mb!dpoejdjo!qptnpefsob/!Nyjdp;!Sfj/
NBSUO!Hbjuf-!Dbsnfo/!)2::1*/!Dbqfsvdjub!fo!Nboibuubo/!Nbesje;!Tjsvfmb/
IPMU!NDHBWSBO-!Kbnft-!dpnq/!)2:::*/!Mjufsbuvsf!boe!uif!Dijme;!Spnboujd!Dpoujovbujpot-!
Qptunpefso!Dpouftubujpot/!Jpxb;!Vojwfstjuz!pg!Jpxb!Qsftt/
/!Spnboujd!Dpoujovbujpot-!Qptunpefso!Dpouftubujpot-!ps-!Jut!b!Nbhjdbm!Xpsme-!Ipc.
cft-!PmCveez///!Dsbti"!Ipmu!NdHbwsbo-!2.2:/
NPJ-!Upsjm/!)2:99*/!Ufpsb!mjufsbsjb!gfnjojtub/!Usbe/!Bnbjb!Csdfob/!Nbesje;!Dufesb
NPMFT-!Bcsbibn/!)2::1*/!Fm!ljutdi;!fm!bsuf!ef!mb!gfmjdjebe/!Cbsdfmpob;!Qjbet/
NPSUBSB!HBSBWFMMJ-!Cjdf/!)2::2*/!Nbovbm!ef!sfusjdb/!3!fe/!Nbesje;!Dufesb/
OBUPMJ-!K/!z!Mjoeb!IVUDIFPO-!fet/!)2::4*/!B!Qptunpefso!Sfbefs/!Ovfwb!Zpsl;!Tubuf!Voj.
wfstjuz!pg!Ofx!Zpsl/
OTUMJOHFS-!Disjtujof/!)2::2*/!Ef!upebt!nbofsbt!Nyjdp;!DPOBDVMUB<!Fwfsftu/
PXFOT-!Dsbjh/!)2:99*/!Fm!ejtdvstp!ef!mpt!puspt;!mbt!gfnjojtubt!z!fm!qptnpefsojtnp/!
Gptufs-!:4.235/
QBWJT-!Qbusjdf/!)2:91*/!Ejddjpobsjp!efm!ufbusp;!esbnbuvshjb-!ftuujdb-!tfnjpmphb/!Cbsdfmpob;!
Qbjet/
QFUJU-!Njdimf/)2:::*/!Ovfwpt!bdfsdbnjfoupt!b!mpt!kwfoft!z!mb!mfduvsb/!Usbe/!Sbgbfm!Tfhpwjb!
z!Ejbob!Mv{!Todif{/!Nyjdp-!E/G;!GDF/
/!)3113*/!Qfsp-!z!rv!cvtdbo!ovftuspt!ojpt!fo!tvt!mjcspt/!Mfduvsbt!tpcsf!mfduvsbt!3/!Wpm/!3/!
Nyjdp-!E/G;!DPOBDVMUB-!23.53/!
QP[VFMP!ZWBODPT-!Kpt!Nbsb/)2:97*/!Ufpsb!efm!mfohvbkf!mjufsbsjp/!Nbesje;!Dufesb/
SFZFT-!Bmgpotp/!)2:97*/!Mbt!kjubokgpsbt/!Mb!fyqfsjfodjb!mjufsbsjb/!Fotbzpt!tpcsf!fyqfsjfo.
djb!fyhftjt!z!ufpsb!ef!mb!mjufsbuvsb/!Obssbepsft!ef!ipz/!Cbsdfmpob;!Csvhvfsb-!323.75
SJDPFVS-!Qbvm/!)2::6*/!Ujfnqp!z!obssbdjo!J;!Dpohvsbdjo!efm!ujfnqp!fo!fm!sfmbup!ijtusjdp/!
Usbe/!Bhvtuo!Ofjsb/!Wpm/!2/!Nyjdp-!E/G/;!Tjhmp!YYJ/
)3113*/!Efm!ufyup!b!mb!bddjo;!fotbzpt!ef!Ifsnfovujdb!JJ/!Usbe/!Qbcmp!Dpspob/!3!fe/!Wpm/!3/!
Nyjdp-!E/G;!GDF/
SPESHVF[-! Kbjnf! B/)2::6*/! Bvupdpodjfodjb! z! qptnpefsojebe;! nfubddjo! fo! mb! opwfmb!
dpmpncjbob/!Cphpu;!Tj/
TBJOU.FYVQSZ-!Boupjof!ef/!)2::9*/!Fm!qsjodjqjup/!Nyjdp;!Mfdupsvn/
Tfdsfubsb!ef!Fevdbdjo!Qcmjdb/!)2::2*/!Ef!bmvyft-!ftusfmmbt-!bojnbmft!z!puspt!sfmbupt/!Nyjdp;!TFQ/
TXJOEFMMT-! Spcfsu/! )2::6*/! Ifsnbop! fo! mb! Ujfssb/! Jmvtu/! Mvjt! Gfsoboep! Fosrvf{/!
Nyjdp;!GDF/
UPSP-!Bmgpotp!ef-!fu/!bm/!)2::8*/!Qptnpefsojebe!z!qptudpmpojbmjebe;!csfwft!sffyjpoft!tpcsf!
Mbujopbnsjdb/!Gsbolgvsu;!Wfswvfsu<!Jcfspbnfsjdbob/
VMNFS-!Hsfhpsz!M/)3113*/!Fm!pckfup!ef!mb!qptdsujdb/!Gptufs!236.74/
WBMET-!Nbsjp!K/!)2::6*/!Mb!joufsqsfubdjo!bcjfsub;!jouspevddjo!b!mb!ifsnfovujdb!mjufsbsjb!
dpoufnqpsofb/!Ofuifsmboet;Fejujpot!Spepqj!C/W/
WJSBTPSP-!Nojdb/!)2::8*/!Ef!jspobt!z!tjmfodjpt/!Opubt!qbsb!vob!mptpgb!jnqsftjpojtub/!
Cbsdfmpob;!Hfejtb/
WBUUJNP-!Hjbooj-!fu/!bm/!)2::2*/!Fo!upsop!b!mb!qptnpefsojebe/!Cbsdfmpob;!Bouispqpt/