You are on page 1of 7

COMPLIANCE STATEMENT FOR SOE POINT LIST COMMENTS OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.

8KV S/S
Project Title: CONSTRUCTION OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV SUBSTATION IN AL-HASSA
CONTRACTOR: AL SHARIF KEC
National Grid-SA Cont # 4400001840/00

J. O. No.
Dated:

1-1233049.02
Monday, September 15, 2014

REF # TS-701-14, Dated September 02, 2014


1. NORMAL INDOOR LIGHTING
Sr. No#

Locations

Specified
Minimum lux

Calculated
Minimum lux

Calculated
Calculated
Average lux Maximum lux

External Battery Room

200

293

453

576

Toilet

100

100

204

327

External Equipment Room

200

210

299

402

Air Lock Room

100

140

146

152

Staircase 1

100

Staircase 2

100

Staircase 3

100

NG-SA Remarks
Source: ISD

Evaluation

ASKEC Response

Not
This room is not available
Acceptable
2 x 100W
2 x 28W
Not
Mt Ht=3.20m
Acceptable
Incandescent lamp is not permitted for
normal lighting
Not
This room is not available
Acceptable
2pcx100W
Not
Mt Ht=3.2m
Acceptable Incandescent lamp is not permitted for
normal lighting
Not
No calculation
Acceptable
Not
No calculation
Acceptable
Not
No calculation
Acceptable

2. DC EMERGENCY LIGHTING
Sr. No#

Locations

Specified Min Calculated Min Calculated


lux
lux
Average lux

Calculated
Max lux

Control Room

10

15

0.29

19

Communication Room

10

11

1.73

16

External Battery Room

10

15

13

17

Cable Entry Room

10

11

2.98

15

External Eqpt Room

10

13

9.07

14

Staircase 1

10

NG-SA Remarks
Source: ISD

Evaluation

16x60W AR
Not
Mt Ht=3.2m
Acceptable
Adjust the min to at least 5 lux
1x60W AR
Not
Mt Ht=3.20m
Acceptable
Adjust the min to at least 5 lux
Not
This room is not available
Acceptable
40pcsx60W
Not
Mt Ht=2.35m
Acceptable
Adjust the min to at least 5 lux
Not
This room is not available
Acceptable
Not
No calculation
Acceptable

CONCURRED

Name & Sig:


PD-E / PD-H

Name & Sig:


E&DD / E&DD-EOA / EHVU

Name & Sig:

Name & Sig:


Al-Sharif & KEC Ltd.

Name & Sig:


DAR Engg.

ASKEC Response

COMPLIANCE STATEMENT FOR SOE POINT LIST COMMENTS OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
Project Title: CONSTRUCTION OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV SUBSTATION IN AL-HASSA
CONTRACTOR: AL SHARIF KEC
National Grid-SA Cont # 4400001840/00

J. O. No.
Dated:

1-1233049.02
Monday, September 15, 2014

REF # TS-701-14, Dated September 02, 2014


7

Staircase 2

10

Staircase 3

10

Not
No calculation
Acceptable
Not
No calculation
Acceptable

3. LIGHTING MATERIALS
NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

Source

No submitted catalogue of portable self-contained emergency lighting (egress and


search light) and exit lighting fixtures for review and approval by ISD/S&ED

ASKEC Response

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

ASKEC Response

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

ISD

4. ELECTRICAL DRAWINGS
NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

Source

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274678 Sheet 1 of 6 Rev B Indoor Lighting Layout Plan Ground Floor

1
1.1

Note 5.B, correct PVC conduit to RSG conduit for above suspended ceiling.

1.2

At 115KV GIS Room,

1.2.1

Along grid U, interchange the location of search light and egress lighting.

1.2.2

Along grid 4, add one (1) egress at column S4 and shift egress light from column Q4
to M4 and egress light from column K4 to H4

1.2.3

Along grid 7, shift the egress light to column S7 and provide egress light at column H7

1.2.4
1.2.5
1.3

Along grid D, shift the egress at the center.


Along grid U, shift the lighting switches near the single leaf door.

1.3.1

Along grid A, re-distribute the egress lighting at column A3, A6, A10 and A18.

1.3.2

Along grid D, re-distribute the egress lighting at column D3, D6, D15 and D19.

1.3.3

Change the exit light to double face type over the door to staircase 2.

ISD

ISD

At 13.8KV Switchgear Room,

ISD

CONCURRED

Name & Sig:


PD-E / PD-H

Name & Sig:


E&DD / E&DD-EOA / EHVU

Name & Sig:

Name & Sig:


Al-Sharif & KEC Ltd.

Name & Sig:


DAR Engg.

COMPLIANCE STATEMENT FOR SOE POINT LIST COMMENTS OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
Project Title: CONSTRUCTION OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV SUBSTATION IN AL-HASSA
CONTRACTOR: AL SHARIF KEC
National Grid-SA Cont # 4400001840/00

J. O. No.
Dated:

1-1233049.02
Monday, September 15, 2014

REF # TS-701-14, Dated September 02, 2014


1.3.4

Along grid 21, shift the lighting switches near the single leaf door.

1.4

At toilet, see our comments on normal lighting calculation.

1.5

At Air Lock Room, see our comments on normal lighting calculation.

1.6
1.6.1
1.6.2
1.6.3
1.6.4

ISD

See our comments for DC emergency lighting calculations for the following room
Control Room
Communication Room
Cable Entry Room
Staircase 1, 2 & 3.

1.7

Staircase 1, 2 and 3, see our comments for normal lighting calculations.

1.8

At battery room, shift the lighting switch outside near the door.

1.9

At staircase 2, show in section the method of installing the normal and emergency
lighting fixtures. See Section A of drawing #EA 274686 Sht 3 of 4 Rev B.

ISD

Note: At battery room, shift the Eye/Face Wash near the exit door.. Coordinate with Mechanical design.
NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

ISD

Same comments as on item 1 above as applicable.

NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

ASKEC Response

Source

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274678 Sheet 3 of 6 Rev B Indoor Lighting Layout Plan Ground Floor

3
3.1

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274678 Sheet 2 of 6 Rev B Indoor Lighting Layout Plan Ground Floor

2
2.1

ASKEC Response

Source

ISD

Same comments as on item 1 above as applicable.

CONCURRED

Name & Sig:


PD-E / PD-H

Name & Sig:


E&DD / E&DD-EOA / EHVU

Name & Sig:

Name & Sig:


Al-Sharif & KEC Ltd.

Name & Sig:


DAR Engg.

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

COMPLIANCE STATEMENT FOR SOE POINT LIST COMMENTS OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
Project Title: CONSTRUCTION OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV SUBSTATION IN AL-HASSA
CONTRACTOR: AL SHARIF KEC
National Grid-SA Cont # 4400001840/00

J. O. No.
Dated:

1-1233049.02
Monday, September 15, 2014

REF # TS-701-14, Dated September 02, 2014


NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

4.2
4.3
4.4
4.5

See our comments for DC emergency lighting


The approval of egress lighting layout is On-Hold subject to the submission of cable
routing plan in the basement.
Consider installing some of the egress lighting on the outer face of cable trays.
Raise the portion of cable trays when routed across passageways and when routed
across the doorway
Provide exit lighting fixtures with directional arrows pointing towards the direction of
exits.

4.6

Raise the cable tray when it is only in two layers for adequate passageway.

4.7

Provide sectional view showing the height of egress lighting against with the lower
cable tray.
NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

ASKEC Response

Source

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

ISD

5.1. Same comments as on item 4 above.

NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

ASKEC Response

Source

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274678 Sht 6 of 6 Rev B Indoor Lighting Layout Plan Cable Basement

6
6.1

ISD

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274678 Sheet 5 of 6 Rev B Indoor Lighting Layout Plan Cable Basement

5
5.1

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274678 Sheet 4 of 6 Rev B Indoor Lighting Layout Plan Cable Basement

4
4.1

ASKEC Response

Source

ISD

5.1. Same comments as on item 4 above.

CONCURRED

Name & Sig:


PD-E / PD-H

Name & Sig:


E&DD / E&DD-EOA / EHVU

Name & Sig:

Name & Sig:


Al-Sharif & KEC Ltd.

Name & Sig:


DAR Engg.

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

COMPLIANCE STATEMENT FOR SOE POINT LIST COMMENTS OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
Project Title: CONSTRUCTION OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV SUBSTATION IN AL-HASSA
CONTRACTOR: AL SHARIF KEC
National Grid-SA Cont # 4400001840/00

J. O. No.
Dated:

1-1233049.02
Monday, September 15, 2014

REF # TS-701-14, Dated September 02, 2014


NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274679 Sheet 1 of 3 Rev B Indoor Lighting Layout Plan First Floor

7
7.1

ASKEC Response

Source

At staircase 1,

7.1.1

Replace the exit light with incandescent lamp over the door outside

7.1.2

Provide portable self contained emergency light (egress light)

7.2
7.2.1

At control room,
Along grid 8,

7.2.2.1

Provide lighting over the single leaf door outside.

7.2.2.2

Provide exit light over the door.

7.2.2.3

Add one egress lighting fixture and distribute the fixtures at equal distance.

7.2.2

Provide egress lighting with extended bracket at column #J14

ISD

7.2.4

Along grid A, add one egress lighting fixure and distribute the fixtures at equal
distance.
Along grid D,

7.2.4.1

Add one (1) egress light and distribute it at column D15 and D19.

7.2.4.2

Delete the search light near column D20.

7.2.3

ISD

ISD

NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274679 Sheet 2 of 3 Rev B Indoor Lighting Layout Plan First Floor

8
8.1

ASKEC Response

Source

ISD

Same comments as on item 7 above.

CONCURRED

Name & Sig:


PD-E / PD-H

Name & Sig:


E&DD / E&DD-EOA / EHVU

Name & Sig:

Name & Sig:


Al-Sharif & KEC Ltd.

Name & Sig:


DAR Engg.

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

COMPLIANCE STATEMENT FOR SOE POINT LIST COMMENTS OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
Project Title: CONSTRUCTION OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV SUBSTATION IN AL-HASSA
CONTRACTOR: AL SHARIF KEC
National Grid-SA Cont # 4400001840/00

J. O. No.
Dated:

1-1233049.02
Monday, September 15, 2014

REF # TS-701-14, Dated September 02, 2014


NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

NG-SA Comments

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

ISD

Revise the layout as per our comments on item C.1 above.

NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

ASKEC Response

Source

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274680 Sheet 2 of 4 Rev B Indoor Auxiliary Power Layout Plan Ground Floor

11

ISD

Revise the layout as per our comments on item C.1 above.

NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

ASKEC Response

Source

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274680 Sheet 3 of 4 Rev B Indoor Auxiliary Power Layout Plan Cable Basement

12
12.1

ASKEC Response

Source

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274680 Sheet 1 of 4 Rev B Indoor Auxiliary Power Layout Plan Ground Floor

10

11.1

ISD

Same comments as on item 7 above.

Sr. No#

10.1

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274679 Sheet 3 of 3 Rev B Indoor Lighting Layout Plan First Floor

9
9.1

ASKEC Response

Source

ISD

Revise the layout as per our comments on item C.4 above.

CONCURRED

Name & Sig:


PD-E / PD-H

Name & Sig:


E&DD / E&DD-EOA / EHVU

Name & Sig:

Name & Sig:


Al-Sharif & KEC Ltd.

Name & Sig:


DAR Engg.

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

COMPLIANCE STATEMENT FOR SOE POINT LIST COMMENTS OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
Project Title: CONSTRUCTION OF MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV SUBSTATION IN AL-HASSA
CONTRACTOR: AL SHARIF KEC
National Grid-SA Cont # 4400001840/00

J. O. No.
Dated:

1-1233049.02
Monday, September 15, 2014

REF # TS-701-14, Dated September 02, 2014


NG-SA Comments

Sr. No#

NG-SA Comments

NG-SA Comments

15

16
16.1
Sr. No#

17
17.1
17.2

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

ISD

Revise the layout as per our comments on item C.7 above

Sr. No#

Sr. No#

ASKEC Response

Source

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274681 Sheet 1 of 2 Rev B Indoor Auxiliary Power Layout Plan First Floor

14

15.1

ISD

Revise the layout as per our comments on item C.4 above.

Sr. No#

14.1

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

SOE POINT LIST


SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274680 Sht 4 of 4 Rev B Indoor Auxiliary Power Layout Plan Cable Basement

13
13.1

ASKEC Response

Source

ASKEC Response
SOE POINT LIST
SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274681 Sheet 2 of 2 Rev B Indoor Auxiliary Power Layout Plan First Floor
Source

ISD

Revise the layout as per our comments on item C.7 above.

ASKEC Response
SOE POINT LIST
SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274682 Sheet 1 of 4 Rev B Indoor Power and Lighting Details
Detail 2, 115KV GIS Room, the indicated height of lighting is 9.0m while 8.2 in the
ISD
calculation.

NG-SA Comments

Source

NG-SA Comments

Source

ASKEC Response
SOE POINT LIST
SOE POINT LIST AT AL-MUBARKIYAH 115/13.8KV S/S
#EA 274686 Sheet 1 of 4 Rev B Cable Raceway Layout Plan & Sections
Raise the portion of cable trays when routed across passageways and when routed
across the doorway.
ISD
Raise the two layers cable tray for adequate passageway.

CONCURRED

Name & Sig:


PD-E / PD-H

Name & Sig:


E&DD / E&DD-EOA / EHVU

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

Name & Sig:

Name & Sig:


Al-Sharif & KEC Ltd.

Name & Sig:


DAR Engg.

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks

Decision / Conclusion / Remarks